Hannes Münchow
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Hannes Münchow has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Tobias Richter
Department of Psychology IV, University of Würzburg, Germany
5 shared publications - Simon P. Tiffin-Richards
Department of Educational Research and Educational Psychology, Leibniz Institute for Science and Mathematics Education, Kiel, Germany
3 shared publications Sarah von der Mühlen
Lehrstuhl Psychologie IV, Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg
2 shared publicationsSebastian Schmid
Institut für Pädagogik, Universität Regensburg
2 shared publications- Andreas G. Wertgen
Department of Psychology IV, University of Würzburg, Würzburg, Germany
1 shared publication Christoph Mengelkamp
Media Communication, University of Würzburg, Oswald-Külpe-Weg 82, 97070 Würzburg, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Thinking & Reasoning
- Vol. 31 (4) , 546-585
Plausible or problematic? Evaluating logical fallacies in a scientific text
- 11 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Thinking & Reasoning
- Vol. 31 (4) , 546-585
Open AccessPlausible or problematic? Evaluating logical fallacies in a scientific text
- Open Access
- 11 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (1) , 1-26
Lasting benefits of a web-based training in understanding informal arguments
Being able to comprehend informal arguments in scientific texts is important for scientific literacy in higher education. Successful intervention studies demonstrating that these skills can be trained in university students have not yet provided evidence that gains of explicit training can be maintained beyond immediate post-training assessment. In this study, we tested whether the gains in argument structure comprehension achieved using a self-directed, web-based training intervention could be maintained over several weeks as an indication of sustained improvement in scientific literacy. We also explored characteristics of students and their engagement with the training intervention that resulted in significant and sustained improvements of their argument structure comprehension skills. One hundred students took part in a voluntary supplement to their university courses, completing an online pretest, a 45-minute training session, a posttest (n = 88), and a follow-up test (n = 31). Training effects at posttest were compared with an active control group. The results suggest that the training group exhibited significant gains in argument structure comprehension. These gains were maintained across a four-week period. Students with low starting ability profited the most from the training and gains in argument comprehension were greatest for complex arguments. Training results were positively related to student motivation and this effect was fully mediated by their engagement with the training exercises. The results demonstrate that training gains can be maintained after immediate post-training assessment and suggest that training is particularly effective for low-performing students, for complex arguments, and when students are motivated and engage with the training exercises.
- 11 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (1) , 1-26
Open AccessLasting benefits of a web-based training in understanding informal arguments
Being able to comprehend informal arguments in scientific texts is important for scientific literacy in higher education. Successful intervention studies demonstrating that these skills can be trained in university students have not yet provided evidence that gains of explicit training can be maintained beyond immediate post-training assessment. In this study, we tested whether the gains in argument structure comprehension achieved using a self-directed, web-based training intervention could be maintained over several weeks as an indication of sustained improvement in scientific literacy. We also explored characteristics of students and their engagement with the training intervention that resulted in significant and sustained improvements of their argument structure comprehension skills. One hundred students took part in a voluntary supplement to their university courses, completing an online pretest, a 45-minute training session, a posttest (n = 88), and a follow-up test (n = 31). Training effects at posttest were compared with an active control group. The results suggest that the training group exhibited significant gains in argument structure comprehension. These gains were maintained across a four-week period. Students with low starting ability profited the most from the training and gains in argument comprehension were greatest for complex arguments. Training results were positively related to student motivation and this effect was fully mediated by their engagement with the training exercises. The results demonstrate that training gains can be maintained after immediate post-training assessment and suggest that training is particularly effective for low-performing students, for complex arguments, and when students are motivated and engage with the training exercises.
- Open Access
- 17 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft
- Vol. 26 (3) , 703-725
Promoting students’ argument comprehension and evaluation skills: Implementation of two training interventions in higher education
The ability to comprehend and evaluate informal arguments is important for making sense of scientific texts and scientific reasoning. However, university students often lack the skills necessary to comprehend the functional structure and evaluate the structural plausibility of informal arguments. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of two training interventions to a) improve students’ argument comprehension (identification of argument structure), and to b) improve students’ argument evaluation (distinguishing good vs. bad arguments). The training interventions were implemented as a voluntary online add-on to a regular university course. The study used a crossover-experimental design with a pre-test and two training phases in which participants (N = 29) alternated between the two training interventions. Students generally improved on the measures of scientific literacy that were practiced in each training intervention. The results provide evidence that voluntary online training interventions for components of scientific literacy can be effectively integrated into higher education settings. However, results further showed an interference effect between the training interventions, indicating that students had problems integrating the different aspects of scientific literacy targeted in the two training interventions.
