Michael J. Carter
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Michael J. Carter has a total of 96 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Joshua G. A. Cashaback
University of Delaware
10 shared publications - Brad McKay
Department of Kinesiology, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada
9 shared publications Brad McKay
8 shared publicationsJan A. Calalo
Affiliation Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware, United States of America
6 shared publicationsAdam M. Roth
Affiliation Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware, United States of America
5 shared publications- John Buggeln
University of Delaware
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 September 2026
- Published by American Physiological Society in Journal of Neurophysiology
- Vol. 136 (3) , 1162-1170
Deliberation is a controllable process governed by desirability and cognitive effort
Desirability and effort are fundamental objectives that drive human and animal behavior. Information processing accounts of decision-making do not consider biologically plausible objectives and thus fail to explain what tunes deliberation. Here, we propose a novel theory where deliberation is a controllable process governed by desirability and cognitive effort. This theoretical model captures classic decision phenomena while the emergent process bears a striking resemblance to complex neural dynamics.
- 1 September 2026
- Published by American Physiological Society in Journal of Neurophysiology
- Vol. 136 (3) , 1162-1170
Open AccessDeliberation is a controllable process governed by desirability and cognitive effort
Desirability and effort are fundamental objectives that drive human and animal behavior. Information processing accounts of decision-making do not consider biologically plausible objectives and thus fail to explain what tunes deliberation. Here, we propose a novel theory where deliberation is a controllable process governed by desirability and cognitive effort. This theoretical model captures classic decision phenomena while the emergent process bears a striking resemblance to complex neural dynamics.
- Open Access
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 22 (8) , e1014574
Successful reinforcement history suppresses explicit and implicit error corrections
A skilled basketball player expects to make many shots. After a miss, they could make a larger correction because the miss was “surprising.” Alternatively, they could make only a small correction since their average past performance was successful. Despite its relevance, past work has not elucidated whether or how a history of reinforcement influences explicit (cognitive) and implicit (involuntary) error corrections. Across three reaching experiments, we compared two competing hypotheses: 1) reward prediction errors (“surprise”) modulate explicit and implicit error corrections, or 2) expected value (average reward) modulates explicit and implicit error corrections. Our experimental results and computational modelling support the idea that the expected value of a long-history of reinforcement modulates explicit error corrections. Further, we find that an immediate-history of reinforcement directly modulates implicit error corrections, which could not be explained by an independent task error model. Collectively, we find that a successful reinforcement history suppresses explicit and implicit error corrections.
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 22 (8) , e1014574
Open AccessSuccessful reinforcement history suppresses explicit and implicit error corrections
A skilled basketball player expects to make many shots. After a miss, they could make a larger correction because the miss was “surprising.” Alternatively, they could make only a small correction since their average past performance was successful. Despite its relevance, past work has not elucidated whether or how a history of reinforcement influences explicit (cognitive) and implicit (involuntary) error corrections. Across three reaching experiments, we compared two competing hypotheses: 1) reward prediction errors (“surprise”) modulate explicit and implicit error corrections, or 2) expected value (average reward) modulates explicit and implicit error corrections. Our experimental results and computational modelling support the idea that the expected value of a long-history of reinforcement modulates explicit error corrections. Further, we find that an immediate-history of reinforcement directly modulates implicit error corrections, which could not be explained by an independent task error model. Collectively, we find that a successful reinforcement history suppresses explicit and implicit error corrections.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2026
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 15
Involuntary feedback responses reflect a representation of partner actions
We have a remarkable ability to seamlessly and rapidly coordinate actions with others, from double Dutch to dancing. Humans use high-level partner representations to jointly control voluntary actions, while other work shows lower-level involuntary feedback responses to sudden visual perturbations. Yet, it is unknown if a high-level partner representation can be rapidly expressed through lower-level involuntary sensorimotor circuitry. Here, we test the idea that a partner representation influences involuntary visuomotor feedback responses during a cooperative sensorimotor task. Using two experiments and dynamic game theory predictions, we show that involuntary visuomotor feedback responses reflect a partner representation and consideration of a partner’s movement cost (i.e., accuracy and energy). Collectively, our results suggest there is top-down modulation from high-level partner representations to lower-level sensorimotor circuits, enabling fast and flexible feedback responses during jointly coordinated actions.
