Salomé Azevedo
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Salomé Azevedo has a total of 38 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ana Londral
Comprehensive Health Research Centre, Lisbon, Portugal
7 shared publications - Federico Guede-Fernández
Value for Health CoLAB, Lisboa, Portugal
5 shared publications - Francisco von Hafe
Value for Health CoLAB, Portugal
3 shared publications - Ana Maria Rodrigues
Comprehensive Health Research Centre (CHRC), Nova Medical School, Nova University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal
2 shared publications - Ana Vieira
CEGIST, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
2 shared publications - Eduarda Oliosi
Value for Health CoLAB, 15 Fontes Pereira de Melo Ave, 2nd Fl, Right, Lisbon, 1050‑115, Portugal, 351 937091767
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
What to measure for monitoring and decision-making in a case management intervention for emergency department high-users: different stakeholder priorities
Background: Multidisciplinary case management (CM) for high users (HU) of the emergency department (ED) is a complex intervention involving multiple stakeholders. CM evaluations typically adopt a provider perspective and rely on hospital utilisation-based indicators. However, different stakeholders bear distinct costs, consider different benefits relevant, and face specific constraints. This study aims to identify, compare, and prioritise the evaluation indicators that different stakeholder groups consider most relevant for monitoring and decision-making in a Portuguese HU CM intervention (GRHU), and to assess their measurability using routinely collected hospital data. Methods: A participatory action research approach was used, structured around two action-reflection cycles across four sequential steps: (1) identifying candidate indicators via interviews with ED and primary care professionals, and hospital intermediate management; (2) structuring indicators using the Donabedian framework; (3) prioritising indicators with senior organisational stakeholders (administrative board members, ED leadership, and GRHU management); (4) operationalising indicators and assessing their measurability and costing using hospital data. This final step included an economic evaluation calculating a ratio of the observed pre-post cost difference to delivery cost for the highest-priority, measurable, and monetisable outcome indicator, using a 12-month before-and-after window anchored to the patient’s first GRHU appointment. Changes in the outcome indicators were monetised using standard national unit prices and compared with intervention delivery costs, estimated using Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing. Results: Twenty-two indicators were defined (9 process, 13 outcome). Priorities differed: board members ( n = 2) prioritised caseload volume; ED leadership ( n = 3) prioritised intervention duration and change in ED visits; and GRHU management ( n = 3) prioritised care plan reassessment frequency and change in ED visits. Only nine indicators were fully measurable using routine data; among these, change in ED visits was the highest-ranked outcome and was used for economic evaluation. In 73 patients, ED visit costs fell by 54.5%, a pre-post difference of €71 622.48; compared with €58 468.51 in delivery costs, this produced a ratio of the observed pre-post ED cost difference to delivery cost of 1.22 over one year. Conclusions: Typically, CM evaluations focused solely on the provider perspective provide an incomplete picture of what different stakeholders consider relevant for monitoring and decision-making. Stakeholders prioritise diverse indicators, many not captured by existing health information systems. This gap is consistent with implementation science evidence suggesting that favourable financial results alone may be insufficient to ensure continued organisational engagement. Therefore, effective governance may benefit from multi-stakeholder evaluation frameworks aligned with decision-making priorities and strengthened health data infrastructures.
