AMAnthony J. Million

Anthony J. Million

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Anthony J. Million has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    More Than a Literature Review: Discussing the Problem of Citing Retracted Papers

    by Anthony Million, John Budd

    While retractions are meant to protect the scientific record, many continue to be cited long after they are withdrawn. This paper discusses retractions through a lens of information-seeking behavior and Library and Information Science education, framing the citation of retracted works as a breakdown in literature reviews. Drawing on one model of information-seeking behavior, we argue that post-retraction citations occur because authors fail to evaluate content, misinterpret findings, or rely on problematic digital infrastructures that do not uniformly surface retraction notices. Discussing three cases from Web of Science and Retraction Watch, we show how non-uniform publisher practices and flawed indexing contribute to authors' unawareness. This suggests current scholarly communications practices are imperfect and poorly coordinated across platforms. In response, we call for the development of a framework to document authors' motivations and behaviors to inform LIS curricula, enhance information literacy, and improve the design of tools that safeguard scientific integrity.

  • Open Access

    Information Needs and Data Harmonization—Two Sides of the Same Coin?

    by A. J. Million, Jenny Bossaller, Sanja Gidakovic

    This article reports on a quality improvement project aimed at supporting the Community Firearm Violence Prevention (CFVP) network at the University of Michigan in the U.S. We examine the information and data needs of researchers in public health, medicine, and criminal justice. Semi-structured interviews with CFVP affiliates and researchers confirm the existence of significant limitations in existing datasets and resources to conduct firearm-violence prevention research. Study participants discussed (1) the infrastructure and research support that would improve their productivity; (2) benefits of using and combining datasets, (3) challenges when accessing data, and (4) data collection and harmonization strategies that increase research impact. We present findings highlighting data-related challenges in this space that concern researchers, data scientists, and policymakers. We conclude that researchers’ information needs and data harmonization initiatives are interrelated phenomena. Our observation carries implications for large-scale data harmonization efforts in the social and behavioral sciences.

  • Open Access

    Data, not documents: Moving beyond theories of information‐seeking behavior to advance data discovery

    by Anthony J. Million, Jeremy York, Sara Lafia, Libby Hemphill

    Many theories of human information behavior (HIB) assume that information objects are in text document format. This paper argues four important HIB theories are insufficient for describing users' search strategies for data because of assumptions about the attributes of objects that users seek. We first review and compare four HIB theories: Bates' berrypicking, Marchionni's electronic information search, Dervin's sense‐making, and Meho and Tibbo's social scientist information‐seeking. All four theories assume that information‐seekers search for text documents. Next, we compare these theories to search behavior by analyzing Google Analytics data from the Inter‐university Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR). Users took direct, scenic, and orienting paths when searching for data. We also interviewed ICPSR users (n = 20), and they said they needed dataset documentation and contextual information to find data. However, Dervin's sense‐making alone cannot explain the information‐seeking behaviors that we observed. Instead, what mattered most were object attributes determined by the type of information that users sought (i.e., data, not documents). We conclude by suggesting an alternative frame for building user‐centered data discovery tools.


  • Open Access

    Exploratory and directed search strategies at a social science data archive

    by Sara Lafia, A.J. Million, Libby Hemphill

    Researchers need to be able to find, access, and use data to participate in open science. To understand how users search for research data, we analyzed textual queries issued at a large social science data archive, the Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR). We collected unique user queries from 988,475 user search sessions over four years (2012-16). Overall, we found that only 30% of site visitors entered search terms into the ICPSR website. We analyzed search strategies within these sessions by extending existing dataset search taxonomies to classify a subset of the 1,554 most popular queries. We identified five categories of commonly-issued queries: keyword-based (e.g., date, place, topic); name (e.g., study, series); identifier (e.g., study, series); author (e.g., institutional, individual); and type (e.g., file, format). While the dominant search strategy used short keywords to explore topics, directed searches for known items using study and series names were also common. We further distinguished exploratory browsing from directed search queries based on their page views, refinements, search depth, duration, and length. Directed queries were longer (i.e., they had more words), while sessions with exploratory queries had more refinements and associated page views. By comparing search interactions at ICPSR to other natural language interactions in similar web search contexts, we conclude that dataset search at ICPSR is underutilized. We envision how alternative search paradigms, such as those enabled by recommender systems, can enhance dataset search.


