Torben Koenigk
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Torben Koenigk has a total of 615 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Klaus Wyser
Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute, Norrköping, Sweden
41 shared publications - Mehdi Pasha Karami
Department of Research and Development, Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute, Norrköping, Sweden
33 shared publications - Ramon Fuentes-Franco
Rossby Centre, Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute (SMHI), Norrköping, Sweden
29 shared publications - Shuting Yang
Danish Meteorological Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark
22 shared publications - Victor Brovkin
Max Planck Institute for Meteorology, Hamburg, Germany
22 shared publications - Tim Kruschke
Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH), Hamburg, Germany
20 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Earth & Environment
Rapid ice loss events in a warming Arctic
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Earth & Environment
Rapid ice loss events in a warming Arctic
- Open Access
- 23 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-24
TIPMIP-OCEAN experimental protocol phase 2: Southern Ocean and Combined Dual-Hemispheric Freshwater Forcing
This paper describes the experiment protocol for coordinated simulations of Southern Ocean and combined dual-hemispheric (Southern Ocean and North Atlantic) ice sheet meltwater flux perturbations. These simulations form the second phase of the TIPMIP-OCEAN domain as part of the international Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP). We propose that the experiments are included in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 7 (CMIP7), although any emission-driven Earth System Models can implement the protocol. The experimental design complements the first phase of the TIPMIP-OCEAN domain experiments which address the response of the North Atlantic to various amounts of Greenland Ice Sheet meltwater at different levels of global warming. Here we propose a similar protocol exploring the impact of freshwater fluxes from the Antarctic Ice Sheet into the Southern Ocean. Further, the impact of freshening in both hemispheres is examined, through simultaneous freshwater release around Greenland and off the coast of Antarctica. Together with the North Atlantic hosing simulations, our proposed experiments will assess the combined impact of freshening in both hemispheres on the stability of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and Southern Ocean Abyssal Circulation (SOAC), and their associated potential tipping mechanisms and impacts on the Earth system.
- 23 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-24
Open AccessTIPMIP-OCEAN experimental protocol phase 2: Southern Ocean and Combined Dual-Hemispheric Freshwater Forcing
This paper describes the experiment protocol for coordinated simulations of Southern Ocean and combined dual-hemispheric (Southern Ocean and North Atlantic) ice sheet meltwater flux perturbations. These simulations form the second phase of the TIPMIP-OCEAN domain as part of the international Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP). We propose that the experiments are included in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 7 (CMIP7), although any emission-driven Earth System Models can implement the protocol. The experimental design complements the first phase of the TIPMIP-OCEAN domain experiments which address the response of the North Atlantic to various amounts of Greenland Ice Sheet meltwater at different levels of global warming. Here we propose a similar protocol exploring the impact of freshwater fluxes from the Antarctic Ice Sheet into the Southern Ocean. Further, the impact of freshening in both hemispheres is examined, through simultaneous freshwater release around Greenland and off the coast of Antarctica. Together with the North Atlantic hosing simulations, our proposed experiments will assess the combined impact of freshening in both hemispheres on the stability of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and Southern Ocean Abyssal Circulation (SOAC), and their associated potential tipping mechanisms and impacts on the Earth system.
- Open Access
- 16 October 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (42)
Reversible Atlantic overturning despite continued Greenland ice sheet melt
The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) is considered vulnerable to irreversible weakening or collapse under global warming and related Greenland ice sheet (GrIS) melt, yet its resilience to either forcing remains poorly constrained. Here, we use a carbon dioxide emission–driven Earth system model with an interactive GrIS to assess AMOC reversibility under a range of idealized carbon dioxide emission pathways that produce near-linear global warming up to 10 kelvins (K), stabilization across 1.5 to 9 K, and subsequent cooling. We find that although the AMOC reaches threshold-defined collapsed states, these do not represent dynamical tipping in this model: The overturning weakens quasi-linearly with global mean temperature increase yet consistently and promptly recovers under cooling. In contrast, GrIS mass loss accelerates with warming, continues through stabilizations, and is only slowed by cooling, committing the planet to long-term sea level rise. These results reveal contrasting resilience across climate system components: Under transient carbon dioxide forcing, AMOC strength remains dynamically reversible despite continued Greenland meltwater input, whereas the GrIS is locked into persistent decline. Our findings underscore the urgency of rapid emission cuts to limit climate overshoot, AMOC weakening, and irreversible ice sheet loss.
