Dirk Spengler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Dirk Spengler has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Adam Włodek
AGH University of Krakow, Department of Mineralogy, Petrography and Geochemistry, al. A. Mickiewicza 30, 30-059 Krakow, Poland
10 shared publications - Simon Cuthbert
AGH University of Krakow, Department of Mineralogy, Petrography and Geochemistry, al. A. Mickiewicza 30, 30-059 Krakow, Poland
10 shared publications - Jarosław Majka
Uppsala University
8 shared publications - Monika Koch-Müller
Deutsches GeoForschungsZentrum GFZ, Telegrafenberg, 14473 Potsdam, Germany
8 shared publications - Anselm Loges
Institut für Geologische Wissenschaften, Freie Universität Berlin, Malteserstr. 74–100, 12249 Berlin, Germany
2 shared publications - Taisia Aleksandrovna Alifirova
Department of Lithospheric Research, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Solid Earth
- Vol. 16 (3) , 233-250
Hydroxyl in eclogitic garnet, orthopyroxene, and oriented inclusion-bearing clinopyroxene, western Norway
A total of 10 western Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633, 3651–3694, and 3698–3735 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite, or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe, and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555, 3595, and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 µg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 µg g−1), and orthopyroxene (4–17 µg g−1). The outer 200 µm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 µg g−1) and clinopyroxene (58–711 µg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high-pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. both metasomatised and pristine eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath several cratons and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs, by up to several hundreds of micrograms per gram (µg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water, and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Solid Earth
- Vol. 16 (3) , 233-250
Open AccessHydroxyl in eclogitic garnet, orthopyroxene, and oriented inclusion-bearing clinopyroxene, western Norway
A total of 10 western Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633, 3651–3694, and 3698–3735 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite, or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe, and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555, 3595, and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 µg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 µg g−1), and orthopyroxene (4–17 µg g−1). The outer 200 µm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 µg g−1) and clinopyroxene (58–711 µg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high-pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. both metasomatised and pristine eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath several cratons and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs, by up to several hundreds of micrograms per gram (µg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water, and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 8 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Reply on RC3
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 8 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessReply on RC3
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Comment on egusphere-2024-2734
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 4 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2734
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 18 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Reply on RC2
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 18 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessReply on RC2
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 14 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-25
Comment on egusphere-2024-2734
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 14 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-25
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2734
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 13 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Reply on RC1
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 13 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessReply on RC1
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Comment on egusphere-2024-2734
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2734
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Hydroxyl in eclogitic garnet, orthopyroxene and oriented inclusion-bearing clinopyroxene, W Norway
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessHydroxyl in eclogitic garnet, orthopyroxene and oriented inclusion-bearing clinopyroxene, W Norway
Ten West Norwegian eclogites, whose mineral chemistry records metamorphism of up to 850 °C and 5.5 GPa, were investigated for structural hydroxyl content in nominally anhydrous minerals. Garnet shows pronounced absorption in the wavenumber ranges of 3596–3633 cm−1, 3651–3694 cm−1 and 3698–3735 cm−1, and minor absorption centred at about 3560 cm−1. Clinopyroxene with aligned inclusions of either quartz, albite or quartz + pargasite has major absorption at 3450–3471 cm−1 and 3521–3538 cm−1 and minor absorption centred at 3350 cm−1 and approximately 3625 cm−1. The latter band is strongest in a sample with minute lamellar inclusions rich in Al, Fe and Na and was excluded from hydroxyl quantification. Orthopyroxene has large, narrow absorption peaks centred at 3415 cm−1 and 3515 cm−1 and smaller peaks at 3555 cm−1, 3595 cm−1 and 3625 cm−1. Five orthopyroxene-bearing eclogites exhibit relatively homogeneous amounts of structural hydroxyl in garnet (13–32 μg g−1), clinopyroxene (119–174 μg g−1) and orthopyroxene (4–17 μg g−1). The outer 200 μm wide rims of the orthopyroxene grains illustrate a late hydroxyl loss compared to core values of about 30 %, which is not evident in garnet and clinopyroxene. In contrast, the other five orthopyroxene-free eclogites exhibit variable amounts of hydroxyl in garnet (8–306 μg g−1 ) and clinopyroxene (58–711 μg g−1). Apart from extreme values, the structural hydroxyl content of clinopyroxene in the eclogites studied is lower than in comparable ultra-high pressure metamorphic samples, e.g. pristine (non-metasomatised) eclogite xenoliths from the lithospheric mantle underneath the Siberian and Slave cratons (by about 200 μg g−1) and coesite- and quartz-eclogites from the Erzgebirge and the Kokchetav massifs (by several hundred μg g−1). The low structural hydroxyl contents, the deficiency of molecular water and the preservation of diffusion-sensitive evidence from the mineral chemistry for metamorphism well beyond the stability field of amphibole suggest that oriented inclusions of quartz + pargasite were formed isochemically during decompression. In addition, structural hydroxyl content in clinopyroxene is inversely correlated with metamorphic pressure estimates obtained from orthopyroxene of the same samples. Therefore, structural hydroxyl in nominally anhydrous eclogite minerals can serve as an indicator of the effectiveness of retrogression.
