Banan Mukhalalati
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Banan Mukhalalati has a total of 138 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Sara Elshami
Qatar University
14 shared publicationsAhmed Awaisu
College of Pharmacy, QU Health, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
12 shared publications- Ahmed Awaisu
Clinical Pharmacy and Practice Department, College of Pharmacy, QU Health, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
7 shared publications Derek Stewart
Department of Clinical Pharmacy and Practice, College of Pharmacy, QU Health, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
4 shared publicationsIan Bates
School of Pharmacy, University College London
4 shared publicationsAaliah Aly
Department of Clinical Pharmacy and Practice, College of Pharmacy, QU Health, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Generative Artificial Intelligence Policies and Guidelines Across Top Ranked Universities: Insights from AI Ecological Education Policy Framework for AI Integration and University Policy Development Framework for GAI
The prevalence and scope of generative artificial intelligence policies and frameworks among universities in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region remain underexplored, with equivocal alignment of international guidelines to regional context. This study aims to explore, map, and analyze AI policies and guidelines within top-ranking universities in the MENA region. A comparative qualitative analysis of AI policies and guidelines from the top 500 universities (QS and THE) in the MENA region was conducted using NVivo-assisted codebook thematic analysis, combining inductive coding and deductive coding guided by Chan and UPDF-GAI frameworks. Across the MENA region, 34 universities had established AI policy and/or guidelines. The predominant themes were governing and attributing AI use, encouraging balanced approach, and providing training, epistemological, and practical support. However, few institutions incorporated stakeholders or adopted from research, peer institutions, and global organizations in policy development. Similarly, environmental and psychological risks were underrepresented compared to ethical and educational concerns. While Chan and UPDF-GAI frameworks demonstrated overlapping priorities, combining their application provides a comprehensive perspective. The findings provide a foundation for policymakers to develop national education strategies, and for universities to establish and implement contextually grounded GenAI policies that follow best-practice approaches.
- 18 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessGenerative Artificial Intelligence Policies and Guidelines Across Top Ranked Universities: Insights from AI Ecological Education Policy Framework for AI Integration and University Policy Development Framework for GAI
The prevalence and scope of generative artificial intelligence policies and frameworks among universities in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region remain underexplored, with equivocal alignment of international guidelines to regional context. This study aims to explore, map, and analyze AI policies and guidelines within top-ranking universities in the MENA region. A comparative qualitative analysis of AI policies and guidelines from the top 500 universities (QS and THE) in the MENA region was conducted using NVivo-assisted codebook thematic analysis, combining inductive coding and deductive coding guided by Chan and UPDF-GAI frameworks. Across the MENA region, 34 universities had established AI policy and/or guidelines. The predominant themes were governing and attributing AI use, encouraging balanced approach, and providing training, epistemological, and practical support. However, few institutions incorporated stakeholders or adopted from research, peer institutions, and global organizations in policy development. Similarly, environmental and psychological risks were underrepresented compared to ethical and educational concerns. While Chan and UPDF-GAI frameworks demonstrated overlapping priorities, combining their application provides a comprehensive perspective. The findings provide a foundation for policymakers to develop national education strategies, and for universities to establish and implement contextually grounded GenAI policies that follow best-practice approaches.
- Open Access
- 23 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Per-Model Risk Bands From Token-Level Uncertainty For Short-Answer Medical Questions: A Held-Out Evaluation Of Five Open-Weight Language Models
A language model's wording does not show whether a medical answer is right or wrong, and when the answer is used there is usually no correct answer to compare it with. We tested whether a model's own token probabilities can sort each answer into a risk band with a measured probability of being correct. Our score, PKEI, weights the normalised entropy of each generated token by the probability the model gave to tokens other than the one it chose. Five open-weight models (4B to 27B parameters, four of them medically fine-tuned) answered 740 open-ended CareQA questions from healthcare licensing examinations and 490 medical flashcard questions, with no answer options shown. For each model we sorted the answers into PKEI deciles and grouped the deciles into low-risk, intermediate-risk, and high-risk bands, splitting where correct and incorrect answers separated best. Measured out of fold, the median probability of a correct answer across models was 0·75 on CareQA and 0·80 on flashcards in the low-risk band, and 0·26 and 0·40 in the high-risk band, against 0·53 and 0·58 across all answers. The bands fell in order in all ten model and question-set combinations, and the 95% intervals of both outer bands excluded the model's overall accuracy. When the band boundaries were re-chosen inside each fold, this still held in nine of ten. Bands moved to the other question set kept their order, but the share of answers in each band changed. Even in the low-risk band, 15% to 45% of answers were wrong. The bands are therefore better used to decide how closely an answer is checked than to decide that it needs no check.
