EOErik Otárola-Castillo

Erik Otárola-Castillo

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Erik Otárola-Castillo has a total of 130 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:

  • Melissa G. Torquato

    Department of Anthropology, Purdue University, West Lafayette, USA

    3 shared publications
  • Curtis W. Marean

    Institute of Human Origins and School of Human Evolution and Social Change, Arizona State University, Tempe, USA

    2 shared publications
  • Douglas J. McCauley

    Department of Ecology, Evolution and Marine Biology, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, USA

    2 shared publications
  • Eric R. Castillo

    Department of Human Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA

    2 shared publications
  • Hannah C. Hawkins

    2 shared publications
  • Jacob A. Harris

    Department of Anthropology, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, USA

    2 shared publications

Latest Publications

  • Integrated evidence‐based extent of occurrence for North American bison (Bison bison) since 1500 CE and before

    by Jeff M. Martin, Rachel A. Short, Glenn E. Plumb, Lauren Markewicz, Dirk H. Van Vuren, Bradly Wehus‐Tow, Erik Otárola‐Castillo, Matthew E. Hill

    Following the near extinction of bison (Bison bison) from its historic range across North America in the late 19th century, novel bison conservation efforts in the early 20th century catalyzed a popular widespread conservation movement to protect and restore bison among other species and places. Since Allen's initial delineation (1876) of the historic distribution of North American bison, subsequent attempts have been hampered by knowledge gaps about bison distribution and abundance prior to and following colonial arrival and settlement. For the first time, we applied a multidisciplinary approach to assemble a comprehensive, integrated geographic database and meta‐analysis of bison occurrence over the last 200,000 years, with particular emphasis on the 450 years before present. We combined paleontology, archaeology, and historical ecology data for our database, which totaled 6438 observations. We derived the observations from existing online databases, published literature, and first‐hand exploration journal entries. To illustrate the conservative maximum historical extent of occurrence of bison, we created a concave hull using observations occurring over the last 450 years (n = 3379 observations), which is the broadly accepted historical benchmark at 1500 CE covering 59% of the North American continent. Although this distribution represents a historic extent of occurrence—merely delineating the maximum margins of the near‐continental distribution—it does not replace a density‐based approach reconstructing potential historical range distributions, which identifies core and marginal ranges. However, we envision the observations contained in this database will contribute to further research in the increasingly evidence‐based disciplines of bison ecology, evolution, rewilding, management, and conservation. There are no copyright or proprietary restrictions on these data, and this data paper should be cited when the data are reused.


  • Open Access

    A New Approach to the Quantitative Analysis of Bone Surface Modifications: the Bowser Road Mastodon and Implications for the Data to Understand Human-Megafauna Interactions in North America

    by Erik R. Otárola-Castillo, Melissa G. Torquato, Trevor L. Keevil, Alejandra May, Sarah Coon, Evalyn J. Stow, John B. Rapes, Jacob A. Harris, Curtis W. Marean, Metin I. Eren, et al.

    Toward the end of the Pleistocene, the world experienced a mass extinction of megafauna. In North America these included its proboscideans—the mammoths and mastodons. Researchers in conservation biology, paleontology, and archaeology have debated the role played by human predation in these extinctions. They point to traces of human butchery, such as cut marks and other bone surface modifications (BSM), as evidence of human-animal interactions—including predation and scavenging, between early Americans and proboscideans. However, others have challenged the validity of the butchery evidence observed on several proboscidean assemblages, largely due to questions of qualitative determination of the agent responsible for creating BSM. This study employs a statistical technique that relies on three-dimensional (3D) imaging data and 3D geometric morphometrics to determine the origin of the BSM observed on the skeletal remains of the Bowser Road mastodon (BR mastodon), excavated in Middletown, New York. These techniques have been shown to have high accuracy in identifying and distinguishing among different types of BSM. To better characterize the BSM on the BR mastodon, we compared them quantitatively to experimental BSM resulting from a stone tool chopping experiment using “Arnold,” the force-calibrated chopper. This study suggests that BSM on the BR mastodon are not consistent with the BSM generated by the experimental chopper. Future controlled experiments will compare other types of BSM to those on BR. This research contributes to continued efforts to decrease the uncertainty surrounding human-megafauna associations at the level of the archaeological site and faunal assemblage—specifically that of the BR mastodon assemblage. Consequently, we also contribute to the dialogue surrounding the character of the human-animal interactions between early Americans and Late Pleistocene megafauna, and the role of human foraging behavior in the latter’s extinction.


