Joris Lammers
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Joris Lammers has a total of 416 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Diederik A. Stapel
Tilburg University
11 shared publicationsAdam D. Galinsky
Columbia Business School
10 shared publicationsJanka I. Stoker
Faculty of Economics and Business, University of Groningen, The Netherlands
10 shared publications- Alexandra Fleischmann
Social Cognition Center Cologne, University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany
6 shared publications - Yael Ecker
Social Cognition Center Cologne University of Cologne Cologne Germany
6 shared publications Jennifer Jordan
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The politics of stasis and change: The motivational roots of conservatism in party platforms and citizens' own words
A central question in political psychology concerns the motivational roots of ideological differences between left and right. A common approach explains right-wing thinking as reflecting heightened sensitivity to threat and a motivation to protect the status quo. We argue that this approach rests on an incomplete model of goals, which overlooks the motive to conserve. Building on the ternary goal model, we examine whether the right is better characterized by maintenance (sustaining a valued present) than by protection (responding to threats). Using a multilingual classifier validated on human-rated statements, we measured goals in a top-down manner, in 892 party platforms from 11 countries, and bottom-up, in the goals spontaneously reported by 2,333 citizens in six countries and in citizens’ support for platform statements that differed in goal orientation. Top-down, right-wing parties were more maintenance-oriented than left-wing parties, and in recent decades less progress-oriented. Protection orientation did not differ by side but was higher in opposition and at the ideological margins. Bottom-up, citizens showed a similar pattern. Progress orientation was strongest on the left. Maintenance orientation followed a curve that peaked among moderate conservatives. Its linear rise with conservatism was suppressed by institutional trust, which was lower on the right. In support ratings, progress-oriented statements appealed more to the left and maintenance-oriented statements more to the right, whereas protection-oriented statements favored neither. The left–right divide thus sets two constructive aims – to progress and to maintain – against each other, while protection marks those in opposition and at the margins.
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe politics of stasis and change: The motivational roots of conservatism in party platforms and citizens' own words
A central question in political psychology concerns the motivational roots of ideological differences between left and right. A common approach explains right-wing thinking as reflecting heightened sensitivity to threat and a motivation to protect the status quo. We argue that this approach rests on an incomplete model of goals, which overlooks the motive to conserve. Building on the ternary goal model, we examine whether the right is better characterized by maintenance (sustaining a valued present) than by protection (responding to threats). Using a multilingual classifier validated on human-rated statements, we measured goals in a top-down manner, in 892 party platforms from 11 countries, and bottom-up, in the goals spontaneously reported by 2,333 citizens in six countries and in citizens’ support for platform statements that differed in goal orientation. Top-down, right-wing parties were more maintenance-oriented than left-wing parties, and in recent decades less progress-oriented. Protection orientation did not differ by side but was higher in opposition and at the ideological margins. Bottom-up, citizens showed a similar pattern. Progress orientation was strongest on the left. Maintenance orientation followed a curve that peaked among moderate conservatives. Its linear rise with conservatism was suppressed by institutional trust, which was lower on the right. In support ratings, progress-oriented statements appealed more to the left and maintenance-oriented statements more to the right, whereas protection-oriented statements favored neither. The left–right divide thus sets two constructive aims – to progress and to maintain – against each other, while protection marks those in opposition and at the margins.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy
- Vol. 26 (3)
The power of the past: Temporal framing enhances gender‐inclusive language support among conservatives
The singular they is commonly used in English as a form of gender‐inclusive language. Despite its potential to contribute to gender equality, gender‐inclusive language is often met with resistance, primarily from political conservatives. Arguments against the use of the singular they include rejection of language change and appeals to tradition. Such arguments fit with conservatives’ nostalgic focus on the past. Thus, we investigate whether conservatives’ support for the singular they can be increased by past‐focused temporal framing that presents the singular they as consistent with the past and thereby appeals to conservatives’ nostalgic focus on the past. In an online experiment, U.S. American participants ( N = 377) indicated their endorsement of either a past‐focused or a future‐focused message promoting the singular they and their personal use of the singular they . Consistent with predictions, the more conservative participants were, the lower their endorsement and use of the singular they . However, the effect of political ideology on endorsement was attenuated by the past‐focused compared to the future‐focused message. Singular they use was not affected by temporal framing. Collective nostalgia was associated with conservatism but was not identified as an underlying mechanism of the temporal focus effect. The present findings suggest that past‐focused temporal framing has the potential to increase conservatives’ support for the singular they and, thereby, offer practical implications for policy.