- 23 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessPer-Model Risk Bands From Token-Level Uncertainty For Short-Answer Medical Questions: A Held-Out Evaluation Of Five Open-Weight Language Models
A language model's wording does not show whether a medical answer is right or wrong, and when the answer is used there is usually no correct answer to compare it with. We tested whether a model's own token probabilities can sort each answer into a risk band with a measured probability of being correct. Our score, PKEI, weights the normalised entropy of each generated token by the probability the model gave to tokens other than the one it chose. Five open-weight models (4B to 27B parameters, four of them medically fine-tuned) answered 740 open-ended CareQA questions from healthcare licensing examinations and 490 medical flashcard questions, with no answer options shown. For each model we sorted the answers into PKEI deciles and grouped the deciles into low-risk, intermediate-risk, and high-risk bands, splitting where correct and incorrect answers separated best. Measured out of fold, the median probability of a correct answer across models was 0·75 on CareQA and 0·80 on flashcards in the low-risk band, and 0·26 and 0·40 in the high-risk band, against 0·53 and 0·58 across all answers. The bands fell in order in all ten model and question-set combinations, and the 95% intervals of both outer bands excluded the model's overall accuracy. When the band boundaries were re-chosen inside each fold, this still held in nine of ten. Bands moved to the other question set kept their order, but the share of answers in each band changed. Even in the low-risk band, 15% to 45% of answers were wrong. The bands are therefore better used to decide how closely an answer is checked than to decide that it needs no check.
- Open Access
- 18 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sage Open
- Vol. 16 (4)
Traditional and Artificial Intelligence-Supported Constructivist Learning in Health Professions Education
Constructivist learning theory emphasizes active, contextualized, and collaborative knowledge construction. Despite its strong theoretical foundation, evidence of its comprehensive application in health professions education (HPE) remains limited, as most studies focus on isolated strategies rather than constructivism as an integrated framework across disciplines and academic levels. Concurrently, artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly used in HPE, yet its pedagogical alignment with constructivist principles is poorly understood. This study examines traditional and AI-supported constructivist learning strategies in undergraduate HPE and their influence on students’ preparedness for clinical practice. A mixed-methods approach was used. In the quantitative phase, 466 undergraduate students from HPE programs at Qatar University completed the Constructivist Practices in the Learning Environment questionnaire, assessing seven constructivist domains. In the qualitative phase, focus groups were conducted with a purposive sample of students (n=26). Thematic analysis explored experiences of active engagement, real-world relevance, social interaction, self-regulation, and AI use. The findings indicated that ‘Making meaning through real-life examples’ was the highest-rated domain ( M = 3.84, SD = 0.89), reflecting strong emphasis on contextualized learning. ‘Conceptual conflicts and dilemmas’ scored lowest ( M = 2.57, SD = 0.94), indicating limited exposure to cognitive challenge. Qualitative findings showed that clinical rotations, collaborative activities, and AI tools supported reflection, inquiry, and personalized learning. Students perceived AI as supportive but emphasized the need for instructor guidance. Integrating AI within constructivist learning environments can enhance active and personalized learning in HPE. However, deliberate inclusion of conceptual challenges and structured guidance for AI use is necessary to strengthen educational outcomes and clinical readiness among health professions students.
