Robert R. Klein
Research Subjects
Robert R. Klein has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Patricia E. Klein
Department of Horticultural Sciences, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA
9 shared publications - William L. Rooney
Department of Soil and Crop Sciences Texas A&M University College Station Texas USA
8 shared publications - Jales Mendes Oliveira Fonseca
Department of Soil and Crop Sciences Texas A&M University College Station TX USA
6 shared publications - Nikhil Yuvaraj Patil
Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Oklahoma Health Campus, Oklahoma City, OK, USA
3 shared publications - Ramasamy Perumal
Agricultural Research Center Kansas State University Hays Kansas USA
3 shared publications - Chad Hayes
USDA‐ARS Plant Stress and Germplasm Development Research Unit Lubbock Texas USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Evaluating and Predicting the Performance of Sorghum Lines in an Elite by Exotic Backcross-Nested Association Mapping Population
Maintaining or introducing genetic diversity into plant breeding programs is necessary for continual genetic gain; however, diversity at the cost of reduced performance is not something sought by breeders. To this end, backcross-nested association mapping (BC-NAM) populations, in which the recurrent parent is an elite line, can be employed as a strategy to introgress diversity from unadapted accessions while maintaining agronomic performance. This study evaluates (i) the hybrid performance of sorghum lines from 18 BC1-NAM families and (ii) the potential of genomic prediction to screen lines from BC1-NAM families for hybrid performance prior to phenotypic evaluation. Despite the diverse geographical origins and agronomic performance of the unadapted parents for BC1-NAM families, many BC1-derived lines performed significantly better in the hybrid trials than the elite recurrent parent, R.Tx436. The genomic prediction accuracies for grain yield, plant height, and days to mid-anthesis were acceptable, but the prediction accuracies for plant height were lower than expected. While the prediction accuracies increased when including more individuals in the training set, improvements tended to plateau between two and five lines per family, with larger training sets being required for more complex traits such as grain yield. Therefore, genomic prediction models can be optimized in a large BC1-NAM population with a relatively low fraction of individuals needing to be evaluated. These results suggest that genomic prediction is an effective method of pre-screening lines within BC1-NAM families prior to evaluation in extensive hybrid field trials.
Open AccessEvaluating and Predicting the Performance of Sorghum Lines in an Elite by Exotic Backcross-Nested Association Mapping Population
Maintaining or introducing genetic diversity into plant breeding programs is necessary for continual genetic gain; however, diversity at the cost of reduced performance is not something sought by breeders. To this end, backcross-nested association mapping (BC-NAM) populations, in which the recurrent parent is an elite line, can be employed as a strategy to introgress diversity from unadapted accessions while maintaining agronomic performance. This study evaluates (i) the hybrid performance of sorghum lines from 18 BC1-NAM families and (ii) the potential of genomic prediction to screen lines from BC1-NAM families for hybrid performance prior to phenotypic evaluation. Despite the diverse geographical origins and agronomic performance of the unadapted parents for BC1-NAM families, many BC1-derived lines performed significantly better in the hybrid trials than the elite recurrent parent, R.Tx436. The genomic prediction accuracies for grain yield, plant height, and days to mid-anthesis were acceptable, but the prediction accuracies for plant height were lower than expected. While the prediction accuracies increased when including more individuals in the training set, improvements tended to plateau between two and five lines per family, with larger training sets being required for more complex traits such as grain yield. Therefore, genomic prediction models can be optimized in a large BC1-NAM population with a relatively low fraction of individuals needing to be evaluated. These results suggest that genomic prediction is an effective method of pre-screening lines within BC1-NAM families prior to evaluation in extensive hybrid field trials.
