Murali Jagannathan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Murali Jagannathan has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Venkata Santosh Kumar Delhi
Assistant Professor, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Maharashtra 400076, India
6 shared publications- Venkata Santosh Kumar Delhi
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
5 shared publications - Vijayeta Malla
Bantrel
3 shared publications Avirag Bajpai
L&T Institute of Project Management
1 shared publicationBhagya S. Nair
Assistant General Manager, Bangalore International Airport Limited, KIAL Rd., Bengaluru, Karnataka 560300, India
1 shared publication- Debopam Roy
National Institute of Construction Management and Research (NICMAR)
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 February 2027
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 19 (1) , 04526059
Developing a Base Framework to Enable a Lean Step Zero toward Dispute Avoidance
Lean construction techniques are being discussed for their benefits in dispute avoidance, along with waste reduction, productivity improvement, and minimizing time and cost overruns. However, implementing lean presents challenges, with stakeholder resistance to change being a primary obstacle. To address this resistance, current literature recommends adding new contract clauses to the traditional standard form contracts (SFCs) to make lean adoption contractually binding. However, since traditional SFC in construction often contains restrictive and one-sided clauses, integrating lean-friendly, collaborative clauses may conflict with existing ones, potentially creating new conflicts. This study, therefore, aims to assess the adaptability of Indian public sector undertakings (PSUs) SFCs to lean, i.e., the leanness of the contract. Built on a base framework developed from lean construction and contract drafting principles recommended in the literature, an automatic leanness assessment application is developed using a multilayer perceptron (MLP) model augmented with synthetic data augmentation and the synthetic minority oversampling technique (SMOTE), achieving an F1 score of 93%. After the assessment, the restrictive clause segments are neutralized using a lean-neutral template via a retrieval-augmented generation (RAG)- assisted large language model (LLM). This makes the traditional contract conducive to adding clauses that actively support lean implementation without conflicting with existing clauses.
- 1 February 2027
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 19 (1) , 04526059
Developing a Base Framework to Enable a Lean Step Zero toward Dispute Avoidance
Lean construction techniques are being discussed for their benefits in dispute avoidance, along with waste reduction, productivity improvement, and minimizing time and cost overruns. However, implementing lean presents challenges, with stakeholder resistance to change being a primary obstacle. To address this resistance, current literature recommends adding new contract clauses to the traditional standard form contracts (SFCs) to make lean adoption contractually binding. However, since traditional SFC in construction often contains restrictive and one-sided clauses, integrating lean-friendly, collaborative clauses may conflict with existing ones, potentially creating new conflicts. This study, therefore, aims to assess the adaptability of Indian public sector undertakings (PSUs) SFCs to lean, i.e., the leanness of the contract. Built on a base framework developed from lean construction and contract drafting principles recommended in the literature, an automatic leanness assessment application is developed using a multilayer perceptron (MLP) model augmented with synthetic data augmentation and the synthetic minority oversampling technique (SMOTE), achieving an F1 score of 93%. After the assessment, the restrictive clause segments are neutralized using a lean-neutral template via a retrieval-augmented generation (RAG)- assisted large language model (LLM). This makes the traditional contract conducive to adding clauses that actively support lean implementation without conflicting with existing clauses.
- 14 August 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Built Environment Project and Asset Management
- Vol. 13 (6) , 846-861
Paths leading contractual disputes to litigation
Purpose: Judiciary plays a pivotal role in the overall development of a nation's economy and its involvement assures process transparency and impartiality. However, litigation is often expensive, uncertain and prone to delays. Notwithstanding such inherent challenges associated with litigation, it is observed that parties in construction disputes do resort to litigation. This study attempts to understand the potential paths triggering litigation of contractual disputes in construction. While extant researchers have identified focus areas or factors influencing litigation, the underlying paths connecting these focus areas, leading parties to litigation, is explored in this study.Design/methodology/approach: Considering the framework of Rachlinski's “framing theory of litigation” and the mixed-methods approach (qualitative and quantitative approaches), this study proposes and validates a model that identifies the paths to litigation of contractual disputes in construction.Findings: The results of in-depth interviews, followed by validation through structural equation modelling (SEM), reveal four critical paths, namely positional focus (PF) – contract and dispute characteristics (CDC) – decision to litigate (DTL), milieu influence (MI) – CDC – DTL, MI-PF-DTL and CDC-DTL.Practical implications: The identified paths highlight the areas policymakers can consider while developing policy interventions to mitigate litigation.Originality/value: Researchers have identified factors causing litigation in construction. However, attempts to examine the existence of multi-factor “paths” on the decision to litigate (DTL) have hitherto received a muted response, so this study focuses on identifying the project-level path(s) leading to the litigation of contractual disputes in construction.