- 18 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sage Open
- Vol. 16 (4)
Open AccessTraditional and Artificial Intelligence-Supported Constructivist Learning in Health Professions Education
Constructivist learning theory emphasizes active, contextualized, and collaborative knowledge construction. Despite its strong theoretical foundation, evidence of its comprehensive application in health professions education (HPE) remains limited, as most studies focus on isolated strategies rather than constructivism as an integrated framework across disciplines and academic levels. Concurrently, artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly used in HPE, yet its pedagogical alignment with constructivist principles is poorly understood. This study examines traditional and AI-supported constructivist learning strategies in undergraduate HPE and their influence on students’ preparedness for clinical practice. A mixed-methods approach was used. In the quantitative phase, 466 undergraduate students from HPE programs at Qatar University completed the Constructivist Practices in the Learning Environment questionnaire, assessing seven constructivist domains. In the qualitative phase, focus groups were conducted with a purposive sample of students (n=26). Thematic analysis explored experiences of active engagement, real-world relevance, social interaction, self-regulation, and AI use. The findings indicated that ‘Making meaning through real-life examples’ was the highest-rated domain ( M = 3.84, SD = 0.89), reflecting strong emphasis on contextualized learning. ‘Conceptual conflicts and dilemmas’ scored lowest ( M = 2.57, SD = 0.94), indicating limited exposure to cognitive challenge. Qualitative findings showed that clinical rotations, collaborative activities, and AI tools supported reflection, inquiry, and personalized learning. Students perceived AI as supportive but emphasized the need for instructor guidance. Integrating AI within constructivist learning environments can enhance active and personalized learning in HPE. However, deliberate inclusion of conceptual challenges and structured guidance for AI use is necessary to strengthen educational outcomes and clinical readiness among health professions students.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education
- Vol. 90 (12) , 102097
Research-Related Education in Undergraduate Pharmacy Curricula: A Scoping Review
- 24 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education
- Vol. 90 (12) , 102097
Open AccessResearch-Related Education in Undergraduate Pharmacy Curricula: A Scoping Review
- Open Access
- 6 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 16 (1)
A mixed methods assessment of disaster management perceptions among healthcare practitioners in Qatar
In response to the growing frequency and complexity of disasters, healthcare practitioners (HCPs) must be proficient in disaster management. Research on HCPs’ perceptions of disaster management often lacks the comprehensive scope needed to address diverse healthcare challenges. This study aimed to assess HCPs’ perceptions of their disaster management capabilities, focusing on their knowledge, attitudes, and practices, as well as their willingness to continue practicing during disasters. Additionally, it assessed organization-based management approaches and explored the opportunities and challenges associated with disaster prevention and control strategies. An explanatory mixed-methods approach guided by the Disaster Management Framework was followed. Quantitative data were collected through a self-reported questionnaire administered to a stratified random sample of 771 HCPs from various health organizations across Qatar. Of these, 436 responded (response rate: 56.5%), with 403 responses valid for the analysis. This sample exceeded the minimum required sample size (n = 379), which ensured adequate statistical power. Qualitative data were obtained through six online focus groups (FGs) conducted via Microsoft Teams with 41 purposively selected HCPs, ensuring representation of those with disaster response experience. Qualitative data were analyzed thematically, and data collection continued until thematic saturation was reached. Integration of qualitative and quantitative findings was conducted at the interpretation and reporting levels using a contiguous narrative approach, enabling complementary insights and enhancing the coherence and validity of findings. Quantitative data indicated good perceptions among HCPs concerning their knowledge (median [IQR] = 41 [34–44], Min–Max = 18–55), attitude (median [IQR] = 46 [43–50], Min–Max = 10–55), willingness to practice (median [IQR] = 23 [1–24], Min–Max = 6–30), and their organization-based management (median [IQR] = 43 [40–50], Min–Max = 10–50). However, they reported less frequent involvement in practical disaster management activities (median [IQR] = 31 [24–39], Min–Max = 2–50). Higher disaster management perceptions were significantly associated with prior disaster training, administrative roles, and experience during national emergencies, gender, years of experience, profession, and worksite (p < 0.05). Qualitative data emphasized the importance of practical training, mental health support, technological innovations, interdisciplinary collaboration, community engagement, and robust planning and leadership to strengthen disaster management and enhance public health outcomes. The findings suggest that healthcare organizations worldwide should prioritize proactive disaster readiness, continuous assessment, comprehensive support systems, adaptable protocols, and public engagement to enhance system-wide resilience, adaptability, and community partnership in disaster management.
