Reed Bowman
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Reed Bowman has a total of 210 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nancy Chen
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of California , Los Angeles, California
9 shared publications - John W. Fitzpatrick
Archbold Biological Station Venus Florida USA
7 shared publications - Andrew G. Clark
Department of Molecular Biology and Genetics, Cornell University
5 shared publications John W. Fitzpatrick
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology Cornell University Ithaca NY USA
4 shared publications- Elissa J. Cosgrove
Department of Molecular Biology and Genetics, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, U.S.A.
3 shared publications Glen E. Woolfenden
Archbold Biological Station
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Sustained multigenerational fitness benefits of natural immigration
The fitness of immigrants and their descendants determines the effectiveness of gene flow. Genetic incompatibilities or outbreeding depression can limit the spread of novel alleles, while highly fit immigrant lineages can hasten introgression. These fitness effects of gene flow can also differ between generations as immigrant and resident haplotypes recombine. Understanding the genetic factors that shape immigrant fitness over multiple generations is increasingly important as habitat fragmentation threatens populations by reducing genetic variation and leading to increased levels of inbreeding. Few studies have measured the multigenerational fitness of immigrant lineages, especially within populations that had histories of high gene flow. We used 33 years of life history and pedigree data on a population of Florida scrub-jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens ) with historically high immigration to quantify the fitness of immigrants and their descendants. We compared the fitness of immigrants and residents as well as their resulting descendants (F1, F2, etc.) to determine the composite genetic effects responsible for fitness differences. We found evidence of additive benefits of immigrant ancestry and heterosis driven by non-additive effects that persists for multiple generations. These results are promising for conservation efforts aiming to increase connectivity and illustrate the complex dynamics that determine the rates of introgression in natural populations.
Open AccessSustained multigenerational fitness benefits of natural immigration
The fitness of immigrants and their descendants determines the effectiveness of gene flow. Genetic incompatibilities or outbreeding depression can limit the spread of novel alleles, while highly fit immigrant lineages can hasten introgression. These fitness effects of gene flow can also differ between generations as immigrant and resident haplotypes recombine. Understanding the genetic factors that shape immigrant fitness over multiple generations is increasingly important as habitat fragmentation threatens populations by reducing genetic variation and leading to increased levels of inbreeding. Few studies have measured the multigenerational fitness of immigrant lineages, especially within populations that had histories of high gene flow. We used 33 years of life history and pedigree data on a population of Florida scrub-jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens ) with historically high immigration to quantify the fitness of immigrants and their descendants. We compared the fitness of immigrants and residents as well as their resulting descendants (F1, F2, etc.) to determine the composite genetic effects responsible for fitness differences. We found evidence of additive benefits of immigrant ancestry and heterosis driven by non-additive effects that persists for multiple generations. These results are promising for conservation efforts aiming to increase connectivity and illustrate the complex dynamics that determine the rates of introgression in natural populations.
- Open Access
Context-Dependent Fitness Outcomes of Helping in the Cooperatively-Breeding Florida Scrub-Jay ( Aphelocoma coerulescens )
Cooperatively breeding species frequently live in family groups of related individuals, with helpers delaying their own reproduction and participating in alloparental care, predator vigilance, and territory defense. It remains challenging to disentangle the roles of the indirect fitness benefits of helping kin and the potential direct fitness benefits helpers receive in the evolution of cooperative breeding. While many studies test for associations between helper relatedness and helping effort, few estimate the realized fitness consequences of helping in relation to these factors. Understanding these fitness outcomes elucidates the selective forces that maintain helping behavior, whether through inclusive fitness gains by helping related individuals or as a means of gaining access to later direct fitness benefits. Using 29 years of extensive demographic data from a closely monitored population of Florida scrub-jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens ), we quantified the effect of helpers on breeder survival, offspring survival, and nestling production and how these effects depend on relatedness and sex of helpers. We found that female breeder survival was significantly greater when more helpers were present and that offspring survival was greater when more male helpers were present on small territories. Neither effect of helpers depended on the relatedness between helpers and the individuals they helped. Our results suggest that helping behavior is highly context-dependent and varies based on the potential impact of helping and the direct fitness benefits helpers receive.