- 9 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Crop Science
- Vol. 63 (6) , 3367-3381
Assessing the agronomic potential of sorghum B‐lines using genomic prediction
In hybrid sorghum breeding, basic agronomic traits, such as days to flowering and plant height, of sorghum seed parents must be within a specific range for hybrid seed production. Because many sorghum programs select new B‐lines outside of commercial seed production environments, the purpose of this study was to determine if genomic prediction is effective to evaluate new lines for their agronomic potential for seed production. Two B‐line RIL populations were evaluated across several environments for days to mid‐anthesis (DY), plant height (PH), panicle length (PL), and seed yield (SY). Across environments and populations, average prediction accuracies were between 0.47 and 0.61 for DY, 0.24 and 0.60 for PH, 0.16 and 0.37 for SY, and 0.37 and 0.57 for PL. The effect of training set size was assessed by subsampling various amounts of data into the training set, ranging from 5% to 65%. Prediction accuracies generally improved as the proportion of the total data in the training set increased for both inter‐ and intrapopulation predictions, but a relatively small portion (15%) of the total data still produced modest prediction accuracies. The effect of the marker density on genomic prediction accuracies was assessed by subsampling various numbers of single nucleotide polymorphisms. It was observed that as few as 500 markers were able to produce prediction accuracies similar to when all markers were used. The results of this study indicated that genomic prediction can be a useful and cost‐effective tool that sorghum breeding programs should incorporate into their pipeline.
- 9 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Crop Science
- Vol. 63 (6) , 3367-3381
Assessing the agronomic potential of sorghum B‐lines using genomic prediction
In hybrid sorghum breeding, basic agronomic traits, such as days to flowering and plant height, of sorghum seed parents must be within a specific range for hybrid seed production. Because many sorghum programs select new B‐lines outside of commercial seed production environments, the purpose of this study was to determine if genomic prediction is effective to evaluate new lines for their agronomic potential for seed production. Two B‐line RIL populations were evaluated across several environments for days to mid‐anthesis (DY), plant height (PH), panicle length (PL), and seed yield (SY). Across environments and populations, average prediction accuracies were between 0.47 and 0.61 for DY, 0.24 and 0.60 for PH, 0.16 and 0.37 for SY, and 0.37 and 0.57 for PL. The effect of training set size was assessed by subsampling various amounts of data into the training set, ranging from 5% to 65%. Prediction accuracies generally improved as the proportion of the total data in the training set increased for both inter‐ and intrapopulation predictions, but a relatively small portion (15%) of the total data still produced modest prediction accuracies. The effect of the marker density on genomic prediction accuracies was assessed by subsampling various numbers of single nucleotide polymorphisms. It was observed that as few as 500 markers were able to produce prediction accuracies similar to when all markers were used. The results of this study indicated that genomic prediction can be a useful and cost‐effective tool that sorghum breeding programs should incorporate into their pipeline.
- Open Access
- 16 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Plant Genome
- Vol. 16 (3) , e20369
Use of genomic prediction to screen sorghum B‐lines in hybrid testcrosses
Use of trifluoromethanesulfonamide (TFMSA), a male gametocide, increases the opportunities to identify promising B‐lines because large quantities of F 1 seed can be generated prior to the laborious task of B‐line sterilization. Combining TFMSA technology with genomic selection could efficiently evaluate sorghum B‐lines in hybrid combination to maximize the rates of genetic gain of the crop. This study used two recombinant inbred B‐line populations, consisting of 217 lines, which were testcrossed to two R‐lines to produce 434 hybrids. Each population of testcross hybrids were evaluated across five environments. Population‐based genomic prediction models were assessed across environments using three different cross‐validation (CV) schemes, each with 70% training and 30% validation sets. The validation schemes were as follows: CV1—hybrids chosen randomly for validation; CV2—B‐lines were randomly chosen, and each chosen B‐line had one of the two corresponding testcross hybrids randomly chosen for the validation; and CV3—B‐lines were randomly chosen, and each chosen B‐line had both corresponding testcross hybrids chosen for the validation. CV1 and CV2 presented the highest prediction accuracies; nonetheless, the prediction accuracies of the CV schemes were not statistically different in many environments. We determined that combining the B‐line populations could improve prediction accuracies, and the genomic prediction models were able to effectively rank the poorest 70% of hybrids even when genomic prediction accuracies themselves were low. Results indicate that combining genomic prediction models and TFMSA technology can effectively aid breeders in predicting B‐line hybrid performance in early generations prior to the laborious task of generating A/B‐line pairs.
