Niall A. Smyth
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Niall A. Smyth has a total of 177 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Christopher D. Murawski
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina
11 shared publicationsAmgad M. Haleem
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Kasr Al-Ainy Hospital, Cairo University School of Medicine, Cairo, Egypt
9 shared publications- Charles P. Hannon
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota
9 shared publications - John Garrett Kennedy
NYU Langone Health, New York City, New York
9 shared publications Lew C. Schon
Institute for Foot and Ankle Reconstruction, Mercy Medical Center, Baltimore, Mayland
9 shared publicationsMaCalus V. Hogan
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
8 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 16 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Surgical Intervention for Massive Lesions (>3cm 2 ): Proceedings of the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Management of massive (>3 cm 2 ) osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) remains challenging due to extensive subchondral bone loss, uncontained lesion morphology, and limited high-quality evidence guiding treatment strategies. To address these gaps, an international group of experts convened to establish consensus-based recommendations for surgical management of massive OLT. Methods: Experts from multiple countries participated in a structured Delphi consensus during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) meetings held in 2017 and 2025. Blinded surveys, structured questionnaires, and in-person discussions were used to develop and refine statements supported by literature review and graded evidence. Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). Grade of evidence was determined by previously established guidelines. Results: A total of 8 consensus statements were developed addressing the surgical management of massive OLT (> 3 cm 2 ), all of which achieved strong consensus (≥86%), including 1 statement with unanimous agreement. Bulk allograft transplantation was identified as a primary joint-preserving strategy for large, uncontained, or previously treated lesions. Key technical considerations included complete lesion excision, adequate graft depth, precise graft matching, and stable fixation. Experts emphasized the importance of patient selection, surgical technique, and postoperative activity modification to optimize outcomes. Conclusion: The ICCRA statements provide structured, evidence-informed guidance for the operative management of massive OLT. By defining indications, technical considerations, and expected outcomes for bulk allograft transplantation and alternative reconstructive strategies, this framework aims to support clinical decision-making and promote consistency in the management of this complex and challenging condition. Level of Evidence: V, expert opinion
- 16 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Surgical Intervention for Massive Lesions (>3cm 2 ): Proceedings of the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Management of massive (>3 cm 2 ) osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) remains challenging due to extensive subchondral bone loss, uncontained lesion morphology, and limited high-quality evidence guiding treatment strategies. To address these gaps, an international group of experts convened to establish consensus-based recommendations for surgical management of massive OLT. Methods: Experts from multiple countries participated in a structured Delphi consensus during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) meetings held in 2017 and 2025. Blinded surveys, structured questionnaires, and in-person discussions were used to develop and refine statements supported by literature review and graded evidence. Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). Grade of evidence was determined by previously established guidelines. Results: A total of 8 consensus statements were developed addressing the surgical management of massive OLT (> 3 cm 2 ), all of which achieved strong consensus (≥86%), including 1 statement with unanimous agreement. Bulk allograft transplantation was identified as a primary joint-preserving strategy for large, uncontained, or previously treated lesions. Key technical considerations included complete lesion excision, adequate graft depth, precise graft matching, and stable fixation. Experts emphasized the importance of patient selection, surgical technique, and postoperative activity modification to optimize outcomes. Conclusion: The ICCRA statements provide structured, evidence-informed guidance for the operative management of massive OLT. By defining indications, technical considerations, and expected outcomes for bulk allograft transplantation and alternative reconstructive strategies, this framework aims to support clinical decision-making and promote consistency in the management of this complex and challenging condition. Level of Evidence: V, expert opinion
