Arnout van de Rijt
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Arnout van de Rijt has a total of 100 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Vincent Buskens
Department of Sociology / ICS, Utrecht University
8 shared publications - Judith Kas
Department of Sociology/ICS, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands
6 shared publications Rense Corten
Department of Sociology/ICS, Utrecht University , Utrecht 3584 CH , The Netherlands
4 shared publications- Rense Corten
Department of Sociology/ICS, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands
4 shared publications Eran Shor
Department of Sociology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada
3 shared publications- Klarita Gërxhani
European University Institute
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Similarity over Status in Partner Selection under Competition
Gender homophily, the tendency to associate with same-gender others, shapes social and professional relationships, influencing team formation and organizational diversity. Yet competitive contexts create strategic incentives that should counteract homophily: to select competitors and teammates based on performance expectations rather than demographic similarity. Through two pre-registered experiments, we test whether gender homophily persists when it conflicts with strategic advantage. Study 1 examines partner selection when performance expectations must be inferred from gender cues alone. Results show homophily as the dominant pattern, with participants most frequently selecting same-gender partners for both competitors and teammates. Study 2 provides a more stringent test by introducing explicit performance ratings for potential partners, creating direct tension between homophily and strategic incentives. Even here, where performance ratings made the cost of a same-gender choice explicit, the preference persisted: participants selected same-gender partners at rates significantly above chance, though more weakly than in Study 1. Women exhibited stronger same-gender preferences than men across both studies. These findings show that gender homophily persists under competitive pressure, evident even when explicit performance incentives work against it. Where cross-gender partnership is the goal, this persistence suggests that incentives alone may not suffice, and that mechanisms constraining partner choice, such as random assignment or structured pairing, may also be needed.
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessSimilarity over Status in Partner Selection under Competition
Gender homophily, the tendency to associate with same-gender others, shapes social and professional relationships, influencing team formation and organizational diversity. Yet competitive contexts create strategic incentives that should counteract homophily: to select competitors and teammates based on performance expectations rather than demographic similarity. Through two pre-registered experiments, we test whether gender homophily persists when it conflicts with strategic advantage. Study 1 examines partner selection when performance expectations must be inferred from gender cues alone. Results show homophily as the dominant pattern, with participants most frequently selecting same-gender partners for both competitors and teammates. Study 2 provides a more stringent test by introducing explicit performance ratings for potential partners, creating direct tension between homophily and strategic incentives. Even here, where performance ratings made the cost of a same-gender choice explicit, the preference persisted: participants selected same-gender partners at rates significantly above chance, though more weakly than in Study 1. Women exhibited stronger same-gender preferences than men across both studies. These findings show that gender homophily persists under competitive pressure, evident even when explicit performance incentives work against it. Where cross-gender partnership is the goal, this persistence suggests that incentives alone may not suffice, and that mechanisms constraining partner choice, such as random assignment or structured pairing, may also be needed.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Similarity over Status in Partner Selection under Competition
Gender homophily, the tendency to associate with same-gender others, shapes social and professional relationships, influencing team formation and organizational diversity. Yet competitive contexts create strategic incentives that should counteract homophily: to select competitors and teammates based on performance expectations rather than demographic similarity. Through two pre-registered experiments, we test whether gender homophily persists when it conflicts with strategic advantage. Study 1 examines partner selection when performance expectations must be inferred from gender cues alone. Results show homophily as the dominant pattern, with participants most frequently selecting same-gender partners for both competitors and teammates. Study 2 provides a more stringent test by introducing explicit performance ratings for potential partners, creating direct tension between homophily and strategic incentives. Even here, where performance ratings made the cost of a same-gender choice explicit, the preference persisted: participants selected same-gender partners at rates significantly above chance, though more weakly than in Study 1. Women exhibited stronger same-gender preferences than men across both studies. These findings show that gender homophily persists under competitive pressure, evident even when explicit performance incentives work against it. Where cross-gender partnership is the goal, this persistence suggests that incentives alone may not suffice, and that mechanisms constraining partner choice, such as random assignment or structured pairing, may also be needed.