- 16 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Plant Genome
- Vol. 16 (3) , e20369
Open AccessUse of genomic prediction to screen sorghum B‐lines in hybrid testcrosses
Use of trifluoromethanesulfonamide (TFMSA), a male gametocide, increases the opportunities to identify promising B‐lines because large quantities of F 1 seed can be generated prior to the laborious task of B‐line sterilization. Combining TFMSA technology with genomic selection could efficiently evaluate sorghum B‐lines in hybrid combination to maximize the rates of genetic gain of the crop. This study used two recombinant inbred B‐line populations, consisting of 217 lines, which were testcrossed to two R‐lines to produce 434 hybrids. Each population of testcross hybrids were evaluated across five environments. Population‐based genomic prediction models were assessed across environments using three different cross‐validation (CV) schemes, each with 70% training and 30% validation sets. The validation schemes were as follows: CV1—hybrids chosen randomly for validation; CV2—B‐lines were randomly chosen, and each chosen B‐line had one of the two corresponding testcross hybrids randomly chosen for the validation; and CV3—B‐lines were randomly chosen, and each chosen B‐line had both corresponding testcross hybrids chosen for the validation. CV1 and CV2 presented the highest prediction accuracies; nonetheless, the prediction accuracies of the CV schemes were not statistically different in many environments. We determined that combining the B‐line populations could improve prediction accuracies, and the genomic prediction models were able to effectively rank the poorest 70% of hybrids even when genomic prediction accuracies themselves were low. Results indicate that combining genomic prediction models and TFMSA technology can effectively aid breeders in predicting B‐line hybrid performance in early generations prior to the laborious task of generating A/B‐line pairs.
- Open Access
Evaluating Introgression Sorghum Germplasm Selected at the Population Level While Exploring Genomic Resources as a Screening Method
To exploit the novel genetic diversity residing in tropical sorghum germplasm, an expansive backcross nested-association mapping (BC-NAM) resource was developed in which novel genetic diversity was introgressed into elite inbreds. A major limitation of exploiting this type of genetic resource in hybrid improvement programs is the required evaluation in hybrid combination of the vast number of BC-NAM populations and lines. To address this, the utility of genomic information was evaluated to predict the hybrid performance of BC-NAM populations. Two agronomically elite BC-NAM populations were chosen for evaluation in which elite inbred RTx436 was the recurrent parent. Each BC1F3 line was evaluated in hybrid combination with an elite tester in two locations with phenotypes of grain yield, plant height, and days to anthesis collected on all test cross hybrids. Lines from both populations were found to outperform their recurrent parent. Efforts to utilize genetic distance based on genotyping-by-sequence (GBS) as a predictive tool for hybrid performance was ineffective. However, utilizing genomic prediction models using additive and dominance GBLUP kernels to screen germplasm appeared to be an effective method to eliminate inferior-performing lines that will not be useful in a hybrid breeding program.
Open AccessEvaluating Introgression Sorghum Germplasm Selected at the Population Level While Exploring Genomic Resources as a Screening Method
To exploit the novel genetic diversity residing in tropical sorghum germplasm, an expansive backcross nested-association mapping (BC-NAM) resource was developed in which novel genetic diversity was introgressed into elite inbreds. A major limitation of exploiting this type of genetic resource in hybrid improvement programs is the required evaluation in hybrid combination of the vast number of BC-NAM populations and lines. To address this, the utility of genomic information was evaluated to predict the hybrid performance of BC-NAM populations. Two agronomically elite BC-NAM populations were chosen for evaluation in which elite inbred RTx436 was the recurrent parent. Each BC1F3 line was evaluated in hybrid combination with an elite tester in two locations with phenotypes of grain yield, plant height, and days to anthesis collected on all test cross hybrids. Lines from both populations were found to outperform their recurrent parent. Efforts to utilize genetic distance based on genotyping-by-sequence (GBS) as a predictive tool for hybrid performance was ineffective. However, utilizing genomic prediction models using additive and dominance GBLUP kernels to screen germplasm appeared to be an effective method to eliminate inferior-performing lines that will not be useful in a hybrid breeding program.
