Jo Hickman Dunne
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Jo Hickman Dunne has a total of 37 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jade Davies
University College London, UK
9 shared publications - Louise Black
Manchester Institute of Education, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
8 shared publications - Margarita Panayiotou
Manchester Institute of Education, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
7 shared publications Molly Anderton
6 shared publications- Brittany I. Davidson
University of Bath
5 shared publications Emily Banwell
University of Manchester
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
From motivation to experience: Blurred boundaries in the measurement of adolescent social media engagement
Despite extensive research on the role of social media use in adolescent mental health, fundamental questions remain about what current self-report measures capture. We systematically reviewed 96 adolescent self-report measures of social media use, comprising 1,526 unique items. Through content analysis, we examined what measures assess and the behavioural and psychological processes through which they are operationalised. We found substantial conceptual overlap between measures, particularly those assessing problematic use and addiction, alongside discrepancies between item content and young people’s reported experiences. Importantly, current measures were found to frequently combine motivation, behaviour, experience, and mindset, despite these psychological behaviours and processes being theoretically distinguished. This raises questions about whether existing measures meaningfully test the hypothesises mechanisms and theoretical frameworks underpinning social media and mental health research. Our findings highlight the need to move beyond content-focused approaches to measurement, towards greater attention to how social media is operationalised and recognition of its potentially dynamic and interdependent nature.
- 29 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessFrom motivation to experience: Blurred boundaries in the measurement of adolescent social media engagement
Despite extensive research on the role of social media use in adolescent mental health, fundamental questions remain about what current self-report measures capture. We systematically reviewed 96 adolescent self-report measures of social media use, comprising 1,526 unique items. Through content analysis, we examined what measures assess and the behavioural and psychological processes through which they are operationalised. We found substantial conceptual overlap between measures, particularly those assessing problematic use and addiction, alongside discrepancies between item content and young people’s reported experiences. Importantly, current measures were found to frequently combine motivation, behaviour, experience, and mindset, despite these psychological behaviours and processes being theoretically distinguished. This raises questions about whether existing measures meaningfully test the hypothesises mechanisms and theoretical frameworks underpinning social media and mental health research. Our findings highlight the need to move beyond content-focused approaches to measurement, towards greater attention to how social media is operationalised and recognition of its potentially dynamic and interdependent nature.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Mapping adolescent social media use: A scoping review
Research on the impact of social media use on adolescent mental health lacks consensus, likely exacerbated by the field’s reliance on coarse measures like time spent online. More granular conceptualisations of use have been proposed as a way to clarify when, why, and for whom social media use may be beneficial, neutral, or harmful. In this scoping review, we used the Multidimensional Model of Social Media Use (Yang et al., 2021) as a framework to systematically map the diversity of adolescent social media use. Specifically, we examined how adolescents describe their social media use, how researchers quantify this use and the degree of (dis)alignment between the two. In total, we reviewed 6,822 articles for inclusion, with 522 meeting the inclusion criteria. Adolescents’ qualitative accounts portrayed social media use as complex, fluid, and multi dimensional, involving a wide range of activities, motivational functions, and communication partners. We draw on these accounts to extend the Multidimensional Model, specifying more precise categories of activity, motivation, and communication partner, and incorporating additional contextual dimensions that characterise adolescents’ social media use. Mapping quantitative studies onto this framework revealed broad conceptual overlap but substantial methodological fragmentation, including heterogeneous and often unvalidated measures. The extended framework developed through this review provides a more precise foundation for future empirical work examining links between social media use and mental health and highlights the need for research designs capable of capturing the dynamic nature of adolescent social media use. Assessing adolescents’ views on the framework represents an important next step.
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessMapping adolescent social media use: A scoping review
Research on the impact of social media use on adolescent mental health lacks consensus, likely exacerbated by the field’s reliance on coarse measures like time spent online. More granular conceptualisations of use have been proposed as a way to clarify when, why, and for whom social media use may be beneficial, neutral, or harmful. In this scoping review, we used the Multidimensional Model of Social Media Use (Yang et al., 2021) as a framework to systematically map the diversity of adolescent social media use. Specifically, we examined how adolescents describe their social media use, how researchers quantify this use and the degree of (dis)alignment between the two. In total, we reviewed 6,822 articles for inclusion, with 522 meeting the inclusion criteria. Adolescents’ qualitative accounts portrayed social media use as complex, fluid, and multi dimensional, involving a wide range of activities, motivational functions, and communication partners. We draw on these accounts to extend the Multidimensional Model, specifying more precise categories of activity, motivation, and communication partner, and incorporating additional contextual dimensions that characterise adolescents’ social media use. Mapping quantitative studies onto this framework revealed broad conceptual overlap but substantial methodological fragmentation, including heterogeneous and often unvalidated measures. The extended framework developed through this review provides a more precise foundation for future empirical work examining links between social media use and mental health and highlights the need for research designs capable of capturing the dynamic nature of adolescent social media use. Assessing adolescents’ views on the framework represents an important next step.