- 26 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
Open AccessWhat to measure for monitoring and decision-making in a case management intervention for emergency department high-users: different stakeholder priorities
Background: Multidisciplinary case management (CM) for high users (HU) of the emergency department (ED) is a complex intervention involving multiple stakeholders. CM evaluations typically adopt a provider perspective and rely on hospital utilisation-based indicators. However, different stakeholders bear distinct costs, consider different benefits relevant, and face specific constraints. This study aims to identify, compare, and prioritise the evaluation indicators that different stakeholder groups consider most relevant for monitoring and decision-making in a Portuguese HU CM intervention (GRHU), and to assess their measurability using routinely collected hospital data. Methods: A participatory action research approach was used, structured around two action-reflection cycles across four sequential steps: (1) identifying candidate indicators via interviews with ED and primary care professionals, and hospital intermediate management; (2) structuring indicators using the Donabedian framework; (3) prioritising indicators with senior organisational stakeholders (administrative board members, ED leadership, and GRHU management); (4) operationalising indicators and assessing their measurability and costing using hospital data. This final step included an economic evaluation calculating a ratio of the observed pre-post cost difference to delivery cost for the highest-priority, measurable, and monetisable outcome indicator, using a 12-month before-and-after window anchored to the patient’s first GRHU appointment. Changes in the outcome indicators were monetised using standard national unit prices and compared with intervention delivery costs, estimated using Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing. Results: Twenty-two indicators were defined (9 process, 13 outcome). Priorities differed: board members ( n = 2) prioritised caseload volume; ED leadership ( n = 3) prioritised intervention duration and change in ED visits; and GRHU management ( n = 3) prioritised care plan reassessment frequency and change in ED visits. Only nine indicators were fully measurable using routine data; among these, change in ED visits was the highest-ranked outcome and was used for economic evaluation. In 73 patients, ED visit costs fell by 54.5%, a pre-post difference of €71 622.48; compared with €58 468.51 in delivery costs, this produced a ratio of the observed pre-post ED cost difference to delivery cost of 1.22 over one year. Conclusions: Typically, CM evaluations focused solely on the provider perspective provide an incomplete picture of what different stakeholders consider relevant for monitoring and decision-making. Stakeholders prioritise diverse indicators, many not captured by existing health information systems. This gap is consistent with implementation science evidence suggesting that favourable financial results alone may be insufficient to ensure continued organisational engagement. Therefore, effective governance may benefit from multi-stakeholder evaluation frameworks aligned with decision-making priorities and strengthened health data infrastructures.
- Open Access
- 9 April 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Aligning Digital Health Frameworks Across Innovation and Intervention Lifecycles: A Cross-Framework Analysis (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Digital health development is often fragmented, with intervention- and innovation-oriented approaches applied interchangeably despite distinct goals and evaluation criteria. This misalignment can result in limited user engagement, premature scale-up, and implementation failure. Existing frameworks offer guidance, but vary widely in scope, terminology, and purpose. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to develop a harmonized lifecycle structure that supports alignment across digital health frameworks and stakeholder needs. METHODS We conducted a multi-step analysis integrating a rapid review and comparative framework analysis. Relevant influential digital health frameworks were selected based on defined inclusion criteria. We analyzed each framework’s structure, assumptions, and use cases through structured coding informed by implementation science, innovation management, and human-centered design. A grounded, iterative process of constant comparison and thematic abstraction was used to identify shared lifecycle functions and align conceptual elements. RESULTS The study generated four key outcomes: (1) a structured map of conceptually diverse digital health frameworks; (2) a positioning of these frameworks along an intervention–innovation continuum based on their input and output logic; (3) a neutral set of cross-cutting lifecycle functions enabling structured comparison across frameworks; and (4) a practical roadmap that integrates these elements to guide alignment between development efforts and system readiness. The frameworks were grouped into three structural types – development-process models, readiness/maturity models, and macro-level transition models – each addressing different lifecycle functions. Their combined alignment revealed complementary roles in supporting the design, evaluation, scale-up, and systemic adoption of digital health solutions. CONCLUSIONS This study offers a transdisciplinary structure that clarifies the contributions of existing digital health frameworks and enables their coordinated use. By introducing neutral lifecycle functions and a practical mapping tool, the work supports researchers, developers, and policymakers in selecting and sequencing frameworks aligned with their goals and contexts. The results promote coherence, evidence-informed decision-making, and more sustainable digital health implementation.
- 9 April 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessAligning Digital Health Frameworks Across Innovation and Intervention Lifecycles: A Cross-Framework Analysis (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Digital health development is often fragmented, with intervention- and innovation-oriented approaches applied interchangeably despite distinct goals and evaluation criteria. This misalignment can result in limited user engagement, premature scale-up, and implementation failure. Existing frameworks offer guidance, but vary widely in scope, terminology, and purpose. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to develop a harmonized lifecycle structure that supports alignment across digital health frameworks and stakeholder needs. METHODS We conducted a multi-step analysis integrating a rapid review and comparative framework analysis. Relevant influential digital health frameworks were selected based on defined inclusion criteria. We analyzed each framework’s structure, assumptions, and use cases through structured coding informed by implementation science, innovation management, and human-centered design. A grounded, iterative process of constant comparison and thematic abstraction was used to identify shared lifecycle functions and align conceptual elements. RESULTS The study generated four key outcomes: (1) a structured map of conceptually diverse digital health frameworks; (2) a positioning of these frameworks along an intervention–innovation continuum based on their input and output logic; (3) a neutral set of cross-cutting lifecycle functions enabling structured comparison across frameworks; and (4) a practical roadmap that integrates these elements to guide alignment between development efforts and system readiness. The frameworks were grouped into three structural types – development-process models, readiness/maturity models, and macro-level transition models – each addressing different lifecycle functions. Their combined alignment revealed complementary roles in supporting the design, evaluation, scale-up, and systemic adoption of digital health solutions. CONCLUSIONS This study offers a transdisciplinary structure that clarifies the contributions of existing digital health frameworks and enables their coordinated use. By introducing neutral lifecycle functions and a practical mapping tool, the work supports researchers, developers, and policymakers in selecting and sequencing frameworks aligned with their goals and contexts. The results promote coherence, evidence-informed decision-making, and more sustainable digital health implementation.