- 6 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Post-Treatment Follow-up, Rehabilitation, and Return to Sport: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Postoperative follow-up, rehabilitation, and return to sport (RTS) are key components of recovery following surgical management of osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT). However, substantial variability exists in postoperative protocols, with limited high-quality evidence guiding clinical practices Methods: International experts convened during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) in Pittsburgh, USA (2017), with subsequent ratification of recommendations in New York, USA (2025). The original consensus statements were developed using a modified Delphi process involving electronic surveys, structured questionnaires, and expert discussion. Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). The recommendations addressed postoperative follow-up, rehabilitation, and RTS following OLT management. Results: A total of 16 consensus statements were developed and subsequently ratified, comprising 7 statements addressing post-treatment follow-up and 9 addressing rehabilitation and RTS. All statements achieved strong consensus, with agreement ranging from 75% to 98%. Follow-up recommendations emphasized standardized clinical assessment and patient-reported outcomes, with extended monitoring in select patients. Rehabilitation recommendations supported early controlled motion and progressive weightbearing, with individualized progression according to procedure and clinical performance. Return to sport recommendations emphasized functional recovery and individualized decision-making. Ten statements (63%) were classified exclusively as Grade E, highlighting the limited evidence supporting several recommendations. Conclusion: The ICCRA consensus statements establish a structured framework for postoperative follow-up, rehabilitation, and RTS following surgical management of OLT. Despite strong expert agreement, several recommendations remain supported by limited evidence, underlining the need for prospective studies to establish validated, procedure-specific rehabilitation protocols and objective RTS criteria. Level of Evidence: V, expert consensus
- 6 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Post-Treatment Follow-up, Rehabilitation, and Return to Sport: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Postoperative follow-up, rehabilitation, and return to sport (RTS) are key components of recovery following surgical management of osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT). However, substantial variability exists in postoperative protocols, with limited high-quality evidence guiding clinical practices Methods: International experts convened during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) in Pittsburgh, USA (2017), with subsequent ratification of recommendations in New York, USA (2025). The original consensus statements were developed using a modified Delphi process involving electronic surveys, structured questionnaires, and expert discussion. Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). The recommendations addressed postoperative follow-up, rehabilitation, and RTS following OLT management. Results: A total of 16 consensus statements were developed and subsequently ratified, comprising 7 statements addressing post-treatment follow-up and 9 addressing rehabilitation and RTS. All statements achieved strong consensus, with agreement ranging from 75% to 98%. Follow-up recommendations emphasized standardized clinical assessment and patient-reported outcomes, with extended monitoring in select patients. Rehabilitation recommendations supported early controlled motion and progressive weightbearing, with individualized progression according to procedure and clinical performance. Return to sport recommendations emphasized functional recovery and individualized decision-making. Ten statements (63%) were classified exclusively as Grade E, highlighting the limited evidence supporting several recommendations. Conclusion: The ICCRA consensus statements establish a structured framework for postoperative follow-up, rehabilitation, and RTS following surgical management of OLT. Despite strong expert agreement, several recommendations remain supported by limited evidence, underlining the need for prospective studies to establish validated, procedure-specific rehabilitation protocols and objective RTS criteria. Level of Evidence: V, expert consensus
- 5 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Revision and Salvage Management of Failed Osteochondral Lesions of the Talus: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Management of failed osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLTs) remains challenging due to limited comparative evidence guiding revision and salvage treatment. This proceedings summary presents the conclusions reached during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) meetings for evaluating failure and selecting subsequent treatment. Methods: Two meetings used a modified Delphi process involving blinded electronic surveys, literature review, in-person discussion, and anonymous final voting. The 2017 panel comprised 75 experts from 25 countries and 1 territory, with the same panel participated in 2025. Eight revision and salvage statements developed in 2017 were ratified in 2025, and 6 statements addressing failed primary bone marrow stimulation (BMS) were developed in 2025. Consensus strength was classified by percentage agreement. Evidence was graded using a scale ranging from randomized controlled trials or meta-analyses (A1/A2) to expert opinion or basic science (E). Results: Of 14 statements, 6 achieved unanimous agreement, 7 strong consensus, and 1 consensus. Evidence grades were B2 for 10 statements, C for 1, and E for 3. The statement identifying lesion size as the main treatment determinant when alignment and stability are maintained achieved 69% agreement, representing modest consensus. Revision recommendations emphasized identifying the lesion as the symptom source and a cause of failure. Salvage was supported when further cartilage revision was unrealistic or progressive osteoarthritis was present. Consideration to use orthobiologics received unanimous agreement, but Grade E evidence. Conclusion: These statements provide an expert-consensus framework for managing failed OLT. Prospective comparative studies are needed to clarify treatment selection and outcomes. Level of Evidence: V, expert consensus
