MQMohsen Qutbi

Mohsen Qutbi

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Mohsen Qutbi has a total of 69 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:

  • Isa Neshandar Asli

    Department of Nuclear Medicine, School of Medicine, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

    15 shared publications
  • Mehdi Soltanshahi

    Department of Nuclear Medicine, Taleghani Educational Hospital, School of Medicine, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

    10 shared publications
  • Reyhane Ahmadi

    Department of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging, Farshchian Heart Center, School of Medicine, Hamadan University of Medical Sciences, Hamadan

    7 shared publications
  • Yaser Shiravand

    Department of Nuclear Medicine, Taleghani Educational Hospital, School of Medicine, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

    7 shared publications
  • Babak Shafiei

    Department of Nuclear Medicine, Taleghani Educational Hospital, School of Medicine, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

    4 shared publications
  • Majid Assadi

    The Persian Gulf Nuclear Medicine Research Center, Department of Nuclear Medicine, Molecular Imaging, and Theranostics, Bushehr Medical University Hospital, School of Medicine, Bushehr University of Medical Sciences, Bushehr, Iran

    4 shared publications

Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Truncation Artifact Presenting as Cropped Projections and Wedge Defect in Sinogram During Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography

    by Mohsen Qutbi, Reyhane Ahmadi, Amirmohammad Alinejad

    Truncation Artifact Presenting as Cropped Projections and Wedge Defect in Sinogram During Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography - Molecular Imaging and Radionuclide Therapy

  • Open Access

    Local distortion as a pitfall of iterative MLEM reconstruction in myocardial perfusion imaging – A phantom study

    by Mohsen Qutbi

    Purpose: To provide insight into appearance of local distortion as a pitfall and to assess performance of MLEM reconstruction in presence of a high‐contrast object or hot spot and to quantify extent of involvement, specifically in myocardial perfusion imaging. Methods: A checkerboard image is reconstructed with MLEM with and without the presence of a high‐contrast region or hot spot to demonstrate pattern of distortion in near and distant locations around it. Then, a cardiac NCAT phantom is constructed without (“control”) and with a nearby hot spot or highly‐intense object (as lung lesion close to lateral wall of LV). An in‐house MLEM algorithm is implemented and utilized for reconstruction. Images are analyzed by creating error images and profile plotting. Findings: Pattern of distortion on a checkerboard image is like a two diagonal bands of the same width of the spot crossing perpendicularly. Higher relative intensity (5:1 vs. 2:1) results in more distortion both in extent and severity. Tomographic image of control NCAT phantom reveals an almost uniform intensity in lateral wall. However, as relative intensity of spot increases, distortion worsens. Circumferential curves of all walls are almost superimposed except for the wall close to object (or lateral wall of the LV). Conclusion: Presence of a hot spot or object creates distortion its own periphery during MLEM reconstruction. The object‐of‐interest is influenced if located in that region. Degree of distortion depends on relative intensity of hot object to background. Likewise, an artifactual defect is created in LV wall in myocardial perfusion imaging.


  • Open Access

    On the Convergence of Maximum Likelihood Expectation–maximization Algorithm for Iterative Tomographic Reconstruction and the Role of Spatial Frequency, Location, Pixel Intensity, Contrast, and Noise

    by Mohsen Qutbi

    Background: It is desirable to iterate the maximum likelihood expectation–maximization (MLEM) algorithm to the point of convergence to obtain the optimal result. However, the impact of spatial frequency on the convergence rate of MLEM algorithm is not well investigated in a practical manner. Factors such as intensity of pixels and noise may also affect the algorithm’s convergence. It is not also well-known that the algorithm converges uniformly or consistently across the field of view (FOV), termed as radial congruency or sensitivity to location and direction. Purpose: The purpose of the study was to evaluate the factors affecting the convergence of MLEM algorithm during iterative reconstruction including spatial frequency, pixel intensity, image contrast, and noise as well as the location or direction sensitivity or performance of algorithm in various parts of FOV. Materials and Methods: Different sets of input test images were reconstructed by MLEM algorithm. To evaluate the role of spatial frequency on convergence rate and effect of direction, “zone plate test” image was used. Another set of images (six checkerboard images containing white and black boxes of different sizes) were used to examine the effect of location and direction in FOV. For the evaluation of image contrast and pixel intensity, a medium-sized checkerboard images was reconstructed. The original and reconstructed images were compared in each iteration using different performance metrics, error or discrepancy (mean squared error [MSE]), similarity (structural similarity index [SSIM]), and distance (Kullback–Leibler divergence). MSE curves were plotted for subregions (in FOV) and the whole image. Reconstruction was performed with 20, 50, 100, and 500 iterations. The Poisson noise was added to the sinograms, and the semiconvergence was assessed in reconstructed images. Results: Using “zone plate test” image, with 20 iterations, the low-frequency components located in the center were visible, but conversely, the middle- and high-frequency components were poorly reproduced. By increasing the iteration number to 50, 100, and 500, more details were visible in the periphery. In terms of the algorithm’s performance in different locations, the center (includes lowest frequency components), the curve immediately starts to converge, however, for other three subregions (include low-, middle-, and high-frequency components, respectively), the convergence occurs later in the expected order. In the reconstructed images of checkerboard images, the central part was more blurred than its periphery. However, when more iterations were performed, the degree of blurring was less apparent. In the image with the smallest size of boxes (or “2”), the convergence occurred later (around 400 iterations). As the size of boxes increased, the convergence took place. The curves of the top and left side of the images were perfectly superimposed and converged earlier than the center. Image contrast and pixel intensity had no effect on the point of convergence. The optimal point in the reconstruction of noisy images, where the MSE was minimum, occurred very early, and it was directly related to the level of noise. Conclusion: The convergence of the algorithm is slower in the center of FOV than periphery (location sensitivity), but no difference exists between the top and left subregions of FOV (no direction sensitivity). High-frequency details (sharp edges) required more iterations to be reproduced. Image contrast and pixel intensity have no discernible effect on the algorithm’s rate of convergence.


