FRFabienne Roche

Fabienne Roche

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Fabienne Roche has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Should the Urgency of Visual-Tactile Takeover Requests Match the Criticality of Takeover Situations?

    by Fabienne Roche, Stefan Brandenburg

    Highly-automated driving requires drivers to take over the control of their vehicle in any situation. In takeover situations with short time budgets, a fast takeover is crucial. Here, drivers could be supported by an appropriate takeover request. This paper presents a driving simulator study investigating whether less critical takeover situations and a match between the urgency of a takeover request and the criticality of the takeover situation benefits drivers regarding their takeover performance and subjective experience. Fifty-two participants experienced two takeover situations with varying time budgets (short and long). A low urgent, visual-tactile takeover-request was presented to half of the participants. The other half experienced a highly urgent, visual-tactile takeover request, resulting in two conditions, in which the takeover requests matched the criticality of the takeover situation, and in two conditions, in which the takeover requests did not match. The results showed that participants generally performed better in low critical takeover situations, but they took over quicker in highly critical situations. However, a match neither shortens takeover time nor enhances subjective experience.


  • Attitude Indicator Format

    by Simon Müller, Fabienne Roche, Dietrich Manzey

    A simulator study investigated the consequences of a transition between two alternative formats of the attitude indictor in aircraft cockpits, the moving-horizon and moving-aircraft format. Two groups of novices practiced performing two flight tasks (flight-path tracking and recovery from unusual attitudes) with one attitude-indicator format for six practice sessions, before transitioning to the other format. The results show that, after practice, participants were able to perform both tasks equally well with both attitude-indicator formats. However, the number of reversal errors in the recovery task increased considerably when transitioning from the moving-aircraft to moving-horizon format. No such effect emerged for the other direction. This suggests that the former transition is more difficult and represents a possible risk for flight safety.


  • Behavioral Changes to Repeated Takeovers in Highly Automated Driving: Effects of the Takeover-Request Design and the Nondriving-Related Task Modality

    by Fabienne Roche, Anna Somieski, Stefan Brandenburg

    Objective: We investigated drivers’ behavior and subjective experience when repeatedly taking over their vehicles’ control depending on the design of the takeover request (TOR) and the modality of the nondriving-related task (NDRT). Background: Previous research has shown that taking over vehicle control after highly automated driving provides several problems for drivers. There is evidence that the TOR design and the NDRT modality may influence takeover behavior and that driver behavior changes with more experience. Method: Forty participants were requested to resume control of their simulated vehicle six times. The TOR design (auditory or visual-auditory) and the NDRT modality (auditory or visual) were varied. Drivers’ takeover behavior, gaze patterns, and subjective workload were recorded and analyzed. Results: Results suggest that drivers change their behavior to the repeated experience of takeover situations. An auditory TOR leads to safer takeover behavior than a visual-auditory TOR. And with an auditory TOR, the takeover behavior improves with experience. Engaging in the visually demanding NDRT leads to fewer gazes on the road than the auditory NDRT. Participants’ fixation duration on the road decreased over the three takeovers with the visually demanding NDRT. Conclusions: The results imply that (a) drivers change their behavior to repeated takeovers, (b) auditory TOR designs might be preferable over visual-auditory TOR designs, and (c) auditory demanding NDRTs allow drivers to focus more on the driving scene. Application: The results of the present study can be used to design TORs and determine allowed NDRTs in highly automated driving.


  • Should the urgency of auditory-tactile takeover requests match the criticality of takeover situations?

    by Fabienne Roche, Stefan Brandenburg

    When highly automated vehicles reach their system limits, the vehicles' control is handed back to the driver by issuing a takeover request (TOR). Each of these takeover situations is different from the other. The shift of control can be hazardous. This study investigated whether a match between the urgency of a TOR and the criticality of the situation benefits drivers regarding their takeover performance and subjective experience. Fifty-two participants experienced two takeover situations with varying criticality (3 s or 7 s time budget). A low urgent, auditory-tactile TOR was presented to half of the participants. The other half experienced a highly urgent, auditory-tactile TOR. This resulted in two conditions, in which the TOR-urgency and the situational criticality matched, e.g. urgent TOR and highly critical situation, and in two conditions, in which the TOR-urgency and the situational criticality did not match. Results indicate that a TOR-urgency that matches the criticality of the driving situation does not benefit drivers. However, drivers generally performed better in takeover situations with low criticality and they took over faster in takeover situations with high criticality. Implications of the results and future work are discussed.


  • The Sooner the Better: Drivers’ Reactions to Two-Step Take-Over Requests in Highly Automated Driving

    by Sandra Epple, Fabienne Roche, Stefan Brandenburg

    Driving behavior after take-over requests (TORs) is one of the most popular subjects in human factors re-search on highly automated driving. Many studies utilized one-step TOR procedures to prompt drivers to resume vehicle control. The present paper examines driver behavior when experiencing a two-step TOR procedure in different modalities. A two-step TOR gives drivers a choice to resume vehicle controls be-tween a warning (first step) and an alarm (second step). Our findings indicate that a substantial number of drivers resumes vehicle controls after the second step, resulting in a higher number of crashes. More generally, criticality of the driving situation increases with increasing reaction times. Driving and interview data suggest that step two of the TOR should be presented earlier. Alternatively, a multi-step TOR could be used to increase drivers’ situational awareness. Auditory TORs are associated with shorter reaction times than visual-auditory TORs. Implications on TOR design are discussed.