Francis Villablanca
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Francis Villablanca has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- William Timothy Bean
California Polytechnic State University
2 shared publications - Ashley Fisher
Biological Sciences Department, Cal Poly State University, San Luis Obispo, CA 93407, USA
1 shared publication - Ashley R. Fisher
Department of Biological Sciences, California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, CA 93407, USA
1 shared publication - Charis Van der Heide
Biological Sciences Department, Cal Poly State University, San Luis Obispo, CA 93407, USA
1 shared publication - Daniel Meade
Althouse and Meade Inc., 1602 Spring St., Paso Robles, CA 93446, USA
1 shared publication Gabriel Marcelo Santos-Elizondo
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Does Wind Disrupt Overwintering Monarch Butterfly Clusters? An Observational Study of Western Monarchs
Wind protection is a central focus of western monarch butterfly (Danaus plexippus) overwintering habitat conservation. The Wind Disruption Hypothesis guiding management decisions predicts that winds at or above 2 m/s disrupt clusters and that cluster abundance decreases as wind speed increases. At two California groves during the 2023–2024 overwintering season, we paired time-lapse estimates of visible cluster size with nearby measurements of maximum wind gust. Stronger gusts were not consistently followed by decreases over 30-min or next-day response windows. In the 30-min analysis, the wind association depended on approximate local temperature and whether visible butterflies were in direct sunlight. Stronger gusts were associated with declines under cool, sunny conditions and increases under warm, sunny conditions. No clear wind association was detected when no visible butterflies were in direct sunlight. The next-day analysis likewise indicated that the wind association varied with sun exposure. Nearby maximum gusts did not measure sustained exposure at butterfly positions, so this was not an exact test of the historical threshold. The results did not support the predicted consistent decline with increasing wind under the monitored conditions. Physiological responses to interacting wind, ambient temperature, and solar exposure offer a plausible hypothesis for future research.
Open AccessDoes Wind Disrupt Overwintering Monarch Butterfly Clusters? An Observational Study of Western Monarchs
Wind protection is a central focus of western monarch butterfly (Danaus plexippus) overwintering habitat conservation. The Wind Disruption Hypothesis guiding management decisions predicts that winds at or above 2 m/s disrupt clusters and that cluster abundance decreases as wind speed increases. At two California groves during the 2023–2024 overwintering season, we paired time-lapse estimates of visible cluster size with nearby measurements of maximum wind gust. Stronger gusts were not consistently followed by decreases over 30-min or next-day response windows. In the 30-min analysis, the wind association depended on approximate local temperature and whether visible butterflies were in direct sunlight. Stronger gusts were associated with declines under cool, sunny conditions and increases under warm, sunny conditions. No clear wind association was detected when no visible butterflies were in direct sunlight. The next-day analysis likewise indicated that the wind association varied with sun exposure. Nearby maximum gusts did not measure sustained exposure at butterfly positions, so this was not an exact test of the historical threshold. The results did not support the predicted consistent decline with increasing wind under the monitored conditions. Physiological responses to interacting wind, ambient temperature, and solar exposure offer a plausible hypothesis for future research.
- Open Access
A Multi-Scale Species Distribution Model for Migrating and Overwintering Western Monarch Butterflies: Climate Is the Best Predictor
Western Monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus) migrate from inland breeding ranges to coastal overwintering grounds in California. Given that migratory individuals may make multi-scale habitat selection decisions, we considered a multi-scale species distribution model (SDM) using range-wide climatic and local landscape-level predictors of migratory and overwintering habitat and community-science presence data. The range-wide model output was included as a predictor in the local-scale model, generating multi-scale habitat suitability. The top range-wide predictor was the minimum temperature in December, contributing 83.7% to the model, and was positively associated with presence. At the local scale, the strongest predictors of presence were the range-wide output and percent coverage of low and medium levels of development, contributing > 95%, with 61–63% from the range-wide output, with local-scale suitability coinciding with the California coastal zones. Development’s positive association with overwintering monarch presence was counterintuitive. It is likely that our local-scale model is overfit to these development zones, but it is unclear whether this overfitting resulted from modeler choices, monarchs overwintering close to human development, biased detection near human development, or a combination of these factors. Therefore, alternative approaches to collecting local-scale attribute data are suggested while recognizing the primacy of climate in restricting overwinter sites.