- 17 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Euphytica
- Vol. 218 (9) , 1-17
Mega-environment analysis to assess adaptability, stability, and genomic predictions in grain sorghum hybrids
- 17 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Euphytica
- Vol. 218 (9) , 1-17
Mega-environment analysis to assess adaptability, stability, and genomic predictions in grain sorghum hybrids
- 24 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Crop Science
- Vol. 61 (6) , 4098-4111
Combining abilities and elite germplasm enhancement across U.S. public sorghum breeding programs
For mature breeding programs, maintaining genetic variation in elite germplasm requires a continual assessment of the most efficient methods to maximize functional genetic variation while improving productivity. This research assessed the relative value (defined as population means and variances) derived from elite germplasm exchange between distinct public breeding programs. Ten elite A‐ and R‐lines from Texas A&M and Kansas State sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L. Moench) breeding programs were crossed in a factorial design to generate 100 hybrids. Hybrid combinations were grouped to represent hybrids within and across programs. Grain yield, plant height, and days to anthesis were measured in 10 environments over 2 yr. Combining abilities and their interactions with the environment were assessed. Combined analysis detected significant effects for all traits, but genetic effects for grain yield were not consistently significant within each group of hybrid combinations. Hybrids derived from only Texas inbreds had limited genetic variation for grain yield but the highest mean of all four groups; hybrids derived from only Kansas inbreds produced moderate genetic variation but lower grain yield potential. Maximum genetic variation for grain yield and plant height occurred when Kansas A‐lines were crossed to Texas R‐lines, whereas hybrids between Texas A‐lines and Kansas R‐lines maximized variation for days to antheses. Results demonstrated the potential benefit from crossing elite inbred parents derived from distinct breeding programs to increase genetic variation and enhance agronomic performance.
- 24 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Crop Science
- Vol. 61 (6) , 4098-4111
Combining abilities and elite germplasm enhancement across U.S. public sorghum breeding programs
For mature breeding programs, maintaining genetic variation in elite germplasm requires a continual assessment of the most efficient methods to maximize functional genetic variation while improving productivity. This research assessed the relative value (defined as population means and variances) derived from elite germplasm exchange between distinct public breeding programs. Ten elite A‐ and R‐lines from Texas A&M and Kansas State sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L. Moench) breeding programs were crossed in a factorial design to generate 100 hybrids. Hybrid combinations were grouped to represent hybrids within and across programs. Grain yield, plant height, and days to anthesis were measured in 10 environments over 2 yr. Combining abilities and their interactions with the environment were assessed. Combined analysis detected significant effects for all traits, but genetic effects for grain yield were not consistently significant within each group of hybrid combinations. Hybrids derived from only Texas inbreds had limited genetic variation for grain yield but the highest mean of all four groups; hybrids derived from only Kansas inbreds produced moderate genetic variation but lower grain yield potential. Maximum genetic variation for grain yield and plant height occurred when Kansas A‐lines were crossed to Texas R‐lines, whereas hybrids between Texas A‐lines and Kansas R‐lines maximized variation for days to antheses. Results demonstrated the potential benefit from crossing elite inbred parents derived from distinct breeding programs to increase genetic variation and enhance agronomic performance.
