PVPertti Vakkari

Pertti Vakkari

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Pertti Vakkari has a total of 62 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The degree of knowledge gain metric: Evaluating how searchers acquire new information while searching online

    by Marcelo Tibau, Sean Wolfgand Matsui Siqueira, Bernardo Pereira Nunes, Pertti Vakkari

    This study presents the degree of knowledge gain, a behavioral metric that estimates how much searchers learn during Web searches. Grounded in information theory and Shannon entropy, the metric quantifies reductions in uncertainty by analyzing query reformulations, clicks, and document positions, avoiding reliance on pre/post-testing or self-reports. The metric was validated with a cohort of legal professionals who completed three domain-specific search tasks on a national legal platform. Behavioral coding of think-aloud sessions and statistical tests (analysis of variance; Spearman rank correlation) demonstrated strong positive correlations between the degree of knowledge gain and conventional transfer of learning scores, with structured tasks producing the highest gains. This approach offers an automated, scalable indicator of learning, enriching the Searching as Learning paradigm and enabling real-time adaptation in personalized search, intelligent tutoring, and conversational systems.

  • Open Access

    LIS Research 1965-2025: a content analysis of topics and methods in journal articles

    by Kalervo Järvelin, Pertti Vakkari

    Purpose: The paper analyses the research in Library and Information Science (LIS) in 2025 and the evolution of LIS research longitudinally from 1965 to 2025. Design/methodology/approach: The study employs a quantitative intellectual content analysis of articles published in ∼30 scholarly LIS journals, following the design by Jarvelin and Vakkari (2022). In content analysis, articles are classified using a multi-dimensional faceted classification covering topical content and methodology. The classification schedules and the journal set are held stable through the years. The classification serves as an explicit definition of the scope of LIS. Findings: The study indicates that the trend of diminishing focus in LIS on Library and information (L&I) services has accelerated, while scientific and professional communication (S&PC) has become the most popular topic. Information storage and retrieval (IS&R) has lost its earlier strong position toward the end of the analysed period. LIS research is methodologically increasingly varied since survey, scientometric methods, experiment, case studies and qualitative studies have all gained in popularity. Consequently, LIS may have become over the years more versatile in the analysis of its research objects. As concrete evidence of change, in all 41% of top-journal articles fell outside LIS topics in 2025. This reflects changing research paradigms and publisher interest. Originality/value: Among quantitative intellectual content analyses of LIS research, the study is unique in its scope: length of analysis period (60 years); width (5 dimensions covering topical content and methodology) and depth (the annual batch of ∼30 scholarly journals).

  • Open Access

    Leveraging search engines and LLMs for creative thinking: effects of prompting skills, and domain knowledge

    by I-Chin Wu, Hsuan-Yu Lin, Pertti Vakkari

    Introduction. We investigated the effects of domain knowledge (DK) and prompting skills by leveraging a traditional search engine and a prompt-based LLM chatbot for a learning-oriented creative task. Method. On a simulated curated calligraphy exhibition task for which one must integrate DK and creativity to write summaries of curatorial planning, we observed behavior when using the NPM Collection, Google Search, and ChatGPT. We assessed the creative thinking demonstrated in the final summaries. User perception of tools supporting creative thinking was evaluated by the creativity support index. Analysis. We analysed information source usage behavior using descriptive statistical analysis and significance testing and used regression analysis to examine the predictive power of tool usage behavior, domain knowledge, and prompting skills for summary writing. Results. We discovered a positive predictive effect of DK and ChatGPT usage on the quality of curatorial planning summaries. Better prompting skills enhanced task performance and perceived creativity. For creative thinking, Google seemed to better foster exploration than ChatGPT. Conclusions. Prompt-based LLM chatbots support learning-oriented creative tasks. As prompting skills are essential, prompting should be integrated into information literacy education. The study provides implications for the design of search systems in human–information retrieval–LLM interaction to better support creative tasks.