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy
- Vol. 26 (3)
Open AccessThe power of the past: Temporal framing enhances gender‐inclusive language support among conservatives
The singular they is commonly used in English as a form of gender‐inclusive language. Despite its potential to contribute to gender equality, gender‐inclusive language is often met with resistance, primarily from political conservatives. Arguments against the use of the singular they include rejection of language change and appeals to tradition. Such arguments fit with conservatives’ nostalgic focus on the past. Thus, we investigate whether conservatives’ support for the singular they can be increased by past‐focused temporal framing that presents the singular they as consistent with the past and thereby appeals to conservatives’ nostalgic focus on the past. In an online experiment, U.S. American participants ( N = 377) indicated their endorsement of either a past‐focused or a future‐focused message promoting the singular they and their personal use of the singular they . Consistent with predictions, the more conservative participants were, the lower their endorsement and use of the singular they . However, the effect of political ideology on endorsement was attenuated by the past‐focused compared to the future‐focused message. Singular they use was not affected by temporal framing. Collective nostalgia was associated with conservatism but was not identified as an underlying mechanism of the temporal focus effect. The present findings suggest that past‐focused temporal framing has the potential to increase conservatives’ support for the singular they and, thereby, offer practical implications for policy.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Maintenance Orientation in Top-Down Political Communication Increases Pro-Environmental Policy Support
Despite overwhelming evidence of the consequences of climate change, many voters—in particular conservatives—oppose pro-environmental policies. Research shows that this opposition can be overcome by reframing the issue in ways that appeal to conservatives’ motives. An important limitation to this literature is that it relies heavily on artificial stimuli in controlled settings, leaving open whether the framing of real political communication shapes conservatives' support for climate action. To address this gap, we examine natural variation in how climate change is framed in top-down political communication across the political spectrum. Drawing on the ternary goal model, we distinguish between progress, maintenance, and protection as three fundamental goals that guide climate action. We propose that maintenance-oriented messaging—reflecting a desire to maintain valued current states—is more effective in increasing conservative political support for climate action. To test this, we use a multilingual machine learning model to rate the goal orientations of pro-environmental policy statements from party platforms across four democracies and then testing voters’ support of these statements. We find that conservatives’ support for pro-environmental statements increases with the degree of maintenance orientation in the text (β = 0.27, p < .001). Moderately strong (+1SD vs -1SD) maintenance orientation reduced the liberal-conservative gap by 31%. In contrast, the degree of progress or protection orientation did not affect conservatives’ support. These findings confirm the importance of policy framing in the debate about climate change and support the practical relevance of maintenance frames to increase conservative support for climate action.
- 10 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessMaintenance Orientation in Top-Down Political Communication Increases Pro-Environmental Policy Support
Despite overwhelming evidence of the consequences of climate change, many voters—in particular conservatives—oppose pro-environmental policies. Research shows that this opposition can be overcome by reframing the issue in ways that appeal to conservatives’ motives. An important limitation to this literature is that it relies heavily on artificial stimuli in controlled settings, leaving open whether the framing of real political communication shapes conservatives' support for climate action. To address this gap, we examine natural variation in how climate change is framed in top-down political communication across the political spectrum. Drawing on the ternary goal model, we distinguish between progress, maintenance, and protection as three fundamental goals that guide climate action. We propose that maintenance-oriented messaging—reflecting a desire to maintain valued current states—is more effective in increasing conservative political support for climate action. To test this, we use a multilingual machine learning model to rate the goal orientations of pro-environmental policy statements from party platforms across four democracies and then testing voters’ support of these statements. We find that conservatives’ support for pro-environmental statements increases with the degree of maintenance orientation in the text (β = 0.27, p < .001). Moderately strong (+1SD vs -1SD) maintenance orientation reduced the liberal-conservative gap by 31%. In contrast, the degree of progress or protection orientation did not affect conservatives’ support. These findings confirm the importance of policy framing in the debate about climate change and support the practical relevance of maintenance frames to increase conservative support for climate action.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 155 (2) , 499-517
A desire for equality produces inequality in social hierarchies when people focus on categories of recipients rather than individuals.