- 22 May 2026
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 15
Open AccessInvoluntary feedback responses reflect a representation of partner actions
We have a remarkable ability to seamlessly and rapidly coordinate actions with others, from double Dutch to dancing. Humans use high-level partner representations to jointly control voluntary actions, while other work shows lower-level involuntary feedback responses to sudden visual perturbations. Yet, it is unknown if a high-level partner representation can be rapidly expressed through lower-level involuntary sensorimotor circuitry. Here, we test the idea that a partner representation influences involuntary visuomotor feedback responses during a cooperative sensorimotor task. Using two experiments and dynamic game theory predictions, we show that involuntary visuomotor feedback responses reflect a partner representation and consideration of a partner’s movement cost (i.e., accuracy and energy). Collectively, our results suggest there is top-down modulation from high-level partner representations to lower-level sensorimotor circuits, enabling fast and flexible feedback responses during jointly coordinated actions.
- Open Access
- 9 April 2026
- Published by University of Ottawa Library in Communications in Kinesiology
- Vol. 8
Emotions in Sport Practice
Despite long-standing research around competition, the multifaceted role of emotions within sport practice remains underexamined. This narrative review integrates literature from across psycho-motor disciplines in kinesiology to outline how emotions are implicated in various practice goals. We focus on how emotions may enhance the quality of sport practice in support of elite athlete development. We highlight how various emotional experiences may facilitate transfer of learning, then more fully consider how emotions serve the development of athletes’ ‘learning-to-learn’ skills and their motivation to practice. Overall, our aim is to initiate dialogue on the role and complexity of emotions in sport practice. In doing so, we propose that emotions serve conceptually different roles depending on whether the preeminent practice goal is competitive transfer, equipping athletes with learning proficiencies, or maintaining/sustaining athletes’ motivational beliefs. We hope that future research and application may consider these perspectives relating to the development of sport expertise.
- 9 April 2026
- Published by University of Ottawa Library in Communications in Kinesiology
- Vol. 8
Open AccessEmotions in Sport Practice
Despite long-standing research around competition, the multifaceted role of emotions within sport practice remains underexamined. This narrative review integrates literature from across psycho-motor disciplines in kinesiology to outline how emotions are implicated in various practice goals. We focus on how emotions may enhance the quality of sport practice in support of elite athlete development. We highlight how various emotional experiences may facilitate transfer of learning, then more fully consider how emotions serve the development of athletes’ ‘learning-to-learn’ skills and their motivation to practice. Overall, our aim is to initiate dialogue on the role and complexity of emotions in sport practice. In doing so, we propose that emotions serve conceptually different roles depending on whether the preeminent practice goal is competitive transfer, equipping athletes with learning proficiencies, or maintaining/sustaining athletes’ motivational beliefs. We hope that future research and application may consider these perspectives relating to the development of sport expertise.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Neuroscience
- Vol. 586, 144-151
Ipsilateral contraction increases map area and decreases motor threshold for contralateral hand muscle
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Neuroscience
- Vol. 586, 144-151
Open AccessIpsilateral contraction increases map area and decreases motor threshold for contralateral hand muscle
- 1 July 2025
- Published by American Physiological Society in Journal of Neurophysiology
- Vol. 134 (1) , 67-79
Indecision under time pressure arises from suboptimal switching behavior
Indecisive behavior is highly prevalent in many aspects of daily life. Despite its ubiquity, there has been very little focus and a lack of explanation for why indecisions occur. Here, we find under high time pressure scenarios that indecisions arise by misrepresenting additional time delays and temporal uncertainties associated when attempting to switch from reacting to guessing. Our novel paradigm presents a new way to elucidate and study indecisions.
