Stephen Gauthier
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Stephen Gauthier has a total of 44 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Matthew Sibbald
McMaster University
4 shared publications - David R. Taylor
Queen's University
3 shared publications - Leslie Martin
Division of General Internal Medicine, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada
3 shared publications - Sarah Blissett
Department of Medicine, Division of Cardiology, Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada
3 shared publications - Allan S. Detsky
Institute for Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, and Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
2 shared publications - Andrew Koch Hall
Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (7) , 769-771
The best of both worlds: Assessing trainee progression in the era of competency based medical education
The authors suggest reducing the use of WBA where it is not fit for purpose and developing locally sustainable and defensible programs of assessment as steps towards unlocking the value of CBME.
- 10 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (7) , 769-771
Open AccessThe best of both worlds: Assessing trainee progression in the era of competency based medical education
The authors suggest reducing the use of WBA where it is not fit for purpose and developing locally sustainable and defensible programs of assessment as steps towards unlocking the value of CBME.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (3) , 308-317
Trainee selection of tasks in postgraduate medical education: Is there a role for ‘cherry‐picking’ to optimise learning?
Purpose: Learning is optimised when postgraduate trainees engage in clinical tasks in their zone of proximal development (ZPD). However, workplace learning environments impose additional non‐learning goals and additional tasks that may lead to trainees engaging in tasks that do not fall within their ZPD. We do not fully understand how trainees select clinical tasks in the workplace learning environment. If we knew the goals and factors they consider when selecting a task, we could better equip trainees with strategies to select tasks that maximise learning. We explored how postgraduate trainees select clinical tasks using echocardiography interpretation as a model. Methods: Canadian General Cardiology residents and Echocardiography fellows were invited to participate in semi‐structured interviews. Aligning with a theory‐informed study, two independent researchers used a deductive, directed content analysis approach to identify codes and themes. Results: Eleven trainees from seven Canadian universities participated (PGY4 = 4, PGY5 = 3, PGY6 = 1 and echocardiography fellows = 3). Goals included learning content, fulfilling assessment criteria and contributing to clinical demands. Trainees switched between goals throughout the day, as it was too effortful for them to engage in tasks within their ZPD at all times. When trainees had sufficient mental effort available, they selected higher complexity tasks that could advance learning content. When available mental effort was low, trainees selected less complex tasks that fulfilled numerically based assessment goals or contributed to clinical demands. Trainees predominantly used perceived complexity of the echocardiogram as a factor to select tasks to achieve their desired goals. Conclusion: Postgraduate trainees select tasks within their ZPD that enable them to maximise learning when they perceive to have sufficient mental effort available and workplace affordances are adequate. These findings can inform individual and systemic strategies to maximise learning when selecting tasks.
- 31 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (3) , 308-317
Open AccessTrainee selection of tasks in postgraduate medical education: Is there a role for ‘cherry‐picking’ to optimise learning?
Purpose: Learning is optimised when postgraduate trainees engage in clinical tasks in their zone of proximal development (ZPD). However, workplace learning environments impose additional non‐learning goals and additional tasks that may lead to trainees engaging in tasks that do not fall within their ZPD. We do not fully understand how trainees select clinical tasks in the workplace learning environment. If we knew the goals and factors they consider when selecting a task, we could better equip trainees with strategies to select tasks that maximise learning. We explored how postgraduate trainees select clinical tasks using echocardiography interpretation as a model. Methods: Canadian General Cardiology residents and Echocardiography fellows were invited to participate in semi‐structured interviews. Aligning with a theory‐informed study, two independent researchers used a deductive, directed content analysis approach to identify codes and themes. Results: Eleven trainees from seven Canadian universities participated (PGY4 = 4, PGY5 = 3, PGY6 = 1 and echocardiography fellows = 3). Goals included learning content, fulfilling assessment criteria and contributing to clinical demands. Trainees switched between goals throughout the day, as it was too effortful for them to engage in tasks within their ZPD at all times. When trainees had sufficient mental effort available, they selected higher complexity tasks that could advance learning content. When available mental effort was low, trainees selected less complex tasks that fulfilled numerically based assessment goals or contributed to clinical demands. Trainees predominantly used perceived complexity of the echocardiogram as a factor to select tasks to achieve their desired goals. Conclusion: Postgraduate trainees select tasks within their ZPD that enable them to maximise learning when they perceive to have sufficient mental effort available and workplace affordances are adequate. These findings can inform individual and systemic strategies to maximise learning when selecting tasks.
