NBNicolas Butel

Nicolas Butel

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Nicolas Butel has a total of 51 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:

  • Claudia Köhler

    Department of Plant Reproductive Biology and Epigenetics, Max Planck Institute of Molecular Plant Physiology, Potsdam, Germany

    5 shared publications
  • Hervé Vaucheret

    Universite Paris-Saclay, INRAE, AgroParisTech, Institut Jean-Pierre Bourgin for Plant Sciences , 78000 Versailles

    5 shared publications
  • Juan Santos-González

    Department of Plant Biology, Uppsala BioCenter, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences and Linnean Centre for Plant Biology, Uppsala, Sweden

    4 shared publications
  • Zhenxing Wang

    State Key Laboratory of Crop Genetics & Germplasm Enhancement and Utilization, Key Laboratory of Flower Biology and Germplasm Innovation, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, College of Horticulture, Nanjing Agricultural University , Nanjing, Jiangsu 211800

    4 shared publications
  • Agnès Yu

    Universite Paris-Saclay, INRAE, AgroParisTech, Institut Jean-Pierre Bourgin for Plant Sciences , 78000 Versailles

    2 shared publications
  • Andana Barrios

    Universite Paris-Saclay, INRAE, AgroParisTech, Institut Jean-Pierre Bourgin for Plant Sciences, 78000 Versailles, France

    2 shared publications

Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Distinct thresholds condition sense PTGS initiation and amplification

    by Martin Lacroix, Nicolas Butel, Andana Barrios, Agnès Yu, Nathalie Bouteiller, Ivan Le Masson, Hervé Vaucheret

    It has long been known that Pro35S-driven sense transgenes have a high propensity to undergo post-transcriptional gene silencing (S-PTGS). However, what exactly conditions S-PTGS initiation and amplification to make it systemic remains unknown. Through genetic screens, we show that antagonistic chromatin-related mutations enhancing and reducing transgene expression, result in enhanced and reduced S-PTGS amplification capacities, respectively, without affecting the initiation rate. Analysis of a large set of independent transgenic plants confirm a direct relationship between transgene expression and its capacity to amplify S-PTGS. Combining an inducible or a tissue-specifically expressed GUS transgene with a Pro35S:GUS transgene locus prone to amplify S-PTGS but unable to spontaneously initiate it induces systemic S-PTGS, indicating that transient and/or local passing of a discrete threshold is sufficient to initiate S-PTGS. Together, these results call for the existence of distinct thresholds related to transiently produced aberrant RNA and permanently produced target mRNA levels, which condition S-PTGS initiation and amplification, respectively. We show that this model also applies to endogenous genes for which RNA Quality Control (RQC) acts as a first layer of protection against S-PTGS, and DCL2’s obscuration by DCL4 as a second layer, allowing RQC to dysfunction locally without translating into the drama of systemic S-PTGS.


  • Open Access

    Distinct thresholds condition sense PTGS initiation and amplification

    by Martin Lacroix, Nicolas Butel, Andana Barrios, Agnès Yu, Nathalie Bouteiller, Ivan Le Masson, Hervé Vaucheret

    It has long been known that Pro35S- driven sense transgenes have a high propensity to undergo post-transcriptional gene silencing (S-PTGS). However, what exactly conditions S-PTGS initiation and amplification to make it systemic remains unknown. Through genetic screens, we show that antagonistic chromatin-related mutations enhancing and reducing transgene expression, result in enhanced and reduced S-PTGS amplification capacities, respectively, without affecting the initiation rate. Analysis of a large set of independent transgenic plants confirm a direct relationship between transgene expression and its capacity to amplify S-PTGS. Combining an inducible or a tissue-specifically expressed GUS transgene with a Pro35S:GUS transgene locus prone to amplify S-PTGS but unable to spontaneously initiate it induces systemic S-PTGS, indicating that transient and/or local passing of a discrete threshold is sufficient to initiate S-PTGS. Together, these results call for the existence of distinct thresholds related to transiently produced aberrant RNA and permanently produced target mRNA levels, which condition S-PTGS initiation and amplification, respectively. We show that this model also applies to endogenous genes for which RNA Quality Control (RQC) acts as a first layer of protection against S-PTGS, and DCL2’s obscuration by DCL4 as a second layer, allowing RQC to dysfunction locally without translating into the drama of systemic S-PTGS.

  • Open Access

    Parental conflict driven regulation of endosperm cellularization by a family of Auxin Response Factors

    by N. Butel, Y. Qiu, W. Xu, J. Santos-González, C. Köhler

    The endosperm is a reproductive tissue supporting embryo development. In most flowering plants, the initial divisions of endosperm nuclei are not succeeded by cellularization; this process occurs only after a specific number of mitotic cycles have taken place. The timing of cellularization significantly influences seed viability and size. Previous research implicated auxin as a key factor in initiating nuclear divisions and determining the timing of cellularization. Here we uncover the involvement of a family of clustered auxin response factors (cARFs) as dosage-sensitive regulators of endosperm cellularization. cARFs, maternally expressed and paternally silenced, are shown to induce cellularization, thereby restricting seed growth. Our findings align with the predictions of the parental conflict theory, suggesting that cARFs represent major molecular targets in this conflict. We further demonstrate a recurring amplification of cARFs in the Brassicaceae, suggesting an evolutionary response to parental conflict by reinforcing maternal control over endosperm cellularization. Our study highlights that antagonistic parental control on endosperm cellularization converges on auxin biosynthesis and signalling.