Open AccessA Multi-Scale Species Distribution Model for Migrating and Overwintering Western Monarch Butterflies: Climate Is the Best Predictor
Western Monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus) migrate from inland breeding ranges to coastal overwintering grounds in California. Given that migratory individuals may make multi-scale habitat selection decisions, we considered a multi-scale species distribution model (SDM) using range-wide climatic and local landscape-level predictors of migratory and overwintering habitat and community-science presence data. The range-wide model output was included as a predictor in the local-scale model, generating multi-scale habitat suitability. The top range-wide predictor was the minimum temperature in December, contributing 83.7% to the model, and was positively associated with presence. At the local scale, the strongest predictors of presence were the range-wide output and percent coverage of low and medium levels of development, contributing > 95%, with 61–63% from the range-wide output, with local-scale suitability coinciding with the California coastal zones. Development’s positive association with overwintering monarch presence was counterintuitive. It is likely that our local-scale model is overfit to these development zones, but it is unclear whether this overfitting resulted from modeler choices, monarchs overwintering close to human development, biased detection near human development, or a combination of these factors. Therefore, alternative approaches to collecting local-scale attribute data are suggested while recognizing the primacy of climate in restricting overwinter sites.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 12, 1359201
Detecting and monitoring rodents using camera traps and machine learning versus live trapping for occupancy modeling
Determining best methods to detect individuals and monitor populations that balance effort and efficiency can assist conservation and land management. This may be especially true for small, non-charismatic species, such as rodents (Rodentia), which comprise 39% of all mammal species. Given the importance of rodents to ecosystems, and the number of listed species, we tested two commonly used detection and monitoring methods, live traps and camera traps, to determine their efficiency in rodents. An artificial-intelligence machine-learning model was developed to process the camera trap images and identify the species within them which reduced camera trapping effort. We used occupancy models to compare probability of detection and occupancy estimates for six rodent species across the two methods. Camera traps yielded greater detection probability and occupancy estimates for all six species. Live trapping yielded biasedly low estimates of occupancy, required greater effort, and had a lower probability of detection. Camera traps, aimed at the ground to capture the dorsal view of an individual, combined with machine learning provided a practical, noninvasive, and low effort solution to detecting and monitoring rodents. Thus, camera trapping with machine learning is a more sustainable and practical solution for the conservation and land management of rodents.
- 22 May 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 12, 1359201
Open AccessDetecting and monitoring rodents using camera traps and machine learning versus live trapping for occupancy modeling
Determining best methods to detect individuals and monitor populations that balance effort and efficiency can assist conservation and land management. This may be especially true for small, non-charismatic species, such as rodents (Rodentia), which comprise 39% of all mammal species. Given the importance of rodents to ecosystems, and the number of listed species, we tested two commonly used detection and monitoring methods, live traps and camera traps, to determine their efficiency in rodents. An artificial-intelligence machine-learning model was developed to process the camera trap images and identify the species within them which reduced camera trapping effort. We used occupancy models to compare probability of detection and occupancy estimates for six rodent species across the two methods. Camera traps yielded greater detection probability and occupancy estimates for all six species. Live trapping yielded biasedly low estimates of occupancy, required greater effort, and had a lower probability of detection. Camera traps, aimed at the ground to capture the dorsal view of an individual, combined with machine learning provided a practical, noninvasive, and low effort solution to detecting and monitoring rodents. Thus, camera trapping with machine learning is a more sustainable and practical solution for the conservation and land management of rodents.
- Open Access
Determining Extinction for Small Cryptic Species: The Morro Bay Kangaroo Rat
One third of missing mammal species thought to be extinct have been rediscovered. Determining extinction correctly, without misinterpreting negative evidence, is difficult and takes significant effort, especially for small, cryptic species. The Morro Bay kangaroo rat (MBKR), Dipodomys heermanni morroensis, is a small nocturnal rodent suspected of being extinct. This is because it has not been seen since 1986 despite three range-wide surveys conducted between 1995 and 2012, a recent scent-detecting dog survey, and over a dozen localized surveys. Causes of decline have been reported and the primary causes are thought to be development-driven habitat loss and ecological succession. Given this, we suspect that if the MBKR is extant, then it occurs in the periphery of its historical range. We summarize a survey of the Morro Bay sandspit, an area not previously considered part of MBKR’s range but that has the potential to be occupied. Inferences from the subspecies’ closest relative, Dipodomys heermanni arenae, were used to inform surveys and detection probability estimates for MBKR. Visual surveys of the sandspit in areas with the greatest probability of displaying signs yielded few occurrences of possible signs. Camera traps were deployed in winter and summer at locations with possible signs, but, despite occupancy model detection probabilities of 0.88 in winter and 0.97 in summer, there were no detections of MBKR. Given detection probability estimates inferred from Dipodomys heermanni arenae, the conditional occupancy estimate that MBKR are present on the sandspit but were missed by all cameras on all nights of surveying is extremely low (5 × 10−6). We conclude that the MBKR is not present on the Morro Bay sandspit, at least not in the habitat where its presence was most likely to be detected. Future surveys for this small, cryptic species will need to adapt to a combination of low expected occupancy and high expected detection probability.