- 17 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft
- Vol. 26 (3) , 703-725
Open AccessPromoting students’ argument comprehension and evaluation skills: Implementation of two training interventions in higher education
The ability to comprehend and evaluate informal arguments is important for making sense of scientific texts and scientific reasoning. However, university students often lack the skills necessary to comprehend the functional structure and evaluate the structural plausibility of informal arguments. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of two training interventions to a) improve students’ argument comprehension (identification of argument structure), and to b) improve students’ argument evaluation (distinguishing good vs. bad arguments). The training interventions were implemented as a voluntary online add-on to a regular university course. The study used a crossover-experimental design with a pre-test and two training phases in which participants (N = 29) alternated between the two training interventions. Students generally improved on the measures of scientific literacy that were practiced in each training intervention. The results provide evidence that voluntary online training interventions for components of scientific literacy can be effectively integrated into higher education settings. However, results further showed an interference effect between the training interventions, indicating that students had problems integrating the different aspects of scientific literacy targeted in the two training interventions.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2020
- Published by Hogrefe Publishing Group in Diagnostica
- Vol. 66 (2) , 136-145
Verstehen von Argumenten in wissenschaftlichen Texten
Zusammenfassung. Informelle Argumente sind in wissenschaftlichen Texten allgegenwärtig. Um solche Argumente verstehen und bewerten zu können, müssen Studierende ihre Struktur entschlüsseln. Zur Erfassung dieser Kompetenz wurde der computergestützte Argumentstrukturtest (AST) für Studierende sozial- und erziehungswissenschaftlicher Fächer sowie Lehramtsstudierende entwickelt. Die Testpersonen lesen kurze Texte mit informellen Argumenten und identifizieren ihre funktionalen Komponenten (z. B. Behauptung, Begründung, Schlussregel). Anhand einer Stichprobe von 225 Studierenden wurde der AST einer ersten Überprüfung seiner Reliabilität und Validität unterzogen. Dabei erwies sich der AST als intern valide, mit einer breiten Streuung der Itemschwierigkeiten. In einem explanatorischen Item-Response-Modell konnten die Itemschwierigkeiten sehr präzise durch theoretisch relevante Itemmerkmale, die das Argumentverstehen beeinflussen, vorhergesagt werden. Korrelationen mit verbaler Intelligenz und Schul- und Studienleistungen sprechen darüber hinaus für die Kriteriumsvalidität des Instruments.
- 1 April 2020
- Published by Hogrefe Publishing Group in Diagnostica
- Vol. 66 (2) , 136-145
Open AccessVerstehen von Argumenten in wissenschaftlichen Texten
Zusammenfassung. Informelle Argumente sind in wissenschaftlichen Texten allgegenwärtig. Um solche Argumente verstehen und bewerten zu können, müssen Studierende ihre Struktur entschlüsseln. Zur Erfassung dieser Kompetenz wurde der computergestützte Argumentstrukturtest (AST) für Studierende sozial- und erziehungswissenschaftlicher Fächer sowie Lehramtsstudierende entwickelt. Die Testpersonen lesen kurze Texte mit informellen Argumenten und identifizieren ihre funktionalen Komponenten (z. B. Behauptung, Begründung, Schlussregel). Anhand einer Stichprobe von 225 Studierenden wurde der AST einer ersten Überprüfung seiner Reliabilität und Validität unterzogen. Dabei erwies sich der AST als intern valide, mit einer breiten Streuung der Itemschwierigkeiten. In einem explanatorischen Item-Response-Modell konnten die Itemschwierigkeiten sehr präzise durch theoretisch relevante Itemmerkmale, die das Argumentverstehen beeinflussen, vorhergesagt werden. Korrelationen mit verbaler Intelligenz und Schul- und Studienleistungen sprechen darüber hinaus für die Kriteriumsvalidität des Instruments.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2019
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 89 (3) , 501-523
The ability to evaluate arguments in scientific texts: Measurement, cognitive processes, nomological network, and relevance for academic success at the university
Background: The evaluation of informal arguments is a key component of comprehending scientific texts and scientific literacy. Aim: The present study examined the nomological network of university students’ ability to evaluate informal arguments in scientific texts and the relevance of this ability for academic success. Sample: A sample of 225 university students from the social and educational sciences participated in the study. Methods: Judgements of plausibility and the ability to recognize argumentation fallacies were assessed with a novel computer‐based diagnostic instrument (Argument Judgement Test; AJT ). Results: The items of the AJT partly conform to a 1‐ PL model and test scores were systematically related to epistemological beliefs and verbal intelligence. Item‐by‐item analyses of responses and response times showed that implausible arguments were more difficult to process and correct responses to these items required increased cognitive effort. Finally, the AJT scores predicted academic success at university even if verbal intelligence and grade point average were controlled for. Conclusion: These findings suggest that the ability to evaluate arguments in scientific texts is an aspect of rationality, relies on reflective processes, and is relevant for academic success.