- Open Access
- 5 March 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR mHealth and uHealth
- Vol. 14, e82412
Evaluation of Smartphone Camera Positioning on Artificial Intelligence Pose Estimation Accuracy for Exercise Detection: Observational Study
Background: Artificial intelligence (AI)–driven pose estimation (PE) offers a scalable and cost-effective solution to track exercises in mobile health apps. However, occlusion, influenced by camera angle and distance, can reduce detection accuracy and repetition counting precision. The influence of smartphone positioning on these performance metrics remains underexplored in controlled studies. Objective: The study aimed to examine how smartphone camera angle (front, side, and diagonal) and distance (90 cm, 180 cm, 200 cm, and 360 cm) affect detection performance and repetition counting accuracy during push-ups and squats using AI-based PE. Methods: In this cross-sectional, within-subject study, 44 healthy university students (9 [20.5%] female participants; mean age 20.3 y, SD 0.4 y; mean BMI 23.2, SD 0.6 kg/m²) were assigned to perform either squats or push-ups. Each participant completed their assigned exercise across 12 predefined smartphone camera configurations, yielding approximately 264 squat trials (n=22) and 264 push-up trials (n=22). Each trial consisted of an average of 5 repetitions, totaling approximately 1320 repetitions per exercise. PE performance was assessed using binary classification accuracy, detection rate, and mean absolute error (MAE) for repetition counting. Generalized linear mixed-effects models evaluated classification odds, linear mixed-effects models analyzed MAE, and Tukey-adjusted post hoc tests followed significant effects. Results: The mean detection rate was 61.1% (SD 48.8%) for push-ups and 61.5% (SD 48.7%) for squats, with MAEs of 1.08 (SD 1.78) and 1.11 (SD 1.82) repetitions, respectively. Push-ups were most accurately detected from diagonal views at 90 to 180 cm (up to 85.7% detection; MAE=0.28) and least accurately from the front at 360 cm (20%; MAE=2.70). Squats performed best from a diagonal view at 200 cm (95.5%; MAE=0.05) and worst from the side at 90 cm (0%; MAE=5). Generalized linear mixed models showed that for push-ups, the front 90 cm and diagonal 360 cm views significantly reduced classification odds compared to the side 90 cm view ( P =.03 and P =.04, respectively), whereas for squats, diagonal and front views significantly outperformed side views across all distances ( P <.001). Post hoc tests confirmed that for push-ups, diagonal close or mid-range views had significantly lower MAEs than far front views, and for squats, diagonal and front views at 180 to 200 cm achieved the highest accuracy and lowest MAEs ( P <.05). Conclusions: AI-based PE effectiveness for exercise tracking is significantly affected by smartphone positioning. Diagonal and frontal views at mid-range distances (180‐200 cm) provided the highest detection accuracy and counting precision. These findings offer actionable guidance for developers, clinicians, coaches, and users optimizing mobile health exercise monitoring.