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessSimilarity over Status in Partner Selection under Competition
Gender homophily, the tendency to associate with same-gender others, shapes social and professional relationships, influencing team formation and organizational diversity. Yet competitive contexts create strategic incentives that should counteract homophily: to select competitors and teammates based on performance expectations rather than demographic similarity. Through two pre-registered experiments, we test whether gender homophily persists when it conflicts with strategic advantage. Study 1 examines partner selection when performance expectations must be inferred from gender cues alone. Results show homophily as the dominant pattern, with participants most frequently selecting same-gender partners for both competitors and teammates. Study 2 provides a more stringent test by introducing explicit performance ratings for potential partners, creating direct tension between homophily and strategic incentives. Even here, where performance ratings made the cost of a same-gender choice explicit, the preference persisted: participants selected same-gender partners at rates significantly above chance, though more weakly than in Study 1. Women exhibited stronger same-gender preferences than men across both studies. These findings show that gender homophily persists under competitive pressure, evident even when explicit performance incentives work against it. Where cross-gender partnership is the goal, this persistence suggests that incentives alone may not suffice, and that mechanisms constraining partner choice, such as random assignment or structured pairing, may also be needed.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2026
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Sociology
- Vol. 52 (1) , 319-339
Luck and Predictability in the Life Course
There is an emerging recognition among sociological theorists that luck may play a substantial role in life course achievement. There is also a nascent empirical literature that finds life outcomes to be unpredictable and unexpected life events to be a likely cause. A third literature of causal event studies provides thousands of point estimates of the life course consequences of random events. This review brings these literatures together under a unified framework.
- 24 April 2026
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Sociology
- Vol. 52 (1) , 319-339
Open AccessLuck and Predictability in the Life Course
There is an emerging recognition among sociological theorists that luck may play a substantial role in life course achievement. There is also a nascent empirical literature that finds life outcomes to be unpredictable and unexpected life events to be a likely cause. A third literature of causal event studies provides thousands of point estimates of the life course consequences of random events. This review brings these literatures together under a unified framework.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 20 February 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (8) , eadr4237
The marginal majority effect: When social influence produces lock-in
People are influenced by the choices of others, a phenomenon observed across contexts in the social and behavioral sciences. Social influence can lock in an initial popularity advantage of an option over a higher quality alternative. Yet, several experiments designed to enable social influence have found that social systems self-correct rather than lock in. Here, we identify a behavioral phenomenon that makes inferior lock-in possible, which we call the “marginal majority effect”: a discontinuous increase in the choice probability of an option as its popularity exceeds that of a competing option. We demonstrate the existence of a marginal majority effect in several recent experiments and show that lock-in always occurs when the effect is large enough to offset the quality effect on choice but rarely otherwise. Our results reconcile conflicting past empirical evidence and connect a behavioral phenomenon to the possibility of social lock-in.
- 20 February 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (8) , eadr4237
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe marginal majority effect: When social influence produces lock-in
People are influenced by the choices of others, a phenomenon observed across contexts in the social and behavioral sciences. Social influence can lock in an initial popularity advantage of an option over a higher quality alternative. Yet, several experiments designed to enable social influence have found that social systems self-correct rather than lock in. Here, we identify a behavioral phenomenon that makes inferior lock-in possible, which we call the “marginal majority effect”: a discontinuous increase in the choice probability of an option as its popularity exceeds that of a competing option. We demonstrate the existence of a marginal majority effect in several recent experiments and show that lock-in always occurs when the effect is large enough to offset the quality effect on choice but rarely otherwise. Our results reconcile conflicting past empirical evidence and connect a behavioral phenomenon to the possibility of social lock-in.