- 5 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Revision and Salvage Management of Failed Osteochondral Lesions of the Talus: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Management of failed osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLTs) remains challenging due to limited comparative evidence guiding revision and salvage treatment. This proceedings summary presents the conclusions reached during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) meetings for evaluating failure and selecting subsequent treatment. Methods: Two meetings used a modified Delphi process involving blinded electronic surveys, literature review, in-person discussion, and anonymous final voting. The 2017 panel comprised 75 experts from 25 countries and 1 territory, with the same panel participated in 2025. Eight revision and salvage statements developed in 2017 were ratified in 2025, and 6 statements addressing failed primary bone marrow stimulation (BMS) were developed in 2025. Consensus strength was classified by percentage agreement. Evidence was graded using a scale ranging from randomized controlled trials or meta-analyses (A1/A2) to expert opinion or basic science (E). Results: Of 14 statements, 6 achieved unanimous agreement, 7 strong consensus, and 1 consensus. Evidence grades were B2 for 10 statements, C for 1, and E for 3. The statement identifying lesion size as the main treatment determinant when alignment and stability are maintained achieved 69% agreement, representing modest consensus. Revision recommendations emphasized identifying the lesion as the symptom source and a cause of failure. Salvage was supported when further cartilage revision was unrealistic or progressive osteoarthritis was present. Consideration to use orthobiologics received unanimous agreement, but Grade E evidence. Conclusion: These statements provide an expert-consensus framework for managing failed OLT. Prospective comparative studies are needed to clarify treatment selection and outcomes. Level of Evidence: V, expert consensus
- 1 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Osteochondral Fragment Fixation: Proceedings of the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: The optimal approach to fixation techniques in cartilage repair of the ankle remains unclear due to the predominance of low-quality evidence and limited high-level studies. To address this gap, an international group of experts convened to establish consensus-based recommendations grounded in the best available evidence, formulated during the 2017 International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle. Methods: Seventy-five multidisciplinary experts from 25 countries and 1 territory participated in a structured Delphi-based consensus process. Eleven working groups were tasked with reviewing specific topics within cartilage repair of the ankle, conducting systematic literature reviews, and grading evidence to support each statement. Statements lacking full agreement were further discussed and refined before final voting. Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). Results: Fifteen consensus statements related to fixation techniques were developed and all achieved strong consensus, with a minimum agreement level of 82%. These statements provide standardized guidance on indications, technical considerations, and expected outcomes for fixation procedures in osteochondral lesions of the talus. Conclusion: This synthesis of the international expert consensus statements offers unified recommendations to guide the use of fixation techniques in the management of osteochondral lesions of the talus, fostering greater consistency in clinical practice, research methodology, and future guideline development.
- 1 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Osteochondral Fragment Fixation: Proceedings of the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: The optimal approach to fixation techniques in cartilage repair of the ankle remains unclear due to the predominance of low-quality evidence and limited high-level studies. To address this gap, an international group of experts convened to establish consensus-based recommendations grounded in the best available evidence, formulated during the 2017 International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle. Methods: Seventy-five multidisciplinary experts from 25 countries and 1 territory participated in a structured Delphi-based consensus process. Eleven working groups were tasked with reviewing specific topics within cartilage repair of the ankle, conducting systematic literature reviews, and grading evidence to support each statement. Statements lacking full agreement were further discussed and refined before final voting. Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). Results: Fifteen consensus statements related to fixation techniques were developed and all achieved strong consensus, with a minimum agreement level of 82%. These statements provide standardized guidance on indications, technical considerations, and expected outcomes for fixation procedures in osteochondral lesions of the talus. Conclusion: This synthesis of the international expert consensus statements offers unified recommendations to guide the use of fixation techniques in the management of osteochondral lesions of the talus, fostering greater consistency in clinical practice, research methodology, and future guideline development.
