Stefano Canessa
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Stefano Canessa has a total of 401 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Frank Pasmans
Wildlife Health Ghent, Department of Pathology, Bacteriology and Avian Diseases, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ghent University, B-9820, Merelbeke, Belgium
12 shared publicationsAn Martel
Wildlife Health Ghent, Department of Pathology, Bacteriology, and Avian Diseases, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ghent University, B-9820 Merelbeke, Belgium
11 shared publications- John G. Ewen
Institute of Zoology Zoological Society of London London UK
10 shared publications - Alejandra Morán-Ordóñez
Institute of Earth Surface Dynamics (IDYST) Université de Lausanne Lausanne Switzerland
7 shared publications - Benedikt Rudolf Schmidt
Department of Evolutionary Biology and Environmental Studies University of Zurich Zürich Switzerland
7 shared publications - Virgilio Hermoso
Departamento de Biología de la Conservación y Cambio Global Estación Biológica de Doñana (EBD‐CSIC) Sevilla Spain
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 October 2026
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in NeoBiota
- Vol. 109, 345-366
Animal welfare implications of management strategies for invasive freshwater turtles
Invasive alien species are a recognised threat to biodiversity, ecosystem functions, and human well-being. Management efforts often prioritise ecological and economic outcomes, neglecting the implications of control methods on animal welfare. We investigated the perceived impacts on animal welfare of different lethal and non-lethal methods to control invasive slider turtles Trachemys scripta in Europe. We elicited the opinions of a group of 24 herpetologists, turtle caretakers, veterinarians and welfare experts, combining the Five Domains welfare framework with a formal structured elicitation approach. Experts generally agreed that welfare impacts in traps or transport would be mostly minor, but could increase with time of exposure, turtle densities and inadequate protocols. For captive containment post-capture, concerns included inadequate diets and habitats, disease and behavioural concerns, although the latter were particularly uncertain. For lethal methods, lethal injection and properly executed shooting were judged to cause no or mild suffering only. Self-expressed confidence in the elicited estimates was relatively high, but decreased for higher impact levels, longer timeframes and less-known welfare domains such as behavioural concerns. Future research would refine welfare assessment models, particularly for the evaluation of cumulative impacts across different methods and multiple affected individuals. However, in a field as multifaceted as animal welfare, some degree of expert interpretation will likely always be necessary to guide policy: structured expert elicitation can help formalise current knowledge and make those interpretations more transparent.
- 19 October 2026
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in NeoBiota
- Vol. 109, 345-366
Open AccessAnimal welfare implications of management strategies for invasive freshwater turtles
Invasive alien species are a recognised threat to biodiversity, ecosystem functions, and human well-being. Management efforts often prioritise ecological and economic outcomes, neglecting the implications of control methods on animal welfare. We investigated the perceived impacts on animal welfare of different lethal and non-lethal methods to control invasive slider turtles Trachemys scripta in Europe. We elicited the opinions of a group of 24 herpetologists, turtle caretakers, veterinarians and welfare experts, combining the Five Domains welfare framework with a formal structured elicitation approach. Experts generally agreed that welfare impacts in traps or transport would be mostly minor, but could increase with time of exposure, turtle densities and inadequate protocols. For captive containment post-capture, concerns included inadequate diets and habitats, disease and behavioural concerns, although the latter were particularly uncertain. For lethal methods, lethal injection and properly executed shooting were judged to cause no or mild suffering only. Self-expressed confidence in the elicited estimates was relatively high, but decreased for higher impact levels, longer timeframes and less-known welfare domains such as behavioural concerns. Future research would refine welfare assessment models, particularly for the evaluation of cumulative impacts across different methods and multiple affected individuals. However, in a field as multifaceted as animal welfare, some degree of expert interpretation will likely always be necessary to guide policy: structured expert elicitation can help formalise current knowledge and make those interpretations more transparent.