- 6 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 16 (1)
Open AccessA mixed methods assessment of disaster management perceptions among healthcare practitioners in Qatar
In response to the growing frequency and complexity of disasters, healthcare practitioners (HCPs) must be proficient in disaster management. Research on HCPs’ perceptions of disaster management often lacks the comprehensive scope needed to address diverse healthcare challenges. This study aimed to assess HCPs’ perceptions of their disaster management capabilities, focusing on their knowledge, attitudes, and practices, as well as their willingness to continue practicing during disasters. Additionally, it assessed organization-based management approaches and explored the opportunities and challenges associated with disaster prevention and control strategies. An explanatory mixed-methods approach guided by the Disaster Management Framework was followed. Quantitative data were collected through a self-reported questionnaire administered to a stratified random sample of 771 HCPs from various health organizations across Qatar. Of these, 436 responded (response rate: 56.5%), with 403 responses valid for the analysis. This sample exceeded the minimum required sample size (n = 379), which ensured adequate statistical power. Qualitative data were obtained through six online focus groups (FGs) conducted via Microsoft Teams with 41 purposively selected HCPs, ensuring representation of those with disaster response experience. Qualitative data were analyzed thematically, and data collection continued until thematic saturation was reached. Integration of qualitative and quantitative findings was conducted at the interpretation and reporting levels using a contiguous narrative approach, enabling complementary insights and enhancing the coherence and validity of findings. Quantitative data indicated good perceptions among HCPs concerning their knowledge (median [IQR] = 41 [34–44], Min–Max = 18–55), attitude (median [IQR] = 46 [43–50], Min–Max = 10–55), willingness to practice (median [IQR] = 23 [1–24], Min–Max = 6–30), and their organization-based management (median [IQR] = 43 [40–50], Min–Max = 10–50). However, they reported less frequent involvement in practical disaster management activities (median [IQR] = 31 [24–39], Min–Max = 2–50). Higher disaster management perceptions were significantly associated with prior disaster training, administrative roles, and experience during national emergencies, gender, years of experience, profession, and worksite (p < 0.05). Qualitative data emphasized the importance of practical training, mental health support, technological innovations, interdisciplinary collaboration, community engagement, and robust planning and leadership to strengthen disaster management and enhance public health outcomes. The findings suggest that healthcare organizations worldwide should prioritize proactive disaster readiness, continuous assessment, comprehensive support systems, adaptable protocols, and public engagement to enhance system-wide resilience, adaptability, and community partnership in disaster management.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2026
- Published by ScienceOpen
A Scoping Review on the Ethical Governance for Using Generative AI Tools in Health Professions Education
Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) represents a paradigm shift in Health Professions Education (HPE), offering substantive potential to enhance pedagogical delivery, clinical simulation, and personalized learning. Despite its rapid expansion, the integration of GenAI remains largely heterogeneous and under-theorized. The absence of standardized regulatory frameworks and comprehensive institutional guidance presents significant challenges to the responsible and pedagogically sound application of these technologies, which potentially compromises academic integrity and educational quality. This study synthesizes current evidence regarding the implementation of GenAI in HPE, critically examining the opportunities and barriers to its adoption while identifying the ethical imperatives and regulatory gaps that necessitate a coordinated policy response. Methods: Adhering to the JBI methodology for scoping reviews and the PRISMA-ScR guidelines, a comprehensive search was executed across major databases, including PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, and Scopus. Data were extracted based on GenAI modalities, curricular integration, operational domains, reported outcomes, ethical and regulatory challenges, and existing or proposed policy frameworks. Findings were synthesized through narrative thematic mapping to identify emergent patterns in practice. Results: The analysis revealed that GenAI is increasingly utilized to optimize curriculum design, facilitate automated feedback, and enhance learner engagement through sophisticated simulations. However, implementation is frequently characterized by a lack of structured oversight. Predominant challenges include algorithmic bias, data privacy concerns, and the reliability of AI-generated content. The review identified a critical need for developing multi-dimensional AI literacies among health professional educators and learners, including technical proficiency, ethical judgment, and the ability to critically evaluate AI-generated clinical insights. Existing regulatory frameworks are noted to be underdeveloped and fragmented. Successful integration is contingent upon proactive institutional safeguards, such as human-in-the-loop validation for high-stakes assessments and the alignment of AI tools with professional accreditation standards. Conclusion: While GenAI offers transformative opportunities, its sustainable adoption is predicated on adaptive, evidence-based regulatory frameworks. Future initiatives must prioritize the definition of core AI competencies and the establishment of anticipatory governance models that evolve alongside technological advancements. HPE can serve as a global benchmark for responsible AI implementation by embedding transparency and ethical accountability into the core of its educational frameworks.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by ScienceOpen