  • Open Access

    Una ley para 4.590 bibliotecas. El caso de Finlandia como oportunidad para España con un análisis basado en indicadores de esfuerzo

    by Pedro Lázaro-Rodríguez, Pertti Vakkari

    Se lleva a cabo un ejercicio de evaluación en el contexto de la biblioteconomía internacional comparativa analizando los sistemas de bibliotecas públicas de España y Finlandia. El análisis se basa en los indicadores de esfuerzo en presupuesto, préstamos y visitas a nivel de comunidades autónomas (España) y regiones (Finlandia) entre 2010 y 2023. Los resultados permiten concluir que Finlandia cuenta con un sistema de bibliotecas uniforme y homogéneo, mientras que en España la situación es más variable y heterogénea. Estas conclusiones se ponen en relación con el hecho de que Finlandia cuenta con una ley de bibliotecas a nivel de país, mientras que España no. Se contextualizan los resultados para cada caso profundizando en aspectos clave y se plantea la cuestión de si en España sería posible, preferible y/o efectiva una ley a nivel de estado que regule la provisión de recursos para bibliotecas públicas según criterios como los que se marcan en Finlandia.

  • Open Access

    Comparing representations of a discipline derived through LDA vs. intellectual content analysis: the case of information science

    by Kaisa Ylikruuvi, Kalervo Järvelin, Pertti Vakkari, Martti Juhola

    The paper looks at the methodology of empirical analyses of the content and structure of Information Science (IS). The traditional approach in empirical analysis is intellectual content analysis (ICA) of a representative data set. The high labor cost prohibits the analysis of massive data sets. A recent alternative is based on data mining/machine learning. Its strength is the capability of analyzing massive datasets efficiently. However, a significant issue is the quality of content analysis. The paper compares latent Dirichlet allocation/topic modeling (LDA/TM) based statistical analysis to ICA using the same data set, 1514 scholarly articles from the year 2015 volumes of 30 IS journals. The intellectual analysis provides the mirror for reflecting the TM results. LDA/TM is strong in identifying new directions of a discipline and processing masses of text. Its weaknesses include semantic haziness of topics due to bag-of-words article representation, text pre-processing, tuning of parameters, and being unanalytic in composing topics from words belonging to different categories.


  • Open Access

    Who cites the contributions by information science?

    by Kalervo Järvelin, Pertti Vakkari

    Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to find out which research topics and methods in information science (IS) articles are used in other disciplines as indicated by citations.Design/methodology/approach: The study analyzes citations to articles in IS published in 31 scholarly IS journals in 2015. The study employs content analysis of articles published in 2015 receiving citations from publication venues representing IS and other disciplines in the citation window 2015–2021. The unit of analysis is the article-citing discipline pair. The data set consists of 1178 IS articles cited altogether 25 K times through 5 K publication venues. Each citation is seen as a contribution to the citing document’s discipline by the cited article, which represents some IS subareas and methodologies, and the author team's disciplinary composition, which is inferred from the authors’ affiliations.Findings: The results show that the citation profiles of disciplines vary depending on research topics, methods and author disciplines. Disciplines external to IS are typically cited in IS articles authored by scholars with the same background. Thus, the export of ideas from IS to other disciplines is evidently smaller than the earlier findings claim. IS should not be credited for contributions by other disciplines published in IS literature.Originality/value: This study is the first to analyze which research topics and methods in the articles of IS are of use in other disciplines as indicated by citations.


  • Open Access

    What characterizes LIS as a fragmenting discipline?

    by Pertti Vakkari

    Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to characterize library and information science (LIS) as fragmenting discipline both historically and by applying Whitley’s (1984) theory about the organization of sciences and Fuchs’ (1993) theory about scientific change.Design/methodology/approach: The study combines historical source analysis with conceptual and theoretical analysis for characterizing LIS. An attempt is made to empirically validate the distinction between LIS context, L&I services and information seeking as fragmented adhocracies and information retrieval and scientific communication (scientometrics) as technologically integrated bureaucracies.Findings: The origin of fragmentation in LIS due the contributions of other disciplines can be traced in the 1960s and 1970s for solving the problems produced by the growth of scientific literature. Computer science and business established academic programs and started research relevant to LIS community focusing on information retrieval and bibliometrics. This has led to differing research interests between LIS and other disciplines concerning research topics and methods. LIS has been characterized as fragmented adhocracy as a whole, but we make a distinction between research topics LIS context, L&I services and information seeking as fragmented adhocracies and information retrieval and scientific communication (scientometrics) as technologically integrated bureaucracies.Originality/value: The paper provides an elaborated historical perspective on the fragmentation of LIS in the pressure of other disciplines. It also characterizes LIS as discipline in a fresh way by applying Whitley’s (1984) theory.


