KNKagiso Ndlovu

Kagiso Ndlovu

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Kagiso Ndlovu has a total of 88 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Developing a National eHealth Enterprise Architecture in Botswana: a digital health case study

    by Audrey Masizana, Mwariri Mwangi, Rugo Kisanga, Kagiso Ndlovu, Badisa Mosesane, Michelle Moghadassi, Fitti Weissglas, Sinka Matengu, Tony Chebani

    Botswana’s health sector comprises numerous digital health systems that operate in isolation, thereby constraining interoperability, limiting data exchange, and hindering coordinated patient care. Although national strategies such as the Botswana eHealth Strategy (2020–24) articulate overarching digital health objectives, they offer limited technical direction for harmonizing digital investments and achieving system-wide interoperability. This article presents a national digital health case study detailing the development of the Botswana eHealth Enterprise Architecture, a strategic blueprint intended to guide the integration and governance of digital health systems nationwide. The architecture was formulated through a participatory process involving stakeholders from the Ministry of Health, healthcare facilities, academic institutions, and international partners. The initiative was informed by internationally recognized frameworks, including The Open Group Architecture Framework and the Open Health Information Exchange interoperability model. Through an iterative development process undertaken between 2023 and 2024, the architecture delineated four core layers—business, data, application, and technology—and established a national interoperability framework grounded in open standards, including HL7 Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources and HL7 v2. The resulting architecture further introduced a suite of shared national digital health services, such as a Master Patient Index, a Shared Health Record, and national facility and provider registries. Key lessons from Botswana’s experience underscore the importance of robust governance structures, inclusive stakeholder engagement, the adoption of open standards, and phased implementation approaches in the development of national digital health architectures. This case study offers practical insights for other low- and middle-income countries seeking to mitigate fragmentation in their health information systems and to implement interoperable digital health ecosystems.

  • Open Access

    Experiences, challenges and lessons while implementing a clinical decision support system in Botswana

    by Kagiso Ndlovu, Nate Stein, Ruth Gaopelo, Mosadikhumo Monkge, Laura Moen, Mmoloki C Molwantwa

    The use of information and communication technologies in healthcare has given rise to mobile health applications and services. For the developing world, mobile health has been hailed as being valuable for extending access to healthcare to underserved populations. More recently, mobile health applications support clinicians to quickly navigate decision making processes. An exemplar decision support system, VisualDx, was implemented in Botswana to provide reference materials at the point of care to support early diagnosis and management of complex dermatological conditions. This study shares experiences, challenges and lessons learnt while implementing VisualDx in Botswana. An explanatory sequential mixed methods feasibility study was conducted with 28 healthcare providers stationed at 20 clinics and hospital sites across Botswana. Nine recorded training sessions were conducted via Zoom and participants thereafter interacted with VisualDx on varying use cases. Quantitative and qualitative data were collected via surveys and a semi-structured interview per participant. Standard VisualDx App usage data was also collected. Descriptive statistics were generated and analyzed. Thematic analysis of interview transcripts was performed using Delve. Experiences, challenges and lessons learned throughout VisualDx implementation in Botswana cut across; Infrastructure, Data protection compliance, Image data quality, Continuous training support, artificial intelligence regulation, Participants’ retention and Sustainable digital health funding. The implementation of VisualDx in Botswana illustrates both the value and the challenges of cross-sector and cross-border collaboration in driving adoption of eHealth tools. The lessons learned may inform future strategy for implementation of other eHealth platforms in Botswana and other similar developing countries.