  • Data Management Plan Implementation, Assessments, and Evaluations: Implications and Recommendations

    by Bradley Wade Bishop, Peter Neish, Ji Hyun Kim, Raphaëlle Bats, A. J. Million, Jake Carlson, Heather Moulaison-Sandy, Minh T. Pham


  • Open Access

    Bureaucratic organization and innovation: a mixed-methods study of US state department of transportation website adoption

    by Anthony J. Million

    This study explores bureaucratic organization and innovation in US state department of transportation (DOT) websites. To determine if working with third parties fosters change in state DOT websites, it employs a two-part, explanatory sequential mixed-methods design. In phase one, an online survey was disseminated to IT managers and communications officers in all 50 states to collect data regarding agency demographics, bureaucratic models, and Web infrastructure. In total, 45 valid responses (or 90 percent) were received from DOTs indicating that most built, hosted, and managed their websites in-house, but that state-level IT consolidations required many to pool resources with third parties. In research phase two, 12 semi-structured interviews were conducted of a maximum variation sample of survey respondents. These interviews were conducted to explain why DOTs built and operated their websites with the support of third parties. Employing a grounded theoretical approach, analysis revealed 6 themes explaining website adoption and showed that working with third parties can foster innovation; however, not all change is positive. Therefore, a need exists for governments to selectively work with others, ascertain future barriers to change, and ensure that adopted innovations meet desired ends. Finally, five best practices informed by study findings are presented that may help decision-makers and civil servants provide e-government services in a flexible manner.

  • Open Access

    Direct, Orienting, and Scenic Paths: How Users Navigate Search in a Research Data Archive

    by Sara Lafia, A.J. Million, Libby Hemphill

    Social scientists increasingly share data so others can evaluate, replicate, and extend their research. To understand the process of data discovery as a precursor to data use, we study prospective users’ interactions with archived data. We gathered data for 98,000 user sessions initiated at a large social science data archive, the Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR). Our data reflect four years (2012-16) of users’ interactions with archival resources, including a data catalog, study-level metadata, variables, and publications that cite nearly 10,000 datasets. We constructed a network of user interactions linking website landing (e.g., site entrances) to exit pages, from which we identified three types of paths that users take through the research data archive: direct, orienting, and scenic. We also interpreted points of failure (e.g., drop-offs) and recurring behaviors (e.g., sensemaking) that support or impede data discovery along search paths. We articulate strategies that users adopt as they navigate data search and suggest ways to enhance the accessibility of data, metadata, and the systems that organize each.


  • Open Access

    The research data life cycle, legacy data, and dilemmas in research data management

    by Jenny Bossaller, Anthony J. Million

    This paper presents findings from an interview study of research data managers in academic data archives. Our study examined policies and professional autonomy with a focus on dilemmas encountered in everyday work by data managers. We found that dilemmas arose at every stage of the research data lifecycle, and legacy data presents particularly vexing challenges. The iFields' emphasis on knowledge organization and representation provides insight into how data, used by scientists, are used to create knowledge. The iFields' disciplinary emphasis also encompasses the sociotechnical complexity of dilemmas that we found arise in research data management. Therefore, we posit that iSchools are positioned to contribute to data science education by teaching about ethics and infrastructure used to collect, organize, and disseminate data through problem‐based learning.


  • Policies, Procedures, and Decision‐Making: Data Managers and the Research Lifecycle

    by A.J. Million, Jenny S. Bossaller

    Research data is an asset. Researchers may be required to provide access to their data by scientific funders or academic journals and deposit their data in archives. Managers of archives are guided by principles, policies, and the law when curating and providing access to data. Practices around data storage and access, however, are not always cut and dry; research data managers sometimes need to interpret policies. This paper presents findings from qualitative interviews with 15 data managers from 8 repositories in the U.S. These repositories were all affiliated with universities but served varied constituents and provided a range of services. Differences revealed opportunities and challenges in managing data repositories regarding, for instance, who can access data and the level of protection data requires. We also found that data‐related policy challenges may stem from any stage of the research lifecycle.


  • How nonprofits use Facebook to craft infrastructure

    by Libby Hemphill, A.J. Million, Ingrid Erickson

    We present findings from interviews with 23 individuals affiliated with non-profit organizations (NPOs) to understand how they deploy information and communication technologies (ICTs) in their civic engagement efforts. Existing research about NPO ICT use is often critical, but we did not find evidence that NPOs fail to use tools effectively. Rather, we detail how NPOs assemble various ICTs to create infrastructures that align with their values. Overall, we find that existing theories about technology choice (e.g., task-technology fit, uses and gratifications) do not explain the assemblages NPOs describe. We argue that the infrastructures they fashion can be explained through the lens of moral economies rather than utility. Together, the rhetorics of infrastructure and moral economies capture the motivations and constraints our participants expressed and challenge how prevailing theories of ICT use describe the non-profit landscape.