Gabriel Chan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Gabriel Chan has a total of 57 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Laura Diaz Anadon
Harvard Kennedy School, Harvard University, 79 John F. Kennedy Street, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA
5 shared publicationsAudrey Lee
2 shared publications- Laura Diaz Anadon
Centre for Environment, Energy and Natural Resource Governance, Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
2 shared publications - Matthew Grimley
Humphrey School of Public Affairs, University of Minnesota, 301 19th Ave S., Minneapolis, MN 55455, United States of America
2 shared publications Sharmila L. Murthy
Suffolk University Law School, Suffolk University, Boston, MA 02108
2 shared publicationsSteffen Jenner
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research: Energy
- Vol. 2 (2) , 025002
Ratemaking for the mid-transition: an example of the social construction of electric system prices from community shared solar
Electric utility rates are usually presented to consumers as reflecting costs or market efficiency. But we argue that utility rates and prices are more than they seem: they are socially constructed, formed from deeply held institutional logics. Working with 104 community shared solar (CSS) subscription contracts across 33 utility programs in Minnesota, we examine the rhetoric over cross-subsidy and ‘paying a fair share,’ showing the construction of utility costs, benefits, and values of these programs. We develop a financial model, apply archival research, and use ethnographic methods to analyze how these electricity system prices of CSS are constructed. We use a framework of embedded, short-run incremental, and long-run incremental institutional logics, demonstrating that if advocates and energy transition researchers are to take clean energy deployment, innovation, and equity seriously, they need more education, transparency, and communication around these logics and their effect on prices. We argue that with a better shared understanding of how electricity prices form, we can take responsibility for our imagined constraints and create electricity prices that can navigate the transition’s phase-in and phase-out activities toward collective, long-term benefit.
- 8 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research: Energy
- Vol. 2 (2) , 025002
Open AccessRatemaking for the mid-transition: an example of the social construction of electric system prices from community shared solar
Electric utility rates are usually presented to consumers as reflecting costs or market efficiency. But we argue that utility rates and prices are more than they seem: they are socially constructed, formed from deeply held institutional logics. Working with 104 community shared solar (CSS) subscription contracts across 33 utility programs in Minnesota, we examine the rhetoric over cross-subsidy and ‘paying a fair share,’ showing the construction of utility costs, benefits, and values of these programs. We develop a financial model, apply archival research, and use ethnographic methods to analyze how these electricity system prices of CSS are constructed. We use a framework of embedded, short-run incremental, and long-run incremental institutional logics, demonstrating that if advocates and energy transition researchers are to take clean energy deployment, innovation, and equity seriously, they need more education, transparency, and communication around these logics and their effect on prices. We argue that with a better shared understanding of how electricity prices form, we can take responsibility for our imagined constraints and create electricity prices that can navigate the transition’s phase-in and phase-out activities toward collective, long-term benefit.