- Open Access
- 27 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Peer Review 2027: Scenarios for Academic Publishing in the Age of AI
The practices of peer review and the broader landscape of academic publishing are under strain. Submission rates are rising, placing greater demands on editorial and reviewer capacity. The use of LLMs in the production of academic papers threatens to accelerate these trends beyond the breaking point. This article is the product of a meeting of editors of academic journals across political science, sociology, and communication science to discuss the issue of LLMs in academic publishing. We argue that peer review is an essential and irreplaceably human component of social science: if elements of the research process traditionally done by humans are substituted by AI, humans should increase their involvement with the evaluation of research. We present a scenario-casting exercise illustrating four possible equilibria for the incorporation of LLMs into the publication ecosystem, and we discuss the various levers that academic journals have at their disposal to navigate the changing landscape. We emphasize that adaptive policies with built-in evaluation mechanisms, feedback loops, and a capacity for revision are required, along with new streams of metascientific data to remain up to date as AI and its adoption continue to evolve.
- 27 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessPeer Review 2027: Scenarios for Academic Publishing in the Age of AI
The practices of peer review and the broader landscape of academic publishing are under strain. Submission rates are rising, placing greater demands on editorial and reviewer capacity. The use of LLMs in the production of academic papers threatens to accelerate these trends beyond the breaking point. This article is the product of a meeting of editors of academic journals across political science, sociology, and communication science to discuss the issue of LLMs in academic publishing. We argue that peer review is an essential and irreplaceably human component of social science: if elements of the research process traditionally done by humans are substituted by AI, humans should increase their involvement with the evaluation of research. We present a scenario-casting exercise illustrating four possible equilibria for the incorporation of LLMs into the publication ecosystem, and we discuss the various levers that academic journals have at their disposal to navigate the changing landscape. We emphasize that adaptive policies with built-in evaluation mechanisms, feedback loops, and a capacity for revision are required, along with new streams of metascientific data to remain up to date as AI and its adoption continue to evolve.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior Reports
- Vol. 20
Does gender status bias carry over from in-person to virtual interaction?
- 1 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior Reports
- Vol. 20
Open AccessDoes gender status bias carry over from in-person to virtual interaction?
- Open Access
- 6 June 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (23)
Reinforcement generates systematic differences without heterogeneity
Inequality in outcomes may emerge through a reinforcement process in which stochastic variation in values is determined by prior values but may also originate in preexisting differences in unobserved factors. A common approach toward differentiating between these origins in longitudinal data is to attribute systematic differences between units—differences in means or differences proportional to a time-varying group average—to unobserved heterogeneity. We show that any longitudinal data with systematic differences can also be produced by a reinforcement-driven data generating process. This result reconciles findings in three distinct research areas—science of science, personal culture, and sexual networks—where reinforcement is a strong theoretical prior, yet longitudinal data analyses advance an explanation of interpersonal differences based on heterogeneity. Future studies may bound the role of heterogeneity and reinforcement from below by measuring fixed traits that systematically vary with the outcome and isolating random events that trigger emergent differences.
- 6 June 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (23)
Open AccessReinforcement generates systematic differences without heterogeneity
Inequality in outcomes may emerge through a reinforcement process in which stochastic variation in values is determined by prior values but may also originate in preexisting differences in unobserved factors. A common approach toward differentiating between these origins in longitudinal data is to attribute systematic differences between units—differences in means or differences proportional to a time-varying group average—to unobserved heterogeneity. We show that any longitudinal data with systematic differences can also be produced by a reinforcement-driven data generating process. This result reconciles findings in three distinct research areas—science of science, personal culture, and sexual networks—where reinforcement is a strong theoretical prior, yet longitudinal data analyses advance an explanation of interpersonal differences based on heterogeneity. Future studies may bound the role of heterogeneity and reinforcement from below by measuring fixed traits that systematically vary with the outcome and isolating random events that trigger emergent differences.