- 5 March 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR mHealth and uHealth
- Vol. 14, e82412
Open AccessEvaluation of Smartphone Camera Positioning on Artificial Intelligence Pose Estimation Accuracy for Exercise Detection: Observational Study
Background: Artificial intelligence (AI)–driven pose estimation (PE) offers a scalable and cost-effective solution to track exercises in mobile health apps. However, occlusion, influenced by camera angle and distance, can reduce detection accuracy and repetition counting precision. The influence of smartphone positioning on these performance metrics remains underexplored in controlled studies. Objective: The study aimed to examine how smartphone camera angle (front, side, and diagonal) and distance (90 cm, 180 cm, 200 cm, and 360 cm) affect detection performance and repetition counting accuracy during push-ups and squats using AI-based PE. Methods: In this cross-sectional, within-subject study, 44 healthy university students (9 [20.5%] female participants; mean age 20.3 y, SD 0.4 y; mean BMI 23.2, SD 0.6 kg/m²) were assigned to perform either squats or push-ups. Each participant completed their assigned exercise across 12 predefined smartphone camera configurations, yielding approximately 264 squat trials (n=22) and 264 push-up trials (n=22). Each trial consisted of an average of 5 repetitions, totaling approximately 1320 repetitions per exercise. PE performance was assessed using binary classification accuracy, detection rate, and mean absolute error (MAE) for repetition counting. Generalized linear mixed-effects models evaluated classification odds, linear mixed-effects models analyzed MAE, and Tukey-adjusted post hoc tests followed significant effects. Results: The mean detection rate was 61.1% (SD 48.8%) for push-ups and 61.5% (SD 48.7%) for squats, with MAEs of 1.08 (SD 1.78) and 1.11 (SD 1.82) repetitions, respectively. Push-ups were most accurately detected from diagonal views at 90 to 180 cm (up to 85.7% detection; MAE=0.28) and least accurately from the front at 360 cm (20%; MAE=2.70). Squats performed best from a diagonal view at 200 cm (95.5%; MAE=0.05) and worst from the side at 90 cm (0%; MAE=5). Generalized linear mixed models showed that for push-ups, the front 90 cm and diagonal 360 cm views significantly reduced classification odds compared to the side 90 cm view ( P =.03 and P =.04, respectively), whereas for squats, diagonal and front views significantly outperformed side views across all distances ( P <.001). Post hoc tests confirmed that for push-ups, diagonal close or mid-range views had significantly lower MAEs than far front views, and for squats, diagonal and front views at 180 to 200 cm achieved the highest accuracy and lowest MAEs ( P <.05). Conclusions: AI-based PE effectiveness for exercise tracking is significantly affected by smartphone positioning. Diagonal and frontal views at mid-range distances (180‐200 cm) provided the highest detection accuracy and counting precision. These findings offer actionable guidance for developers, clinicians, coaches, and users optimizing mobile health exercise monitoring.
- 2 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 157-171
Using Open-Source Hardware for Enhancing Lean Entrepreneurship
- 2 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 157-171
Using Open-Source Hardware for Enhancing Lean Entrepreneurship
- Open Access
- 14 August 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Evaluation of Smartphone Camera Positioning on Artificial Intelligence Pose Estimation Accuracy for Exercise Detection (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Artificial Intelligence (AI)-driven pose estimation offers a scalable and cost-effective solution to track exercises in mobile health (mHealth) applications. However, occlusion, influenced by camera angle and distance, can reduce detection accuracy and repetition counting precision. The influence of smartphone positioning on these performance metrics remains underexplored in controlled studies. OBJECTIVE To examine how smartphone camera angle (front, side, and diagonal) and distance (90 cm, 180 cm, 200 cm, and 360 cm) affect detection performance and repetition counting accuracy during push-ups and squats using AI-based pose estimation. METHODS In this cross-sectional, within-subject study, 44 healthy university students (nine female [20.5%]; mean age 20.3 ± 0.4 years; mean BMI 23.2 ± 0.6 kg/m²) were assigned to perform either squats or push-ups. Each participant completed their assigned exercise across 12 predefined smartphone camera configurations, yielding ~264 squat trials (n=22) and 264 push-up trials (n=22). Each trial averaged five repetitions, totaling ~1,320 repetitions per exercise. Pose estimation performance was assessed using binary classification accuracy, detection rate, and mean absolute error (MAE) for repetition counting. Generalized linear mixed-effects models (GLMMs) evaluated classification odds, linear mixed-effects models (LMMs) analyzed MAE, and Tukey-adjusted post hoc tests followed significant effects. RESULTS The mean detection rate was 61.1% (SD 48.8%) for push-ups and 61.5% (SD 48.7%) for squats, with MAEs of 1.08 (SD 1.78) and 1.11 (SD 1.82) repetitions, respectively. Push-ups were most accurately detected from diagonal views at 90–180 cm (up to 85.7% detection; MAE = 0.28) and least accurately from the front at 360 cm (20.0%; MAE = 2.70). Squats performed best from a diagonal view at 200 cm (95.5%; MAE = 0.05) and worst from the side at 90 cm (0.0%; MAE = 5.00). GLMMs showed that for push-ups, the front 90 cm and diagonal 360 cm views significantly reduced classification odds compared to the side 90 cm view (p = 0.032 and p = 0.040, respectively), whereas for squats, diagonal and front views significantly outperformed side views across all distances (p < .001). Post hoc tests confirmed that for push-ups, diagonal close/mid-range views had significantly lower MAEs than far front views, and for squats, diagonal and front views at 180-200 cm achieved the highest accuracy and lowest MAEs (p < .05). CONCLUSIONS AI-based pose estimation effectiveness for exercise tracking is significantly affected by smartphone positioning. Diagonal and frontal views at mid-range distances (180–200 cm) provided the highest detection accuracy and counting precision. These findings offer actionable guidance for developers, clinicians, coaches, and users optimizing mHealth exercise monitoring.
