RSRobert S. Schick

Robert S. Schick

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Robert S. Schick has a total of 98 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Foraging behavior of Critically Endangered North Atlantic right whales is associated with ambient noise, prey density, and the acoustic behavior of conspecifics

    by Robert S Schick, Tina M Yack, Enrico Pirotta, Charles A Mayo, Christopher W Clark, Christine A Hudak, Ryan B Schosberg, Alyvia Martinez, Madeleine D Paris, Nicholas A Kaney, et al.

    The endangered North Atlantic right whale (NARW) faces threats from lethal and sublethal stressors. Prey limitation has been linked to reduced growth and fecundity, while anthropogenic noise has been associated with acoustic behavior changes and increased physiological stress. We combined disparate data sets collected in Cape Cod Bay, Massachusetts, USA, across multiple years, quantifying links between prey, calling behavior, noise, and foraging behavior to answer 3 questions: (1) What are the characteristics of noise and prey density in the patches where NARW forage? Are prey density, call rate, and noise related to (2) the probability of being in a foraging state and (3) the size of the foraging group? We found links between predicted prey density and 2 measures of NARW foraging: probability of being in a foraging state and foraging group size. There were also significant non-linear relationships between lagged calling behavior and these same measures. For group size, an interaction term between calling behavior and prey density suggested a complex interrelationship between these variables. When more ambient noise was measured near a patch in the 4 h prior to a sighting of foraging whales, whales foraged in lower-quality zooplankton patches. Elevated noise ahead of aggregated sightings was also associated with a smaller group size. This is consistent with the hypothesis that increased ambient noise disturbs foraging and/or reduces communication space, limiting the ability of NARWs to fully exploit their environment. Our findings suggest pathways for future experiments to explicitly test the mechanisms underpinning foraging processes in endangered NARW.

  • Open Access

    From signal to location: using goniometer-derived Argos UHF power to enhance movement data for cryptic whales

    by Anna Borroni, Robert S. Schick, Alberto D. Sechi, Aurélie Moulins, Francesca Grossi, Paola Tepsich, Massimiliano Rosso

  • Open Access

    The combined effects of multiple stressors in an endangered, long‐lived species: Lessons learned and ways forward

    by Enrico Pirotta, Peter L. Tyack, Jeffrey Adams, Michael J. Asaro, Phil J. Bouchet, Daniel E. Crocker, John W. Durban, Ailsa J. Hall, Catriona M. Harris, Amy R. Knowlton, et al.

    Exploring solutions to expanding industrial activities and climate change requires assessments of the combined effects of multiple stressors on wildlife populations. We present a spatially explicit state‐space model for the health, survival, reproduction, and somatic growth of individuals in a long‐lived, wide‐ranging species. The model is applied to critically endangered North Atlantic right whales ( Eubalaena glacialis ) to investigate the combined effects of three primary stressors affecting the species' viability: entanglements in fishing gear, vessel strikes, and prey availability. We estimate exposure to these stressors in space and time and assess how their effects may combine in the pathway from exposure to vital rates. Results suggest that changes in whale distribution after 2010 led to increased entanglement risk. Poorer prey conditions were associated with an increased effect of carrying fishing gear, but, overall, results on combined effects were not conclusive and depended on model formulation. We also incorporated the estimated effects of stressors into a population viability analysis to explore alternative scenarios of stressor reduction. This integrated analysis highlighted the importance of the declining trend in maximum body length and its effect on reproduction, in addition to the documented impact of entanglements on survival. Model development and application elucidated critical data needs and the influence of underlying mechanistic assumptions. Specifically, models for the combined effects of stressors hinge on the availability of extended longitudinal measurements of individual health and life history outcomes, extensive datasets on the spatiotemporal distribution of stressors, and information on individual space use affecting rates of exposure to stressors. Lessons from this data‐rich case study will support the generalization of the modeling approach to other long‐lived species where measuring the population‐level consequences of multiple stressors directly is unfeasible.