- 16 October 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (42)
Open AccessReversible Atlantic overturning despite continued Greenland ice sheet melt
The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) is considered vulnerable to irreversible weakening or collapse under global warming and related Greenland ice sheet (GrIS) melt, yet its resilience to either forcing remains poorly constrained. Here, we use a carbon dioxide emission–driven Earth system model with an interactive GrIS to assess AMOC reversibility under a range of idealized carbon dioxide emission pathways that produce near-linear global warming up to 10 kelvins (K), stabilization across 1.5 to 9 K, and subsequent cooling. We find that although the AMOC reaches threshold-defined collapsed states, these do not represent dynamical tipping in this model: The overturning weakens quasi-linearly with global mean temperature increase yet consistently and promptly recovers under cooling. In contrast, GrIS mass loss accelerates with warming, continues through stabilizations, and is only slowed by cooling, committing the planet to long-term sea level rise. These results reveal contrasting resilience across climate system components: Under transient carbon dioxide forcing, AMOC strength remains dynamically reversible despite continued Greenland meltwater input, whereas the GrIS is locked into persistent decline. Our findings underscore the urgency of rapid emission cuts to limit climate overshoot, AMOC weakening, and irreversible ice sheet loss.
- Open Access
- 13 September 2026
- Published by Wiley
High-impact climate events and tipping dynamics: assessing scientific understanding and future challenges
This paper is motivated by growing concern about tipping dynamics and processes that can cause abrupt, self-amplifying, and irreversible changes across the Earth system and societies. It assesses current scientific understanding of the most severe climate outcomes, and proposes ways to address the deep uncertainty surrounding them. We find substantial, though difficult-to-quantify, probabilities of major disruptions to large-scale ocean circulation, including the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation and the Southern Ocean Abyssal Circulation, with the potential to cause global climate shifts. The probability of ice sheet instability in vulnerable sectors, particularly Antarctica's marine-based sectors, is already high and could accelerate sea level rise over centennial to multi-centennial timescales. Permafrost thaw is underway, with the potential for accelerated greenhouse gas release. Tropical forests face increasing risks of widespread tree mortality, with major consequences for biodiversity, regional climate, and water availability. Coral reef dieback and mountain glacier loss are also underway, while severe compound marine events may trigger irreversible ecosystem changes. Even gradual climate change can produce nonlinear, abrupt impacts when hazards breach physiological or socioecological thresholds, disrupting health, food, or economic systems. It is essential to determine how the probability of such outcomes depends on the level and rate of warming. Current modelling systems challenge our ability to reliably quantify these risks. Sustained investment in observations, process understanding and next-generation earth system modelling is critical to identify precursors and improve early warning. Decision frameworks are needed to support proactive, flexible, anticipatory adaptation. Effective mitigation reduces risks of these highly disruptive outcomes.