- Open Access
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Developing an adolescent self-report measure of social media experience: Insights from cognitive interviews
Despite a rapid increase in research exploring the relationship between adolescent social media use and mental health, the field is hindered by poor quality tools that lack the validity and precision to assess this relationship. The current study presents findings from cognitive interviews that aimed to refine a multidimensional measure of adolescents’ social media experiences relevant to their mental health and wellbeing. We conducted 20 individual, paired or group interviews with 35 adolescents aged 11-16, across three rounds of interviews, testing 83 of a possible 107 items. Through iterative testing, issues relating to comprehension; inapplicability and assumptions within items; and items not addressing their intended experience, were identified and addressed. The interviews also highlighted two wider conceptual issues: (1) the impact of parental restrictions on adolescents’ experiences, and (2) difficulties in responding to items about abstract, identity-based experiences. In addition, the interviews supported an understanding of preferred response options and format. Findings from this study informed specific revisions to measure items to enhance validity, as well as broader considerations for assessing adolescent social media experience. Our study also reinforces the importance of cognitive interviewing in refining adolescent measures more broadly. We identify the need for the development of a set of general recommendations to guide item writing for adolescents, and further work to understand optimal response label options and wording for longer recall periods. Development of such guidance, alongside the greater use of cognitive interviews to pre-test measures, is crucial for improving instrument validity in the field of adolescent mental health.
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessDeveloping an adolescent self-report measure of social media experience: Insights from cognitive interviews
Despite a rapid increase in research exploring the relationship between adolescent social media use and mental health, the field is hindered by poor quality tools that lack the validity and precision to assess this relationship. The current study presents findings from cognitive interviews that aimed to refine a multidimensional measure of adolescents’ social media experiences relevant to their mental health and wellbeing. We conducted 20 individual, paired or group interviews with 35 adolescents aged 11-16, across three rounds of interviews, testing 83 of a possible 107 items. Through iterative testing, issues relating to comprehension; inapplicability and assumptions within items; and items not addressing their intended experience, were identified and addressed. The interviews also highlighted two wider conceptual issues: (1) the impact of parental restrictions on adolescents’ experiences, and (2) difficulties in responding to items about abstract, identity-based experiences. In addition, the interviews supported an understanding of preferred response options and format. Findings from this study informed specific revisions to measure items to enhance validity, as well as broader considerations for assessing adolescent social media experience. Our study also reinforces the importance of cognitive interviewing in refining adolescent measures more broadly. We identify the need for the development of a set of general recommendations to guide item writing for adolescents, and further work to understand optimal response label options and wording for longer recall periods. Development of such guidance, alongside the greater use of cognitive interviews to pre-test measures, is crucial for improving instrument validity in the field of adolescent mental health.
- Open Access
- 5 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Aligning how we measure and support social media addiction with young people's lived experience
Social media use is widely conceptualised as a potential addiction. However, the instruments used to index it are reformulations of criteria developed for established addictions, presuming pathology rather than establishing it. We inverted the direction of inference, integrating lived experience from adolescents who feel addicted to social media and experienced substantial life impairment as a consequence. We conducted eight in-person workshops with 44 adolescents (contributors) to discuss experiences constituting social media addiction, their perceived harms, and how those experiencing it could best be supported. We examined correspondence between lived experiences and features of established addictions, such as conflict (interpersonal struggles and loss of self-control), salience (preoccupation with social media), and tolerance (needing more to get the same effect). Discussions of how, by whom, and through what means adolescents could be supported were analysed using framework analysis. Correspondence between lived experience and the prevailing addiction model was partial and asymmetric. Of 121 experiences, 58.7% described conflict or salience, none described tolerance, and few described withdrawal (2.5%) or relapse (7.4%). A fifth (20.7%) fell outside the model. Effects on sleep, attention, mental health, and time displacement were ranked as most harmful, while impaired control and social comparison ranked lower. Discussions of support revealed a strong sense of individual responsibility, alongside agreement that platform redesign, provision of alternative activities, and shifts in social norms would be most effective. Clinical addiction intervention was rarely raised, despite frequent use of medical addiction language and analogies. These results raise questions about current addiction models and the assumption of pathology applied to social media use. Future work should move beyond these frameworks and ground conceptualisation and measurement in lived experience rather than predefined notions of disorder.
