Hao Zhang
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Hao Zhang has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anatole Boute
The Chinese University of Hong Kong
1 shared publication - Barry Barton
University of Waikato
1 shared publication - Damilola S. Olawuyi
Hamad Bin Khalifa University
1 shared publication - Hanri Mostert
University of Cape Town
1 shared publication Haomiao Du
Utrecht Centre for Water, Oceans and Sustainability Law Utrecht University Utrecht The Netherlands
1 shared publication- Kaisa Huhta
University of Eastern Finland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- p. 1-8
Sustainable distributed energy resources: law and policy (Oxford University Press, 2026)
1. In May 2026, at the Biennial Conference of the International Bar Association (IBA)’s Section on Energy, Environment, Natural Resources and Infrastructure Law (SEERIL),1 the Academic Advisory Gro...
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- p. 1-8
Sustainable distributed energy resources: law and policy (Oxford University Press, 2026)
1. In May 2026, at the Biennial Conference of the International Bar Association (IBA)’s Section on Energy, Environment, Natural Resources and Infrastructure Law (SEERIL),1 the Academic Advisory Gro...
- 26 February 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 44 (4) , 613-628
Does Lliuya v RWE mark a turning point in climate litigation: examining the establishment of causation
On 28 May 2025, roughly a decade after the plaintiff first filed the lawsuit before the Essen Regional Court, the case of Saúl Luciano Lliuya v RWE AG (Lliuya)1 was finally decided by the Higher Re...
- 26 February 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 44 (4) , 613-628
Does Lliuya v RWE mark a turning point in climate litigation: examining the establishment of causation
On 28 May 2025, roughly a decade after the plaintiff first filed the lawsuit before the Essen Regional Court, the case of Saúl Luciano Lliuya v RWE AG (Lliuya)1 was finally decided by the Higher Re...
- Open Access
- 12 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 44 (1) , 67-93
Resilience of critical transition minerals supply chain in the context of strategic rivalry: implications for the national policy and regulatory frameworks
- 12 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 44 (1) , 67-93
Open AccessResilience of critical transition minerals supply chain in the context of strategic rivalry: implications for the national policy and regulatory frameworks
- Open Access
- 22 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in China-EU Law Journal
- p. 1-16
The impact of adjustment mechanisms on China’s ETS: lessons from the pilot programs
This article examines the adjustment mechanisms which have been designed and implemented under China’s experimentations with its emissions trading scheme (ETS). In China, several ETS pilot programs have adopted these mechanisms in the process of cap setting, allowance allocation and price regulation to allow regulatory intervention at different stages of the ETS operation to ensure that particular regulatory objectives are going to be achieved. Using doctrinal analysis, this article provides some critical insights into the specific regulatory design of the flexible mechanisms in China. It highlights their impact on regulatory stability and on the credibility of the ETS program. Considering that the ETS pilots are designed for and operated at local levels for the purpose of testing regulatory design and implementation in order to inform the policymakers at the central government when designing the national scheme, the lessons learned from the ETS pilots with respect to the adjustment mechanism are critical to fulfilling this strategy.
- 22 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in China-EU Law Journal
- p. 1-16
Open AccessThe impact of adjustment mechanisms on China’s ETS: lessons from the pilot programs
This article examines the adjustment mechanisms which have been designed and implemented under China’s experimentations with its emissions trading scheme (ETS). In China, several ETS pilot programs have adopted these mechanisms in the process of cap setting, allowance allocation and price regulation to allow regulatory intervention at different stages of the ETS operation to ensure that particular regulatory objectives are going to be achieved. Using doctrinal analysis, this article provides some critical insights into the specific regulatory design of the flexible mechanisms in China. It highlights their impact on regulatory stability and on the credibility of the ETS program. Considering that the ETS pilots are designed for and operated at local levels for the purpose of testing regulatory design and implementation in order to inform the policymakers at the central government when designing the national scheme, the lessons learned from the ETS pilots with respect to the adjustment mechanism are critical to fulfilling this strategy.
