Sinan Aral
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Recognitions
Sinan Aral has a total of 57 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Paramveer S. Dhillon
School of Information, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA
7 shared publications - Dean Eckles
Institute for Data, Systems, and Society, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States of America; Sloan School of Management, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States of America
6 shared publications - Harang Ju
Carey Business School, Johns Hopkins University
4 shared publications - Avinash Collis
McCombs School of Business, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, USA
3 shared publications - David Holtz
Decision, Risk and Operations, Columbia Business School, New York, USA
3 shared publications - Mohammad Amin Rahimian
Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Pittsburgh
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 August 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123  (35)
Personality pairing improves human–AI collaboration
Here we examine how AI agent “personalities” interact with human personalities to shape human–AI collaboration and performance. In a large-scale, preregistered randomized experiment, we paired 1,258 participants with AI agents prompted to exhibit varying levels of the Big Five personality traits. These human–AI teams produced 7,266 display ads for a real think tank, which we evaluated using 1,168 independent human raters, and a field experiment on X that generated nearly 5 million impressions. We found that human and AI personalities individually shaped ad quality and teamwork and that human–AI personality pairings directly influenced ad quality. For example, extraverted humans paired with conscientious AI produced the lowest quality ads, followed by conscientious humans paired with agreeable AI and neurotic humans paired with conscientious AI. In the field experiment, ad quality significantly influenced ad performance, measured by click-through rates and cost-per-click. Together, these results demonstrate that personality pairing can improve human–AI collaboration and performance. They also motivate future research on the complex implications of AI personalization for human–AI collaboration, teamwork, and performance.
- 28 August 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123  (35)
Open AccessPersonality pairing improves human–AI collaboration
Here we examine how AI agent “personalities” interact with human personalities to shape human–AI collaboration and performance. In a large-scale, preregistered randomized experiment, we paired 1,258 participants with AI agents prompted to exhibit varying levels of the Big Five personality traits. These human–AI teams produced 7,266 display ads for a real think tank, which we evaluated using 1,168 independent human raters, and a field experiment on X that generated nearly 5 million impressions. We found that human and AI personalities individually shaped ad quality and teamwork and that human–AI personality pairings directly influenced ad quality. For example, extraverted humans paired with conscientious AI produced the lowest quality ads, followed by conscientious humans paired with agreeable AI and neurotic humans paired with conscientious AI. In the field experiment, ad quality significantly influenced ad performance, measured by click-through rates and cost-per-click. Together, these results demonstrate that personality pairing can improve human–AI collaboration and performance. They also motivate future research on the complex implications of AI personalization for human–AI collaboration, teamwork, and performance.
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
Scalable Bundle Recommendations: A Large-Scale Field Experiment
We develop an end-to-end, scalable machine learning framework for designing bundle recommendations in a high-dimensional choice setting. We leverage historical purchases and consideration sets determined from clickstream data to generate dense representations (embeddings) of products. We impose minimal structure on these embeddings and develop heuristics for complementarity and substitutability among products. Subsequently, we use the heuristics to create multiple bundle recommendations for each of 4,500 focal products and test their performance using a field experiment with a large retailer. We use the experimental data to optimize the recommendation design policy with offline policy learning. Our optimized policy is robust across product categories, generalizes well to the retailer’s entire assortment, and provides an expected improvement of 35% ([Formula: see text] per 100 visits) in revenue from bundle recommendations over the baseline policy. This paper was accepted by Hemant Bhargava, information systems. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.01864 .
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
Scalable Bundle Recommendations: A Large-Scale Field Experiment
We develop an end-to-end, scalable machine learning framework for designing bundle recommendations in a high-dimensional choice setting. We leverage historical purchases and consideration sets determined from clickstream data to generate dense representations (embeddings) of products. We impose minimal structure on these embeddings and develop heuristics for complementarity and substitutability among products. Subsequently, we use the heuristics to create multiple bundle recommendations for each of 4,500 focal products and test their performance using a field experiment with a large retailer. We use the experimental data to optimize the recommendation design policy with offline policy learning. Our optimized policy is robust across product categories, generalizes well to the retailer’s entire assortment, and provides an expected improvement of 35% ([Formula: see text] per 100 visits) in revenue from bundle recommendations over the baseline policy. This paper was accepted by Hemant Bhargava, information systems. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.01864 .