When distributing resources, people often experience a conflict between two fundamental moral principles: The equality principle prescribes that all recipients receive the same, while the proportionality principle prescribes that allocations should be in proportion to the contribution of each recipient. We propose that if people consider recipient units of distributions in hierarchies as categories, rather than individuals, seeking categorical equality leads to individual inequality, because in most hierarchical groups there are fewer higher ranked (e.g., management) than lower ranked members (e.g., workers). Ten preregistered experiments conducted in the United States and China (N = 4,902) confirm this idea and show that participants who focus on categorical (vs. individual) recipients perceive unequal distributions as fairer (Experiment 1) and create more unequal distributions (Experiments 2a-2d), even when this reduces their own payoffs (Experiment 3). This effect occurs because when construing recipient units as categories (vs. individuals), people seek equality at a categorical level, without sufficiently correcting for differences in group size. Supporting this theoretical explanation, this effect is eliminated when thinking of individual-level equality (Experiments 4a-4b). Furthermore, this effect exists only when the higher ranked group is smaller sized, as is often the case in hierarchies (Experiment 5), and only when inequality is consistent with proportionality (Experiment 6). Combined, our results show that when people perceive a hierarchy in categorical (rather than individual) terms, this increases distributive inequality between its higher and lower ranked members. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 155 (2) , 499-517
A desire for equality produces inequality in social hierarchies when people focus on categories of recipients rather than individuals.
When distributing resources, people often experience a conflict between two fundamental moral principles: The equality principle prescribes that all recipients receive the same, while the proportionality principle prescribes that allocations should be in proportion to the contribution of each recipient. We propose that if people consider recipient units of distributions in hierarchies as categories, rather than individuals, seeking categorical equality leads to individual inequality, because in most hierarchical groups there are fewer higher ranked (e.g., management) than lower ranked members (e.g., workers). Ten preregistered experiments conducted in the United States and China (N = 4,902) confirm this idea and show that participants who focus on categorical (vs. individual) recipients perceive unequal distributions as fairer (Experiment 1) and create more unequal distributions (Experiments 2a-2d), even when this reduces their own payoffs (Experiment 3). This effect occurs because when construing recipient units as categories (vs. individuals), people seek equality at a categorical level, without sufficiently correcting for differences in group size. Supporting this theoretical explanation, this effect is eliminated when thinking of individual-level equality (Experiments 4a-4b). Furthermore, this effect exists only when the higher ranked group is smaller sized, as is often the case in hierarchies (Experiment 5), and only when inequality is consistent with proportionality (Experiment 6). Combined, our results show that when people perceive a hierarchy in categorical (rather than individual) terms, this increases distributive inequality between its higher and lower ranked members. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).
- 5 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Climate Change
- Vol. 16 (2) , 123-124
Communicating the need for climate action
- 5 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Climate Change
- Vol. 16 (2) , 123-124
Communicating the need for climate action
- 1 November 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 154 (11) , 2963-2980
Bias toward progress-oriented leaders: People prefer progress- over maintenance-oriented leaders even when a maintenance orientation is required.
We uncover a dissociation between leadership preferences (for progress, protection, or maintenance-oriented leaders) and situational requirements (to make progress, protect, or maintain). Despite maintenance being crucial for sustaining groups' ongoing activity, we find a bias favoring progress-oriented leaders across contexts. In six preregistered experiments (Ntotal = 3,324), participants consistently preferred progress-oriented leaders even when they recognized maintenance as the primary situational need. In Experiment 1, people preferred progress- over maintenance-oriented political leaders in a mock-election paradigm even when maintenance was explicitly the dominant concern. In Experiment 2, participants chose progress-oriented group leaders in an incentivized group task, despite maintenance investments yielding greater monetary rewards. Furthermore, participants preferred maintenance-oriented over progress-oriented agendas but showed no (Experiment 3a) or opposite preference (Experiment 3b) when evaluating leaders who advocated identical policies. Our final studies test two explanations regarding the underlying process: Experiment 4 tests the idea that progress-oriented leaders are expected to invest more effort than others. However, manipulating perceived leader effort did not affect the preference for progress-oriented leaders. Instead, Experiment 5 identifies a different mechanism: Participants assume that progress-oriented leaders have wider goal scopes that also include maintenance goals, whereas maintenance-oriented leaders' goal scope is assumed to be limited to maintenance. Blocking this assumption by explicitly describing progress leaders as maintenance-neutral reversed the preference pattern. Together, these studies point to a systematic bias in leadership selection that persists regardless of situational demands or personal policy preferences, revealing how biased assumptions about progress-oriented leadership shape choices that undermine optimal collective decision making. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 November 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 154 (11) , 2963-2980
Bias toward progress-oriented leaders: People prefer progress- over maintenance-oriented leaders even when a maintenance orientation is required.
