TKTine Köhler

Tine Köhler

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Tine Köhler has a total of 107 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Care-Full Reviewing at Academy of Management Journal : Celebrating Our Reviewers and Putting Care Front and Center in the Review Process

    by Madeline Toubiana, Fadel K. Matta, Jamie J. Ladge, Tine Köhler, David Kryscynski, Charlotte Cloutier, Benjamin M. Cole

  • Open Access

    Editorial: What Constitutes a Methodological Contribution at ORM ?

    by Tine Köhler, Lisa Schurer Lambert, Thomas Greckhamer, Michael Sturman, Catherine Welch, Jeremy F. Dawson, Justin DeSimone, Dina V. Krasikova, Jane K. Lȇ, Mikko Rönkkö, et al.

    Organizational Research Methods ( ORM ) is a research methods journal that aims to publish articles making a methodological contribution to management and organization science. In this editorial, we provide guidance for what constitutes a methodological contribution for this journal. Our goal is to facilitate understanding of how methodological contributions differ from theoretical or empirical contributions. We also seek to illustrate how a paper aspiring to make a methodological contribution needs to be crafted differently, including different needs for conceptual argumentation and empirical evidence. We offer specific examples of various kinds of methodological contributions that are more typical in qualitative and quantitative traditions, those of an ontological and epistemological nature, or those related to the method of theorizing more generally. We further highlight published ORM papers that offer concrete examples for each kind of contribution.

  • Research Methods Articles Designed to Advance Theory: An Update and Further Guidance

    by Paul D. Bliese, John Busenbark, S. Trevis Certo, Tine Köhler, Anne D. Smith, Quinetta Roberson

  • Open Access

    Advanced Qualitative Analyses for Theorizing: Balancing Deep Data Engagement With Imaginative Theorizing

    by Tine Köhler, Jane Lê, Anne Smith

    Qualitative research crucially contributes to knowledge generation via theory development, refinement, and refutation. A plethora of resources exist facilitating raw data engagement and immersion strategies. Yet, advanced analytic techniques for deriving theoretical insight are scantly understood and documented in the methods literature. The current paper creates a procedural framework for advancing theoretical insight via the use of qualitative analytic techniques by collating insights from the groundbreaking work of Klag and Langley , Langley , Locke et al. , and Locke —which builds heavily on Peirce's work on abduction and Weick's work on disciplined imagination. We construct this framework around three core processes: challenging, seeing, and articulating. We provide three practical examples from our own research projects to demonstrate how these core processes are supported by advanced analytic techniques. We discuss the impact of different theorizing goals, different epistemological grounding, future applications, and further methodological development.

  • Open Access

    Women’s and Men’s Authorship Experiences: A Prospective Meta-Analysis

    by George C. Banks, Lisa M. Rasmussen, Scott Tonidandel, Jeffrey M. Pollack, Mary M. Hausfeld, Courtney Williams, Betsy H. Albritton, Joseph A. Allen, Nicolas Bastardoz, John H. Batchelor, et al.

    The opaqueness of author naming and ordering, when coupled with power dynamics, can lead to a number of disadvantages in academic careers. In this commentary, we investigate gender differences in authorship experiences in a large prospective meta-analytic study (k = 46; n = 3,565; 12 countries). We find that women’s and men’s authorship experiences differ significantly with women reporting greater prevalence of problematic behaviors. We present seven actionable recommendations for improving the receipt and reporting of intellectual credit. Such actions are needed to ensure fairness in authorship, which is one of the most powerful factors in academics’ career outcomes.


  • The influence of personality on emotional and behavioral responses to psychological contract breach

    by Rachel M. Saef, Tine Köhler, Andrew Jebb

    Using Hirschman's Exit–Voice–Loyalty–Neglect (EVLN) framework, this study examines the dual-moderating role of the big five personality traits in shaping workers' behavioral responses to psychological contract breach. Building from calls for research on individual differences in psychological contract dynamics, the current study applies the theory of purposeful work behavior to delineate how the higher-order goals prescribed by one's personality jointly guide interpretation processes in forming emotional and behavioral responses. In doing so, we map how certain big five traits shape felt violation and EVLN responses following breach events, while others seem to only moderate emotional or EVLN responses. A scenario-based experimental study asked participants (N = 610) about their reactions to a breach event. We tested a dual moderated mediation model, in which agreeableness, extraversion, conscientiousness and neuroticism moderated the intensity of felt violation, and the likelihood of each EVLN behavior following from felt violation. We found evidence for the dual moderating effect of agreeableness on voice responses to breach. Additionally, neuroticism strengthened felt violation following breach, and extraversion weakened endorsement of neglecting work to cope with felt violation. Our results suggest that certain traits are particularly important for individual differences in emotional responses to breach (e.g. neuroticism), while others are important for shaping differences in behavior (e.g. extraversion). Additionally, results shed light on the importance of taking a person-by-situation perspective in understanding work behavior, such that extraversion, while conceptualized as general emotional tendencies, does not significantly influence felt violation in breach contexts. While previous research has looked at how personality traits moderate either the breach–felt violation relation or the breach–EVLN relation, research has yet to test the moderating effect of personality simultaneously. Excluding one or the other overlooks important individual differences in the process, as interpretation processes guiding emotional and behavioral responses happen concurrently. In doing so, we examine responses to a specific breach event (rather than general breach perceptions), as this better aligns with the conceptualizations of breach (as specific occasions of broken promises) and felt violation (as an emotional state).


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Qualitative Restudies: Research Designs for Retheorizing

    by Tine Köhler, Maria Rumyantseva, Catherine Welch

    Qualitative research methods are deemed best suited to exploring novel phenomena and generating new concepts. Their potential to reevaluate existing theorizing, however, is underestimated. Qualitative restudies that return to the data and settings on which the original theories were built are a well-established tradition in other disciplines (e.g., history, sociology, and anthropology), but have received little recognition in management and organization studies. We introduce qualitative restudies as a powerful means to improve theorizing by revising or challenging theories that have become outdated or obsolete and establishing transferability and longevity of findings and interpretations. We provide a typology of qualitative restudy designs drawing on an integrative review of literature in management, strategy, and the social sciences and humanities. We highlight the main design and ethical considerations for researchers in undertaking a restudy. We argue for the strengths of restudies as lying in their possibilities for retheorizing, above and beyond verifying or updating prior studies. Restudies draw on the strengths of in-depth qualitative work to uncover how interpretations and theorizing are shaped by methodological traditions, historical contexts, existing societal structures, and researcher backgrounds.


  • Current reproducibility practices in management: What they are versus what they could be

    by José M. Cortina, Tine Köhler, Lydia C. Aulisi

    While debates about a replication crisis in organization studies have taken up significant journal space over the past years, the issue of reproducibility has been mostly ignored. Reproducibility manifests when researchers draw the same conclusions from a reanalysis of the same dataset as used in the original study with the same (literal reproducibility) or superior (constructive reproducibility) data analytic techniques. Reproducibility studies are crucial for correcting accidental mistakes as well as intentional distortions during data preparation and analysis, thus allowing a science to be self-correcting. In the current editorial, we define reproducibility, provide published examples that illustrate the crucial role that reproducibility plays in scientific knowledge production, and offer findings from a review of papers published in the 2019 volumes of Academy of Management Journal and Journal of Management to explore how frequently different forms of reproducibility are employed in the top management outlet. We discuss the implications of our findings for future research and reporting practices and offer guidance for authors, reviewers, and editors.