Open AccessContext-Dependent Fitness Outcomes of Helping in the Cooperatively-Breeding Florida Scrub-Jay ( Aphelocoma coerulescens )
Cooperatively breeding species frequently live in family groups of related individuals, with helpers delaying their own reproduction and participating in alloparental care, predator vigilance, and territory defense. It remains challenging to disentangle the roles of the indirect fitness benefits of helping kin and the potential direct fitness benefits helpers receive in the evolution of cooperative breeding. While many studies test for associations between helper relatedness and helping effort, few estimate the realized fitness consequences of helping in relation to these factors. Understanding these fitness outcomes elucidates the selective forces that maintain helping behavior, whether through inclusive fitness gains by helping related individuals or as a means of gaining access to later direct fitness benefits. Using 29 years of extensive demographic data from a closely monitored population of Florida scrub-jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens ), we quantified the effect of helpers on breeder survival, offspring survival, and nestling production and how these effects depend on relatedness and sex of helpers. We found that female breeder survival was significantly greater when more helpers were present and that offspring survival was greater when more male helpers were present on small territories. Neither effect of helpers depended on the relatedness between helpers and the individuals they helped. Our results suggest that helping behavior is highly context-dependent and varies based on the potential impact of helping and the direct fitness benefits helpers receive.
- 2 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Wilson Journal of Ornithology
- Vol. 137 (1) , 24-37
Saturation of breeding territories limits the expression of Natal Habitat Preference Induction (NHPI) by Florida Scrub-Jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens )
- 2 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Wilson Journal of Ornithology
- Vol. 137 (1) , 24-37
Saturation of breeding territories limits the expression of Natal Habitat Preference Induction (NHPI) by Florida Scrub-Jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens )
- 24 October 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithology
- Vol. 142 (1)
Warm winters lead to increased reproductive effort, but lower reproductive success: Hidden costs of climate warming in a threatened bird
Climate warming is affecting the phenology and life history of animals around the world. In birds, although warm winters have been shown to advance breeding dates and affect reproductive success in a diverse range of taxa, few studies document whether changes in breeding phenology are associated with variability in reproductive effort by breeders. We leveraged a 37-year dataset on the demography of Aphelocoma coerulescens (Florida Scrub-Jay) to investigate not only whether winter weather affects jay phenology and reproductive success, but also whether winter weather affects overall reproductive effort. Jays bred early but fledged fewer offspring in springs following warm winters. Surprisingly, this reduced reproductive success came at the expense of increased reproductive effort (number of nests built, number of eggs laid, and length of the breeding period across all attempts) by the breeders. Given the well-known trade-off between reproductive effort and survival, we highlight an important but typically unrecognized cost of climate warming on birds, as revealed by a long-term study of a large, well-protected population.
- 24 October 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithology
- Vol. 142 (1)
Warm winters lead to increased reproductive effort, but lower reproductive success: Hidden costs of climate warming in a threatened bird
Climate warming is affecting the phenology and life history of animals around the world. In birds, although warm winters have been shown to advance breeding dates and affect reproductive success in a diverse range of taxa, few studies document whether changes in breeding phenology are associated with variability in reproductive effort by breeders. We leveraged a 37-year dataset on the demography of Aphelocoma coerulescens (Florida Scrub-Jay) to investigate not only whether winter weather affects jay phenology and reproductive success, but also whether winter weather affects overall reproductive effort. Jays bred early but fledged fewer offspring in springs following warm winters. Surprisingly, this reduced reproductive success came at the expense of increased reproductive effort (number of nests built, number of eggs laid, and length of the breeding period across all attempts) by the breeders. Given the well-known trade-off between reproductive effort and survival, we highlight an important but typically unrecognized cost of climate warming on birds, as revealed by a long-term study of a large, well-protected population.
