GVGillian Vance

Gillian Vance

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Gillian Vance has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Improving the sustainability of the dental workforce in Cumbria: a mixed methods study

    by G. Vance, A. Asuni, R. Karanjkar, B. Burford

    Background: Patients are increasingly unable to access NHS dental care in the UK. This is more marked in rural and coastal communities, where challenges of attracting and retaining dental professionals contribute to the problem. However, despite being a well-recognised issue, there is relatively little research to guide meaningful interventions in under-served locations. Accordingly, this study sought to examine challenges to the sustainability of the NHS dental workforce in one remote and rural area of the UK and identify opportunities to improve recruitment and retention. Methods: Staff working in primary care dentistry across Cumbria were invited to complete a survey that asked what had attracted them to the region and about any intentions to change their working pattern, to leave dentistry, or the region. Factors affecting workforce sustainability and ideas for change were explored in workshops held at a regional symposium. Results: Survey responses (n=136 across staff groups, including 40 dentists) showed that 70% (n=90) of respondents (85% of dentists, n=40) were intending to change their working pattern within 5 years, whether by reducing their working hours (n=50, 38%), change the NHS/private mix (n=36, 26%) or leave their current job for another post or further training in dentistry (n=41, 30%). Thirty-two percent of dentists (n=15) were planning to leave dentistry altogether. Free text responses suggested ‘personal’ (including family, quality of life, finance) and ‘professional’ factors (including career development, job satisfaction) influenced plans. Workshop data (20 dentists, 10 nurses/practice managers, 8 other stakeholders) identified themes relating to the rural community, as well as educational systems supporting entry to a dental career and enabling career progression. There were also profession-related systems that had financial impact at a local level. Potential interventions included bespoke marketing strategies, education and training initiatives to support local populations enter dentistry, host undergraduate placements and promote career development. Conclusions: The sustainability of the dental workforce in Cumbria is at risk. Locally-led interventions should seek to capitalise on the strengths of the geography and create a positive learning experience that builds a community of practitioners. National solutions will require financial investment and educational reform to bring about effective change.

  • Open Access

    Valuing and retaining the dental workforce: a mixed-methods exploration of workforce sustainability in the North East of England

    by Heidi Stelling, Megan Brown, Bryan Burford, Paul Blaylock, Gillian Vance

    Background: NHS dentistry is experiencing significant recruitment and retention challenges, particularly in rural, coastal, and deprived urban areas. Issues have been exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic, leading to unequal distribution of dental professionals across UK geographies. Despite workforce policy initiatives, issues persist. This study explores factors influencing workforce sustainability in the North East of England – an under-served region of the UK. Methods: Forty-six participants, including 30 dentists, 3 dental care professionals, and 13 managers, contributed to this study. Four focus groups were held at two events in July 2023 – one in the north of the region, and one in the south to enable broad stakeholder engagement and reflect the different geographies within the region. These groups generated qualitative data to elaborate on the factors influencing workforce sustainability and ideas for change. Analysis involved a codebook approach to thematic analysis. Results: Thematic analysis identified four key factors influencing workforce sustainability: careers, collaboration, costs, and contentment. Career development in a supportive learning environment was essential for professional growth and retention, yet systemic barriers hindered progression. Collaboration, both within dental teams and across regulatory bodies, played a vital role in improving job satisfaction and service delivery, but fragmented communication remained a challenge. Financial pressures, particularly rigid NHS contracts and inadequate remuneration, emerged as significant concerns impacting recruitment and retention. Contentment was shaped by work-life balance, professional recognition, and the ability to provide high-quality care without excessive bureaucracy. These systemic challenges collectively contribute to workforce instability, particularly in the North East. Conclusion: Findings highlight critical systemic barriers that threaten workforce sustainability in NHS dentistry. Addressing career progression pathways, improving collaboration, reforming contracts, and enhancing professional support systems are essential for sector stability. Without coordinated action from employers and policymakers, NHS dentistry will remain unsustainable, necessitating urgent interventions to support workforce retention and service provision.