- 5 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessAligning how we measure and support social media addiction with young people's lived experience
Social media use is widely conceptualised as a potential addiction. However, the instruments used to index it are reformulations of criteria developed for established addictions, presuming pathology rather than establishing it. We inverted the direction of inference, integrating lived experience from adolescents who feel addicted to social media and experienced substantial life impairment as a consequence. We conducted eight in-person workshops with 44 adolescents (contributors) to discuss experiences constituting social media addiction, their perceived harms, and how those experiencing it could best be supported. We examined correspondence between lived experiences and features of established addictions, such as conflict (interpersonal struggles and loss of self-control), salience (preoccupation with social media), and tolerance (needing more to get the same effect). Discussions of how, by whom, and through what means adolescents could be supported were analysed using framework analysis. Correspondence between lived experience and the prevailing addiction model was partial and asymmetric. Of 121 experiences, 58.7% described conflict or salience, none described tolerance, and few described withdrawal (2.5%) or relapse (7.4%). A fifth (20.7%) fell outside the model. Effects on sleep, attention, mental health, and time displacement were ranked as most harmful, while impaired control and social comparison ranked lower. Discussions of support revealed a strong sense of individual responsibility, alongside agreement that platform redesign, provision of alternative activities, and shifts in social norms would be most effective. Clinical addiction intervention was rarely raised, despite frequent use of medical addiction language and analogies. These results raise questions about current addiction models and the assumption of pathology applied to social media use. Future work should move beyond these frameworks and ground conceptualisation and measurement in lived experience rather than predefined notions of disorder.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior Reports
- Vol. 22
Understanding the key domains of adolescent social media experience: a parallel Delphi study with young people and key adults
- 27 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior Reports
- Vol. 22
Open AccessUnderstanding the key domains of adolescent social media experience: a parallel Delphi study with young people and key adults
- Open Access
- 15 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Understanding the key domains of adolescent social media experience: a parallel Delphi study with young people and key adults
This study aimed to identify the key domains of adolescent social media experience that relate to mental health, and how perspectives on these differ between adolescents and adults. Whilst there has been an explosion in studies looking at the relationship between social media use and mental health, little attention has been paid to the measurement of social media experiences. To fill this gap, we conducted a three-round, online parallel Delphi study with two panels: (1) an adult panel made up of five stakeholder groups (n=39); and (2) an adolescent panel made up of individuals aged 11-15 (n=27). Round 1 used open-text responses to generate 44 statements about adolescent social media experiences, which participants rated their agreement with over two subsequent rounds via iterative, anonymous voting. 18 statements reached consensus, covering ten domains of experience. Statements that reached consensus for both panels related to (1) peer pressure, (2) anxiety, (3) exclusion, (4) body image, (5) self-esteem, and (6) addiction. Statements that reached consensus for the adult panel related to (7) relationships, and (8) validation, and statements that reached consensus for the adolescent panel related to (9) coping/emotion regulation, and (10) empowerment. These findings contribute to a more balanced conceptualisation of social media experience and will guide the development of a psychometric measure. Further research is needed to explore the nuances in adolescent and adult perspectives, including regarding relational experiences, how adolescents feel they can influence others, and adolescents’ conceptualisation of social media as a coping mechanism.
- 15 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessUnderstanding the key domains of adolescent social media experience: a parallel Delphi study with young people and key adults
This study aimed to identify the key domains of adolescent social media experience that relate to mental health, and how perspectives on these differ between adolescents and adults. Whilst there has been an explosion in studies looking at the relationship between social media use and mental health, little attention has been paid to the measurement of social media experiences. To fill this gap, we conducted a three-round, online parallel Delphi study with two panels: (1) an adult panel made up of five stakeholder groups (n=39); and (2) an adolescent panel made up of individuals aged 11-15 (n=27). Round 1 used open-text responses to generate 44 statements about adolescent social media experiences, which participants rated their agreement with over two subsequent rounds via iterative, anonymous voting. 18 statements reached consensus, covering ten domains of experience. Statements that reached consensus for both panels related to (1) peer pressure, (2) anxiety, (3) exclusion, (4) body image, (5) self-esteem, and (6) addiction. Statements that reached consensus for the adult panel related to (7) relationships, and (8) validation, and statements that reached consensus for the adolescent panel related to (9) coping/emotion regulation, and (10) empowerment. These findings contribute to a more balanced conceptualisation of social media experience and will guide the development of a psychometric measure. Further research is needed to explore the nuances in adolescent and adult perspectives, including regarding relational experiences, how adolescents feel they can influence others, and adolescents’ conceptualisation of social media as a coping mechanism.