  • Open Access

    Artificial High- and Low-density Materials in Bone Mineral Densitometry Using Dual-energy X-ray Absorptiometry: A GATE Monte Carlo Simulation of “Black-hole” Artifact

    by Mohsen Qutbi

    Objective: The objective of the study was to evaluate the effect of artificial high- and low-density materials on Bone mineral density (BMD)scans in dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) method and emergence of black-hole artifact through GATE Monte Carlo simulation. Materials and Methods: GATE Monte Carlo code was utilized to simulate the artifact encountered in clinical scans acquired by HOLOGIC ® bone densitometer. Two simplified phantoms were designed. The first one was a rectangular box with six smaller cubes inside and the second one was a body torso. Materials of cubes were spine bone, polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), barium sulfate suspension in water, stainless steel, titanium alloy, and gold. The torso phantom contained objects of 5 vertebrae, bowel and 3 small spherical objects near the surface of the torso as piercing objects on the abdominal wall, each overlying the vertebrae. Using 100 and 140 kVp, spectral X-rays were generated to simulate DXA. For both phantoms, two simulations were carried out. The pair of projections acquired for each phantom were then subtracted and analyzed by curve fitting techniques. Results: Except for spine bone, in which radio-opacity decreases with increasing spectral X-ray energy (from 100 to 140 kVp), other squares exhibit little changes over different energies. PMMA shows consistently very low radio-opacity. Four other materials (barium sulfate in water, stainless steel alloy, titanium alloy, and gold), all attenuate the X-ray photons substantially. Except for spine bone, other materials are barely noticeable in pairwise subtracted images. In torso phantom, piercing objects are visualized as “holes” in vertebrae. Conclusion: Both artificial high- and low-density materials, compared to bone, are eliminated during the subtraction of dual-energy X-ray profiles and therefore, can create black-hole artifact.

  • Adjacent object distorts the organ-of-interest in filtered back-projection tomographic image reconstruction: ‘ramp filter’ or ‘reconstruction’ artifact revisited

    by Mohsen Qutbi

    Objective: To simulate the artifact caused by an adjacent object on organ-of-interest during filtered back-projection (FBP) tomographic reconstruction (the so-called “ramp filter” artifact) and to demonstrate the extent to which an organ-of-interest is influenced by such adjacent hot spot or attenuating object. Methods and Materials: Two simulations are conducted with two simplified phantoms: “hot spot” and “cardiac.” First one is used to visualize effect of hot spot on its periphery. Second one is used to evaluate effect of nearby object (liver) on left ventricle (LV) as organ-of-interest. To generate sinograms, forward projection process is done with and without modeling radiation attenuation. FBP using windowed ramp filter is done. All slices are analyzed by plotting intensity profiles. Results: In tomographic slices, there is a hypo-intense halo around presumed edge of object when compared to background intensity, more noticeable in phantoms with less blurring. Even with ramp filter applied, no halo is visible in FBP without attenuation for cardiac phantom. In contrast, in slices with considering attenuation, zones with different levels of count suppression on both sides of object are visualized instead. The most prominent one is between liver and LV in simulation with higher-attenuating object and higher activity. Conclusion: A single hot spot with sufficient amount of blurring does not distort its surroundings. Hot spots and attenuating objects near organ-of-interest, however, distort myocardial perfusion imaging. Artifactual defects are thus only created when attenuation is modeled during FBP, producing zones of count suppression between organ-of-interest and nearby object or hot spot.