Open AccessA Scoping Review on the Ethical Governance for Using Generative AI Tools in Health Professions Education
Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) represents a paradigm shift in Health Professions Education (HPE), offering substantive potential to enhance pedagogical delivery, clinical simulation, and personalized learning. Despite its rapid expansion, the integration of GenAI remains largely heterogeneous and under-theorized. The absence of standardized regulatory frameworks and comprehensive institutional guidance presents significant challenges to the responsible and pedagogically sound application of these technologies, which potentially compromises academic integrity and educational quality. This study synthesizes current evidence regarding the implementation of GenAI in HPE, critically examining the opportunities and barriers to its adoption while identifying the ethical imperatives and regulatory gaps that necessitate a coordinated policy response. Methods: Adhering to the JBI methodology for scoping reviews and the PRISMA-ScR guidelines, a comprehensive search was executed across major databases, including PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, and Scopus. Data were extracted based on GenAI modalities, curricular integration, operational domains, reported outcomes, ethical and regulatory challenges, and existing or proposed policy frameworks. Findings were synthesized through narrative thematic mapping to identify emergent patterns in practice. Results: The analysis revealed that GenAI is increasingly utilized to optimize curriculum design, facilitate automated feedback, and enhance learner engagement through sophisticated simulations. However, implementation is frequently characterized by a lack of structured oversight. Predominant challenges include algorithmic bias, data privacy concerns, and the reliability of AI-generated content. The review identified a critical need for developing multi-dimensional AI literacies among health professional educators and learners, including technical proficiency, ethical judgment, and the ability to critically evaluate AI-generated clinical insights. Existing regulatory frameworks are noted to be underdeveloped and fragmented. Successful integration is contingent upon proactive institutional safeguards, such as human-in-the-loop validation for high-stakes assessments and the alignment of AI tools with professional accreditation standards. Conclusion: While GenAI offers transformative opportunities, its sustainable adoption is predicated on adaptive, evidence-based regulatory frameworks. Future initiatives must prioritize the definition of core AI competencies and the establishment of anticipatory governance models that evolve alongside technological advancements. HPE can serve as a global benchmark for responsible AI implementation by embedding transparency and ethical accountability into the core of its educational frameworks.
- Open Access
- 26 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 19 (1)
Assessing academic capacity and quality assurance in pharmacy education: a focus on the Eastern Mediterranean region
Pharmacy workforce intelligence (PWI) involves the development, implementation, and evaluation of effective strategies and tools to ensure the availability and quality of pharmacy workforce (PW). Academic capacity (AC) is essential in producing graduates for PW, while quality assurance (QA) in education is crucial in developing competent PW. There is a lack of information about PWI in the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR). Based on the available data, there is a notable imbalance in PW distribution in EMR. This study aimed to evaluate the status of AC and QA of pharmacy education in the EMR using the International-Pharmaceutical-Federation (FIP)’s Development-Goals and their associated mechanisms as a framework. An explanatory sequential mixed-methods approach was used. The quantitative phase involved distributing a validated questionnaire among pharmacy leaders of all accessible pharmacy schools in the EMR. The qualitative phase involved the conduct of semi-structured interviews with pharmacy leaders, and the data were thematically analysed. Of 112 identified pharmacy leaders, 61 participated in the survey (response rate, 55%) and 14 participated in the interviews. Most data were consistent among the quantitative and qualitative results. In both phases, most participants reported implementing a student – teacher ratio (70%), periodic accreditation (82%), adoption of global QA standards (67%), and involving key stakeholders in programme development. Enrolment planning based on workforce needs (51%) and capacity-building for teacher-practitioners (47%) were less common and less emphasised in interviews. Although some AC and QA mechanisms are achieved, many require further improvement. Policymakers could establish a national body representing PW, improve workforce data systems for evidence-based enrolment planning, invest in faculty development, and standardised QA frameworks. Standardising stakeholder engagement and enhancing graduate tracking would further ensure that programmes remain aligned with workforce and health system needs.