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Information Systems Research
Explaining Sustained Blockchain Decentralization with Quasi-Experiments: The Resource Flexibility of Consensus Mechanisms
Blockchains support a rapidly growing digital economy. Through decentralization, they enable the ownership and transfer of digital assets without centralized intermediaries while resisting attacks, faults, and collusion. Yet decentralization is not guaranteed and must be sustained against external shocks. What design choices help blockchains maintain decentralization when disrupted? We find that resource flexibility, how easily consensus resources can be moved and redeployed, is key to sustained decentralization. Using three real-world shocks—China’s 2021 crypto mining ban, Hetzner’s 2022 shutdown of Solana validators, and Ethereum’s transition from proof-of-work to proof-of-stake—we show that blockchains whose consensus resources are more flexible recover decentralization faster. These findings offer actionable guidance. Blockchain designers should consider resource flexibility as a first-order design parameter. Operators should diversify infrastructure across jurisdictions to reduce vulnerability to localized shocks. Policymakers should be aware that regulations targeting blockchains can have unintended effects on decentralization.
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Information Systems Research
Explaining Sustained Blockchain Decentralization with Quasi-Experiments: The Resource Flexibility of Consensus Mechanisms
Blockchains support a rapidly growing digital economy. Through decentralization, they enable the ownership and transfer of digital assets without centralized intermediaries while resisting attacks, faults, and collusion. Yet decentralization is not guaranteed and must be sustained against external shocks. What design choices help blockchains maintain decentralization when disrupted? We find that resource flexibility, how easily consensus resources can be moved and redeployed, is key to sustained decentralization. Using three real-world shocks—China’s 2021 crypto mining ban, Hetzner’s 2022 shutdown of Solana validators, and Ethereum’s transition from proof-of-work to proof-of-stake—we show that blockchains whose consensus resources are more flexible recover decentralization faster. These findings offer actionable guidance. Blockchain designers should consider resource flexibility as a first-order design parameter. Operators should diversify infrastructure across jurisdictions to reduce vulnerability to localized shocks. Policymakers should be aware that regulations targeting blockchains can have unintended effects on decentralization.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 5 June 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123  (23)
Advancing AI negotiations: A large-scale autonomous negotiation competition
We conducted an international AI negotiation competition in which participants designed and refined prompts for AI negotiation agents. We then facilitated over 180,000 negotiations between these agents across multiple scenarios with diverse characteristics and objectives. Our findings revealed that principles from human negotiation theory remain crucial even in AI–AI contexts. Surprisingly, warmth—a traditionally human relationship-building trait—was consistently associated with superior outcomes across all key performance metrics. Dominant agents, meanwhile, were especially effective at claiming value. Our analysis also revealed unique dynamics in AI–AI negotiations not fully explained by negotiation theory, including AI-specific technical strategies like chain-of-thought reasoning and prompt injection. When we applied natural language processing methods to the full transcripts of all negotiations, we found positivity, gratitude, and question-asking (associated with warmth) were strongly associated with reaching deals as well as objective and subjective value, whereas conversation lengths (associated with dominance) were strongly associated with impasses. The results suggest the need to establish a new theory of AI negotiation, which integrates classic negotiation theory with AI-specific negotiation theories to better understand autonomous negotiations and optimize agent performance.
- 5 June 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123  (23)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessAdvancing AI negotiations: A large-scale autonomous negotiation competition
We conducted an international AI negotiation competition in which participants designed and refined prompts for AI negotiation agents. We then facilitated over 180,000 negotiations between these agents across multiple scenarios with diverse characteristics and objectives. Our findings revealed that principles from human negotiation theory remain crucial even in AI–AI contexts. Surprisingly, warmth—a traditionally human relationship-building trait—was consistently associated with superior outcomes across all key performance metrics. Dominant agents, meanwhile, were especially effective at claiming value. Our analysis also revealed unique dynamics in AI–AI negotiations not fully explained by negotiation theory, including AI-specific technical strategies like chain-of-thought reasoning and prompt injection. When we applied natural language processing methods to the full transcripts of all negotiations, we found positivity, gratitude, and question-asking (associated with warmth) were strongly associated with reaching deals as well as objective and subjective value, whereas conversation lengths (associated with dominance) were strongly associated with impasses. The results suggest the need to establish a new theory of AI negotiation, which integrates classic negotiation theory with AI-specific negotiation theories to better understand autonomous negotiations and optimize agent performance.