- 14 August 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Built Environment Project and Asset Management
- Vol. 13 (6) , 846-861
Paths leading contractual disputes to litigation
Purpose: Judiciary plays a pivotal role in the overall development of a nation's economy and its involvement assures process transparency and impartiality. However, litigation is often expensive, uncertain and prone to delays. Notwithstanding such inherent challenges associated with litigation, it is observed that parties in construction disputes do resort to litigation. This study attempts to understand the potential paths triggering litigation of contractual disputes in construction. While extant researchers have identified focus areas or factors influencing litigation, the underlying paths connecting these focus areas, leading parties to litigation, is explored in this study.Design/methodology/approach: Considering the framework of Rachlinski's “framing theory of litigation” and the mixed-methods approach (qualitative and quantitative approaches), this study proposes and validates a model that identifies the paths to litigation of contractual disputes in construction.Findings: The results of in-depth interviews, followed by validation through structural equation modelling (SEM), reveal four critical paths, namely positional focus (PF) – contract and dispute characteristics (CDC) – decision to litigate (DTL), milieu influence (MI) – CDC – DTL, MI-PF-DTL and CDC-DTL.Practical implications: The identified paths highlight the areas policymakers can consider while developing policy interventions to mitigate litigation.Originality/value: Researchers have identified factors causing litigation in construction. However, attempts to examine the existence of multi-factor “paths” on the decision to litigate (DTL) have hitherto received a muted response, so this study focuses on identifying the project-level path(s) leading to the litigation of contractual disputes in construction.
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Built Environment Project and Asset Management
- Vol. 13 (3) , 453-470
Decoding a construction organisation's tendency to litigate: an understanding through financial statements
Purpose: Despite the availability of amicable means to resolve construction disputes, litigation remains a mainstream dispute resolution process in some countries. This tendency to litigate (TTL) calls for research to develop appropriate precautions to encourage stakeholders to resolve most commercial disputes through alternate dispute resolution (ADR) techniques. While a claimant's TTL arise from the individual, project and organisation preferences, this study, which can benefit both potential claimants and employers by saving time and money on litigation, identifies a bidder's financial parameters that may increase its litigation propensities, as a first step towards aiding employers to incorporate precautions to discourage such tendencies.Design/methodology/approach: After the literature review, the theoretical construct proposed by Rachlinski's “framing theory of litigation” (based on Kahneman and Tversky's Prospects Theory) is used to explain organisation-level litigation decision-making. The study sources data from the financial statements of Indian construction/real estate firms, followed by panel regression analysis to test the theoretical construct's validity.Findings: The results show that the TTL (risk-seeking behaviour) generally increases with a lower value of sales, higher assets and profitability. Interestingly, organisation-level cash flow shows an insignificant influence on litigation tendencies.Practical implications: Knowing which financial parameters may increase litigation tendencies could help employers evaluate a bidder's propensity to litigate project disputes.Originality/value: Researchers use financial statements to explore correlations among financial variables. However, in the construction context, there are no empirical studies with data from construction firms to understand potential litigation expenses compared to specific financial ratios.
