Nursaule Zh. Brimbetova
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Nursaule Zh. Brimbetova has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Azimkhan Satybaldin
Institute of Economics of SC MSHE RK, Almaty 050010, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications - Nailya K. Nurlanova
Doctor of Economics, Professor, Project Scientific Supervisor, Department of Regional Economy Development, Institute of Economics, Committee of Science of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan
2 shared publications - Nurgul K. Saparbek
Al-Farabi Kazakh National University
2 shared publications - Zaure K. Chulanova
Institute of Economics of the SC MSHE RK
2 shared publications - A. A. Sultanaev
Institute of Economics CS MSHE RK
1 shared publication - A. Balykbayeva
Al-Farabi Kazakh National University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 June 2026
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 2,p. 86-97
Wages in Kazakhstan: problems of regional-industrial differentiation and optimization prospects
This article examines the development of the wage system in Kazakhstan. The aim of this study is to examine the differentiation of employee wages in the Republic of Kazakhstan and develop recommendations for optimizing its structure across regions and industries. A systems approach was used to analyze wages across industries and regions, employing economic and statistical methods, classification, structural analysis, historical and comparative analysis, and participant observation across various organizations across the country. It was determined that the implementation of a market mechanism for wage regulation largely depends on the optimization of individual structural elements of wages. An important approach to addressing this issue is the de facto recognition of wages as the price of labor, established through collective bargaining between representatives of employees and employers in the labor market. The amount of wages for hired workers should initially be determined through collective bargaining agreements at all levels: industry, regional, and national. Implementing this provision requires a radical revision of the entire legislative framework governing labor relations and the transformation of trade unions into a real force in the negotiating process.
- 29 June 2026
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 2,p. 86-97
Open AccessWages in Kazakhstan: problems of regional-industrial differentiation and optimization prospects
This article examines the development of the wage system in Kazakhstan. The aim of this study is to examine the differentiation of employee wages in the Republic of Kazakhstan and develop recommendations for optimizing its structure across regions and industries. A systems approach was used to analyze wages across industries and regions, employing economic and statistical methods, classification, structural analysis, historical and comparative analysis, and participant observation across various organizations across the country. It was determined that the implementation of a market mechanism for wage regulation largely depends on the optimization of individual structural elements of wages. An important approach to addressing this issue is the de facto recognition of wages as the price of labor, established through collective bargaining between representatives of employees and employers in the labor market. The amount of wages for hired workers should initially be determined through collective bargaining agreements at all levels: industry, regional, and national. Implementing this provision requires a radical revision of the entire legislative framework governing labor relations and the transformation of trade unions into a real force in the negotiating process.
- 5 April 2026
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 21 (1)
Digital Finance and Agricultural Productivity Growth: Comparative Evidence from China and Kazakhstan
The digital transformation of the agricultural sector strengthens the role of digital infrastructure and financial inclusion as factors of productivity growth in agriculture in the context of structural modernization of the economy. The aim of the study is to assess the impact of digital infrastructure on agricultural productivity and to identify the cross—country heterogeneity of effects in economies with different levels of digitalization and institutional development. A balanced panel for 2011-2023 (26 observations) based on data from the World Bank and the International Labour Organisation was used. In the combined model, digital infrastructure demonstrates a positive and statistically significant relationship with performance (β = 0.7626; p < 0.01), with a high quality of fit (r2 = 0.946). The exclusion of pandemic years confirms the stability of the effect (β = 0.744; p < 0.01; r2 = 0.937). The cross-country analysis revealed heterogeneity: in China, the effect of digital infrastructure is positive and significant (β = 0.421; p < 0.01), while in Kazakhstan the coefficient is negative and weakly significant at the level of 10% (β = -0.483; p = 0.092), indicating differences in institutional readiness and the level of digital maturity. The results obtained confirm the importance of digital infrastructure in improving the efficiency of the agricultural sector, but demonstrate that the institutional and structural environment determines the scale and direction of this impact.