  • An exploration of search-as-learning in digital archives of an online museum

    by I-Chin Wu, Pertti Vakkari, Bo-Xian Huang

    Purpose: Recent studies on search-as-learning (SAL) have recognized the significance of identifying users' learning needs as they evolve for acquiring knowledge during the search process. In this study, the authors clarify the extent to which search behaviors reflect the learning outcome and foster the users' knowledge of Chinese art.Design/methodology/approach: The authors conducted an exploratory-sequential mixed-methods approach using simulated work task situations to collect empirical data. The authors used two types of simulated learning tasks for topics related to painting and antique knowledge. A lot of 25 users participated in this evaluation of digital archives (DAs) at the National Palace Museum (NPM) in Taiwan. For each set of topics, a close-ended task related to lower-level learning goals and an open-ended task related to higher-level learning goals.Findings: The learning criteria reflect changes in the users' knowledge structure, revealing the SAL process. Furthermore, users achieved better task performance on the higher-level creative-learning task, which suggests that they met more learning criteria, exhibited a greater variety of search patterns when exploring the topics via interaction with various sources. Finally, there is a close relationship between creative-learning tasks, prior knowledge, keyword search actions and learning outcomes.Originality/value: The authors discuss implications with respect to the design of DAs in practice and contributions to the body of SAL knowledge in DAs of online museums. For future reference, the authors provide implications for the development of learning measures from the perspective of user search behavior with associated learning outcomes in the context of DAs.


  • Open Access

    The association of disciplinary background with the evolution of topics and methods in Library and Information Science research 1995–2015

    by Pertti Vakkari, Kalervo Järvelin, Yu‐Wei Chang

    The paper reports a longitudinal analysis of the topical and methodological development of Library and Information Science (LIS). Its focus is on the effects of researchers' disciplines on these developments. The study extends an earlier cross‐sectional study (Vakkari et al., Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2022a, 73, 1706–1722) by a coordinated dataset representing a content analysis of articles published in 31 scholarly LIS journals in 1995, 2005, and 2015. It is novel in its coverage of authors' disciplines, topical and methodological aspects in a coordinated dataset spanning two decades thus allowing trend analysis. The findings include a shrinking trend in the share of LIS from 67 to 36% while Computer Science, and Business and Economics increase their share from 9 and 6% to 21 and 16%, respectively. The earlier cross‐sectional study (Vakkari et al., Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2022a, 73, 1706–1722) for the year 2015 identified three topical clusters of LIS research, focusing on topical subfields, methodologies, and contributing disciplines. Correspondence analysis confirms their existence already in 1995 and traces their development through the decades. The contributing disciplines infuse their concepts, research questions, and approaches to LIS and may also subsume vital parts of LIS in their own structures of knowledge production.


  • Open Access

    Characteristics of LIS Research Articles Affecting Their Citation Impact

    by Kalervo Jarvelin, Yu-Wei Chang, Pertti Vakkari

    The paper analyses the citation impact of Library and Information Science, LIS for short, research articles published in 31 leading international LIS journals in 2015. The main research question is: to what degree do authors' disciplinary composition in association with other content characteristics of LIS articles affect their citation impact? The impact is analysed in terms of the number of citations received and their authority, using outlier normalization and subfield normalization. The article characteristics analysed using quantitative content analysis include topic, methodology, type of contribution, and the disciplinary composition of their author teams. The citations received by the articles are traced from 2015 to May 2021. Citing document authority is measured by the citations they had received up to May 2021. The overall finding was that authors' disciplinary composition is significantly associated with citation scores. The differences in citation scores between disciplinary compositions appeared typically within information retrieval and scientific communication. In both topics LIS and computer science jointly received significantly higher citation scores than many disciplines like LIS alone or humanities in information retrieval, or natural sciences, medicine, or social sciences alone in scientific communication. The paper is original in allowing joint analysis of content, authorship composition, and impact.