- 2 August 2022
- Published by Wiley in Review of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law
- Vol. 31 (3) , 495-509
Climate neutrality in the EU and China: An analysis of the stringency of targets and the adaptiveness of the relevant legal frameworks
The European Union (EU) and China have committed to achieving net‐zero emissions by 2050 and 2060, respectively. To explore the legal nature of these objectives and how the legal frameworks support their delivery, this article assesses the stringency of objectives and the adaptiveness of relevant legal frameworks. The former compares the objectives' bindingness, scope, prescriptiveness and precision of such obligations and compliance mechanisms. The latter compares the dynamism of mitigation policies and the legal institutions and processes that promote decarbonization. The article concludes that the climate neutrality objective is enshrined in the EU's climate law framework with a high degree of stringency overall. By contrast, China mainly incorporates the targets into administrative measures, the cadre responsibility and evaluation system, lacking formal rules and robust enforcement. By accelerating legal reform to integrate carbon neutrality into relevant regulatory instruments and addressing implementation problems, China explores its distinctive pathway to delivering on the objective.
- 2 August 2022
- Published by Wiley in Review of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law
- Vol. 31 (3) , 495-509
Climate neutrality in the EU and China: An analysis of the stringency of targets and the adaptiveness of the relevant legal frameworks
The European Union (EU) and China have committed to achieving net‐zero emissions by 2050 and 2060, respectively. To explore the legal nature of these objectives and how the legal frameworks support their delivery, this article assesses the stringency of objectives and the adaptiveness of relevant legal frameworks. The former compares the objectives' bindingness, scope, prescriptiveness and precision of such obligations and compliance mechanisms. The latter compares the dynamism of mitigation policies and the legal institutions and processes that promote decarbonization. The article concludes that the climate neutrality objective is enshrined in the EU's climate law framework with a high degree of stringency overall. By contrast, China mainly incorporates the targets into administrative measures, the cadre responsibility and evaluation system, lacking formal rules and robust enforcement. By accelerating legal reform to integrate carbon neutrality into relevant regulatory instruments and addressing implementation problems, China explores its distinctive pathway to delivering on the objective.
- 6 June 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 41 (1) , 49-70
Stranded between political imperative and regulatory uncertainty: China’s move towards natural gas pricing reform
The Chinese government considers natural gas the preferred transition energy resource and is attempting to increase its proportion in China’s primary energy mix. In recent years, the reform of China’s natural gas sector has been steered towards breaking down vertical integration and developing a more market-based pricing system, the latter of which has long been subject to decisive government intervention. This article provides a comprehensive study of China’s gas pricing system through an analysis of policy and regulation. It shows that the previous reform was parochial and incremental, driven by the critical developmental conditions of China’s gas market. The gradual reform exemplifies the lack of systematic planning for the pricing reform and a relatively weak regulatory system. The latest reform has demonstrated a more systematic approach to restructuring China’s natural gas market with the improved political will to introduce competition into China’s gas market. However, the political imperative to reform natural gas pricing is challenged by the regulatory uncertainty rooted in the pre-existing conditions of China’s natural gas sector and the vested interest of industrial stakeholders. This article analyses the challenges of the latest reform to understand the limitations of the reform measures.
- 6 June 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 41 (1) , 49-70
Stranded between political imperative and regulatory uncertainty: China’s move towards natural gas pricing reform
The Chinese government considers natural gas the preferred transition energy resource and is attempting to increase its proportion in China’s primary energy mix. In recent years, the reform of China’s natural gas sector has been steered towards breaking down vertical integration and developing a more market-based pricing system, the latter of which has long been subject to decisive government intervention. This article provides a comprehensive study of China’s gas pricing system through an analysis of policy and regulation. It shows that the previous reform was parochial and incremental, driven by the critical developmental conditions of China’s gas market. The gradual reform exemplifies the lack of systematic planning for the pricing reform and a relatively weak regulatory system. The latest reform has demonstrated a more systematic approach to restructuring China’s natural gas market with the improved political will to introduce competition into China’s gas market. However, the political imperative to reform natural gas pricing is challenged by the regulatory uncertainty rooted in the pre-existing conditions of China’s natural gas sector and the vested interest of industrial stakeholders. This article analyses the challenges of the latest reform to understand the limitations of the reform measures.