- Open Access
- 17 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems
- Vol. 36 (8) , e70443
Beyond the Shell: Reviewing the Ecological and Economic Impact of Trachemys scripta in Europe Over the Past 25 Years
The introduction of exotic species, alongside habitat degradation and global warming, is one of the most pressing issues in conservation ecology. Trachemys scripta is now widespread throughout Europe after decades of pet trade and releases and is often considered a threat to native freshwater turtles. This assumption led to the implementation of significant management efforts across Europe. However, understanding the true impact of T. scripta on the invaded habitats remains difficult to assess due to context dependence and limited empirical evidence. For this reason, we conducted a critical review of scientific literature examining the interaction between T. scripta and European freshwater turtles, combined with an analysis of the management costs of T. scripta within EU funded LIFE projects and an assessment of expert perception. We identified 39 studies, whose relevance highly depended on the study context; nine demonstrated an effective negative impact of T. scripta on native European turtles. Cost analysis from 13 LIFE projects revealed a total cost of 2,509,134 €, with an average removal cost of 364 € per individual turtle. Expert responses highlighted the importance of field‐based evidence and public awareness in management strategies. Overall, our findings indicate that the impact of T. scripta is context‐dependent and often difficult to quantify, while management actions can be economically demanding. This review provides an objective synthesis of the ecological and economic impact of T. scripta in Europe, proposing targeted, context‐specific and cost‐effective management strategies, based on precautionary action and realistic assessments of impact and feasibility.
- 17 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems
- Vol. 36 (8) , e70443
Open AccessBeyond the Shell: Reviewing the Ecological and Economic Impact of Trachemys scripta in Europe Over the Past 25 Years
The introduction of exotic species, alongside habitat degradation and global warming, is one of the most pressing issues in conservation ecology. Trachemys scripta is now widespread throughout Europe after decades of pet trade and releases and is often considered a threat to native freshwater turtles. This assumption led to the implementation of significant management efforts across Europe. However, understanding the true impact of T. scripta on the invaded habitats remains difficult to assess due to context dependence and limited empirical evidence. For this reason, we conducted a critical review of scientific literature examining the interaction between T. scripta and European freshwater turtles, combined with an analysis of the management costs of T. scripta within EU funded LIFE projects and an assessment of expert perception. We identified 39 studies, whose relevance highly depended on the study context; nine demonstrated an effective negative impact of T. scripta on native European turtles. Cost analysis from 13 LIFE projects revealed a total cost of 2,509,134 €, with an average removal cost of 364 € per individual turtle. Expert responses highlighted the importance of field‐based evidence and public awareness in management strategies. Overall, our findings indicate that the impact of T. scripta is context‐dependent and often difficult to quantify, while management actions can be economically demanding. This review provides an objective synthesis of the ecological and economic impact of T. scripta in Europe, proposing targeted, context‐specific and cost‐effective management strategies, based on precautionary action and realistic assessments of impact and feasibility.
- Open Access
- 20 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- p. e70340
Key agroecosystems for the conservation of amphibians and reptiles in Europe
Agricultural expansion and intensification are driving amphibian and reptile declines worldwide. However, sustainably managed agroecosystems can support a high diversity of herpetofauna, which play a key role in pest control, reducing crop damage. Therefore, integrating herpetofauna conservation into agricultural policies is vital for enhancing human well‐being, but it remains largely overlooked. High nature value farmlands (HNVFs) offer a promising framework for conserving herpetofauna outside protected areas; however, the lack of a standardized protocol for HNVF identification can complicate agroecosystem conservation prioritization. We used amphibian and reptile presence data to assess the environmental and climatic factors shaping amphibian and reptile diversity across European agroecosystems and identify HNVFs at large (10 km) and small (2 km) spatial scales. We compared two approaches for HNVF identification, species richness, and irreplaceability and tested whether these areas are protected by the current conservation framework. Coverage of both groups was promoted by heterogenous agroecosystems with natural elements (forest patches, hedgerows, and water bodies), whereas agricultural cover showed negative effects. HNVF identification was generally consistent among the different spatial scales. HNVFs identified through irreplaceability placed greater emphasis on agricultural areas hosting farmland‐associated species, highlighting that irreplaceability provides a more robust approach to HNVF identification. Only a small fraction of HNVFs was protected by the existing European Natura 2000 network, emphasizing the need for improved agrienvironmental schemes to ensure herpetofauna conservation.
