Deirdre M. Kelly
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Deirdre M. Kelly has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Dawn H. Currie
University of British Columbia
10 shared publications Shauna Pomerantz
Brock University
6 shared publicationsGabriella Minnes Brandes
University of British Columbia
2 shared publications- Ashley R. Moore
University of Toronto
1 shared publication Chrissie Arnold
University of British Columbia, Canada
1 shared publicationJohn L. Rury
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 23
Getting Real About Critical Realist Interviewing: Five Principles to Guide Practice
Critical realism refers to a broad project to realize a post-positivist social science. At its best, it responds to the challenges thrown down by social constructionist critiques of positivist science, while also allowing us to make interrogable claims about reality—a priority for many working to expose and eradicate structural oppression. In the social sciences, interviews remain one of the foremost methods through which researchers generate data to inform our understanding of reality. In this article, however, we argue that for critical realism to deliver on its promise as a philosophy of science for critical social scientists, we need theoretically sound guidance on what a critical realist approach to research interviewing might look like. Currently, this guidance is lacking. Through a systematic analysis of prominent qualitative research interviewing textbooks, we found that critical realism is ignored, mischaracterized, and underdeveloped. In response, we offer five principles, rooted in critical realism’s key tenets, that can guide researchers as they design, conduct, and evaluate critical realist interview studies. These principles are: (1) craft interview protocols to generate data that can inform answers to ontological research questions; (2) keep in view the interview as social practice throughout the study; (3) treat interview data as both interactively achieved co-constructions and as verifiable evidence for real phenomena; (4) be guided and informed by an aim to reduce suffering and promote social justice; and (5) demonstrate reflexivity as ongoing self-awareness.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 23
Open AccessGetting Real About Critical Realist Interviewing: Five Principles to Guide Practice
Critical realism refers to a broad project to realize a post-positivist social science. At its best, it responds to the challenges thrown down by social constructionist critiques of positivist science, while also allowing us to make interrogable claims about reality—a priority for many working to expose and eradicate structural oppression. In the social sciences, interviews remain one of the foremost methods through which researchers generate data to inform our understanding of reality. In this article, however, we argue that for critical realism to deliver on its promise as a philosophy of science for critical social scientists, we need theoretically sound guidance on what a critical realist approach to research interviewing might look like. Currently, this guidance is lacking. Through a systematic analysis of prominent qualitative research interviewing textbooks, we found that critical realism is ignored, mischaracterized, and underdeveloped. In response, we offer five principles, rooted in critical realism’s key tenets, that can guide researchers as they design, conduct, and evaluate critical realist interview studies. These principles are: (1) craft interview protocols to generate data that can inform answers to ontological research questions; (2) keep in view the interview as social practice throughout the study; (3) treat interview data as both interactively achieved co-constructions and as verifiable evidence for real phenomena; (4) be guided and informed by an aim to reduce suffering and promote social justice; and (5) demonstrate reflexivity as ongoing self-awareness.
- 15 July 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies
- Vol. 44 (5) , 406-446
Critical social literacy: Media engagement as an exercise of power
While recognition of the need for teacher education in media literacy is not new, in the context of social media it is growing. What we offer is an approach to critical media literacy for teachers—...
- 15 July 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies
- Vol. 44 (5) , 406-446
Critical social literacy: Media engagement as an exercise of power
While recognition of the need for teacher education in media literacy is not new, in the context of social media it is growing. What we offer is an approach to critical media literacy for teachers—...
- 25 May 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in The International Journal of Critical Media Literacy
- Vol. 2 (2) , 121-147
Teacher Reflexivity When Using Pop Culture in the Classroom
The purpose of the research was to explore what teacher reflexivity looks like when considering pop culture texts for classroom use or planning media education lessons. We build on Margaret Archer’s work, defining reflexivity as ongoing inner dialogue that precedes, attends, and reflects upon our actions. We theorize reflexive interrogation across five key dimensions: personal, emotional, analytical, political, and ethical. We discuss the types of questions teachers might ask themselves to hone their sensitivity in these areas and develop particular habits of thinking and acting. We then illustrate how these five domains of potential learning, in turn, can inform teaching strategies, using stories from our multiple case-study research into teaching media literacy for social justice.
