RRRenate Rabenstein

Renate Rabenstein

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Renate Rabenstein has a total of 48 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Micro-computed tomography indicates Eurotamandua, putative anteater from the Eocene of Messel, Germany, is related to pangolins, not xenarthrans

    by Kenneth D. Rose, Renate Rabenstein, Jörg Habersetzer, Timothy J. Gaudin

    Eurotamandua joresi, based on an articulated skeleton unearthed half a century ago at the middle Eocene Messel Pit near Darmstadt, Germany, was initially described as the oldest known anteater and the only member of mammalian clade Xenarthra from outside the New World. The implied biogeographical link to South America raised suspicions about the relationships of Eurotamandua and its similarity to true anteaters (Vermilingua). Because the skeleton was held in a private collection for many years, only a cast was available for study after the initial report. Even when the original specimen became accessible, it was clear that important anatomical features were not visible because many bones were in articulation, and the skeleton was compressed in matrix. Moreover, it had been encased in fiberglass-reinforced resin, further obscuring skeletal details. Here we report new evidence revealed through micro-computed tomography of the entire skeleton and digital segmentation of individual elements. For the first time, phylogenetically critical anatomy can be seen in three dimensions. Many unique features, especially of the forelimb, indicate that Eurotamandua was a highly specialized digger most closely related to extinct Holarctic palaeanodonts (Pholidotamorpha: pangolins and their extinct relatives) and not to Xenarthra. Consequently, no Old World xenarthrans are known.

  • Open Access

    Anatomy of Eurotamandua joresi (Mammalia) from Grube Messel, Germany, based on computed tomography, and implications for its relationships. Part I: Background and forelimb

    by Kenneth D. Rose, Renate Rabenstein, Jörg Habersetzer, Timothy J. Gaudin

    Micro-computed tomography of the unique skeleton of Eurotamandua joresi Storch, 1981 (middle Eocene, Grube Messel)—initially described as the oldest myrmecophagid and the only known Old World xenarthran—reveals details of its skeletal anatomy that were previously obscured, enabling close comparative study for the first time. In this report we focus on the forelimb. The segmentation of scapula, humerus, radius, ulna, carpals, metacarpals and phalanges reveals exceptional specializations for scratch digging. These include numerous features that are strikingly similar to those of palaeanodonts, and to a lesser degree manids, but which contrast sharply with those of the xenarthrans Tamandua and Dasypus . Other features once thought to ally Eurotamandua with xenarthrans, such as a secondary scapular spine, absence of teeth, and a tubular snout, are not restricted to Xenarthra. The new forelimb characters are here incorporated into a phylogenetic analysis that includes xenarthrans, pholidotans, and palaeanodonts. This new analysis provides compelling evidence that Eurotamandua is related to Palaeanodonta (Laurasiatheria: Pholidotamorpha) rather than to Xenarthra, thus separating it from xenarthrans at the superordinal level. Consequently, there is no evidence that Xenarthra ever reached the Old World.


  • Open Access

    The biodiversity of the Eocene Messel Pit

    by Krister T. Smith, Margaret Collinson, Annelise Folie, Jörg Habersetzer, Florian Hennicke, Erika Kothe, Thomas Lehmann, Olaf K. Lenz, Gerald Mayr, Norbert Micklich, et al.

    The Messel Pit is a Konservat-Lagerstätte in Germany, representing the deposits of a latest early to earliest middle Eocene maar lake, and one of the first palaeontological sites to be included on the list of UNESCO World Heritage Sites. One aspect of Messel that makes it so extraordinary is that its sediments are rich in different fossilised organisms – microfossils, plants, fungi, invertebrate animals and vertebrates – that are rarely preserved together. We present an updated list of all taxa, named or not, that have been documented at Messel, comprising 1409 taxa, which represent a smaller but inexactly known number of biological species. The taxonomic list of Labandeira and Dunne (2014) contains serious deficiencies and should not be used uncritically. Furthermore, we compiled specimen lists of all Messel amphibians, reptiles and mammals known to us. In all, our analyses incorporate data from 32 public collections and some 20 private collections. We apply modern biodiversity-theoretic techniques to ascertain how species richness tracks sampling, to estimate what is the minimum asymptotic species richness, and to project how long it will take to sample a given proportion of that minimum richness. Plant and insect diversity is currently less well investigated than vertebrate diversity. Completeness of sampling in aquatic and semiaquatic, followed by volant, vertebrates is higher than in terrestrial vertebrates. Current excavation rates are one-half to two-thirds lower than in the recent past, leading to much higher estimates of the future excavation effort required to sample species richness more completely, should these rates be maintained. Species richness at Messel, which represents a lake within a paratropical forest near the end of the Early Eocene Climate Optimum, was generally higher than in comparable parts of Central Europe today but lower than in present-day Neotropical biotopes. There is no evidence that the Eocene Messel ecosystem was a “tropical rainforest.”


