CBCathleen Balantic

Cathleen Balantic

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Cathleen Balantic has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Acoustic indices are not useful for biodiversity research

    by Larissa S. M. Sugai, Cathleen Balantic, Dena J. Clink, Vijay Ramesh, Stefan Kahl, Holger Klinck, Connor M. Wood

    Biodiversity assessment using passive acoustic monitoring has historically been challenging due to the limited availability of multi‐species acoustic detectors. In this context, acoustic indices were introduced as an alternative way to represent species diversity in acoustic datasets. Although there is increasing evidence that their effectiveness as a proxy for species diversity is limited, acoustic indices are still used and recommended for biodiversity research. Acoustic indices face structural issues, with a flawed theoretical basis and weak empirical support. Additionally, limited generalizability, dependence on context and inconsistent performance make it difficult to assess their value in the inferential process. Without a clear method to map acoustic indices into meaningful biological components, their interpretability is greatly compromised. Biodiversity assessment through acoustic monitoring benefits significantly from frameworks that use species as the fundamental analytical unit, even when misclassification might occur. In contrast, acoustic indices ignore species recognition due to their reliance on properties such as spectral distribution of acoustic energy and consequently limit the inference of causal links to species diversity. A variety of options are available to enhance species‐based biodiversity acoustic monitoring. We emphasize that manual annotation and single‐species detectors have contributed significantly to the field, and effective methods for multi‐species classification now exist. This has opened new paradigms and expanded opportunities for directly identifying target signals in audio data across a broad range of species. In the ongoing biodiversity crisis, resources should be prioritized for tools and approaches that provide managers and stakeholders with meaningful information on the composition, structure, and function of biodiversity. Acoustic indices are not suitable as reliable biodiversity indicators, and their continued use in biodiversity research is unjustifiable. Acoustic monitoring should leverage existing and emerging methods to extract species‐level data from recordings, offering more valuable and impactful contributions to ecology and conservation efforts.


  • Synthesis of Studies on the Effects of Noise, 1978–2025

    by Cathleen Balantic, Tyra Olstad

    The Natural Sounds and Night Skies Division (NSNSD) works to understand, contribute to, and communicate scientific knowledge that informs management of natural and cultural resources and the visitor experience related to natural sounds and night skies. This project summarizes the results of a systematic annual query of scientific literature to provide park managers with updated knowledge about the effects of noise. This product represents our continued efforts to describe the quantity of literature available, the kinds of noise sources studied, and the breadth of documented effects within an accessible format. Results demonstrate the extent of scientific support for park planning and management related to noise. Distinct subsets of the scientific literature may be of relevance for specific locations or management actions; the authors will assist parks and regions with more detailed and specific analyses of this literature upon request. A CSV of the annual literature results is included with the report products on NPS DataStore.

  • Synthesis of Studies on the Effects of Artificial Light at Night, 1978–2025

    by Cathleen Balantic, Tyra Olstad

    The Natural Sounds and Night Skies Division (NSNSD) works to understand, contribute to, and communicate scientific knowledge that informs management of natural and cultural resources and the visitor experience related to natural sounds and night skies. This project summarizes the results of a systematic annual query of scientific literature to provide park managers with updated knowledge about the effects of artificial light at night (ALAN). This product represents our continued efforts to describe the quantity of literature available, the types of light sources studied, and the breadth of documented effects within an accessible format. Results demonstrate the extent of scientific support for park planning and management related to ALAN. Distinct subsets of the scientific literature may be of relevance for specific locations or management actions; the authors will assist parks and regions with more detailed and specific analyses of this literature upon request. A CSV of the annual literature results is included with the report products on NPS DataStore.

