PBPauline Brémond

Pauline Brémond

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Pauline Brémond has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Caractérisation et évaluation économique de la vulnérabilité des exploitations agricoles aux inondations

    by Pauline Bremond

    L'échec des politiques structurelles de gestion des inondations à réduire les dommages a orienté les décideurs publics vers la restauration de zones de rétention et la réduction de la vulnérabilité. L'évaluation économique de ces politiques requiert une évaluation fine des dommages agricoles car ils contribuent fortement à déterminer leur efficacité. Or, les méthodes existantes n'intègrent que les pertes de récolte. Considérant que la vulnérabilité des exploitations agricoles dépend de la sensibilité et de la capacité à se remettre en route, entraînant respectivement des dommages directs et induits sur l'activité, nous proposons un modèle conceptuel de vulnérabilité permettant l'évaluation de l'ensemble de ces dommages. Trois profils d'exploitants sont définis selon la possibilité de mobiliser des ressources externes (main d'œuvre et matériel) pour la remise en route. Le profil Interne ne dispose d'aucune ressource externe contrairement aux profils Prestation et Solidarité. Après implémentation, le modèle a permis d'évaluer les dommages de trois exploitations types sur le Rhône aval avec une valorisation financière puis économique. Les dommages supportés par les exploitants de profil Interne sont plus élevés que ceux des deux autres profils. Les dommages évités par la mise en place de mesures de réduction de la vulnérabilité sur ces trois exploitations sont ensuite évalués. Nous montrons que les mesures sont plus efficaces et peuvent être mises en œuvre avec un ratio bénéfice-coût supérieur à un, pour les exploitations fréquemment inondées. Elles sont également plus efficaces pour les profils Interne, la mise en œuvre de la solidarité se dégageant comme une mesure intéressante pour toutes les exploitations.

  • Open Access

    Effects of flood‐induced financial stress on the viability of a cooperative production system and its farmers: A multilevel study

    by David Nortes Martínez, Frédéric Grelot, Pauline Brémond, Stefano Farolfi, Juliette Rouchier

    Floods can severely disrupt agricultural activities. When these activities are part of production chains, domino effects can occur. We use agent‐based modeling to simulate the production dynamics of a French cooperative winery as an example of a production chain, adopting a dual individual‐collective perspective. The cash‐flow analysis shows that there are nonexplicit mechanisms in the cooperative organization that allow the propagation of flood impacts throughout the chain and influence the winegrowers' ability to cope, thus threatening the continuity of the winegrowers' activity and the cooperative winery itself.

  • Open Access

    Impacts of successive climatic events on a wine cooperative system

    by Pauline Bremond, Frédéric Grelot, Maxime Modjeska, David Nortes Martinez, Justine Panégos

    The analysis of impacts of climatic events on socioeconomic systems is based on the collection of post-event data. However, this method rarely describes the processes and the decisions that generated the impacts. Yet, counting on thorough descriptions of those processes and decisions, although very time-consuming, takes on its full meaning when several climatic phenomena follow one another on complex economic systems. In the Mediterranean context, and moreover in the context of climate change, it is not uncommon for several climatic hazards to follow one another. For agricultural activities, whose harvests and thus added value are produced over several months, this implies that a production campaign can be affected by different events (e.g. frost, hail, drought, flooding, etc.), causing the strategy of the various actors involved to be readjusted. We propose to address the problem of the analysis of the succession of two climatic events for the estimation of the impacts on a complex economic system through the case study of a wine cooperative located in the department of Aude in the South-West of France which was affected during the 2021 production campaign by a frost in March and a flood in September at the time of the harvest. We are interested in three questions: (i) are there impacts resulting specifically from the succession of both climatic events?; (ii) are there impacts resulting from the organisational links between the winegrowers (individual level) and the wine-making cooperative (collective level)?; (iii) which indicators are relevant to highlight them? In our case study, the cooperative winery brings together 128 winegrowers representing 1100 ha and has three vinification sites. 65 winegrowers out of the 128 were impacted by at least one of the events. To analyse the impacts of both events on the cooperative, we carried out a questionnaire-type survey among the affected winegrowers. We obtained 57 responses to the preliminary questionnaire and 33 exhaustive interviews. Three interviews were also conducted with the managers in charge of the winery during this campaign. After an initial analysis of the results, we presented and discussed these results with the representatives and some of the winegrowers surveyed. The consolidation of the analyses is still in progress. However, this work already shows that there are cross-effects resulting from the succession of both events. For instance, our surveys enable us to discern the loss of quality or yield due to biophysical processes (e.g. frost, berries' rotting or bursting) from loss of quality due to organizational impacts at the winegrower level (e.g. inaccessibility of the plots at the time of harvesting due to flooding that aggravates the loss of quality). We also show that the succession of events generated specific impacts linked to collective readjustment decisions taken at the winery level. We will discuss the scope of this analysis and the interest of this approach to consider possible adaptations to be implemented.