- 5 April 2026
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 21 (1)
Digital Finance and Agricultural Productivity Growth: Comparative Evidence from China and Kazakhstan
The digital transformation of the agricultural sector strengthens the role of digital infrastructure and financial inclusion as factors of productivity growth in agriculture in the context of structural modernization of the economy. The aim of the study is to assess the impact of digital infrastructure on agricultural productivity and to identify the cross—country heterogeneity of effects in economies with different levels of digitalization and institutional development. A balanced panel for 2011-2023 (26 observations) based on data from the World Bank and the International Labour Organisation was used. In the combined model, digital infrastructure demonstrates a positive and statistically significant relationship with performance (β = 0.7626; p < 0.01), with a high quality of fit (r2 = 0.946). The exclusion of pandemic years confirms the stability of the effect (β = 0.744; p < 0.01; r2 = 0.937). The cross-country analysis revealed heterogeneity: in China, the effect of digital infrastructure is positive and significant (β = 0.421; p < 0.01), while in Kazakhstan the coefficient is negative and weakly significant at the level of 10% (β = -0.483; p = 0.092), indicating differences in institutional readiness and the level of digital maturity. The results obtained confirm the importance of digital infrastructure in improving the efficiency of the agricultural sector, but demonstrate that the institutional and structural environment determines the scale and direction of this impact.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Academy Qainar in Qainar Journal of Social Science
- Vol. 5 (1) , 87-107
Regional Social and Economic Imbalances: Evidence from Data Envelopment Analysis in Kazakhstan
The problem of territorial socio-economic imbalances remains one of the key issues in Kazakhstan's regional policy, as differences between the economic potential of regions and the achieved social results persist even with sustained economic growth. The purpose of the study is to evaluate the effectiveness of the transformation of economic and infrastructural resources of the regions of Kazakhstan into social results, primarily in reducing poverty and unemployment. The methodological basis of the study is the nonparametric method of Data Envelope Analysis (DEA), which makes it possible to assess the relative effectiveness of regions as decision-making units in converting resources into social outcomes. The results of the DEA analysis showed that 13 of the 20 regions achieved full efficiency, while 7 regions demonstrated relative inefficiency, including Almaty с. (0.8087), Mangystau (0.8840) and Pavlodar (0.9327) regions. At the same time, a territorial differentiation of social indicators was revealed: the depth of poverty varies from 0.3 to 1.6, and the proportion of the population with incomes below the subsistence level ranges from less than 3% to more than 8%. The results showed that a high level of economic development in the region does not guarantee proportionately high social efficiency, and territorial imbalances are associated with differences in management efficiency and resource use. A promising area of further research is to expand the time coverage of the analysis through the use of panel data, which will allow us to assess the dynamics of the relative effectiveness of regions and identify trends in the transformation of economic resources into social outcomes.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Academy Qainar in Qainar Journal of Social Science
- Vol. 5 (1) , 87-107
Open AccessRegional Social and Economic Imbalances: Evidence from Data Envelopment Analysis in Kazakhstan
The problem of territorial socio-economic imbalances remains one of the key issues in Kazakhstan's regional policy, as differences between the economic potential of regions and the achieved social results persist even with sustained economic growth. The purpose of the study is to evaluate the effectiveness of the transformation of economic and infrastructural resources of the regions of Kazakhstan into social results, primarily in reducing poverty and unemployment. The methodological basis of the study is the nonparametric method of Data Envelope Analysis (DEA), which makes it possible to assess the relative effectiveness of regions as decision-making units in converting resources into social outcomes. The results of the DEA analysis showed that 13 of the 20 regions achieved full efficiency, while 7 regions demonstrated relative inefficiency, including Almaty с. (0.8087), Mangystau (0.8840) and Pavlodar (0.9327) regions. At the same time, a territorial differentiation of social indicators was revealed: the depth of poverty varies from 0.3 to 1.6, and the proportion of the population with incomes below the subsistence level ranges from less than 3% to more than 8%. The results showed that a high level of economic development in the region does not guarantee proportionately high social efficiency, and territorial imbalances are associated with differences in management efficiency and resource use. A promising area of further research is to expand the time coverage of the analysis through the use of panel data, which will allow us to assess the dynamics of the relative effectiveness of regions and identify trends in the transformation of economic resources into social outcomes.
- Open Access
- 7 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 16 (16) , 6752
Poverty in the Kazakhstan Regions: Assessing the Influence of Key Indicators on Differences in Its Level
Modern Kazakhstan is characterized by significant regional socioeconomic differences due to climatic conditions, natural resources, migration, and regional specialization. The persistence of these regional differences can lead to increased stratification of society, social tension, and disruption of the country’s economic stability. These issues have intensified under the influence of Industry 4.0 trends and geopolitical processes in the region. Among the various sources of social inequality, we have chosen to focus on the problem of population poverty in our study. Addressing this problem is crucial for taking a comprehensive approach to addressing regional disparities in social development. The purpose of our study is to determine and assess the features of poverty in the regions of Kazakhstan. Our research methodology is based on evaluating the integral poverty index using four indicators: the share of the population with incomes below the subsistence level, the population under 60 years of age, youth aged 15–17 who are not working or studying, and the unemployment rate in the regions of Kazakhstan. Based on these indicators, we grouped the regions according to their poverty level, identified and compared regional differences, and identified the most vulnerable areas in need of intervention. This approach has enabled us to propose appropriate instruments of state support for different territories and promote inclusive regional development to overcome social imbalances.