- 9 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Genetics
- Vol. 227 (3)
Allele frequency dynamics under sex-biased demography and sex-specific inheritance in a pedigreed jay population
Sex-biased demography, including sex-biased survival or migration, can alter allele frequency changes across the genome. In particular, we can expect different patterns of genetic variation on autosomes and sex chromosomes due to sex-specific differences in life histories, as well as differences in effective population size, transmission modes, and the strength and mode of selection. Here, we demonstrate the role that sex differences in life history played in shaping short-term evolutionary dynamics across the genome. We used a 25-year pedigree and genomic dataset from a long-studied population of Florida Scrub-Jays (Aphelocoma coerulescens) to directly characterize the relative roles of sex-biased demography and inheritance in shaping genome-wide allele frequency trajectories. We used gene dropping simulations to estimate individual genetic contributions to future generations and to model drift and immigration on the known pedigree. We quantified differential expected genetic contributions of males and females over time, showing the impact of sex-biased dispersal in a monogamous system. Due to female-biased dispersal, more autosomal variation is introduced by female immigrants. However, due to male-biased transmission, more Z variation is introduced by male immigrants. Finally, we partitioned the proportion of variance in allele frequency change through time due to male and female contributions. Overall, most allele frequency change is due to variance in survival and births. Males and females make similar contributions to autosomal allele frequency change, but males make higher contributions to allele frequency change on the Z chromosome. Our work shows the importance of understanding sex-specific demographic processes in characterizing genome-wide allele frequency change in wild populations.
- 9 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Genetics
- Vol. 227 (3)
Allele frequency dynamics under sex-biased demography and sex-specific inheritance in a pedigreed jay population
Sex-biased demography, including sex-biased survival or migration, can alter allele frequency changes across the genome. In particular, we can expect different patterns of genetic variation on autosomes and sex chromosomes due to sex-specific differences in life histories, as well as differences in effective population size, transmission modes, and the strength and mode of selection. Here, we demonstrate the role that sex differences in life history played in shaping short-term evolutionary dynamics across the genome. We used a 25-year pedigree and genomic dataset from a long-studied population of Florida Scrub-Jays (Aphelocoma coerulescens) to directly characterize the relative roles of sex-biased demography and inheritance in shaping genome-wide allele frequency trajectories. We used gene dropping simulations to estimate individual genetic contributions to future generations and to model drift and immigration on the known pedigree. We quantified differential expected genetic contributions of males and females over time, showing the impact of sex-biased dispersal in a monogamous system. Due to female-biased dispersal, more autosomal variation is introduced by female immigrants. However, due to male-biased transmission, more Z variation is introduced by male immigrants. Finally, we partitioned the proportion of variance in allele frequency change through time due to male and female contributions. Overall, most allele frequency change is due to variance in survival and births. Males and females make similar contributions to autosomal allele frequency change, but males make higher contributions to allele frequency change on the Z chromosome. Our work shows the importance of understanding sex-specific demographic processes in characterizing genome-wide allele frequency change in wild populations.
- Open Access
Impacts of increasing isolation and environmental variation on Florida Scrub-Jay demography
Isolation caused by anthropogenic habitat fragmentation can destabilize populations. Populations relying on the inflow of immigrants can face reduced fitness due to inbreeding depression as fewer new individuals arrive. Empirical studies of the demographic consequences of isolation are critical to understand how populations persist through changing conditions. We used a 34-year demographic and environmental dataset from a population of cooperatively-breeding Florida Scrub-Jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens ) to create mechanistic models linking environmental and demographic factors to population growth rates. We found that the population has not declined despite both declining immigration and increasing inbreeding, owing to a coinciding response in breeder survival. We find evidence of density-dependent immigration, breeder survival, and fecundity, indicating that interactions between vital rates and local density play a role in buffering the population against change. Our study elucidates the impacts of isolation on demography and how long-term stability is maintained via demographic responses.
Open AccessImpacts of increasing isolation and environmental variation on Florida Scrub-Jay demography
Isolation caused by anthropogenic habitat fragmentation can destabilize populations. Populations relying on the inflow of immigrants can face reduced fitness due to inbreeding depression as fewer new individuals arrive. Empirical studies of the demographic consequences of isolation are critical to understand how populations persist through changing conditions. We used a 34-year demographic and environmental dataset from a population of cooperatively-breeding Florida Scrub-Jays ( Aphelocoma coerulescens ) to create mechanistic models linking environmental and demographic factors to population growth rates. We found that the population has not declined despite both declining immigration and increasing inbreeding, owing to a coinciding response in breeder survival. We find evidence of density-dependent immigration, breeder survival, and fecundity, indicating that interactions between vital rates and local density play a role in buffering the population against change. Our study elucidates the impacts of isolation on demography and how long-term stability is maintained via demographic responses.