- 1 July 2025
- Published by American Physiological Society in Journal of Neurophysiology
- Vol. 134 (1) , 67-79
Indecision under time pressure arises from suboptimal switching behavior
Indecisive behavior is highly prevalent in many aspects of daily life. Despite its ubiquity, there has been very little focus and a lack of explanation for why indecisions occur. Here, we find under high time pressure scenarios that indecisions arise by misrepresenting additional time delays and temporal uncertainties associated when attempting to switch from reacting to guessing. Our novel paradigm presents a new way to elucidate and study indecisions.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Preferences for costly cooperation are highly individualized
When deciding between action alternatives, we use information about the costs and rewards of each action to choose an appropriate plan. Curioni et al. (2022) recently found that participants had a strong preference for completing a virtual box-clearing task cooperatively with a partner rather than alone, despite it being more motorically and cognitively costly. Participants completed the task standing beside each other in close proximity, which may have created a social pressure to cooperate through a need to manage one’s reputation or a sense of commitment. Here, 50 human pairs—each composed of a “Decision-maker” and “Helper”—completed a box-clearing task modeled after Curioni et al. while seated farther away and out of view of one another. In 50% of trials, Decision-makers were forced to complete the task alone or with the Helper. In the remaining 50% of trials, Decision-makers chose to work alone or cooperatively. When working together, participants were required to synchronize their movements without communication or feedback of their partner’s movements. Decision-makers answered open-ended questions regarding why and when they chose to complete the task alone and together. We found a slight preference for individual action over costly joint action, yet this preference was not significantly different from chance. Inductive thematic analysis revealed two dominant themes: “chose actions with greater instrumental utility” and “chose actions with greater social value”. The identified themes suggest that preferences to cooperate are highly individualized, and that cooperative actions may provide additional social rewards that drive preferences for cooperation even when it is more costly.
- 25 March 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessPreferences for costly cooperation are highly individualized
When deciding between action alternatives, we use information about the costs and rewards of each action to choose an appropriate plan. Curioni et al. (2022) recently found that participants had a strong preference for completing a virtual box-clearing task cooperatively with a partner rather than alone, despite it being more motorically and cognitively costly. Participants completed the task standing beside each other in close proximity, which may have created a social pressure to cooperate through a need to manage one’s reputation or a sense of commitment. Here, 50 human pairs—each composed of a “Decision-maker” and “Helper”—completed a box-clearing task modeled after Curioni et al. while seated farther away and out of view of one another. In 50% of trials, Decision-makers were forced to complete the task alone or with the Helper. In the remaining 50% of trials, Decision-makers chose to work alone or cooperatively. When working together, participants were required to synchronize their movements without communication or feedback of their partner’s movements. Decision-makers answered open-ended questions regarding why and when they chose to complete the task alone and together. We found a slight preference for individual action over costly joint action, yet this preference was not significantly different from chance. Inductive thematic analysis revealed two dominant themes: “chose actions with greater instrumental utility” and “chose actions with greater social value”. The identified themes suggest that preferences to cooperate are highly individualized, and that cooperative actions may provide additional social rewards that drive preferences for cooperation even when it is more costly.
- 26 November 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Psychological Research
- Vol. 89 (1) , 1-14
Autonomy-supportive instructional language does not enhance skill acquisition compared to controlling instructional language
Instructional language is one of three techniques in OPTIMAL theory that can be manipulated to foster an autonomy-supportive practice environment to enhance motor performance and learning. While autonomy-supportive language has been shown to be beneficial in educational psychology, coaching, and health settings, the wording of task instructions has received minimal attention in the motor learning literature to date. We investigated the influence of two instructional language styles on skill acquisition in a preregistered experiment. Participants (N = 156) learned a speed cup stacking task and received instructions throughout practice that used either autonomy-supportive or controlling language. Although the autonomy-supportive instructions resulted in higher perceptions of autonomy, there were no group differences for motor performance in acquisition or retention. Perceptions of competence and intrinsic motivation did not differ between groups at any time point. These data are difficult to reconcile with key predictions in OPTIMAL theory regarding a direct and causal influence of motivational factors on performance and learning. However, our equivalence test suggests these effects on skill acquisition may be smaller than what we were powered to detect. These findings are consistent with a growing body of evidence highlighting the need for much larger N experiments in motor learning research.