  • Open Access

    Urbanisation in flood-prone areas, hydraulic infrastructures and economic evaluation

    by Frédéric Grelot, David Nortes Martinez, Pauline Brémond

    Following the example of pioneering countries (UK, USA in particular), since 2010, in France, local managers have been required to justify the efficiency of hydraulic infrastructure projects (dyke, dam, etc.) for flood prevention in order to claim subsidies granted by the State. The efficiency assessment must be carried out according to a cost-benefit analysis (CBA) respecting the State's guidelines. Among these guidelines, it is requested to estimate the impact of the project in terms of monetised flood damage, i.e. as the difference in mean annualised damage between the reference situation and the situation with the project. This guideline has led to many advances in French flood damage modelling practice.  The French government also requires that a so-called "constant land use" assumption be made. In concrete terms, this means estimating damage by considering that the land use remains "frozen" in the state it is in at the time of the study. This assumption greatly facilitates the implementation of the method, as it makes it unnecessary to make projections on the evolution of land use, either in the reference situation or in the project situation. The main reason for this recommendation is not the latter, but that the State considers that anticipating changes in land use as a result of the project would be contrary to the policy of regulating land use in flood-prone areas that it has been pursuing since the early 1980s. At the same time, the French government is pursuing a policy to encourage territories not to rely entirely on hydraulic infrastructures, by promoting so-called integrated flood management projects (combining crisis management, control of land use and adaptation of existing stakes). In practice, the "constant land use" assumption is not verified, even less so on the time scale of the economic evaluation. It is very common that the installation of a hydraulic infrastructure is associated with an intensification of urbanisation in the newly protected area, less so with a disuse of the area. The objective of our work is to show how relaxing the "constant land use" assumption in the economic evaluation based on the estimation of flood damages can, contrary to the fears expressed by the French State, allow to better clarify the irrelevance of focusing exclusively on structural solutions, without questioning the interest of controlling the use of flood-prone areas. To this end, we show how to relax this assumption in practice within the framework of a CBA. Then, using actual, real projects from a database of about 200 CBAs carried out to obtain subsidies over the last 10 years, we analyse the influence of the "constant land use" assumption on the estimation of the efficiency of projects. In perspective, we argue that relaxing this assumption could also allow to enter a virtuous circle of knowledge production by encouraging the consolidation of the understanding of the co-evolution of urbanisation and hydraulic infrastructures.

    • 1 January 2023
    • Published by HAL in HAL
    Open Access

    Why the Capacity to Recover Matters in Assessing Farm Vulnerability to Flooding: A Modelling Approach at Farm Level, Ava Model

    by Pauline Bremond, Frédéric Grelot

    Vulnerability to climate hazards has two components: sensitivity and capacity to recover. While sensitivity is related to biophysical phenomena, recovery requires modelling the functioning of the system and the interactions between internal and external resources. The Agricultural Vulnerability Assessment (AVA) model takes both components into account to provide a monetary assessment of the vulnerability of farms to flooding. Applied to the Rhône Valley, we show that the damage suffered by farmers is highly dependent on access to external resources. Even outside the harvest period, flood scenarios can cause damage to farms that jeopardises their financial viability if they cannot rely on solidarity. The financial situation of farms can be threatened even during crop dormancy. This has important operational implications for flood management policies that inundate farmland and encourages greater attention to be paid to farm vulnerability assessments.

  • Open Access

    Process-based flood damage modelling relying on expert knowledge: a methodological contribution applied to the agricultural sector

