Christoph Wenzel
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Christoph Wenzel has a total of 31 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Markus Kloker
University of Stuttgart
9 shared publications - Tobias Gibis
University of Stuttgart
9 shared publications Ulrich Rist
Institute of Aerodynamics and Gas Dynamics, University of Stuttgart, Stuttgart, Germany
6 shared publications- Ulrich Rist
University of Stuttgart
5 shared publications - Jason Appelbaum
Institute of Aerodynamics and Gas Dynamics, University of Stuttgart, 70563 Stuttgart, Germany
3 shared publications - Tristan M. Römer
University of Stuttgart
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1036
On the influence of free stream turbulence on roughness-induced boundary-layer transition
This study experimentally examines how free stream turbulence (FST) alters roughness-induced transition by exposing cylindrical roughness elements of diameter-to-height ratios $\eta =1,2,3$ to three FST levels ( $ \textit{Tu}\approx 0.05\,\%$ , $1.15\,\%$ , $1.55\,\%$ ). Although the roughness Reynolds number $ \textit{Re}_{\textit{kk}}$ is varied solely through the free stream velocity, a detailed characterisation of the incoming FST and resulting Klebanoff modes shows that their variation remains moderate, enabling a controlled assessment of FST effects. The FST consistently promotes earlier transition for all $\eta$ at subcritical global-instability Reynolds numbers, but its influence on the underlying instability mechanisms depends strongly on $\eta$ . For the ‘thick’ cylinders ( $\eta =2,3$ ), the global instability remains remarkably robust: the dominant varicose mode and its frequency scaling show virtually no sensitivity to FST. In contrast, the ‘thin’ cylinder ( $\eta =1$ ) exhibits an extreme susceptibility: already moderate FST suppresses the sinuous mode predicted by global stability theory at supercritical Reynolds numbers. These findings provide a clear, experimentally grounded explanation for why global stability predictions often fail to materialise the structures in real, turbulence-contaminated environments and establish FST as a decisive factor governing whether, when and how roughness-induced instabilities manifest.- 29 May 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1036
Open AccessOn the influence of free stream turbulence on roughness-induced boundary-layer transition
This study experimentally examines how free stream turbulence (FST) alters roughness-induced transition by exposing cylindrical roughness elements of diameter-to-height ratios $\eta =1,2,3$ to three FST levels ( $ \textit{Tu}\approx 0.05\,\%$ , $1.15\,\%$ , $1.55\,\%$ ). Although the roughness Reynolds number $ \textit{Re}_{\textit{kk}}$ is varied solely through the free stream velocity, a detailed characterisation of the incoming FST and resulting Klebanoff modes shows that their variation remains moderate, enabling a controlled assessment of FST effects. The FST consistently promotes earlier transition for all $\eta$ at subcritical global-instability Reynolds numbers, but its influence on the underlying instability mechanisms depends strongly on $\eta$ . For the ‘thick’ cylinders ( $\eta =2,3$ ), the global instability remains remarkably robust: the dominant varicose mode and its frequency scaling show virtually no sensitivity to FST. In contrast, the ‘thin’ cylinder ( $\eta =1$ ) exhibits an extreme susceptibility: already moderate FST suppresses the sinuous mode predicted by global stability theory at supercritical Reynolds numbers. These findings provide a clear, experimentally grounded explanation for why global stability predictions often fail to materialise the structures in real, turbulence-contaminated environments and establish FST as a decisive factor governing whether, when and how roughness-induced instabilities manifest. - Open Access
- 21 July 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1015, A37
The onset of outer-layer self-similarity in turbulent boundary layers
In this study, changes in the mean flow of a compressible turbulent boundary layer spatially evolving from low to ‘moderate’ Reynolds numbers are examined. All discussions are based on literature data and a direct numerical simulation (DNS) of a supersonic boundary layer specifically designed to be effectively free of spurious inflow effects in the range $4000 \lessapprox Re_\theta \lessapprox 5000$ , which enables discussion of sensitive properties such as the turbulent wake. Most noticeably, the DNS data show the formation of a distinct ‘bend’ in the friction coefficient distribution reflected in sudden deviation from established low-Reynolds-number correlations. As will be shown, the bend is related to the surprisingly abrupt saturation of the turbulent wake, marking the change from low- to moderate-Reynolds-number behaviour; in previous studies, this trend was potentially obscured by data scatter in experiments and/or insufficient domain length in DNS. Moreover, the influence of the wake saturation on the formation of the early logarithmic overlap layer is assessed, which, if fully developed, leads to the onset of high-Reynolds-number behaviour further downstream.- 21 July 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1015, A37
Open AccessThe onset of outer-layer self-similarity in turbulent boundary layers
