CBChiara Bortolotto

Chiara Bortolotto

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Chiara Bortolotto has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Creativity and innovation in heritage bureaucracy

    by Chiara Bortolotto, Florence Graezer Bideau

    The nomination of Avalanche Risk Management (ARM) to UNESCO’s Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity illustrates how heritage governance can become a site of bureaucratic creativity and political innovation. In contrast to folkloric and identitarian understandings of intangible heritage, ARM positions traditional knowledge as a forward-looking resource for climate change adaptation and sustainable development. Drawing on the Swiss case, this chapter examines how administrative procedures and expert interventions reframe heritage as a strategic tool for environmental governance. Ethnographic attention to two experts, one a cantonal museum director, the other a federal heritage official, highlights the role of individual agency, ethical commitments, and professional trajectories in shaping institutional choices. Their work demonstrates how heritage bureaucrats mobilize anthropological expertise and civic engagement to challenge conventional representations of intangible heritage while aligning with global sustainability agendas. At once innovative and abstract, ARM reveals the tensions between intellectualized, policy-oriented heritage projects and more emotionally resonant, identity-based and community-driven traditions.

  • Open Access

    Engagement et militance

    by Chiara Bortolotto, Christine Noiville

    Respectivement titulaire de la chaire Unesco « Patrimoine culturel immatériel et développement durable » et présidente du Comité d’éthique du CNRS, Chiara Bortolotto et Christine Noiville évoquent pour La lettre de l’Ocim la question de la frontière entre engagement et militance, pour les professionnels des musées et du patrimoine et pour les chercheurs. Selon les deux universitaires, concilier sauvegarde du passé et exigences du présent, dans un monde en mutation qui génère de multiples tensions, demande inévitablement une certaine forme d’engagement.Propos recueillis par Isabelle Fougère

  • Let’s get together: The making of shared heritage between bureaucratization of utopia and utopianization of bureaucracy

    by Chiara Bortolotto

    Cet article traite de la corrélation entre bureaucratie, idéologies d’échelle et utopie dans la production du « patrimoine partagé » comme incarnation de l’idéal porté par l’UNESCO pour rapprocher les peuples par-delà les frontières physiques et symboliques. L’utopie scalaire de l’UNESCO est explorée en mettant l’accent sur la promotion des « candidatures multi-nationales » à la Liste représentative du patrimoine culturel immatériel. Leur agentivité politique est illustrée par la candidature binationale de la lutte coréenne qui célèbre le partage d’une même culture par des pays rivaux. Ce dispositif est comparé à la rhétorique universaliste des débats qui ont accompagné l’inscription du reggae et du yoga sur la même liste. Une observation participante du dispositif global du patrimoine culturel immatériel met en évidence l’ingéniosité des fonctionnaires du patrimoine dans leur poursuite d’idéaux d’unité : des technologies administratives créant des représentations du patrimoine partagé sont conçues et mises en œuvre dans un processus qui rend l’utopie bureaucratique et la bureaucratie utopique.


  • Top Cited Papers

    Sharing heritage? Politics and territoriality in UNESCO’s heritage lists

    by Bernard Debarbieux, Chiara Bortolotto, Hervé Munz, Cecilia Raziano

    UNESCO heritage policies encourage the idea that heritage should be ‘shared’ at the international scale, and invite states and the involved actors to adopt this vision. Yet, ‘sharedness’ can be understood in many different ways. This paper explores several territorial and political issues related to this notion of sharedness. A focus on the uses of a particular UNESCO tool – ‘multinational nominations’ – sheds a light on transnational cultural practices and examines forms of cooperation within communities and between states in the framework of the Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH). Specifically, it analyses the work of a French commission for the ICH as well as the nomination processes of three different cultural practices to the ICH lists: flamenco, falconry and alpinism. It is argued that ‘shared heritage’ is interpreted in a variety of ways, leading to contrastive appropriations and competing territorial scenarios among the various protagonists.


  • Commercialization without over-commercialization: normative conundrums across heritage rationalities

    by Chiara Bortolotto

    In aligning its priorities around the Sustainable Development Goals, UNESCO officially acknowledges the need to reconcile the market and heritage. Yet inscriptions of commercial practices on the Intangible Cultural Heritage lists are qualified as ‘traumatic’ by actors that design normative principles for ‘good’ heritage governance. Based on ethnographic observations of the meetings of the governing bodies of the Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage, I analyse the controversies generated by the ‘risks of over-commercialization’, shedding light on the disputed entanglements between ICH and the market. In exploring the notion of ‘commercialization without over-commercialization’ meant to resolve the tension between heritage and the market, I highlight how ‘over-commercialization’ refers to notions of ‘misappropriation’ and ‘decontextualization’ and the ways it, therefore, intersects with the logics of Intellectual Property. This allows to elucidate a constitutive ambiguity in the implementation of the Convention, torn between the rationalities of heritage and property regimes.


  • Proving participation: vocational bureaucrats and bureaucratic creativity in the implementation of the UNESCO Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage

    by Chiara Bortolotto, Philipp Demgenski, Panas Karampampas, Simone Toji

    This paper investigates the bureaucratisation of the (utopian) ideal of community participation in Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH) safeguarding and management. The analysis considers the whole ‘policy life’ of the UNESCO Convention for the Safeguarding of ICH. Our ethnographic examples from UNESCO, Brazil, China and Greece illustrate how bureaucratic operations often disenchant the participatory ideal, alienating it from its original intention. At the same time, driven by their commitment to ‘good’ governance and informed by sentiments of frustration and disappointment with actual policy results, vocational bureaucrats at different administrative levels experiment with and conceive of new tools in order to produce evidence of participation. We demonstrate how this bureaucratic creativity has concrete consequences, which may differ from the intended utopia, but nevertheless bring to life particular interpretations of the participatory principle among the recipients for whom heritage policies were originally designed. Thus, we present a more nuanced picture of bureaucratisation in which officials’ emotions and engagement sustain their agency against structural constraints as well as the futility and fragility of administrative procedures.


  • Le patrimoine immatériel et le tabou de l’authenticité : de la pérennisation à la durabilité

    by Chiara Bortolotto

    Conçu historiquement comme objet de conservation dont le monument est l’incarnation exemplaire, le patrimoine est désormais défini comme « recréé en permanence » (Unesco 2003 : art. 2) et conçu comme une ressource dynamique où l’impératif de la transmission du vivant fait du futur le temps fort du patrimoine1. Loin d’incarner banalement une coupure aberrante et artificielle entre matériel et immatériel, le concept de patrimoine culturel immatériel introduit par l’Organisation des Nations Unie...


  • The French Inventory of Intangible Cultural Heritage: Domesticating a Global Paradigm into French Heritage Regime

    by Chiara Bortolotto

    Acknowledgements. I would like to thank Regina Bendix, Aditya Eggert, David Berliner, and Christian Hottin for their comments on the manuscript of this article. This research is the result of a broader research project (ICHEUROPE) funded by a Marie Curie fellowship (FP7-PEOPLE-2009-IEF) and conducted at the Laboratoire d’Anthropologie des Mondes Contemporains in the Université Libre de Bruxelles.