- 25 May 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in The International Journal of Critical Media Literacy
- Vol. 2 (2) , 121-147
Teacher Reflexivity When Using Pop Culture in the Classroom
The purpose of the research was to explore what teacher reflexivity looks like when considering pop culture texts for classroom use or planning media education lessons. We build on Margaret Archer’s work, defining reflexivity as ongoing inner dialogue that precedes, attends, and reflects upon our actions. We theorize reflexive interrogation across five key dimensions: personal, emotional, analytical, political, and ethical. We discuss the types of questions teachers might ask themselves to hone their sensitivity in these areas and develop particular habits of thinking and acting. We then illustrate how these five domains of potential learning, in turn, can inform teaching strategies, using stories from our multiple case-study research into teaching media literacy for social justice.
- 12 October 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Gender and Education
- Vol. 33 (6) , 676-691
Beyond stereotype analysis in critical media literacy: case study of reading and writing gender in pop music videos
In this article we explore the utility but also limitations of gender stereotyping lessons, a common undertaking by teachers introducing media analysis to youth. We document our collaboration with a Canadian high school teacher as she translated her understanding of critical media literacy into practice in a unit addressing questions about the gendered nature of pop music videos. Informed by feminist cultural studies, we explore challenges that arose when teaching about gender stereotyping. Factors that circumscribed deeper inquiry included (a) discussing whether media texts were unrealistic rather than focusing on meaning-making practices; (b) inattention to hidden yet active media texts that worked to sustain dominant meanings; (c) lack of access to counter-frames; (d) inattention to intersectionality so that gender was conflated with sex and sexuality, allowing heteronormativity to go unrecognized; and (e) the ambiguities of how sexual power operates in commercial pop culture, making it difficult for students to discern feminist parody.
- 12 October 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Gender and Education
- Vol. 33 (6) , 676-691
Beyond stereotype analysis in critical media literacy: case study of reading and writing gender in pop music videos
In this article we explore the utility but also limitations of gender stereotyping lessons, a common undertaking by teachers introducing media analysis to youth. We document our collaboration with a Canadian high school teacher as she translated her understanding of critical media literacy into practice in a unit addressing questions about the gendered nature of pop music videos. Informed by feminist cultural studies, we explore challenges that arose when teaching about gender stereotyping. Factors that circumscribed deeper inquiry included (a) discussing whether media texts were unrealistic rather than focusing on meaning-making practices; (b) inattention to hidden yet active media texts that worked to sustain dominant meanings; (c) lack of access to counter-frames; (d) inattention to intersectionality so that gender was conflated with sex and sexuality, allowing heteronormativity to go unrecognized; and (e) the ambiguities of how sexual power operates in commercial pop culture, making it difficult for students to discern feminist parody.
- 1 January 2016
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 529-559
Cyberbullying and Internet Safety
The chapter considers cyberbullying in relation to Internet safety, concentrating on recent, high quality empirical studies. The review discusses conventional debates over how to define cyberbullying, arguing to limit the term to repeated, electronically-mediated incidents involving intention to harm and a power imbalance between bully and victim. It also takes note of the critical perspective that cyberbullying—through its generic and individualistic framing—deflects attention from the racism, sexism, ableism, and heterosexism that can motivate or exacerbate the problem of such bullying. The review concludes that: (a) cyberbullying, rigorously defined, is a phenomenon that is less pervasive and dire than widely believed; and (b) cyber-aggression and online harassment are more prevalent, yet understudied. Fueled by various societal inequalities, these latter forms of online abuse require urgent public attention. The chapter's recommendations are informed by a view of young people as apprentice citizens, who learn democratic participation by practicing it.
- 1 January 2016
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 529-559
Cyberbullying and Internet Safety
The chapter considers cyberbullying in relation to Internet safety, concentrating on recent, high quality empirical studies. The review discusses conventional debates over how to define cyberbullying, arguing to limit the term to repeated, electronically-mediated incidents involving intention to harm and a power imbalance between bully and victim. It also takes note of the critical perspective that cyberbullying—through its generic and individualistic framing—deflects attention from the racism, sexism, ableism, and heterosexism that can motivate or exacerbate the problem of such bullying. The review concludes that: (a) cyberbullying, rigorously defined, is a phenomenon that is less pervasive and dire than widely believed; and (b) cyber-aggression and online harassment are more prevalent, yet understudied. Fueled by various societal inequalities, these latter forms of online abuse require urgent public attention. The chapter's recommendations are informed by a view of young people as apprentice citizens, who learn democratic participation by practicing it.
