Karim Bettache
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Karim Bettache has a total of 195 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Agnieszka Sorokowska
The International Institute for Mental Health, Babes-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania
7 shared publications - Ana Paula Relvas
University of Coimbra
7 shared publications - Gyesook Yoo
Department of Child & Family Studies, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
7 shared publications - Ike Ernest Onyishi
Department of Psychology, University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Nigeria
7 shared publications - Jean Carlos Natividade
Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Campinas
7 shared publications - Khodabakhsh Ahmadi
Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perspectives on Psychological Science
“WEIRDly Exceptional”: Has Cultural Psychology Reproduced What It Sought to Critique?
The WEIRD framework—Western, educated, industrialized, rich, democratic—introduced in 2010 by Henrich et al. drew widespread attention to psychology’s overreliance on Western samples and its assumption of universal human psychology. However, in this article I argue that the framework’s popularization—particularly in work explaining the origins and consequences of WEIRD psychology—has paradoxically generated a new form of exceptionalism. By designating Western populations as psychologically “peculiar,” the framework inadvertently maintains the West as the central reference point against which human variation is measured. I identify three mechanisms through which this occurs. First, the WEIRD acronym itself embeds developmental assumptions: Its components connote achievements rather than neutral differences, while implicitly defining non-WEIRD populations through deficit (uneducated, undeveloped, poor, authoritarian). Second, the comparative structure positions WEIRD populations as the persistent baseline, with non-WEIRD psychologies understood through their deviation from Western patterns rather than as autonomous systems. Third, cultural-historical accounts tracing WEIRD psychology to internal European developments risk obscuring how extraction and violence constituted the material conditions for Western institutional dominance. I propose that genuinely decentering Western psychology requires moving beyond binary comparative frameworks, developing research programs that engage diverse cultural psychologies on their own terms and transforming institutional structures that implicitly favor Western theoretical frameworks as unmarked universals.
- 3 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perspectives on Psychological Science
Open Access“WEIRDly Exceptional”: Has Cultural Psychology Reproduced What It Sought to Critique?
The WEIRD framework—Western, educated, industrialized, rich, democratic—introduced in 2010 by Henrich et al. drew widespread attention to psychology’s overreliance on Western samples and its assumption of universal human psychology. However, in this article I argue that the framework’s popularization—particularly in work explaining the origins and consequences of WEIRD psychology—has paradoxically generated a new form of exceptionalism. By designating Western populations as psychologically “peculiar,” the framework inadvertently maintains the West as the central reference point against which human variation is measured. I identify three mechanisms through which this occurs. First, the WEIRD acronym itself embeds developmental assumptions: Its components connote achievements rather than neutral differences, while implicitly defining non-WEIRD populations through deficit (uneducated, undeveloped, poor, authoritarian). Second, the comparative structure positions WEIRD populations as the persistent baseline, with non-WEIRD psychologies understood through their deviation from Western patterns rather than as autonomous systems. Third, cultural-historical accounts tracing WEIRD psychology to internal European developments risk obscuring how extraction and violence constituted the material conditions for Western institutional dominance. I propose that genuinely decentering Western psychology requires moving beyond binary comparative frameworks, developing research programs that engage diverse cultural psychologies on their own terms and transforming institutional structures that implicitly favor Western theoretical frameworks as unmarked universals.
- 19 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Psychology
- Vol. 5 (4) , 256-272
The culture-to-cognition transmission of inequality and the psychological necessity of consciousness-raising
- 19 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Psychology
- Vol. 5 (4) , 256-272
The culture-to-cognition transmission of inequality and the psychological necessity of consciousness-raising
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 19 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Social Psychology
- Vol. 65 (1) , e70044
The crisis we are not naming: The psychology of capitalism
Psychology has rendered capitalism invisible, treating individualism as cultural inheritance rather than a response to contemporary economic conditions. Building on my recent theoretical framework (Bettache, Personality and Social Psychology Review , 29, 215, 2024), this article explores how capitalism functions as a missing link in psychology—an overlooked generative mechanism that shapes the phenomena we study. Three ‘capitalist syndromes’—Gain Primacy Syndrome (perpetual accumulation as life orientation), Zero‐Sum Rivalry Syndrome (competitive ethos eroding social bonds) and Ownership Syndrome (possessive identity formation)—interact recursively to generate a self‐enhancement agenda we recognize as individualism. This framework reinterprets established findings, from the correlation between economic development and individualism to social class differences in self‐concept, as responses to political‐economic structures rather than ancient traditions. Making capitalism visible transforms psychological distress from individual pathology into rational responses to structural dysfunction, opening possibilities for interventions that address root causes rather than merely helping individuals cope with harmful conditions.