- Open Access
- 9 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in The Plant Genome
- Vol. 14 (3) , e20127
Assessing combining abilities, genomic data, and genotype × environment interactions to predict hybrid grain sorghum performance
Genomic selection in maize ( Zea mays L.) has been one factor that has increased the rate of genetic gain when compared with other cereals. However, the technological foundations in maize also exist in other cereal crops that would allow prediction of hybrid performance based on general (GCA) and specific (SCA) combining abilities applied through genomic‐enabled prediction models. Further, the incorporation of genotype × environment (G × E) interaction effects present an opportunity to deploy hybrids to targeted environments. To test these concepts, a factorial mating design of elite yet divergent grain sorghum lines generated hybrids for evaluation. Inbred parents were genotyped, and markers were used to assess population structure and develop the genomic relationship matrix (GRM). Grain yield, height, and days to anthesis were collected for hybrids in replicated trials, and best linear unbiased estimates were used to train classical GCA‐SCA–based and genomic (GB) models under a hierarchical Bayesian framework. To incorporate population structure, GB was fitted using the GRM of both parents and hybrids. For GB models, G × E interaction effects were included by the Hadamard product between GRM and environments. A leave‐one‐out cross‐validation scheme was used to study the prediction capacity of models. Classical and genomic models effectively predicted hybrid performance and prediction accuracy increased by including genomic data. Genomic models effectively partitioned the variation due to GCA, SCA, and their interaction with the environment. A strategy to implement genomic selection for hybrid sorghum [ Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] breeding is presented herein.
- 9 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in The Plant Genome
- Vol. 14 (3) , e20127
Open AccessAssessing combining abilities, genomic data, and genotype × environment interactions to predict hybrid grain sorghum performance
Genomic selection in maize ( Zea mays L.) has been one factor that has increased the rate of genetic gain when compared with other cereals. However, the technological foundations in maize also exist in other cereal crops that would allow prediction of hybrid performance based on general (GCA) and specific (SCA) combining abilities applied through genomic‐enabled prediction models. Further, the incorporation of genotype × environment (G × E) interaction effects present an opportunity to deploy hybrids to targeted environments. To test these concepts, a factorial mating design of elite yet divergent grain sorghum lines generated hybrids for evaluation. Inbred parents were genotyped, and markers were used to assess population structure and develop the genomic relationship matrix (GRM). Grain yield, height, and days to anthesis were collected for hybrids in replicated trials, and best linear unbiased estimates were used to train classical GCA‐SCA–based and genomic (GB) models under a hierarchical Bayesian framework. To incorporate population structure, GB was fitted using the GRM of both parents and hybrids. For GB models, G × E interaction effects were included by the Hadamard product between GRM and environments. A leave‐one‐out cross‐validation scheme was used to study the prediction capacity of models. Classical and genomic models effectively predicted hybrid performance and prediction accuracy increased by including genomic data. Genomic models effectively partitioned the variation due to GCA, SCA, and their interaction with the environment. A strategy to implement genomic selection for hybrid sorghum [ Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] breeding is presented herein.
- 12 May 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Plant Registrations
- Vol. 14 (2) , 179-188
Registration of 11 diverse sorghum germplasm lines for grain and silage hybrid production
Genotypic variance is necessary for trait improvement because limited diversity can reduce genetic gains in crop improvement. To maintain genetic diversity, a wealth of germplasm exists in the USDA‐ARS sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] collection, but most of the accessions are not adapted to temperate climates. To address this issue, the Reinstated Sorghum Conversion program (RSC, ∼2009–2014) converted 155 tropical accessions to combine height and early maturing F3 and BC1F3 families. Here, 11 germplasm lines Tx3429 to Tx3439 (Reg. no. GP‐889, PI 692640 to Reg. no. GP‐899, PI 692650) released by Texas A&M AgriLife Research in 2019 and derived from the RSC program are described. This germplasm was derived from F3, BC1F3, and BC1F4 RSC families that were selected based on testcross hybrid performance for either grain or silage production. Six lines are grain sorghum pollinators, one line is a seed parent, and four lines are silage pollinators. These lines combined agronomic productivity with greater genetic diversity as confirmed via genotyping‐by‐sequencing. These 11 parental germplasms are being released to provide new genetic diversity for forage and grain hybrid improvement programs.