- 20 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- p. e70340
Open AccessKey agroecosystems for the conservation of amphibians and reptiles in Europe
Agricultural expansion and intensification are driving amphibian and reptile declines worldwide. However, sustainably managed agroecosystems can support a high diversity of herpetofauna, which play a key role in pest control, reducing crop damage. Therefore, integrating herpetofauna conservation into agricultural policies is vital for enhancing human well‐being, but it remains largely overlooked. High nature value farmlands (HNVFs) offer a promising framework for conserving herpetofauna outside protected areas; however, the lack of a standardized protocol for HNVF identification can complicate agroecosystem conservation prioritization. We used amphibian and reptile presence data to assess the environmental and climatic factors shaping amphibian and reptile diversity across European agroecosystems and identify HNVFs at large (10 km) and small (2 km) spatial scales. We compared two approaches for HNVF identification, species richness, and irreplaceability and tested whether these areas are protected by the current conservation framework. Coverage of both groups was promoted by heterogenous agroecosystems with natural elements (forest patches, hedgerows, and water bodies), whereas agricultural cover showed negative effects. HNVF identification was generally consistent among the different spatial scales. HNVFs identified through irreplaceability placed greater emphasis on agricultural areas hosting farmland‐associated species, highlighting that irreplaceability provides a more robust approach to HNVF identification. Only a small fraction of HNVFs was protected by the existing European Natura 2000 network, emphasizing the need for improved agrienvironmental schemes to ensure herpetofauna conservation.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 40 (4) , e70292
Improving the use of expert opinion in disease risk analysis for conservation translocations
Conservation translocations are subject to considerable uncertainty and risk, of which disease is one of the most recognized. To address disease risks, several protocols for qualitative disease risk analysis (qDRA) exist and are used for responsible conservation translocation planning. Existing qDRA protocols usually rely on expert judgment, but they lack quantitative aggregation of elicited estimates, transparent treatment of uncertainty, and explicit comparison of alternative disease risk management pathways. We added these factors to a qDRA for translocation of a charismatic species that is extinct in the wild, the sihek (Guam kingfisher) ( Todiramphus cinnamominus ). We asked a panel of seven independent experts to quantify their judgment of risks of pathogen release, exposure, and consequences for seven pathogen hazards under three translocation management scenarios. Experts suggested that implementing a full biosecurity protocol would reduce risk for several pathogen hazards but would have variable effectiveness (11–65% depending on the hazard). There was substantial uncertainty associated with individual experts and noise among different experts, showing the potential for error if decisions are based on single‐point judgments (i.e., providing judgment of a central tendency without accounting for uncertainty) from one expert or on collaborative consensus of multiple experts, as is current practice.
- 24 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 40 (4) , e70292
Open AccessImproving the use of expert opinion in disease risk analysis for conservation translocations
Conservation translocations are subject to considerable uncertainty and risk, of which disease is one of the most recognized. To address disease risks, several protocols for qualitative disease risk analysis (qDRA) exist and are used for responsible conservation translocation planning. Existing qDRA protocols usually rely on expert judgment, but they lack quantitative aggregation of elicited estimates, transparent treatment of uncertainty, and explicit comparison of alternative disease risk management pathways. We added these factors to a qDRA for translocation of a charismatic species that is extinct in the wild, the sihek (Guam kingfisher) ( Todiramphus cinnamominus ). We asked a panel of seven independent experts to quantify their judgment of risks of pathogen release, exposure, and consequences for seven pathogen hazards under three translocation management scenarios. Experts suggested that implementing a full biosecurity protocol would reduce risk for several pathogen hazards but would have variable effectiveness (11–65% depending on the hazard). There was substantial uncertainty associated with individual experts and noise among different experts, showing the potential for error if decisions are based on single‐point judgments (i.e., providing judgment of a central tendency without accounting for uncertainty) from one expert or on collaborative consensus of multiple experts, as is current practice.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
- Vol. 75 (9) , 722-736
Clarifying ethical stances in conservation: a trolley problem thought experiment
Conservation policies often need to integrate scientific predictions with ethical considerations. However, different normative ethical systems at the root of conservation approaches often support different decisions, and the moral stances of stakeholders are influenced by diverse societal values and perceptions. This creates the potential for dilemmas and conflicts. In the present article, we adapt the well-known trolley problem thought experiment to a conservation context. Exploring variations in how the problem is framed enables us to highlight key concepts that need to be considered in decision-making (uncertainty; asymmetry in numbers, victims, and impacts; temporal and spatial asymmetry; causal relationships and stakeholder involvement). We argue that the trolley problem offers a simplified but flexible framework to understand and predict the factors underlying differences in moral stances across diverse conservation issues, foster communication, and facilitate informed decision-making in conservation practice.