- Open Access
Physiological costs of prospecting in a resident cooperative breeder, the Florida scrub-jay
Prospecting is an understudied yet pivotal information-gathering process often preceding natal dispersal. While prospecting may enable individuals to optimise dispersal outcomes and obtain high quality territories, it is also likely to incur costs stemming from energy expenditure and predation risks. This trade-off may drive individual differences in prospecting effort. We tested for evidence of costs of prospecting behaviour in a wild population of Florida scrub-jays, Aphelocoma coerulescens , which prospect as nonbreeding helpers. Using random sampling across all helpers, we compared prospecting effort—approximated by frequency, distance, and activity level—with body mass changes and oxidative stress levels. We tested if prospecting incurred costs and if early-life body condition predicted subsequent prospecting effort. Prospecting frequency was positively linked to oxidative damage but not to any loss in body mass during the breeding season, suggesting that extra-territorial movement costs manifest unevenly. Early-stage body condition did not affect subsequent prospecting effort across a large set of helpers, but early-stage body condition and morphometric measures did correlate with subsequent oxidative status of those sampled. Our results suggest that prospecting movement carries some physiological costs, perhaps contributing to individual differences in prospecting. This research highlights how body condition plays a role in trade-offs between information gathering movement and physiological costs of movement itself, ultimately providing insight on the evolution of prospecting in social species. HIGHLIGHTS: Prospecting prior to breeding enables informed dispersal but incurs cost We tested whether prospecting by nonbreeding Florida scrub-jays results in physiological costs or varies with initial condition We measured oxidative status using assays testing antioxidant capacity and oxidative damage Frequent prospecting was linked to subsequent oxidative damage Early-stage body condition and wing length affected subsequent oxidative status
Open AccessPhysiological costs of prospecting in a resident cooperative breeder, the Florida scrub-jay
Prospecting is an understudied yet pivotal information-gathering process often preceding natal dispersal. While prospecting may enable individuals to optimise dispersal outcomes and obtain high quality territories, it is also likely to incur costs stemming from energy expenditure and predation risks. This trade-off may drive individual differences in prospecting effort. We tested for evidence of costs of prospecting behaviour in a wild population of Florida scrub-jays, Aphelocoma coerulescens , which prospect as nonbreeding helpers. Using random sampling across all helpers, we compared prospecting effort—approximated by frequency, distance, and activity level—with body mass changes and oxidative stress levels. We tested if prospecting incurred costs and if early-life body condition predicted subsequent prospecting effort. Prospecting frequency was positively linked to oxidative damage but not to any loss in body mass during the breeding season, suggesting that extra-territorial movement costs manifest unevenly. Early-stage body condition did not affect subsequent prospecting effort across a large set of helpers, but early-stage body condition and morphometric measures did correlate with subsequent oxidative status of those sampled. Our results suggest that prospecting movement carries some physiological costs, perhaps contributing to individual differences in prospecting. This research highlights how body condition plays a role in trade-offs between information gathering movement and physiological costs of movement itself, ultimately providing insight on the evolution of prospecting in social species. HIGHLIGHTS: Prospecting prior to breeding enables informed dispersal but incurs cost We tested whether prospecting by nonbreeding Florida scrub-jays results in physiological costs or varies with initial condition We measured oxidative status using assays testing antioxidant capacity and oxidative damage Frequent prospecting was linked to subsequent oxidative damage Early-stage body condition and wing length affected subsequent oxidative status
- Open Access
Visual Monitoring Strategies of Sentinels in a Cooperative Breeder
Vigilance is important for early detection of threats. Previous studies have focused on the allocation of time to vigilance but neglected how animals monitor their surroundings during vigilance. Where animals look and how long each look lasts can affect the quality of visual monitoring and thus the ability to detect threats during vigilance. We examined visual monitoring strategies in the Florida scrub-jay (Aphelocoma coerulescens), a cooperative breeder with sentinel behaviour. Sentinels in this species make head turns from vantage points to detect the arrival of predators and intruding neighbours. We found that sentinels initiated head turns at regular intervals and also returned their gaze to areas previously monitored at regular intervals, which is predicted when predators and intruders rely on surprise rather than stealth to approach. Sentinels made head turns in several directions, but often more frequently on one side of the body than the other, which was not predicted for regular vigilance. Average look duration during sentinel bouts was shorter in smaller groups and in juveniles. We argue that shorter looks are beneficial to increase visual coverage in more threatening situations. Our study highlights how visual monitoring strategies during vigilance reflect the risk posed by predators and intruders.
