Quinn Asena
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Quinn Asena has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Janet M. Wilmshurst
Research Manaaki Whenua – Landcare Research, 76 Gerald Street, Lincoln, New Zealand, 7608
10 shared publications George L. W. Perry
School of Environment, University of Auckland, 23 Symonds Street, Auckland 1010, New Zealand
9 shared publications- Andreas Heinemeyer
Stockholm Environment Institute (York, United Kingdom)
2 shared publications - Alexandra L. Noronha
Department of Geological Sciences, Jackson School of Geosciences University of Texas at Austin Austin Texas USA
1 shared publication - André Michael Bellvé
Department of Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology The Ohio State University Columbus Ohio USA
1 shared publication Anthony L. Jones
Department of Environment and Geography Stockholm Environment Institute University of York York UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Climate of the Past
- Vol. 22 (4) , 783-796
Information loss in palaeoecological data from process and observer error
Palaeoecological data provide insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and, with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask “true” signals in the data. How different sources of uncertainty influence the inferences drawn from palaeoecological data is rarely assessed, but is critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the effects of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them most influence statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can inform study design before a project is carried out, and so increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic “error-free” core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods used to synthesise palaeoecological records: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 10 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Climate of the Past
- Vol. 22 (4) , 783-796
Open AccessInformation loss in palaeoecological data from process and observer error
Palaeoecological data provide insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and, with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask “true” signals in the data. How different sources of uncertainty influence the inferences drawn from palaeoecological data is rarely assessed, but is critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the effects of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them most influence statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can inform study design before a project is carried out, and so increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic “error-free” core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods used to synthesise palaeoecological records: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- Open Access
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Reply on RC1
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Open AccessReply on RC1
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- Open Access
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Reply on RC1
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Open AccessReply on RC1
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- Open Access
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Reply on RC2
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Open AccessReply on RC2
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- Open Access
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Reply on RC2
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 18 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Open AccessReply on RC2
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Comment on egusphere-2024-3845
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 7 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3845
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Comment on egusphere-2024-3845
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 24 April 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3845
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "Information loss in palaeoecological data from process and observer error"
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "Information loss in palaeoecological data from process and observer error"
- Open Access
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Information loss in palaeoecological data from process and observer error
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-31
Open AccessInformation loss in palaeoecological data from process and observer error
Palaeoecological data give us insight into how ecosystems have changed in the past, and with the development of new sources of proxy data and statistical methods, they are being used to address questions around the underlying mechanisms of change, such as biotic- and climate-ecosystem interactions. However, inferences from palaeoecological data can be hindered by uncertainties inherent in core-type samples that arise from environmental processes and observer-introduced error. Environmental processes, core extraction methods, sub-sampling strategies, laboratory methods, and data processing can potentially mask ‘true’ signals in the data. The influence of sources of uncertainty on inferences drawn from palaeoecological data are rarely assessed but are critical to the confidence of our conclusions. To address this concern, we use a virtual ecological approach to assess the influences of environmental and observer introduced uncertainty to better understand which of them have the strongest influence on statistical methods applied to the data. Quantifying information loss from uncertainty can be used to inform study design before a project is carried out to increase the likelihood of detecting a given signal of interest and make more robust inferences from statistical analyses of palaeoproxy data. We generate synthetic ‘error-free’ core-type samples of pseudoproxies, on which environmental and observational processes are systematically introduced to impose uncertainties on the simulated pseudoproxies. The influence of three sources of uncertainty (core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification from sub-subsamples), are assessed for their individual and combined effects on two statistical methods: Fisher Information and principal curves. Increasing sub-sampling intervals has the most substantial influence on the two statistical methods applied to the pseudoproxy data. When combined, the interaction between increasing sub-sampling interval, and decreasing the number of proxies counted per sub-sample has the strongest influence on Fisher Information and principal curves. Fisher Information and principal curves are not affected in the same way by introducing uncertainty, with principal curves being less influenced by simulated proxy counting and sub-sampling of the core. Virtually assessing uncertainties is a powerful method to better understand the influence that uncertainties introduced at different parts of the analytical process have on conclusions drawn from palaeoecological data.
- 26 February 2025
- Published by New Zealand Ecological Society in New Zealand Journal of Ecology
Using population viability analysis and fossil records to inform the conservation of pāteke (Anas chlorotis)
Population decline and extinction are often driven by multiple stressors. Since AD 1500, the predicted global extinction rates for birds is estimated to be at least 80-times higher than the long-term background average. Pāteke/brown teal (Anas chlorotis) is a threatened waterfowl endemic to Aotearoa New Zealand, with a current population of c. 2500, spread across two remnant populations and a handful of reintroduction sites. The decline of pāteke since the arrival of humans results from habitat loss and fragmentation, predation, and other anthropogenic interactions.
- 26 February 2025
- Published by New Zealand Ecological Society in New Zealand Journal of Ecology
Using population viability analysis and fossil records to inform the conservation of pāteke (Anas chlorotis)
Population decline and extinction are often driven by multiple stressors. Since AD 1500, the predicted global extinction rates for birds is estimated to be at least 80-times higher than the long-term background average. Pāteke/brown teal (Anas chlorotis) is a threatened waterfowl endemic to Aotearoa New Zealand, with a current population of c. 2500, spread across two remnant populations and a handful of reintroduction sites. The decline of pāteke since the arrival of humans results from habitat loss and fragmentation, predation, and other anthropogenic interactions.