- 17 June 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
- Vol. 75 (9) , 722-736
Open AccessClarifying ethical stances in conservation: a trolley problem thought experiment
Conservation policies often need to integrate scientific predictions with ethical considerations. However, different normative ethical systems at the root of conservation approaches often support different decisions, and the moral stances of stakeholders are influenced by diverse societal values and perceptions. This creates the potential for dilemmas and conflicts. In the present article, we adapt the well-known trolley problem thought experiment to a conservation context. Exploring variations in how the problem is framed enables us to highlight key concepts that need to be considered in decision-making (uncertainty; asymmetry in numbers, victims, and impacts; temporal and spatial asymmetry; causal relationships and stakeholder involvement). We argue that the trolley problem offers a simplified but flexible framework to understand and predict the factors underlying differences in moral stances across diverse conservation issues, foster communication, and facilitate informed decision-making in conservation practice.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 39 (4) , e70022
A spatial planning approach for the identification of critical habitat for threatened species
The designation of critical habitat for the conservation of threatened species has long been recognized in the environmental legislation of different countries. However, translating vague legislation about critical habitat into practical real‐world designation remains challenging because of its sensitivity to many context‐ and species‐specific criteria and assumptions. We explored how spatial prioritization tools can help navigate such challenges and explicitly address sensitivities. Using a case study on the endangered little bustard ( Tetrax tetrax ) in Spain and the spatial prioritization tool Marxan, we tested and compared different critical habitat spatial designs across a series of scenarios for the little bustard at the national level. The scenarios accounted for habitat availability requirements over the species’ annual cycle, the species’ representativeness across the territory, the spatial connectivity of its habitat and populations, and potential cost constraints. This approach allowed us to quantify the sensitivity of critical habitat designations to how these criteria are quantified and integrated. Considering unoccupied habitat as critical habitat for the species generated larger, more spatially aggregated solutions that would likely be harder to implement than scenarios focusing conservation efforts on currently occupied habitat only. Considering the species’ extirpation risks at individual planning units as a constraint to management success generated completely different solutions than scenarios assuming homogeneous extirpation risk across the landscape. The overall connectivity of identified critical habitats across the entire study area was double in scenarios that accounted for extirpation risk in individual planning units than that in scenarios that held extirpation risk constant across all units. Our approach, based on freely available software, can help guide conservation efforts by identifying new critical areas that maximize the effectiveness of conservation actions and can be used to assess the sensitivity and uncertainty of critical habitat designation to different criteria.
- 2 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 39 (4) , e70022
Open AccessA spatial planning approach for the identification of critical habitat for threatened species
The designation of critical habitat for the conservation of threatened species has long been recognized in the environmental legislation of different countries. However, translating vague legislation about critical habitat into practical real‐world designation remains challenging because of its sensitivity to many context‐ and species‐specific criteria and assumptions. We explored how spatial prioritization tools can help navigate such challenges and explicitly address sensitivities. Using a case study on the endangered little bustard ( Tetrax tetrax ) in Spain and the spatial prioritization tool Marxan, we tested and compared different critical habitat spatial designs across a series of scenarios for the little bustard at the national level. The scenarios accounted for habitat availability requirements over the species’ annual cycle, the species’ representativeness across the territory, the spatial connectivity of its habitat and populations, and potential cost constraints. This approach allowed us to quantify the sensitivity of critical habitat designations to how these criteria are quantified and integrated. Considering unoccupied habitat as critical habitat for the species generated larger, more spatially aggregated solutions that would likely be harder to implement than scenarios focusing conservation efforts on currently occupied habitat only. Considering the species’ extirpation risks at individual planning units as a constraint to management success generated completely different solutions than scenarios assuming homogeneous extirpation risk across the landscape. The overall connectivity of identified critical habitats across the entire study area was double in scenarios that accounted for extirpation risk in individual planning units than that in scenarios that held extirpation risk constant across all units. Our approach, based on freely available software, can help guide conservation efforts by identifying new critical areas that maximize the effectiveness of conservation actions and can be used to assess the sensitivity and uncertainty of critical habitat designation to different criteria.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 7 (4)
Self‐sustaining populations are a conservation vision, not an operational objective
It is common for species conservation plans to identify the establishment or maintenance of a “self‐sustaining population” as an objective. However, this statement vaguely conflates different formulations and interpretations of population viability, management costs, and cultural preferences for non‐invasive population management. Hidden value judgments and assumptions about these components can create disagreement and conflict among partners. Thus, although a simple statement about “achieving self‐sustaining populations” can be a powerful strategic vision, evoking important shared values, it will not be effective as an operational objective for conservation decision making. Best practices in decision making emphasize the importance of fundamental objectives that are clear, unambiguous, and operational. Conservation planners may be better served by replacing the self‐sustaining concept with better‐defined fundamental objectives using quantitative statements about viability and clearly laying out ecological, economic, and cultural values.
