Timothy J. Maguire
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Timothy J. Maguire has a total of 59 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Craig A. Stow
Great Lakes Environmental Research Laboratory National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Ann Arbor MI USA
7 shared publications Casey Godwin
Cooperative Institute for Great Lakes Research, School for Environment and Sustainability, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, United States
5 shared publications- Scott O. C. Mundle
Great Lakes Institute for Environmental Research, University of Windsor, Windsor, ON, Canada
5 shared publications Robinson W. Fulweiler
Biology Department, Boston University, 5 Cummington Mall, Boston, MA 02215, United States of America; Earth and Environment Department, Boston University, 685 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston, MA 02215, United States of America
4 shared publications- Robinson W. Fulweiler
Boston University Boston MA USA
4 shared publications - Nicholas E. Ray
School of Marine Science and Policy University of Delaware Lewes Delaware USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 9 October 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Harmful Algae
- Vol. 139, 102731
Defining algal bloom phenology in Lake Erie
- 9 October 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Harmful Algae
- Vol. 139, 102731
Defining algal bloom phenology in Lake Erie
- 13 September 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering
- Vol. 218
Monitoring CO2 injection and retention in steam-assisted gravity drainage (SAGD) operations
- 13 September 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering
- Vol. 218
Monitoring CO2 injection and retention in steam-assisted gravity drainage (SAGD) operations
- Open Access
- 25 April 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 26 (8) , 1993-2017
Spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model of total phosphorus in western Lake Erie
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate; however, it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change in in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node, the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that, in the absence of the Maumee River load, lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg L−1 (±1.75, 95 % CI, credible interval) and that for each 100 t of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg L−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modeling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- 25 April 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 26 (8) , 1993-2017
Open AccessSpatially referenced Bayesian state-space model of total phosphorus in western Lake Erie
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate; however, it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change in in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node, the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that, in the absence of the Maumee River load, lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg L−1 (±1.75, 95 % CI, credible interval) and that for each 100 t of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg L−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modeling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- Open Access
- 3 December 2021
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography: Methods
- Vol. 20 (1) , 26-33
Ultraviolet‐visual spectroscopy estimation of nitrate concentrations in surface waters via machine learning
High‐frequency acquisition of nutrient concentrations in rivers is needed to generate nutrient loading estimates commensurate with flow and discharge data. Although the combination of field sampling and laboratory analysis is the standard approach to riverine water quality analysis, this strategy is expensive and can miss important storm‐related events. Ultraviolet‐visual (UV–Vis) spectroscopy is widely used in drinking water and wastewater systems for high‐frequency concentration estimates. However, surface waters present a unique challenge as co‐occurring constituents in environmental samples cause spectral interference at the wavelengths used to measure concentrations of dissolved nutrients. Partial least squares regression (PLSR), Lasso regression (Lasso), and stepwise multivariate linear regression (Stepwise) models can be effective predictors of nitrate concentrations using UV–Vis absorbance and are used in many available in‐situ nitrate sensors; however, the proliferation of user‐friendly open‐source machine learning (ML) algorithms offers an opportunity to use sophisticated big‐data techniques to predict nutrient concentrations in surface waters. We collected samples from four rivers across southern Ontario with a variety of nitrate concentrations, flow regimes, and interfering co‐contaminants. We demonstrated that ML applications of random forest and gradient boosting models significantly outperformed PLSR, Lasso, and Stepwise methodologies to estimate nitrate concentrations in complex environmental samples via UV–Vis absorbance. Importantly, ML applications outcompete current models at low concentrations. This new predictive methodology provides regulators and stakeholders an opportunity to establish low cost, continuous monitoring environmental programs using UV–Vis approaches.
- 3 December 2021
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography: Methods
- Vol. 20 (1) , 26-33
Open AccessUltraviolet‐visual spectroscopy estimation of nitrate concentrations in surface waters via machine learning
High‐frequency acquisition of nutrient concentrations in rivers is needed to generate nutrient loading estimates commensurate with flow and discharge data. Although the combination of field sampling and laboratory analysis is the standard approach to riverine water quality analysis, this strategy is expensive and can miss important storm‐related events. Ultraviolet‐visual (UV–Vis) spectroscopy is widely used in drinking water and wastewater systems for high‐frequency concentration estimates. However, surface waters present a unique challenge as co‐occurring constituents in environmental samples cause spectral interference at the wavelengths used to measure concentrations of dissolved nutrients. Partial least squares regression (PLSR), Lasso regression (Lasso), and stepwise multivariate linear regression (Stepwise) models can be effective predictors of nitrate concentrations using UV–Vis absorbance and are used in many available in‐situ nitrate sensors; however, the proliferation of user‐friendly open‐source machine learning (ML) algorithms offers an opportunity to use sophisticated big‐data techniques to predict nutrient concentrations in surface waters. We collected samples from four rivers across southern Ontario with a variety of nitrate concentrations, flow regimes, and interfering co‐contaminants. We demonstrated that ML applications of random forest and gradient boosting models significantly outperformed PLSR, Lasso, and Stepwise methodologies to estimate nitrate concentrations in complex environmental samples via UV–Vis absorbance. Importantly, ML applications outcompete current models at low concentrations. This new predictive methodology provides regulators and stakeholders an opportunity to establish low cost, continuous monitoring environmental programs using UV–Vis approaches.