  • Open Access

    Clinical Data Flow in Botswana Clinics: Protocol for a Mixed-Methods Assessment

    by Grey Faulkenberry, Audrey Masizana, Badisa Mosesane, Kagiso Ndlovu

    Background: Botswana has made significant investments in its health care information infrastructure, including vertical programs for child health and nutrition, HIV care, and tuberculosis. However, effectively integrating the more than 18 systems in place for data collection and reporting has proved to be challenging. The Botswana Health Data Collaborative Roadmap Strategy (2020-24) states that “there exists parallel reporting systems and data is not integrated into the mainstream reports at the national level,” seconded by the Botswana National eLearning strategy (2020), which states that “there is inadequate information flow at all levels, proliferation of systems, reporting tools are not synthesized; hence too many systems are not communicating.” Objective: The objectives of this study are to (1) create a visual representation of how data are processed and the inputs and outputs through each health care system level; (2) understand how frontline workers perceive health care data sharing across existing platforms and the impact of data on health care service delivery. Methods: The setting included a varied range of 30 health care facilities across Botswana, aiming to capture insights from multiple perspectives into data flow and system integration challenges. The study design combined qualitative and quantitative methodologies, informed by the rapid assessment process and the technology assessment model for resource limited settings. The study used a participatory research approach to ensure comprehensive stakeholder engagement from its inception. Survey instruments were designed to capture the intricacies of data processing, sharing, and integration among health care workers. A purposive sampling strategy was used to ensure a wide representation of participants across different health care roles and settings. Data collection used both digital surveys and in-depth interviews. Preliminary themes for analysis include perceptions of the value of health care data and experiences in data collection and sharing. Ethical approvals were comprehensively obtained, reflecting the commitment to uphold research integrity and participant welfare throughout the study. Results: The study recruited almost 44 health care facilities, spanning a variety of health care facilities. Of the 44 recruited facilities, 27 responded to the surveys and participated in the interviews. A total of 75% (112/150) of health care professionals participating came from clinics, 20% (30/150) from hospitals, and 5% (8/150) from health posts and mobile clinics. As of October 10, 2023, the study had collected over 200 quantitative surveys and conducted 90 semistructured interviews. Conclusions: This study has so far shown enthusiastic engagement from the health care community, underscoring the relevance and necessity of this study’s objectives. We believe the methodology, centered around extensive community engagement, is pivotal in capturing a nuanced understanding of the health care data ecosystem. The focus will now shift to the analysis phase of the study, with the aim of developing comprehensive recommendations for improving data flow within Botswana's health care system. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): DERR1-10.2196/52411


  • Open Access

    Project Kamogano: A Mixed-Methods Approach for Evaluating Healthcare Data Collection, Sharing and Use in Botswana (Preprint)

    by J. Grey Faulkenberry, Badisa Mosesane, Audrey Masizana, Kagiso Ndlovu

    BACKGROUND Botswana has made significant investments in its healthcare information infrastructure, including vertical programs for child health and nutrition, HIV care, and Tuberculosis (TB). However, effectively integrating the more than 18 systems in place for data collection and reporting has proved to be challenging. The Botswana Health Data Collaborative Roadmap Strategy (2020-24) states that “there exists parallel reporting systems and data is not integrated into the mainstream reports at the national level,” seconded by the Botswana National eLearning strategy (2020) stating that “there is inadequate information flow at all levels, proliferation of systems, reporting tools are not synthesized; hence too many systems are not communicating.” OBJECTIVE 1. Create a visual representation of how data is processed and the inputs and outputs through each healthcare system level. 2. Understand how front-line workers perceive healthcare data sharing across existing platforms and the impact of data on healthcare service delivery. METHODS A mixed-methods approach was adopted, combining quantitative surveys with semi-structured interviews among healthcare professionals across Botswana. This comprehensive strategy aimed to unearth both statistical trends and nuanced personal perceptions regarding the adoption and use of technology in healthcare data management. RESULTS Despite a prevalent reliance on paper-based records, a broadly positive attitude towards digital technology was observed among healthcare workers. Notable challenges were identified, including disparities in data sharing, access, and the variability in the adoption and comfort level with technological devices. These issues underscore the critical need for enhanced infrastructure and digital literacy among healthcare providers. CONCLUSIONS The findings highlight the transformative potential of digital technology in Botswana's healthcare sector, conditioned on addressing existing barriers. Specifically, the study calls for focused educational initiatives tailored to mitigate disparities in technology usage and to foster a cohesive understanding of data sharing practices among healthcare professionals. "Project Kamogano" underscores the opportunity for significant improvements in healthcare data management in Botswana, leveraging healthcare professionals' optimistic attitudes towards digital innovations. The study advocates for targeted interventions aimed at bridging the digital literacy gap and infrastructure enhancements, thereby facilitating effective patient care and informed public health strategies through strategic system upgrades and interoperability enhancements.