- 26 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 19 (1)
Open AccessAssessing academic capacity and quality assurance in pharmacy education: a focus on the Eastern Mediterranean region
Pharmacy workforce intelligence (PWI) involves the development, implementation, and evaluation of effective strategies and tools to ensure the availability and quality of pharmacy workforce (PW). Academic capacity (AC) is essential in producing graduates for PW, while quality assurance (QA) in education is crucial in developing competent PW. There is a lack of information about PWI in the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR). Based on the available data, there is a notable imbalance in PW distribution in EMR. This study aimed to evaluate the status of AC and QA of pharmacy education in the EMR using the International-Pharmaceutical-Federation (FIP)’s Development-Goals and their associated mechanisms as a framework. An explanatory sequential mixed-methods approach was used. The quantitative phase involved distributing a validated questionnaire among pharmacy leaders of all accessible pharmacy schools in the EMR. The qualitative phase involved the conduct of semi-structured interviews with pharmacy leaders, and the data were thematically analysed. Of 112 identified pharmacy leaders, 61 participated in the survey (response rate, 55%) and 14 participated in the interviews. Most data were consistent among the quantitative and qualitative results. In both phases, most participants reported implementing a student – teacher ratio (70%), periodic accreditation (82%), adoption of global QA standards (67%), and involving key stakeholders in programme development. Enrolment planning based on workforce needs (51%) and capacity-building for teacher-practitioners (47%) were less common and less emphasised in interviews. Although some AC and QA mechanisms are achieved, many require further improvement. Policymakers could establish a national body representing PW, improve workforce data systems for evidence-based enrolment planning, invest in faculty development, and standardised QA frameworks. Standardising stakeholder engagement and enhancing graduate tracking would further ensure that programmes remain aligned with workforce and health system needs.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 23 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 26 (1)
A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education
Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered care. Although the use of GenAI in health professions is increasing, its optimal integration in HPE is still ambiguous. This scoping review aims to synthesize currently available literature regarding the use of GenAI in health professions education. Method: This scoping review is conducted following JBI methodology for scoping reviews framework 2020 and aligned with PRISMA-ScR. A systematic and comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and ProQuest Central with no language restrictions. The identified evidence was screened and extracted using Covidence software. Publications on the integration of GenAI in undergraduate or graduate health profession education were considered. Data was analyzed and presented using graphs and charts. Followed by a narrative thematic mapping of the included studies. Results: Out of 14,208 scanned records, 241 were considered eligible. The included studies discuss the application of GenAI in diverse education processes of different health professions, such as curriculum design, content creation, content delivery, personalized learning, assessment, evaluation, and feedback provision. Most studies focused on ChatGPT integration in medical and nursing education, with content creation emerging as the predominant area of integration, whereas curriculum design and GenAI literacy were underexplored. Perception studies reported a positive perspective regarding GenAI used in education among students and faculty. Conclusion: This review provides an overview of the current integration of GenAI in HPE in the literature, highlighting the associated opportunities, challenges, facilitators, and barriers. Future education efforts should focus on enhancing GenAI literacy, developing policy, and adopting a balanced approach. In addition to conducting comparative studies and long-term assessment of GenAI impact.
- 23 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 26 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessA scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education
Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered care. Although the use of GenAI in health professions is increasing, its optimal integration in HPE is still ambiguous. This scoping review aims to synthesize currently available literature regarding the use of GenAI in health professions education. Method: This scoping review is conducted following JBI methodology for scoping reviews framework 2020 and aligned with PRISMA-ScR. A systematic and comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and ProQuest Central with no language restrictions. The identified evidence was screened and extracted using Covidence software. Publications on the integration of GenAI in undergraduate or graduate health profession education were considered. Data was analyzed and presented using graphs and charts. Followed by a narrative thematic mapping of the included studies. Results: Out of 14,208 scanned records, 241 were considered eligible. The included studies discuss the application of GenAI in diverse education processes of different health professions, such as curriculum design, content creation, content delivery, personalized learning, assessment, evaluation, and feedback provision. Most studies focused on ChatGPT integration in medical and nursing education, with content creation emerging as the predominant area of integration, whereas curriculum design and GenAI literacy were underexplored. Perception studies reported a positive perspective regarding GenAI used in education among students and faculty. Conclusion: This review provides an overview of the current integration of GenAI in HPE in the literature, highlighting the associated opportunities, challenges, facilitators, and barriers. Future education efforts should focus on enhancing GenAI literacy, developing policy, and adopting a balanced approach. In addition to conducting comparative studies and long-term assessment of GenAI impact.