  • Top Cited Papers

    Does the evidence at Arroyo del Vizcaíno (Uruguay) support the claim of human occupation 30,000 years ago?

    by Justin A. Holcomb, Rolfe D. Mandel, Erik Otárola-Castillo, Kurt Rademaker, Richard L. Rosencrance, Katelyn N. McDonough, D. Shane Miller, Brian T. Wygal


  • Open Access

    Beyond Chronology, Using Bayesian Inference to Evaluate Hypotheses in Archaeology

    by Erik R. Otárola-Castillo, Melissa G. Torquato, Jesse Wolfhagen, Matthew E. Hill, Caitlin E. Buck

    Archaeologists frequently use probability distributions and null hypothesis significance testing (NHST) to assess how well survey, excavation, or experimental data align with their hypotheses about the past. Bayesian inference is increasingly used as an alternative to NHST and, in archaeology, is most commonly applied to radiocarbon date estimation and chronology building. This article demonstrates that Bayesian statistics has broader applications. It begins by contrasting NHST and Bayesian statistical frameworks, before introducing and applying Bayes's theorem. In order to guide the reader through an elementary step-by-step Bayesian analysis, this article uses a fictional archaeological faunal assemblage from a single site. The fictional example is then expanded to demonstrate how Bayesian analyses can be applied to data with a range of properties, formally incorporating expert prior knowledge into the hypothesis evaluation process.


  • Open Access

    The Bayesian Inferential Paradigm in Archaeology

    by Erik Otarola-Castillo, Meissa G Torquato, Caitlin Elisabeth Buck

    Archaeologists often use data and quantitative statistical methods to evaluate their ideas. Although there are various statistical frameworks for decision-making in archaeology and science in general, in this chapter, we provide a simple explanation of Bayesian statistics. To contextualize the Bayesian statistical framework, we briefly compare it to the more widespread null hypothesis significance testing (NHST) approach. We also provide a simple example to illustrate how archaeologists use data and the Bayesian framework to compare hypotheses and evaluate their uncertainty. We then review how archaeologists have applied Bayesian statistics to solve research problems related to radiocarbon dating and chronology, lithic, ceramic, zooarchaeological, bioarchaeological, and spatial analyses. Because recent work has reviewed Bayesian applications in archaeology from the 1990s up to 2017, this work considers the relevant literature published since 2017.

  • Parts and Wholes: Reduction Allometry and Modularity in Experimental Folsom Points

    by Michael J. Shott, Erik Otárola-Castillo

    Projectile points are a common subject of archaeological study. In the past decade, landmark-based geometric morphometrics (LGM) has increasingly been used to analyze points as whole objects. LGM and other studies document allometric changes in points—change in shape with change in size—as a product of resharpening. Allometry registers in part because different segments or modules of points are subject to different degrees of resharpening, with blades often experiencing more reduction than stems. Different modules retain varying degrees of morphological integrity as points move through their use lives. Most previous LGM studies involved two-dimensional point models, and few tested directly for modularity. We apply LGM methods to three-dimensional models of Folsom point replicas whose degree and pattern of reduction are known, finding evidence for both allometry and modularity, with modest integration. Complementary non-LGM data reveal similar results, indicating a robust pattern and ways to approximate LGM results in other data. Moreover, our dataset's experimental control clearly identifies the results as a function of the progressive reduction in use experienced by points. Cabezales líticos son sujetos populares en análises arqueológicos. Recientemente, la geometría morfométrica basada en hitos (LGM en inglés) se ve aumentanda en el análisis de cabezales como objetos enteros. La LGM y otros estudios documentan cambios alométricos —cambio de forma con cambio en tamaño— entre los cabezales como producto de la reactivación. En parte, se registre la alometría porque segmentos distintos, es decir módulos, de los cabezales se sujetan a grados diferentes de la reactivación, los limbos a menudo soportando mas reducción que las pedúnculas. Módulos distintos conservan grados diferentes de la integridad morfológica como pasan los cabezales a lo largo de sus vidas útiles. La mayoría de estudios anteriores de la LGM involucran modelos 2-dimensionales de los cabezales, y pocos investigaron directamente la modularidad. Aplicamos métodos de la LGM a modelos 3-dimensionales de réplicas cabezales del tipo Folsom, entre quienes se conocen grado y patrón de la reactivación. Encontramos prueba de ambas de la alometría y la modularidad, con integración intermedia. Medidas complementarias no-LGM revelan resultados semejantes, indicando un patrón bien fuerte, y tambien maneras a aproximar los datos y resultados de la LGM en otros fuentes o tipos de datos. Más bien, los controles experimentales que residen en nuestros datos identifiquen claramente los resultados como función de la reducción en uso secuencial a que los cabezales se sujetaron.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Early human impacts and ecosystem reorganization in southern-central Africa

    by Jessica C. Thompson, David K. Wright, Sarah J. Ivory, Jeong-Heon Choi, Sheila Nightingale, Alex Mackay, Flora Schilt, Erik Otárola-Castillo, Julio Mercader, Steven L. Forman, et al.

