Grischa Y. Chen

Understanding the cause and consequences of bacterial strain variation remains a challenge in the study of symbioses. While the diverse reactions of the host immune system to strain variants have been well studied in pathogenesis, much less is known about how strain variation influences beneficial associations. From the complex vertebrate gut microbiome to the more tractable invertebrate models of symbiosis, the host’s cellular and molecular responses to this diversity remain largely a mystery. Here, we explore strain diversity in Vibrio fischeri , the bioluminescent bacterial symbiont of the Hawaiian bobtail squid, Euprymna scolopes . Phylogenetic analyses of the genomes of 62 V . fischeri strains, including 50 light organ-associated and 12 planktonic isolates, revealed several genes that were absent in planktonic strains, but uniformly present in symbiotic ones. To better understand the consequences of this diversity to the host, we selected five light-organ associated strains: three from E. scolopes but having different combinations of colonization factors, one from a congeneric squid host, and one from a marine fish. We colonized juvenile E. scolopes with these strains and, using RNAseq, found that (i) the most similar host transcriptomic responses occurred among the native E. scolopes strains, (ii) intermediate was the strain from the related squid, and (iii) least similar was the fish strain. Importantly, native strains downregulated immune-related genes more than non-native ones. Finally, host development was atypical or delayed when colonized by non-native strains. These experiments point the way to more targeted studies of the mechanisms underlying host responses to symbiont strain diversity. IMPORTANCE: Variation among strains of a bacterial species is a powerful factor underlying the intensity of host responses during pathogenic infections. Less is known about the cellular and molecular responses of host tissues to differences between the strains present in an animal's normal microbiome. We use a natural, species-specific, symbiosis to explore the influence of strain-level differences on host gene expression and morphogenesis. Analysis of symbiotic strains from squids and fishes, as well as free-living strains, shows that the carriage of colonization determinants, while critical to competitive success among strains of a species, has a minimal effect on the transcriptional response of the host. We provide evidence that a more important driver of normal gene expression during the development of symbiosis is the history of a strain’s co-diversification with its host species. Such studies, using simple invertebrate models, allow the recognition of otherwise obscured interactions underlying the more complex microbiomes of vertebrates.

Animals often acquire their microbial symbionts from the environment, but the mechanisms underlying how specificity of the association is achieved are poorly understood. We demonstrate that the conserved proton pump, V-type ATPase (VHA), plays a key role in the establishment of the model light-organ symbiosis between the squid Euprymna scolopes and its bacterial partner, Vibrio fischeri. Recruitment of V. fischeri from the surrounding seawater is mediated by juvenile-specific ciliated fields on the organ’s surface. These epithelia produce acidic mucus containing antimicrobials with low-pH optima, creating a chemical environment fostering specific recruitment of V. fischeri. We provide evidence that this critical acidic landscape is created by activity of VHA. VHA inhibition abolished epithelial-cell acidity, resulting in increased mucus pH and inefficient symbiont colonization. Thus, VHA provides a mechanistic link between host modulation of microenvironmental acidity, immune function, and selection of microbial symbionts, a strategy for specificity that may govern other symbioses.

Animals evolved two defense strategies to survive infections. Antagonistic strategies include immune resistance mechanisms that operate to kill invading pathogens. Cooperative or physiological defenses mediate host adaptation to the infected state, limiting physiological damage and disease, without killing the pathogen, and have been shown to cause asymptomatic carriage and transmission of lethal pathogens. Here, we demonstrate that physiological defenses cooperate with the adaptive immune response to generate long-term asymptomatic carriage of the lethal enteric murine pathogen, Citrobacter rodentium . Asymptomatic carriage of genetically virulent C. rodentium provided immune resistance against subsequent infections. Immune protection was dependent on systemic antibody responses and pathogen virulence behavior rather than the recognition of specific virulent antigens. Last, we demonstrate that an avirulent strain of C. rodentium in the field has background mutations in genes that are important for LPS structure. Our work reveals insight into how asymptomatic infections can arise mechanistically with immune resistance, mediating exclusion of phenotypically virulent enteric pathogen to promote asymptomatic carriage.

