MPMykola Anatoliiovych Pohoretskyi

Mykola Anatoliiovych Pohoretskyi

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Mykola Anatoliiovych Pohoretskyi has a total of 32 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • DOCUMENT IN CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL PROOF: A DOCTRINAL MODEL OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN INFORMATION, ITS CARRIER AND A PROCEDURAL SOURCE OF EVIDENCE

    by Mykola Anatoliiovych Pohoretskyi

    У статті досліджено доктринальні та прикладні проблеми визначення документа у кримінальному процесуальному доказуванні, зумовлені змішуванням у законодав- стві й правозастосуванні інформації, її носія, документа, процесуального джерела доказів і самих доказів. Метою статті є формування цілісної доктринальної моделі документа, придатної для матеріальної та цифрової форм фіксації інформації. Мето- дологічну основу дослідження становлять діалектичний, системно-структурний, фор- мально-юридичний, порівняльно-правовий і функціональний методи, застосовані до аналізу законодавства, судової практики та наукових джерел. Обґрунтовано, що доку- мент є не доказом, інформацією чи носієм, а процесуальним джерелом доказів, з якого у встановленому законом порядку одержують фактичні дані. Запропоновано розмеж- овувати походження інформації, її первинне джерело, спосіб фіксації, носій, інфор- маційний об’єкт, процесуальне залучення документа та одержані з нього докази. Сформульовано доктринальне поняття документа, визначено момент набуття ним процесуального статусу та доведено, що цифрова форма не утворює окремого виду доказів або самостійного процесуального джерела доказів. Розкрито функціональний критерій відмежування документа від речового доказу та обґрунтовано можливість подвійного процесуального значення одного об’єкта з окремим оцінюванням його інформаційного змісту і матеріальних властивостей. Уточнено підходи до визначення оригіналу, дубліката, копії, похідного документа, перенесення та перетворення циф- рових даних, а також до перевірки походження, цілісності й автентичності документа. Доведено, що автентичність не тотожна достовірності, а сумніви щодо походження або цілісності не завжди спричиняють недопустимість доказів. Запропоновано зміни до Кримінального процесуального кодексу України щодо одержання, залучення, збе- реження, відкриття, дослідження, оцінювання та використання документів із забезпе- ченням рівних функціональних вимог для сторін обвинувачення і захисту.

  • Open Access

    Criminal procedural proof in the mixed model of criminal procedure of Ukraine: a new authorial integrative doctrine

    by M. A. Pohoretskyi

    The article substantiates a new authorial integrative doctrine of criminal procedural proof in the mixed model of criminal procedure of Ukraine. The methodological basis of the study is the author’s previous concept of criminal procedural proof, in which proof was considered as cognitive-practical, legal and logical-intellectual activity aimed at obtaining and using evidence. It is argued that the current state of criminal procedure, the development of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights, the digitalisation of evidentiary activity, the use of OSINT, multisensor data, results of covert investigative actions, materials of operational-search activity, as well as the specific features of criminal proceedings under martial law require a transition from a conceptual model of proof to a coherent authorial integrative doctrine. The article substantiates that criminal procedural proof cannot be reduced only to the collection, verification and evaluation of evidence. It should be understood as a normatively regulated, adversarially organised, judicially controlled, standard-oriented, procedurally integral and technologically supported activity involving the obtaining, procedural recording, disclosure, examination, verification, evaluation and use of evidence in order to form an admissible, reliable, sufficient, adversarially tested and fair factual basis for a criminal procedural decision. The article reveals the importance of the mixed model of criminal procedure of Ukraine as a procedural environment of proof, within which pre-trial investigation, judicial control and trial have different but interrelated evidentiary purposes. A differentiated understanding of the subjects of proof, subjects of evidentiary interest, subjects of obtaining and submitting evidence, subjects of judicial control, examination and evaluation of evidence is proposed. Particular attention is paid to standards of proof, admissibility of evidence, procedural integrity, the digital form of evidence, OSINT, multisensor data, covert investigative actions and operational-search materials. The article concludes that the new authorial integrative doctrine of criminal procedural proof should become a methodological basis for the further development of the law of evidence of Ukraine, improvement of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and formation of a procedurally integral, digitally verifiable and judicially controlled model of proof in the mixed criminal procedure of Ukraine.


  • Open Access

    Dispositivity and criminal procedural proof: from evidentiary initiative to the legal consequences of procedural manifestation of will

    by M. A. Pohoretskyi

    The article develops a special doctrinal model of dispositivity in criminal procedural proof. It proceeds from the proposition that dispositivity in the evidentiary sphere is not identical to any procedural independence, evidentiary tactics, or professional discretion. Instead, it characterises a legally recognised and guaranteed sphere of autonomous decision-making by the proper holder of specific evidentiary procedural opportunities. It is substantiated that the immediate object of dispositivity is neither evidence as such nor proof as a whole, but a personalised evidentiary procedural opportunity whose legal fate is left by law to the will of its holder. A functional typology of the forms of dispositivity in proof is proposed: initiative, formative, presentational, verification, and waiver forms. Evidentiary initiative is defined as the primary mechanism for activating an evidentiary procedural opportunity, while it does not exhaust the content of dispositivity. The central result of the study is the distinction between three normative planes of proof: the sphere of autonomous use of one’s own evidentiary procedural opportunity; the sphere of mandatory rules governing the formation, verification, admissibility and use of evidence; and the sphere of judicial competence concerning the legal evaluation of evidentiary material. The article formulates the rule that a participant may dispose of his or her own evidentiary activity but may not dispose of the normative legal regime of evidence. Accordingly, the parties’ consent cannot create missing public competence, legitimise an unlawful method of obtaining information, or cure a fundamental defect in the formation of evidence. The concept of an evidentiary procedural manifestation of will is introduced as an independent category linking the evidentiary procedural opportunity belonging to a participant with the procedural consequence provided by law. Non-use of an evidentiary opportunity, procedural passivity and a legally significant waiver are distinguished. The article substantiates a prohibition on retrospectively inferring waiver solely from silence, inactivity, or an unfavourable procedural outcome. A special test for the validity of evidentiary procedural manifestation of will is proposed, covering proper subject, permissible object, voluntariness, awareness, sufficient information, unequivocal character and proper procedural form. A rule of an increasing standard of review is formulated: the more significant and less reversible the consequences of waiving an evidentiary opportunity are for the right of defence and the final procedural outcome, the more rigorously the validity of the relevant manifestation of will must be examined. Functionally differentiated legal consequences of defects in such manifestation of will are identified. It is further shown that digitalisation expands the technical forms through which evidentiary autonomy may be exercised but does not alter the normative limits of dispositivity and, at the same time, increases the importance of authentic recording and the legal validity of procedural manifestations of will.