- Open Access
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 5  (5) , pgag144
Teaching AI to handle exceptions: Supervised fine-tuning with human-aligned judgment
Large language models (LLMs), initially developed for generative AI, are now evolving into agentic AI systems, which make decisions in complex, real-world contexts. Unfortunately, while their generative capabilities are well-documented, their decision-making processes remain poorly understood. This is particularly evident when testing targeted decision-making: for instance, how models handle exceptions, a critical and challenging aspect of decision-making made relevant by the inherent incompleteness of contracts. Here, we demonstrate that LLMs, even ones that excel at reasoning, deviate significantly from human judgments because they adhere strictly to policies, even when such adherence is impractical, suboptimal, or even counterproductive. We then evaluate three approaches to tuning AI agents to handle exceptions: ethical framework prompting, chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, and supervised fine-tuning. We find that while ethical framework prompting fails and CoT prompting provides only slight improvements, supervised fine-tuning—specifically with human explanations—yields markedly better results. Surprisingly, in our experiments, supervised fine-tuning even enabled models to generalize human-like decision-making to novel scenarios, demonstrating transfer learning of human-aligned decision-making across contexts. Furthermore, fine-tuning with explanations, not just labels, was critical for alignment, suggesting that aligning LLMs with human judgment requires explicit training on how decisions are made, not just which decisions are made. These findings highlight the need to address LLMs’ shortcomings in handling exceptions in order to guide the development of agentic AI toward models that can effectively align with human judgment and simultaneously adapt to novel contexts.
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 5  (5) , pgag144
Open AccessTeaching AI to handle exceptions: Supervised fine-tuning with human-aligned judgment
Large language models (LLMs), initially developed for generative AI, are now evolving into agentic AI systems, which make decisions in complex, real-world contexts. Unfortunately, while their generative capabilities are well-documented, their decision-making processes remain poorly understood. This is particularly evident when testing targeted decision-making: for instance, how models handle exceptions, a critical and challenging aspect of decision-making made relevant by the inherent incompleteness of contracts. Here, we demonstrate that LLMs, even ones that excel at reasoning, deviate significantly from human judgments because they adhere strictly to policies, even when such adherence is impractical, suboptimal, or even counterproductive. We then evaluate three approaches to tuning AI agents to handle exceptions: ethical framework prompting, chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, and supervised fine-tuning. We find that while ethical framework prompting fails and CoT prompting provides only slight improvements, supervised fine-tuning—specifically with human explanations—yields markedly better results. Surprisingly, in our experiments, supervised fine-tuning even enabled models to generalize human-like decision-making to novel scenarios, demonstrating transfer learning of human-aligned decision-making across contexts. Furthermore, fine-tuning with explanations, not just labels, was critical for alignment, suggesting that aligning LLMs with human judgment requires explicit training on how decisions are made, not just which decisions are made. These findings highlight the need to address LLMs’ shortcomings in handling exceptions in order to guide the development of agentic AI toward models that can effectively align with human judgment and simultaneously adapt to novel contexts.
- 21 October 2025
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing
- Vol. 20  (5) , 633-656
Effects of video ad features on audience engagement: evidence from a large-scale video platform
Purpose: Understanding video advertising effectiveness is essential, given advertisers’ substantial investment in the format and its ubiquitous presence in our daily lives. But understanding video ad feature effectiveness is challenging due to the limited availability of video ad data and the complexity of video features. Design/methodology/approach: We therefore collected video ad and performance data on more than 90,000 video ad campaigns, registering 1 trillion impressions, across more than 20 industry segments, on six popular social media platforms, including Facebook, YouTube, SnapChat, LinkedIn, Twitter and Pinterest. We establish a taxonomy of video ad features, based on the Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM), using unsupervised clustering to explore how different features cluster across our sample. We then perform a feature importance analysis, using group Lasso and Random Forest models, and employ multilevel linear models of video feature effects on ad performance. Findings: We find, for example, that the presence and early appearance of text in videos reduces view-related performance metrics, while the presence and early appearance of people improves view-related metrics. We also explore the heterogeneity of video ad feature performance effects across platforms, industries and campaign objectives. As predicted by ELM, for example, text reduces ad performance in the luxury industry and increases performance in professional services ads. Originality/value: To our knowledge, ours is the largest analysis of video ad features and their performance implications to date. We hope to provide a foundation for future causal studies of video ad features and their performance effects.
