KDKathleen Daly

Kathleen Daly

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Kathleen Daly has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Catching and Making Waves in an Academic Life

    by Kathleen Daly

    I trace my memories growing up in the US Northeast, South, and Midwest; my 8-year gap; my serendipitous encounters leading to university, graduate school, and jobs in the United States and Australia; and my evolving areas of research. Before academia, I was motivated to be economically independent and employable. Once in academia, I was motivated to participate in new waves of thought and to make waves with critiques and new concepts. Timing matters in an academic life. I began when academic work was a site of liberty and transcendence. Today, depending on where you are, academic work is sliding into restricted conditions and precarity and, increasingly, a site of immanence. Still, it is a privileged role, and there are new waves to catch and make, even in hard times.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Justice: word, idea, practice

    by Kathleen Daly

    What do “justice,” “social justice,” and “injustice” mean? What is your idea of justice? This article analyzes macrolevel understandings of justice (distributive justice) in political philosophy and mesolevel understandings of justice as rectification (criminal and civil justice) in penal philosophy, law, and social science. I call attention to unresolved disconnects in these understandings of justice, and I propose the abandonment of ideal theories and construct of “distribution of benefits and burdens” in philosophy in favor of nonideal theories and societal inequalities or injustices. My review of criminal, civil, and restorative justice identifies limits on what each can achieve and discusses the compromised character of criminal justice in unjust societies. When comparing the fields of institutional, historical, and transitional justice, I identify distinctive questions for justice and obstacles for victims and society. No one field can accommodate all large‐scale wrongs in diverse sociopolitical contexts. I put forward my idea of justice, which is keyed to research on victim–survivors’ claims for institutional justice. Drawing on Derrida (1992), I view justice as an unachievable ideal, but one that is empirically present in calculations of and struggles for justice.


  • Civil justice and redress scheme outcomes for child sexual abuse by the Catholic Church

    by Kathleen Daly, Juliet Davis

    Procedural differences between civil justice and redress schemes are well known, but knowledge gaps stymie an ability to compare monetary outcomes. This paper advances the field of institutional abuse of children by analysing outcomes for 4563 civil justice and redress scheme claims of sexual abuse of children received by 36 Australian Catholic Church authorities (CCAs) over 35 years. The authorities are archdioceses, dioceses and male and female religious institutes. As expected, average civil justice payments are higher than those for redress schemes. However, there is huge payment variation and a good deal of overlap between the two, especially at the lower end of the payment spectrum. We explain payment variation by a generally lower, average or higher paying orientation of the CCAs, coupled with a strong lower paying orientation of the female religious institutes. Victims and survivors of institutional child abuse require information on outcomes of civil justice and redress scheme claims, rather than the siren song of large civil payments. We join others in calling upon all relevant actors to ‘show the data’ on settled claims.


  • State Payments to Victims of Violent Crime: Discretion and Bias in Awards for Sexual Offences

    by Kathleen Daly, Robyn L Holder

    State monetary schemes for victims of violent crime began in the 1960s and operate in 35 countries today, yet knowledge is lacking on who is applying, how decisions are reached, variation in awards and why amounts may differ. Analysing 291 sexual offence cases in Queensland, we ask whether awards differ by victim sex/gender and by societal constructs of ideal, real rape, and credible victims. We found that male child victims received higher awards than female child victims for more serious sexual offences and that awards to females aged 12 and older were affected by elements associated with real rape and credible victims. We call upon researchers and governments to pursue and expand this new area of research.


  • Feminist Thinking About Crime

    by Kathleen Daly

    The central questions asked by feminist scholars concern the place of sex/gender relations in the shaping of crime, justice, and criminology. With the second wave of the women's movement in the 1970s, scholars who took feminist perspectives challenged the male-centeredness of the field. Major shifts occurred in feminist thinking during the 1990s: Greater emphasis was placed on differences among women, representations of women and gender, and different epistemologies in knowledge production. This led to two developments: First, there emerged a proliferation of ways to relate sex/gender to crime and justice system practices, which have been collectively, though reluctantly, called "feminist criminologies". Second, there was recognition that criminology may be an unhelpful starting point from which to analyze how gender shapes crime and justice. Feminist scholars are more likely to begin with theories of sex/gender, applying these to crime and criminal justice, than to begin with theories of crime from mainstream criminology.


  • Inequalities of Redress: Australia’s National Redress Scheme for Institutional Abuse of Children

    by Kathleen Daly

    The national redress scheme proposed by the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse is unique and unusual in the world of government redress. It is unique with its inclusion of both care leavers and non-care leavers (it is the only government scheme to do so), and it is unusual in focusing on sexual abuse alone (18% of government schemes do). These unique and unusual qualities come at a price for justice. Care leavers and non-care leavers are different groups with respect to their experiences of abuse and social status as child victims. Unless these group differences are explicitly recognised in guidelines for the monetary payment, care leavers will be disadvantaged. Two corrective measures are proposed: adopting an inclusive understanding of sexual abuse in closed and open settings, and addressing the negative bias that may result from care leavers’ lower social status as children compared to that of non-care leavers. Their lower status is likely to affect (that is, devalue) judgements of the severity and impact of abuse.


  • Recognition, reconnection, and renewal

    by Robyn L Holder, Kathleen Daly

    Money as recompense for crime is variously described as making victims whole, restoring them to their pre-victimisation status, recognising the harm done, and facilitating closure and healing. This article explores the meaning of money to survivors of sexual victimisation and its place in their lives. Drawing on interviews with 20 female and male victims who applied for financial assistance to a state-administered scheme in Australia, we examine their motivations for applying, their reflections on the money received, and how they spent it. Claimants can receive two types of money in the overall financial assistance award: one for eligible expenses (or ‘economic loss’) and another, the ‘special assistance’ payment (for ‘non-economic loss’ or what is termed ‘pain and suffering’), the latter of which they can spend in any way they wish. Most survivors applied for financial assistance because they required financial help, but upon receiving the ‘special assistance’ payment, half said it meant acknowledgement by others. They spent this money on practical things, alone or in combination with items related to self-renewal and savings. In jurisdictions having a payment for ‘pain and suffering’, we argue that its meaning is better conveyed to survivors as symbolic recognition of the wrong rather than a token recognition of the harm or injuries. If the aim of a scheme is victim recovery, emphasis should be placed on activities that enable survivors to reconnect with others and rebuild the self.


  • Sequencing Justice: A Longitudinal Study of Justice Goals of Domestic Violence Victims

    by Robyn L Holder, Kathleen Daly

    What women as victims of domestic violence want from criminal justice has long interested researchers and advocates. This article foregrounds the ways in which ‘justice’ matters to victims and how a desire for justice may change over time. We find that victims have multiple justice goals, which are ordered and unfold through the criminal justice process. The goals are directed towards three domains of victim, offender and community; and are influenced by both personal and public interests. Accountability is a threshold goal from which others—punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation or another—may be contemplated. From the perspective of victims, achieving justice is sequencing these goals through hybrid processes with differing degrees of victim participation.