  • Open Access

    Exploring how starting work during COVID-19 impacted post-foundation career decisions of new doctors: a mixed methods study

    by Anna Harvey Bluemel, Megan E L Brown, Gillian Vance, Yu Fu, Christopher Price, Bryan Burford

    Objectives This study addressed two research questions: What factors do doctors in training describe as influencing their choices to apply (or not apply) for specialty training during their Foundation Year 2? Which of these factors are specific to the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the unique experiences of the cohort of doctors who qualified early during the pandemic? Design Sequential explanatory mixed methods study: Quantitative survey. Qualitative semistructured interviews. Quantitative data were analysed with logistic regression. Qualitative data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Setting UK-wide. Participants Junior doctors who graduated medical school in 2020. Survey: 320 participants (22% of those contacted). 68% (n=219) were female, 60% (n=192) under 25 and 35% (n=112) 25–30. 72% (n=230) were white, 18% (n=58) Asian and 3% (n=10) black. Interviews: 20 participants, 10 had applied for specialty training, 10 had not. Results A minority of respondents had applied for specialty training to start in 2022 (114, 36%). While burnout varied, with 15% indicating high burnout, this was not associated with the decision to apply. This decision was predicted by having taken time off due to work-related stress. Those who had not taken time off were 2.4 times more likely to have applied for specialty training (OR=2.43, 95% CI 1.20 to 5.34). Interviews found reasons for not applying included wanting to ‘step off the treadmill’ of training; perceptions of training pathways as inflexible, impacting well-being; and disillusionment with the community and vocation of healthcare, based, in part, on their experiences working through COVID-19. Conclusions Participants infrequently cited factors specific to the pandemic had impacted their decision-making but spoke more broadly about challenges associated with increasing pressure on the health service and an eroded sense of vocation and community.


  • Open Access

    Widening interest, widening participation: factors influencing school students’ aspirations to study medicine

    by Alexander J. Martin, Benjamin J. Beska, Greta Wood, Nicola Wyatt, Anthony Codd, Gillian Vance, Bryan Burford

    Under-representation of some socio-economic groups in medicine is rooted in under-representation of those groups in applications to medical school. This study aimed to explore what may deter school-age children from applying to study medicine. Workshops were undertaken with school students aged 16–17 years (‘Year 12’, n = 122 across three workshops) and 13–14 years (‘Year 9’, n = 295 across three workshops). Workshops used a variety of methods to identify and discuss participants’ perceptions of medicine, medical school and the application process. Year 12 workshops focused on applications and medical school, while Year 9 took a broader approach reflecting their relative distance from applying. Subsequent workshops were informed by the findings of earlier ones. The main finding was that potential applicants had limited knowledge about medicine and medical school in several areas. Older students would benefit from accessible information about medical degrees and application processes, access to work experience opportunities and personal contact with medical students and junior doctors, particularly those from a similar background. Younger students demonstrated a lack of awareness of the breadth of medical careers and a limited understanding of what medicine encompasses. Many Year 9 students were attracted by elements of practice which they did not associate with medicine, such as ‘talking to people with mental health problems’. An exercise addressing this elicited an increase in their interest in medicine. These issues were identified by participants as being more marked for those without knowledgeable support at home or school. It was apparent that school teachers may not be equipped to fill these knowledge gaps. Gaps in knowledge and support may reflect the importance of ‘social capital’ in facilitating access to medical school. Medical schools could act as hubs to introduce students to resources which are essential for widening participation. Outreach and support to schools may ensure that fundamental knowledge gaps are equitably addressed for all prospective applicants. More generally, a focus on medicine which under-emphasises aspects of medical practice involving communication may deter some students and have longer term impact on recruitment to careers including general practice and psychiatry.


  • Open Access

    The relationship between medical student learning opportunities and preparedness for practice: a questionnaire study

    by Bryan Burford, Victoria Whittle, Gillian Hs Vance

    Alongside providing a knowledge base and practical skills, undergraduate medical education must prepare graduates to immediately begin practice as qualified doctors. A significant challenge is to provide safe learning opportunities that will optimise students’ preparedness to start work. This study examined UK graduates’ preparedness for clinical practice, and their exposure to real-life and simulated immediate care scenarios during final year placements.