Listeria monocytogenes, the causative agent of listeriosis, is an intracellular pathogen that is exquisitely evolved to survive and replicate in the cytosol of eukaryotic cells. Eukaryotic cells typically restrict bacteria from colonising the cytosol, likely through a combination of cell autonomous defences, nutritional immunity, and innate immune responses including induction of programmed cell death. This suggests that L. monocytogenes and other professional cytosolic pathogens possess unique metabolic adaptations, not only to support replication but also to facilitate resistance to host‐derived stresses/defences and avoidance of innate immune activation. In this review, we outline our current understanding of L. monocytogenes metabolism in the host cytosol and highlight major metabolic processes which promote intracellular replication and survival.

Through unknown mechanisms, the host cytosol restricts bacterial colonization; therefore, only professional cytosolic pathogens are adapted to colonize this host environment. Listeria monocytogenes is a Gram-positive intracellular pathogen that is highly adapted to colonize the cytosol of both phagocytic and nonphagocytic cells. To identify L. monocytogenes determinants of cytosolic survival, we designed and executed a novel screen to isolate L. monocytogenes mutants with cytosolic survival defects. Multiple mutants identified in the screen were defective for synthesis of menaquinone (MK), an essential molecule in the electron transport chain. Analysis of an extensive set of MK biosynthesis and respiratory chain mutants revealed that cellular respiration was not required for cytosolic survival of L. monocytogenes but that, instead, synthesis of 1,4-dihydroxy-2-naphthoate (DHNA), an MK biosynthesis intermediate, was essential. Recent discoveries showed that modulation of the central metabolism of both host and pathogen can influence the outcome of host-pathogen interactions. Our results identify a potentially novel function of the MK biosynthetic intermediate DHNA and specifically highlight how L. monocytogenes metabolic adaptations promote cytosolic survival and evasion of host immunity. IMPORTANCE Cytosolic bacterial pathogens, such as Listeria monocytogenes and Francisella tularensis , are exquisitely evolved to colonize the host cytosol in a variety of cell types. Establishing an intracellular niche shields these pathogens from effectors of humoral immunity, grants access to host nutrients, and is essential for pathogenesis. Through yet-to-be-defined mechanisms, the host cytosol restricts replication of non-cytosol-adapted bacteria, likely through a combination of cell autonomous defenses (CADs) and nutritional immunity. Utilizing a novel genetic screen, we identified determinants of L. monocytogenes cytosolic survival and virulence and identified a role for the synthesis of the menaquinone precursor 1,4-dihydroxy-2-naphthoate (DHNA) in cytosolic survival. Together, these data begin to elucidate adaptations that allow cytosolic pathogens to survive in their intracellular niches.

Obstacles to bacterial survival and replication in the cytosol of host cells, and the mechanisms used by bacterial pathogens to adapt to this niche are not well understood. Listeria monocytogenes is a well-studied Gram-positive foodborne pathogen that has evolved to invade and replicate within the host cell cytosol; yet the mechanisms by which it senses and responds to stress to survive in the cytosol are largely unknown. To assess the role of the L. monocytogenes penicillin-binding-protein and serine/threonine associated (PASTA) kinase PrkA in stress responses, cytosolic survival and virulence, we constructed a ΔprkA deletion mutant. PrkA was required for resistance to cell wall stress, growth on cytosolic carbon sources, intracellular replication, cytosolic survival, inflammasome avoidance and ultimately virulence in a murine model of Listeriosis. In Bacillus subtilis and Mycobacterium tuberculosis, homologues of PrkA phosphorylate a highly conserved protein of unknown function, YvcK. We found that, similar to PrkA, YvcK is also required for cell wall stress responses, metabolism of glycerol, cytosolic survival, inflammasome avoidance and virulence. We further demonstrate that similar to other organisms, YvcK is directly phosphorylated by PrkA, although the specific site(s) of phosphorylation are not highly conserved. Finally, analysis of phosphoablative and phosphomimetic mutants of YvcK in vitro and in vivo demonstrate that while phosphorylation of YvcK is irrelevant to metabolism and cell wall stress responses, surprisingly, a phosphomimetic, nonreversible negative charge of YvcK is detrimental to cytosolic survival and virulence in vivo. Taken together our data identify two novel virulence factors essential for cytosolic survival and virulence of L. monocytogenes. Furthermore, our data demonstrate that regulation of YvcK phosphorylation is tightly controlled and is critical for virulence. Finally, our data suggest that yet to be identified substrates of PrkA are essential for cytosolic survival and virulence of L. monocytogenes and illustrate the importance of studying protein phosphorylation in the context of infection. Infection with intracellular pathogens causes a majority of the global infectious disease associated mortality. A number of intracellular pathogens must directly access the host cytosol in order to cause disease; however, non-cytosol adapted bacteria do not survive or replicate upon access to the cytosol. The mechanisms cytosolic pathogens use to adapt to this niche are largely unknown. The model cytosolic bacterial pathogen Listeria monocytogenes contains a single penicillin-binding-protein and serine/threonine associated (PASTA) kinase, PrkA. In other bacteria, PASTA kinases bind cell wall fragments and phosphorylate downstream effectors involved in cell wall synthesis, central metabolism, virulence, cell division, and biofilm formation. We demonstrate that in L. monocytogenes, PrkA is required for cell wall homeostasis, growth under nutrient limiting conditions, survival and replication in host cells, and virulence in vivo. Furthermore, we identify a highly conserved protein of unknown function, YvcK, as a PrkA substrate. We demonstrate that L. monocytogenes YvcK is similarly required for cell wall stress responses, growth on glycerol, cytosolic survival and virulence in vivo. Surprisingly, a phosphomimetic, nonreversible negative charge at the phosphorylation sites on YvcK inactivates functions of the protein related to intracellular survival and virulence, suggesting that the identification of PASTA kinase substrates phosphorylated during infection will be critical to our understanding of this central regulator metabolism, cell wall homeostasis and ultimately virulence.

