MGMirta Galesic

Mirta Galesic

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Mirta Galesic has a total of 124 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Combining survey questions with a Bayesian bootstrap method improves election forecasts

    by Henrik Olsson, Wandi Bruine de Bruin, Mirta Galesic, Drazen Prelec

    We present a Bayesian bootstrap method for election forecasting that integrates traditional own-intention questions with wisdom-of-crowds questions, which ask for social-circle expectations and election forecasts. Across the 2018, 2020, and 2024 U.S. elections, wisdom-of-crowds questions consistently outperformed own-intention questions in predicting vote shares. The Bayesian bootstrap combines these questions in a theoretically justified way, assigning weights based on their inferred informational value. The main assumption is that election winner expectations for a given participant are themselves an optimal Bayesian forecast in light of all evidence available to that participant. Social-circle expectations contribute the most to the Bayesian bootstrap forecast, as they reduce demographic biases and capture hidden voter preferences. The method improves forecast accuracy across diverse electoral contexts, offering a principled approach to combining polling questions and suggesting applicability to forecasting other social phenomena.

  • Open Access

    Devaluation underlies gendered US faculty departures across disciplines and institutions

    by Katie Spoon, Joanna Mendy, Maria Martinez, Mirta Galesic, Daniel B Larremore, Aaron Clauset, Lauren A Rivera

    Women faculty experience academia differently from men in many ways, which can lead them to consider leaving their positions. Using a large-scale survey of both current and former tenure-line faculty across nearly all US PhD-granting institutions and 29 disciplines, we investigate which aspects of the academic workplace are (i) most gendered and (ii) most relevant to faculty retention patterns among respondents. Analyzing 6,615 free-text responses reveals that feeling devalued at work, both in formal evaluations and informal interactions, is the topic where women and men’s reported experiences diverge the most when given the opportunity to discuss anything that needed to be different about their jobs—a pattern that holds for nearly 300 institutions and across both STEM and non-STEM fields, and was particularly strong for women of color and tenured women in our sample. This is in contrast to most existing gender-based interventions in academia that target work–life balance. Further, devaluation is the topic most strongly associated with gendered departures among respondents, accounting for the majority of the gender gap in both considering leaving (current faculty) and leaving (former faculty). Finally, illustrative quotations contextualize gender-based devaluation in academia. These results provide new evidence for the long-known gender gap in faculty retention, illuminating how gendered dynamics in the workplace cross disciplines and institutions and relate to gendered decisions to leave academia.

  • Open Access

    Visual Network tool: Individual belief networks from LLM-guided interviews and a visual canvas

    by Victor Poulsen, Peter Steiglechner, Henrik Olsson, Mirta Galesic

    Belief systems are theorized on individual and collective levels, but are typically studied and inferred only at the collective level. We introduce a new tool to measure individual-level belief networks from open-ended conversations, using a visual canvas. This ``Visual Network'' tool addresses several limitations of existing measures and enables fast and scalable measurement of the differences in content and structure of individual networks. Participants complete a semi-structured interview about their beliefs and behaviors on a given issue guided by an LLM, evaluate LLM-extracted statements that summarize the beliefs they have expressed, and construct personal belief networks by creating supporting and conflicting relations between these statements on a visual canvas. We validate the tool in a two-wave study on meat-eating. Participants evaluate the experience positively, and both belief network content and structure show satisfactory reliability across the two measurement points. We also find support for face, concurrent, and criterion validity of the measured individual belief networks. The new ``Visual Network'' tool opens up new empirical possibilities to test theories of belief dynamics and belief change.