In this study, changes in the mean flow of a compressible turbulent boundary layer spatially evolving from low to ‘moderate’ Reynolds numbers are examined. All discussions are based on literature data and a direct numerical simulation (DNS) of a supersonic boundary layer specifically designed to be effectively free of spurious inflow effects in the range $4000 \lessapprox Re_\theta \lessapprox 5000$ , which enables discussion of sensitive properties such as the turbulent wake. Most noticeably, the DNS data show the formation of a distinct ‘bend’ in the friction coefficient distribution reflected in sudden deviation from established low-Reynolds-number correlations. As will be shown, the bend is related to the surprisingly abrupt saturation of the turbulent wake, marking the change from low- to moderate-Reynolds-number behaviour; in previous studies, this trend was potentially obscured by data scatter in experiments and/or insufficient domain length in DNS. Moreover, the influence of the wake saturation on the formation of the early logarithmic overlap layer is assessed, which, if fully developed, leads to the onset of high-Reynolds-number behaviour further downstream. - Open Access
- 9 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics
- Vol. 39 (1) , 1-18
A systematic DNS approach to isolate wall-curvature effects in spatially developing boundary layers
A methodology to numerically assess wall-curvature effects in boundary layers is introduced. Wall curvature, which directly induces streamline curvature, is associated with several changes in boundary-layer flow. By necessity, a local radial pressure gradient emerges to balance mean flow turning. Moreover, a streamwise (wall-tangential) pressure gradient can appear for configurations with non-constant wall curvature or a particular freestream condition; zero pressure gradient is a special case. In laminar concave flow, the Görtler instability and the associated Taylor-Görtler vortices destabilize the flow and promote laminar-turbulent transition, whereas in the fully turbulent regime, unsteady coherent structures formed by the centrifugal instability mechanism dramatically redistribute turbulent shear stress. One difficulty of assessing centrifugal effects on boundary layers is that they often appear simultaneously with other phenomena, such as a streamwise pressure gradient, making their individual evaluation often ambiguous. For numerical studies of transitional and turbulent boundary layers, it is therefore beneficial to understand the interactive nature of such coupled effects for generic configurations. A methodology to do so is presented, and is verified using the case of a subsonic, compressible turbulent boundary layer. Four direct numerical simulations have been computed, forming a $$2{\times }2$$ matrix of turbulent boundary-layer states; namely with and without concave wall curvature, each having a zero and a non-zero streamwise-pressure-gradient realization. The setup and accompanying procedures to determine appropriate boundary conditions are discussed, and the methodology is evaluated through analysis of the mean flow fields. Differences in mean flow properties such as wall shear stress and boundary-layer thickness due to either streamwise pressure gradient or wall curvature are shown to be remarkably independent of one another.- 9 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics
- Vol. 39 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessA systematic DNS approach to isolate wall-curvature effects in spatially developing boundary layers
A methodology to numerically assess wall-curvature effects in boundary layers is introduced. Wall curvature, which directly induces streamline curvature, is associated with several changes in boundary-layer flow. By necessity, a local radial pressure gradient emerges to balance mean flow turning. Moreover, a streamwise (wall-tangential) pressure gradient can appear for configurations with non-constant wall curvature or a particular freestream condition; zero pressure gradient is a special case. In laminar concave flow, the Görtler instability and the associated Taylor-Görtler vortices destabilize the flow and promote laminar-turbulent transition, whereas in the fully turbulent regime, unsteady coherent structures formed by the centrifugal instability mechanism dramatically redistribute turbulent shear stress. One difficulty of assessing centrifugal effects on boundary layers is that they often appear simultaneously with other phenomena, such as a streamwise pressure gradient, making their individual evaluation often ambiguous. For numerical studies of transitional and turbulent boundary layers, it is therefore beneficial to understand the interactive nature of such coupled effects for generic configurations. A methodology to do so is presented, and is verified using the case of a subsonic, compressible turbulent boundary layer. Four direct numerical simulations have been computed, forming a $$2{\times }2$$ matrix of turbulent boundary-layer states; namely with and without concave wall curvature, each having a zero and a non-zero streamwise-pressure-gradient realization. The setup and accompanying procedures to determine appropriate boundary conditions are discussed, and the methodology is evaluated through analysis of the mean flow fields. Differences in mean flow properties such as wall shear stress and boundary-layer thickness due to either streamwise pressure gradient or wall curvature are shown to be remarkably independent of one another. - Open Access