    Modern Homo sapiens engage in substantial ecosystem modification, but it is difficult to detect the origins or early consequences of these behaviors. Archaeological, geochronological, geomorphological, and paleoenvironmental data from northern Malawi document a changing relationship between forager presence, ecosystem organization, and alluvial fan formation in the Late Pleistocene. Dense concentrations of Middle Stone Age artifacts and alluvial fan systems formed after ca. 92 thousand years ago, within a paleoecological context with no analog in the preceding half-million-year record. Archaeological data and principal coordinates analysis indicate that early anthropogenic fire relaxed seasonal constraints on ignitions, influencing vegetation composition and erosion. This operated in tandem with climate-driven changes in precipitation to culminate in an ecological transition to an early, pre-agricultural anthropogenic landscape.


  • Open Access

    Intensification Mechanisms Driving Dietary Change among the Great Plains Big Game Hunters of North America

    by Erik Otarola-Castillo, Meissa G Torquato, Matthew E Hill

    Boresup's Theory of subsistence intensification is that as human populations grow, they give up "efficient" food-producing behaviors to increase the total food yield over a given unit of time or space. Anthropologists have vigorously debated this concept during the latter part of the twentieth century. They have proposed that dietary specialization and dietary diversification are two mechanisms responsible for subsistence intensification trends over time. On the North American Great Plains, archaeologists attribute the observed record of human dietary variation of at least 13,000 years, partially to the effects of human agency, temporal and regional variability in environmental conditions, and human and prey population dynamics. Despite this variation, an apparent big-game hunting specialization persisted in this region alongside more diversified strategies, until much later than in adjacent areas. This interpretation of specialized bison hunting proposed by early archaeologists likely fueled two widespread hypotheses: A) that prehistoric Great Plains indigenous people's lives were highly contingent on the vast herds of bison that roamed the region, and B) that through time, a simplified progression of subsistence intensification took place. This progression begins with highly specialized big-game hunters during the Paleoindian period (13,500–9,000 BP) and culminates with a much more diversified economy during the Late Prehistoric period (1000–300 BP) that included foraged and domesticated resources. However, these inferences remain unevaluated across the Great Plains' vast geographic range and its complete cultural chronology. To assess them, we employ a large dataset of dietary remains and investigate the broad patterns of dietary specialization and diversification used by Great Plains indigenous people over the past 13,500 years. Our analyses led to a twofold conclusion: 1) we find that even though prehistoric indigenous people of the Great Plains maintained a way of life associated with bison over time, bison was not the dominant hunted species in their diet; and 2) the hunting strategies and dietary variation that we observed on the Great Plains, through time, does not support a model of progressive resource intensification from hunting and gathering to farming. Instead, the data support a model of constant diversification of hunting strategies from the Paleoindian through the Late Prehistoric periods. In this model, hunters on the Plains (and elsewhere) maintained a consistently high resource diversity. We propose that this highly flexible and diversified portfolio of dietary strategies enabled the Great Plains people to successfully adapt their approaches to procuring food across different habitats and periods.

  • Open Access

    Differentiating between cutting actions on bone using 3D geometric morphometrics and Bayesian analyses with implications to human evolution

    by Erik Otárola-Castillo, Melissa G. Torquato, Hannah C. Hawkins, Emma James, Jacob A. Harris, Curtis W. Marean, Shannon P. McPherron, Jessica C. Thompson


  • Open Access

    Interacting effects of land use and climate on rodent-borne pathogens in central Kenya

    by Hillary S. Young, Douglas J. McCauley, Rodolfo Dirzo, Charles L. Nunn, Michael G. Campana, Bernard Agwanda, Erik R. Otarola-Castillo, Eric R. Castillo, Robert M. Pringle, Kari E. Veblen, et al.

    Understanding the effects of anthropogenic disturbance on zoonotic disease risk is both a critical conservation objective and a public health priority. Here, we evaluate the effects of multiple forms of anthropogenic disturbance across a precipitation gradient on the abundance of pathogen-infected small mammal hosts in a multi-host, multi-pathogen system in central Kenya. Our results suggest that conversion to cropland and wildlife loss alone drive systematic increases in rodent-borne pathogen prevalence, but that pastoral conversion has no such systematic effects. The effects are most likely explained both by changes in total small mammal abundance, and by changes in relative abundance of a few high-competence species, although changes in vector assemblages may also be involved. Several pathogens responded to interactions between disturbance type and climatic conditions, suggesting the potential for synergistic effects of anthropogenic disturbance and climate change on the distribution of disease risk. Overall, these results indicate that conservation can be an effective tool for reducing abundance of rodent-borne pathogens in some contexts (e.g. wildlife loss alone); however, given the strong variation in effects across disturbance types, pathogen taxa and environmental conditions, the use of conservation as public health interventions will need to be carefully tailored to specific pathogens and human contexts. This article is part of the themed issue ‘Conservation, biodiversity and infectious disease: scientific evidence and policy implications’.