  • Open Access

    Heterogeneous, Adaptive Networks of Beliefs

    by Peter Steiglechner, Victor Poulsen, Mirta Galesic, Henrik Olsson

    People's beliefs about social or political issues can change in different ways, even when they encounter the same new information. Some people show compliance through lasting belief change, others show resilience through temporary belief change, and yet others show resistance by not changing their beliefs at all. Existing explanations often focus on belief content, evidence, motivation, personality, or social influence. We introduce Adaptive Networks of Beliefs, a theory describing how beliefs and belief relations co-evolve through internal and social adaptation. Internal adaptation changes belief relations based on the individual's belief changes. Social adaptation aligns belief relations across individuals. Simulations show that internal adaptation generates heterogeneous belief-network structures, causing individuals with similar targeted beliefs to show compliance, resilience, or resistance under the same external pressure. These response patterns depend on how the targeted belief is embedded in the belief network before the pressure is applied. Compliance is associated with less balanced, less clustered, and more dissonant belief networks. Resistance is associated with stronger connectedness and balance around the targeted belief. Social adaptation reduces belief-network heterogeneity but changes response patterns non-monotonically. Weak to moderate social adaptation increases compliance, whereas stronger social adaptation increases resilience. Finally, external pressure affects not only the targeted belief but also how it is embedded, and this affects future belief change. Our results illustrate how individual differences in belief change can arise from adaptive belief-network structures itself. Explaining why people's beliefs show compliance, resilience, or resistance therefore requires understanding how these networks change through internal and social adaptation.

  • Open Access

    Heterogeneous learning strategies interact with social network structure and problem complexity to benefit collective search

    by Maria Pykälä, Maria Pykälä, Danica Dillion, Danica Dillion, Mirta Galesic, Mirta Galesic

    Groups can outperform individuals by sharing and aggregating information through diverse social structures and learning strategies that shape how innovations are discovered and transmitted. At the same time, groups must solve problems that vary in complexity, from relatively simple decisions to complex tasks with many interacting components such as scientific discovery. Interdisciplinary research shows that collective outcomes depend on learning strategies, group structure and problem complexity, yet it remains unclear how these factors together influence the success of collective search and problem-solving. We develop an evolutionary agent-based model in which selection operates at the group level: networks compete based on collective performance and reproduce, selecting for successful proportions of learning strategies. We use this framework to study the co-emergence of learning strategies across network sizes and densities and across tasks of varying complexity. Our results show that payoff-biased and frequency-biased social learning can co-exist, with their relative prevalence shifting as a function of network structure and task complexity. These findings suggest that no single learning strategy distribution is universally the best; instead, network structure and task complexity jointly shape the proportions of different learning strategies to support collective search. This article is part of the theme issue ‘The evolution of collective intelligence’.

  • Open Access

    Cultural tightness and social cohesion under coevolving beliefs, behaviors, and preferences

    by Filippo Zimmaro, Jacopo Grilli, Mirta Galesic, Alexander J. Stewart

    Successful collective action on issues from climate change to the maintenance of democracy depends on societal properties such as cultural tightness and social cohesion. How these properties evolve is not well understood because they emerge from a complex interplay between beliefs and behaviors that are usually modeled separately. Here, we address this challenge by developing a game-theoretic framework incorporating norm-utility models to study the coevolutionary dynamics of cooperative behavior, expressed belief, and norm-utility preferences. We show that the introduction of evolving beliefs and preferences into the Snowdrift game and Prisoner’s Dilemma leads to a proliferation of evolutionary stable equilibria, each with different societal properties. In particular, we find that reduced material benefits from cooperation can be associated with an expected increase in cultural tightness (the degree to which norms are strong and shared, so that individuals behave in accordance with widely held beliefs) and an expected reduction in social homogeneity and cohesion (the extent to which individuals belong to a single well-defined group with similar beliefs, behaviors, and preferences). Loss of social homogeneity occurs via a process of evolutionary branching, in which a population fragments into two distinct social groups with strikingly different characteristics. The groups that emerge differ not only in their willingness to cooperate, but also in their expressed beliefs about cooperation and in their preferences for conformity and coherence of their behaviors and expressed beliefs. These results have implications for our understanding of the resilience of cooperation and collective action in times of crisis.

  • Open Access

    Measuring complex psychological and sociological constructs in large-scale text

    by Alina Herderich, Jana Lasser, Mirta Galesic, Segun Taofeek Aroyehun, David Garcia, Joshua Garland

    In recent years, there has been an increasing exchange between social science and machine learning. In principle, natural language processing enables social scientists to systematically process large amounts of text, while rich domain knowledge helps machine learning scholars to build valid models of social phenomena. However, there is a lack of clear guidelines for constructing valid and reliable mixed methods approaches, which can increase the rigor and comparability of computational social science research. We provide a set of guidelines for leveraging human data annotation and automatic text classification at scale in five stages: (1) classification scheme development, (2) data labeling, (3) model selection, (4) model training and performance improvement, and (5) statistical analysis. Using examples from our own research on countering online hate, we outline potential problems and respective solutions. We demonstrate how consequently integrating expertise from social science and machine learning can enhance the study of diverse social phenomena.