- 3 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Experiments in Fluids
- Vol. 65 (12) , 1-20
Experimental investigation on boundary-layer streaks induced by grid-generated free-stream turbulence in a water channel
In this study, the influence of various turbulence-grid configurations is analysed on both the induced free-stream turbulence (FST) and the resulting Klebanoff modes/streaks developing in a laminar flat-plate boundary layer downstream in a laminar water channel. All results are based on hot-film and particle image velocimetry measurements as well as visualizations. The grid design and installation has been done according to common grid installation recommendations to ensure homogeneous FST causing meandering Klebanoff modes inside the boundary layer. But it was found that (i) the Klebanoff modes do not meander for all grid configurations, (ii) not all configurations cause Klebanoff modes with the expected temporal and spatial behaviour, and (iii) for some configurations, the spanwise streak spacing is strictly locked to the grid spacing (mesh width). As these observations are unreported in the literature, this study is aimed at a thorough description of the influence of key grid parameters on the FST and the resulting streaks within the boundary layer. The investigation includes the grid parameters typically reported, such as the grid-bar diameters, the associated Reynolds numbers, or the streamwise placement of the grid, but now also the grid-orientation order (horizontal/vertical or vertical/horizontal order of grid bars of the dual-plane grid), the wall-normal position of the horizontal bars relative to the leading edge of the flat plate, and the existence of palpable imperfections in the manufactured grids. The Reynolds-number range covered lies well in the lower band of wind-tunnel experiments. Thus, this study suggests that the reliability and reproducibility of future experimental studies on FST would be greatly improved if they demonstrated homogeneity in the free-stream in both spanwise and wall-normal directions, documented the ongoing meandering and wavelengths of the generated Klebanoff modes and thus (implicitly) documented the spanwise independence of the results in the temporal mean. The latter is a prerequisite for the reliable investigation of FST/isolated-roughness interactions. Graphical abstract
- 3 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Experiments in Fluids
- Vol. 65 (12) , 1-20
Open AccessExperimental investigation on boundary-layer streaks induced by grid-generated free-stream turbulence in a water channel
In this study, the influence of various turbulence-grid configurations is analysed on both the induced free-stream turbulence (FST) and the resulting Klebanoff modes/streaks developing in a laminar flat-plate boundary layer downstream in a laminar water channel. All results are based on hot-film and particle image velocimetry measurements as well as visualizations. The grid design and installation has been done according to common grid installation recommendations to ensure homogeneous FST causing meandering Klebanoff modes inside the boundary layer. But it was found that (i) the Klebanoff modes do not meander for all grid configurations, (ii) not all configurations cause Klebanoff modes with the expected temporal and spatial behaviour, and (iii) for some configurations, the spanwise streak spacing is strictly locked to the grid spacing (mesh width). As these observations are unreported in the literature, this study is aimed at a thorough description of the influence of key grid parameters on the FST and the resulting streaks within the boundary layer. The investigation includes the grid parameters typically reported, such as the grid-bar diameters, the associated Reynolds numbers, or the streamwise placement of the grid, but now also the grid-orientation order (horizontal/vertical or vertical/horizontal order of grid bars of the dual-plane grid), the wall-normal position of the horizontal bars relative to the leading edge of the flat plate, and the existence of palpable imperfections in the manufactured grids. The Reynolds-number range covered lies well in the lower band of wind-tunnel experiments. Thus, this study suggests that the reliability and reproducibility of future experimental studies on FST would be greatly improved if they demonstrated homogeneity in the free-stream in both spanwise and wall-normal directions, documented the ongoing meandering and wavelengths of the generated Klebanoff modes and thus (implicitly) documented the spanwise independence of the results in the temporal mean. The latter is a prerequisite for the reliable investigation of FST/isolated-roughness interactions. Graphical abstract
- Open Access
- 20 September 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 995, A14
Heat-transfer effects in compressible turbulent boundary layers – a regime diagram