  • Open Access

    Special pre-trial investigation (in absentia) in the criminal process of Ukraine: evidentiary nature of grounds, subject of proof and judicial control

    by M. A. Pohoretskyi

    The article examines special pre-trial investigation (in absentia) in the criminal process of Ukraine through the prism of the evidentiary nature of the grounds for its application, the subject of proof and judicial control. The relevance of the topic is determined by the significant increase in the importance of this institution under the conditions of the armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine, the temporary occupation of part of the territory of Ukraine, the presence of suspects in the territory of the aggressor state, or their evasion from pre-trial investigation bodies and the court. It is substantiated that special pre-trial investigation (in absentia) is not only an exceptional procedural form, but also a specific evidentiary regime. The article defines the subject of proof of the grounds for special pre-trial investigation, which includes: the reasonableness of suspicion; proper notification of the person of suspicion; summonses carried out in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law; establishment of the suspect’s location or procedural unavailability; the existence of factual data on evasion; the person’s actual awareness or the state’s taking of all reasonable and available measures to inform the person; and ensuring a real right to defence. The necessity of differentiating the standards of proof of the grounds for special pre-trial investigation is demonstrated. Particular attention is paid to the digital form of factual data that may be used to confirm notification, actual awareness, location or evasion of the suspect. It is substantiated that such data do not constitute an independent type of evidence and must be assessed according to the general criteria of relevance, admissibility, reliability and sufficiency. The article concludes that judicial control over special pre-trial investigation must be substantive, active and evidence-oriented. The author proposes directions for improving legislation and practice aimed at increasing the evidentiary certainty of the grounds for in absentia proceedings, strengthening the reasoning of investigating judges’ rulings, ensuring the procedurally correct use of digital information, and safeguarding a real, effective and practical right to defence.


  • Open Access

    Time limits for conducting covert investigative (search) actions as a procedural guarantee of the quality of evidence: problems of calculation, judicial control, and legal certainty

    by M.A. Pohoretskyi, M.V. Chlenov

    The article provides a comprehensive scholarly analysis of the time limits for conducting covert investigative (search) actions through the prism of judicial control, legal certainty, the principle of proportionality, and the concept of criminal procedural proof. It is substantiated that the time limits for covert investigative (search) actions should be regarded not only as a temporal regulator of the activities of pre-trial investigation bodies, but above all as an independent criminal procedural guarantee of compliance with a person’s constitutional rights, the lawfulness of covert interference with the private sphere, and the quality of evidence obtained as a result of such interference. It is proved that exceeding the time limit specified in the investigating judge’s ruling constitutes not merely a formal procedural violation, but a defect in the procedural form of obtaining evidentiary information, which directly affects the admissibility, procedural suitability, and the possibility of further use of the results of covert investigative (search) actions in proof. In this regard, the time limits for covert investigative (search) actions are examined as guarantee-type time limits that establish non-exceedable temporal boundaries of permissible state interference with constitutional rights, determine the limits of validity of the judicial authorization for such interference, and at the same time serve as an essential element of the proper procedural form of obtaining evidentiary information. It is emphasized that a proper normative definition, calculation, and judicial control of such time limits ensure a balance between the interests of criminal prosecution and the State’s obligation to effectively protect fundamental human rights. The methodological framework of the study includes dialectical, systemic-structural, formal-logical, and comparative-legal methods, the application of which made it possible to identify an internal contradiction between the guarantee nature of the time limits for covert investigative (search) actions and the general rules for calculating procedural time limits provided for in Article 115 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine. The article reveals the content of the normative and restrictive approaches to calculating such time limits applied in the practice of investigating judges, as a result of which the variability of the two-month validity period of an investigating judge’s ruling, ranging from 59 to 63 days, has been established. It is proved that such variability makes the scope of restriction of a person’s constitutional rights dependent on random calendar factors and the practice of a particular investigating judge, which contradicts the requirements of legal certainty and equality before the law and the court. The inadmissibility of the automatic application of general rules for calculating procedural time limits to the time limits for covert investigative (search) actions is substantiated. It is also argued that it is expedient to establish the maximum validity period of the investigating judge’s ruling in days rather than in months, to require the mandatory indication of the exact moment of commencement and expiry of such time limits in judicial rulings, and to provide for a clear normative regulation of the continuous conduct of covert investigative (search) actions within the validity period of the authorization. The article proposes amendments to the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine aimed at unifying judicial practice, strengthening procedural guarantees, enhancing the predictability of law enforcement, and ensuring fair and admissible criminal procedural proof.