- 8 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Clinical Work-up, Diagnostic Imaging, and Radiographic Classification Systems for Osteochondral Lesions of the Talus: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: The evaluation of osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) has long been limited by variability in imaging protocols, lesion measurement techniques, and clinical utility of radiographic classification systems. To address these challenges, 3 International Congress Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle were convened in Pittsburgh, USA (2017), Dublin, Ireland (2019), and New York, USA (2025) to establish agreement on the work-up, diagnostic imaging, and radiographic classification systems for OLT. Methods: Seventy-five multidisciplinary experts from over 25 countries and 1 territory participated in a structured Delphi-based consensus process. Blinded surveys, structured questionnaires, and in-person discussions were used to develop and refine statements, supported by literature review and graded evidence (A1-E). Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). Results: In total, 19 consensus statements were achieved across the 3 meetings. Strong agreement was reached for first-line use of weight-bearing radiographs and complementary use of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography for lesion characterization. Standardized assessment of lesion size in 3 planes and localization using a 9-zone grid were endorsed. Diagnostic arthroscopy was considered to have limited routine value in the setting of advanced imaging. Post-treatment imaging recommendations clarified indications for radiographs and cross-sectional imaging and emphasized the limited correlation between imaging findings and clinical function. Computed tomography–based classification systems were considered more useful for guiding treatment decisions than plain radiographic or MRI-based systems. Conclusion: These international consensus statements establish a standardized imaging-based framework for the evaluation and classification of OLT, improving consistency in diagnosis, treatment planning, and clinical reporting.
- 8 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Clinical Work-up, Diagnostic Imaging, and Radiographic Classification Systems for Osteochondral Lesions of the Talus: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: The evaluation of osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) has long been limited by variability in imaging protocols, lesion measurement techniques, and clinical utility of radiographic classification systems. To address these challenges, 3 International Congress Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle were convened in Pittsburgh, USA (2017), Dublin, Ireland (2019), and New York, USA (2025) to establish agreement on the work-up, diagnostic imaging, and radiographic classification systems for OLT. Methods: Seventy-five multidisciplinary experts from over 25 countries and 1 territory participated in a structured Delphi-based consensus process. Blinded surveys, structured questionnaires, and in-person discussions were used to develop and refine statements, supported by literature review and graded evidence (A1-E). Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%). Results: In total, 19 consensus statements were achieved across the 3 meetings. Strong agreement was reached for first-line use of weight-bearing radiographs and complementary use of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography for lesion characterization. Standardized assessment of lesion size in 3 planes and localization using a 9-zone grid were endorsed. Diagnostic arthroscopy was considered to have limited routine value in the setting of advanced imaging. Post-treatment imaging recommendations clarified indications for radiographs and cross-sectional imaging and emphasized the limited correlation between imaging findings and clinical function. Computed tomography–based classification systems were considered more useful for guiding treatment decisions than plain radiographic or MRI-based systems. Conclusion: These international consensus statements establish a standardized imaging-based framework for the evaluation and classification of OLT, improving consistency in diagnosis, treatment planning, and clinical reporting.