  • Open Access

    AMMonitor 2: Remote monitoring of biodiversity in an adaptive framework in R

    by Laurence Clarfeld, Caroline Tang, Kaitlin Huber, Cathleen Balantic, Therese Donovan

    Wildlife face a myriad of challenges due to changing climate and land use regimes that necessitate efficient monitoring methods on large geospatial scales. This monitoring is increasingly accomplished with remotely deployed trail cameras and automated recording units. However, remote wildlife monitoring comes with data management challenges, such as storing, organizing and analysing large volumes of digital data. Data management tools can assist biologists in managing projects to reduce the barriers between data collection and dissemination of results. AMMonitor is an R package for remote wildlife monitoring with greatly increased functionality in the version 2 release, including a new database structure, support for both photographs and audio monitoring, a rich graphical user interface (Shiny) that includes media labelling tools, integration of machine learning classification outputs and 20 in‐depth tutorials. As a fully open‐source data management solution, AMMonitor is highly accessible, extensible and customizable, making it especially useful for students and users with some coding experience who desire a standardized yet flexible data management framework. AMMonitor project data can be released to the public via the USGS ScienceBase data repository, where released projects can be reconstituted by AMMonitor functions.


  • Minidoka National Historic Site: Acoustic monitoring report, 2022

    by Erik Meyer, Cathleen Balantic

    This study arose from the Minidoka National Historic Site (MIIN) Technical Assistance Request (TAR; #21332), which identified the need for baseline acoustic surveys to understand potential impacts to the acoustic environment from nearby proposed renewable energy development. From September through October 2022, the Natural Sounds and Night Skies Division (NSNSD) gathered acoustic data at one site in MIIN to provide park managers with baseline information about the acoustic environment, including existing ambient sound levels and time-above noise effect levels. Overall, existing median ambient sound levels (LA50) at MIIN were 30.0 dB during the day and 33.1 dB at night. In the ANS-weighted frequency range, the sound level 35 dB (LAeq, 1s), was exceeded 24.2% of the day and 18.2% of the night. All other key sound levels (i.e., 45 dB and above) during the day and night were exceeded less than 4% of the time. Due to an error in the acoustic recording schedule, some NSNSD metrics are not included. As a supplement, a geospatial sound model predicts existing and natural ambient sound levels at MIIN are 32.8 (dBA) and 23.5 (dBA), respectively.

  • Open Access

    Snowmobile noise alters bird vocalization patterns during winter and pre‐breeding season

    by Benjamin Cretois, Ian Avery Bick, Cathleen Balantic, Femke B. Gelderblom, Diego Pávon‐Jordán, Julia Wiel, Sarab S. Sethi, Davyd H. Betchkal, Ben Banet, Carolyn M. Rosten, et al.

    Noise pollution poses a significant threat to ecosystems worldwide, disrupting animal communication and causing cascading effects on biodiversity. In this study, we focus on the impact of snowmobile noise on avian vocalizations during the non‐breeding winter season, a less‐studied area in soundscape ecology. We developed a pipeline relying on deep learning methods to detect snowmobile noise and applied it to a large acoustic monitoring dataset collected in Yellowstone National Park. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of the snowmobile detection model in identifying snowmobile noise and reveal an association between snowmobile passage and changes in avian vocalization patterns. Snowmobile noise led to a decrease in the frequency of bird vocalizations during mornings and evenings, potentially affecting winter and pre‐breeding behaviours such as foraging, predator avoidance and successfully finding a mate. However, we observed a recovery in avian vocalizations after detection of snowmobiles during mornings and afternoons, indicating some resilience to sporadic noise events. Synthesis and applications: Our findings emphasize the need to consider noise impacts in the non‐breeding season and provide valuable insights for natural resource managers to minimize disturbance and protect critical avian habitats. The deep learning approach presented in this study offers an efficient and accurate means of analysing large‐scale acoustic monitoring data and contributes to a comprehensive understanding of the cumulative impacts of multiple stressors on avian communities.


  • Open Access

    Toward climate change refugia conservation at an ecoregion scale

    by Cathleen Balantic, Andrea Adams, Shana Gross, Rachel Mazur, Sarah Sawyer, Jody Tucker, Marian Vernon, Claudia Mengelt, Jennifer Morales, James H. Thorne, et al.