We uncover a dissociation between leadership preferences (for progress, protection, or maintenance-oriented leaders) and situational requirements (to make progress, protect, or maintain). Despite maintenance being crucial for sustaining groups' ongoing activity, we find a bias favoring progress-oriented leaders across contexts. In six preregistered experiments (Ntotal = 3,324), participants consistently preferred progress-oriented leaders even when they recognized maintenance as the primary situational need. In Experiment 1, people preferred progress- over maintenance-oriented political leaders in a mock-election paradigm even when maintenance was explicitly the dominant concern. In Experiment 2, participants chose progress-oriented group leaders in an incentivized group task, despite maintenance investments yielding greater monetary rewards. Furthermore, participants preferred maintenance-oriented over progress-oriented agendas but showed no (Experiment 3a) or opposite preference (Experiment 3b) when evaluating leaders who advocated identical policies. Our final studies test two explanations regarding the underlying process: Experiment 4 tests the idea that progress-oriented leaders are expected to invest more effort than others. However, manipulating perceived leader effort did not affect the preference for progress-oriented leaders. Instead, Experiment 5 identifies a different mechanism: Participants assume that progress-oriented leaders have wider goal scopes that also include maintenance goals, whereas maintenance-oriented leaders' goal scope is assumed to be limited to maintenance. Blocking this assumption by explicitly describing progress leaders as maintenance-neutral reversed the preference pattern. Together, these studies point to a systematic bias in leadership selection that persists regardless of situational demands or personal policy preferences, revealing how biased assumptions about progress-oriented leadership shape choices that undermine optimal collective decision making. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).
- Open Access
- 15 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology
- Vol. 19
A Cyclical Time Concept Increases the Perceived Predictability of the Future and Reduces the Perceived Risk of Unlikely, but not Likely Risks
Time can be perceived in linear terms, but also in cyclical terms. For example, people may think about the progress of time in terms of years, moving linearly from 2025 to 2026 and further onwards or they may think about time in cyclical terms, following the four seasons in an eternal cycle. We argue that when time is perceived as cyclical, similarities across time are more salient. For example, the four seasons always repeat themselves in the same order. Based on the assumption that similarities across time allows prediction about the future occurrence or non-occurrence of events based on their past (non-)occurrence than dissimilarities, we hypothesize that an experimentally induced cyclical time perception leads people to see the future as more predictable and therefore as less risky. Importantly, we also hypothesize this only applies to uncommon risks, but not to common risks. After all, when people adopt a cyclical time perspective, this allows them to confidently predict that uncommon risks are unlikely to occur in the near future, given their non-occurrence in the past. In contrast, this should not have the same effect for common risks that are likely to occur both in the past and present. We report two pilot studies and three preregistered experiments (total N = 1555) that test these predictions. Experiment 1 shows that the future appears more predictable when people adopt a cyclical time concept. Experiment 2 replicates this and shows it reduces the perceived risk of unlikely threats. Finally, Experiment 3 replicates this but shows time concept does not affect the perceived risk of mundane threats. Together, these studies suggest that a linear versus cyclical time perception affects perceived risks, because it affects how people use knowledge of the past to predict the future.