- Open Access
- 11 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Policy Studies Journal
- Vol. 53 (3) , 654-680
Institutions, in time: Designing feedback pathways for shared infrastructure transitions
Electric utilities, challenged by a rapidly unfolding energy transition, use many informal institutions to bridge across technologies and sectors. Little is known, however, about how electric utility systems and other polycentric systems' institutions‐in‐use vary and evolve over time. We use a novel engaged research method, the Nominal Group Technique, to solicit current, future, and potential institutions‐in‐use from 66 staff and board members across 18 electric utilities in a shared electric system in Minnesota. Our questions focus on favored institutions for distributed energy resources like solar, electric vehicles, and batteries. Generating 578 ideas, we parse each into institutional statements using Institutional Grammar. We then identify institutional configurations for current and desired feedback pathways across different infrastructures and actor groups. Our results demonstrate the potential importance of structure and context‐related adjustment mechanisms in designing change for shared infrastructure systems and the potential importance of information and payoff rules. Theoretically, we advance understanding of change theories in polycentric governance systems, toward linear, parallel, recursive, and conjunctive dynamics that expand beyond evolutionary change theories. Our methods point toward engaged research methods as a way to help converse between theory and practice, particularly in institutionally and technologically complex systems in periods of transition.摘要: 面对快速展开的能源转型挑战,电力公司使用许多非正式制度来连接技术和部门。然而,研究不足的是,电力公司系统和其他多中心系统的现行制度如何随时间推移而变化和发展。我们使用一种新颖的参与式研究方法(即名义团体技术),从明尼苏达州的一个共享电力系统中的18家电力公司的66名员工和董事会成员那里征集当前、未来和潜在的现行制度。我们的问题聚焦于太阳能、电动汽车和电池等分布式能源资源所偏好的制度。我们生成了578个想法,并使用制度语法将每个想法解析为制度陈述,以帮助确定不同基础设施和行动者群体中当前和期望的反馈途径的制度配置。我们的研究结果表明,结构和与情境相关的调整机制在“设计共享基础设施系统变革”方面具有潜在重要性,信息和回报规则也具有潜在重要性。我们从理论上增进了对多中心治理系统中变革理论的理解,即朝着“超越进化变革理论的线性、并行、递归和联合动态”发展。我们的方法将参与式研究方法作为一种方式来帮助理论与实践之间的交流,特别针对在转型期间具备复杂制度和复杂技术的系统。Resumen: Las empresas eléctricas, ante el desafío de una transición energética que se desarrolla rápidamente, utilizan muchas instituciones informales para tender puentes entre tecnologías y sectores. Pero se sabe poco sobre cómo varían y evolucionan con el tiempo las instituciones en uso de los sistemas de servicios eléctricos y otros sistemas policéntricos. Utilizamos un novedoso método de investigación comprometida, la Técnica de Grupo Nominal, para solicitar instituciones en uso actuales, futuras y potenciales a 66 miembros del personal y de la junta directiva de 18 empresas eléctricas en un sistema eléctrico compartido en Minnesota. Nuestras preguntas se centran en las instituciones favoritas para los recursos energéticos distribuidos, como la energía solar, los vehículos eléctricos y las baterías. Generamos 578 ideas y las analizamos en declaraciones institucionales utilizando la Gramática Institucional, para ayudar a identificar configuraciones institucionales para las vías de retroalimentación actuales y deseadas en diferentes infraestructuras y grupos de actores. Nuestros resultados demuestran la importancia potencial de la estructura y los mecanismos de ajuste relacionados con el contexto en el diseño de cambios para sistemas de infraestructura compartida y la importancia potencial de la información y las reglas de recompensa. Teóricamente, avanzamos en la comprensión de las teorías del cambio en sistemas de gobernanza policéntrica, hacia dinámicas lineales, paralelas, recursivas y conjuntivas que se expanden más allá de las teorías del cambio evolutivo. Nuestros métodos apuntan hacia métodos de investigación comprometidos como una forma de ayudar a conversar entre la teoría y la práctica, particularmente en sistemas institucional y tecnológicamente complejos en períodos de transición. institucional y tecnológicamente complejos en períodos de transición
- 11 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Policy Studies Journal
- Vol. 53 (3) , 654-680
Open AccessInstitutions, in time: Designing feedback pathways for shared infrastructure transitions