- 14 August 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessEvaluation of Smartphone Camera Positioning on Artificial Intelligence Pose Estimation Accuracy for Exercise Detection (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Artificial Intelligence (AI)-driven pose estimation offers a scalable and cost-effective solution to track exercises in mobile health (mHealth) applications. However, occlusion, influenced by camera angle and distance, can reduce detection accuracy and repetition counting precision. The influence of smartphone positioning on these performance metrics remains underexplored in controlled studies. OBJECTIVE To examine how smartphone camera angle (front, side, and diagonal) and distance (90 cm, 180 cm, 200 cm, and 360 cm) affect detection performance and repetition counting accuracy during push-ups and squats using AI-based pose estimation. METHODS In this cross-sectional, within-subject study, 44 healthy university students (nine female [20.5%]; mean age 20.3 ± 0.4 years; mean BMI 23.2 ± 0.6 kg/m²) were assigned to perform either squats or push-ups. Each participant completed their assigned exercise across 12 predefined smartphone camera configurations, yielding ~264 squat trials (n=22) and 264 push-up trials (n=22). Each trial averaged five repetitions, totaling ~1,320 repetitions per exercise. Pose estimation performance was assessed using binary classification accuracy, detection rate, and mean absolute error (MAE) for repetition counting. Generalized linear mixed-effects models (GLMMs) evaluated classification odds, linear mixed-effects models (LMMs) analyzed MAE, and Tukey-adjusted post hoc tests followed significant effects. RESULTS The mean detection rate was 61.1% (SD 48.8%) for push-ups and 61.5% (SD 48.7%) for squats, with MAEs of 1.08 (SD 1.78) and 1.11 (SD 1.82) repetitions, respectively. Push-ups were most accurately detected from diagonal views at 90–180 cm (up to 85.7% detection; MAE = 0.28) and least accurately from the front at 360 cm (20.0%; MAE = 2.70). Squats performed best from a diagonal view at 200 cm (95.5%; MAE = 0.05) and worst from the side at 90 cm (0.0%; MAE = 5.00). GLMMs showed that for push-ups, the front 90 cm and diagonal 360 cm views significantly reduced classification odds compared to the side 90 cm view (p = 0.032 and p = 0.040, respectively), whereas for squats, diagonal and front views significantly outperformed side views across all distances (p < .001). Post hoc tests confirmed that for push-ups, diagonal close/mid-range views had significantly lower MAEs than far front views, and for squats, diagonal and front views at 180-200 cm achieved the highest accuracy and lowest MAEs (p < .05). CONCLUSIONS AI-based pose estimation effectiveness for exercise tracking is significantly affected by smartphone positioning. Diagonal and frontal views at mid-range distances (180–200 cm) provided the highest detection accuracy and counting precision. These findings offer actionable guidance for developers, clinicians, coaches, and users optimizing mHealth exercise monitoring.
- Open Access
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research in Health Services & Regions
- Vol. 2 (1) , 1-11
Initial steps for the Portuguese Atlas of geographical variation in healthcare
Non-clinical aspects contribute to differences in healthcare practices within each country, which may imply that some patients do not receive the care they need. In contrast, others may not benefit from the care that they receive. However, to the authors’ knowledge, only a few geographical variation studies with a national scope were recently conducted in Portugal. This study aimed to test if it was possible to conduct a geographical variation analysis in Portugal using publicly available data to compare the 18 districts and stimulate a debate around this topic. To achieve this goal, we first investigated the publicly available Portuguese National Health Service database (Transparency Portal) for data from activities and procedures that could be included in this analysis. Four were included: percentage of cesarian sections in total births, rate of hip surgeries within the first 48 h after admission in patients older than 65, rate of consumed antibiotics in the total drugs consumed, and percentage of elective surgeries. After retrieving the data, we mapped the results and computed the ratio of variation and the coefficient of variation. Finally, we discussed the results with medical doctors, public health researchers, and health economists. Results suggested geographical variation mainly in the rate of hip surgeries performed 48 h after admission (from 18.53% to 83.64%). Overall, the results highlighted the need for a national benchmarking system to span this analysis to other activities and initiate a broader discussion with patients, clinicians, providers, and policymakers.