- 19 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Social Psychology
- Vol. 65 (1) , e70044
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe crisis we are not naming: The psychology of capitalism
Psychology has rendered capitalism invisible, treating individualism as cultural inheritance rather than a response to contemporary economic conditions. Building on my recent theoretical framework (Bettache, Personality and Social Psychology Review , 29, 215, 2024), this article explores how capitalism functions as a missing link in psychology—an overlooked generative mechanism that shapes the phenomena we study. Three ‘capitalist syndromes’—Gain Primacy Syndrome (perpetual accumulation as life orientation), Zero‐Sum Rivalry Syndrome (competitive ethos eroding social bonds) and Ownership Syndrome (possessive identity formation)—interact recursively to generate a self‐enhancement agenda we recognize as individualism. This framework reinterprets established findings, from the correlation between economic development and individualism to social class differences in self‐concept, as responses to political‐economic structures rather than ancient traditions. Making capitalism visible transforms psychological distress from individual pathology into rational responses to structural dysfunction, opening possibilities for interventions that address root causes rather than merely helping individuals cope with harmful conditions.
- 28 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Social Issues
- Vol. 81 (4)
Geopolitical Psychology: An Emerging Perspective
This article aims to introduce geopolitical psychology as an emerging interdisciplinary perspective in psychological science. Broadly defined, this perspective (a) synergizes insights from geography, political economy, and psychology, and (b) broadens and deepens the understanding of the society–psychology nexus and its transformations vis‐à‐vis the transactions of the person and the historical, current, and imagined geopolitical contexts. We propose eight propositions to organize currently disparate research on geopolitical psychology and guide future investigations in this field. We also elaborate on the methodology of geopolitical psychology. We believe that geopolitical psychology can deepen the understanding of key social and psychological phenomena, offer new theoretical insights, lead to critical interrogations of received social representations, and inspire collective actions to change the status quo. We also expect geopolitical psychology to be able to address past critiques of intrapersonal psychology as a socially indifferent science, and conceptually and methodologically connect psychological science with its cognate disciplines in humanities and social sciences.
- 28 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Social Issues
- Vol. 81 (4)
Geopolitical Psychology: An Emerging Perspective
This article aims to introduce geopolitical psychology as an emerging interdisciplinary perspective in psychological science. Broadly defined, this perspective (a) synergizes insights from geography, political economy, and psychology, and (b) broadens and deepens the understanding of the society–psychology nexus and its transformations vis‐à‐vis the transactions of the person and the historical, current, and imagined geopolitical contexts. We propose eight propositions to organize currently disparate research on geopolitical psychology and guide future investigations in this field. We also elaborate on the methodology of geopolitical psychology. We believe that geopolitical psychology can deepen the understanding of key social and psychological phenomena, offer new theoretical insights, lead to critical interrogations of received social representations, and inspire collective actions to change the status quo. We also expect geopolitical psychology to be able to address past critiques of intrapersonal psychology as a socially indifferent science, and conceptually and methodologically connect psychological science with its cognate disciplines in humanities and social sciences.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Social Psychology
- Vol. 65 (1) , e70031
Redefining power in social psychology
This article synthesizes cutting‐edge research from our special issue examining power across groups, communities and nations to advance a fundamental reconceptualization that reveals power's inherent plurality, dynamism and cultural embeddedness. Drawing on evidence from a diverse set of countries and innovative methodologies, we demonstrate that traditional definitions of power as asymmetric resource control fail to capture its real‐world complexity. The collected research reveals three critical insights. First, power operates through multiple, intersecting mechanisms—from ideological frameworks like hegemonic masculinity to seemingly benevolent helping behaviours that maintain hierarchies. Second, power's meaning and operation vary dramatically across cultural contexts, with the power‐status relationship ranging from nearly synonymous in some societies to entirely disconnected in others. Third, marginalized groups develop sophisticated alternative conceptualizations of power as collective resistance, cultural preservation and mutual aid that enable transformation despite structural disadvantages. These findings necessitate theoretical frameworks that accommodate power's plurality while identifying general principles, examining dynamic processes rather than static attributes and integrating multiple levels of analysis. We argue for moving beyond imposed definitions to understand how diverse groups conceptualize their own agency, examining not just domination but resistance and developing interventions that promote more equitable power distributions.