Electric utilities, challenged by a rapidly unfolding energy transition, use many informal institutions to bridge across technologies and sectors. Little is known, however, about how electric utility systems and other polycentric systems' institutions‐in‐use vary and evolve over time. We use a novel engaged research method, the Nominal Group Technique, to solicit current, future, and potential institutions‐in‐use from 66 staff and board members across 18 electric utilities in a shared electric system in Minnesota. Our questions focus on favored institutions for distributed energy resources like solar, electric vehicles, and batteries. Generating 578 ideas, we parse each into institutional statements using Institutional Grammar. We then identify institutional configurations for current and desired feedback pathways across different infrastructures and actor groups. Our results demonstrate the potential importance of structure and context‐related adjustment mechanisms in designing change for shared infrastructure systems and the potential importance of information and payoff rules. Theoretically, we advance understanding of change theories in polycentric governance systems, toward linear, parallel, recursive, and conjunctive dynamics that expand beyond evolutionary change theories. Our methods point toward engaged research methods as a way to help converse between theory and practice, particularly in institutionally and technologically complex systems in periods of transition.摘要: 面对快速展开的能源转型挑战,电力公司使用许多非正式制度来连接技术和部门。然而,研究不足的是,电力公司系统和其他多中心系统的现行制度如何随时间推移而变化和发展。我们使用一种新颖的参与式研究方法(即名义团体技术),从明尼苏达州的一个共享电力系统中的18家电力公司的66名员工和董事会成员那里征集当前、未来和潜在的现行制度。我们的问题聚焦于太阳能、电动汽车和电池等分布式能源资源所偏好的制度。我们生成了578个想法,并使用制度语法将每个想法解析为制度陈述,以帮助确定不同基础设施和行动者群体中当前和期望的反馈途径的制度配置。我们的研究结果表明,结构和与情境相关的调整机制在“设计共享基础设施系统变革”方面具有潜在重要性,信息和回报规则也具有潜在重要性。我们从理论上增进了对多中心治理系统中变革理论的理解,即朝着“超越进化变革理论的线性、并行、递归和联合动态”发展。我们的方法将参与式研究方法作为一种方式来帮助理论与实践之间的交流,特别针对在转型期间具备复杂制度和复杂技术的系统。Resumen: Las empresas eléctricas, ante el desafío de una transición energética que se desarrolla rápidamente, utilizan muchas instituciones informales para tender puentes entre tecnologías y sectores. Pero se sabe poco sobre cómo varían y evolucionan con el tiempo las instituciones en uso de los sistemas de servicios eléctricos y otros sistemas policéntricos. Utilizamos un novedoso método de investigación comprometida, la Técnica de Grupo Nominal, para solicitar instituciones en uso actuales, futuras y potenciales a 66 miembros del personal y de la junta directiva de 18 empresas eléctricas en un sistema eléctrico compartido en Minnesota. Nuestras preguntas se centran en las instituciones favoritas para los recursos energéticos distribuidos, como la energía solar, los vehículos eléctricos y las baterías. Generamos 578 ideas y las analizamos en declaraciones institucionales utilizando la Gramática Institucional, para ayudar a identificar configuraciones institucionales para las vías de retroalimentación actuales y deseadas en diferentes infraestructuras y grupos de actores. Nuestros resultados demuestran la importancia potencial de la estructura y los mecanismos de ajuste relacionados con el contexto en el diseño de cambios para sistemas de infraestructura compartida y la importancia potencial de la información y las reglas de recompensa. Teóricamente, avanzamos en la comprensión de las teorías del cambio en sistemas de gobernanza policéntrica, hacia dinámicas lineales, paralelas, recursivas y conjuntivas que se expanden más allá de las teorías del cambio evolutivo. Nuestros métodos apuntan hacia métodos de investigación comprometidos como una forma de ayudar a conversar entre la teoría y la práctica, particularmente en sistemas institucional y tecnológicamente complejos en períodos de transición. institucional y tecnológicamente complejos en períodos de transición
- Open Access
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Technovation
- Vol. 134
A framework and methodology for analyzing technology spillover processes with an application in solar photovoltaics
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Technovation
- Vol. 134
Open AccessA framework and methodology for analyzing technology spillover processes with an application in solar photovoltaics
- 21 November 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Energy Policy
- Vol. 172
“Cooperative is an oxymoron!”: A polycentric energy transition perspective on distributed energy deployment in the Upper Midwestern United States
- 21 November 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Energy Policy
- Vol. 172
“Cooperative is an oxymoron!”: A polycentric energy transition perspective on distributed energy deployment in the Upper Midwestern United States
- Open Access
- 21 November 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Cooperative Clean Energy