- Open Access
- 14 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in European Journal of Mineralogy
- Vol. 35 (6) , 1125-1147
Retrogression of ultrahigh-pressure eclogite, Western Gneiss Region, Norway
The Western Gneiss Region (WGR) in western Norway exposes ultrahigh-pressure (UHP) eclogites that occur repeatedly, within an area of high-pressure (HP) eclogites, without evidence of being separated by tectonic shear or ductile flow structures. We studied 10 eclogites from two northern UHP areas and the interjacent HP area to evaluate the significance of this pattern. The orthopyroxene in orthopyroxene-bearing samples has low Al2O3 contents (0.17 wt %–0.37 wt %), provided its grain boundaries were unaffected by partial recrystallisation or replacement. Classical geothermobarometry based on element partitioning between coexisting mineral phases suggests metamorphic conditions within the diamond stability field for the samples from both the HP and UHP areas. The primary clinopyroxene in the associated orthopyroxene-free eclogites contains aligned inclusions of either needle-shaped quartz ± pargasite or lamellar albite, which are absent from the secondary (symplectic) clinopyroxene. Reconstructed mineral compositions of the primary clinopyroxene obtained from grain cross-section surfaces using a scanning electron beam or image processing are non-stoichiometric, and they have higher Ca-Eskola and lower Ca-Tschermak components than the inclusion-bearing host clinopyroxene. The molar ratios of these endmembers are consistent with the needles in the primary clinopyroxene being formed from vacancy-bearing precursor clinopyroxene by the exsolution reaction 2 Ca-Eskola = Ca-Tschermak + 3 quartz during early eclogite-facies retrogression. Further retrogression partially transformed the needle-shaped quartz to irregularly shaped albite within the clinopyroxene and partially transformed both clinopyroxene generations to amphibole that occasionally preserves the needles. The similarity of both the maximum metamorphic conditions and the mineral exsolution microstructures in the eclogites from UHP and HP areas indicates a shared metamorphic history within the stability field of diamond, but a history that diverged during retrogression. Consequently, the alternations of UHP and HP areas in the WGR may have formed by a process that allowed for spatial variations in retrogression efficiency, such as the localisation of strain (recrystallisation) or fluid flow (diffusion) or both, rather than by tectonic stacking of UHP and HP units. Evidence for the UHP metamorphism of WGR crustal rocks is now found from NE to SW along the entire coastal section that covers previously recognised UHP and interjacent areas.
- 14 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in European Journal of Mineralogy
- Vol. 35 (6) , 1125-1147
Open AccessRetrogression of ultrahigh-pressure eclogite, Western Gneiss Region, Norway
The Western Gneiss Region (WGR) in western Norway exposes ultrahigh-pressure (UHP) eclogites that occur repeatedly, within an area of high-pressure (HP) eclogites, without evidence of being separated by tectonic shear or ductile flow structures. We studied 10 eclogites from two northern UHP areas and the interjacent HP area to evaluate the significance of this pattern. The orthopyroxene in orthopyroxene-bearing samples has low Al2O3 contents (0.17 wt %–0.37 wt %), provided its grain boundaries were unaffected by partial recrystallisation or replacement. Classical geothermobarometry based on element partitioning between coexisting mineral phases suggests metamorphic conditions within the diamond stability field for the samples from both the HP and UHP areas. The primary clinopyroxene in the associated orthopyroxene-free eclogites contains aligned inclusions of either needle-shaped quartz ± pargasite or lamellar albite, which are absent from the secondary (symplectic) clinopyroxene. Reconstructed mineral compositions of the primary clinopyroxene obtained from grain cross-section surfaces using a scanning electron beam or image processing are non-stoichiometric, and they have higher Ca-Eskola and lower Ca-Tschermak components than the inclusion-bearing host clinopyroxene. The molar ratios of these endmembers are consistent with the needles in the primary clinopyroxene being formed from vacancy-bearing precursor clinopyroxene by the exsolution reaction 2 Ca-Eskola = Ca-Tschermak + 3 quartz during early eclogite-facies retrogression. Further retrogression partially transformed the needle-shaped quartz to irregularly shaped albite within the clinopyroxene and partially transformed both clinopyroxene generations to amphibole that occasionally preserves the needles. The similarity of both the maximum metamorphic conditions and the mineral exsolution microstructures in the eclogites from UHP and HP areas indicates a shared metamorphic history within the stability field of diamond, but a history that diverged during retrogression. Consequently, the alternations of UHP and HP areas in the WGR may have formed by a process that allowed for spatial variations in retrogression efficiency, such as the localisation of strain (recrystallisation) or fluid flow (diffusion) or both, rather than by tectonic stacking of UHP and HP units. Evidence for the UHP metamorphism of WGR crustal rocks is now found from NE to SW along the entire coastal section that covers previously recognised UHP and interjacent areas.