  • Decadal oscillations in the ocean’s largest oxygen-deficient zone

    by N. N. Duprey, A. D. Foreman, J. D. Carriquiry, C. D. Charles, S. C. Sanchez, H. Vonhof, F. Rubach, R. Rabenstein, M. Rohr, H. Reyes-Bonilla, et al.

    The impact of global warming on the ocean’s oxygen-deficient zones (ODZs) is uncertain, partly because of a lack of data on past changes. We report monthly resolved records of coral skeleton–bound nitrogen isotopes (CS-δ 15 N) to reconstruct denitrification in the Eastern Tropical North Pacific (ETNP) ODZ over the last 80 years. The data indicate strong decadal variation in ETNP denitrification, with maxima during the cool North Pacific phase of Pacific Decadal Variability. The maxima in denitrification (and thus oxygen deficiency) were likely due to stronger upwelling that enhanced productivity leading to greater oxygen demand in the thermocline. Prior findings of multidecadal-to-centennial ODZ trends were likely biased by this variability. ODZ evolution over the next century will depend on how global warming interacts with the decadal oscillations.


  • Open Access

    Was Palaeolake Messel a death-trap? Insight from modern bat drownings and decay experiments

    by Krister T. Smith, Renate Rabenstein, Joy O’kEefe

    The Messel Pit is an ancient maar lake that preserves an ecosystem from the last greenhouse phase of Earth’s climate with exceptional fidelity. There are two main competing hypotheses to explain the occurrence of animal fossils at Messel: asphyxiation in layers of heavy, toxic gases like carbon dioxide, and death following ingestion of surface water contaminated by cyanobacterial toxins. Both hypotheses imply mortality much higher than the null hypothesis of accidental death, for instance by drowning. We tested these hypotheses amongst bats by recourse to a unique survey on bats that drowned in modern swimming pools. We further conducted experiments on the fate of fresh bat carcasses that simulate drowning. Finally, we estimated the annual rate of bat fossil production at Messel. Overall, there are few good surveyed predictors of whether bats drown in swimming pools: most physical parameters like pool size or the height and distance of obstructions were not associated with mortality, although pool liner type would be a good candidate parameter for future study. In our experiments, carcasses with water-filled lungs tend to sink more quickly than those with air-filled lungs; all carcasses that initially sink “bloat and float” at shallow depths, but all floaters eventually disarticulate and sink within days to weeks. Our estimates of annual bat mortality at Palaeolake Messel are of the same order of magnitude as mortality in swimming pools. Mass mortality horizons for vertebrates are very rare at Messel. In sum, our quantitative analyses provide no evidence that bat mortality at Messel rises above background levels.


  • Open Access

    Cranium of an Eocene/Oligocene pheasant-sized galliform bird from western North America, with the description of a vascular autapomorphy of the Galliformes

    by Gerald Mayr, James L. Goedert, Renate Rabenstein

    We describe the fossil cranium of a pheasant-sized galliform land bird from latest Eocene or earliest Oligocene marine rocks of the Jansen Creek Member, Makah Formation (Washington State, USA), which is the only three-dimensionally preserved cranium of a Paleogene representative of the Galliformes. The specimen was freed from a hard calcareous nodule with dilute formic acid. Micro-computed tomography provided further osteological details and a virtual cranial endocast. The fossil exhibits a plesiomorphic temporal morphology, lacking an ossified aponeurosis zygomatica, a feature characterizing some extant Cracidae and most Odontophoridae and Phasianidae. Overall, the fossil is most similar to the skull of the Asian phasianid taxonArborophila, but this resemblance may well be plesiomorphic for a more inclusive clade. Still, we consider it possible that the fossil represents an archaic member of the Phasianoidea, in which case it would be the earliest record of this taxon from the New World. The fossil exhibits a previously unnoticed cranial autapomorphy of galliforms, a foramen in the temporal region that enables the vena profunda to enter the braincase, for which the name foramen temporale venosum is here introduced. Consistently present in all studied extant galliform taxa and absent in all other extant birds, this foramen enables a vascular connection between the brain and the ophthalmic rete, the latter playing an important role in thermoregulation of the avian brain.