- 15 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology
- Vol. 19
Open AccessA Cyclical Time Concept Increases the Perceived Predictability of the Future and Reduces the Perceived Risk of Unlikely, but not Likely Risks
Time can be perceived in linear terms, but also in cyclical terms. For example, people may think about the progress of time in terms of years, moving linearly from 2025 to 2026 and further onwards or they may think about time in cyclical terms, following the four seasons in an eternal cycle. We argue that when time is perceived as cyclical, similarities across time are more salient. For example, the four seasons always repeat themselves in the same order. Based on the assumption that similarities across time allows prediction about the future occurrence or non-occurrence of events based on their past (non-)occurrence than dissimilarities, we hypothesize that an experimentally induced cyclical time perception leads people to see the future as more predictable and therefore as less risky. Importantly, we also hypothesize this only applies to uncommon risks, but not to common risks. After all, when people adopt a cyclical time perspective, this allows them to confidently predict that uncommon risks are unlikely to occur in the near future, given their non-occurrence in the past. In contrast, this should not have the same effect for common risks that are likely to occur both in the past and present. We report two pilot studies and three preregistered experiments (total N = 1555) that test these predictions. Experiment 1 shows that the future appears more predictable when people adopt a cyclical time concept. Experiment 2 replicates this and shows it reduces the perceived risk of unlikely threats. Finally, Experiment 3 replicates this but shows time concept does not affect the perceived risk of mundane threats. Together, these studies suggest that a linear versus cyclical time perception affects perceived risks, because it affects how people use knowledge of the past to predict the future.
- Open Access
- 28 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Bias Towards Progress-Oriented Leaders: People Prefer Progress- over Maintenance-Oriented Leaders Even When a Maintenance Orientation is Required
We uncover a dissociation between leadership preferences (for progress, protection, or maintenance-oriented leaders) and situational requirements (to make progress, protect, or maintain). Despite maintenance being crucial for sustaining groups’ ongoing activity, we find a bias favoring progress-oriented leaders across contexts. In six preregistered experiments (Ntotal = 3,324), participants consistently preferred progress-oriented leaders even when they recognized maintenance as the primary situational need. In Experiment 1, people preferred progress- over maintenance-oriented political leaders in a mock-election paradigm even when maintenance was explicitly the dominant concern. In Experiment 2, participants chose progress-oriented group leaders in an incentivized group task, despite maintenance investments yielding greater monetary rewards. Furthermore, participants preferred maintenance-oriented over progress-oriented agendas, but showed no (Experiment 3a) or opposite preference (Experiment 3b) when evaluating leaders who advocated identical policies. Our final studies test two explanations regarding the underlying process: Experiment 4 tests the idea that progress-oriented leaders are expected to invest more effort than others. However, manipulating perceived leader effort did not affect the preference for progress-oriented leaders. Instead, Experiment 5 identifies a different mechanism: Participants assume that progress-oriented leaders have wider goal scopes that also include maintenance goals, whereas maintenance-oriented leaders’ goal scope is assumed to be limited to maintenance. Blocking this assumption by explicitly describing progress leaders as maintenance-neutral reversed the preference pattern. Together, these studies point to a systematic bias in leadership selection that persists regardless of situational demands or personal policy preferences, revealing how biased assumptions about progress-oriented leadership shape choices that undermine optimal collective decision-making.
- 28 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessBias Towards Progress-Oriented Leaders: People Prefer Progress- over Maintenance-Oriented Leaders Even When a Maintenance Orientation is Required
We uncover a dissociation between leadership preferences (for progress, protection, or maintenance-oriented leaders) and situational requirements (to make progress, protect, or maintain). Despite maintenance being crucial for sustaining groups’ ongoing activity, we find a bias favoring progress-oriented leaders across contexts. In six preregistered experiments (Ntotal = 3,324), participants consistently preferred progress-oriented leaders even when they recognized maintenance as the primary situational need. In Experiment 1, people preferred progress- over maintenance-oriented political leaders in a mock-election paradigm even when maintenance was explicitly the dominant concern. In Experiment 2, participants chose progress-oriented group leaders in an incentivized group task, despite maintenance investments yielding greater monetary rewards. Furthermore, participants preferred maintenance-oriented over progress-oriented agendas, but showed no (Experiment 3a) or opposite preference (Experiment 3b) when evaluating leaders who advocated identical policies. Our final studies test two explanations regarding the underlying process: Experiment 4 tests the idea that progress-oriented leaders are expected to invest more effort than others. However, manipulating perceived leader effort did not affect the preference for progress-oriented leaders. Instead, Experiment 5 identifies a different mechanism: Participants assume that progress-oriented leaders have wider goal scopes that also include maintenance goals, whereas maintenance-oriented leaders’ goal scope is assumed to be limited to maintenance. Blocking this assumption by explicitly describing progress leaders as maintenance-neutral reversed the preference pattern. Together, these studies point to a systematic bias in leadership selection that persists regardless of situational demands or personal policy preferences, revealing how biased assumptions about progress-oriented leadership shape choices that undermine optimal collective decision-making.