- 29 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Surgical Intervention for Moderate-To-Large lesions (1-2.9 cm 2 ): Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Management of moderate-to-large (1-2.9 cm 2 ) osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) remains challenging due to the transition from reparative to replacement surgical strategies and the absence of high-level comparative evidence guiding treatment selection. Methods: An international panel of experts participated in a modified Delphi consensus process during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) meetings held in 2017 and 2025. Survey rounds and structured discussions were used to generate and refine consensus statements. Consensus strength was categorized as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%), and levels of evidence were graded according to established criteria. Results: Consensus statements were developed for autologous osteochondral transplantation (AOT), osteochondral allograft transplantation (OCA), scaffold-based cartilage restoration techniques, and emerging extracellular matrix and juvenile cartilage allograft strategies. Autologous osteochondral transplantation was supported as a primary treatment option for cystic, uncontained, and revision lesions, with emphasis on graft continuity and appropriate depth. Osteochondral allograft transplantation was recommended for larger or uncontained lesions and in cases where autograft is contraindicated, with preference for fresh, size-matched grafts used within 28 days. Scaffold-based techniques were identified as viable alternatives in select primary and revision settings, although not superior to AOT for larger lesions. Extracellular matrix cartilage allograft (ECMA) and particulate juvenile cartilage allograft transplantation (PJCAT) potentially enhance cartilage restoration. Conclusion: The ICCRA consensus provides a structured, evidence-informed framework for the surgical management of moderate-to-large OLT. Although multiple treatment strategies demonstrate clinical utility, the current literature remains heterogeneous with limited high-level evidence. Further prospective and comparative studies are warranted to better define optimal indications and long-term outcomes for each approach. Level of Evidence: V, Expert consensus
- 29 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Surgical Intervention for Moderate-To-Large lesions (1-2.9 cm 2 ): Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: Management of moderate-to-large (1-2.9 cm 2 ) osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) remains challenging due to the transition from reparative to replacement surgical strategies and the absence of high-level comparative evidence guiding treatment selection. Methods: An international panel of experts participated in a modified Delphi consensus process during the International Congress on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle (ICCRA) meetings held in 2017 and 2025. Survey rounds and structured discussions were used to generate and refine consensus statements. Consensus strength was categorized as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%), and levels of evidence were graded according to established criteria. Results: Consensus statements were developed for autologous osteochondral transplantation (AOT), osteochondral allograft transplantation (OCA), scaffold-based cartilage restoration techniques, and emerging extracellular matrix and juvenile cartilage allograft strategies. Autologous osteochondral transplantation was supported as a primary treatment option for cystic, uncontained, and revision lesions, with emphasis on graft continuity and appropriate depth. Osteochondral allograft transplantation was recommended for larger or uncontained lesions and in cases where autograft is contraindicated, with preference for fresh, size-matched grafts used within 28 days. Scaffold-based techniques were identified as viable alternatives in select primary and revision settings, although not superior to AOT for larger lesions. Extracellular matrix cartilage allograft (ECMA) and particulate juvenile cartilage allograft transplantation (PJCAT) potentially enhance cartilage restoration. Conclusion: The ICCRA consensus provides a structured, evidence-informed framework for the surgical management of moderate-to-large OLT. Although multiple treatment strategies demonstrate clinical utility, the current literature remains heterogeneous with limited high-level evidence. Further prospective and comparative studies are warranted to better define optimal indications and long-term outcomes for each approach. Level of Evidence: V, Expert consensus
- 24 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Bridging Conservative Management With Injectable Orthobiologic Therapies: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: The management of osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) is challenging, with 2 main options being conservative and surgical management. Orthobiologic therapies come to bridge the gap between these 2 options; however, inconsistencies in indication, composition, and heterogeneous evidence limit clinical decision-making. To address these challenges, 3 International Congress Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle were convened in Pittsburgh, USA (2017), Dublin, Ireland (2019), and New York, USA (2025) to establish agreement on the role of conservative management and injectable orthobiologic strategies in the treatment of OLT. Methods: Seventy-five multidisciplinary experts from over 25 countries and 1 territory participated in a structured Delphi-based consensus process. Blinded surveys, structured questionnaires, and in-person discussions were used to develop and refine statements, supported by literature review and graded evidence (A1–E). Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%) Results: In total, 29 consensus statements were achieved across the 3 meetings. Strong agreement was reached regarding indications and expected outcomes of conservative management, including the role of immobilization and appropriate timing for surgical intervention. Orthobiologic injections, including platelet-rich plasma, concentrated bone marrow aspirate, and hyaluronic acid, were considered appropriate in select patients with persistent symptoms, although no superiority was demonstrated among formulations, preparation methods, or injection strategies. When used as adjuncts to surgical procedures, orthobiologics may improve radiological outcomes, with limited evidence for improvement in clinical outcomes. Technical considerations, including preferred harvest sites and a lack of standardized preparation protocols, were identified, along with key principles for patient counseling Conclusion: These international consensus statements establish a standardized framework for the conservative management and use of injectable orthobiologic therapies in OLT. By clarifying indications, technical considerations, and current limitations, this work aims to improve consistency in clinical practice, guide treatment decision-making, and inform future research.