  • Cutaneous Metastasis From Prostate Cancer on Posttherapeutic 177Lu–Prostate-Specific Membrane Antigen Scan

    by Mohammad Taghavi, Reyhane Ahmadi, Mohsen Qutbi

    In this note, we aim to present a patient with a known case of prostate cancer with widespread metastasis to the skeleton and liver who has undergone several cycles of chemoradiotherapy. The patient received 2 doses of 177Lu–prostate-specific membrane antigen therapy, in which several zones of uptake were detected on the thoracic wall compatible with cutaneous metastatic lesions of prostate cancer.

  • Open Access

    Quantitative Performance Evaluation of Commonly Used Colormaps for Image Display in Myocardial Perfusion Imaging: Analysis based on Perceptual Metrics

    by Mohsen Qutbi

    Objectives: To quantitatively evaluate the performance of the most used colormaps in image display using perceptual metrics and to what extent these measures are congruent with the true intensity or uptake of pixels at different levels of defect severity in simulated cardiac images. Methods: Six colormaps, labeled "Gray", "Thermal", "Cool", "CEqual", "Siemens" and "S Pet" extracted from FIJI ImageJ software are included. Colormap data are converted from the red, green, blue color space to CIELAB. Perceptual metrics for measuring "color difference" were calculated, including difference ( triangle E 76 ) and "speed". The pairwise color difference in every two levels or entries is visualized in a 2-dimensional "heatmap distance matrix" for each colormap. Curves are plotted for each colormap and compared. In addition, to apply this technique to clinical images, simulated short-axis cardiac slices with incremental defect severity (10% grading) were employed. The circumferential profile curves of true pixel intensity, lightness or luminance, and color difference are plotted simultaneously for each defect severity to visualize the concordance of the three curves in various colormaps. Results: In 0% defect, all the curves are at the highest level, except for "s pet", in that the lightness is not at its maximum value. In the phantom with 10% defect (or 90% of maximum value), discrepancies among curves appear. In "Siemens", the triangle E 76 drops sharply. In "Siemens" colormap, the triangle E 76 drops sharply. In 80% defect, triangle E 76 curve, in "gray" colormap drops more slowly than other curves of other colormaps. In "s pet", lightness curve rises paradoxically, although the count intensity and triangle E 76 curve match. In 70% defect, again, the curves are in good agreement in "thermal", "Siemens" and "cequal". However, a consistent lag exists in "gray". Up to 50% defect, curves maintain their expected pattern, but in defects more severe than 40%, lightness and triangle E 76 curves in "cool" and "cequal" rise paradoxically, and in "thermal", they start to slow down in descent. In "Siemens", falling pattern of the three curves continues. For "s pet" colormap, an erratic pattern of lightness and triangle E 76 curves exists. Conclusion: Of 6 colormaps investigated for estimating defect severity, "grayscale" is less favorable than others and "thermal" performs slightly better. "S pet" or rainbow, which is used traditionally by many practitioners, is strongly discouraged. The "Siemens" colormap suffers from decreased discriminating power in the range of mild to moderate/severe. In contrast, the "cool" and "cequal" colormaps outperform the other colormaps employed in this study to some extent, although they have some shortcomings.


  • Open Access

    Exploring the Influence of Initial Estimates on Iterative Maximum Likelihood Expectation–maximization in Tomographic Reconstruction

    by Mohsen Qutbi

    Purpose: To explore the influence of initial guess or estimate (uniform as “ones” and “zeros” vs. filtered back projection [FBP] image) as an input image for maximum likelihood expectation–maximization (MLEM) tomographic reconstruction algorithm and provide the curves of error or convergence for each of these three initial estimates. Methods: Two phantoms, created as digital images, were utilized: one was a simple noiseless object and the other was a more complicated, noise-degraded object of the section of lower thorax in a matrix of 256 × 256 pixels. Both underwent radon transform or forward projection process and the corresponding sinograms were generated. For filtering during tomographic image reconstruction, ramp and Butterworth filters, as high-pass and low-pass ones, were applied to images. The second phantom (lower thorax) was radon-transformed and the resulting sinogram was degraded by noise. As initial guess or estimate images, in addition to FBP tomographic image, two uniform images, one with all pixels having a value of 1 (“ones”) and the other with all having zero (“zeros”), were created. The three initial estimates (FBP, ones, and zeros) were reconstructed with iterative MLEM tomographic reconstruction (with 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, and 64 iterations). The difference between the object and the updated slice was calculated at the end of each iteration (as error matrix), and the mean squared error (MSE) was computed and plotted separately or in conjunction with the MSE curves of other initial estimates. All computations were implemented in MATLAB software. Results: The results of ones and zeros seemed strikingly similar. The curves of uniform ones and uniform zeros were so close to each other that overlap near-perfectly. However, in the FBP slice as an initial estimate, the resulting tomographic slice was similar with a much higher extent to the object even after 1 or 2 iterations. The pattern of convergence for all three curves was roughly similar. The normalized MSE decreased sharply up to 5 iterations and then, after 10 iterations, the curves reached a plateau until 32 iterations. For the phantom of the lower thorax section with its noise-degraded sinogram, similar to the pattern observed for simple disk-shaped phantom, the curves (normalized MSE) fell sharply up to 10 iterations and then rapidly converged thereafter until 64 iterations. Conclusion: Similar results are observed when choosing different initial guesses or estimates (uniform vs. FBP) as the starting point, based on the error calculation using MSE. The algorithm converges almost similarly for all initial estimates. Therefore, selecting a uniform initial guess image can be an appropriate choice and may be preferred over an FBP image. Reducing the processing time can be a valid reason for this choice.