  • Open Access

    Social networks affect redistribution decisions and polarization

    by Milena Tsvetkova, Henrik Olsson, Mirta Galesic

    We investigate theoretically and empirically how network structure affects collective decisions about redistribution in an unequal society. We study the effects of assortativity by wealth (observing others with similar or different wealth) and visibility by wealth (observing rich or poor others) on voting for redistribution and the polarization of votes, as well as satisfaction and perceptions of fairness. We develop a computational model and test the predictions of the model in an online network experiment. The results reveal that although most social networks lead people to under-observe inequality, different structural properties produce different collective outcomes: redistribution and polarization are the lowest in networks with maximum assortativity, where participants are segregated by wealth, and the highest in networks where the rich are most visible. Furthermore, segregation keeps the poor poorest but satisfied, while observing the rich makes them dissatisfied despite becoming better off. These findings suggest that political communication and policy strategies aiming to increase support for redistribution should enhance the visibility of excessive wealth. At the same time, it is crucial to ensure that this does not exacerbate polarization and conflict.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Collective moderation of hate, toxicity, and extremity in online discussions

    by Jana Lasser, Alina Herderich, Joshua Garland, Segun Taofeek Aroyehun, David Garcia, Mirta Galesic

    In the digital age, hate speech poses a threat to the functioning of social media platforms as spaces for public discourse. Top-down approaches to moderate hate speech encounter difficulties due to conflicts with freedom of expression and issues of scalability. Counter speech, a form of collective moderation by citizens, has emerged as a potential remedy. Here, we aim to investigate which counter speech strategies are most effective in reducing the prevalence of hate, toxicity, and extremity on online platforms. We analyze more than 130,000 discussions on German Twitter starting at the peak of the migrant crisis in 2015 and extending over 4 years. We use human annotation and machine learning classifiers to identify argumentation strategies, ingroup and outgroup references, emotional tone, and different measures of discourse quality. Using matching and time-series analyses we discern the effectiveness of naturally observed counter speech strategies on the microlevel (individual tweet pairs), mesolevel (entire discussions) and macrolevel (over days). We find that expressing straightforward opinions, even if not factual but devoid of insults, results in the least subsequent hate, toxicity, and extremity over all levels of analyses. This strategy complements currently recommended counter speech strategies and is easy for citizens to engage in. Sarcasm can also be effective in improving discourse quality, especially in the presence of organized extreme groups. Going beyond one-shot analyses on smaller samples prevalent in most prior studies, our findings have implications for the successful management of public online spaces through collective civic moderation.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Networks of beliefs: An integrative theory of individual- and social-level belief dynamics.

    by Jonas Dalege, Mirta Galesic, Henrik Olsson

    We present a theory of belief dynamics that explains the interplay between internal beliefs in people's minds and beliefs of others in their external social environments. The networks of belief theory goes beyond existing theories of belief dynamics in three ways. First, it provides an explicit connection between belief networks in individual minds and belief dynamics on social networks. The connection, absent from most previous theories, is established through people's social beliefs or perceived beliefs of others. Second, the theory recognizes that the correspondence between social beliefs and others' actual beliefs can be imperfect, because social beliefs are affected by personal beliefs as well as by the actual beliefs of others. Past theories of belief dynamics on social networks do not distinguish between perceived and actual beliefs of others. Third, the theory explains diverse belief dynamics phenomena parsimoniously through the differences in attention and the resulting felt dissonances in personal, social, and external parts of belief networks. We implement our theoretical assumptions in a computational model within a statistical physics framework and derive model predictions. We find support for our theoretical assumptions and model predictions in two large survey studies (N₁ = 973, N₂ = 669). We then derive insights about diverse phenomena related to belief dynamics, including group consensus and polarization, group radicalization, minority influence, and different empirically observed belief distributions. We discuss how the theory goes beyond different existing models of belief dynamics and outline promising directions for future research. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).