- 13 September 2026
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessHigh-impact climate events and tipping dynamics: assessing scientific understanding and future challenges
This paper is motivated by growing concern about tipping dynamics and processes that can cause abrupt, self-amplifying, and irreversible changes across the Earth system and societies. It assesses current scientific understanding of the most severe climate outcomes, and proposes ways to address the deep uncertainty surrounding them. We find substantial, though difficult-to-quantify, probabilities of major disruptions to large-scale ocean circulation, including the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation and the Southern Ocean Abyssal Circulation, with the potential to cause global climate shifts. The probability of ice sheet instability in vulnerable sectors, particularly Antarctica's marine-based sectors, is already high and could accelerate sea level rise over centennial to multi-centennial timescales. Permafrost thaw is underway, with the potential for accelerated greenhouse gas release. Tropical forests face increasing risks of widespread tree mortality, with major consequences for biodiversity, regional climate, and water availability. Coral reef dieback and mountain glacier loss are also underway, while severe compound marine events may trigger irreversible ecosystem changes. Even gradual climate change can produce nonlinear, abrupt impacts when hazards breach physiological or socioecological thresholds, disrupting health, food, or economic systems. It is essential to determine how the probability of such outcomes depends on the level and rate of warming. Current modelling systems challenge our ability to reliably quantify these risks. Sustained investment in observations, process understanding and next-generation earth system modelling is critical to identify precursors and improve early warning. Decision frameworks are needed to support proactive, flexible, anticipatory adaptation. Effective mitigation reduces risks of these highly disruptive outcomes.
- Open Access
- 25 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (4) , 1151-1176
Historical Climate and Future Projection in the North Atlantic and Arctic: Insights from EC-Earth3 High-Resolution Simulations
This study presents a new set of high-resolution global climate simulations conducted with the EC-Earth3 model, including a 350 year pre-industrial, followed by historical (1850–2014) and future (2015–2100, SSP2-4.5) simulations. The model features a horizontal resolution of ∼ 40 km in the atmosphere and 0.25° in the ocean. The high-resolution EC-Earth3 (EC-Earth3-HR) is compared to the standard-resolution version used in CMIP6 to assess the impact of increased resolution on the representation of key climate variables, focusing particularly on the Arctic and North Atlantic regions. The high-resolution model aligns more closely with reanalysis data, particularly for global mean surface temperature and sea surface temperature. Both model resolutions exhibit similar biases in North Atlantic sea surface temperature and salinity, and in Arctic sea ice concentration, although the higher-resolution version shows regional improvements. The EC-Earth3-HR model captures the observed AMOC variability in the early 2000s, along with the trend and rapid loss event in Arctic sea ice. For future projection under SSP2-4.5, the high-resolution model projects a nearly ice-free Arctic by 2040 – earlier than the standard-resolution model – while simulating less Arctic warming and a more pronounced weakening of the AMOC. We also introduce a framework to diagnose deep-water formation (DWF) in the Labrador, Irminger, and Greenland Seas and to quantify their regional contributions to the AMOC. Applying this framework, we find that projected DWF weakens across all regions, with the largest reduction in the Labrador Sea, making it the dominant contributor to long-term AMOC weakening. By 2100, diagnosed DWF ceases in the Labrador Sea, compared with declines of 62 % in the Greenland Sea and 13 % in the Irminger Sea.
- 25 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (4) , 1151-1176
Open AccessHistorical Climate and Future Projection in the North Atlantic and Arctic: Insights from EC-Earth3 High-Resolution Simulations
This study presents a new set of high-resolution global climate simulations conducted with the EC-Earth3 model, including a 350 year pre-industrial, followed by historical (1850–2014) and future (2015–2100, SSP2-4.5) simulations. The model features a horizontal resolution of ∼ 40 km in the atmosphere and 0.25° in the ocean. The high-resolution EC-Earth3 (EC-Earth3-HR) is compared to the standard-resolution version used in CMIP6 to assess the impact of increased resolution on the representation of key climate variables, focusing particularly on the Arctic and North Atlantic regions. The high-resolution model aligns more closely with reanalysis data, particularly for global mean surface temperature and sea surface temperature. Both model resolutions exhibit similar biases in North Atlantic sea surface temperature and salinity, and in Arctic sea ice concentration, although the higher-resolution version shows regional improvements. The EC-Earth3-HR model captures the observed AMOC variability in the early 2000s, along with the trend and rapid loss event in Arctic sea ice. For future projection under SSP2-4.5, the high-resolution model projects a nearly ice-free Arctic by 2040 – earlier than the standard-resolution model – while simulating less Arctic warming and a more pronounced weakening of the AMOC. We also introduce a framework to diagnose deep-water formation (DWF) in the Labrador, Irminger, and Greenland Seas and to quantify their regional contributions to the AMOC. Applying this framework, we find that projected DWF weakens across all regions, with the largest reduction in the Labrador Sea, making it the dominant contributor to long-term AMOC weakening. By 2100, diagnosed DWF ceases in the Labrador Sea, compared with declines of 62 % in the Greenland Sea and 13 % in the Irminger Sea.