    by Pauline Brémond, Anne-Laurence Agenais, Frédéric Grelot, Claire Richert

    Flood damage assessment is crucial for evaluating flood management policies. In particular, properly assessing damage to agricultural assets is important because they are complex economic systems particularly exposed to floods. The modelling approaches used to assess flood damage are of several types and can be fed by damage data collected post-flood, from experiments or based on expert knowledge. The process-based models fed by expert knowledge are the subject of research and also widely used in an operational way. Although identified as potentially transferable, they are in reality often case-specific and difficult to reuse in time (updatability) and space (transferability). In this paper, we argue that process-based models, based on a rigorous modelling process, can be suitable for application in different contexts. We propose a methodological framework aimed at verifying the conditions necessary to develop these models in a spirit of capitalisation by relying on four axes which are (i) the explicitation of assumptions, (ii) the validation, (iii) the updatability, (iv) the transferability. The methodological framework is then applied to the model we have developed in France to produce national damage functions for the agricultural sector. We show in this paper that the proposed methodological framework facilitates an explicit description of the modelling assumptions and data used, which is necessary to consider for a reuse in time or for transfer to another geographical area. In this sense, this methodological framework constitutes a solid basis for considering the validation, transfer, comparison and capitalisation of data collected around models based on processes relying on expert knowledge. In conclusion, we identify research tracks to be implemented so as to pursue this improvement in a spirit of capitalisation and international cooperation.


  • Open Access

    Contribution of a systematic and long-term observation method to improve the understanding of flood impacts 

    by Pauline Bremond, Pierre Balzergue, Frédéric Grelot, Valériane Marry, Maxime Modjeska, David Nortes Martinez

    Floods are the natural hazard that generates the most damage in the world, but many aspects of how this damage occurs are still poorly understood. Indeed, the impacts of floods can concern all types of stakes (dwellings, economic or agricultural activities, public infrastructures, networks, etc.), whether they are directly impacted by the flood or indirectly by the propagation of disturbances through society, or even in a temporal delay compared to the original event. Moreover, these impacts may differ according to the nature of the flood (e.g. overflow, runoff, salt water flooding). Finally, the impacts are the result of complex biophysical processes but also of protection, repair and adaptation actions implemented by affected people.Our objective is to highlight the diversity of flood impacts, including the issue of their persistence. To this end, we propose an original method that combines post-flood observation surveys with long-term monitoring of individuals exposed to floods. This methodology is implemented in the framework of the system of observations of the impacts of floods (so-ii, http://so-ii.org) in the Greater Montpellier area coordinated by our team. For the quantitative surveys, based on our past observation and modelling experiences, we have developed questionnaires that aim to collect the impacts of flooding, following an event, in an exhaustive and cumulative manner.These questionnaires were applied following a flood event that occurred on September 20th 2020 in the north of Montpellier. For long-term monitoring, we set up networks of impact observers (inhabitants and farmers for the moment), with whom we agreed to work over the long term (about fifteen years).With these groups, we have defined an observation protocol, combining individual interviews to better specify each person's situation (e.g. individual vulnerability, characteristics of buildings) with participatory workshops to discuss the results, orient future work, and pool each person's experiences. In this paper we present the intermediate results of this ongoing research. We also discuss the relevance and limitations of such an approach to improve the understanding and assessment of flood damage.

  • Open Access

    How does a hidden profession reveal hidden processes and what are the implications for flood damage assessment?

    by Pauline Brémond, Guillaume Bouche, Anne Laure Collard, Frédéric Grelot, Reine Tarrit

    Flood economic damage results from complex phenomena involving biophysical processes that determine the damage of the components but also the decisions taken for reconstruction. The method most frequently used to estimate damage is based on the assumption that the property will be restored to its original condition. This method is supported by expert knowledge of damage processes and restoration costs. However, in practice, we wonder about the implementation by individuals of this identical restoration at a time when the build back better is an injunction that is found in many institutional discourses. In France, insurance experts are mandated by insurance companies within the framework of the cat-nat insurance process to ascertain and evaluate the damage suffered by insured persons following a flood. This experience gives them a privileged place to feed the ex ante damage assessment models. However, although, the experts intervene to establish the damage at the very moment when the dwellings are dealing with reconstruction decisions, this profession remains little studied in the literature. In this study, we tried to determine, on the one hand, to what extent the posture of experts influences the assessment of damage and, on the other hand, what role they play in the process of reconstruction and individual adaptation of housing following a flood. Since 2012, we have met with 15 insurance experts, conducted 20 individual interviews and two intermediate workshops on understanding damage mechanisms and estimating repair costs. This work has enabled us to develop damage functions for different sectors (households and economic activities) which were validated during a participatory workshop with the experts. We will present a critical analysis of this work, focusing on the view of damage held by insurance experts and the underlying assumptions. To complete this analysis, we have carried out additional work specifically on the role of insurance experts in the reconstruction process of households. Through a qualitative field survey in 2021, we met a dozen insurance experts. First, we established the standard expertise process used by the experts. Based on these procedures, we questioned them on how to conduct an expertise. Through narratives, we highlighted the roles that insurance experts actually play with dwellings. In particular, we showed that despite the technical and human skills available to the experts, the issue of reconstruction can only be dealt with informally and remains marginal due to the missions entrusted to the experts by the insurance companies. In conclusion, we will discuss the implication for damage estimation.