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Built Environment Project and Asset Management
- Vol. 13 (3) , 453-470
Decoding a construction organisation's tendency to litigate: an understanding through financial statements
Purpose: Despite the availability of amicable means to resolve construction disputes, litigation remains a mainstream dispute resolution process in some countries. This tendency to litigate (TTL) calls for research to develop appropriate precautions to encourage stakeholders to resolve most commercial disputes through alternate dispute resolution (ADR) techniques. While a claimant's TTL arise from the individual, project and organisation preferences, this study, which can benefit both potential claimants and employers by saving time and money on litigation, identifies a bidder's financial parameters that may increase its litigation propensities, as a first step towards aiding employers to incorporate precautions to discourage such tendencies.Design/methodology/approach: After the literature review, the theoretical construct proposed by Rachlinski's “framing theory of litigation” (based on Kahneman and Tversky's Prospects Theory) is used to explain organisation-level litigation decision-making. The study sources data from the financial statements of Indian construction/real estate firms, followed by panel regression analysis to test the theoretical construct's validity.Findings: The results show that the TTL (risk-seeking behaviour) generally increases with a lower value of sales, higher assets and profitability. Interestingly, organisation-level cash flow shows an insignificant influence on litigation tendencies.Practical implications: Knowing which financial parameters may increase litigation tendencies could help employers evaluate a bidder's propensity to litigate project disputes.Originality/value: Researchers use financial statements to explore correlations among financial variables. However, in the construction context, there are no empirical studies with data from construction firms to understand potential litigation expenses compared to specific financial ratios.
- 1 November 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 14 (4) , 04522025
Role of Case Laws in Claim Management and Contracts
There is a long history of court judgments in the construction sector, providing a wealth of knowledge that can guide contract parties in preempting claims and disputes in construction projects. However, knowledge from case law findings does not seem to percolate to day-to-day contract management activities. This anecdotal statement needs empirical verification. Thus, the current study attempted to understand the extent of case-law-based legal knowledge percolation in day-to-day contract management and its impact on the dispute resolution climate. The study highlighted the gap between the need for and availability of case-law-based training/knowledge using data from India. There were four major observations from the research. First, questionnaire survey results highlighted the fact that engineers and managers in construction projects acknowledge the inevitability of legal awareness for day-to-day contract management. While about 72% of the respondents (76 out of 106) agreed that case-law-based training could have helped in managing disputes better, only 10% (11 out of 106 respondents) reported that their organizations offer regular case-law-based knowledge and training. Moreover, 65% of the respondents (69 out of 106) either confirmed that their organizations do not maintain a case-law learning repository or they are unaware of its availability. Therefore, the second observation is that there is a shortfall in avenues that help professionals gain case-law-based knowledge from training. Although pure experience-based learning can lead to a risky trial and error approach, opportunities for self-learning are also muted. Third, by highlighting a growing trend of expenses incurred for the arbitration and litigation of construction disputes—in other words, legalization—the study highlighted the importance of the development and administration of case-law-based professional training programs. Last, the study also illustrated the potential for case laws to guide engineers and managers in their day-to-day contract management activities. The findings from the study can help the construction industry collaborate closely with researchers and academicians to move a step closer to making legal knowledge easily accessible to contract managers and help them make decisions that can withstand legal scrutiny.
- 1 November 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 14 (4) , 04522025
Role of Case Laws in Claim Management and Contracts
There is a long history of court judgments in the construction sector, providing a wealth of knowledge that can guide contract parties in preempting claims and disputes in construction projects. However, knowledge from case law findings does not seem to percolate to day-to-day contract management activities. This anecdotal statement needs empirical verification. Thus, the current study attempted to understand the extent of case-law-based legal knowledge percolation in day-to-day contract management and its impact on the dispute resolution climate. The study highlighted the gap between the need for and availability of case-law-based training/knowledge using data from India. There were four major observations from the research. First, questionnaire survey results highlighted the fact that engineers and managers in construction projects acknowledge the inevitability of legal awareness for day-to-day contract management. While about 72% of the respondents (76 out of 106) agreed that case-law-based training could have helped in managing disputes better, only 10% (11 out of 106 respondents) reported that their organizations offer regular case-law-based knowledge and training. Moreover, 65% of the respondents (69 out of 106) either confirmed that their organizations do not maintain a case-law learning repository or they are unaware of its availability. Therefore, the second observation is that there is a shortfall in avenues that help professionals gain case-law-based knowledge from training. Although pure experience-based learning can lead to a risky trial and error approach, opportunities for self-learning are also muted. Third, by highlighting a growing trend of expenses incurred for the arbitration and litigation of construction disputes—in other words, legalization—the study highlighted the importance of the development and administration of case-law-based professional training programs. Last, the study also illustrated the potential for case laws to guide engineers and managers in their day-to-day contract management activities. The findings from the study can help the construction industry collaborate closely with researchers and academicians to move a step closer to making legal knowledge easily accessible to contract managers and help them make decisions that can withstand legal scrutiny.
