MOMathieu O'NEil

Mathieu O'NEil

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Mathieu O'NEil has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    University Rents Enabling Corporate Innovation

    by Xiaolan Cai, Mathieu O'NEil, Stefano Zacchiroli

    This article explores the role of unrecognised labour in corporate innovation systems via an analysis of researcher coding and discursive contributions to R, one of the largest statistical software ecosystems. Studies of online platforms typically focus on how platform affordances constrain participants’ actions, and profit from their labour. We innovate by connecting the labour performed inside digital platforms to the professional employment of participants. Our case study analyses 8,924 R package repositories on GitHub, examining commits and communications. Our quantitative findings show that researchers, alongside non-affiliated contributors, are the most frequent owners of R package repositories and their most active contributors. Researchers are more likely to hold official roles compared to the average, and to engage in collaborative problem-solving and support work during package development. This means there is, underneath the ‘recognised’ category of star researchers who transition between academia and industry and secure generous funding, an ‘unrecognised’ category of researchers who not only create and maintain key statistical infrastructure, but also provide support to industry employees, for no remuneration. Our qualitative findings show how this unrecognised labour affects practitioners. Finally, our analysis of the ideology and practice of free, libre and open source software (FLOSS) shows how this ideology and practice legitimate the use of ‘university rents’ by Big Tech. In conclusion, we argue that existing mechanisms are insufficient to ensure these digital commons’ sustainability: FLOSS needs broader systemic support.

  • A Remedy for Epistemic Pollution? Public and Professional Reactions to Fact-Checking with Wikipedia in Australian Classrooms

    by Mathieu O'Neil, Rachel Cunneen, Megan Deas

    Any attempt to increase the information literacy of citizens must incorporate the need to restore trust in our public institutions. To that end, we propose three principles for an effective information literacy strategy: non-partisanship, speed and transparency. These principles were put into practice during an information literacy program trialled in four Canberra (Australian Capital Territory) primary schools in 2022. This programme innovated in three respects: first, because of the age of the students, since information literacy is typically researched in high schools or universities; second, because we challenged conventional understandings of critical thinking by recommending that students “read laterally”; and third, because we used Wikipedia as a fact-checking resource – for the most part, Wikipedia’s auditable and distributed peer review neutralises misinformation. In this chapter, we outline why the current crisis of trust in public institutions necessitates adopting such innovative approaches, and analyse the reactions we encountered when presenting our program in public and professional arenas. These reactions centered around the use of Wikipedia. Classroom teachers sometimes reacted adversely, though teacher-librarians were highly supportive, leading us to conclude that there is a need to reform teacher education. Finally, we review issues that still affect Wikipedia, such as manipulation attempts and systemic imbalances.

  • Open Access

    Subverting or preserving the institution: Competing IT firm and foundation discourses about open source

    by Laure Muselli, Mathieu O’nEil, Fred Pailler, Stefano Zacchiroli

    The data economy depends on digital infrastructure produced in self-managed projects and communities. To understand how information technology (IT) firms communicate to a volunteer workforce, we examine IT firm and foundation employee discourses about open source. We posit that organizations employ rhetorical strategies to advocate for or resist changing the meaning of this institution. Our analysis of discourses collected at three open source professional conferences in 2019 is complemented by computational methods, which generate semantic clusters from presentation summaries. In terms of defining digital infrastructure, business models, and the firm-community relationship, we find a clear division between the discourses of large firm and consortia foundation employees, on one hand, and small firm and non-profit foundation employees, on the other. These divisions reflect these entities’ roles in the data economy and levels of concern about predatory “Big Tech” practices, which transform common goods to be shared into proprietary assets to be sold.


  • Open Access

    Digital Commons for the Ecological Transition: Ethics, Praxis and Policies

    by Sébastien Shulz, Mathieu O’nEil, Sébastien Broca, Angela Daly

    The article seeks to understand how the digital commons movement addresses ecological issues, how its actors incorporate them into their ethics and praxis, and the challenges they face in scaling up to become a viable ecological alternative to digital capitalism. Building on three case studies, we show that the digital commons currently face three major limitations: reliance on unsustainable Big Tech products, inability or unwillingness to scale up, and negligible political support. Based on two Policy Labs we conducted with actors of the digital commons movement, we conclude by outlining proposals to overcome these limits by adopting E.O. Wright’s anti-capitalist strategies framework.