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Social Psychology
- Vol. 65 (1) , e70031
Open AccessRedefining power in social psychology
This article synthesizes cutting‐edge research from our special issue examining power across groups, communities and nations to advance a fundamental reconceptualization that reveals power's inherent plurality, dynamism and cultural embeddedness. Drawing on evidence from a diverse set of countries and innovative methodologies, we demonstrate that traditional definitions of power as asymmetric resource control fail to capture its real‐world complexity. The collected research reveals three critical insights. First, power operates through multiple, intersecting mechanisms—from ideological frameworks like hegemonic masculinity to seemingly benevolent helping behaviours that maintain hierarchies. Second, power's meaning and operation vary dramatically across cultural contexts, with the power‐status relationship ranging from nearly synonymous in some societies to entirely disconnected in others. Third, marginalized groups develop sophisticated alternative conceptualizations of power as collective resistance, cultural preservation and mutual aid that enable transformation despite structural disadvantages. These findings necessitate theoretical frameworks that accommodate power's plurality while identifying general principles, examining dynamic processes rather than static attributes and integrating multiple levels of analysis. We argue for moving beyond imposed definitions to understand how diverse groups conceptualize their own agency, examining not just domination but resistance and developing interventions that promote more equitable power distributions.
- Top Cited Papers
- 16 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Personality and Social Psychology Review
- Vol. 29 (3) , 215-249
Where Is Capitalism? Unmasking Its Hidden Role in Psychology
This article critically examines the pervasive yet often-neglected influence of capitalism on psychological processes and human behavior. While capitalist ideologies like neoliberalism have entered the mainstream in psychology, there remains a lack of deeper engagement with the foundations of capitalism. The article argues that capitalism generates distinct cultural syndromes that emerged from the unique historical experiences of Western societies and are deeply rooted in the core principles of capitalism: profit motive, market competition, and private property ownership. The article then argues that these principles manifest as capitalist cultural syndromes termed the “gain primacy,” “zero-sum rivalry,” and “ownership” syndromes, which collectively drive a self-enhancement agenda resulting in an overarching “individualist syndrome.” It then explores how these syndromes maintain and reproduce social inequalities. By adopting a critical-historical approach, this article situates its analysis within a broader critique of capitalism, aiming to illuminate its impact on human thought, behavior, and well-being. Public Our thoughts, behaviors, and well-being are deeply influenced by the economic system we live in—capitalism. While psychologists have explored capitalist ideologies like neoliberalism, they often overlook capitalism’s core foundations driving inequality. This work argues that capitalism, rooted in Western colonial history, generates powerful cultural narratives prioritizing profit, competition, and private ownership. These capitalist principles manifest as pervasive societal mindsets obsessed with personal gain, viewing life as a zero-sum rivalry, and deriving self-worth from possessions. Collectively, they breed an individualistic syndrome of selfish striving at the expense of community. By understanding how these capitalist cultural forces psychologically shape us, maintaining oppressive societal hierarchies, we can reimagine economic systems that truly uplift the human spirit across all peoples and the planet we share. Unveiling capitalism’s influence is crucial to recover from its alienating effects and envision liberating alternatives.