- 13 May 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in CSI Transactions on ICT
- Vol. 10 (2) , 97-106
Application of NLP-based topic modeling to analyse unstructured text data in annual reports of construction contracting companies
The construction industry is the backbone of a nation’s economy. It is a matter of great concern that such an industry suffers from time and cost overruns, especially in these challenging times. Coupled with the overrun issues, the sector is often criticized for lacking adequate quality and quantity of structured secondary data. The emerging technologies in data science and machine intelligence present a unique opportunity to understand the sector better and aid in effective decision-making. To better understand the utility of such technologies, the Management Discussion and Analysis ssections of the annual reports of publicly listed top Indian construction contracting firms are analyzed to identify the presence of ‘strategy themes’ and further map them to the organizations considered. Natural Language Processing (NLP)-based topic modeling algorithms, namely Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) and Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF), are used in this study to perform a qualitative content analysis to identify the latent themes. From a methodological standpoint, considering the context of this study, the NMF results are better in accuracy, precision, and recall compared with the LDA. The results show that while most construction contracting firms prioritized a ‘revenue-focused’ strategy to expand their order books, a smaller set of large-sized firms seem to prioritize process improvement to improve their execution productivity and therefore are ‘profit margin improvement focused’ or ‘lean-focussed’ in their approach. Although a proof-of-concept, this study unlocks the immense potential of unsupervised NLP-based topic-modeling tools to understand and infer from unstructured and freely available text data in the public domain to aid sectoral analysis and policymaking.
- 13 May 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in CSI Transactions on ICT
- Vol. 10 (2) , 97-106
Application of NLP-based topic modeling to analyse unstructured text data in annual reports of construction contracting companies
The construction industry is the backbone of a nation’s economy. It is a matter of great concern that such an industry suffers from time and cost overruns, especially in these challenging times. Coupled with the overrun issues, the sector is often criticized for lacking adequate quality and quantity of structured secondary data. The emerging technologies in data science and machine intelligence present a unique opportunity to understand the sector better and aid in effective decision-making. To better understand the utility of such technologies, the Management Discussion and Analysis ssections of the annual reports of publicly listed top Indian construction contracting firms are analyzed to identify the presence of ‘strategy themes’ and further map them to the organizations considered. Natural Language Processing (NLP)-based topic modeling algorithms, namely Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) and Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF), are used in this study to perform a qualitative content analysis to identify the latent themes. From a methodological standpoint, considering the context of this study, the NMF results are better in accuracy, precision, and recall compared with the LDA. The results show that while most construction contracting firms prioritized a ‘revenue-focused’ strategy to expand their order books, a smaller set of large-sized firms seem to prioritize process improvement to improve their execution productivity and therefore are ‘profit margin improvement focused’ or ‘lean-focussed’ in their approach. Although a proof-of-concept, this study unlocks the immense potential of unsupervised NLP-based topic-modeling tools to understand and infer from unstructured and freely available text data in the public domain to aid sectoral analysis and policymaking.
- 1 May 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 14 (2) , 04522008
BIM-Specific Prequalification Criteria in Construction Projects: Exploring the Nature and Timeline of Their Inclusion
Building information modeling (BIM) can potentially enhance project visibility, improve productivity, and promote shared understanding among various construction project stakeholders. The benefits of BIM implementation in a construction project may remain a distant dream if there is no structured way to select a BIM-capable contractor. Existing studies have focused on identifying BIM prequalification (PQ) criteria in countries where BIM implementation is advanced. Therefore, considering the early stages of BIM adoption in many developing countries, this study identified the mandatory and desirable BIM-specific PQ criteria to be included in the short, medium, and long term, considering the perspectives of clients, contractors, consultants, and academicians in the context of engineering, procurement, and construction—turnkey (EPC–Turnkey) projects. Objectives were achieved by identifying the relevant BIM-specific PQ criteria through content analysis of the literature and interviews with experts predominantly from countries where BIM implementation is nascent. Following the literature review and interviews, a questionnaire survey of globally spread stakeholders assessed their extent of agreement or disagreement on including a criterion as a BIM-specific PQ criterion. The results showed that, while all the identified BIM-specific PQ criteria were rated on the agreement side, most respondents preferred including the criteria as desirable rather than mandatory, with their inclusion in the short and medium term (less than five years). In terms of stakeholder perspectives, there was no significant difference between the agreement levels of stakeholder groups. However, considering the overall responses, realizing the need to provide time for holistic BIM diffusion, the practitioners preferred a middle path to include the BIM-specific PQ criteria as desirable rather than mandatory within a timeline of the next five years. The study results can help project stakeholders assess bidders’ BIM implementation capability by considering the conflicting dual needs of BIM implementation urgency and the varying extents of BIM percolation among contractor organizations.