- 24 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
Bridging Conservative Management With Injectable Orthobiologic Therapies: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle
Background: The management of osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT) is challenging, with 2 main options being conservative and surgical management. Orthobiologic therapies come to bridge the gap between these 2 options; however, inconsistencies in indication, composition, and heterogeneous evidence limit clinical decision-making. To address these challenges, 3 International Congress Meetings on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle were convened in Pittsburgh, USA (2017), Dublin, Ireland (2019), and New York, USA (2025) to establish agreement on the role of conservative management and injectable orthobiologic strategies in the treatment of OLT. Methods: Seventy-five multidisciplinary experts from over 25 countries and 1 territory participated in a structured Delphi-based consensus process. Blinded surveys, structured questionnaires, and in-person discussions were used to develop and refine statements, supported by literature review and graded evidence (A1–E). Consensus strength was defined as consensus (51%-74%), strong consensus (75%-99%), or unanimous (100%) Results: In total, 29 consensus statements were achieved across the 3 meetings. Strong agreement was reached regarding indications and expected outcomes of conservative management, including the role of immobilization and appropriate timing for surgical intervention. Orthobiologic injections, including platelet-rich plasma, concentrated bone marrow aspirate, and hyaluronic acid, were considered appropriate in select patients with persistent symptoms, although no superiority was demonstrated among formulations, preparation methods, or injection strategies. When used as adjuncts to surgical procedures, orthobiologics may improve radiological outcomes, with limited evidence for improvement in clinical outcomes. Technical considerations, including preferred harvest sites and a lack of standardized preparation protocols, were identified, along with key principles for patient counseling Conclusion: These international consensus statements establish a standardized framework for the conservative management and use of injectable orthobiologic therapies in OLT. By clarifying indications, technical considerations, and current limitations, this work aims to improve consistency in clinical practice, guide treatment decision-making, and inform future research.
- 27 August 2021
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
- Vol. 30 (1) , e118-e123
The Mandated Publication of Individual Hospital Charge Description Masters Does Not Permit the Estimation of Complex Procedure Charges
Background: As healthcare spending continues to rise, price transparency is crucial for patients to calculate a reasonable cost estimate for tests and procedures. Legislative efforts have been successful at mandating increased hospital price transparency, including publishing charge description masters (CDMs), but their usefulness in permitting patients to assess the cost for complex procedures is unclear. We sought to determine CDM and diagnosis-related group (DRG) prevalence and evaluate whether these are effective tools for patients to preemptively ascertain the costs for simple and complex tests and procedures. Methods: Cross-sectional analysis of publicly available 2019 CDMs and DRGs from 122 hospitals in the United States, including the top-20 as ranked by the US News & World Report Honor Roll and two top-ranked hospitals per state. We first determined the availability of CDMs and DRGs and then determined the ability to estimate the hospital charge for a three-view knee radiograph and a primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) using CDM and DRG data. Results: One hundred fifteen of 122 (94.3%) hospitals published a CDM, and 78 (63.9%) published a DRG. Top-ranked hospitals published DRGs more frequently than those outside of the Honor Roll designation (P = 0.04). The estimated charge for a three-view knee radiograph could be calculated from 113/115 (98.3%) CDMs. The estimated total charge for a primary TKA could not be obtained from any of the available CDMs. By comparison, the estimated charge for a primary TKA could be obtained from 76/78 (97.4%) of the available DRGs. Discussion: CDMs are available as currently mandated for most hospitals and generally can be used to identify the charges for simple procedures, but they are ineffective tools for patients to estimate the charges associated with a multifaceted healthcare procedure, such as TKA. Although DRGs are less frequently available, they are a more effective resource for patients to estimate charges.