  • Open Access

    Contrasting epigenetic control of transgenes and endogenous genes promotes post-transcriptional transgene silencing in Arabidopsis

    by Nicolas Butel, Agnès Yu, Ivan Le Masson, Filipe Borges, Taline Elmayan, Christelle Taochy, Nial R. Gursanscky, Jiangling Cao, Shengnan Bi, Anne Sawyer, et al.

    Transgenes that are stably expressed in plant genomes over many generations could be assumed to behave epigenetically the same as endogenous genes. Here, we report that whereas the histone H3K9me2 demethylase IBM1, but not the histone H3K4me3 demethylase JMJ14, counteracts DNA methylation of Arabidopsis endogenous genes, JMJ14, but not IBM1, counteracts DNA methylation of expressed transgenes. Additionally, JMJ14-mediated specific attenuation of transgene DNA methylation enhances the production of aberrant RNAs that readily induce systemic post-transcriptional transgene silencing (PTGS). Thus, the JMJ14 chromatin modifying complex maintains expressed transgenes in a probationary state of susceptibility to PTGS, suggesting that the host plant genome does not immediately accept expressed transgenes as being epigenetically the same as endogenous genes.


  • Open Access

    Transgenerational effect of mutants in the RNA-directed DNA methylation pathway on the triploid block in Arabidopsis

    by Zhenxing Wang, Nicolas Butel, Juan Santos-González, Lauriane Simon, Cecilia Wärdig, Claudia Köhler

    Background: Hybridization of plants that differ in number of chromosome sets (ploidy) frequently causes endosperm failure and seed arrest, a phenomenon referred to as triploid block. In Arabidopsis, loss of function of NRPD1, encoding the largest subunit of the plant-specific RNA polymerase IV (Pol IV), can suppress the triploid block. Pol IV generates short RNAs required to guide de novo methylation in the RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM) pathway. Recent work suggests that suppression of the triploid block by mutants in RdDM components differs, depending on whether the diploid pollen is derived from tetraploid plants or from the omission in second division 1 (osd1) mutant. This study aims to understand this difference. Results: In this study, we find that the ability of mutants in the RdDM pathway to suppress the triploid block depends on their degree of inbreeding. While first homozygous generation mutants in RdDM components NRPD1, RDR2, NRPE1, and DRM2 have weak or no ability to rescue the triploid block, they are able to suppress the triploid block with successive generations of inbreeding. Inbreeding of nrpd1 was connected with a transgenerational loss of non-CG DNA methylation on sites jointly regulated by CHROMOMETHYLASES 2 and 3. Conclusions: Our data reveal that loss of RdDM function differs in its effect in early and late generations, which has important implications when interpreting the effect of RdDM mutants.


  • Open Access

    Transgenerational effect of mutants in the RNA-directed DNA methylation pathway on the triploid block

    by Zhenxing Wang, Nicolas Butel, Juan Santos-González, Lauriane Simon, Cecilia Wärdig, Claudia Köhler

    Hybridization of plants that differ in number of chromosome sets (ploidy) frequently causes endosperm failure and seed arrest, a phenomenon referred to as triploid block. Mutation in NRPD1 , encoding the largest subunit of the plant-specific RNA Polymerase IV (Pol IV), can suppress the triploid block. Pol IV generates short RNAs required to guide de novo methylation in the RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM) pathway. In this study, we found that the ability of mutants in the RdDM pathway to suppress the triploid block depends on their degree of inbreeding. While nrpd1 is able to suppress in the first homozygous generation, mutants in RDR2 , NRPE1 , and DRM2 require at least one additional round of inbreeding to exert a suppressive effect. Inbreeding of nrpd1 was connected with a transgenerational loss of non-CG DNA methylation on sites jointly regulated by CHROMOMETHYLASES 2 and 3. Our data thus reveal that loss of RdDM function differs in its effect in early and late generations and that Pol IV acts at an early stage of triploid block establishment. One-sentence summary: Inbreeding of mutants impaired in RdDM components transgenerationally enhanced their ability to suppress the triploid block.