- Open Access
- 19 October 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Adolescents’ Lived Experiences of Mental Health: A Systematic Umbrella Review to Aid Assessment Reform
Background: Adolescent mental health is deteriorating, and identifying those in need is challenging because of flawed assessments, flooded services, and low help-seeking by those most in need. A critical problem is the omission of adolescents’ perspectives in the development of diagnostic frameworks and questionnaires. Synthesising lived experience evidence can help inform better identification of youth mental health needs.Methods: A preregistered systematic search was conducted through Medline: Ovid, Epistemonikos, ProQuest dissertations, Prospero, and Psyarxiv. Systematic reviews were included if they contained qualitative evidence from adolescents (aged 10-24) experiencing the most common clinically-relevant problems (e.g., depression, self-harm). Informed by lived experience expertise, qualitative data were synthesized, including to understand which experiences were transdiagnostic (common across different mental health types). Experiences were also compared to existing questionnaires and reported alongside quality assessment via AMSTAR2.Outcomes: Eighteen reviews were synthesized into 30 experiences (subthemes), which were grouped into six themes: social disconnection, behavioural expression, how I relate to the experience, emotional experiences, negative and shifting beliefs of self, and disrupted ability to function. Interpretation: This review highlights the need to update existing frameworks and provides initial groundwork for doing so. We argue social indicators should be given more weight, and lived experience evidence also challenged traditional boundaries between symptoms and functioning. Experiences tended to be transdiagnostic, with evidence of dimensionality, overlap between disorders, and new experiences missing from existing frameworks revealed. We make recommendations for research and practice to improve how young people in need are identified and supported.
- 19 October 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessAdolescents’ Lived Experiences of Mental Health: A Systematic Umbrella Review to Aid Assessment Reform
Background: Adolescent mental health is deteriorating, and identifying those in need is challenging because of flawed assessments, flooded services, and low help-seeking by those most in need. A critical problem is the omission of adolescents’ perspectives in the development of diagnostic frameworks and questionnaires. Synthesising lived experience evidence can help inform better identification of youth mental health needs.Methods: A preregistered systematic search was conducted through Medline: Ovid, Epistemonikos, ProQuest dissertations, Prospero, and Psyarxiv. Systematic reviews were included if they contained qualitative evidence from adolescents (aged 10-24) experiencing the most common clinically-relevant problems (e.g., depression, self-harm). Informed by lived experience expertise, qualitative data were synthesized, including to understand which experiences were transdiagnostic (common across different mental health types). Experiences were also compared to existing questionnaires and reported alongside quality assessment via AMSTAR2.Outcomes: Eighteen reviews were synthesized into 30 experiences (subthemes), which were grouped into six themes: social disconnection, behavioural expression, how I relate to the experience, emotional experiences, negative and shifting beliefs of self, and disrupted ability to function. Interpretation: This review highlights the need to update existing frameworks and provides initial groundwork for doing so. We argue social indicators should be given more weight, and lived experience evidence also challenged traditional boundaries between symptoms and functioning. Experiences tended to be transdiagnostic, with evidence of dimensionality, overlap between disorders, and new experiences missing from existing frameworks revealed. We make recommendations for research and practice to improve how young people in need are identified and supported.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2025
- Published by University of California Press in Collabra: Psychology
- Vol. 11 (1)
Identifying Relevant Dimensions to the Measurement of Adolescent Social Media Experience via Focus Groups With Young People
While work on the relationship between social media use and adolescent mental health has allowed for some progress, research in this area is still relatively new and shows mixed evidence. This is partly the consequence of a rapidly changing field, resulting in conceptualisation and measurement issues that hinder progress. Given the need for robust conceptualisation, the present study included five focus groups with 26 adolescents aged 11-15 in Northwest England, to understand their experiences, motivations, and perceptions of social media use, relating to mental health and wellbeing. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to analyse the transcripts. We developed five themes and 10 sub-themes. Young people discussed being present and connected on social media (theme A); identity formation and self-presentation (theme B); enjoyment and managing moods (theme C); exposure to risky content and relationships (theme D); and self-control (theme E). Across these themes three direct mental health and wellbeing outcomes were identified: social aspects, anxiety and self-esteem, plus two less clearly defined experiences around coping and self-control. Our findings also demonstrate the heterogeneity and multidimensionality of social media experience, and point to some possibly differences across age and gender. Overall, this study has contributed to our understanding of the salient dimensions and language to inform the development of an adolescent social media experience measure related to mental health.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by University of California Press in Collabra: Psychology