    Climate change uncertainty poses serious challenges to conservation efforts. One emerging conservation strategy is to identify and conserve climate change refugia: areas relatively buffered from contemporary climate change that enable persistence of valued resources. This management paradigm may be pursued at broad scales by leveraging existing resources and placing them into a tangible framework to stimulate further collaboration that fosters management decision‐making. Here, we describe a framework for moving toward operationalizing climate change refugia conservation at an ecoregion scale with an analysis for the Sierra Nevada ecoregion (CA, USA). Structured within the Climate Change Refugia Conservation Cycle, we identify a preliminary suite of conservation priorities for the ecoregion, and demonstrate how existing mapping, data, and applications could be used for identifying, prioritizing, managing, and monitoring refugia. We focus on six stakeholder‐identified conservation priorities, including two process‐based refugial priorities (snow and fire), and four ecosystem‐based refugial priorities (meadows, giant sequoia, old growth forests, and alpine communities). This pilot overview of concepts and resources provides a foundation for both near‐term implementation and further discussion in moving from science to conservation practice. Such an approach may provide new practical insights for ecosystem management at ecoregion scales in the face of climate change.


  • Open Access

    Ten simple rules for productive lab meetings

    by Nigel Golden, Kadambari Devarajan, Cathleen Balantic, Joseph Drake, Michael T. Hallworth, Toni Lyn Morelli


  • Open Access

    AMMonitor: Remote monitoring of biodiversity in an adaptive framework with r

    by Cathleen Balantic, Therese Donovan

    Ecological research and management programs are increasingly using autonomous monitoring units (AMUs) to collect large volumes of acoustic and/or photo data to address pressing management objectives or research goals. The data management requirements of an AMU‐based monitoring effort are often overwhelming, with a considerable amount of processing to translate raw data into models and analyses that have research and management utility. We created the r package AMMonitor to simplify the process of moving from remotely collected data to analysis and results, using a comprehensive SQLite database for data management that tracks all components of a remote monitoring program. This framework enables the tracking of analyses and research/management objectives through time. We illustrate the AMMonitor approach with the example of evaluating an occurrence‐based management objective for a target species. First, we provide an overview of the database and data management approach. Next, we illustrate a few available workflows: temporally adaptive sampling, automated detection of species sounds from acoustic recordings and aggregation of automated detections into an encounter history for use in an occupancy analysis, the outcome of which can be analysed with respect to the motivating management objective. Without a comprehensive framework for efficiently moving from raw remote monitoring data collection to results and analysis, monitoring programs are limited in their capacity to systematically characterize ecological processes and inform management decisions through time. AMMonitor provides an option for such a framework. Code, comprehensive documentation and step‐by‐step examples are available online at https://code.usgs.gov/vtcfwru/AMMonitor


  • Open Access

    Temporally adaptive acoustic sampling to maximize detection across a suite of focal wildlife species

    by Cathleen Balantic, Therese Donovan

    Acoustic recordings of the environment can produce species presence–absence data for characterizing populations of sound‐producing wildlife over multiple spatial scales. If a species is present at a site but does not vocalize during a scheduled audio recording survey, researchers may incorrectly conclude that the species is absent (“false negative”). The risk of false negatives is compounded when audio devices have sampling constraints, do not record continuously, and must be manually scheduled to operate at pre‐selected times of day, particularly when research programs target multiple species with acoustic availability that varies across temporal conditions. We developed a temporally adaptive acoustic sampling algorithm to maximize detection probabilities for a suite of focal species amid sampling constraints. The algorithm combines user‐supplied species vocalization models with site‐specific weather forecasts to set an optimized sampling schedule for the following day. To test our algorithm, we simulated hourly vocalization probabilities for a suite of focal species in a hypothetical monitoring area for the year 2016. We conducted a factorial experiment that sampled from the 2016 acoustic environment to compare the probability of acoustic detection by a fixed (stationary) schedule versus a temporally adaptive optimized schedule under several sampling efforts and monitoring durations. We found that over the course of a study season, the probability of acoustically capturing a focal species (given presence) at least once via automated acoustic monitoring was greater (and acoustic capture occurred earlier in the season) when using the temporally adaptive optimized schedule as compared to a fixed schedule. The advantages of a temporally adaptive optimized acoustic sampling schedule are magnified when a study duration is short, sampling effort is low, and/or species acoustic availability is minimal. This methodology presents the opportunity to maximize acoustic monitoring sampling efforts amid constraints.