SWScarlet Wilcock

Scarlet Wilcock

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Scarlet Wilcock has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Welfare Compliance and Domestic Violence: How Australia's Welfare Fraud Tip-Off Line is Used as a Tool of State Violence Against Women

    by Lyndal Sleep, Scarlet Wilcock, Nan Seuffert

    In this article, we contribute to the literature on state violence against women (VAW) by examining the intersection of domestic violence and welfare fraud tip-off lines. Tip-off lines enable anonymous reporting of suspected welfare fraud, forming part of the punitive welfare-to-work reforms within Western democratic nation states. Via examination of interviews with victims/survivors and community lawyers, alongside analysis of social security appeal decisions, we argue that Australia's welfare system, which claims to prioritize supporting women affected by domestic violence, may instead be complicit in, intensify, and perpetrate VAW through its administrative compliance procedures as a form of state systems abuse.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    The Digital Welfare State: Conceptual limits and possibilities

    by Scarlet Wilcock, Georgia van Toorn

    The concept of the digital welfare state (DWS) has gained popularity in research on welfare system digitalization, but its meaning is under-theorized and largely unproblematized. Invoked without clear criteria, the concept leaves open fundamental questions about what qualifies as a DWS and why. In this article, we propose three key pillars as foundational criteria for analyses of the DWS: (1) the presence of a welfare state, (2) processes of digitalization – encompassing older digital technologies and more advanced technologies and their interplay with enduring manual processes, and (3) the degree of digitalization and whether this warrants a particular welfare state's classification as digital. We argue that these pillars, although seemingly self-evident, raise under-explored questions about the theoretical foundations and boundaries of the DWS concept. In highlighting these questions, we reveal that much of the literature is characterized by single country case studies, assumptions of linear change, and a degree of Western-centrism, which leaves broader patterns of digital welfare reform, and the role of non-state actors therein, under-theorized if not overlooked. By foregrounding these limitations, we demonstrate how greater theoretical rigor and reflexivity can sharpen the concept's analytical and practical value. Properly specified, the DWS provides a useful heuristic for researching broad patterns of digitalization without flattening national or local specificities, and for equipping both scholars and policy makers with a clearer lens for critical engagement and political contestation.


  • Governing Welfare Fraud and Non-compliance in Neoliberal Times

    by Scarlet Wilcock

    The aim of this chapter is to outline the development of Australia’s contemporary welfare compliance regime to contextualise the present-focused chapters that follow. It picks up where the previous chapter left off, taking the election of the Hawke Labor Government in 1983 as its starting point. It was in the 1980s, during Hawke’s term in office, that Australia’s contemporary welfare compliance apparatus began to take shape. The chapter charts the development and consolidation of this contemporary welfare compliance regime and considers the extent to which these developments reflect and reify neoliberal rationalities. The chapter also describes Centrelink’s current organisational structure and approach to welfare fraud and non-compliance and introduces the key governmental techniques employed to police this problem today. This provides the foundation for elaborating on these specific governmentality techniques in the next four thematic chapters.

  • Managing ‘Risky’ Recipients

    by Scarlet Wilcock

    Chapter 5 describes and analyses the set of risk-based compliance strategies used to detect welfare non-compliance and fraud. It focuses on two specific risk profiling strategies, which were implemented in Australia in the mid-2010s: Data Mining Risk Profiling focused on detecting criminal fraud and Risk-based Compliance Reviews targeting welfare non-compliance and debt. The chapter also reflects on more recent developments in risk-based welfare surveillance tied to rapid technological advancements, including machine learning. Using these case studies, the chapter highlights and critiques the regressive effects of risk profiling in the realm of welfare compliance. It suggests that these techniques serve to increase the surveillance of the most economically and socially marginalised recipients, including poor single mothers. But, this chapter also demonstrates how risk logics are open to re-articulation alongside more progressive goals and agendas. This finding challenges strands of the risk literature, including scholarship inspired by the ‘new penology’ perspective, which assume that actuarial and algorithmic risk-based practices are necessarily regressive in their effects. Instead, inspired by scholars such as Pat O'Malley and Kelly Hannah-Moffat, this chapter illustrates the malleability of risk strategies and reinforces the importance of examining welfare governance in situ.