- 29 February 2012
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Group Interviews: Understanding Shared Meaning and Meaning-Making
- 29 February 2012
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Group Interviews: Understanding Shared Meaning and Meaning-Making
- 14 January 2011
- Published by Springer Nature in Studies in Philosophy and Education
- Vol. 30 (2) , 185-198
The Public Policy Pedagogy of Corporate and Alternative News Media
- 14 January 2011
- Published by Springer Nature in Studies in Philosophy and Education
- Vol. 30 (2) , 185-198
The Public Policy Pedagogy of Corporate and Alternative News Media
- 29 April 2009
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Equity & Excellence in Education
- Vol. 42 (2) , 202-216
How Young is Too Young? Exploring Beginning Teachers' Assumptions about Young Children and Teaching for Social Justice
This study investigates what preservice elementary school teachers assume about children's capacities to learn about equity issues and how teachers might translate teaching for social justice into actual classroom practices. Participants said they did not see the age of their students as a barrier to teaching for social justice, although their ways of conceptualizing this varied considerably, and those teaching grade 4–6 students were generally more risk-taking in the curricular and pedagogical choices they made. We found that the concepts of childhood innocence and developmental appropriateness mediated the topics and approach to topics that beginning teachers considered. Roughly half the participants believed that younger children are relatively uninterested in the events of the day, are incapable of forming nuanced opinions, and are unable to analyze political issues; while the other half disagreed. Participants concerned about engendering negative emotional responses from elementary students made more limited and generic responses to name-calling or teasing rather than naming specific forms of oppression or prompting students to reflect critically on hurtful language and behavior.
- 29 April 2009
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Equity & Excellence in Education
- Vol. 42 (2) , 202-216
How Young is Too Young? Exploring Beginning Teachers' Assumptions about Young Children and Teaching for Social Justice
This study investigates what preservice elementary school teachers assume about children's capacities to learn about equity issues and how teachers might translate teaching for social justice into actual classroom practices. Participants said they did not see the age of their students as a barrier to teaching for social justice, although their ways of conceptualizing this varied considerably, and those teaching grade 4–6 students were generally more risk-taking in the curricular and pedagogical choices they made. We found that the concepts of childhood innocence and developmental appropriateness mediated the topics and approach to topics that beginning teachers considered. Roughly half the participants believed that younger children are relatively uninterested in the events of the day, are incapable of forming nuanced opinions, and are unable to analyze political issues; while the other half disagreed. Participants concerned about engendering negative emotional responses from elementary students made more limited and generic responses to name-calling or teasing rather than naming specific forms of oppression or prompting students to reflect critically on hurtful language and behavior.
- 1 January 2008
- Published by Springer Nature in Interchange
- Vol. 39 (1) , 49-76
Equitable Classroom Assessment: Promoting Self-Development and Self-Determination
- 1 January 2008
- Published by Springer Nature in Interchange
- Vol. 39 (1) , 49-76
Equitable Classroom Assessment: Promoting Self-Development and Self-Determination
- 29 May 2007
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education
- Vol. 20 (4) , 377-400
Listening to girls: discursive positioning and the construction of self
Recent decades have seen a proliferation of books that ‘listen in’ on the everyday lives of girls. In their research the authors maintain that ‘listening’ to girls in order to make claims about what they ‘heard’ is a theoretically mediated process, and therefore it is not as straightforward as many authors imply. The purpose of this paper is to explore what they call the ‘symptomatic reading’ of interview transcripts. While attending to the contradiction and inconsistencies that characterize interview texts, they also recognize stabilizing strategies—what they call ‘trump discourses’—that make social life possible. Such a way of working enables us to see how power works through discourse. It helps us understand why many girls express a feminist Subjectivity, while distancing themselves from the identity as ‘feminist.’
- 29 May 2007
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education
- Vol. 20 (4) , 377-400
Listening to girls: discursive positioning and the construction of self
Recent decades have seen a proliferation of books that ‘listen in’ on the everyday lives of girls. In their research the authors maintain that ‘listening’ to girls in order to make claims about what they ‘heard’ is a theoretically mediated process, and therefore it is not as straightforward as many authors imply. The purpose of this paper is to explore what they call the ‘symptomatic reading’ of interview transcripts. While attending to the contradiction and inconsistencies that characterize interview texts, they also recognize stabilizing strategies—what they call ‘trump discourses’—that make social life possible. Such a way of working enables us to see how power works through discourse. It helps us understand why many girls express a feminist Subjectivity, while distancing themselves from the identity as ‘feminist.’