- 21 October 2025
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing
- Vol. 20  (5) , 633-656
Effects of video ad features on audience engagement: evidence from a large-scale video platform
Purpose: Understanding video advertising effectiveness is essential, given advertisers’ substantial investment in the format and its ubiquitous presence in our daily lives. But understanding video ad feature effectiveness is challenging due to the limited availability of video ad data and the complexity of video features. Design/methodology/approach: We therefore collected video ad and performance data on more than 90,000 video ad campaigns, registering 1 trillion impressions, across more than 20 industry segments, on six popular social media platforms, including Facebook, YouTube, SnapChat, LinkedIn, Twitter and Pinterest. We establish a taxonomy of video ad features, based on the Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM), using unsupervised clustering to explore how different features cluster across our sample. We then perform a feature importance analysis, using group Lasso and Random Forest models, and employ multilevel linear models of video feature effects on ad performance. Findings: We find, for example, that the presence and early appearance of text in videos reduces view-related performance metrics, while the presence and early appearance of people improves view-related metrics. We also explore the heterogeneity of video ad feature performance effects across platforms, industries and campaign objectives. As predicted by ELM, for example, text reduces ad performance in the luxury industry and increases performance in professional services ads. Originality/value: To our knowledge, ours is the largest analysis of video ad features and their performance implications to date. We hope to provide a foundation for future causal studies of video ad features and their performance effects.
- Open Access
Measuring Social Media Network Effects
We use representative, incentive-compatible online choice experiments involving 19,923 Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, and X users in the US to provide the first large-scale, empirical measurement of local network effects in the digital economy. Our analysis reveals social media platform value ranges from $78 to $101 per consumer, per month, on average, and that 20-34% of that value is explained by local network effects. We also find 1) stronger ties are more valuable on Facebook and Instagram, while weaker ties are more valuable on LinkedIn and X; 2) connections known through work are most valuable on LinkedIn and least valuable on Facebook, and people looking for work value LinkedIn significantly more and Facebook significantly less than people not looking for work; 3) men value connections to women on social media significantly more than they value connections to other men, particularly on Instagram, Facebook and X, while women value connections to men and women equally; 4) white consumers value relationships with other white consumers significantly more than they value relationships with non-white consumers on Facebook while, on Instagram, connections to alters eighteen years old or younger are valued significantly more than any other age group-two patterns not seen on any other platforms. Social media platforms individually generate between $53B and $215B in consumer surplus per year in the US alone. These results suggest social media generates significant value, local network effects drive a substantial fraction of that value and that these effects vary across platforms, consumers, and connections.
Open AccessMeasuring Social Media Network Effects
We use representative, incentive-compatible online choice experiments involving 19,923 Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, and X users in the US to provide the first large-scale, empirical measurement of local network effects in the digital economy. Our analysis reveals social media platform value ranges from $78 to $101 per consumer, per month, on average, and that 20-34% of that value is explained by local network effects. We also find 1) stronger ties are more valuable on Facebook and Instagram, while weaker ties are more valuable on LinkedIn and X; 2) connections known through work are most valuable on LinkedIn and least valuable on Facebook, and people looking for work value LinkedIn significantly more and Facebook significantly less than people not looking for work; 3) men value connections to women on social media significantly more than they value connections to other men, particularly on Instagram, Facebook and X, while women value connections to men and women equally; 4) white consumers value relationships with other white consumers significantly more than they value relationships with non-white consumers on Facebook while, on Instagram, connections to alters eighteen years old or younger are valued significantly more than any other age group-two patterns not seen on any other platforms. Social media platforms individually generate between $53B and $215B in consumer surplus per year in the US alone. These results suggest social media generates significant value, local network effects drive a substantial fraction of that value and that these effects vary across platforms, consumers, and connections.