  • Co-producing industrial public goods on GitHub: Selective firm cooperation, volunteer-employee labour and participation inequality

    by Mathieu O’nEil, Laure Muselli, Xiaolan Cai, Stefano Zacchiroli

    The global economy’s digital infrastructure is based on free and open source software. To analyse how firms indirectly collaborate via employee contributions to developer-run projects, we propose a formal definition of ‘industrial public goods’ – inter-firm cooperation, volunteer and paid labour overlap, and participation inequality. We verify its empirical robustness by collecting networks of commits made by firm employees to active GitHub software repositories. Despite paid workers making more contributions, volunteers play a significant role. We find which firms contribute most, which projects benefit from firm investments, and identify distinct ‘contribution territories’ since the two central firms never co-contribute to top-20 repositories. We highlight the challenge posed by ‘Big Tech’ to the non-rival status of industrial public goods, thanks to cloud-based systems which resist sharing, and suggest there may be ‘contribution deserts’ neglected by large information technology firms, despite their importance for the open source ecosystem’s sustainability and diversity.


  • Mapping the connections of health professionals to COVID-19 myths and facts in the Australian Twittersphere

    by Mathieu O’neil, Irfan Khan, Kate Holland, Xiaolan Cai

    The spread of COVID-19 misinformation on social media has elicited concern amongst scholars, health agencies and governments owing to its potential harms to public health. This article addresses the question of how networks of Australian health professionals engaged with COVID-19 facts and myths on Twitter between August and October 2020. After reviewing selected literature on COVID-19 misinformation, we present our analytical choices and the methodology we used to constitute datasets of COVID-19 factual and mythical hashtags and of verified Australian health professional accounts (N:377). The article distinguishes between the capacities of ‘actor-actants’ and ‘issue-actants,’ and between the adoption of ‘field’ and ‘contested’ hashtags during a controversy. We identify categories of Australian health professional Twitter accounts such as GPs, nurses, specialists, public health professionals and researchers, and analyse the patterns of connections between these actor-actants and COVID-19 facts and myths. We find that these categories exhibit clearly distinct behaviour when tweeting or retweeting factual and mythical hashtags. Even though the rate of Australian health professionals’ connection with myths in comparison to facts on Twitter is low, hashtags such as #hydroxychloroquine attracted significant engagement. We examine these hashtags’ context and find that they were mainly being debunked, though a minority of accounts endorsed them. We analyse these adoption patterns, and critically assess the ‘echo chamber effect.’ We also consider public health and privacy implications for the dissemination of accurate information, for trust in health professionals during a pandemic, and for combatting misinformation.


  • ‘Open source has won and lost the war’: Legitimising commercial–communal hybridisation in a FOSS project

    by Mathieu O’nEil, Laure Muselli, Mahin Raissi, Stefano Zacchiroli

    Information technology (IT) firms are paying developers in Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) projects, leading to the emergence of hybrid forms of work. In order to understand how the firm–project hybridisation process occurs, we present the results of an online survey of participants in the Debian project, as well as interviews with Debian Developers. We find that the intermingling of the commercial logic of the firm and the communal logic of the project requires rhetorical legitimation. We analyse the discourses used to legitimise firm–project cooperation as well as the organisational mechanisms which facilitate this cooperation. A first phase of legitimation, based on firm adoption of open licenses and developer self-fulfilment, aims to erase the commercial/communal divide. A second more recent phase seeks to professionalise work relations inside the project and, in doing so, challenges the social order which restricts participation in FOSS. Ultimately, hybridisation raises the question of the fair distribution of the profits firms derive from FOSS.


  • Online Field Theory

    by Mathieu O’nEil, Robert Ackland


  • Risk issue adoption in an online social movement field

    by Mathieu O’nEil, Robert Ackland

    This article extends the field conceptualisation of social change and innovation adoption, which hinges upon the strategic capacities of actors, to the online environment. We focus on a key aspect of social movement organisations (SMOs), competition for members, resources and attention over an environmental risk issue. The incorporation of network theory enables us to map how the structural position of actors in the field is associated with their actions – for example, their response to an exogenous shock such as a new threat to the environment. We analyse how actors in the online environmental movement respond to the emergence of nanoscience and technology (NST) as a risk issue, and test the field theory hypothesis that dominated actors are more likely to adopt this issue in the early stages of emergence. Our findings challenge field theory orthodoxy and suggest that whilst challengers innovate, dominants co-opt by adopting the issue in a second stage. Finally, we examine why the notion that NST entails significant environmental and health risks was not propelled into wider public consciousness.


  • Online Field Theory

    by Mathieu O’NEil, Robert Ackland