- 29 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Teaching and Learning in Medicine
- Vol. 36 (4) , 478-487
Assessment-Seeking Strategies: Navigating the Decision to Initiate Workplace-Based Assessment
Phenomenon: Competency-based medical education (CBME) relies on workplace-based assessment (WBA) to generate formative feedback (assessment for learning-AfL) and make inferences about competence (assessment of learning-AoL). When approaches to CBME rely on residents to initiate WBA, learners experience tension between seeking WBA for learning and for establishing competence. How learners resolve this tension may lead to unintended consequences for both AfL and AoL. We sought to explore the factors that impact both decisions to seek and not to seek WBA and use the findings to build a model of assessment-seeking strategy used by residents. In building this model we consider how the link between WBA and promotion or progression within a program impacts an individual's assessment-seeking strategy. Approach: We conducted 20 semi-structured interviews with internal medicine residents at Queen's University about the factors that influence their decision to seek or avoid WBA. Using grounded theory methodology, we applied a constant comparative analysis to collect data iteratively and identify themes. A conceptual model was developed to describe the interaction of factors impacting the decision to seek and initiate WBA. Findings: Participants identified two main motivations when deciding to seek assessments: the need to fulfill program requirements and the desire to receive feedback for learning. Analysis suggested that these motivations are often at odds with each other. Participants also described several moderating factors that impact the decision to initiate assessments, irrespective of the primary underlying motivation. These included resident performance, assessor factors, training program expectations, and clinical context. A conceptual framework was developed to describe the factors that lead to strategic assessment-seeking behaviors. Insights: Faced with the dual purpose of WBA in CBME, resident behavior in initiating assessment is guided by specific assessment-seeking strategies. Strategies reflect individual underlying motivations, influenced by four moderating factors. These findings have broad implications for programmatic assessment in a CBME context including validity considerations for assessment data used in summative decision-making including readiness for unsupervised practice.
- 29 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Teaching and Learning in Medicine
- Vol. 36 (4) , 478-487
Assessment-Seeking Strategies: Navigating the Decision to Initiate Workplace-Based Assessment
Phenomenon: Competency-based medical education (CBME) relies on workplace-based assessment (WBA) to generate formative feedback (assessment for learning-AfL) and make inferences about competence (assessment of learning-AoL). When approaches to CBME rely on residents to initiate WBA, learners experience tension between seeking WBA for learning and for establishing competence. How learners resolve this tension may lead to unintended consequences for both AfL and AoL. We sought to explore the factors that impact both decisions to seek and not to seek WBA and use the findings to build a model of assessment-seeking strategy used by residents. In building this model we consider how the link between WBA and promotion or progression within a program impacts an individual's assessment-seeking strategy. Approach: We conducted 20 semi-structured interviews with internal medicine residents at Queen's University about the factors that influence their decision to seek or avoid WBA. Using grounded theory methodology, we applied a constant comparative analysis to collect data iteratively and identify themes. A conceptual model was developed to describe the interaction of factors impacting the decision to seek and initiate WBA. Findings: Participants identified two main motivations when deciding to seek assessments: the need to fulfill program requirements and the desire to receive feedback for learning. Analysis suggested that these motivations are often at odds with each other. Participants also described several moderating factors that impact the decision to initiate assessments, irrespective of the primary underlying motivation. These included resident performance, assessor factors, training program expectations, and clinical context. A conceptual framework was developed to describe the factors that lead to strategic assessment-seeking behaviors. Insights: Faced with the dual purpose of WBA in CBME, resident behavior in initiating assessment is guided by specific assessment-seeking strategies. Strategies reflect individual underlying motivations, influenced by four moderating factors. These findings have broad implications for programmatic assessment in a CBME context including validity considerations for assessment data used in summative decision-making including readiness for unsupervised practice.