As shown by Wenzel et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 930, 2022, A1), the Eckert number $Ec$ defined using the difference between recovery temperature $\bar{T}_r$ and wall temperature $\bar{T}_w$ can be understood as a meaningful quantity to compare heat-transfer effects inside compressible turbulent boundary layers (for a calorically perfect gas), no matter whether these are caused by different Mach-number or wall-temperature conditions. While the named study deduced this comparative behaviour of $Ec$ from an integral perspective in a strict sense, Cogo et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 974, 2023, A10) performed a systematic parameter study based on the previous findings to look at wall-normal profiles. They have shown that the diabatic parameter $\varTheta$ , being equivalent to $Ec$ , is capable of categorizing heat-transfer effects for cases at different Mach numbers, even to some extent for some of the wall-normal profiles. Building on this progress, the present paper provides a comprehensive classification of both existing and newly computed super- and hypersonic direct numerical simulation data at various wall temperature conditions into heated cases, adiabatic cases or weakly/moderately/strongly/quasi-incompressibly cooled cases. Hereby, the classification is largely based on the wall-normal position of the temperature peak occurring in cooled boundary-layer cases, which is one of the determining factors for the topological characteristics of diabatic boundary-layer profiles. Integrating high-enthalpy data into the analysis allowed us to confirm the reliability of the proposed classification also in more complex scenarios, where the calorically perfect gas assumption no longer applies and additional heat-transfer mechanisms come into play. While the Eckert number is shown to well characterize heat-transfer effects on most important temperature-related quantities for a wide range of Mach numbers and $\bar {T}_w/\bar {T}_r$ conditions, also the local Reynolds number $Re_{\tau }$ is shown to notably affect the strength of heat-transfer effects. Since both $Ec$ and $Re_{\tau }$ can be determined in advance – or estimated to a reasonable extent – a key advantage of the classification scheme is to allow for an effective a priori estimation of the extent to which heat-transfer effects are to be expected for a given compressible turbulent boundary-layer configuration.- 20 September 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 995, A14
Open AccessHeat-transfer effects in compressible turbulent boundary layers – a regime diagram
As shown by Wenzel et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 930, 2022, A1), the Eckert number $Ec$ defined using the difference between recovery temperature $\bar{T}_r$ and wall temperature $\bar{T}_w$ can be understood as a meaningful quantity to compare heat-transfer effects inside compressible turbulent boundary layers (for a calorically perfect gas), no matter whether these are caused by different Mach-number or wall-temperature conditions. While the named study deduced this comparative behaviour of $Ec$ from an integral perspective in a strict sense, Cogo et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 974, 2023, A10) performed a systematic parameter study based on the previous findings to look at wall-normal profiles. They have shown that the diabatic parameter $\varTheta$ , being equivalent to $Ec$ , is capable of categorizing heat-transfer effects for cases at different Mach numbers, even to some extent for some of the wall-normal profiles. Building on this progress, the present paper provides a comprehensive classification of both existing and newly computed super- and hypersonic direct numerical simulation data at various wall temperature conditions into heated cases, adiabatic cases or weakly/moderately/strongly/quasi-incompressibly cooled cases. Hereby, the classification is largely based on the wall-normal position of the temperature peak occurring in cooled boundary-layer cases, which is one of the determining factors for the topological characteristics of diabatic boundary-layer profiles. Integrating high-enthalpy data into the analysis allowed us to confirm the reliability of the proposed classification also in more complex scenarios, where the calorically perfect gas assumption no longer applies and additional heat-transfer mechanisms come into play. While the Eckert number is shown to well characterize heat-transfer effects on most important temperature-related quantities for a wide range of Mach numbers and $\bar {T}_w/\bar {T}_r$ conditions, also the local Reynolds number $Re_{\tau }$ is shown to notably affect the strength of heat-transfer effects. Since both $Ec$ and $Re_{\tau }$ can be determined in advance – or estimated to a reasonable extent – a key advantage of the classification scheme is to allow for an effective a priori estimation of the extent to which heat-transfer effects are to be expected for a given compressible turbulent boundary-layer configuration. - 1 May 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 36 (5)
Comparison of high-order numerical methodologies for the simulation of the supersonic Taylor–Green vortex flow
This work presents a comparison of several high-order numerical methodologies for simulating shock/turbulence interactions based on the supersonic Taylor–Green vortex flow, considering a Reynolds number of 1600 and a Mach number of 1.25. The numerical schemes considered include high-order Finite Difference, Targeted Essentially Non-Oscillatory, Discontinuous Galerkin, and Spectral Difference schemes. The shock capturing methods include high-order filtering, localized artificial diffusivity, non-oscillatory numerical fluxes, and local low-order switching. The ability of the various high-order numerical methodologies to both capture shocks and represent accurately the development of turbulent vortices is assessed.