Open AccessVisual Monitoring Strategies of Sentinels in a Cooperative Breeder
Vigilance is important for early detection of threats. Previous studies have focused on the allocation of time to vigilance but neglected how animals monitor their surroundings during vigilance. Where animals look and how long each look lasts can affect the quality of visual monitoring and thus the ability to detect threats during vigilance. We examined visual monitoring strategies in the Florida scrub-jay (Aphelocoma coerulescens), a cooperative breeder with sentinel behaviour. Sentinels in this species make head turns from vantage points to detect the arrival of predators and intruding neighbours. We found that sentinels initiated head turns at regular intervals and also returned their gaze to areas previously monitored at regular intervals, which is predicted when predators and intruders rely on surprise rather than stealth to approach. Sentinels made head turns in several directions, but often more frequently on one side of the body than the other, which was not predicted for regular vigilance. Average look duration during sentinel bouts was shorter in smaller groups and in juveniles. We argue that shorter looks are beneficial to increase visual coverage in more threatening situations. Our study highlights how visual monitoring strategies during vigilance reflect the risk posed by predators and intruders.
- 26 October 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithology
- Vol. 140 (1)
Professional ethics survey identifies strengths and areas for improvement in the American Ornithological Society
In response to a growing need to foster ethical behavior within scientific societies, the American Ornithological Society’s (AOS) professional ethics committee conducted a survey of members in spring 2021 to identify the primary challenges and ethical conduct concerns. The survey indicated that the AOS has a strong culture of professional ethics and highlighted areas needing improvement. Participants identified discrimination and lack of inclusivity (44%), scientific fraud and abuse in data and publications (35%), and sexual harassment (31%) as the highest potential risks for unethical behavior in our organization. Moreover, approximately one-third of respondents (34%) had personally witnessed or experienced unethical behavior as an AOS member. A smaller proportion (16%) felt pressure to compromise their work standards in ornithology. These findings are likely representative of broader patterns that professional, scientific societies face as they seek to provide safe, welcoming, and thoughtful environments for researchers to share their work, gain valuable feedback, and develop collaborations. The survey results also create a framework for workshops, training opportunities, and disseminating information within the AOS and, ideally, with the broader, international community of ornithologists.
- 26 October 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithology
- Vol. 140 (1)
Professional ethics survey identifies strengths and areas for improvement in the American Ornithological Society
In response to a growing need to foster ethical behavior within scientific societies, the American Ornithological Society’s (AOS) professional ethics committee conducted a survey of members in spring 2021 to identify the primary challenges and ethical conduct concerns. The survey indicated that the AOS has a strong culture of professional ethics and highlighted areas needing improvement. Participants identified discrimination and lack of inclusivity (44%), scientific fraud and abuse in data and publications (35%), and sexual harassment (31%) as the highest potential risks for unethical behavior in our organization. Moreover, approximately one-third of respondents (34%) had personally witnessed or experienced unethical behavior as an AOS member. A smaller proportion (16%) felt pressure to compromise their work standards in ornithology. These findings are likely representative of broader patterns that professional, scientific societies face as they seek to provide safe, welcoming, and thoughtful environments for researchers to share their work, gain valuable feedback, and develop collaborations. The survey results also create a framework for workshops, training opportunities, and disseminating information within the AOS and, ideally, with the broader, international community of ornithologists.