- 7 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 16 (16) , 6752
Open AccessPoverty in the Kazakhstan Regions: Assessing the Influence of Key Indicators on Differences in Its Level
Modern Kazakhstan is characterized by significant regional socioeconomic differences due to climatic conditions, natural resources, migration, and regional specialization. The persistence of these regional differences can lead to increased stratification of society, social tension, and disruption of the country’s economic stability. These issues have intensified under the influence of Industry 4.0 trends and geopolitical processes in the region. Among the various sources of social inequality, we have chosen to focus on the problem of population poverty in our study. Addressing this problem is crucial for taking a comprehensive approach to addressing regional disparities in social development. The purpose of our study is to determine and assess the features of poverty in the regions of Kazakhstan. Our research methodology is based on evaluating the integral poverty index using four indicators: the share of the population with incomes below the subsistence level, the population under 60 years of age, youth aged 15–17 who are not working or studying, and the unemployment rate in the regions of Kazakhstan. Based on these indicators, we grouped the regions according to their poverty level, identified and compared regional differences, and identified the most vulnerable areas in need of intervention. This approach has enabled us to propose appropriate instruments of state support for different territories and promote inclusive regional development to overcome social imbalances.
- Open Access
- 3 October 2023
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 18 (3) , 140-156
New Opportunities and Prerequisites for Cross-Border Cooperation between Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan
The purpose of this article is to explore the cross-border processes of neighbouring countries based on the interaction and mutual influence of the economies of Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan and to identify new opportunities in the development of border areas. Scientific research has been studied and a review of literary sources reflecting not only the processes of interaction between Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan in the field of economics, politics, economic security, education and the formation of infrastructure projects has been conducted. Research and compare the economic development of the two countries, show the economic and resource potential and give a comparative description of the development of border areas. The research methodology was aimed at a comprehensive analysis of cooperation priorities based on a survey of the main documents on cross-border cooperation of international organizations, including a database on measuring and monitoring the effectiveness of corridors; conducting a comprehensive statistical analysis of data from the Bureau of Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Economic Reform of the Republic of Kazakhstan, international rating agencies; assessing the distribution of regions of Kazakhstan in terms of per capita GRP; development and calculation of the coefficient of uneven economic development of the regions of Kazakhstan; conducting a rating of regions of Uzbekistan in terms of GRP per capita
- 3 October 2023
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 18 (3) , 140-156
Open AccessNew Opportunities and Prerequisites for Cross-Border Cooperation between Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan
The purpose of this article is to explore the cross-border processes of neighbouring countries based on the interaction and mutual influence of the economies of Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan and to identify new opportunities in the development of border areas. Scientific research has been studied and a review of literary sources reflecting not only the processes of interaction between Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan in the field of economics, politics, economic security, education and the formation of infrastructure projects has been conducted. Research and compare the economic development of the two countries, show the economic and resource potential and give a comparative description of the development of border areas. The research methodology was aimed at a comprehensive analysis of cooperation priorities based on a survey of the main documents on cross-border cooperation of international organizations, including a database on measuring and monitoring the effectiveness of corridors; conducting a comprehensive statistical analysis of data from the Bureau of Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Economic Reform of the Republic of Kazakhstan, international rating agencies; assessing the distribution of regions of Kazakhstan in terms of per capita GRP; development and calculation of the coefficient of uneven economic development of the regions of Kazakhstan; conducting a rating of regions of Uzbekistan in terms of GRP per capita
- Open Access
- 3 April 2023
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 18 (1) , 36-54
Food Security and Social Development of Regions: International Experience
Food security is an economic category officially accepted in international practice, used to describe the state of the food market of a country or group of countries, as well as the world market that provides guaranteed access to all social groups. As world experience shows, special state bodies developed in the agro-industrial sphere have been established in all countries, performing the functions of regulating and protecting the agricultural sector and the agricultural food market. The main goal of our research work is to determine and prove the current level of food safety. At the same time, the social development of leading countries and determination of Kazakhstan’s priorities in this field using domestic food security policy. Materials on the regulation and support of food security in the USA and Brazil, which are of interest to other countries, are presented and analyzed. Our research paper also presents the policy of food security in China and the Russian Federation. Food security of the Republic of Kazakhstan is provided. In our opinion, a necessary and sufficient condition for food security is economic growth, which leads to an increase in food production, real incomes of people, and an active policy on the part of the state to help the poor. Ensuring food security is associated with the impact of various factors and conditions: as it is the driving force, the cause of the process, and the phenomenon. Food security is influenced by political, social, economic, natural and other factors.