  • Making Welfare Fraud ‘Everybody’s Business'

    by Scarlet Wilcock

    This chapter explores the set of strategies designed to enlist the public and welfare recipients themselves in the business of welfare compliance. This includes the introduction and promotion of fraud tip-off or ‘snitch’ lines and ‘voluntary compliance’ strategies that encourage welfare recipients to manage their own compliance risks. Drawing on the work of David Garland, these strategies can be understood as a form of ‘responsibilisation’ in which responsibility for crime control functions is partially divested from the state to private citizens. As this chapter argues, the effect of responsibilisation strategies in the realm of welfare compliance is to recast the problem of welfare fraud as ‘everybody’s business’ rather than a problem solely for the state. This serves to deflect blame away from the state, not just for the problem of welfare fraud but for the broader failings of welfare provision.

  • Deterrence, Disruption, Deservingness

    by Scarlet Wilcock

    This chapter is concerned with welfare fraud prosecution strategies and particularly the changed basis for investigating and prosecuting welfare fraud in Australia. I characterise this shift as a move from a ‘prosecution-first’ mentality to an approach underpinned by the technology of Intelligence-Led Policing (ILP). Drawing on detailed analyses of interview and documentary data, I describe and interrogate the technologies and effects of these two approaches. Where the first relies on quantitative targets, decentralisation and the pursuit of prosecution at any cost, the ILP model invokes the strategies of centralisation, economic efficiency and disruption tactics. As I argue in this chapter, this new regime has also provided scope for investigators to consider the impacts of prosecution on social security recipients and question the use of prosecution in some circumstances. This has, at times, resulted in the less punitive treatment of welfare recipients.

  • Preventing or Pre-empting Welfare Compliance? Policing the Borders of the Welfare State

    by Scarlet Wilcock

    This chapter examines the deployment of pre-emptive compliance strategies, which seek to anticipate and forestall welfare fraud and abuse. These strategies include ‘front door’ claim verification measures, notably proof of identity procedures and verification of a recipients’ relationship status, as well as measures applied to the social security population on an ongoing basis, such as data matching (including robodebt) and routine payment reviews. As this chapter demonstrates, these strategies involve future-oriented forms of governance designed to intervene in and forestall potential non-compliance rather than respond to specific cases of actual or suspected non-compliance. The effect of this way of governing is to treat and therefore produce the social security population as a whole as risky. The rollout of a cumbersome and intrusive compliance regime emerges as a self-evident and necessary feature of the modern welfare state.

  • Policing Welfare Fraud

    by Scarlet Wilcock

    Policing Welfare Fraud charts and interrogates the suite of measures ostensibly designed to combat welfare fraud and non-compliance. In Australia, which serves as the empirical focus of this book, these strategies include stringent ID checks, pre-emptive data surveillance technologies including the infamous and illegal ‘robodebt’ programme, a dedicated fraud hotline and an ‘intelligence-led’ fraud investigation framework. Drawing on original documentary and interview data, including interviews with fraud investigators, this book unpacks the logics that underpin these anti-fraud initiatives with a focus on how these initiatives are imbued with logics and practices more readily associated with the criminal justice system. The central argument of the book is that the emergence of contemporary welfare compliance regimes represents a form of ‘governing through fraud’ in which the threat of welfare fraud has effectively necessitated a regime of criminalisation within the welfare state. This has been enabled by a broader process of neoliberal welfare reform, which has cast suspicion over all welfare use. The overall effect of this regime is to restrict access to social security, punish welfare recipients and stigmatise welfare use. Policing Welfare Fraud also highlights points of contradiction and multiplicity in the enactment of specific welfare compliance initiatives, including attempts by welfare officials to moderate or reformulate these strategies ‘on the ground’. These findings demonstrate that the criminalisation of welfare is neither uniform nor inexorable, and that more progressive welfare reform is possible. An accessible and compelling read, this book will appeal to students and scholars of criminology, sociology, politics and those interested in the policing of welfare recipients.


  • Introduction

    by Scarlet Wilcock

    The ‘Introduction’ outlines the background and motivation for the study and introduces the theoretical foundations for the research. It begins by introducing and problematising the progressive encroachment of criminal justice logics and practices into the arena of social security administration in post-Keynesian welfare states, including Australia, which provides the empirical focus of the book. It introduces the Australian ‘welfare compliance’ regime and situates this regime within the context of neoliberal welfare reform. The next part of this chapter outlines the structure of the Australian social security state for an international readership and defines the problems of welfare fraud and non-compliance. The chapter then discusses the key aims of the research and outlines the theoretical and methodological approach that underpins the study which draws on Foucault’s concept of ‘governmentality’. Finally, this chapter presents the structure of the book.