- 17 June 2019
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 89 (3) , 501-523
Open AccessThe ability to evaluate arguments in scientific texts: Measurement, cognitive processes, nomological network, and relevance for academic success at the university
Background: The evaluation of informal arguments is a key component of comprehending scientific texts and scientific literacy. Aim: The present study examined the nomological network of university students’ ability to evaluate informal arguments in scientific texts and the relevance of this ability for academic success. Sample: A sample of 225 university students from the social and educational sciences participated in the study. Methods: Judgements of plausibility and the ability to recognize argumentation fallacies were assessed with a novel computer‐based diagnostic instrument (Argument Judgement Test; AJT ). Results: The items of the AJT partly conform to a 1‐ PL model and test scores were systematically related to epistemological beliefs and verbal intelligence. Item‐by‐item analyses of responses and response times showed that implausible arguments were more difficult to process and correct responses to these items required increased cognitive effort. Finally, the AJT scores predicted academic success at university even if verbal intelligence and grade point average were controlled for. Conclusion: These findings suggest that the ability to evaluate arguments in scientific texts is an aspect of rationality, relies on reflective processes, and is relevant for academic success.
- 14 November 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Educational Psychology
- Vol. 39 (4) , 530-549
Feeling good, learning better? Effectivity of an emotional design procedure in multimedia learning
Emotional designing describes the elicitation of positive affect during learning through specific design elements of the learning environment to enhance learning. This experimental study examined the effectivity of an emotional design procedure on learning performance. Moreover, the learner’s affective states before learning were taken into consideration as possible moderators. 145 university students learned for 20 min either in a multimedia positive affect inducing learning environment (n = 85) or a neutral multimedia learning environment (n = 60). The Affect was measured before, during, and after learning. Performance was tested afterwards. To control for possible confounding effects, achievement motivation, emotion regulation, and situational interest were measured. In contrast to earlier findings, no superiority effect of the emotional design procedure was found. Furthermore, the effectivity of the emotional design procedure was not moderated by student’s prior effective states. However, there was a main influence of student’s positive affect on transfer performance.
- 14 November 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Educational Psychology
- Vol. 39 (4) , 530-549
Feeling good, learning better? Effectivity of an emotional design procedure in multimedia learning
Emotional designing describes the elicitation of positive affect during learning through specific design elements of the learning environment to enhance learning. This experimental study examined the effectivity of an emotional design procedure on learning performance. Moreover, the learner’s affective states before learning were taken into consideration as possible moderators. 145 university students learned for 20 min either in a multimedia positive affect inducing learning environment (n = 85) or a neutral multimedia learning environment (n = 60). The Affect was measured before, during, and after learning. Performance was tested afterwards. To control for possible confounding effects, achievement motivation, emotion regulation, and situational interest were measured. In contrast to earlier findings, no superiority effect of the emotional design procedure was found. Furthermore, the effectivity of the emotional design procedure was not moderated by student’s prior effective states. However, there was a main influence of student’s positive affect on transfer performance.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Wiley in Education Research International
- Vol. 2017 (1)
The Better You Feel the Better You Learn: Do Warm Colours and Rounded Shapes Enhance Learning Outcome in Multimedia Learning?
The aim of the present study was to examine whether fostering positive activating affect during multimedia learning enhances learning outcome. University students were randomly assigned to either a multimedia learning environment designed to induce positive activating affect through the use of “warm” colours and rounded shapes (n = 61) or an affectively neutral environment that used achromatic colours and sharp edges (n = 50). Participants learned about the topic of functional neuroanatomy for 20 minutes and had to answer several questions for comprehension and transfer afterwards. Affective states as well as achievement goal orientations were investigated before and after the learning phase using questionnaires. The results show that participants in the affectively positive environment were superior in comprehension as well as transfer when initial affect was strong. Preexperimental positive affect was therefore a predictor of comprehension and a moderator for transfer. Goal orientations did not influence these effects. The findings support the idea that positive affect, induced through the design of the particular multimedia learning environment, can facilitate performance if initial affective states are taken into account.
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Wiley in Education Research International
- Vol. 2017 (1)
Open AccessThe Better You Feel the Better You Learn: Do Warm Colours and Rounded Shapes Enhance Learning Outcome in Multimedia Learning?
The aim of the present study was to examine whether fostering positive activating affect during multimedia learning enhances learning outcome. University students were randomly assigned to either a multimedia learning environment designed to induce positive activating affect through the use of “warm” colours and rounded shapes (n = 61) or an affectively neutral environment that used achromatic colours and sharp edges (n = 50). Participants learned about the topic of functional neuroanatomy for 20 minutes and had to answer several questions for comprehension and transfer afterwards. Affective states as well as achievement goal orientations were investigated before and after the learning phase using questionnaires. The results show that participants in the affectively positive environment were superior in comprehension as well as transfer when initial affect was strong. Preexperimental positive affect was therefore a predictor of comprehension and a moderator for transfer. Goal orientations did not influence these effects. The findings support the idea that positive affect, induced through the design of the particular multimedia learning environment, can facilitate performance if initial affective states are taken into account.