Open AccessDetermining Extinction for Small Cryptic Species: The Morro Bay Kangaroo Rat
One third of missing mammal species thought to be extinct have been rediscovered. Determining extinction correctly, without misinterpreting negative evidence, is difficult and takes significant effort, especially for small, cryptic species. The Morro Bay kangaroo rat (MBKR), Dipodomys heermanni morroensis, is a small nocturnal rodent suspected of being extinct. This is because it has not been seen since 1986 despite three range-wide surveys conducted between 1995 and 2012, a recent scent-detecting dog survey, and over a dozen localized surveys. Causes of decline have been reported and the primary causes are thought to be development-driven habitat loss and ecological succession. Given this, we suspect that if the MBKR is extant, then it occurs in the periphery of its historical range. We summarize a survey of the Morro Bay sandspit, an area not previously considered part of MBKR’s range but that has the potential to be occupied. Inferences from the subspecies’ closest relative, Dipodomys heermanni arenae, were used to inform surveys and detection probability estimates for MBKR. Visual surveys of the sandspit in areas with the greatest probability of displaying signs yielded few occurrences of possible signs. Camera traps were deployed in winter and summer at locations with possible signs, but, despite occupancy model detection probabilities of 0.88 in winter and 0.97 in summer, there were no detections of MBKR. Given detection probability estimates inferred from Dipodomys heermanni arenae, the conditional occupancy estimate that MBKR are present on the sandspit but were missed by all cameras on all nights of surveying is extremely low (5 × 10−6). We conclude that the MBKR is not present on the Morro Bay sandspit, at least not in the habitat where its presence was most likely to be detected. Future surveys for this small, cryptic species will need to adapt to a combination of low expected occupancy and high expected detection probability.
- Open Access
- 16 May 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Conservation Science
- Vol. 3
Hierarchy and Scale Influence the Western Monarch Butterfly Overwintering Microclimate
Migratory species are expected to demonstrate habitat selection that occurs at multiple spatial and temporal scales. Western monarch butterflies migrate seasonally to overwintering groves at geographically predictable locations along the coast of California. To date, overwintering habitat selection by western monarch butterflies has primarily been studied assuming the microclimate hypothesis. Specifically, that microclimate habitat selection occurs when monarchs form dense overwintering aggregations in overwintering groves. However, western monarch butterflies are migratory; thus, previous habitat selection studies could have commingled selection at different scales into a single local scale in the site of aggregation. Therefore, we explore monarch overwintering habitat selection to determine whether an explicit spatial framework is necessary. We studied nine groves on the coast of California, and at each we collected temperature, humidity, and light data from grove edges, grove interiors, and aggregation locations for several weeks during the overwintering season. We tested the hypothesis that monarchs aggregate in locations in groves that have a unique microclimate that is consistently selected across groves (the microclimate hypothesis). We find no evidence supporting the hypothesis that aggregation locations have a unique microclimate that differs significantly from that of other locations inside the grove or that aggregation locations are uniform in their microclimatic attributes across overwintering groves. Rather, we find that microclimatic attributes in aggregation locations vary spatially with latitude, and that aggregation conditions exist in a large portion of each grove. We conclude that it will be necessary to consider spatial effects when studying or managing western monarch butterfly overwintering habitats, and that interpretations of habitat selection to date likely commingle habitat selection on the local and geographical scales.
- 16 May 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Conservation Science
- Vol. 3
Open AccessHierarchy and Scale Influence the Western Monarch Butterfly Overwintering Microclimate
Migratory species are expected to demonstrate habitat selection that occurs at multiple spatial and temporal scales. Western monarch butterflies migrate seasonally to overwintering groves at geographically predictable locations along the coast of California. To date, overwintering habitat selection by western monarch butterflies has primarily been studied assuming the microclimate hypothesis. Specifically, that microclimate habitat selection occurs when monarchs form dense overwintering aggregations in overwintering groves. However, western monarch butterflies are migratory; thus, previous habitat selection studies could have commingled selection at different scales into a single local scale in the site of aggregation. Therefore, we explore monarch overwintering habitat selection to determine whether an explicit spatial framework is necessary. We studied nine groves on the coast of California, and at each we collected temperature, humidity, and light data from grove edges, grove interiors, and aggregation locations for several weeks during the overwintering season. We tested the hypothesis that monarchs aggregate in locations in groves that have a unique microclimate that is consistently selected across groves (the microclimate hypothesis). We find no evidence supporting the hypothesis that aggregation locations have a unique microclimate that differs significantly from that of other locations inside the grove or that aggregation locations are uniform in their microclimatic attributes across overwintering groves. Rather, we find that microclimatic attributes in aggregation locations vary spatially with latitude, and that aggregation conditions exist in a large portion of each grove. We conclude that it will be necessary to consider spatial effects when studying or managing western monarch butterfly overwintering habitats, and that interpretations of habitat selection to date likely commingle habitat selection on the local and geographical scales.