- 26 November 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Psychological Research
- Vol. 89 (1) , 1-14
Autonomy-supportive instructional language does not enhance skill acquisition compared to controlling instructional language
Instructional language is one of three techniques in OPTIMAL theory that can be manipulated to foster an autonomy-supportive practice environment to enhance motor performance and learning. While autonomy-supportive language has been shown to be beneficial in educational psychology, coaching, and health settings, the wording of task instructions has received minimal attention in the motor learning literature to date. We investigated the influence of two instructional language styles on skill acquisition in a preregistered experiment. Participants (N = 156) learned a speed cup stacking task and received instructions throughout practice that used either autonomy-supportive or controlling language. Although the autonomy-supportive instructions resulted in higher perceptions of autonomy, there were no group differences for motor performance in acquisition or retention. Perceptions of competence and intrinsic motivation did not differ between groups at any time point. These data are difficult to reconcile with key predictions in OPTIMAL theory regarding a direct and causal influence of motivational factors on performance and learning. However, our equivalence test suggests these effects on skill acquisition may be smaller than what we were powered to detect. These findings are consistent with a growing body of evidence highlighting the need for much larger N experiments in motor learning research.
- 1 November 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Psychological Bulletin
- Vol. 150 (11) , 1347-1362
Reporting bias, not external focus: A robust Bayesian meta-analysis and systematic review of the external focus of attention literature.
Evidence has ostensibly been accumulating over the past 2 decades suggesting that an external focus on the intended movement effect (e.g., on the golf club during a swing) is superior to an internal focus on body movements (e.g., on your arms during a swing) for skill acquisition. Seven previous meta-studies have all reported evidence of external focus superiority. The most comprehensive of these concluded that an external focus enhances motor skill retention, transfer, and performance and leads to reduced eletromyographic activity during performance and that more distal external foci are superior to proximal external foci for performance. Here, we reanalyzed these data using robust Bayesian meta-analyses that included several plausible models of publication bias. We found moderate to strong evidence of publication bias for all analyses. After correcting for publication bias, estimated mean effects were negligible: g = 0.01 (performance), g = 0.15 (retention), g = 0.09 (transfer), g = 0.06 (electromyography), and g = -0.01 (distance effect). Bayes factors indicated data favored the null for each analysis, ranging from BF01 = 1.3 (retention) to 5.75 (performance). We found clear evidence of heterogeneity in each analysis, suggesting the impact of attentional focus depends on yet unknown contextual factors. Our results contradict the existing consensus that an external focus is always more effective than an internal focus. Instead, focus of attention appears to have a variety of effects that we cannot account for, and, on average, those effects are small to nil. These results parallel previous metascience suggesting publication bias has obfuscated the motor learning literature. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 November 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Psychological Bulletin
- Vol. 150 (11) , 1347-1362
Reporting bias, not external focus: A robust Bayesian meta-analysis and systematic review of the external focus of attention literature.