- 16 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Personality and Social Psychology Review
- Vol. 29 (3) , 215-249
Top Cited PapersWhere Is Capitalism? Unmasking Its Hidden Role in Psychology
This article critically examines the pervasive yet often-neglected influence of capitalism on psychological processes and human behavior. While capitalist ideologies like neoliberalism have entered the mainstream in psychology, there remains a lack of deeper engagement with the foundations of capitalism. The article argues that capitalism generates distinct cultural syndromes that emerged from the unique historical experiences of Western societies and are deeply rooted in the core principles of capitalism: profit motive, market competition, and private property ownership. The article then argues that these principles manifest as capitalist cultural syndromes termed the “gain primacy,” “zero-sum rivalry,” and “ownership” syndromes, which collectively drive a self-enhancement agenda resulting in an overarching “individualist syndrome.” It then explores how these syndromes maintain and reproduce social inequalities. By adopting a critical-historical approach, this article situates its analysis within a broader critique of capitalism, aiming to illuminate its impact on human thought, behavior, and well-being. Public Our thoughts, behaviors, and well-being are deeply influenced by the economic system we live in—capitalism. While psychologists have explored capitalist ideologies like neoliberalism, they often overlook capitalism’s core foundations driving inequality. This work argues that capitalism, rooted in Western colonial history, generates powerful cultural narratives prioritizing profit, competition, and private ownership. These capitalist principles manifest as pervasive societal mindsets obsessed with personal gain, viewing life as a zero-sum rivalry, and deriving self-worth from possessions. Collectively, they breed an individualistic syndrome of selfish striving at the expense of community. By understanding how these capitalist cultural forces psychologically shape us, maintaining oppressive societal hierarchies, we can reimagine economic systems that truly uplift the human spirit across all peoples and the planet we share. Unveiling capitalism’s influence is crucial to recover from its alienating effects and envision liberating alternatives.
- Open Access
- 22 July 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The W.E.I.R.D. Microcosm of Microaggression Research: Toward a Cultural Psychological Approach
Microaggression research has made great strides over the past decade, while steadily pushing itself into mainstream psychological science. Yet, the field remains firmly situated within the North American (W.E.I.R.D.) cultural context. Correspondingly, recurring criticisms against the validity of microaggressions are often rooted in individualist, decontextualized understandings of behavior. While their rebuttals are often grounded in a philosophical and reflective understanding of the cultural context. In this article, I put forward that (a) the enactments and appraisals of microaggressions are the behavioral results of the cognitive salience of cultural schemas; (b) that cultural schemas are informed by cultural ideologies, underlining their methodological and empirical relevance for future research; and (c) that cultures are dynamic by highlighting the effects of (geo-)political events on the content of cultural schemas which may moderate the perception and enactment of microaggressions. As such, I argue that a cultural psychology of microaggressions may help to de-pathologize the individual by situating behavior in its cultural context, while at the same time necessitating the inclusion of communities residing in non-W.E.I.R.D. societies.
- 22 July 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe W.E.I.R.D. Microcosm of Microaggression Research: Toward a Cultural Psychological Approach
Microaggression research has made great strides over the past decade, while steadily pushing itself into mainstream psychological science. Yet, the field remains firmly situated within the North American (W.E.I.R.D.) cultural context. Correspondingly, recurring criticisms against the validity of microaggressions are often rooted in individualist, decontextualized understandings of behavior. While their rebuttals are often grounded in a philosophical and reflective understanding of the cultural context. In this article, I put forward that (a) the enactments and appraisals of microaggressions are the behavioral results of the cognitive salience of cultural schemas; (b) that cultural schemas are informed by cultural ideologies, underlining their methodological and empirical relevance for future research; and (c) that cultures are dynamic by highlighting the effects of (geo-)political events on the content of cultural schemas which may moderate the perception and enactment of microaggressions. As such, I argue that a cultural psychology of microaggressions may help to de-pathologize the individual by situating behavior in its cultural context, while at the same time necessitating the inclusion of communities residing in non-W.E.I.R.D. societies.