The last decade has seen significant attention and debate among academics, policymakers, and the broader public about how to accelerate the “clean energy transition” in the United States. Legal academics have made valuable contributions to the literature in this field, developing a rich body of scholarship on a broad range of legal, policy, economic, and technological aspects of the clean energy transition in the electricity sector. But this scholarship has for the most part ignored the role of rural electric cooperatives, which serve 14% of the U.S. population. This scholarship gap has important implications. Rural electric cooperatives, first created by local communities in the United States in the early part of the 20th century to electrify rural America, own and continue to operate a significant percentage of the nation’s coal-fired power plants. Retiring these plants and replacing them with clean energy would reduce the nation’s contribution to global climate change and help ensure that rural America is not left with billions of dollars of stranded coal-fired power plant assets that can no longer compete against low-cost renewable energy. In this Article, we draw on the structure and foundational principles underlying the cooperative form itself to create a framework for clean energy transition in rural electric cooperatives. Notably, the proposals we develop in this Article do not rely on imposing new federal or state clean energy mandates on cooperatives, as has been the focus of the limited legal scholarship that exists to date. Although such mandates can be very effective, the long history of Congress and state legislatures allowing cooperatives to “self-regulate” makes reliance on such mandates a limited solution at best. Instead, we draw on the “Cooperative Principles” that govern all cooperatives—open and voluntary membership; democratic member control; members’ economic participation; autonomy and independence; education, training, and information; cooperation among cooperatives; and concern for community. Emphasis on these principles allows cooperatives to engage in the clean energy transition in a way that builds on their history and foundational principles as self-help organizations controlled by their members. Such an approach also recognizes the increasing grassroots activism within cooperatives that has the potential to increase democratic accountability focused on clean energy deployment along with calls for increased racial and social equity in cooperative governance.
- 21 November 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessCooperative Clean Energy
The last decade has seen significant attention and debate among academics, policymakers, and the broader public about how to accelerate the “clean energy transition” in the United States. Legal academics have made valuable contributions to the literature in this field, developing a rich body of scholarship on a broad range of legal, policy, economic, and technological aspects of the clean energy transition in the electricity sector. But this scholarship has for the most part ignored the role of rural electric cooperatives, which serve 14% of the U.S. population. This scholarship gap has important implications. Rural electric cooperatives, first created by local communities in the United States in the early part of the 20th century to electrify rural America, own and continue to operate a significant percentage of the nation’s coal-fired power plants. Retiring these plants and replacing them with clean energy would reduce the nation’s contribution to global climate change and help ensure that rural America is not left with billions of dollars of stranded coal-fired power plant assets that can no longer compete against low-cost renewable energy. In this Article, we draw on the structure and foundational principles underlying the cooperative form itself to create a framework for clean energy transition in rural electric cooperatives. Notably, the proposals we develop in this Article do not rely on imposing new federal or state clean energy mandates on cooperatives, as has been the focus of the limited legal scholarship that exists to date. Although such mandates can be very effective, the long history of Congress and state legislatures allowing cooperatives to “self-regulate” makes reliance on such mandates a limited solution at best. Instead, we draw on the “Cooperative Principles” that govern all cooperatives—open and voluntary membership; democratic member control; members’ economic participation; autonomy and independence; education, training, and information; cooperation among cooperatives; and concern for community. Emphasis on these principles allows cooperatives to engage in the clean energy transition in a way that builds on their history and foundational principles as self-help organizations controlled by their members. Such an approach also recognizes the increasing grassroots activism within cooperatives that has the potential to increase democratic accountability focused on clean energy deployment along with calls for increased racial and social equity in cooperative governance.