- Open Access
- 21 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 19 (1)
Competency-based curricula in the Eastern Mediterranean Region schools of pharmacy: a framework-informed mixed method study
Competency-based education (CBE) has been implemented across healthcare disciplines, including pharmacy, to address the limitations of the traditional teaching system. While CBE implementation in pharmacy education has been studied globally, research examining its adoption across pharmacy schools in the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR) remains limited. Explore the nature and extent of CBE incorporation within pharmacy schools' curricula across the EMR and identify barriers and facilitators influencing CBE implementation. A sequential explanatory mixed-methods approach was used, combining an online survey followed by semi-structured online interviews. The study was guided by the International Pharmaceutical Federation Global Competency Framework (FIP GbCF). Out of the 116 schools that received the survey link, 55 responses were received from pharmacy schools in the EMR (any-response rate 47.4%), of which 38 were complete and included in the final analysis (complete-response rate 32.8%). Furthermore, 18 participants participated in the online interview. The majority of the pharmacy schools were accredited (81.6%), and (63.2%) of these implement/incorporate CBE in their curricula. The analysis of the FIP GbCF competencies incorporation revealed that various competencies were prevalent, including communication skills and professional and ethical practice (95.8%), and dispensing and inter-professional collaboration (91.7%). The least incorporated competencies included emergency response (58.3%), followed by workplace management (25%). Inductive thematic analysis identified key challenges for the implementation of CBE in some pharmacy schools, including internal resistance, resource limitations and workload challenges. On the other hand, schools highlighted important facilitators such as leadership support, communication and engagement. Most accredited pharmacy schools in the EMR adopted CBE, yet considerable gaps remain in implementing many of the FIP GbCF competencies. The study reveals that pharmacy schools face significant challenges in CBE implementation, regardless of their current adoption status, suggesting opportunities for the enhancement of pharmacy education across the region.
- 21 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 19 (1)
Open AccessCompetency-based curricula in the Eastern Mediterranean Region schools of pharmacy: a framework-informed mixed method study
Competency-based education (CBE) has been implemented across healthcare disciplines, including pharmacy, to address the limitations of the traditional teaching system. While CBE implementation in pharmacy education has been studied globally, research examining its adoption across pharmacy schools in the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR) remains limited. Explore the nature and extent of CBE incorporation within pharmacy schools' curricula across the EMR and identify barriers and facilitators influencing CBE implementation. A sequential explanatory mixed-methods approach was used, combining an online survey followed by semi-structured online interviews. The study was guided by the International Pharmaceutical Federation Global Competency Framework (FIP GbCF). Out of the 116 schools that received the survey link, 55 responses were received from pharmacy schools in the EMR (any-response rate 47.4%), of which 38 were complete and included in the final analysis (complete-response rate 32.8%). Furthermore, 18 participants participated in the online interview. The majority of the pharmacy schools were accredited (81.6%), and (63.2%) of these implement/incorporate CBE in their curricula. The analysis of the FIP GbCF competencies incorporation revealed that various competencies were prevalent, including communication skills and professional and ethical practice (95.8%), and dispensing and inter-professional collaboration (91.7%). The least incorporated competencies included emergency response (58.3%), followed by workplace management (25%). Inductive thematic analysis identified key challenges for the implementation of CBE in some pharmacy schools, including internal resistance, resource limitations and workload challenges. On the other hand, schools highlighted important facilitators such as leadership support, communication and engagement. Most accredited pharmacy schools in the EMR adopted CBE, yet considerable gaps remain in implementing many of the FIP GbCF competencies. The study reveals that pharmacy schools face significant challenges in CBE implementation, regardless of their current adoption status, suggesting opportunities for the enhancement of pharmacy education across the region.
- Open Access
- 6 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
- Vol. 12 (1) , 1-21
Exploring healthcare professional students’ perceptions of disaster management: a mixed-methods study
- 6 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
- Vol. 12 (1) , 1-21
Open AccessExploring healthcare professional students’ perceptions of disaster management: a mixed-methods study