  • Open Access

    Experiences, Lessons, and Challenges With Adapting REDCap for COVID-19 Laboratory Data Management in a Resource-Limited Country: Descriptive Study

    by Kagiso Ndlovu, Kabelo Leonard Mauco, Onalenna Makhura, Robin Hu, Nkwebi Peace Motlogelwa, Audrey Masizana, Emily Lo, Thongbotho Mphoyakgosi, Sikhulile Moyo

    Background: The COVID-19 pandemic brought challenges requiring timely health data sharing to inform accurate decision-making at national levels. In Botswana, we adapted and integrated the Research Electronic Data Capture (REDCap) and the District Health Information System version 2 (DHIS2) platforms to support timely collection and reporting of COVID-19 cases. We focused on establishing an effective COVID-19 data flow at the national public health laboratory, being guided by the needs of health care professionals at the National Health Laboratory (NHL). This integration contributed to automated centralized reporting of COVID-19 results at the Ministry of Health (MOH). Objective: This paper reports the experiences, challenges, and lessons learned while designing, adapting, and implementing the REDCap and DHIS2 platforms to support COVID-19 data management at the NHL in Botswana. Methods: A participatory design approach was adopted to guide the design, customization, and implementation of the REDCap platform in support of COVID-19 data management at the NHL. Study participants included 29 NHL and 4 MOH personnel, and the study was conducted from March 2, 2020, to June 30, 2020. Participants’ requirements for an ideal COVID-19 data management system were established. NVivo 11 software supported thematic analysis of the challenges and resolutions identified during this study. These were categorized according to the 4 themes of infrastructure, capacity development, platform constraints, and interoperability. Results: Overall, REDCap supported the majority of perceived technical and nontechnical requirements for an ideal COVID-19 data management system at the NHL. Although some implementation challenges were identified, each had mitigation strategies such as procurement of mobile Internet routers, engagement of senior management to resolve conflicting policies, continuous REDCap training, and the development of a third-party web application to enhance REDCap’s capabilities. Lessons learned informed next steps and further refinement of the REDCap platform. Conclusions: Implementation of REDCap at the NHL to streamline COVID-19 data collection and integration with the DHIS2 platform was feasible despite the urgency of implementation during the pandemic. By implementing the REDCap platform at the NHL, we demonstrated the possibility of achieving a centralized reporting system of COVID-19 cases, hence enabling timely and informed decision-making at a national level. Challenges faced presented lessons learned to inform sustainable implementation of digital health innovations in Botswana and similar resource-limited countries.


  • Open Access

    Clinical Data Flow in Botswana Clinics: Protocol for a Mixed-Methods Assessment (Preprint)

    by Grey Faulkenberry, Audrey Masizana, Badisa Mosesane, Kagiso Ndlovu

    BACKGROUND Botswana has made significant investments in its health care information infrastructure, including vertical programs for child health and nutrition, HIV care, and tuberculosis. However, effectively integrating the more than 18 systems in place for data collection and reporting has proved to be challenging. The Botswana Health Data Collaborative Roadmap Strategy (2020-24) states that “there exists parallel reporting systems and data is not integrated into the mainstream reports at the national level,” seconded by the Botswana National eLearning strategy (2020), which states that “there is inadequate information flow at all levels, proliferation of systems, reporting tools are not synthesized; hence too many systems are not communicating.” OBJECTIVE The objectives of this study are to (1) create a visual representation of how data are processed and the inputs and outputs through each health care system level; (2) understand how frontline workers perceive health care data sharing across existing platforms and the impact of data on health care service delivery. METHODS The setting included a varied range of 30 health care facilities across Botswana, aiming to capture insights from multiple perspectives into data flow and system integration challenges. The study design combined qualitative and quantitative methodologies, informed by the rapid assessment process and the technology assessment model for resource limited settings. The study used a participatory research approach to ensure comprehensive stakeholder engagement from its inception. Survey instruments were designed to capture the intricacies of data processing, sharing, and integration among health care workers. A purposive sampling strategy was used to ensure a wide representation of participants across different health care roles and settings. Data collection used both digital surveys and in-depth interviews. Preliminary themes for analysis include perceptions of the value of health care data and experiences in data collection and sharing. Ethical approvals were comprehensively obtained, reflecting the commitment to uphold research integrity and participant welfare throughout the study. RESULTS The study recruited almost 44 health care facilities, spanning a variety of health care facilities. Of the 44 recruited facilities, 27 responded to the surveys and participated in the interviews. A total of 75% (112/150) of health care professionals participating came from clinics, 20% (30/150) from hospitals, and 5% (8/150) from health posts and mobile clinics. As of October 10, 2023, the study had collected over 200 quantitative surveys and conducted 90 semistructured interviews. CONCLUSIONS This study has so far shown enthusiastic engagement from the health care community, underscoring the relevance and necessity of this study’s objectives. We believe the methodology, centered around extensive community engagement, is pivotal in capturing a nuanced understanding of the health care data ecosystem. The focus will now shift to the analysis phase of the study, with the aim of developing comprehensive recommendations for improving data flow within Botswana's health care system. INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT DERR1-10.2196/52411