- Open Access
- 27 June 2023
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 14 (3) , 92-98
Simulation vs workplace-based assessment in resuscitation: a cross-specialty descriptive analysis and comparison
Background: Simulation-based assessment can complement workplace-based assessment of rare or difficult to assess Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs). We aimed to compare the use of simulation-based assessment for resuscitation-focused EPAs in three postgraduate medical training programs and describe faculty perceptions of simulation-based assessment. Methods: EPA assessment scores and setting (simulation or workplace) were extracted from 2017-2020 for internal medicine, emergency medicine, and surgical foundations residents at the transition to discipline and foundations of discipline stages. A questionnaire was distributed to clinical competency committee members. Results: Eleven percent of EPA assessments were simulation-based. The proportion of simulation-based assessment did not differ between programs but differed between transition (38%) and foundations (4%) stages within surgical foundations only. Entrustment scores differed between settings in emergency medicine at the transition level only (simulation: 4.82 ± 0.60 workplace: 3.74 ± 0.93). 70% of committee members (n=20) completed the questionnaire. Of those that use simulation-based assessment, 45% interpret them differently than workplace-based assessments. 73% and 100% trust simulation for high-stakes and low-stakes assessment, respectively. Conclusions: The proportion of simulation-based assessment for resuscitation focused EPAs did not differ between three postgraduate medical training programs. Interpretation of simulation-based assessment data between committee members was inconsistent. All respondents trust simulation-based assessment for low-stakes, and the majority for high-stakes assessment. These findings have practical implications for the integration simulation into programs of assessment.
- 27 June 2023
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 14 (3) , 92-98
Open AccessSimulation vs workplace-based assessment in resuscitation: a cross-specialty descriptive analysis and comparison
Background: Simulation-based assessment can complement workplace-based assessment of rare or difficult to assess Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs). We aimed to compare the use of simulation-based assessment for resuscitation-focused EPAs in three postgraduate medical training programs and describe faculty perceptions of simulation-based assessment. Methods: EPA assessment scores and setting (simulation or workplace) were extracted from 2017-2020 for internal medicine, emergency medicine, and surgical foundations residents at the transition to discipline and foundations of discipline stages. A questionnaire was distributed to clinical competency committee members. Results: Eleven percent of EPA assessments were simulation-based. The proportion of simulation-based assessment did not differ between programs but differed between transition (38%) and foundations (4%) stages within surgical foundations only. Entrustment scores differed between settings in emergency medicine at the transition level only (simulation: 4.82 ± 0.60 workplace: 3.74 ± 0.93). 70% of committee members (n=20) completed the questionnaire. Of those that use simulation-based assessment, 45% interpret them differently than workplace-based assessments. 73% and 100% trust simulation for high-stakes and low-stakes assessment, respectively. Conclusions: The proportion of simulation-based assessment for resuscitation focused EPAs did not differ between three postgraduate medical training programs. Interpretation of simulation-based assessment data between committee members was inconsistent. All respondents trust simulation-based assessment for low-stakes, and the majority for high-stakes assessment. These findings have practical implications for the integration simulation into programs of assessment.
- Open Access
- 11 January 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in International Medical Education
- Vol. 2 (1) , 1-10
What Do Clinicians Mean by “Good Clinical Judgment”: A Qualitative Study
Good Clinical Judgment (GCJ) is associated with clinical excellence and accolades whereas poor clinical judgment is often associated with suboptimal care and the need for remediation. Although commonly referenced in practice, a shared definition for GCJ based on primary data is lacking. We interviewed 16 clinicians and surgeons across different specialties at one Canadian academic center to understand their conceptualization of GCJ. The data analysis led to the formulation of three pillars that were viewed by participants as core ingredients of GCJ. These included (1) a strong baseline knowledge and breadth of clinical experience, (2) the demonstration of curiosity, reflection, and wisdom, and (3) an ability to attend to contextual factors and understand the “bigger picture” when providing care to patients. Although there were inconsistent opinions regarding whether GCJ is innate or learned, participants reflected on strategies to support the development or improvement in clinical judgement for trainees.
- 11 January 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in International Medical Education
- Vol. 2 (1) , 1-10
Open AccessWhat Do Clinicians Mean by “Good Clinical Judgment”: A Qualitative Study
Good Clinical Judgment (GCJ) is associated with clinical excellence and accolades whereas poor clinical judgment is often associated with suboptimal care and the need for remediation. Although commonly referenced in practice, a shared definition for GCJ based on primary data is lacking. We interviewed 16 clinicians and surgeons across different specialties at one Canadian academic center to understand their conceptualization of GCJ. The data analysis led to the formulation of three pillars that were viewed by participants as core ingredients of GCJ. These included (1) a strong baseline knowledge and breadth of clinical experience, (2) the demonstration of curiosity, reflection, and wisdom, and (3) an ability to attend to contextual factors and understand the “bigger picture” when providing care to patients. Although there were inconsistent opinions regarding whether GCJ is innate or learned, participants reflected on strategies to support the development or improvement in clinical judgement for trainees.