- 27 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 7 (4)
Open AccessSelf‐sustaining populations are a conservation vision, not an operational objective
It is common for species conservation plans to identify the establishment or maintenance of a “self‐sustaining population” as an objective. However, this statement vaguely conflates different formulations and interpretations of population viability, management costs, and cultural preferences for non‐invasive population management. Hidden value judgments and assumptions about these components can create disagreement and conflict among partners. Thus, although a simple statement about “achieving self‐sustaining populations” can be a powerful strategic vision, evoking important shared values, it will not be effective as an operational objective for conservation decision making. Best practices in decision making emphasize the importance of fundamental objectives that are clear, unambiguous, and operational. Conservation planners may be better served by replacing the self‐sustaining concept with better‐defined fundamental objectives using quantitative statements about viability and clearly laying out ecological, economic, and cultural values.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Letters
- Vol. 18 (2)
Simulating Demography, Monitoring, and Management Decisions to Evaluate Adaptive Management Strategies for Endangered Species
Adaptive management (AM) remains underused in conservation, partly because optimization‐based approaches require real‐world problems to be substantially simplified. We present an approach to AM based in management strategy evaluation, a method used largely in fisheries. Managers define objectives and nominate alternative adaptive strategies, whose future performance is simulated by integrating ecological, learning and decision processes. We applied this approach to conservation of hihi ( Notiomystis cincta ) across Aotearoa‐New Zealand. For multiple extant and prospective hihi populations, we jointly simulated demographic trends, monitoring, estimation, and decisions including translocations and supplementary feeding. Results confirmed that food supplementation assisted recovery, but was more intensive and expensive. Over 20 years, actively pursuing learning, for example by removing food from populations, provided little benefit. Recovery group members supported continuing current management or increasing priority on existing populations before reintroducing new populations. Our simulation‐based approach can complement formal optimization‐based approaches and improve AM uptake, particularly for programs involving many complex and coordinated decisions.
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Letters
- Vol. 18 (2)
Open AccessSimulating Demography, Monitoring, and Management Decisions to Evaluate Adaptive Management Strategies for Endangered Species
Adaptive management (AM) remains underused in conservation, partly because optimization‐based approaches require real‐world problems to be substantially simplified. We present an approach to AM based in management strategy evaluation, a method used largely in fisheries. Managers define objectives and nominate alternative adaptive strategies, whose future performance is simulated by integrating ecological, learning and decision processes. We applied this approach to conservation of hihi ( Notiomystis cincta ) across Aotearoa‐New Zealand. For multiple extant and prospective hihi populations, we jointly simulated demographic trends, monitoring, estimation, and decisions including translocations and supplementary feeding. Results confirmed that food supplementation assisted recovery, but was more intensive and expensive. Over 20 years, actively pursuing learning, for example by removing food from populations, provided little benefit. Recovery group members supported continuing current management or increasing priority on existing populations before reintroducing new populations. Our simulation‐based approach can complement formal optimization‐based approaches and improve AM uptake, particularly for programs involving many complex and coordinated decisions.
- 19 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 94 (3) , 436-448
Frankenstein matrices: Among‐population life history variation affects the reliability and predictions of demographic models
Population matrix models are routinely used to study the demography of wild populations and to guide management choices. When vital rates are unknown for a specific population or life history stage, researchers often replace them with estimates from other populations of the same species. Such ‘hybrid’ matrices might ignore among‐population life history variation and lead to incorrect inferences. In this study, we examined the real‐world effect of using hybrid matrices on demographic inference and management decisions, using a large dataset on yellow‐bellied toad (Bombina variegata) populations, an amphibian species whose life history depends on human land use. We estimated stage‐specific survival and recruitment for 18 populations across different habitat types. We then assessed how estimated population growth rates and elasticities changed when population‐specific vital rates were replaced by estimates from other populations, chosen randomly or based on habitat, demographic or geographic proximity. The use of hybrid matrices mixing demographic estimates from different populations and habitats biased predictions. The mean bias was relatively minor even when sampling randomly across all populations, because our large dataset represented the whole range of life histories and errors cancelled out on average. However, borrowing estimates from geographically close or demographically similar populations substantially reduced the risk of extreme errors. Borrowing from populations from similar habitat types could also reduce bias, but results varied depending on the exact habitat types concerned. Our study illustrates how habitat‐specific among‐population variation in life history affects the reliability of population matrices commonly used in evolutionary demography, ecology and conservation. When the use of hybrid population matrices cannot be avoided, their creation can be informed by additional information about ecological or demographic patterns, helping reduce bias. When such information is not available, we recommend that studies should consider the whole space of parameter estimates (the complete range of estimates available), thus transparently describing the true uncertainty surrounding demographic estimates.