- 1 May 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 14 (2) , 04522008
BIM-Specific Prequalification Criteria in Construction Projects: Exploring the Nature and Timeline of Their Inclusion
Building information modeling (BIM) can potentially enhance project visibility, improve productivity, and promote shared understanding among various construction project stakeholders. The benefits of BIM implementation in a construction project may remain a distant dream if there is no structured way to select a BIM-capable contractor. Existing studies have focused on identifying BIM prequalification (PQ) criteria in countries where BIM implementation is advanced. Therefore, considering the early stages of BIM adoption in many developing countries, this study identified the mandatory and desirable BIM-specific PQ criteria to be included in the short, medium, and long term, considering the perspectives of clients, contractors, consultants, and academicians in the context of engineering, procurement, and construction—turnkey (EPC–Turnkey) projects. Objectives were achieved by identifying the relevant BIM-specific PQ criteria through content analysis of the literature and interviews with experts predominantly from countries where BIM implementation is nascent. Following the literature review and interviews, a questionnaire survey of globally spread stakeholders assessed their extent of agreement or disagreement on including a criterion as a BIM-specific PQ criterion. The results showed that, while all the identified BIM-specific PQ criteria were rated on the agreement side, most respondents preferred including the criteria as desirable rather than mandatory, with their inclusion in the short and medium term (less than five years). In terms of stakeholder perspectives, there was no significant difference between the agreement levels of stakeholder groups. However, considering the overall responses, realizing the need to provide time for holistic BIM diffusion, the practitioners preferred a middle path to include the BIM-specific PQ criteria as desirable rather than mandatory within a timeline of the next five years. The study results can help project stakeholders assess bidders’ BIM implementation capability by considering the conflicting dual needs of BIM implementation urgency and the varying extents of BIM percolation among contractor organizations.
- 1 February 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 14 (1) , 04521040
Identification of BIM Dimension-Specific Contract Clauses in EPC Turnkey Projects
Construction operations are becoming increasingly complex, necessitating a greater need for collaboration. Building information modeling (BIM) aids enhanced project visualization and collaboration. The extant literature has mainly focused on model ownership, intellectual property, and data security issues with regard to contractual issues associated with BIM implementation. There has been a lack of focus on the expectations set out in engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) contracts with regard to envisaged BIM uses (dimensions), making BIM implementation superficial rather than purposive. This study identified BIM dimension-specific contract provisions (BDSCP) to address this gap. To accomplish this, a literature review was undertaken; this was followed by a qualitative inductive study involving 12 international experts from industry and academia to identify BDSCPs. The resulting 28 BDSCPs highlight focus areas with regard to drafting contracts and will assist stakeholders in realizing the benefits of BIM implementation.
- 1 February 2022
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 14 (1) , 04521040
Identification of BIM Dimension-Specific Contract Clauses in EPC Turnkey Projects
Construction operations are becoming increasingly complex, necessitating a greater need for collaboration. Building information modeling (BIM) aids enhanced project visualization and collaboration. The extant literature has mainly focused on model ownership, intellectual property, and data security issues with regard to contractual issues associated with BIM implementation. There has been a lack of focus on the expectations set out in engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) contracts with regard to envisaged BIM uses (dimensions), making BIM implementation superficial rather than purposive. This study identified BIM dimension-specific contract provisions (BDSCP) to address this gap. To accomplish this, a literature review was undertaken; this was followed by a qualitative inductive study involving 12 international experts from industry and academia to identify BDSCPs. The resulting 28 BDSCPs highlight focus areas with regard to drafting contracts and will assist stakeholders in realizing the benefits of BIM implementation.