- 21 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 57 (5) , 394-405
How workplace‐based assessments guide learning in postgraduate education: A scoping review
Introduction: Competency‐based medical education (CBME) led to the widespread adoption of workplace‐based assessment (WBA) with the promise of achieving assessment for learning. Despite this, studies have illustrated tensions between the summative and formative role of WBA which undermine learning goals. Models of workplace‐based learning (WBL) provide insight, however, these models excluded WBA. This scoping review synthesizes the primary literature addressing the role of WBA to guide learning in postgraduate medical education, with the goal of identifying gaps to address in future studies. Methods: The search was applied to OVID Medline, Web of Science, ERIC and CINAHL databases, articles up to September 2020 were included. Titles and abstracts were screened by two reviewers, followed by a full text review. Two members independently extracted and analysed quantitative and qualitative data using a descriptive‐analytic technique rooted in Billett's four premises of WBL. Themes were synthesized and discussed until consensus. Results: All 33 papers focused on the perception of learning through WBA. The majority applied qualitative methodology (70%), and 12 studies (36%) made explicit reference to theory. Aligning with Billett's first premise, results reinforce that learning always occurs in the workplace. WBA helped guide learning goals and enhanced feedback frequency and specificity. Billett's remaining premises provided an important lens to understand how tensions that existed in WBL have been exacerbated with frequent WBA. As individuals engage in both work and WBA, they are slowly transforming the workplace. Culture and context frame individual experiences and the perceived authenticity of WBA. Finally, individuals will have different goals, and learn different things, from the same experience. Conclusion: Analysing WBA literature through the lens of WBL theory allows us to reframe previously described tensions. We propose that future studies attend to learning theory, and demonstrate alignment with philosophical position, to advance our understanding of assessment‐for‐learning in the workplace.
- 21 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 57 (5) , 394-405
How workplace‐based assessments guide learning in postgraduate education: A scoping review
Introduction: Competency‐based medical education (CBME) led to the widespread adoption of workplace‐based assessment (WBA) with the promise of achieving assessment for learning. Despite this, studies have illustrated tensions between the summative and formative role of WBA which undermine learning goals. Models of workplace‐based learning (WBL) provide insight, however, these models excluded WBA. This scoping review synthesizes the primary literature addressing the role of WBA to guide learning in postgraduate medical education, with the goal of identifying gaps to address in future studies. Methods: The search was applied to OVID Medline, Web of Science, ERIC and CINAHL databases, articles up to September 2020 were included. Titles and abstracts were screened by two reviewers, followed by a full text review. Two members independently extracted and analysed quantitative and qualitative data using a descriptive‐analytic technique rooted in Billett's four premises of WBL. Themes were synthesized and discussed until consensus. Results: All 33 papers focused on the perception of learning through WBA. The majority applied qualitative methodology (70%), and 12 studies (36%) made explicit reference to theory. Aligning with Billett's first premise, results reinforce that learning always occurs in the workplace. WBA helped guide learning goals and enhanced feedback frequency and specificity. Billett's remaining premises provided an important lens to understand how tensions that existed in WBL have been exacerbated with frequent WBA. As individuals engage in both work and WBA, they are slowly transforming the workplace. Culture and context frame individual experiences and the perceived authenticity of WBA. Finally, individuals will have different goals, and learn different things, from the same experience. Conclusion: Analysing WBA literature through the lens of WBL theory allows us to reframe previously described tensions. We propose that future studies attend to learning theory, and demonstrate alignment with philosophical position, to advance our understanding of assessment‐for‐learning in the workplace.