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research in Health Services & Regions
- Vol. 2 (1) , 1-11
Open AccessInitial steps for the Portuguese Atlas of geographical variation in healthcare
Non-clinical aspects contribute to differences in healthcare practices within each country, which may imply that some patients do not receive the care they need. In contrast, others may not benefit from the care that they receive. However, to the authors’ knowledge, only a few geographical variation studies with a national scope were recently conducted in Portugal. This study aimed to test if it was possible to conduct a geographical variation analysis in Portugal using publicly available data to compare the 18 districts and stimulate a debate around this topic. To achieve this goal, we first investigated the publicly available Portuguese National Health Service database (Transparency Portal) for data from activities and procedures that could be included in this analysis. Four were included: percentage of cesarian sections in total births, rate of hip surgeries within the first 48 h after admission in patients older than 65, rate of consumed antibiotics in the total drugs consumed, and percentage of elective surgeries. After retrieving the data, we mapped the results and computed the ratio of variation and the coefficient of variation. Finally, we discussed the results with medical doctors, public health researchers, and health economists. Results suggested geographical variation mainly in the rate of hip surgeries performed 48 h after admission (from 18.53% to 83.64%). Overall, the results highlighted the need for a national benchmarking system to span this analysis to other activities and initiate a broader discussion with patients, clinicians, providers, and policymakers.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Design Journal
- Vol. 25 (6) , 997-1018
Navigating the tensions of integrating lived experience in participatory healthcare design
Despite growing interest in participatory approaches to healthcare design, the integration of people’s lived experience—direct, first-hand understanding of a certain condition, situation, or identity—remains a key challenge to meaningful participation. Through an interview study with 23 patients, designers, family caregivers, and healthcare professionals involved in participatory healthcare design initiatives, the authors identify underlying tensions associated with leveraging lived experiences in healthcare design and investigate how existing strategies for integrating lived experience relate to these tensions. In doing so, this research offers insights for practitioners regarding ways of strategically navigating tensions when integrating people’s lived experience through design in complex healthcare contexts.
- 1 September 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Design Journal
- Vol. 25 (6) , 997-1018
Open AccessNavigating the tensions of integrating lived experience in participatory healthcare design
Despite growing interest in participatory approaches to healthcare design, the integration of people’s lived experience—direct, first-hand understanding of a certain condition, situation, or identity—remains a key challenge to meaningful participation. Through an interview study with 23 patients, designers, family caregivers, and healthcare professionals involved in participatory healthcare design initiatives, the authors identify underlying tensions associated with leveraging lived experiences in healthcare design and investigate how existing strategies for integrating lived experience relate to these tensions. In doing so, this research offers insights for practitioners regarding ways of strategically navigating tensions when integrating people’s lived experience through design in complex healthcare contexts.