- Open Access
- 9 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Reply on EC1
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- 9 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Open AccessReply on EC1
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- Open Access
- 2 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Reply on RC1
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- 2 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Open AccessReply on RC1
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- Open Access
- 2 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Reply on RC2
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- 2 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Open AccessReply on RC2
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- Open Access
- 26 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography: Methods
- Vol. 19 (10) , 714-731
A review of how we assess denitrification in oyster habitats and proposed guidelines for future studies
Excess nitrogen (N) loading and resulting eutrophication plague coastal ecosystems globally. Much work is being done to remove N before it enters coastal receiving waters, yet these efforts are not enough. Novel techniques to remove N from within the coastal ecosystem are now being explored. One of these techniques involves using oysters and their habitats to remove N via denitrification. There is substantial interest in incorporating oyster‐mediated enhancement of benthic denitrification into N management plans and trading schemes. Measuring denitrification, however, is expensive and time consuming. For large‐scale adoption of oyster‐mediated denitrification into nutrient management plans, we need an accurate model that can be applied across ecosystems. Despite significant effort to measure and report rates of denitrification in oyster habitats, we are unable to create such a model, due to methodological differences between studies, incomplete data reporting, and inconsistent measurements of environmental variables that may be used to predict denitrification. To make a model that can predict denitrification in oyster habitats a reality, a common sampling and reporting scheme is needed across studies. Here, we provide relevant background on how oysters may stimulate denitrification, and the importance of oyster‐mediated denitrification in remediating excess N loading to coastal systems. We then summarize methods commonly used to measure denitrification in oyster habitats, discuss the importance of various environmental variables that may be useful for predicting denitrification, and present a set of guidelines for measuring denitrification in oyster habitats, allowing development of models to support incorporation of oyster‐mediated denitrification into future policy decisions.
- 26 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography: Methods
- Vol. 19 (10) , 714-731
Open AccessA review of how we assess denitrification in oyster habitats and proposed guidelines for future studies
Excess nitrogen (N) loading and resulting eutrophication plague coastal ecosystems globally. Much work is being done to remove N before it enters coastal receiving waters, yet these efforts are not enough. Novel techniques to remove N from within the coastal ecosystem are now being explored. One of these techniques involves using oysters and their habitats to remove N via denitrification. There is substantial interest in incorporating oyster‐mediated enhancement of benthic denitrification into N management plans and trading schemes. Measuring denitrification, however, is expensive and time consuming. For large‐scale adoption of oyster‐mediated denitrification into nutrient management plans, we need an accurate model that can be applied across ecosystems. Despite significant effort to measure and report rates of denitrification in oyster habitats, we are unable to create such a model, due to methodological differences between studies, incomplete data reporting, and inconsistent measurements of environmental variables that may be used to predict denitrification. To make a model that can predict denitrification in oyster habitats a reality, a common sampling and reporting scheme is needed across studies. Here, we provide relevant background on how oysters may stimulate denitrification, and the importance of oyster‐mediated denitrification in remediating excess N loading to coastal systems. We then summarize methods commonly used to measure denitrification in oyster habitats, discuss the importance of various environmental variables that may be useful for predicting denitrification, and present a set of guidelines for measuring denitrification in oyster habitats, allowing development of models to support incorporation of oyster‐mediated denitrification into future policy decisions.
- Open Access
- 15 July 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Comment on hess-2021-296
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- 15 July 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-42
Open AccessComment on hess-2021-296
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- Open Access
- 2 June 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2021, 1-42
Spatially Referenced Bayesian State-Space Model of Total Phosphorus in western Lake Erie
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.
- 2 June 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2021, 1-42
Open AccessSpatially Referenced Bayesian State-Space Model of Total Phosphorus in western Lake Erie
Collecting water quality data across large lakes is often done under regulatory mandate, however it is difficult to connect nutrient concentration observations to sources of those nutrients and to quantify this relationship. This difficulty arises from the spatial and temporal separation between observations, the impact of hydrodynamic forces, and the cost involved in discrete samples collected aboard vessels. These challenges are typified in Lake Erie, where binational agreements regulate riverine loads of total phosphorus (TP) to address the impacts from annual harmful algal blooms (HABs). While it is known that the Maumee River supplies 50 % of the nutrient load to Lake Erie, the details of how the Maumee River TP load changes Lake Erie TP concentration have not been demonstrated. We developed a hierarchical spatially referenced Bayesian state-space model with an adjacency matrix defined by surface currents. This was applied to a 2 km-by-2 km grid of nodes, to which observed lake and river TP concentrations were joined. The model generated posterior samples describing the unobserved nodes and observed nodes on unobserved days. We quantified the impact plume of the Maumee River by experimentally changing concentration data and tracking the change of in-lake predictions. Our impact plume represents the spatial and temporal variation of how river concentrations correlate with lake concentrations. We used the impact plume to scale the Maumee River spring TP load to an effective Maumee River TP spring load for each node in the lake. By assigning an effective load to each node the relationship between load and concentration is consistent throughout our sampling locations. A linear model of annual lake node mean TP concentration and effective Maumee River load estimated that in the absence of the Maumee River load lake concentrations at the sampled nodes would be 23.1 µg l−1 (±1.75, 95 % credible interval, CI) and that for each 100 tons of spring TP effective load delivered to Lake Erie, mean TP concentrations increase by 11 µg l−1 (±1, 95 % CI). Our proposed modelling technique allowed us to establish these quantitative connections between Maumee TP load and Lake Erie TP concentrations which otherwise would be masked by the movement of water through space and time.