- 3 August 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 56 (12) , 1194-1202
Supervising the senior medical resident: Entrusting the role, supporting the tasks
Introduction: Postgraduate competency‐based medical education has been implemented with programmatic assessment that relies on entrustment‐based ratings. Yet, in less procedurally oriented specialties such as internal medicine, the relationship between entrustment and supervision remains unclear. We undertook the current study to address how internal medicine supervisors conceptualise entrusting senior medical residents while supervising them on the acute care wards. Methods: Guided by constructivist grounded theory, we interviewed 19 physicians who regularly supervised senior internal medicine residents on inpatient wards at three Canadian universities. We developed a theoretical model through iterative cycles of data collection and analysis using a constant comparative process. Results: On the internal medicine ward, the senior resident role is viewed as a fundamentally managerial and rudimentary version of the supervisor's role. Supervisors come to trust their residents in the senior role through an early ‘hands‐on’ period of assessment followed by a gradual withdrawal of support to promote independence. When considering entrustment, supervisors focused on entrusting a particular scope of the senior resident role as opposed to entrustment of individual tasks . Irrespective of the scope of the role that was entrusted, supervisors at times stepped in and stepped back to support specific tasks. Conclusion: Supervisors' stepping in and stepping back to support individual tasks on the acute care ward has an inconsistent relationship to their entrustment of the resident with a particular scope of the senior resident role . In this context, entrustment‐based assessment would need to capture more of the holistic perspective of the supervisor's entrustment of the senior resident role. Understanding the dance of supervision, from relatively static overall support of the resident in their role, to fluidly stepping in and out for specific patient care tasks, allows us insight into the affordances of the supervisory relationship and how it may be leveraged for assessment.
- 3 August 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 56 (12) , 1194-1202
Supervising the senior medical resident: Entrusting the role, supporting the tasks
Introduction: Postgraduate competency‐based medical education has been implemented with programmatic assessment that relies on entrustment‐based ratings. Yet, in less procedurally oriented specialties such as internal medicine, the relationship between entrustment and supervision remains unclear. We undertook the current study to address how internal medicine supervisors conceptualise entrusting senior medical residents while supervising them on the acute care wards. Methods: Guided by constructivist grounded theory, we interviewed 19 physicians who regularly supervised senior internal medicine residents on inpatient wards at three Canadian universities. We developed a theoretical model through iterative cycles of data collection and analysis using a constant comparative process. Results: On the internal medicine ward, the senior resident role is viewed as a fundamentally managerial and rudimentary version of the supervisor's role. Supervisors come to trust their residents in the senior role through an early ‘hands‐on’ period of assessment followed by a gradual withdrawal of support to promote independence. When considering entrustment, supervisors focused on entrusting a particular scope of the senior resident role as opposed to entrustment of individual tasks . Irrespective of the scope of the role that was entrusted, supervisors at times stepped in and stepped back to support specific tasks. Conclusion: Supervisors' stepping in and stepping back to support individual tasks on the acute care ward has an inconsistent relationship to their entrustment of the resident with a particular scope of the senior resident role . In this context, entrustment‐based assessment would need to capture more of the holistic perspective of the supervisor's entrustment of the senior resident role. Understanding the dance of supervision, from relatively static overall support of the resident in their role, to fluidly stepping in and out for specific patient care tasks, allows us insight into the affordances of the supervisory relationship and how it may be leveraged for assessment.
- Open Access
- 20 April 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 12 (5) , 293
Do Resident Archetypes Influence the Functioning of Programs of Assessment?
While most case studies consider how programs of assessment may influence residents’ achievement, we engaged in a qualitative, multiple case study to model how resident engagement and performance can reciprocally influence the program of assessment. We conducted virtual focus groups with program leaders from four residency training programs from different disciplines (internal medicine, emergency medicine, neurology, and rheumatology) and institutions. We facilitated discussion with live screen-sharing to (1) improve upon a previously-derived model of programmatic assessment and (2) explore how different resident archetypes (sample profiles) may influence their program of assessment. Participants agreed that differences in resident engagement and performance can influence their programs of assessment in some (mal)adaptive ways. For residents who are disengaged and weakly performing (of which there are a few), significantly more time is spent to make sense of problematic evidence, arrive at a decision, and generate recommendations. Whereas for residents who are engaged and performing strongly (the vast majority), significantly less effort is thought to be spent on discussion and formalized recommendations. These findings motivate us to fulfill the potential of programmatic assessment by more intentionally and strategically challenging those who are engaged and strongly performing, and by anticipating ways that weakly performing residents may strain existing processes.
- 20 April 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 12 (5) , 293
Open AccessDo Resident Archetypes Influence the Functioning of Programs of Assessment?