- 19 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 94 (3) , 436-448
Frankenstein matrices: Among‐population life history variation affects the reliability and predictions of demographic models
Population matrix models are routinely used to study the demography of wild populations and to guide management choices. When vital rates are unknown for a specific population or life history stage, researchers often replace them with estimates from other populations of the same species. Such ‘hybrid’ matrices might ignore among‐population life history variation and lead to incorrect inferences. In this study, we examined the real‐world effect of using hybrid matrices on demographic inference and management decisions, using a large dataset on yellow‐bellied toad (Bombina variegata) populations, an amphibian species whose life history depends on human land use. We estimated stage‐specific survival and recruitment for 18 populations across different habitat types. We then assessed how estimated population growth rates and elasticities changed when population‐specific vital rates were replaced by estimates from other populations, chosen randomly or based on habitat, demographic or geographic proximity. The use of hybrid matrices mixing demographic estimates from different populations and habitats biased predictions. The mean bias was relatively minor even when sampling randomly across all populations, because our large dataset represented the whole range of life histories and errors cancelled out on average. However, borrowing estimates from geographically close or demographically similar populations substantially reduced the risk of extreme errors. Borrowing from populations from similar habitat types could also reduce bias, but results varied depending on the exact habitat types concerned. Our study illustrates how habitat‐specific among‐population variation in life history affects the reliability of population matrices commonly used in evolutionary demography, ecology and conservation. When the use of hybrid population matrices cannot be avoided, their creation can be informed by additional information about ecological or demographic patterns, helping reduce bias. When such information is not available, we recommend that studies should consider the whole space of parameter estimates (the complete range of estimates available), thus transparently describing the true uncertainty surrounding demographic estimates.
- Open Access
- 26 November 2024
- Published by Firenze University Press in Acta Herpetologica
- Vol. 19 (2) , 155-159
Uncertain future and uncertain projections: assessing extinction risks in European salamanders from projected chytrid fungus invasion using IUCN Criterion E
Amphibians are among the most threatened vertebrates globally, and their conservation status continues to decline. In the updated Global Amphibian Assessment (GAA2), the use of IUCN Criterion E, which projects extinction risks through quantitative models, highlighted southern Europe as a hotspot for salamander extinction risk due to the risk of invasion by the fungal pathogen Batrachochytrium salamandrivorans (Bsal). In particular, for five Italian salamander species, risk categories were elevated significantly based on Criterion E, from Vulnerable or lower to Endangered or Critically Endangered. This increased reliance on Criterion E raises concerns regarding its treatment of uncertainty, as these projections depend heavily on assumptions about Bsal spread, environmental suitability, and host dynamics. Limited exploration of alternative scenarios and reliance on extreme parameter values may result in inflated extinction risk estimates. We emphasize the need for improved documentation of uncertainty and integration of diverse expert opinions in extinction risk assessments, to balance proactive conservation planning with robust scientific methodology.
- 26 November 2024
- Published by Firenze University Press in Acta Herpetologica
- Vol. 19 (2) , 155-159
Open AccessUncertain future and uncertain projections: assessing extinction risks in European salamanders from projected chytrid fungus invasion using IUCN Criterion E
Amphibians are among the most threatened vertebrates globally, and their conservation status continues to decline. In the updated Global Amphibian Assessment (GAA2), the use of IUCN Criterion E, which projects extinction risks through quantitative models, highlighted southern Europe as a hotspot for salamander extinction risk due to the risk of invasion by the fungal pathogen Batrachochytrium salamandrivorans (Bsal). In particular, for five Italian salamander species, risk categories were elevated significantly based on Criterion E, from Vulnerable or lower to Endangered or Critically Endangered. This increased reliance on Criterion E raises concerns regarding its treatment of uncertainty, as these projections depend heavily on assumptions about Bsal spread, environmental suitability, and host dynamics. Limited exploration of alternative scenarios and reliance on extreme parameter values may result in inflated extinction risk estimates. We emphasize the need for improved documentation of uncertainty and integration of diverse expert opinions in extinction risk assessments, to balance proactive conservation planning with robust scientific methodology.