- 1 May 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 36 (5)
Comparison of high-order numerical methodologies for the simulation of the supersonic Taylor–Green vortex flow
This work presents a comparison of several high-order numerical methodologies for simulating shock/turbulence interactions based on the supersonic Taylor–Green vortex flow, considering a Reynolds number of 1600 and a Mach number of 1.25. The numerical schemes considered include high-order Finite Difference, Targeted Essentially Non-Oscillatory, Discontinuous Galerkin, and Spectral Difference schemes. The shock capturing methods include high-order filtering, localized artificial diffusivity, non-oscillatory numerical fluxes, and local low-order switching. The ability of the various high-order numerical methodologies to both capture shocks and represent accurately the development of turbulent vortices is assessed.
- 1 May 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 36 (5)
Wall-modeled large eddy simulation of a tandem wing configuration in transonic flow
In this study, the interaction between a turbulent wake and the boundary layer of a horizontal tail plane (HTP) in the transonic flow regime is investigated. The setup considered corresponds to a generic tandem wing configuration with an OAT15A airfoil as the main wing and a National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics (NACA) 64A-110 as an HTP. Due to the transonic flow, the suction side of the OAT15A exhibits buffet. The numerical approach consists of a two-stage procedure in which a detached eddy simulation (DES) provides unsteady inflow conditions for a subsequent zonal high-fidelity large eddy simulation (LES) performed for the HTP region only; the turbulent boundary layer is modeled using scale-resolved wall-modeled LES (WMLES). The study mainly pursues two objectives: first, to discuss the influence of wake turbulence on the flow characteristics of the NACA airfoil; and second, to evaluate the capability of WMLES as a low-cost but high-resolution numerical approach in challenging flow conditions. Essentially, the study confirms the expected result that the outer part of the HTP's boundary layer is dominated by the wake of the main wing. Mainly based on a discussion of turbulence spectra, the study further demonstrates the advantage of WMLES over DES, proving that WMLES is able to capture the effects of wake turbulence on boundary layer dynamics, and thus validates the WMLES approach as a cost-effective, high-resolution turbulence modeling approach. On a superordinate level, the study further sketches a possible way on how a flow problem with such a strongly unsteady behavior could be systematically evaluated.
- 1 May 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Physics of Fluids
- Vol. 36 (5)
Wall-modeled large eddy simulation of a tandem wing configuration in transonic flow
In this study, the interaction between a turbulent wake and the boundary layer of a horizontal tail plane (HTP) in the transonic flow regime is investigated. The setup considered corresponds to a generic tandem wing configuration with an OAT15A airfoil as the main wing and a National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics (NACA) 64A-110 as an HTP. Due to the transonic flow, the suction side of the OAT15A exhibits buffet. The numerical approach consists of a two-stage procedure in which a detached eddy simulation (DES) provides unsteady inflow conditions for a subsequent zonal high-fidelity large eddy simulation (LES) performed for the HTP region only; the turbulent boundary layer is modeled using scale-resolved wall-modeled LES (WMLES). The study mainly pursues two objectives: first, to discuss the influence of wake turbulence on the flow characteristics of the NACA airfoil; and second, to evaluate the capability of WMLES as a low-cost but high-resolution numerical approach in challenging flow conditions. Essentially, the study confirms the expected result that the outer part of the HTP's boundary layer is dominated by the wake of the main wing. Mainly based on a discussion of turbulence spectra, the study further demonstrates the advantage of WMLES over DES, proving that WMLES is able to capture the effects of wake turbulence on boundary layer dynamics, and thus validates the WMLES approach as a cost-effective, high-resolution turbulence modeling approach. On a superordinate level, the study further sketches a possible way on how a flow problem with such a strongly unsteady behavior could be systematically evaluated.