- Open Access
- 10 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology
- Vol. 178 (9) , 1-11
Zirconium/hafnium fractionation and rare earth element systematics in sub-cratonic garnet pyroxenites, Norway
Ten previously studied garnet pyroxenites and one eclogite from orogenic peridotites in the Western Gneiss Region of Norway were analysed for whole-rock major and trace and mineral trace elements to characterise the evolutionary stages of the East Greenland sub-cratonic mantle. A continuous range of whole-rock MgO contents (17–30 wt.%) correlates inversely with $$\hbox {Na}_2\hbox {O}$$ , $$\hbox {Al}_2\hbox {O}_3$$ , and CaO contents. In contrast, rare earth element (REE) compositions allow the samples to be devided into two types. Type I samples have relatively flat primitive mantle (PM) normalised REE patterns (0.4 $$-$$ 6.8 times PM values) with minor fractionation of middle–heavy REEs. Type II samples are simlar to type I samples but have higher light REE contents (6.1–57 times PM values) that reflect metasomatic enrichment. Whole-rock Zr contents (1– $$27\,\upmu \hbox {g}\,\hbox {g}^{-1}$$ ) and Zr/Hf ratios (17–39) are positively correlated. Type I samples have low Zr/Hf ratios that mostly differ from type II samples, indicating that metasomatism modified the initially sub-chondritic Zr/Hf ratios. Garnet Zr–Zr/Hf–Y–Ti systematics suggest that metasomatic enrichment transformed the type I samples into type II samples, consistent with processes observed in other cratonic areas (e.g., the northern East European Platform and the Kaapvaal Craton). The formation of type I pyroxenite in dunite from a melt at $$\sim 100\,\text {km}$$ depth implies the sub-chondritic Zr/Hf ratios were inherited from that melt. Such melts are thought to form by melting of garnet-bearing, melt-depleted mantle, which is consistent with models for recycling of Archaean palaeo-oceanic crust throughout the mantle prior to the formation of the sub-cratonic lithosphere beneath East Greenland.- 10 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology
- Vol. 178 (9) , 1-11
Open AccessZirconium/hafnium fractionation and rare earth element systematics in sub-cratonic garnet pyroxenites, Norway
Ten previously studied garnet pyroxenites and one eclogite from orogenic peridotites in the Western Gneiss Region of Norway were analysed for whole-rock major and trace and mineral trace elements to characterise the evolutionary stages of the East Greenland sub-cratonic mantle. A continuous range of whole-rock MgO contents (17–30 wt.%) correlates inversely with $$\hbox {Na}_2\hbox {O}$$ , $$\hbox {Al}_2\hbox {O}_3$$ , and CaO contents. In contrast, rare earth element (REE) compositions allow the samples to be devided into two types. Type I samples have relatively flat primitive mantle (PM) normalised REE patterns (0.4 $$-$$ 6.8 times PM values) with minor fractionation of middle–heavy REEs. Type II samples are simlar to type I samples but have higher light REE contents (6.1–57 times PM values) that reflect metasomatic enrichment. Whole-rock Zr contents (1– $$27\,\upmu \hbox {g}\,\hbox {g}^{-1}$$ ) and Zr/Hf ratios (17–39) are positively correlated. Type I samples have low Zr/Hf ratios that mostly differ from type II samples, indicating that metasomatism modified the initially sub-chondritic Zr/Hf ratios. Garnet Zr–Zr/Hf–Y–Ti systematics suggest that metasomatic enrichment transformed the type I samples into type II samples, consistent with processes observed in other cratonic areas (e.g., the northern East European Platform and the Kaapvaal Craton). The formation of type I pyroxenite in dunite from a melt at $$\sim 100\,\text {km}$$ depth implies the sub-chondritic Zr/Hf ratios were inherited from that melt. Such melts are thought to form by melting of garnet-bearing, melt-depleted mantle, which is consistent with models for recycling of Archaean palaeo-oceanic crust throughout the mantle prior to the formation of the sub-cratonic lithosphere beneath East Greenland.