- Open Access
- 4 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Comment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- 4 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- Open Access
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (14) , 6941-6966
The TIPMIP Earth system model experiment protocol: phase 1
We describe a new Earth system model (ESM) experiment protocol, as part of the international Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP) project. We propose this as a protocol for the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project 7 (CMIP7). The protocol requires ESMs to run in CO 2 -emission mode, with atmospheric CO 2 a predicted variable. Forcing for the protocol consists solely of a constant emission of CO 2 , based on each model's transient climate response to cumulative emissions of carbon dioxide (TCRE) value, to give a common global mean surface warming rate of 2 °C per century. This positive emission (ramp-up) experiment is started from the pre-industrial state of a given model. When the ramp-up run first exceeds a specified level of global warming (2 and 4 °C) relative to the model's pre-industrial global mean surface air temperature (GMSAT), CO 2 emissions are set to zero and the positive emission run is branched into a zero-emission run. The zero-emission runs continue for 300 years. 50 years into each zero-emission run, CO 2 emissions are set to the negative of the positive emission rate and the model run until GMSAT cools below the original pre-industrial value. Additionally, when the negative emission run started from the global warming level (GWL)=4 °C first drops below GWL=2 °C, a zero-emission run is branched off this, completing the set of experiments. Using this protocol, we are able to control the rate of global warming, and potentially also the rate of cooling, across participating models. TIPMIP experiments will support a range of analyses, including; an assessment of abrupt/rapid Earth system change under net zero CO 2 emissions at a range of global warming levels, the long-term Earth system response to net zero CO 2 emissions at these warming levels, the response to net negative CO 2 emissions and the efficacy of negative emissions to drive cooling, and the reversibility of Earth system change under a pathway of positive (warming), zero, and negative (cooling) CO 2 emissions.
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (14) , 6941-6966
Open AccessThe TIPMIP Earth system model experiment protocol: phase 1
We describe a new Earth system model (ESM) experiment protocol, as part of the international Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP) project. We propose this as a protocol for the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project 7 (CMIP7). The protocol requires ESMs to run in CO 2 -emission mode, with atmospheric CO 2 a predicted variable. Forcing for the protocol consists solely of a constant emission of CO 2 , based on each model's transient climate response to cumulative emissions of carbon dioxide (TCRE) value, to give a common global mean surface warming rate of 2 °C per century. This positive emission (ramp-up) experiment is started from the pre-industrial state of a given model. When the ramp-up run first exceeds a specified level of global warming (2 and 4 °C) relative to the model's pre-industrial global mean surface air temperature (GMSAT), CO 2 emissions are set to zero and the positive emission run is branched into a zero-emission run. The zero-emission runs continue for 300 years. 50 years into each zero-emission run, CO 2 emissions are set to the negative of the positive emission rate and the model run until GMSAT cools below the original pre-industrial value. Additionally, when the negative emission run started from the global warming level (GWL)=4 °C first drops below GWL=2 °C, a zero-emission run is branched off this, completing the set of experiments. Using this protocol, we are able to control the rate of global warming, and potentially also the rate of cooling, across participating models. TIPMIP experiments will support a range of analyses, including; an assessment of abrupt/rapid Earth system change under net zero CO 2 emissions at a range of global warming levels, the long-term Earth system response to net zero CO 2 emissions at these warming levels, the response to net negative CO 2 emissions and the efficacy of negative emissions to drive cooling, and the reversibility of Earth system change under a pathway of positive (warming), zero, and negative (cooling) CO 2 emissions.