  • Open Access

    Evaluating the Feasibility and Acceptance of a Mobile Clinical Decision Support System in a Resource-Limited Country: Exploratory Study

    by Kagiso Ndlovu, Nate Stein, Ruth Gaopelo, Michael Annechino, Mmoloki C Molwantwa, Mosadikhumo Monkge, Amy Forrestel, Victoria L Williams

    Background: In resource-limited countries, access to specialized health care services such as dermatology is limited. Clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) offer innovative solutions to address this challenge. However, the implementation of CDSSs is commonly associated with unique challenges. VisualDx—an exemplar CDSS—was recently implemented in Botswana to provide reference materials in support of the diagnosis and management of dermatological conditions. To inform the sustainable implementation of VisualDx in Botswana, it is important to evaluate the intended users’ perceptions about the technology. Objective: This study aims to determine health care workers’ acceptance of VisualDx to gauge the feasibility of future adoption in Botswana and other similar health care systems. Methods: The study’s design was informed by constructs of the Technology Acceptance Model. An explanatory, sequential, mixed methods study involving surveys and semistructured interviews was conducted. The REDCap (Research Electronic Data Capture; Vanderbilt University) platform supported web-based data capture from March 2021 through August 2021. In total, 28 health care workers participated in the study. Descriptive statistics were generated and analyzed using Excel (Microsoft Corp), and thematic analysis of interview transcripts was performed using Delve software. Results: All survey respondents (N=28) expressed interest in using mobile health technology to support their work. Before VisualDx, participants referenced textbooks, journal articles, and Google search engines. Overall, participants’ survey responses showed their confidence in VisualDx (18/19, 95%); however, some barriers were noted. Frequently used VisualDx features included generating a differential diagnosis through manual entry of patient symptoms (330/681, 48.5% of total uses) or using the artificial intelligence feature to analyze skin conditions (150/681, 22% of total uses). Overall, 61% (17/28) of the survey respondents were also interviewed, and 4 thematic areas were derived. Conclusions: Participants’ responses indicated their willingness to accept VisualDx. The ability to access information quickly without internet connection is crucial in resource-constrained environments. Selected enhancements to VisualDx may further increase its feasibility in Botswana. Study findings can serve as the basis for improving future CDSS studies and innovations in Botswana and similar resource-limited countries.


  • Open Access

    Experiences, Lessons, and Challenges With Adapting REDCap for COVID-19 Laboratory Data Management in a Resource-Limited Country: Descriptive Study (Preprint)

    by Kagiso Ndlovu, Kabelo Leonard Mauco, Onalenna Makhura, Robin Hu, Nkwebi Peace Motlogelwa, Audrey Masizana, Emily Lo, Thongbotho Mphoyakgosi, Sikhulile Moyo

    BACKGROUND The COVID-19 pandemic brought challenges requiring timely health data sharing to inform accurate decision-making at national levels. In Botswana, we adapted and integrated the Research Electronic Data Capture (REDCap) and the District Health Information System version 2 (DHIS2) platforms to support timely collection and reporting of COVID-19 cases. We focused on establishing an effective COVID-19 data flow at the national public health laboratory, being guided by the needs of health care professionals at the National Health Laboratory (NHL). This integration contributed to automated centralized reporting of COVID-19 results at the Ministry of Health (MOH). OBJECTIVE This paper reports the experiences, challenges, and lessons learned while designing, adapting, and implementing the REDCap and DHIS2 platforms to support COVID-19 data management at the NHL in Botswana. METHODS A participatory design approach was adopted to guide the design, customization, and implementation of the REDCap platform in support of COVID-19 data management at the NHL. Study participants included 29 NHL and 4 MOH personnel, and the study was conducted from March 2, 2020, to June 30, 2020. Participants’ requirements for an ideal COVID-19 data management system were established. NVivo 11 software supported thematic analysis of the challenges and resolutions identified during this study. These were categorized according to the 4 themes of infrastructure, capacity development, platform constraints, and interoperability. RESULTS Overall, REDCap supported the majority of perceived technical and nontechnical requirements for an ideal COVID-19 data management system at the NHL. Although some implementation challenges were identified, each had mitigation strategies such as procurement of mobile Internet routers, engagement of senior management to resolve conflicting policies, continuous REDCap training, and the development of a third-party web application to enhance REDCap’s capabilities. Lessons learned informed next steps and further refinement of the REDCap platform. CONCLUSIONS Implementation of REDCap at the NHL to streamline COVID-19 data collection and integration with the DHIS2 platform was feasible despite the urgency of implementation during the pandemic. By implementing the REDCap platform at the NHL, we demonstrated the possibility of achieving a centralized reporting system of COVID-19 cases, hence enabling timely and informed decision-making at a national level. Challenges faced presented lessons learned to inform sustainable implementation of digital health innovations in Botswana and similar resource-limited countries.