- Vol. 11 (1)
Open AccessIdentifying Relevant Dimensions to the Measurement of Adolescent Social Media Experience via Focus Groups With Young People
While work on the relationship between social media use and adolescent mental health has allowed for some progress, research in this area is still relatively new and shows mixed evidence. This is partly the consequence of a rapidly changing field, resulting in conceptualisation and measurement issues that hinder progress. Given the need for robust conceptualisation, the present study included five focus groups with 26 adolescents aged 11-15 in Northwest England, to understand their experiences, motivations, and perceptions of social media use, relating to mental health and wellbeing. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to analyse the transcripts. We developed five themes and 10 sub-themes. Young people discussed being present and connected on social media (theme A); identity formation and self-presentation (theme B); enjoyment and managing moods (theme C); exposure to risky content and relationships (theme D); and self-control (theme E). Across these themes three direct mental health and wellbeing outcomes were identified: social aspects, anxiety and self-esteem, plus two less clearly defined experiences around coping and self-control. Our findings also demonstrate the heterogeneity and multidimensionality of social media experience, and point to some possibly differences across age and gender. Overall, this study has contributed to our understanding of the salient dimensions and language to inform the development of an adolescent social media experience measure related to mental health.
- Open Access
- 18 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
- Vol. 65 (11) , 1538-1542
Commentary: Expanding the vision of Registered Reports for qualitative mental health research: A response and extension to ‘Misaligned incentives in mental health research – the case for Registered Reports’, Baldwin (2023)
There is a growing exploration of how Registered Reports can benefit individual researchers and wider research fields as part of a wider shift towards open research principles and practices. In ‘Misaligned incentives in mental health research – the case for Registered Reports’, Baldwin examines this in the context of mental health research, arguing that Registered Reports (RRs) can be a valuable solution to misaligned incentive structures in the field. However, this original piece was generally inclined towards how such incentives and the use of RRs can play out in the context of quantitative research. Such reflection is valuable, but to examine the case for RRs in mental health research as a field, we must also explore such practices within the context of qualitative research. In this commentary, we therefore expand and reframe this discussion to make the case for RRs in qualitative mental health research. We explore the place for qualitative research in the mental health research field and examine possibilities for how RRs fit within principles and practices in such methods. We discuss the various benefits and challenges of RRs in qualitative research, reflecting on our experiences as authors and reviewers of qualitative RRs and exploring how research infrastructure can facilitate engagement with this publishing approach.
- 18 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
- Vol. 65 (11) , 1538-1542
Open AccessCommentary: Expanding the vision of Registered Reports for qualitative mental health research: A response and extension to ‘Misaligned incentives in mental health research – the case for Registered Reports’, Baldwin (2023)
There is a growing exploration of how Registered Reports can benefit individual researchers and wider research fields as part of a wider shift towards open research principles and practices. In ‘Misaligned incentives in mental health research – the case for Registered Reports’, Baldwin examines this in the context of mental health research, arguing that Registered Reports (RRs) can be a valuable solution to misaligned incentive structures in the field. However, this original piece was generally inclined towards how such incentives and the use of RRs can play out in the context of quantitative research. Such reflection is valuable, but to examine the case for RRs in mental health research as a field, we must also explore such practices within the context of qualitative research. In this commentary, we therefore expand and reframe this discussion to make the case for RRs in qualitative mental health research. We explore the place for qualitative research in the mental health research field and examine possibilities for how RRs fit within principles and practices in such methods. We discuss the various benefits and challenges of RRs in qualitative research, reflecting on our experiences as authors and reviewers of qualitative RRs and exploring how research infrastructure can facilitate engagement with this publishing approach.
- Open Access
- 22 January 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 344, 116614
‘My doctor just called me a good girl and I died a bit inside’: From everyday misogyny to obstetric violence in UK fertility and maternity services
- 22 January 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 344, 116614
Open Access‘My doctor just called me a good girl and I died a bit inside’: From everyday misogyny to obstetric violence in UK fertility and maternity services