  • Open Access

    Deterministic Modeling for Radiation Attenuation-integrated Radon Transform in Emission Computed Tomography: Algorithm, Curve Fitting Analysis, and Introduction of Attenuation Hadamard Matrix

    by Mohsen Qutbi

    Purpose: The purpose of the study is to propose an algorithm to implement and visualize radiation attenuation-integrated Radon transform based on Beer–Lambert law during emission computed tomography simulation using a deterministic model and also to perform image analysis on resulting images. Methods: Two types of phantoms are designed: plain-disk phantom and patterned-disk phantom. The large disk is filled with an activity of 5 units and the smaller disks have 10 units of activity of 99mTc isotope as an emission map. Three transmission maps for patterned-disk phantom are created with uniform linear attenuation coefficient. Phantoms are scanned with 360° and 180° acquisition arcs. Then, using the algorithm designed, the exponential Radon transform is implemented. After that, the projections are back-projected and filtered to generate tomographic slices. Finally, all slices are analyzed using profile plotting and curve fitting. Moreover, an attenuation Hadamard matrix is provided to facilitate attenuation modeling. Results: The uniform intensity of activity in the phantoms is converted to a disk with progressively decreasing intensity from the periphery to the center in the tomographic slices. Similarly, the circles positioned more centrally appear less intense than those positioned in the periphery, despite all circles having equal activity. When the phantom is scanned in 180° arc, the circles closest to the camera are visualized more intensely. The profile curves of the slices generated by exponential Radon transformation are depicted as U-shaped in profile plotting and are fitted to a bi-exponential function with a near-perfect precision. Conclusions: The incorporation of radiation attenuation results in the development of more realistic models for quantification purposes.


  • Open Access

    Gastric Emptying Scintigraphy: Diagnostic Value of Delayed Imaging and the Impact on Reclassification of Diagnosis

    by Mohsen Qutbi, Reyhane Ahmadi, Elinaz Hosseinzadeh, Ali Asadi

    Objectives: To investigate the added diagnostic value of delayed imaging at 3 and 4 h compared to 2 h imaging as well as scanning up to 4 h compared to 3, and by this means, diagnosis reclassification or changes in diagnosis across various time points.Methods: Seventeen patients clinically suspected of gastroparesis, 8 (47.1%) men and 9 (52.9%) women, according to the standard procedural guidelines, underwent gastric emptying scintigraphy after ingesting a standard meal. One-minute static images in anterior and posterior projections were acquired immediately after ingestion and then at 1-, 2-, 3-, and 4 h time points. For image analysis, a manual region-of-interest was drawn, and then, count of stomach in each projection was used to calculate geometric mean for each time point. Decay correction was applied. At 2-, 3 -and 4 h time points, percentage of retained activity was compared to standard values; therefore, each patient was labeled as normal or delayed.Results: Pairwise correlation between time points was statistically significant. Value of hour 3 shows an extremely strong correlation with the value of hour 4 (r=0.951, p<0.001). In hour 2, of 17 participants, 11 (64.7%) were diagnosed as normal and 6 (35.3%) as delayed. In hour 3, the diagnosis made as delayed rose to 9 (52.9%), whereas normal was 8 (47.1%). Finally, in hour 4, results were 10 (58.8%) as delayed and 7 (41.2%) as normal. All subjects who were labeled as delayed in hour 3 remained with the same diagnosis and 1 out of 8 subjects categorized as normal in hour 3 changed to delayed. For testing agreement, coefficient of kappa was computed between each pair. Agreement between diagnosis in hour 2 with hours 3 or 4 was not strong (kappa <0.6 for both pairs). However, a strong agreement was found between diagnosis in hours 3 and 4 (kappa: 0.881).Conclusion: Because of excellent correlation between values of hours 3 and 4 and strong agreement between the diagnosis in those time points, extending acquisition from 3 to 4 h adds little to the final diagnosis and may not be noticeably meaningful, especially in the clinical setting.