Previous studies have demonstrated that Pseudomonas putida strains are not only capable of growth on a wide range of organic substrates, but also chemotactic towards many of these compounds. However, in most cases the specific chemoreceptors that are involved have not been identified. The complete genome sequences of P. putida strains F1 and KT2440 revealed that each strain is predicted to encode 27 methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins (MCPs) or MCP-like proteins, 25 of which are shared by both strains. It was expected that orthologous MCPs in closely related strains of the same species would be functionally equivalent. However, deletion of the gene encoding the P. putida F1 orthologue (locus tag Pput_4520, designated mcfS) of McpS, a known receptor for organic acids in P. putida KT2440, did not result in an obvious chemotaxis phenotype. Therefore, we constructed individual markerless MCP gene deletion mutants in P. putida F1 and screened for defective sensory responses to succinate, malate, fumarate and citrate. This screen resulted in the identification of a receptor, McfQ (locus tag Pput_4894), which responds to citrate and fumarate. An additional receptor, McfR (locus tag Pput_0339), which detects succinate, malate and fumarate, was found by individually expressing each of the 18 genes encoding canonical MCPs from strain F1 in a KT2440 mcpS-deletion mutant. Expression of mcfS in the same mcpS deletion mutant demonstrated that, like McfR, McfS responds to succinate, malate, citrate and fumarate. Therefore, at least three receptors, McfR, McfS, and McfQ, work in concert to detect organic acids in P. putida F1.

It has become clear in current scientific pedagogy that the emersion of students in the scientific process in terms of designing, implementing, and analyzing experiments is imperative for their education; as such, it has been our goal to model this active learning process in the classroom and laboratory in the context of a genuine scientific question. Toward this objective, the National Science Foundation funded a collaborative research grant between a primarily undergraduate institution and a research-intensive institution to study the chemotactic responses of the bacterium Pseudomonas putida F1. As part of the project, a new Bioinformatics course was developed in which undergraduates annotate relevant regions of the P. putida F1 genome using Integrated Microbial Genomes Annotation Collaboration Toolkit, a bioinformatics interface specifically developed for undergraduate programs by the Department of Energy Joint Genome Institute. Based on annotations of putative chemotaxis genes in P. putida F1 and comparative genomics studies, undergraduate students from both institutions developed functional genomics research projects that evolved from the annotations. The purpose of this study is to describe the nature of the NSF grant, the development of the Bioinformatics lecture and wet laboratory course, and how undergraduate student involvement in the project that was initiated in the classroom has served as a springboard for independent undergraduate research projects. © 2012 by The International Union of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, 41(1):16–23, 2013