  • Open Access

    Polymerase IV Plays a Crucial Role in Pollen Development in Capsella

    by Zhenxing Wang, Nicolas Butel, Juan Santos-González, Filipe Borges, Jun Yi, Robert A. Martienssen, German Martinez, Claudia Köhler

    Unlike in Arabidopsis, loss of function of Polymerase IV in the Brassicaceae species Capsella rubella causes microspore arrest, revealing an important role for


  • Open Access

    Functional role of Polymerase IV during pollen development inCapsella

    by Zhenxing Wang, Nicolas Butel, Juan Santos-González, Filipe Borges, Jun Yi, Robert A Martienssen, German Martinez, Claudia Köhler

    InArabidopsis thaliana,the DNA-dependent RNA polymerase IV (Pol IV) is required for the formation of transposable element (TE)-derived small RNA (sRNA) transcripts. These transcripts are processed by DICER-LIKE 3 into 24-nt small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) that guide RNA-dependent DNA methylation. In the pollen grain, Pol IV is also required for the accumulation of 21/22-nt epigenetically-activated siRNAs (easiRNAs) that likely silence TEs by post-transcriptional mechanisms. Despite this proposed functional role, loss of Pol IV function inArabidopsisdoes not cause a discernable pollen defect. Here, we show that loss ofNRPD1,encoding the largest subunit of Pol IV in the BrassicaceaeCapsella rubella,causes post-meiotic arrest of pollen development at the microspore stage. As inArabidopsis,all TE-derived siRNAs were depleted inCapsella nrpd1microspores. In wild-type background, we found that the same TEs produced 21/22-nt and 24-nt siRNAs, leading us to propose that Pol IV is generating the direct precursors for 21-24-nt siRNAs, which are targeted by different DICERs. Arrest ofCapsella nrpd1microspores was accompanied by deregulation of genes targeted by Pol IV-dependent siRNAs. The distance of TEs to genes was much closer inCapsella rubellacompared toArabidopsis thaliana,providing a possible explanation for the essential role of Pol IV for pollen development inCapsella.Our study inCapsellauncovers a functional requirement of Pol IV in microspores, emphasizing the relevance of investigating different plant models.One-sentence summary: Loss of Polymerase IV function inCapsella rubellacauses microspore arrest, revealing an important functional role of Polymerase IV during pollen development.The author responsible for distribution of materials integral to the findings presented in this article in accordance with the policy described in the Instructions for Authors (www.plantcell.org) is: Claudia Kohler (Claudia.Kohler@slu.se)


  • Open Access

    RST1 and RIPR connect the cytosolic RNA exosome to the Ski complex in Arabidopsis

    by Heike Lange, Simon Y. A. Ndecky, Carlos Gomez-Diaz, David Pflieger, Nicolas Butel, Julie Zumsteg, Lauriane Kuhn, Christina Piermaria, Johana Chicher, Michael Christie, et al.

    The RNA exosome is a key 3’−5’ exoribonuclease with an evolutionarily conserved structure and function. Its cytosolic functions require the co-factors SKI7 and the Ski complex. Here we demonstrate by co-purification experiments that the ARM-repeat protein RESURRECTION1 (RST1) and RST1 INTERACTING PROTEIN (RIPR) connect the cytosolic Arabidopsis RNA exosome to the Ski complex. rst1 and ripr mutants accumulate RNA quality control siRNAs (rqc-siRNAs) produced by the post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) machinery when mRNA degradation is compromised. The small RNA populations observed in rst1 and ripr mutants are also detected in mutants lacking the RRP45B/CER7 core exosome subunit. Thus, molecular and genetic evidence supports a physical and functional link between RST1, RIPR and the RNA exosome. Our data reveal the existence of additional cytosolic exosome co-factors besides the known Ski subunits. RST1 is not restricted to plants, as homologues with a similar domain architecture but unknown function exist in animals, including humans.


  • Open Access

    RST1 and RIPR connect the cytosolic RNA exosome to the Ski complex in Arabidopsis

    by Heike Lange, Simon Y. A. Ndecky, Carlos Gomez-Diaz, David Pflieger, Nicolas Butel, Julie Zumsteg, Lauriane Kuhn, Christina Piermaria, Johana Chicher, Michael Christie, et al.

    The RNA exosome is a key 3’-5’ exoribonuclease with an evolutionarily conserved structure and function. Its cytosolic functions require the co-factors SKI7 and the Ski complex. Here we demonstrate by co-purification experiments that the ARM repeat protein RESURRECTION1 (RST1) and RST1 INTERACTING PROTEIN (RIPR) connect the cytosolic Arabidopsis RNA exosome to the Ski complex. rst1 and ripr mutants accumulate RNA quality control siRNAs (rqc-siRNAs) produced by the post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) machinery when mRNA degradation is compromised. The small RNA populations observed in rst1 and ripr mutants are also detected in mutants lacking the RRP45B/CER7 core exosome subunit. Thus, molecular and genetic evidence supports a physical and functional link between RST1, RIPR and the RNA exosome. Our data reveal the existence of additional cytosolic exosome co-factors besides the known SKI subunits. RST1 is not restricted to plants, as homologues with a similar domain architecture but unknown function exist in animals, including humans.