- 27 August 2021
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
- Vol. 30 (1) , e118-e123
The Mandated Publication of Individual Hospital Charge Description Masters Does Not Permit the Estimation of Complex Procedure Charges
Background: As healthcare spending continues to rise, price transparency is crucial for patients to calculate a reasonable cost estimate for tests and procedures. Legislative efforts have been successful at mandating increased hospital price transparency, including publishing charge description masters (CDMs), but their usefulness in permitting patients to assess the cost for complex procedures is unclear. We sought to determine CDM and diagnosis-related group (DRG) prevalence and evaluate whether these are effective tools for patients to preemptively ascertain the costs for simple and complex tests and procedures. Methods: Cross-sectional analysis of publicly available 2019 CDMs and DRGs from 122 hospitals in the United States, including the top-20 as ranked by the US News & World Report Honor Roll and two top-ranked hospitals per state. We first determined the availability of CDMs and DRGs and then determined the ability to estimate the hospital charge for a three-view knee radiograph and a primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) using CDM and DRG data. Results: One hundred fifteen of 122 (94.3%) hospitals published a CDM, and 78 (63.9%) published a DRG. Top-ranked hospitals published DRGs more frequently than those outside of the Honor Roll designation (P = 0.04). The estimated charge for a three-view knee radiograph could be calculated from 113/115 (98.3%) CDMs. The estimated total charge for a primary TKA could not be obtained from any of the available CDMs. By comparison, the estimated charge for a primary TKA could be obtained from 76/78 (97.4%) of the available DRGs. Discussion: CDMs are available as currently mandated for most hospitals and generally can be used to identify the charges for simple procedures, but they are ineffective tools for patients to estimate the charges associated with a multifaceted healthcare procedure, such as TKA. Although DRGs are less frequently available, they are a more effective resource for patients to estimate charges.
- 26 September 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle International
- Vol. 42 (1) , 89-95
Biomechanical Comparison of Hook Plate vs Headless Compression Screw Fixation of Large Fifth Metatarsal Base Avulsion Fractures
Debate exists on the optimum fixation construct for large avulsion fractures of the fifth metatarsal base. We compared the biomechanical strength of 2 headless compression screws vs a hook plate for fixation of these fractures. Large avulsion fractures were simulated on 10 matched pairs of fresh-frozen cadaveric specimens. Specimens were assigned to receive two 2.5-mm headless compression screws or an anatomic fifth metatarsal hook plate, then cyclically loaded through the plantar fascia and metatarsal base. Specimens underwent 100 cycles at 50%, 75%, and 100% physiological load for a total of 300 cycles. The hook plate group demonstrated a significantly higher number of cycles to failure compared with the screw group (270.7 ± 66.0 [range 100-300] cycles vs 178.6 ± 95.7 [range 24-300] cycles, respectively; P = .039). Seven of 10 hook plate specimens remained intact at the maximum 300 cycles compared with 2 of 10 screw specimens. Nine of 10 plate specimens survived at least 1 cycle at 100% physiologic load compared with 5 of 10 screw specimens. A hook plate construct was biomechanically superior to a headless compression screw construct for fixation of large avulsion fractures of the fifth metatarsal base. Whether using hook plates or headless compression screws, surgeons should consider protecting patient weight-bearing after fixation of fifth metatarsal base large avulsion fracture until bony union has occurred.