- 2 May 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The Chinese Journal of Comparative Law
- Vol. 10 (2) , 246-273
Legal Enforcement of the National Emissions Trading Scheme and the Environmental Protection Tax in China: Heavy Hand or Light Touch?
This article evaluates the severity of legal enforcement measures for the 2021 National Carbon Emissions Trading Management (Trial) Measures (ETS Trial Measures) and the Environment Protection Tax (EPT) as a potential model or basis for carbon taxation. While the focus is on the content of specific regulatory provisions, evidence of enforcement action forms part of their evaluation. The ETS Trial Measures are compared to the enforcement provisions in Chinese regional emission-trading scheme (ETS) pilots, the 2019 and 2020 opinion solicitation drafts (OSDs), and the March 2021 OSD for a proposed State Council regulation, drawing on the scholarly literature and interviews in the specialist Chinese government and professional and research institutions. The current ETS enforcement measures are weaker and less comprehensive than those in some pilots and in all of the OSDs. Adopting measures recommended by interviewees as effective in the pilots could augment their stringency. The EPT has a stronger basis for enforcement through existing taxation and environmental laws. While its enforcement has been backed by an increasingly centralized environmental governance system, design elements that allow regional flexibility in implementation and inconsistent enforcement have reduced its effectiveness. These outcomes may be influenced by trade-offs between central government objectives and subnational economic and industrial priorities and resistance by powerful commercial interests. These limiting factors can be addressed by effective regulatory implementation, successful trading, and combining stringent penalties with measures that have a lighter touch, such as capacity building, leading to deepening acceptance by all stakeholders.
- 2 May 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The Chinese Journal of Comparative Law
- Vol. 10 (2) , 246-273
Legal Enforcement of the National Emissions Trading Scheme and the Environmental Protection Tax in China: Heavy Hand or Light Touch?
This article evaluates the severity of legal enforcement measures for the 2021 National Carbon Emissions Trading Management (Trial) Measures (ETS Trial Measures) and the Environment Protection Tax (EPT) as a potential model or basis for carbon taxation. While the focus is on the content of specific regulatory provisions, evidence of enforcement action forms part of their evaluation. The ETS Trial Measures are compared to the enforcement provisions in Chinese regional emission-trading scheme (ETS) pilots, the 2019 and 2020 opinion solicitation drafts (OSDs), and the March 2021 OSD for a proposed State Council regulation, drawing on the scholarly literature and interviews in the specialist Chinese government and professional and research institutions. The current ETS enforcement measures are weaker and less comprehensive than those in some pilots and in all of the OSDs. Adopting measures recommended by interviewees as effective in the pilots could augment their stringency. The EPT has a stronger basis for enforcement through existing taxation and environmental laws. While its enforcement has been backed by an increasingly centralized environmental governance system, design elements that allow regional flexibility in implementation and inconsistent enforcement have reduced its effectiveness. These outcomes may be influenced by trade-offs between central government objectives and subnational economic and industrial priorities and resistance by powerful commercial interests. These limiting factors can be addressed by effective regulatory implementation, successful trading, and combining stringent penalties with measures that have a lighter touch, such as capacity building, leading to deepening acceptance by all stakeholders.
- 2 January 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Asia Pacific Law Review
- Vol. 30 (1) , 167-187
Exploring energy resilience in China’s energy law in the carbon neutrality era
Through the lens of scholarly discussion on law, resilience, and adaptive capacity, this article critically discusses the extent to which energy law and governance in China has been steered towards better resilience. By looking at the laws and regulations in China’s electricity sector, this article argues that China’s efforts to create a more resilient and adaptive electric power system that can respond to disruptions is challenged by three key factors. The first of these is the historic focus in China on assuring adequate supplies of energy to support economic growth, an approach that relies more on the conventional aspect of the resilience theory, known as engineering resilience, rather than transformational resilience. The second factor is the multi-level and fragmented authoritarian governance structure in China’s energy sector that opens the door to local authorities and SOEs favouring especially coal generation and curtailing generation from renewable energy sources. Finally, the laws supporting the transition to a cleaner, lower carbon and more efficient energy system in China essential to transformational resilience need to be strictly enforced since the current enforcement regime has not achieved the desired result.