- Open Access
- 30 October 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 3 (11) , pgae506
Partisan belief in new misinformation is resistant to accuracy incentives
One explanation for why people accept ideologically welcome misinformation is that they are insincere. Consistent with the insincerity hypothesis, past experiments have demonstrated that bias in the veracity assessment of publicly reported statistics and debunked news headlines often diminishes considerably when accuracy is incentivized. Many statements encountered online, however, constitute previously unseen claims that are difficult to evaluate the veracity of. We hypothesize that when confronted with unfamiliar content, unsure partisans will form sincere beliefs that are ideologically aligned. Across three experimental studies, 1,344 conservative and liberal US participants assessed the veracity of 20 politically sensitive statements that either confirmed or contradicted social science evidence only known to experts. As hypothesized, analyses show that incentives failed to correct most ideological differences in the perceived veracity of statements. Sixty six to 78% of partisan differences in accuracy assessment persisted even when monetary stakes were raised beyond levels in prior studies. Participants displayed a surprising degree of confidence in their erroneous beliefs, as bias was not reduced when participants could safely avoid rating statements they were unsure about, without monetary loss. These findings suggest limits to the ability of disciplining interventions to reduce the expression of false statements, because many of the targeted individuals sincerely believe them to be true.
- 30 October 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 3 (11) , pgae506
Open AccessPartisan belief in new misinformation is resistant to accuracy incentives
One explanation for why people accept ideologically welcome misinformation is that they are insincere. Consistent with the insincerity hypothesis, past experiments have demonstrated that bias in the veracity assessment of publicly reported statistics and debunked news headlines often diminishes considerably when accuracy is incentivized. Many statements encountered online, however, constitute previously unseen claims that are difficult to evaluate the veracity of. We hypothesize that when confronted with unfamiliar content, unsure partisans will form sincere beliefs that are ideologically aligned. Across three experimental studies, 1,344 conservative and liberal US participants assessed the veracity of 20 politically sensitive statements that either confirmed or contradicted social science evidence only known to experts. As hypothesized, analyses show that incentives failed to correct most ideological differences in the perceived veracity of statements. Sixty six to 78% of partisan differences in accuracy assessment persisted even when monetary stakes were raised beyond levels in prior studies. Participants displayed a surprising degree of confidence in their erroneous beliefs, as bias was not reduced when participants could safely avoid rating statements they were unsure about, without monetary loss. These findings suggest limits to the ability of disciplining interventions to reduce the expression of false statements, because many of the targeted individuals sincerely believe them to be true.
- 29 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 373-399
Methodological Individualism and Formal Models
- 29 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 373-399
Methodological Individualism and Formal Models
- Open Access
Inferring cumulative advantage from longitudinal records
Inequality in human success may emerge through endogenous success-breeds-success dynamics but may also originate in pre-existing differences in talent. It is widely recognized that the skew in static frequency distributions of success implied by a cumulative advantage model is also consistent with a talent model. Studies have turned to longitudinal records of success, seeking to exploit the time dimension for adjudication. Here we show that success histories suffer from a similar identification problem as static distributional evidence. We prove that for any talent model there exists an analogous path dependent model that generates the same longitudinal predictions, and vice versa. We formally identify such twins for prominent models in the literature, in both directions. These results imply that longitudinal data previously interpreted to support a talent model equally well fits a model of cumulative advantage and vice versa.
Open AccessInferring cumulative advantage from longitudinal records
Inequality in human success may emerge through endogenous success-breeds-success dynamics but may also originate in pre-existing differences in talent. It is widely recognized that the skew in static frequency distributions of success implied by a cumulative advantage model is also consistent with a talent model. Studies have turned to longitudinal records of success, seeking to exploit the time dimension for adjudication. Here we show that success histories suffer from a similar identification problem as static distributional evidence. We prove that for any talent model there exists an analogous path dependent model that generates the same longitudinal predictions, and vice versa. We formally identify such twins for prominent models in the literature, in both directions. These results imply that longitudinal data previously interpreted to support a talent model equally well fits a model of cumulative advantage and vice versa.