- Open Access
- 17 March 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (12)
Maintaining cooperation through vertical communication of trust when removing sanctions
An effective way to foster cooperation is to monitor behavior and sanction freeriding. Yet, previous studies have shown that cooperation quickly declines when sanctioning mechanisms are removed. We test whether explicitly expressing trust in players’ capability to maintain cooperation after the removal of sanctions, i.e., vertical communication of trust, has the potential to alleviate this drop in compliance. Four incentivized public-goods experiments ( N = 2,823) find that the vertical communication of trust maintains cooperation upon the removal of centralized (Study 1), third-party (Study 2a, 2b), and peer punishment (Study 3), and this effect extends beyond single interactions (Study 4). In all studies, vertical trust communication increases mutual trust among players, providing support to the idea that vertically communicating trust can be a self-fulfilling prophecy. Extrapolating our findings to natural environments, they suggest that authorities should carefully consider how they communicate the lifting of rules and sanctions.
- 17 March 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (12)
Open AccessMaintaining cooperation through vertical communication of trust when removing sanctions
An effective way to foster cooperation is to monitor behavior and sanction freeriding. Yet, previous studies have shown that cooperation quickly declines when sanctioning mechanisms are removed. We test whether explicitly expressing trust in players’ capability to maintain cooperation after the removal of sanctions, i.e., vertical communication of trust, has the potential to alleviate this drop in compliance. Four incentivized public-goods experiments ( N = 2,823) find that the vertical communication of trust maintains cooperation upon the removal of centralized (Study 1), third-party (Study 2a, 2b), and peer punishment (Study 3), and this effect extends beyond single interactions (Study 4). In all studies, vertical trust communication increases mutual trust among players, providing support to the idea that vertically communicating trust can be a self-fulfilling prophecy. Extrapolating our findings to natural environments, they suggest that authorities should carefully consider how they communicate the lifting of rules and sanctions.
- 12 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Psychological and Personality Science
- Vol. 17 (1) , 7-16
Understanding the Devaluation of Female Leaders: A Cognitive-Ecological Perspective
Women in leadership positions are often devalued. Complementing previous approaches, we provide a novel cognitive-ecological explanation for this phenomenon. We suggest that perceiving certain leaders as a subcategory of leaders, a tendency primarily observed for female leaders, focuses attention on their distinct attributes that differentiate them from the broader category of leaders. Since people have predominantly positive perceptions of leaders, such distinct attributes are likely more negative. Three preregistered experiments ( N total = 2,878 US-Americans) confirm our model’s prediction that both subcategories of female and male leaders are judged more negatively than leaders of unspecified gender and that the effect reverses when the overarching category of leaders is viewed negatively. We discuss our findings’ implications for advancing gender equality in leadership.
- 12 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Psychological and Personality Science
- Vol. 17 (1) , 7-16
Understanding the Devaluation of Female Leaders: A Cognitive-Ecological Perspective
Women in leadership positions are often devalued. Complementing previous approaches, we provide a novel cognitive-ecological explanation for this phenomenon. We suggest that perceiving certain leaders as a subcategory of leaders, a tendency primarily observed for female leaders, focuses attention on their distinct attributes that differentiate them from the broader category of leaders. Since people have predominantly positive perceptions of leaders, such distinct attributes are likely more negative. Three preregistered experiments ( N total = 2,878 US-Americans) confirm our model’s prediction that both subcategories of female and male leaders are judged more negatively than leaders of unspecified gender and that the effect reverses when the overarching category of leaders is viewed negatively. We discuss our findings’ implications for advancing gender equality in leadership.