Evidence has ostensibly been accumulating over the past 2 decades suggesting that an external focus on the intended movement effect (e.g., on the golf club during a swing) is superior to an internal focus on body movements (e.g., on your arms during a swing) for skill acquisition. Seven previous meta-studies have all reported evidence of external focus superiority. The most comprehensive of these concluded that an external focus enhances motor skill retention, transfer, and performance and leads to reduced eletromyographic activity during performance and that more distal external foci are superior to proximal external foci for performance. Here, we reanalyzed these data using robust Bayesian meta-analyses that included several plausible models of publication bias. We found moderate to strong evidence of publication bias for all analyses. After correcting for publication bias, estimated mean effects were negligible: g = 0.01 (performance), g = 0.15 (retention), g = 0.09 (transfer), g = 0.06 (electromyography), and g = -0.01 (distance effect). Bayes factors indicated data favored the null for each analysis, ranging from BF01 = 1.3 (retention) to 5.75 (performance). We found clear evidence of heterogeneity in each analysis, suggesting the impact of attentional focus depends on yet unknown contextual factors. Our results contradict the existing consensus that an external focus is always more effective than an internal focus. Instead, focus of attention appears to have a variety of effects that we cannot account for, and, on average, those effects are small to nil. These results parallel previous metascience suggesting publication bias has obfuscated the motor learning literature. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
- Open Access
- 14 October 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 20 (10) , e1012474
Roles and interplay of reinforcement-based and error-based processes during reaching and gait in neurotypical adults and individuals with Parkinson’s disease
From a game of darts to neurorehabilitation, the ability to explore and fine tune our movements is critical for success. Past work has shown that exploratory motor behaviour in response to reinforcement (reward) feedback is closely linked with the basal ganglia, while movement corrections in response to error feedback is commonly attributed to the cerebellum. While our past work has shown these processes are dissociable during adaptation, it is unknown how they uniquely impact exploratory behaviour. Moreover, converging neuroanatomical evidence shows direct and indirect connections between the basal ganglia and cerebellum, suggesting that there is an interaction between reinforcement-based and error-based neural processes. Here we examine the unique roles and interaction between reinforcement-based and error-based processes on sensorimotor exploration in a neurotypical population. We also recruited individuals with Parkinson’s disease to gain mechanistic insight into the role of the basal ganglia and associated reinforcement pathways in sensorimotor exploration. Across three reaching experiments, participants were given either reinforcement feedback, error feedback, or simultaneously both reinforcement & error feedback during a sensorimotor task that encouraged exploration. Our reaching results, a re-analysis of a previous gait experiment, and our model suggests that in isolation, reinforcement-based and error-based processes respectively boost and suppress exploration. When acting in concert, we found that reinforcement-based and error-based processes interact by mutually opposing one another. Finally, we found that those with Parkinson’s disease had decreased exploration when receiving reinforcement feedback, supporting the notion that compromised reinforcement-based processes reduces the ability to explore new motor actions. Understanding the unique and interacting roles of reinforcement-based and error-based processes may help to inform neurorehabilitation paradigms where it is important to discover new and successful motor actions.
- 14 October 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 20 (10) , e1012474
Open AccessRoles and interplay of reinforcement-based and error-based processes during reaching and gait in neurotypical adults and individuals with Parkinson’s disease
From a game of darts to neurorehabilitation, the ability to explore and fine tune our movements is critical for success. Past work has shown that exploratory motor behaviour in response to reinforcement (reward) feedback is closely linked with the basal ganglia, while movement corrections in response to error feedback is commonly attributed to the cerebellum. While our past work has shown these processes are dissociable during adaptation, it is unknown how they uniquely impact exploratory behaviour. Moreover, converging neuroanatomical evidence shows direct and indirect connections between the basal ganglia and cerebellum, suggesting that there is an interaction between reinforcement-based and error-based neural processes. Here we examine the unique roles and interaction between reinforcement-based and error-based processes on sensorimotor exploration in a neurotypical population. We also recruited individuals with Parkinson’s disease to gain mechanistic insight into the role of the basal ganglia and associated reinforcement pathways in sensorimotor exploration. Across three reaching experiments, participants were given either reinforcement feedback, error feedback, or simultaneously both reinforcement & error feedback during a sensorimotor task that encouraged exploration. Our reaching results, a re-analysis of a previous gait experiment, and our model suggests that in isolation, reinforcement-based and error-based processes respectively boost and suppress exploration. When acting in concert, we found that reinforcement-based and error-based processes interact by mutually opposing one another. Finally, we found that those with Parkinson’s disease had decreased exploration when receiving reinforcement feedback, supporting the notion that compromised reinforcement-based processes reduces the ability to explore new motor actions. Understanding the unique and interacting roles of reinforcement-based and error-based processes may help to inform neurorehabilitation paradigms where it is important to discover new and successful motor actions.