- Open Access
- 19 August 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR mHealth and uHealth
- Vol. 9 (8) , e29381
Domains and Methods Used to Assess Home Telemonitoring Scalability: Systematic Review
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic catalyzed the adoption of home telemonitoring to cope with social distancing challenges. Recent research on home telemonitoring demonstrated benefits concerning the capacity, patient empowerment, and treatment commitment of health care systems. Moreover, for some diseases, it revealed significant improvement in clinical outcomes. Nevertheless, when policy makers and practitioners decide whether to scale-up a technology-based health intervention from a research study to mainstream care delivery, it is essential to assess other relevant domains, such as its feasibility to be expanded under real-world conditions. Therefore, scalability assessment is critical, and it encompasses multiple domains to ensure population-wide access to the benefits of the growing technological potential for home telemonitoring services in health care. Objective: This systematic review aims to identify the domains and methods used in peer-reviewed research studies that assess the scalability of home telemonitoring–based interventions under real-world conditions. Methods: The authors followed the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis) guidelines and used multiple databases (PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and EconLit). An integrative synthesis of the eligible studies was conducted to better explore each intervention and summarize relevant information concerning the target audience, intervention duration and setting, and type of technology. Each study design was classified based on the strength of its evidence. Lastly, the authors conducted narrative and thematic analyses to identify the domains, and qualitative and quantitative methods used to support scalability assessment. Results: This review evaluated 13 articles focusing on the potential of scaling up a home telemonitoring intervention. Most of the studies considered the following domains relevant for scalability assessment: problem (13), intervention (12), effectiveness (13), and costs and benefits (10). Although cost-effectiveness was the most common evaluation method, the authors identified seven additional cost analysis methods to evaluate the costs. Other domains were less considered, such as the sociopolitical context (2), workforce (4), and technological infrastructure (3). Researchers used different methodological approaches to assess the effectiveness, costs and benefits, fidelity, and acceptability. Conclusions: This systematic review suggests that when assessing scalability, researchers select the domains specifically related to the intervention while ignoring others related to the contextual, technological, and environmental factors, which are also relevant. Additionally, studies report using different methods to evaluate the same domain, which makes comparison difficult. Future work should address research on the minimum required domains to assess the scalability of remote telemonitoring services and suggest methods that allow comparison among studies to provide better support to decision makers during large-scale implementation.
- 19 August 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR mHealth and uHealth
- Vol. 9 (8) , e29381
Open AccessDomains and Methods Used to Assess Home Telemonitoring Scalability: Systematic Review
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic catalyzed the adoption of home telemonitoring to cope with social distancing challenges. Recent research on home telemonitoring demonstrated benefits concerning the capacity, patient empowerment, and treatment commitment of health care systems. Moreover, for some diseases, it revealed significant improvement in clinical outcomes. Nevertheless, when policy makers and practitioners decide whether to scale-up a technology-based health intervention from a research study to mainstream care delivery, it is essential to assess other relevant domains, such as its feasibility to be expanded under real-world conditions. Therefore, scalability assessment is critical, and it encompasses multiple domains to ensure population-wide access to the benefits of the growing technological potential for home telemonitoring services in health care. Objective: This systematic review aims to identify the domains and methods used in peer-reviewed research studies that assess the scalability of home telemonitoring–based interventions under real-world conditions. Methods: The authors followed the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis) guidelines and used multiple databases (PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and EconLit). An integrative synthesis of the eligible studies was conducted to better explore each intervention and summarize relevant information concerning the target audience, intervention duration and setting, and type of technology. Each study design was classified based on the strength of its evidence. Lastly, the authors conducted narrative and thematic analyses to identify the domains, and qualitative and quantitative methods used to support scalability assessment. Results: This review evaluated 13 articles focusing on the potential of scaling up a home telemonitoring intervention. Most of the studies considered the following domains relevant for scalability assessment: problem (13), intervention (12), effectiveness (13), and costs and benefits (10). Although cost-effectiveness was the most common evaluation method, the authors identified seven additional cost analysis methods to evaluate the costs. Other domains were less considered, such as the sociopolitical context (2), workforce (4), and technological infrastructure (3). Researchers used different methodological approaches to assess the effectiveness, costs and benefits, fidelity, and acceptability. Conclusions: This systematic review suggests that when assessing scalability, researchers select the domains specifically related to the intervention while ignoring others related to the contextual, technological, and environmental factors, which are also relevant. Additionally, studies report using different methods to evaluate the same domain, which makes comparison difficult. Future work should address research on the minimum required domains to assess the scalability of remote telemonitoring services and suggest methods that allow comparison among studies to provide better support to decision makers during large-scale implementation.