- 2 January 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Asia Pacific Law Review
- Vol. 30 (1) , 167-187
Exploring energy resilience in China’s energy law in the carbon neutrality era
Through the lens of scholarly discussion on law, resilience, and adaptive capacity, this article critically discusses the extent to which energy law and governance in China has been steered towards better resilience. By looking at the laws and regulations in China’s electricity sector, this article argues that China’s efforts to create a more resilient and adaptive electric power system that can respond to disruptions is challenged by three key factors. The first of these is the historic focus in China on assuring adequate supplies of energy to support economic growth, an approach that relies more on the conventional aspect of the resilience theory, known as engineering resilience, rather than transformational resilience. The second factor is the multi-level and fragmented authoritarian governance structure in China’s energy sector that opens the door to local authorities and SOEs favouring especially coal generation and curtailing generation from renewable energy sources. Finally, the laws supporting the transition to a cleaner, lower carbon and more efficient energy system in China essential to transformational resilience need to be strictly enforced since the current enforcement regime has not achieved the desired result.
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The Journal of World Energy Law & Business
- Vol. 14 (6) , 447-463
China’s natural gas sector regulation in the context of pipeline restructuring: towards independent gas pipeline operation?
The establishment of China National Oil and Gas Pipeline Network Corporation (PipeChina) is one of the most ambitious reforms of China’s oil and gas industry to date. As a cleaner type of fossil fuel, natural gas is considered the preferred transition energy resource during China’s transformation from fossil fuel-intensive to renewable energy. The strategic choice is to increase the proportion of natural gas in China’s primary energy portfolio. The creation of PipeChina, through acquiring the pipeline assets from the national oil companies, is an essential part of the reform agenda to increase natural gas supply and consumption through a monopoly and independent midstream sector. Accompanying this change is the promulgation of two sets of regulations governing a new transmission tariff regime and third-party access, respectively. Given the nascency of China’s gas pipeline restructuring, this article critically examines the regulations that underpin the independent operation of PipeChina. It discovers that enforcement of third-party access contradicts the existing regulations on gas concession rights. PipeChina’s independent operation is also likely to be challenged by the regulatory uncertainties identified by this study. Therefore, the success of PipeChina to achieve the reform objectives largely depends on how these challenges can be addressed appropriately in the process of ongoing reform.
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The Journal of World Energy Law & Business
- Vol. 14 (6) , 447-463
China’s natural gas sector regulation in the context of pipeline restructuring: towards independent gas pipeline operation?
The establishment of China National Oil and Gas Pipeline Network Corporation (PipeChina) is one of the most ambitious reforms of China’s oil and gas industry to date. As a cleaner type of fossil fuel, natural gas is considered the preferred transition energy resource during China’s transformation from fossil fuel-intensive to renewable energy. The strategic choice is to increase the proportion of natural gas in China’s primary energy portfolio. The creation of PipeChina, through acquiring the pipeline assets from the national oil companies, is an essential part of the reform agenda to increase natural gas supply and consumption through a monopoly and independent midstream sector. Accompanying this change is the promulgation of two sets of regulations governing a new transmission tariff regime and third-party access, respectively. Given the nascency of China’s gas pipeline restructuring, this article critically examines the regulations that underpin the independent operation of PipeChina. It discovers that enforcement of third-party access contradicts the existing regulations on gas concession rights. PipeChina’s independent operation is also likely to be challenged by the regulatory uncertainties identified by this study. Therefore, the success of PipeChina to achieve the reform objectives largely depends on how these challenges can be addressed appropriately in the process of ongoing reform.