  • Open Access

    Methodology for assessing flood damage to farms: observation and modelling

    by Maxime Modjeska, Pauline Brémond, Frédéric Grelot, Laure Hossard, Nina Graveline

    In the context of climate change and growing urbanization, farms are expected to face more frequent extreme events (e.g. heat peaks, droughts, frost, hail or floods). Floods being the natural hazard that generates the most damage in the world, we focus our research on the impact of floods on farms and their adaptation to climate change. Flood damage on farms is the result of complex phenomena involving biophysical processes on the one hand, and farmers' decisions on rehabilitation and adaptation on the other. Some impacts are directly visible; others may be delayed and persist over time (Bremond et al, 2013). When they persist over time, they may impact the development trajectory of farms. For the observation of impacts, there are in fact two challenges: to identify the diversity of impacts and their temporality of occurrence. Field surveys following flood events often focus on short-term damage and on impacts resulting from extreme events, leaving long-term damage and minor events aside. In this paper, we aim to propose a methodology that we are currently implementing to jointly and recursively improve the observation and modelling of flood impacts on agricultural systems. In particular, we wish to define more precisely the diversity of flood impacts and long-term damage on farms by taking into account the development trajectory of farms. To this end, we combine two complementary approaches: observation and modelling. Our work is implemented in the framework of the system of observations of the impacts of floods (so-ii, http://so-ii.org), in the Greater Montpellier area, coordinated by our team. Based on our experience, we have developed diverse methods for both short-term and long-term monitoring such as: surveys, participative workshops, drone pictures, predictive models.  To cover on field-observations, quantitative and qualitative surveys have been carried out over the years on the so-ii territory. Interviews took place both after a flood, to gather quantitative data, and several years after a flood (Bremond et al, 2020), to collect quantitative and qualitative data. In parallel, we are exploring the use of drones to gather pictures of plots from post-flood to several years later in order to understand mechanisms behind the impacts of floods on soil, plant material and adaptations. To reinforce long-term monitoring, we have set up a network of impact observers, on the so-ii territory, with whom we agreed to work over the long-term (about fifteen years). On the other hand, we are working on the use of predictive models to estimate flood damage to farms. For now, 3 models have been developed: floodam.agri (Bremond et al, 2022), R-EVA (Bremond et al, 2012) and COOPER (Nortes Martinez et al, 2021). Each of these models have different application levels (respectively plot, farm and cooperative system) and time-scales which helps for the observation of farm trajectories as a whole. In conclusion, we will discuss the perspectives and limitations of this approach. We will open up on the perspectives to share our methodology so it can be adapted to other territories by stakeholders who are interested in setting up a similar system of observation.

  • Open Access

    Process-based flood damage modelling relying on expert knowledge: a methodological contribution applied to agricultural sector

    by Pauline Brémond, Anne-Laurence Agenais, Frédéric Grelot, Claire Richert

    Flood damage assessment is crucial for evaluating flood management policies. In particular, properly assessing damage to the agricultural assets is important because they may have greater exposure and are complex economic systems. The modelling approaches used to assess flood damage are of several types and can be fed by damage data collected post-flood, from experiments or based on expert knowledge. The process-based models fed by expert knowledge are subject of research and also widely used in an operational way. Although identified as potentially transferable, they are in reality often case-specific and difficult to reuse in time (updatbililty) and space (transferability). In this paper, we argue that process-based models are not doomed to be context specific as far as the modelling process is rigorous. We propose a methodological framework aiming at verifying the conditions necessary to develop these models in a spirit of capitalisation by relying on four axes which are: i/ the explicitation of assumptions, ii/ the validation, iii/ the updatability, iv/ the transferability. The methodological framework is then applied to the model we have developed in France to produce national damage functions for the agricultural sector. We show in this paper that the proposed methodological framework allows an explicit description of the modelling assumptions and data used, which is necessary to consider a reuse in time or a transfer to another geographical area. We also highlight that despite the lack of feedback data on post-flood damages, the proposed methodological framework is a solid basis to consider the validation, transfer, comparison and capitalisation of data collected around process-based models relying on expert knowledge. In conclusion, we identify research tracks to be implemented to pursue this improvement in a spirit of capitalisation and international cooperation.