While most case studies consider how programs of assessment may influence residents’ achievement, we engaged in a qualitative, multiple case study to model how resident engagement and performance can reciprocally influence the program of assessment. We conducted virtual focus groups with program leaders from four residency training programs from different disciplines (internal medicine, emergency medicine, neurology, and rheumatology) and institutions. We facilitated discussion with live screen-sharing to (1) improve upon a previously-derived model of programmatic assessment and (2) explore how different resident archetypes (sample profiles) may influence their program of assessment. Participants agreed that differences in resident engagement and performance can influence their programs of assessment in some (mal)adaptive ways. For residents who are disengaged and weakly performing (of which there are a few), significantly more time is spent to make sense of problematic evidence, arrive at a decision, and generate recommendations. Whereas for residents who are engaged and performing strongly (the vast majority), significantly less effort is thought to be spent on discussion and formalized recommendations. These findings motivate us to fulfill the potential of programmatic assessment by more intentionally and strategically challenging those who are engaged and strongly performing, and by anticipating ways that weakly performing residents may strain existing processes.
- Open Access
- 19 April 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 56 (9) , 881-891
The logic behind entrustable professional activity frameworks: A scoping review of the literature
Introduction: Entrustable professional activities (EPAs), discrete profession‐specific tasks requiring integration of multiple competencies, are increasingly used to help define and inform curricula of specialty training programmes. Although guidelines exist to help guide the developmental process, deciding what logic to use to draft a preliminary EPA framework poses a crucial but often difficult first step. The logic of an EPA framework can be defined as the perspective used by its developers to break down the practice of a profession into units of professional work. This study aimed to map dominant logics and their rationales across postgraduate medical education and fellowship programmes. Methods: A scoping review using systematic searches within five electronic databases (Medline, Embase, Google Scholar, Scopus and Web of Science) was performed. Dominant logics of included papers were identified using inductive coding and iterative analysis. Results: In total, 42 studies were included. Most studies were conducted in the United States (n = 22; 52%), Canada (n = 6; 14%) and the Netherlands (n = 4; 10%). Across the reported range of specialties, family medicine (n = 4; 10%), internal medicine (n = 4; 10%), paediatrics (n = 3; 7%) and psychiatry (n = 3; 7%) were the most common. Three dominant logics could be identified, namely, ‘service provision’, ‘procedures’ and/or ‘disease or patient categories’. The majority of papers (n = 37; 88%) used two or more logics when developing EPA frameworks (median = 3, range = 1–4). Disease or patient groups and service provision were the most common logics used (39% and 37%, respectively). Conclusions: Most programmes used a combination of logics when trying to capture the essential tasks of a profession in EPAs. For each of the three dominant logics, the authors arrived at a definition and identified benefits, limitations and examples. These findings may potentially inform best practice guidelines for EPA development.
- 19 April 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 56 (9) , 881-891
Open AccessThe logic behind entrustable professional activity frameworks: A scoping review of the literature
Introduction: Entrustable professional activities (EPAs), discrete profession‐specific tasks requiring integration of multiple competencies, are increasingly used to help define and inform curricula of specialty training programmes. Although guidelines exist to help guide the developmental process, deciding what logic to use to draft a preliminary EPA framework poses a crucial but often difficult first step. The logic of an EPA framework can be defined as the perspective used by its developers to break down the practice of a profession into units of professional work. This study aimed to map dominant logics and their rationales across postgraduate medical education and fellowship programmes. Methods: A scoping review using systematic searches within five electronic databases (Medline, Embase, Google Scholar, Scopus and Web of Science) was performed. Dominant logics of included papers were identified using inductive coding and iterative analysis. Results: In total, 42 studies were included. Most studies were conducted in the United States (n = 22; 52%), Canada (n = 6; 14%) and the Netherlands (n = 4; 10%). Across the reported range of specialties, family medicine (n = 4; 10%), internal medicine (n = 4; 10%), paediatrics (n = 3; 7%) and psychiatry (n = 3; 7%) were the most common. Three dominant logics could be identified, namely, ‘service provision’, ‘procedures’ and/or ‘disease or patient categories’. The majority of papers (n = 37; 88%) used two or more logics when developing EPA frameworks (median = 3, range = 1–4). Disease or patient groups and service provision were the most common logics used (39% and 37%, respectively). Conclusions: Most programmes used a combination of logics when trying to capture the essential tasks of a profession in EPAs. For each of the three dominant logics, the authors arrived at a definition and identified benefits, limitations and examples. These findings may potentially inform best practice guidelines for EPA development.