- 1 November 2021
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 13 (4) , 04521035
Application of Natural Language Processing to Automatically Identify Exculpatory Clauses in Construction Contracts
Construction projects, by their very nature, are capital-intensive and risk-prone. Risk allocation and its management are therefore, integral parts of construction operations. A reasonably drafted contract allocates risk to the party that is best capable of handling it. Imbalance in risk allocation, however, is a common contract feature. By including exculpatory clauses, risks are often transferred without assessing a party’s ability to handle them. This bias in risk allocation promotes an adversarial relationship. Therefore, it is essential to identify such clauses before signing a contract. While it is possible to identify them by reading the bid documents, the manual process is time-consuming and often not pursued considering the lack of time in the bidding stage. Automation of such tasks can therefore aid a manager’s decision making. However, it requires tools that can quickly and reliably identify and extract exculpatory clauses. This study developed a natural language processing (NLP) model as a proof of concept to identify exculpatory clauses automatically. The developed model demonstrates that NLP is a potentially useful tool, aiding decision makers in refining their negotiation strategies before signing a contract.
- 1 November 2021
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 13 (4) , 04521035
Application of Natural Language Processing to Automatically Identify Exculpatory Clauses in Construction Contracts
Construction projects, by their very nature, are capital-intensive and risk-prone. Risk allocation and its management are therefore, integral parts of construction operations. A reasonably drafted contract allocates risk to the party that is best capable of handling it. Imbalance in risk allocation, however, is a common contract feature. By including exculpatory clauses, risks are often transferred without assessing a party’s ability to handle them. This bias in risk allocation promotes an adversarial relationship. Therefore, it is essential to identify such clauses before signing a contract. While it is possible to identify them by reading the bid documents, the manual process is time-consuming and often not pursued considering the lack of time in the bidding stage. Automation of such tasks can therefore aid a manager’s decision making. However, it requires tools that can quickly and reliably identify and extract exculpatory clauses. This study developed a natural language processing (NLP) model as a proof of concept to identify exculpatory clauses automatically. The developed model demonstrates that NLP is a potentially useful tool, aiding decision makers in refining their negotiation strategies before signing a contract.
- 1 August 2021
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 13 (3) , 04521018
Litigation Risk Transfer Mechanisms in Construction Dispute Resolution Process: Cross-Case Analysis
Disputes in construction projects are a common phenomenon around the world. The practice of approaching courts to resolve disputes, a risk-seeking behavior of parties in a dispute, is influenced by several factors. The availability of litigation risk transfer instruments like litigation insurance (LI) and third-party litigation funding (TPLF) can potentially change the litigious behavior of disputants. LI and TPLF markets have evolved differently in various jurisdictions around the world. The variation in the maturity levels provides a research opportunity to distill and document the learnings pertaining to the growth LI and TPLF in matured regimes and apply them in nascent markets. In this research, the authors consider the German (matured market for LI and TPLF) and Indian (nascent market) jurisdictions to identify potential focus areas influencing the growth of litigation risk transfer instruments. With reference to TPLF, this study concludes that while the legal framework is no doubt important in creating a favorable climate for adoption, its growth is influenced by agreement-level factors.
- 1 August 2021
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 13 (3) , 04521018
Litigation Risk Transfer Mechanisms in Construction Dispute Resolution Process: Cross-Case Analysis
Disputes in construction projects are a common phenomenon around the world. The practice of approaching courts to resolve disputes, a risk-seeking behavior of parties in a dispute, is influenced by several factors. The availability of litigation risk transfer instruments like litigation insurance (LI) and third-party litigation funding (TPLF) can potentially change the litigious behavior of disputants. LI and TPLF markets have evolved differently in various jurisdictions around the world. The variation in the maturity levels provides a research opportunity to distill and document the learnings pertaining to the growth LI and TPLF in matured regimes and apply them in nascent markets. In this research, the authors consider the German (matured market for LI and TPLF) and Indian (nascent market) jurisdictions to identify potential focus areas influencing the growth of litigation risk transfer instruments. With reference to TPLF, this study concludes that while the legal framework is no doubt important in creating a favorable climate for adoption, its growth is influenced by agreement-level factors.