- Open Access
- 4 September 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 970, A31
Investigation of Lagrangian Areas of Minimal Stretching (LAMS) in a turbulent boundary layer
In this paper the three-dimensional finite-time Lyapunov exponent (FTLE) field of a direct numerical simulation of a flat-plate turbulent boundary layer is analysed in several wall-parallel sections. The data consider a case at a low subsonic Mach number with a moderate positive pressure gradient in the streamwise direction. In contrast to other studies mainly focusing on the maxima of the FTLE field, particular emphasis is placed on the regions of minimal stretching between the vortices and shear layers of the three-dimensional turbulent flow field. These visually appear as contiguous islands or ‘valleys’ between the ‘ridges’ of the FTLE maxima, both at forward and backward integration of the flow field in time. To clearly distinguish the structures investigated from their more common counterparts (e.g. Lagrangian coherent structures, LCS), the acronym LAMS (Lagrangian areas of minimal stretching) is proposed to denote the associated cohesive fluid regions. Consistent with intuition, the largest LAMS occur near the boundary-layer edge, where large regions of homogeneous laminar external flow coexist with upwelling turbulent structures. Compensating for turbulent regions pushing upward, they sink from there down toward the wall, becoming smaller and longer. This process is associated with an increased relative velocity of the LAMS compared with the mean flow, which is observed over the whole boundary layer in the range $y^+ \gtrsim 10$ . Furthermore, it is observed that the Q4 (sweep) events contained in the LAMS clearly dominate over Q2 (ejection) events above $y^+ \approx 10$ . Thereby, local maxima occur at $y^+ \approx 20$ and near the boundary-layer edge. Below $y^+ \approx 10$ , the relationship reverses. Sweeping LAMS from above $y^+ \approx 10$ and ejecting LAMS from below meet in the layer where the maximal vortical activity occurs. The latter is caused by mostly streamwise oriented vortices with maximal vortex stretching in the streamwise direction. Overall, LAMS are associated with cohesive fluid regions between the surrounding vortices and shear layers that both drop down from the boundary-layer edge toward the wall in the outer region of the boundary layer and lift from the wall in the near-wall region.- 4 September 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 970, A31
Open AccessInvestigation of Lagrangian Areas of Minimal Stretching (LAMS) in a turbulent boundary layer
In this paper the three-dimensional finite-time Lyapunov exponent (FTLE) field of a direct numerical simulation of a flat-plate turbulent boundary layer is analysed in several wall-parallel sections. The data consider a case at a low subsonic Mach number with a moderate positive pressure gradient in the streamwise direction. In contrast to other studies mainly focusing on the maxima of the FTLE field, particular emphasis is placed on the regions of minimal stretching between the vortices and shear layers of the three-dimensional turbulent flow field. These visually appear as contiguous islands or ‘valleys’ between the ‘ridges’ of the FTLE maxima, both at forward and backward integration of the flow field in time. To clearly distinguish the structures investigated from their more common counterparts (e.g. Lagrangian coherent structures, LCS), the acronym LAMS (Lagrangian areas of minimal stretching) is proposed to denote the associated cohesive fluid regions. Consistent with intuition, the largest LAMS occur near the boundary-layer edge, where large regions of homogeneous laminar external flow coexist with upwelling turbulent structures. Compensating for turbulent regions pushing upward, they sink from there down toward the wall, becoming smaller and longer. This process is associated with an increased relative velocity of the LAMS compared with the mean flow, which is observed over the whole boundary layer in the range $y^+ \gtrsim 10$ . Furthermore, it is observed that the Q4 (sweep) events contained in the LAMS clearly dominate over Q2 (ejection) events above $y^+ \approx 10$ . Thereby, local maxima occur at $y^+ \approx 20$ and near the boundary-layer edge. Below $y^+ \approx 10$ , the relationship reverses. Sweeping LAMS from above $y^+ \approx 10$ and ejecting LAMS from below meet in the layer where the maximal vortical activity occurs. The latter is caused by mostly streamwise oriented vortices with maximal vortex stretching in the streamwise direction. Overall, LAMS are associated with cohesive fluid regions between the surrounding vortices and shear layers that both drop down from the boundary-layer edge toward the wall in the outer region of the boundary layer and lift from the wall in the near-wall region. - Open Access
- 13 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Experiments in Fluids
- Vol. 64 (2) , 1-8
Delay of laminar–turbulent transition by counter-rotating cylindrical roughness elements in a laminar flat plate boundary layer
Delaying laminar–turbulent transition in boundary layers is of great interest since the skin-friction coefficient can be reduced by up to one order of magnitude. In this experimental research, it is shown that counter-rotating cylindrical roughness elements are able to delay transition under realistic flow conditions. Evidence is given by the intermittency, evaluated from hot-film measurements in a laminar water channel. An increase in rotation speed results in a delay of transition of up to $${6.5}{\%}$$ in the center of the plate. This trend can be explained by the streaks amplified by the rotating cylinders, resulting in a damping of the fluctuation amplitude in the boundary layer. The advantage of this method is that the transition delay can be actively controlled with conventional cylindrical roughness elements. Graphical- 13 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Experiments in Fluids