- 1 June 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 70  (6) , 3841-3855
Targeting for Long-Term Outcomes
Decision makers often want to target interventions so as to maximize an outcome that is observed only in the long term. This typically requires delaying decisions until the outcome is observed or relying on simple short-term proxies for the long-term outcome. Here, we build on the statistical surrogacy and policy learning literatures to impute the missing long-term outcomes and then approximate the optimal targeting policy on the imputed outcomes via a doubly robust approach. We first show that conditions for the validity of average treatment effect estimation with imputed outcomes are also sufficient for valid policy evaluation and optimization; furthermore, these conditions can be somewhat relaxed for policy optimization. We apply our approach in two large-scale proactive churn management experiments at The Boston Globe by targeting optimal discounts to its digital subscribers with the aim of maximizing long-term revenue. Using the first experiment, we evaluate this approach empirically by comparing the policy learned using imputed outcomes with a policy learned on the ground-truth, long-term outcomes. The performance of these two policies is statistically indistinguishable, and we rule out large losses from relying on surrogates. Our approach also outperforms a policy learned on short-term proxies for the long-term outcome. In a second field experiment, we implement the optimal targeting policy with additional randomized exploration, which allows us to update the optimal policy for future subscribers. Over three years, our approach had a net-positive revenue impact in the range of $4–$5 million compared with the status quo. This paper was accepted by Eric Anderson, marketing. Funding: This work was supported by Boston Globe Media. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.4881 .
- 1 June 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 70  (6) , 3841-3855
Targeting for Long-Term Outcomes
Decision makers often want to target interventions so as to maximize an outcome that is observed only in the long term. This typically requires delaying decisions until the outcome is observed or relying on simple short-term proxies for the long-term outcome. Here, we build on the statistical surrogacy and policy learning literatures to impute the missing long-term outcomes and then approximate the optimal targeting policy on the imputed outcomes via a doubly robust approach. We first show that conditions for the validity of average treatment effect estimation with imputed outcomes are also sufficient for valid policy evaluation and optimization; furthermore, these conditions can be somewhat relaxed for policy optimization. We apply our approach in two large-scale proactive churn management experiments at The Boston Globe by targeting optimal discounts to its digital subscribers with the aim of maximizing long-term revenue. Using the first experiment, we evaluate this approach empirically by comparing the policy learned using imputed outcomes with a policy learned on the ground-truth, long-term outcomes. The performance of these two policies is statistically indistinguishable, and we rule out large losses from relying on surrogates. Our approach also outperforms a policy learned on short-term proxies for the long-term outcome. In a second field experiment, we implement the optimal targeting policy with additional randomized exploration, which allows us to update the optimal policy for future subscribers. Over three years, our approach had a net-positive revenue impact in the range of $4–$5 million compared with the status quo. This paper was accepted by Eric Anderson, marketing. Funding: This work was supported by Boston Globe Media. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.4881 .
- 5 April 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 71  (1)
Reducing Interference Bias in Online Marketplace Experiments Using Cluster Randomization: Evidence from a Pricing Meta-experiment on Airbnb
Online marketplace designers frequently run randomized experiments to measure the impact of proposed product changes. However, given that marketplaces are inherently connected, total average treatment effect (TATE) estimates obtained through individual-level randomized experiments may be biased because of violations of the stable unit treatment value assumption, a phenomenon we refer to as “interference bias.” Cluster randomization (i.e., the practice of randomizing treatment assignment at the level of “clusters” of similar individuals) is an established experiment design technique for countering interference bias in social networks, but it is unclear ex ante if it will be effective in marketplace settings. In this paper, we use a meta-experiment or “experiment over experiments” conducted on Airbnb to both provide empirical evidence of interference bias in online marketplace settings and assess the viability of cluster randomization as a tool for reducing interference bias in marketplace TATE estimates. Results from our meta-experiment indicate that at least 20% of the TATE estimate produced by an individual-level randomized evaluation of the platform fee increase we study is attributable to interference bias and eliminated through the use of cluster randomization. We also find suggestive, nonstatistically significant evidence that interference bias in seller-side experiments is more severe in demand-constrained geographies and that the efficacy of cluster randomization at reducing interference bias increases with cluster quality. This paper was accepted by Chris Forman, information systems. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2020.01157 .