  • The apex of amphicyonid hypercarnivory: solving the riddle of Agnotherium antiquum Kaup, 1833 (Mammalia, Carnivora)

    by Michael Morlo, Katharina Bastl, Jörg Habersetzer, Thomas Engel, Bastian Lischewsky, Herbert Lutz, Axel von Berg, Renate Rabenstein, Doris Nagel

    Since its first description, only a single undisputed specimen, an isolated, highly abraded m1, was known from the enigmatic amphicyonid Agnotherium antiquum Kaup, 1833. Here, we describe the second specimen of A. antiquum from the type locality of Eppelsheim (early late Miocene, MN 9/10 of Germany), unearthed 184 years after the first description of A. antiquum. The specimen consists of a partial left juvenile mandible with dp3, m1 in eruption, i3, canine, p4, and a highly reduced m2 still in crypt. The p1–3 and m3 are completely reduced, as are the metaconids of m1 and m2. We confirm previous assignments of late Miocene specimens from the localities of Charmoille, Switzerland, and Pedregueras 2A, Spain, to A. antiquum, whereas a maxilla from Bled Douarah, Tunisia, can only tentatively be assigned to the species. We confirm that the monotypic genus Agnotherium is a thaumastocyonine amphicyonid, discuss other supposed thaumastocyonine specimens, and briefly review the evolutionary history of the subfamily. Agnotherium was a 275 kg, extremely powerful, strictly carnivorous ambush hunter that represents the apex of amphicyonid evolution toward carnivory. Its tooth eruption pattern resembles recent Ursus more than recent Canis, but it shows a considerable delay of eruption timing like in the ursid Agriotherium. Agnotherium antiquum is one of six carnivoran species from the Eppelsheim Formation that is heavier than 200 kg. The co-occurrence of Agnotherium (or its relatives Tomocyon and Thaumastocyon), Machairodus, and a smaller saber-toothed carnivoran is typical for early late Miocene faunas of Europe and tentatively North Africa.


  • Long-leggedness in cataglyphoid Baltic amber ants

    by Rüdiger Wehner, Renate Rabenstein, Jörg Habersetzer


  • Open Access

    Improved non-destructive 2D and 3D X-ray imaging of leaf venation

    by Julio V. Schneider, Renate Rabenstein, Jens Wesenberg, Karsten Wesche, Georg Zizka, Jörg Habersetzer

    Leaf venation traits are important for many research fields such as systematics and evolutionary biology, plant physiology, climate change, and paleoecology. In spite of an increasing demand for vein trait data, studies are often still data-limited because the development of methods that allow rapid generation of large sets of vein data has lagged behind. Recently, non-destructive X-ray technology has proven useful as an alternative to traditional slow and destructive chemical-based methods. Non-destructive techniques more readily allow the use of herbarium specimens, which provide an invaluable but underexploited resource of vein data and related environmental information. The utility of 2D X-ray technology and microfocus X-ray computed tomography, however, has been compromised by insufficient image resolution. Here, we advanced X-ray technology by increasing image resolution and throughput without the application of contrast agents. For 2D contact microradiography, we developed a method which allowed us to achieve image resolutions of up to 7 µm, i.e. a 3.6-fold increase compared to the industrial standard (25 µm resolution). Vein tracing was further optimized with our image processing standards that were specifically adjusted for different types of leaf structure and the needs of higher imaging throughput. Based on a test dataset, in 91% of the samples the 7 µm approach led to a significant improvement in estimations of minor vein density compared to the industrial standard. Using microfocus X-ray computed tomography, very high-resolution images were obtained from a virtual 3D–2D transformation process, which was superior to that of 3D images. Our 2D X-ray method with a significantly improved resolution advances rapid non-destructive bulk scanning at a quality that in many cases is sufficient to determine key venation traits. Together with our high-resolution microfocus X-ray computed tomography method, both non-destructive approaches will help in vein trait data mining from museum collections, which provide an underexploited resource of historical and recent data on environmental and evolutionary change. In spite of the significant increase in effective image resolution, a combination of high-throughput and full visibility of the vein network (including the smallest veins and their connectivity) remains challenging, however.