- Open Access
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Comment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- Open Access
- 27 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Comment on egusphere-2026-1698
This paper describes the experimental protocol for a set of coordinated simulations involving oceanic surface freshwater flux perturbations, conducted as part of the international Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP). These simulations constitute the first phase of the TIPMIP-OCEAN domain. We propose this protocol for inclusion in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 7 (CMIP7), although it can also be implemented within CMIP6+ or other types of coupled or ocean standalone models. This initial phase focuses primarily on the dynamics of the North Atlantic Ocean, particularly the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). The different experiments are designed to (i) evaluate the impacts of a potential major AMOC weakening under a 2 °C global warming scenario, (ii) assess the sensitivity of the AMOC to combined global warming and freshwater forcing, (iii) investigate the potential recovery of the AMOC following the reversal of forcings, and (iv) compare past AMOC variations with available climate observations and reconstructions. Four categories of experiments are included. Experiment group A examines the effect of freshwater release around Greenland under ramp-up, stabilization, and ramp-down scenarios in both CO2 emissions and freshwater input. Experiment group B complements this idealized set by using historical climate simulations and projections for 1850–2100, incorporating realistic estimates of Greenland Ice Sheet melt based on observations for the historical period and ice-sheet model projections for the future. Experiment group C extends the existing North Atlantic Hosing Model Intercomparison Project (NAHosMIP) by applying large freshwater perturbations to both control and 2 °C-warming simulations to assess how global warming influences AMOC reversibility. Finally, experiment group D imposes freshwater inputs, consistent with those inferred for the 8.2 kyr before present event, under pre-industrial conditions, in order to constrain model sensitivity to freshwater forcing using paleoclimate reconstructions. Together, these coordinated experiments will allow systematic evaluation of how different climate models respond to identical freshwater perturbations—an essential step toward better understanding the wide inter-model spread in North Atlantic dynamics and projected future AMOC changes.
- 27 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-1698
This paper describes the experimental protocol for a set of coordinated simulations involving oceanic surface freshwater flux perturbations, conducted as part of the international Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP). These simulations constitute the first phase of the TIPMIP-OCEAN domain. We propose this protocol for inclusion in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 7 (CMIP7), although it can also be implemented within CMIP6+ or other types of coupled or ocean standalone models. This initial phase focuses primarily on the dynamics of the North Atlantic Ocean, particularly the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). The different experiments are designed to (i) evaluate the impacts of a potential major AMOC weakening under a 2 °C global warming scenario, (ii) assess the sensitivity of the AMOC to combined global warming and freshwater forcing, (iii) investigate the potential recovery of the AMOC following the reversal of forcings, and (iv) compare past AMOC variations with available climate observations and reconstructions. Four categories of experiments are included. Experiment group A examines the effect of freshwater release around Greenland under ramp-up, stabilization, and ramp-down scenarios in both CO2 emissions and freshwater input. Experiment group B complements this idealized set by using historical climate simulations and projections for 1850–2100, incorporating realistic estimates of Greenland Ice Sheet melt based on observations for the historical period and ice-sheet model projections for the future. Experiment group C extends the existing North Atlantic Hosing Model Intercomparison Project (NAHosMIP) by applying large freshwater perturbations to both control and 2 °C-warming simulations to assess how global warming influences AMOC reversibility. Finally, experiment group D imposes freshwater inputs, consistent with those inferred for the 8.2 kyr before present event, under pre-industrial conditions, in order to constrain model sensitivity to freshwater forcing using paleoclimate reconstructions. Together, these coordinated experiments will allow systematic evaluation of how different climate models respond to identical freshwater perturbations—an essential step toward better understanding the wide inter-model spread in North Atlantic dynamics and projected future AMOC changes.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Decomposition of the Zero Emissions Commitment into thermal warming pipeline and carbon buffering components
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Open AccessDecomposition of the Zero Emissions Commitment into thermal warming pipeline and carbon buffering components
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.