- 5 April 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 71  (1)
Reducing Interference Bias in Online Marketplace Experiments Using Cluster Randomization: Evidence from a Pricing Meta-experiment on Airbnb
Online marketplace designers frequently run randomized experiments to measure the impact of proposed product changes. However, given that marketplaces are inherently connected, total average treatment effect (TATE) estimates obtained through individual-level randomized experiments may be biased because of violations of the stable unit treatment value assumption, a phenomenon we refer to as “interference bias.” Cluster randomization (i.e., the practice of randomizing treatment assignment at the level of “clusters” of similar individuals) is an established experiment design technique for countering interference bias in social networks, but it is unclear ex ante if it will be effective in marketplace settings. In this paper, we use a meta-experiment or “experiment over experiments” conducted on Airbnb to both provide empirical evidence of interference bias in online marketplace settings and assess the viability of cluster randomization as a tool for reducing interference bias in marketplace TATE estimates. Results from our meta-experiment indicate that at least 20% of the TATE estimate produced by an individual-level randomized evaluation of the platform fee increase we study is attributable to interference bias and eliminated through the use of cluster randomization. We also find suggestive, nonstatistically significant evidence that interference bias in seller-side experiments is more severe in demand-constrained geographies and that the efficacy of cluster randomization at reducing interference bias increases with cluster quality. This paper was accepted by Chris Forman, information systems. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2020.01157 .
- 1 February 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 69  (2) , 1092-1115
What (Exactly) Is Novelty in Networks? Unpacking the Vision Advantages of Brokers, Bridges, and Weak Ties
The strength of weak ties and brokerage theory both rely on the argument that weak bridging ties deliver novel information to create “vision advantages” for actors in brokerage positions. However, our conceptualization of novelty is itself fundamentally underdeveloped. We, therefore, develop a theory of how three distinct types of novelty—diversity, non-redundancy, and uniqueness—combine with network structure to create vision advantages in social networks. We test this theory using panel data on an evolving corporate email network. Three main results emerge from our analysis. First, we confirm the diversity-bandwidth tradeoff (DBT) at the heart of the vision advantage. As brokers’ networks become more diverse, their channel bandwidth contracts, creating countervailing effects on access to novel information. Second, we uncover a mechanism driving the DBT, which helps explain differences in vision advantages across strong and weak ties. Strong, cohesive ties deliver greater information diversity and non-redundancy, whereas weak bridging ties contribute the most unique information (the information that is most different from what other contacts deliver). Third, we find network diversity (in contrast to network constraint) to be positively associated with longitudinal entropy, a measure of the accumulation of novel information over time. This suggests that weak bridging ties, which provide the most unique information through low bandwidth, structurally diverse channels, contribute the most to one’s aggregation of novel information over time. Collectively, these results take a step toward resolving a long-standing debate in network theory about whether strong, cohesive networks or weak bridging networks contribute more to vision advantages. This work firmly establishes that it depends.This paper was accepted by Kartik Hosanagar, information systems.Supplemental Material: The code and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.4377 .
- 1 February 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 69  (2) , 1092-1115
What (Exactly) Is Novelty in Networks? Unpacking the Vision Advantages of Brokers, Bridges, and Weak Ties
The strength of weak ties and brokerage theory both rely on the argument that weak bridging ties deliver novel information to create “vision advantages” for actors in brokerage positions. However, our conceptualization of novelty is itself fundamentally underdeveloped. We, therefore, develop a theory of how three distinct types of novelty—diversity, non-redundancy, and uniqueness—combine with network structure to create vision advantages in social networks. We test this theory using panel data on an evolving corporate email network. Three main results emerge from our analysis. First, we confirm the diversity-bandwidth tradeoff (DBT) at the heart of the vision advantage. As brokers’ networks become more diverse, their channel bandwidth contracts, creating countervailing effects on access to novel information. Second, we uncover a mechanism driving the DBT, which helps explain differences in vision advantages across strong and weak ties. Strong, cohesive ties deliver greater information diversity and non-redundancy, whereas weak bridging ties contribute the most unique information (the information that is most different from what other contacts deliver). Third, we find network diversity (in contrast to network constraint) to be positively associated with longitudinal entropy, a measure of the accumulation of novel information over time. This suggests that weak bridging ties, which provide the most unique information through low bandwidth, structurally diverse channels, contribute the most to one’s aggregation of novel information over time. Collectively, these results take a step toward resolving a long-standing debate in network theory about whether strong, cohesive networks or weak bridging networks contribute more to vision advantages. This work firmly establishes that it depends.This paper was accepted by Kartik Hosanagar, information systems.Supplemental Material: The code and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.4377 .