  • Joint spatiotemporal modelling of zooplankton and whale abundance in a dynamic marine environment

    by Bokgyeong Kang, Erin M Schliep, Alan E Gelfand, Christopher W Clark, Christine A Hudak, Charles A Mayo, Ryan Schosberg, Tina M Yack, Robert S Schick

    North Atlantic right whales are an endangered species. Their entire population is estimated to be approximately 372 individuals, and they are subject to major anthropogenic threats. They feed on zooplankton species whose distribution shifts in a dynamic and warming oceanic environment. Because right whales in turn follow their shifting food resource, it is necessary to jointly study the distribution of whales and their prey. The innovative joint species distribution modelling (JSDM) contribution here is different from anything in the large JDSM literature, reflecting the processes and data we have to work with. Specifically, our JSDM supplies a geostatistical model for the expected amount of zooplankton collected at a site. We require a point pattern model for the intensity of right whale abundance. The two process models are linked through a latent conditional-marginal specification. Furthermore, each species has two data sources informing its respective distribution, necessitating a novel data fusion approach. The result is a complex multi-level model. Through simulation, we demonstrate that our joint specification effectively identifies model unknowns and improves the estimation of species distributions compared to modelling them separately. We then apply our model to real data from Cape Cod Bay, Massachusetts, USA.


  • Estimating received level in behavioral response studies through the use of ancillary data

    by Robert S. Schick, William R. Cioffi, Heather J. Foley, John Joseph, Nicholas A. Kaney, Tetyana Margolina, Zachary T. Swaim, Larry Zheng, Brandon L. Southall

    Marine mammals are known to respond to various human noises, including and in certain cases, strongly, to military active sonar. Responses include small and short-term changes in diving behavior, horizontal avoidance of an ensonified area, and mass strandings. Considerable research has been conducted using short-term biologging tags to understand these responses. Yet researchers and managers want a better understanding of responses to sound over longer periods of time in a variety of contexts. The Atlantic Behavioral Response Study examines responses across multiple spatial and temporal scales using vessel-based focal follows, short-term biologging tags, and medium-term satellite transmitting tags. Since the latter do not record sound, we must intersect positions with a sound propagation model to estimate received sound pressure levels. We use all available information from (1) the observed x,y positions from the tag(s) and from focal follow vessels; (2) the discrete depth bin data (z) from the tag; (3) ocean bathymetry; and (4) outputs from sound propagation models. All these disparate streams of data contain varying levels of error in x, y, or z. We account for as much uncertainty as possible and include here a refined approach to better estimate the range of sound levels received by animals.


  • Open Access

    Decreasing body size is associated with reduced calving probability in critically endangered North Atlantic right whales

    by Enrico Pirotta, Peter L. Tyack, John W. Durban, Holly Fearnbach, Philip K. Hamilton, Catriona M. Harris, Amy R. Knowlton, Scott D. Kraus, Carolyn A. Miller, Michael J. Moore, et al.

    Body size is key to many life-history processes, including reproduction. Across species, climate change and other stressors have caused reductions in the body size to which animals can grow, called asymptotic size, with consequences for demography. A reduction in mean asymptotic length was documented for critically endangered North Atlantic right whales, in parallel with declines in health and vital rates resulting from human activities and environmental changes. Here, we tested whether smaller body size was associated with lower reproductive output, using a state-space model for individual health, survival and reproduction that quantifies the mechanistic links between these processes. Body size (as represented by the cube of length) was strongly associated with a female's calving probability at each reproductive opportunity. This relationship explained 62% of the variation in calving among reproductive females, along with their decreasing health (20%). The effects of decreasing mean body size on reproductive performance are another concerning indication of the worsening prospects for this species and many others affected by environmental change, requiring a focus of conservation and management interventions on improving conditions that affect reproduction as well as reducing mortality.