- Open Access
- 16 April 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
A patient-centered digital cost simulator based on Time-Driven Based-Activity Costing: a proof-of-concept study of knee replacement in two private Portuguese hospitals (Preprint)
BACKGROUND The number of knee replacement surgeries in OECD countries will continue rising due to the prevalence of osteoarthritis caused by aging and obesity. It is a cost-effective but expensive procedure. Consequently, decision-makers need accurate information on intervention outcomes and costs to manage the healthcare system efficiently. Literature proposed Time-Driven Based-Activity Costing (TDABC) as a cost measurement model that accounts for care cycle complexity, such as patient diversity and treatment variation. However, few studies show how to apply the TDABC model in a real context, considering the existing hospitals' information systems (IS). OBJECTIVE Our primary goal was to design a patient-centered digital cost simulator for assessing the provider's cost of care delivery that complemented the outcomes analysis in Knee Surgery. The secondary goal was to synthesize the learning experience of implementing the method in two Portuguese private hospitals of the same provider. METHODS The proof-of-concept study was designed based on the TDABC model. As the two hospitals had different care delivery chains for the same procedure, each hospital's study was independent. The unit cost of supplying capacity was calculated using data collected from interviews, literature reviews, and general ledger accounts. Both care delivery chains were defined using information from interviews with hospital staff and mapped using Visual Paradigm©. Time estimations were based on direct observation and data exported from hospitals' IS. The patient-centered digital cost simulator was created using Google Sheets. Through a focus group, the multidisciplinary team evaluated the model feasibility and generalisability. RESULTS A patient-centered digital cost simulator and the data structure that allows collecting the most relevant cost analysis data are presented. The main lessons learned are described through this paper and are based on practical application: (1) the patient journey must drive data collection, organization, and analysis for the TDABC implementation; (2) the implementation of TDABC in healthcare involves the commitment and dedication of the healthcare provider's teams; (3) breaking the activities into operations helps to obtain time estimations and allocate resources in the patient care pathway; (4) the listing of the used resources should follow the financial IS classification. CONCLUSIONS The simulator that was developed is still a proof-of-concept, but it enlightened the healthcare provider of future improvements in the existing IS infrastructure. The TDABC implementation requires that the hospitals' IS collect and interoperate different data sources (clinical, financial, and logistics) along the patient pathway. Therefore, future research should focus on developing effective and efficient interfaces to allow importing process, activity, resources, and time information from the existing IS and calculate the total costs of care per patient. Such data needs to be integrated with health outcomes measures in order to monitor healthcare interventions' value.
- 16 April 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessA patient-centered digital cost simulator based on Time-Driven Based-Activity Costing: a proof-of-concept study of knee replacement in two private Portuguese hospitals (Preprint)
BACKGROUND The number of knee replacement surgeries in OECD countries will continue rising due to the prevalence of osteoarthritis caused by aging and obesity. It is a cost-effective but expensive procedure. Consequently, decision-makers need accurate information on intervention outcomes and costs to manage the healthcare system efficiently. Literature proposed Time-Driven Based-Activity Costing (TDABC) as a cost measurement model that accounts for care cycle complexity, such as patient diversity and treatment variation. However, few studies show how to apply the TDABC model in a real context, considering the existing hospitals' information systems (IS). OBJECTIVE Our primary goal was to design a patient-centered digital cost simulator for assessing the provider's cost of care delivery that complemented the outcomes analysis in Knee Surgery. The secondary goal was to synthesize the learning experience of implementing the method in two Portuguese private hospitals of the same provider. METHODS The proof-of-concept study was designed based on the TDABC model. As the two hospitals had different care delivery chains for the same procedure, each hospital's study was independent. The unit cost of supplying capacity was calculated using data collected from interviews, literature reviews, and general ledger accounts. Both care delivery chains were defined using information from interviews with hospital staff and mapped using Visual Paradigm©. Time estimations were based on direct observation and data exported from hospitals' IS. The patient-centered digital cost simulator was created using Google Sheets. Through a focus group, the multidisciplinary team evaluated the model feasibility and generalisability. RESULTS A patient-centered digital cost simulator and the data structure that allows collecting the most relevant cost analysis data are presented. The main lessons learned are described through this paper and are based on practical application: (1) the patient journey must drive data collection, organization, and analysis for the TDABC implementation; (2) the implementation of TDABC in healthcare involves the commitment and dedication of the healthcare provider's teams; (3) breaking the activities into operations helps to obtain time estimations and allocate resources in the patient care pathway; (4) the listing of the used resources should follow the financial IS classification. CONCLUSIONS The simulator that was developed is still a proof-of-concept, but it enlightened the healthcare provider of future improvements in the existing IS infrastructure. The TDABC implementation requires that the hospitals' IS collect and interoperate different data sources (clinical, financial, and logistics) along the patient pathway. Therefore, future research should focus on developing effective and efficient interfaces to allow importing process, activity, resources, and time information from the existing IS and calculate the total costs of care per patient. Such data needs to be integrated with health outcomes measures in order to monitor healthcare interventions' value.