  • Open Access

    Adapting REDCap for COVID-19 Laboratory Data Management in Botswana - Experiences, Lessons and Challenges

    by Kagiso Ndlovu, Kabelo Leonard Mauco, Onalenna Makhura, Robin Hu, Nkwebi Motlogelwa, Audrey Masizana, Emily Lo, Thongbotho Mphoyakgosi, Sikhulile Moyo

    Background The COVID-19 pandemic brought challenges requiring timely health data sharing to inform decision making on appropriate interventions at a national level. To streamline the collection and integration of data, we designed and piloted a workflow utilizing the REDCap platform. Our approach focused on establishing efficient COVID-19 data flows within a national public health laboratory, enabling seamless integration with the national district health information management system (DHIS2). This integration facilitated an automated centralized reporting of COVID-19 results at the Ministry of Health. This paper reports the experiences, challenges and lessons learnt while designing, adapting, and implementing REDCap to support COVID-19 data management at the National Health Lab in Botswana. Methods A participatory design approach was adopted to guide the design, customization, and implementation of the REDCap platform in support of COVID-19 data management at the NHL. Twenty-nine NHL and four Ministry of Health personnel participated in the study, effective from 02 March 2020 to 30 June 2020. Participants’ requirements for an ideal COVID-19 data management system were established. NVivo 11 software supported thematic analysis of the challenges and resolutions identified during this study. These were categorized according to four themes of Infrastructure, Capacity Development, Platform constraints, and Interoperability. Results Overall, REDCap supported a majority of perceived technical and non-technical requirements for an ideal COVID-19 data management system at the NHL. Although some implementation challenges were identified, each had mitigation strategies such as procurement of mobile internet routers, engagement of senior management to resolve conflicting policies, continuous REDCap training, and the development of a third-party web application to enhance REDCap’s capabilities. Lessons learnt informed next steps and further refinement of the REDCap platform. Conclusion Implementation of REDCap at the NHL to streamline COVID-19 data collection and integration with national systems was feasible despite its emergency implementation during the pandemic. By piloting and implementing the REDCap workflow at a national public health laboratory, we demonstrated feasibility for centralized reporting of COVID-19 cases, enabling timely and informed decision-making at the national level. Challenges faced presented lessons learnt to inform sustainable implementation of digital health innovations in a resource-constrained environment.

  • Open Access

    What's fair is… fair? Presenting JustEFAB, an ethical framework for operationalizing medical ethics and social justice in the integration of clinical machine learning

    by Melissa Mccradden, Oluwadara Odusi, Shalmali Joshi, Ismail Akrout, Kagiso Ndlovu, Ben Glocker, Gabriel Maicas, Xiaoxuan Liu, Mjaye Mazwi, Tee Garnett, et al.

    The problem of algorithmic bias represents an ethical threat to the fair treatment of patients when their care involves machine learning (ML) models informing clinical decision-making. The design, development, testing, and integration of ML models therefore require a lifecycle approach to bias identification and mitigation efforts. Presently, most work focuses on the ML tool alone, neglecting the larger sociotechnical context in which these models operate. Moreover, the narrow focus on technical definitions of fairness must be integrated within the larger context of medical ethics in order to facilitate equitable care with ML. Drawing from principles of medical ethics, research ethics, feminist philosophy of science, and justice-based theories, we describe the Justice, Equity, Fairness, and Anti-Bias (JustEFAB) guideline intended to support the design, testing, validation, and clinical evaluation of ML models with respect to algorithmic fairness. This paper describes JustEFAB's development and vetting through multiple advisory groups and the lifecycle approach to addressing fairness in clinical ML tools. We present an ethical decision-making framework to support design and development, adjudication between ethical values as design choices, silent trial evaluation, and prospective clinical evaluation guided by medical ethics and social justice principles. We provide some preliminary considerations for oversight and safety to support ongoing attention to fairness issues. We envision this guideline as useful to many stakeholders, including ML developers, healthcare decision-makers, research ethics committees, regulators, and other parties who have interest in the fair and judicious use of clinical ML tools.