- Open Access
- 22 November 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ATS Scholar
- Vol. 2 (4) , 620-631
Trainee Uncertainty around Intervening When Patients Decompensate
Background: Trainees in acute care specialties often grapple with the decision to perform an invasive procedure in a rapidly decompensating patient, for whom the benefits and risks are inherently uncertain. The difference between trainees who know when to act and when to seek supervision and those who do not is often linked to individual trainee psychological and cultural perceptions of uncertainty. But how much comfort with uncertainty relates to the situational context rather than the trainee traits is underexplored. Objective: The objective of this study was to explore trainee actions around decompensating patients and assess the degree to which invasive intervention and supervision seeking depend on situational certainty or individual trait-based perceptions of uncertainty. Methods: A total of 41 internal medicine residents completed a survey to measure anxiety related to uncertainty using the Physicians’ Reactions to Uncertainty (PRU) tool and to measure uncertainty avoidance using the Values Survey Module (VSM) before responding to 14 written emergency situations. Half of the scenarios contain sufficient diagnostic certainty to warrant aggressive intervention, and half lack sufficient diagnostic clarity to offset the risk of intervention. Mixed multivariable modeling was used to identify the relationship between planned invasive intervention, situational uncertainty, and trait-based perceptions of uncertainty measured in the PRU and VSM. Results: Trainees’ first actions were appropriate in 60% of cases. Multivariable modeling suggested that situational certainty was more predictive of upfront intervention (odds ratio [OR], 30.5; P < 0.0001) than trait-based PRU (OR, 1.22; P = 0.05) and VSM (OR, 1.73; P < 0.0001). Similarly, situational certainty was more predictive of reduced supervision seeking (OR, 0.20; P < 0.0001) than trait-based PRU (OR, 2.03; P < 0.001) and VSM (P = not significant). Conclusion:s Situation-specific certainty was more strongly correlated with invasive intervention in cases of decompensated patients than individual trainee traits. Focusing on trainee contextual understanding of procedural risk–benefit ratios in decompensating patients holds more promise for improving trainee actions and supervision seeking than tackling their perceptions around uncertainty.
- 22 November 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ATS Scholar
- Vol. 2 (4) , 620-631
Open AccessTrainee Uncertainty around Intervening When Patients Decompensate
Background: Trainees in acute care specialties often grapple with the decision to perform an invasive procedure in a rapidly decompensating patient, for whom the benefits and risks are inherently uncertain. The difference between trainees who know when to act and when to seek supervision and those who do not is often linked to individual trainee psychological and cultural perceptions of uncertainty. But how much comfort with uncertainty relates to the situational context rather than the trainee traits is underexplored. Objective: The objective of this study was to explore trainee actions around decompensating patients and assess the degree to which invasive intervention and supervision seeking depend on situational certainty or individual trait-based perceptions of uncertainty. Methods: A total of 41 internal medicine residents completed a survey to measure anxiety related to uncertainty using the Physicians’ Reactions to Uncertainty (PRU) tool and to measure uncertainty avoidance using the Values Survey Module (VSM) before responding to 14 written emergency situations. Half of the scenarios contain sufficient diagnostic certainty to warrant aggressive intervention, and half lack sufficient diagnostic clarity to offset the risk of intervention. Mixed multivariable modeling was used to identify the relationship between planned invasive intervention, situational uncertainty, and trait-based perceptions of uncertainty measured in the PRU and VSM. Results: Trainees’ first actions were appropriate in 60% of cases. Multivariable modeling suggested that situational certainty was more predictive of upfront intervention (odds ratio [OR], 30.5; P < 0.0001) than trait-based PRU (OR, 1.22; P = 0.05) and VSM (OR, 1.73; P < 0.0001). Similarly, situational certainty was more predictive of reduced supervision seeking (OR, 0.20; P < 0.0001) than trait-based PRU (OR, 2.03; P < 0.001) and VSM (P = not significant). Conclusion:s Situation-specific certainty was more strongly correlated with invasive intervention in cases of decompensated patients than individual trainee traits. Focusing on trainee contextual understanding of procedural risk–benefit ratios in decompensating patients holds more promise for improving trainee actions and supervision seeking than tackling their perceptions around uncertainty.