- 26 September 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle International
- Vol. 42 (1) , 89-95
Biomechanical Comparison of Hook Plate vs Headless Compression Screw Fixation of Large Fifth Metatarsal Base Avulsion Fractures
Debate exists on the optimum fixation construct for large avulsion fractures of the fifth metatarsal base. We compared the biomechanical strength of 2 headless compression screws vs a hook plate for fixation of these fractures. Large avulsion fractures were simulated on 10 matched pairs of fresh-frozen cadaveric specimens. Specimens were assigned to receive two 2.5-mm headless compression screws or an anatomic fifth metatarsal hook plate, then cyclically loaded through the plantar fascia and metatarsal base. Specimens underwent 100 cycles at 50%, 75%, and 100% physiological load for a total of 300 cycles. The hook plate group demonstrated a significantly higher number of cycles to failure compared with the screw group (270.7 ± 66.0 [range 100-300] cycles vs 178.6 ± 95.7 [range 24-300] cycles, respectively; P = .039). Seven of 10 hook plate specimens remained intact at the maximum 300 cycles compared with 2 of 10 screw specimens. Nine of 10 plate specimens survived at least 1 cycle at 100% physiologic load compared with 5 of 10 screw specimens. A hook plate construct was biomechanically superior to a headless compression screw construct for fixation of large avulsion fractures of the fifth metatarsal base. Whether using hook plates or headless compression screws, surgeons should consider protecting patient weight-bearing after fixation of fifth metatarsal base large avulsion fracture until bony union has occurred.
- 3 July 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
- Vol. 14 (4) , 366-371
The Use of a Synthetic Cartilage Implant for Hallux Rigidus: A Systematic Review
Background. Hallux rigidus is a common pathology afflicting the foot, for which various joint salvage techniques have been described with a multitude of different implants. Recently, a synthetic cartilage implant composed of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) received FDA premarket approval for the treatment of arthritis of the great toe. The purpose of this study was to (1) systematically review the clinical evidence supporting the use of a PVA implant in hallux rigidus and (2) determine the strength of the recommendation that can be made supporting the use of a PVA implant by evaluating the quality of evidence available. Methods. A systematic review was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis. Using the terms “cartiva OR polyvinyl alcohol OR synthetic cartilage OR hemiarthroplasty AND hallux rigidus OR great toe arthritis OR first toe arthritis” we searched the PubMed/Medline database. The quality of the included studies was evaluated using the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Clinical Practice Guideline and Systematic Review Methodology. Results. Seven studies met the inclusion criteria, 6 of these were derived from a single randomized controlled trial. A moderate recommendation can be given for the use of a PVA implant for hallux rigidus based on short-term outcomes. A limited recommendation can be given for the use of a PVA implant for hallux rigidus based on mid-term outcomes. Conclusion. There are limited studies available detailing the outcomes of a PVA implant for hallux rigidus; however, the results that are available demonstrate a high level of evidence. Levels of Evidence: Level I: Systematic review
- 3 July 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle Specialist
- Vol. 14 (4) , 366-371
The Use of a Synthetic Cartilage Implant for Hallux Rigidus: A Systematic Review
Background. Hallux rigidus is a common pathology afflicting the foot, for which various joint salvage techniques have been described with a multitude of different implants. Recently, a synthetic cartilage implant composed of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) received FDA premarket approval for the treatment of arthritis of the great toe. The purpose of this study was to (1) systematically review the clinical evidence supporting the use of a PVA implant in hallux rigidus and (2) determine the strength of the recommendation that can be made supporting the use of a PVA implant by evaluating the quality of evidence available. Methods. A systematic review was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis. Using the terms “cartiva OR polyvinyl alcohol OR synthetic cartilage OR hemiarthroplasty AND hallux rigidus OR great toe arthritis OR first toe arthritis” we searched the PubMed/Medline database. The quality of the included studies was evaluated using the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Clinical Practice Guideline and Systematic Review Methodology. Results. Seven studies met the inclusion criteria, 6 of these were derived from a single randomized controlled trial. A moderate recommendation can be given for the use of a PVA implant for hallux rigidus based on short-term outcomes. A limited recommendation can be given for the use of a PVA implant for hallux rigidus based on mid-term outcomes. Conclusion. There are limited studies available detailing the outcomes of a PVA implant for hallux rigidus; however, the results that are available demonstrate a high level of evidence. Levels of Evidence: Level I: Systematic review