- Vol. 64 (2) , 1-8
Open AccessDelay of laminar–turbulent transition by counter-rotating cylindrical roughness elements in a laminar flat plate boundary layer
Delaying laminar–turbulent transition in boundary layers is of great interest since the skin-friction coefficient can be reduced by up to one order of magnitude. In this experimental research, it is shown that counter-rotating cylindrical roughness elements are able to delay transition under realistic flow conditions. Evidence is given by the intermittency, evaluated from hot-film measurements in a laminar water channel. An increase in rotation speed results in a delay of transition of up to $${6.5}{\%}$$ in the center of the plate. This trend can be explained by the streaks amplified by the rotating cylinders, resulting in a damping of the fluctuation amplitude in the boundary layer. The advantage of this method is that the transition delay can be actively controlled with conventional cylindrical roughness elements. Graphical - 13 July 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 7 (7) , 073902
Stochastic receptivity of laminar compressible boundary layers: An input-output analysis
This study extends the input-output framework for the receptivity analysis of an incompressible boundary layer introduced by Ran et al. [ Phys. Rev. Fluids 4, 093901 (2019)] to the laminar adiabatic supersonic case. Spatially distributed in the wall-normal direction, a -correlated Gaussian noise is considered as input, both including the velocity and temperature fields. Similarly, components of the resulting velocity and/or temperature fields are chosen as outputs. To study effects on the boundary layer, the measurements of the output are restricted within the boundary layer thickness, implying, however, that effects like acoustic radiation to the free stream are outside the scope of the present analysis. The main goal of the study is twofold: first, to demonstrate the potential of the chosen approach by comparison with familiar results, and second, to extend the current state of knowledge in the compressible regime in selected points by exploiting the extended capabilities of the chosen framework. To this end, the importance of the different inputs—especially the temperature effects—for the amplification of two-dimensional, oblique flow structures and streaks are discussed. Furthermore, the influence of first and second Mach modes (not present in the incompressible regime) is identified within the stochastic framework and results are discussed in light of previous receptivity analyses where the output is restricted to a single mode. By varying the spatial distribution of the forcing, the dependence of the receptivity on the wall-normal position, where the forcing is introduced, is illustrated and discussed. Finally, dominant coherent structures are identified by evaluating the first singular vector of the correlation matrix (proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) modes). By analyzing the dependence of both forcing and response POD modes on the choice of the measured component, further insight is provided about the contribution of temperature fluctuation to the stochastically maintained variance of the system.- 13 July 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 7 (7) , 073902
Stochastic receptivity of laminar compressible boundary layers: An input-output analysis
This study extends the input-output framework for the receptivity analysis of an incompressible boundary layer introduced by Ran et al. [ Phys. Rev. Fluids 4, 093901 (2019)] to the laminar adiabatic supersonic case. Spatially distributed in the wall-normal direction, a -correlated Gaussian noise is considered as input, both including the velocity and temperature fields. Similarly, components of the resulting velocity and/or temperature fields are chosen as outputs. To study effects on the boundary layer, the measurements of the output are restricted within the boundary layer thickness, implying, however, that effects like acoustic radiation to the free stream are outside the scope of the present analysis. The main goal of the study is twofold: first, to demonstrate the potential of the chosen approach by comparison with familiar results, and second, to extend the current state of knowledge in the compressible regime in selected points by exploiting the extended capabilities of the chosen framework. To this end, the importance of the different inputs—especially the temperature effects—for the amplification of two-dimensional, oblique flow structures and streaks are discussed. Furthermore, the influence of first and second Mach modes (not present in the incompressible regime) is identified within the stochastic framework and results are discussed in light of previous receptivity analyses where the output is restricted to a single mode. By varying the spatial distribution of the forcing, the dependence of the receptivity on the wall-normal position, where the forcing is introduced, is illustrated and discussed. Finally, dominant coherent structures are identified by evaluating the first singular vector of the correlation matrix (proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) modes). By analyzing the dependence of both forcing and response POD modes on the choice of the measured component, further insight is provided about the contribution of temperature fluctuation to the stochastically maintained variance of the system.