- Open Access
Climatic Niche Model for Overwintering Monarch Butterflies in a Topographically Complex Region of California
We use climatic conditions that are associated with known monarch butterfly overwintering groves in California to build a Maxent model, and focus on the fine scale probability of overwintering grove occurrence in a topographically complex region of the state (Santa Barbara County). Grove locations are known from recent and historical surveys and a long-term citizen science database. The climatic niche model performs well, predicting that overwintering habitat is most likely to occur along the coast and at low elevations, as shown by empirical data. We then use climatic variables in conjunction with climate change scenarios to model the future location of overwintering habitat, and find a substantial shift in the predicted distribution. Under a plausible scenario, the probability of occurrence of overwintering habitat directly reflects elevation, with coastal regions having a reduced probability relative to today, and higher elevation sites increasing in probability. Under a more extreme scenario, high probability sites are only located along ridgelines and in mountaintop regions of the county. This predicted shift in distribution is likely to have management implications, as sites that currently lack monarchs may become critical to conservation in the future. Our results suggest that estimating the size of the western overwintering population in the future will be problematic, unless annual counts compensate for a shift in the distribution and a potential change in the number and location of occupied sites.
Open AccessClimatic Niche Model for Overwintering Monarch Butterflies in a Topographically Complex Region of California
We use climatic conditions that are associated with known monarch butterfly overwintering groves in California to build a Maxent model, and focus on the fine scale probability of overwintering grove occurrence in a topographically complex region of the state (Santa Barbara County). Grove locations are known from recent and historical surveys and a long-term citizen science database. The climatic niche model performs well, predicting that overwintering habitat is most likely to occur along the coast and at low elevations, as shown by empirical data. We then use climatic variables in conjunction with climate change scenarios to model the future location of overwintering habitat, and find a substantial shift in the predicted distribution. Under a plausible scenario, the probability of occurrence of overwintering habitat directly reflects elevation, with coastal regions having a reduced probability relative to today, and higher elevation sites increasing in probability. Under a more extreme scenario, high probability sites are only located along ridgelines and in mountaintop regions of the county. This predicted shift in distribution is likely to have management implications, as sites that currently lack monarchs may become critical to conservation in the future. Our results suggest that estimating the size of the western overwintering population in the future will be problematic, unless annual counts compensate for a shift in the distribution and a potential change in the number and location of occupied sites.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Queen's University Library in Ideas in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 11 (1) , 19-28
Meiosis decreases recombination load; Mitosis increases recombination load
Chiasmata are necessary for proper chromosomal segregation, but can result in inadvertent recombination. Bernstein and Michod demonstrated that meiosis evolved as a means of error correction, not genetic mixing. Therefore meiotic recombination is not the sine qua non of sex, but is instead an epiphenomenon of imperfect meiotic error correction. By correcting against recombinant genotypes, meiosis reduces recombination load, thereby providing an unappreciated selective advantage for sex. Sex reducing recombination load should be integrated into population genetic models of multi-locus epistasis for maintenance of sex and may explain sequestration of germ lines in animals. We predict that eumetazoa have less recombination load than sexual organisms without a germ line. Mitosis largely lacks the error correction of meiosis, destroys linkage through ubiquitous mitotic recombination, and thereby increases recombination load, especially in co-adapted gene complexes. Meiosis and possibly karyogamy provide an unexpected benefit to sex, offsetting at least some of the famed costs of sex.
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Queen's University Library in Ideas in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 11 (1) , 19-28
Open AccessMeiosis decreases recombination load; Mitosis increases recombination load
Chiasmata are necessary for proper chromosomal segregation, but can result in inadvertent recombination. Bernstein and Michod demonstrated that meiosis evolved as a means of error correction, not genetic mixing. Therefore meiotic recombination is not the sine qua non of sex, but is instead an epiphenomenon of imperfect meiotic error correction. By correcting against recombinant genotypes, meiosis reduces recombination load, thereby providing an unappreciated selective advantage for sex. Sex reducing recombination load should be integrated into population genetic models of multi-locus epistasis for maintenance of sex and may explain sequestration of germ lines in animals. We predict that eumetazoa have less recombination load than sexual organisms without a germ line. Mitosis largely lacks the error correction of meiosis, destroys linkage through ubiquitous mitotic recombination, and thereby increases recombination load, especially in co-adapted gene complexes. Meiosis and possibly karyogamy provide an unexpected benefit to sex, offsetting at least some of the famed costs of sex.