- 27 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 91 (5) , 970-982
Staging to join non‐kin groups in a classical cooperative breeder, the Florida scrub‐jay
Why unrelated members form groups in animal societies remains a pertinent topic in evolutionary biology because benefits for group members often are not obvious. We studied subordinates that disperse to join unrelated social groups in the Florida scrub‐jay Aphelocoma coerulescens, a cooperative breeding species mainly composed of kin‐based groups. We evaluated potential adaptive benefits of dispersing to become an unrelated helper (staging) versus remaining home and dispersing only to pair and breed (direct dispersal) to understand why non‐kin‐based groups form. Using 35 years of demographic data, we quantified life‐history aspects of staging individuals and tested associations between social and ecological factors on the natal and staging territories. We compared fitness outcomes between dispersal strategies by analysing survival, breeding recruitment and direct reproductive output. We tested for sexual asymmetry potentially driven by differences in territory acquisition patterns and female‐biased dispersal for this species. Of birds that reached 1 year, 28% staged at a non‐natal territory before breeding or disappearing. Staging dispersers departed at younger ages and moved greater distances than direct dispersers. When looking at proximate factors on the natal territory associated with staging, males left groups with many same‐sex helpers, while females often left when their father disappeared. For both sexes, staging individuals more likely came from high‐quality territories and joined groups with fewer same‐sex helpers than in their natal group. While staging and direct dispersers did not differ in survival or likelihood of becoming a breeder, staging males became breeders later and had lower lifetime reproductive success than direct dispersers. In Florida scrub‐jays, staging appears to be an alternative strategy for female helpers, but a best‐of‐a‐bad‐situation for males. This sexual asymmetry is consistent with males having more options than females to achieve higher reproductive success by breeding near home. Trade‐offs in cost–benefits of departing the natal territory and joining unrelated groups as a helper seem to best explain alternative dispersal patterns, with optimal social queues primarily driving the benefits. This research highlights plasticity in dispersal behaviour in response to social and environmental conditions and offers a new perspective in our understanding of non‐kin‐based social groups.
- 27 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 91 (5) , 970-982
Staging to join non‐kin groups in a classical cooperative breeder, the Florida scrub‐jay
Why unrelated members form groups in animal societies remains a pertinent topic in evolutionary biology because benefits for group members often are not obvious. We studied subordinates that disperse to join unrelated social groups in the Florida scrub‐jay Aphelocoma coerulescens, a cooperative breeding species mainly composed of kin‐based groups. We evaluated potential adaptive benefits of dispersing to become an unrelated helper (staging) versus remaining home and dispersing only to pair and breed (direct dispersal) to understand why non‐kin‐based groups form. Using 35 years of demographic data, we quantified life‐history aspects of staging individuals and tested associations between social and ecological factors on the natal and staging territories. We compared fitness outcomes between dispersal strategies by analysing survival, breeding recruitment and direct reproductive output. We tested for sexual asymmetry potentially driven by differences in territory acquisition patterns and female‐biased dispersal for this species. Of birds that reached 1 year, 28% staged at a non‐natal territory before breeding or disappearing. Staging dispersers departed at younger ages and moved greater distances than direct dispersers. When looking at proximate factors on the natal territory associated with staging, males left groups with many same‐sex helpers, while females often left when their father disappeared. For both sexes, staging individuals more likely came from high‐quality territories and joined groups with fewer same‐sex helpers than in their natal group. While staging and direct dispersers did not differ in survival or likelihood of becoming a breeder, staging males became breeders later and had lower lifetime reproductive success than direct dispersers. In Florida scrub‐jays, staging appears to be an alternative strategy for female helpers, but a best‐of‐a‐bad‐situation for males. This sexual asymmetry is consistent with males having more options than females to achieve higher reproductive success by breeding near home. Trade‐offs in cost–benefits of departing the natal territory and joining unrelated groups as a helper seem to best explain alternative dispersal patterns, with optimal social queues primarily driving the benefits. This research highlights plasticity in dispersal behaviour in response to social and environmental conditions and offers a new perspective in our understanding of non‐kin‐based social groups.