- Open Access
- 25 August 2020
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 15 (9) , 093006
A review of barriers in implementing dynamic electricity pricing to achieve cost-causality
Rapidly changing economics, customer preferences, and policy to address climate change and local environmental pollutants have driven increased deployment of a wide range of distributed energy resources in the U.S. electricity system. Distributed energy resources have enabled an expanded role for energy consumers and non-utility third parties to reshape system costs, drawing renewed attention to the potential of reforming electricity rate design based on the further application of cost-causal principals to improve overall system fairness and efficiency. One mechanism to move toward greater application of cost-causal rate design is dynamic pricing, which varies electricity prices across time and location to reflect costs of providing electricity to consumers under specific market conditions and grid operation conditions. While dynamic electricity pricing has penetrated some markets, and it has not been widely implemented, particularly for residential consumers. In this review article, we provide a brief summary of electricity rate design, including the possibility of introducing dynamic prices, and explain why dynamic prices are more reflective of the short-run marginal costs of electricity supply than volumetric rates. We then explore the barriers to the widespread adoption of residential dynamic pricing, emphasizing technical, economic, and political challenges. Our assessment reflects the ability of dynamic prices to engender more equitable and efficient outcomes by achieving the goal of cost-causality, and we argue that a move toward more dynamic pricing can constitute a welfare improvement over volumetric rates. However, dynamic pricing does not completely address the full set of challenges associated with rate design and, alone, is unlikely to enable the full recovery of fixed costs and the fair attribution of the positive and negative externalities of electricity provision. Therefore, electricity rate design requires tradeoffs, making it as much an art as a science. This analysis synthesizes literature across multiple fields and suggests avenues for further research.
- 25 August 2020
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 15 (9) , 093006
Open AccessA review of barriers in implementing dynamic electricity pricing to achieve cost-causality
Rapidly changing economics, customer preferences, and policy to address climate change and local environmental pollutants have driven increased deployment of a wide range of distributed energy resources in the U.S. electricity system. Distributed energy resources have enabled an expanded role for energy consumers and non-utility third parties to reshape system costs, drawing renewed attention to the potential of reforming electricity rate design based on the further application of cost-causal principals to improve overall system fairness and efficiency. One mechanism to move toward greater application of cost-causal rate design is dynamic pricing, which varies electricity prices across time and location to reflect costs of providing electricity to consumers under specific market conditions and grid operation conditions. While dynamic electricity pricing has penetrated some markets, and it has not been widely implemented, particularly for residential consumers. In this review article, we provide a brief summary of electricity rate design, including the possibility of introducing dynamic prices, and explain why dynamic prices are more reflective of the short-run marginal costs of electricity supply than volumetric rates. We then explore the barriers to the widespread adoption of residential dynamic pricing, emphasizing technical, economic, and political challenges. Our assessment reflects the ability of dynamic prices to engender more equitable and efficient outcomes by achieving the goal of cost-causality, and we argue that a move toward more dynamic pricing can constitute a welfare improvement over volumetric rates. However, dynamic pricing does not completely address the full set of challenges associated with rate design and, alone, is unlikely to enable the full recovery of fixed costs and the fair attribution of the positive and negative externalities of electricity provision. Therefore, electricity rate design requires tradeoffs, making it as much an art as a science. This analysis synthesizes literature across multiple fields and suggests avenues for further research.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2018
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 13 (4) , 044001
Why is China’s wind power generation not living up to its potential?
- 19 March 2018
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 13 (4) , 044001
Open AccessWhy is China’s wind power generation not living up to its potential?
- 31 October 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Energy
- Vol. 1 (11) , 16171
Energy poverty: Electrification and well-being
- 31 October 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Energy
- Vol. 1 (11) , 16171
Energy poverty: Electrification and well-being
- 12 September 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Energy
- Vol. 1 (10) , 16117-8
The pressing energy innovation challenge of the US National Laboratories
- 12 September 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Energy
- Vol. 1 (10) , 16117-8
The pressing energy innovation challenge of the US National Laboratories