- 12 May 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Plant Registrations
- Vol. 14 (2) , 179-188
Registration of 11 diverse sorghum germplasm lines for grain and silage hybrid production
Genotypic variance is necessary for trait improvement because limited diversity can reduce genetic gains in crop improvement. To maintain genetic diversity, a wealth of germplasm exists in the USDA‐ARS sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] collection, but most of the accessions are not adapted to temperate climates. To address this issue, the Reinstated Sorghum Conversion program (RSC, ∼2009–2014) converted 155 tropical accessions to combine height and early maturing F3 and BC1F3 families. Here, 11 germplasm lines Tx3429 to Tx3439 (Reg. no. GP‐889, PI 692640 to Reg. no. GP‐899, PI 692650) released by Texas A&M AgriLife Research in 2019 and derived from the RSC program are described. This germplasm was derived from F3, BC1F3, and BC1F4 RSC families that were selected based on testcross hybrid performance for either grain or silage production. Six lines are grain sorghum pollinators, one line is a seed parent, and four lines are silage pollinators. These lines combined agronomic productivity with greater genetic diversity as confirmed via genotyping‐by‐sequencing. These 11 parental germplasms are being released to provide new genetic diversity for forage and grain hybrid improvement programs.
- 5 November 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Crop Improvement
- Vol. 33 (1) , 1-24
Heritability and quantitative trait loci of composition and structural characteristics in sorghum grain
Breeding efforts in cereal crops directed toward developing or improving end-use products of grain require assessment of existing phenotypic variance and an understanding of the genetic control of grain quality traits. To this end, a grain sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] mapping population consisting of 113 F2:7 recombinant inbred lines (RILs) derived from a cross between Sureño and RTx430 was evaluated in multiple environments for grain composition (fat, fiber, protein, starch) using near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy (NIRS), and size estimates of grain parts (embryo, vitreous endosperm, floury endosperm, kernel area) using an image-based phenotyping software system. Estimates of broad-sense heritability of grain compositional traits ranged from 0.11 to 0.90, whereas those of grain size ranged from 0.16 to 0.72. Composite interval mapping (CIM) was applied to a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)-based linkage map to identify marker-trait associations, and through these efforts, a total of 37 quantitative trait loci (QTL) for grain quality were identified across environments. Each QTL explained between 7 and 23% of the phenotypic variation for a given grain trait. Three of the five QTL that colocalized were for traits with significant negative correlation, which included grain protein content that was negatively correlated with grain starch content. In addition, several traits that were positively correlated (e.g. fat and fiber content) also revealed colocalized QTL. Finally, we compared the present study with previous studies identifying grain composition trait loci in an effort to identify genomic regions controlling grain traits across a diversity of environments and sorghum genotypes.
- 5 November 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Crop Improvement
- Vol. 33 (1) , 1-24
Heritability and quantitative trait loci of composition and structural characteristics in sorghum grain
Breeding efforts in cereal crops directed toward developing or improving end-use products of grain require assessment of existing phenotypic variance and an understanding of the genetic control of grain quality traits. To this end, a grain sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] mapping population consisting of 113 F2:7 recombinant inbred lines (RILs) derived from a cross between Sureño and RTx430 was evaluated in multiple environments for grain composition (fat, fiber, protein, starch) using near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy (NIRS), and size estimates of grain parts (embryo, vitreous endosperm, floury endosperm, kernel area) using an image-based phenotyping software system. Estimates of broad-sense heritability of grain compositional traits ranged from 0.11 to 0.90, whereas those of grain size ranged from 0.16 to 0.72. Composite interval mapping (CIM) was applied to a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)-based linkage map to identify marker-trait associations, and through these efforts, a total of 37 quantitative trait loci (QTL) for grain quality were identified across environments. Each QTL explained between 7 and 23% of the phenotypic variation for a given grain trait. Three of the five QTL that colocalized were for traits with significant negative correlation, which included grain protein content that was negatively correlated with grain starch content. In addition, several traits that were positively correlated (e.g. fat and fiber content) also revealed colocalized QTL. Finally, we compared the present study with previous studies identifying grain composition trait loci in an effort to identify genomic regions controlling grain traits across a diversity of environments and sorghum genotypes.