- Open Access
- 23 October 2020
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 12 (21) , 8817
Global Perspective on Marital Satisfaction
Across the world, millions of couples get married each year. One of the strongest predictors of whether partners will remain in their relationship is their reported satisfaction. Marital satisfaction is commonly found to be a key predictor of both individual and relational well-being. Despite its importance in predicting relationship longevity, there are relatively few empirical research studies examining predictors of marital satisfaction outside of a Western context. To address this gap in the literature and complete the existing knowledge about global predictors of marital satisfaction, we used an open-access database of self-reported assessments of self-reported marital satisfaction with data from 7178 participants representing 33 different countries. The results showed that sex, age, religiosity, economic status, education, and cultural values were related, to various extents, to marital satisfaction across cultures. However, marriage duration, number of children, and gross domestic product (GDP) were not found to be predictors of marital satisfaction for countries represented in this sample. While 96% of the variance of marital satisfaction was attributed to individual factors, only 4% was associated with countries. Together, the results show that individual differences have a larger influence on marital satisfaction compared to the country of origin. Findings are discussed in terms of the advantages of conducting studies on large cross-cultural samples.
- 23 October 2020
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 12 (21) , 8817
Open AccessGlobal Perspective on Marital Satisfaction
Across the world, millions of couples get married each year. One of the strongest predictors of whether partners will remain in their relationship is their reported satisfaction. Marital satisfaction is commonly found to be a key predictor of both individual and relational well-being. Despite its importance in predicting relationship longevity, there are relatively few empirical research studies examining predictors of marital satisfaction outside of a Western context. To address this gap in the literature and complete the existing knowledge about global predictors of marital satisfaction, we used an open-access database of self-reported assessments of self-reported marital satisfaction with data from 7178 participants representing 33 different countries. The results showed that sex, age, religiosity, economic status, education, and cultural values were related, to various extents, to marital satisfaction across cultures. However, marriage duration, number of children, and gross domestic product (GDP) were not found to be predictors of marital satisfaction for countries represented in this sample. While 96% of the variance of marital satisfaction was attributed to individual factors, only 4% was associated with countries. Together, the results show that individual differences have a larger influence on marital satisfaction compared to the country of origin. Findings are discussed in terms of the advantages of conducting studies on large cross-cultural samples.
- 1 August 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 34, 217-222
The merciless mind in a dog-eat-dog society: neoliberalism and the indifference to social inequality
- 1 August 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 34, 217-222
The merciless mind in a dog-eat-dog society: neoliberalism and the indifference to social inequality
- 23 April 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perspectives on Psychological Science
- Vol. 15 (4) , 1131-1139
A Call to Action: The Need for a Cultural Psychological Approach to Discrimination on the Basis of Skin Color in Asia
A strong preference for fair skin appears to be the norm across the Asian continent and may pervade many aspects of social life. Yet scholarly work on this ubiquitous phenomenon is rare within psychological science. This article is a call for a psychological investigation into colorism in Asia. I argue that colorism has firm systemic roots as a result of the sociohistorical trajectories of different Asian societies that have attached cultural meanings to skin color. Consequently, similarities and differences in such trajectories may account for variability in the expression of colorism within contemporary Asian societies. Directions for a cultural psychological approach to colorism are suggested.
- 23 April 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perspectives on Psychological Science
- Vol. 15 (4) , 1131-1139
A Call to Action: The Need for a Cultural Psychological Approach to Discrimination on the Basis of Skin Color in Asia
A strong preference for fair skin appears to be the norm across the Asian continent and may pervade many aspects of social life. Yet scholarly work on this ubiquitous phenomenon is rare within psychological science. This article is a call for a psychological investigation into colorism in Asia. I argue that colorism has firm systemic roots as a result of the sociohistorical trajectories of different Asian societies that have attached cultural meanings to skin color. Consequently, similarities and differences in such trajectories may account for variability in the expression of colorism within contemporary Asian societies. Directions for a cultural psychological approach to colorism are suggested.