  • Open Access

    Space-time multi-level modeling for zooplankton abundance employing double data fusion and calibration

    by Jorge Castillo-Mateo, Alan E. Gelfand, Christine A. Hudak, Charles A. Mayo, Robert S. Schick

    An important objective for marine biologists is to forecast the distribution and abundance of planktivorous marine predators. To do so, it is critically important to understand the spatiotemporal dynamics of their prey. Here, the prey we study are zooplankton and we build a novel space-time hierarchical fusion model to describe the distribution and abundance of zooplankton species in Cape Cod Bay (CCB), MA, USA. The data were collected irregularly in space and time at sites within the first half of the year over a 17 year period, using two different sampling methods. We focus on sea surface zooplankton abundance and incorporate sea surface temperature as a primary driver, also collected with two different sampling methods. So, with two sources for each, we observe true abundance or true sea surface temperature with measurement error. To account for such error, we apply calibrations to align the data sources and use the fusion model to develop a prediction of daily spatial zooplankton abundance surfaces throughout CCB. To infer average abundance on a given day within a given year in CCB, we present a marginalization of the zooplankton abundance surface. We extend the inference to consider abundance averaged to a bi-weekly or annual scale as well as to make an annual comparison of abundance.


  • Open Access

    Estimating the effects of stressors on the health, survival and reproduction of a critically endangered, long‐lived species

    by Enrico Pirotta, Robert S. Schick, Philip K. Hamilton, Catriona M. Harris, Joshua Hewitt, Amy R. Knowlton, Scott D. Kraus, Erin Meyer‐Gutbrod, Michael J. Moore, Heather M. Pettis, et al.

    Quantifying the cumulative effects of stressors on individuals and populations can inform the development of effective management and conservation strategies. We developed a Bayesian state–space model to assess the effects of multiple stressors on individual survival and reproduction. In the model, stressor effects on vital rates are mediated by changes in underlying health, allowing for the comparison of effect sizes while accounting for intrinsic factors that might affect an individual's vulnerability and resilience. We applied the model to a 50‐year dataset of sightings, calving events and stressor exposure of critically endangered North Atlantic right whales Eubalaena glacialis . The viability of this population is threatened by a complex set of stressors, including vessel strikes, entanglement in fishing gear and fluctuating prey availability. We estimated that blunt and deep vessel strike injuries and severe entanglement injuries had the largest effect on the health of exposed individuals, reinforcing the urgent need for mitigation measures. Prey abundance had a smaller but protracted effect on health across individuals, and estimated long‐term trends in survival and reproduction followed the trend of the prey index, highlighting that long‐term ecosystem‐based management strategies are also required. Our approach can be applied to quantify the effects of multiple stressors on any long‐lived species where suitable indicators of health and long‐term monitoring data are available.


  • Open Access

    Fishing gear entanglement threatens recovery of critically endangered North Atlantic right whales

    by Amy R. Knowlton, James S. Clark, Philip K. Hamilton, Scott D. Kraus, Heather M. Pettis, Rosalind M. Rolland, Robert S. Schick

    North Atlantic right whales frequently become entangled in fishing gear, which can negatively affect their reproductive output and probability of survival. We estimated individual whale health from a hierarchical Bayesian model fit to photographic indices of health. We reviewed 696 whales sighted from 1980 to 2011 and assigned 1196 entanglement events to 573 individuals in six categories of increasing injury severity and estimated monthly median health scores (0–100 scale) for the duration of their life within the study period. We then quantified the relationship between entanglement injury events and their severity with survival, reproduction, and population health. Severe entanglements resulted in worse health for all whales—males and females with severe injuries were eight times more likely to die than males with minor injuries. Females with severe injuries that survived had the lowest birth rates. Though the relationship between entanglement and fecundity was complex, we found that as the health of reproductively active females declined, their calving intervals increased. Unimpacted whale health scores declined significantly over three decades, 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s, suggesting food limitations may be contributing to population‐wide health declines. Decadal health scores of entangled whales showed a more notable reduction in health suggesting a clear and perhaps synergistic effect.


  • Open Access

    A fine-scale marine mammal movement model for assessing long-term aggregate noise exposure

    by Ruth Joy, Robert S. Schick, Michael Dowd, Tetyana Margolina, John E. Joseph, Len Thomas