- 3 April 2023
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 18 (1) , 36-54
Open AccessFood Security and Social Development of Regions: International Experience
Food security is an economic category officially accepted in international practice, used to describe the state of the food market of a country or group of countries, as well as the world market that provides guaranteed access to all social groups. As world experience shows, special state bodies developed in the agro-industrial sphere have been established in all countries, performing the functions of regulating and protecting the agricultural sector and the agricultural food market. The main goal of our research work is to determine and prove the current level of food safety. At the same time, the social development of leading countries and determination of Kazakhstan’s priorities in this field using domestic food security policy. Materials on the regulation and support of food security in the USA and Brazil, which are of interest to other countries, are presented and analyzed. Our research paper also presents the policy of food security in China and the Russian Federation. Food security of the Republic of Kazakhstan is provided. In our opinion, a necessary and sufficient condition for food security is economic growth, which leads to an increase in food production, real incomes of people, and an active policy on the part of the state to help the poor. Ensuring food security is associated with the impact of various factors and conditions: as it is the driving force, the cause of the process, and the phenomenon. Food security is influenced by political, social, economic, natural and other factors.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2022
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 3,p. 108-121
Poverty of population and regional differences in the social development of Kazakhstan
The purpose of this study is to determine the features of regional differences in social development, the ways of their cognition and regulation. Regional differences in the level of social development from the perspective of inclusiveness are understood as inequality of individuals or groups in access to material goods and services. The receipt of monetary income by the population is only an instrument of access to them. Therefore, in order to develop methodological approaches and make managerial decisions, it is important to answer two questions: what specific material goods and services are considered within the framework of social inequalities, how to assess the level of the latter? However, the presence of regional differences in social development contributes to the search for real opportunities of regions in smoothing or leveling imbalances, identifying the sources of their occurrence. This approach made it possible to develop specific mechanisms to overcome social imbalances that will ensure inclusive regional development. From the totality of the sources of social inequalities in the regions, the problems of poverty of the population are chosen as the subject of research. Solving this problem is a key position in an integrated approach to regulating regional differences in social development. The methodology of the study is based on the calculation of the population poverty index according to the recommendations of the UNDP on four indicators. Based on these indicators, the calculation of the integral poverty index of the population and the grouping of regions of Kazakhstan are made. This approach will make it possible to introduce adequate tools for state support of various territories. Today, the identification and assessment of the level of poverty of the population is very relevant, since ensuring the sustainable development of regions does not allow ignoring situations of social inequalities in society.
- 10 October 2022
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 3,p. 108-121
Open AccessPoverty of population and regional differences in the social development of Kazakhstan
The purpose of this study is to determine the features of regional differences in social development, the ways of their cognition and regulation. Regional differences in the level of social development from the perspective of inclusiveness are understood as inequality of individuals or groups in access to material goods and services. The receipt of monetary income by the population is only an instrument of access to them. Therefore, in order to develop methodological approaches and make managerial decisions, it is important to answer two questions: what specific material goods and services are considered within the framework of social inequalities, how to assess the level of the latter? However, the presence of regional differences in social development contributes to the search for real opportunities of regions in smoothing or leveling imbalances, identifying the sources of their occurrence. This approach made it possible to develop specific mechanisms to overcome social imbalances that will ensure inclusive regional development. From the totality of the sources of social inequalities in the regions, the problems of poverty of the population are chosen as the subject of research. Solving this problem is a key position in an integrated approach to regulating regional differences in social development. The methodology of the study is based on the calculation of the population poverty index according to the recommendations of the UNDP on four indicators. Based on these indicators, the calculation of the integral poverty index of the population and the grouping of regions of Kazakhstan are made. This approach will make it possible to introduce adequate tools for state support of various territories. Today, the identification and assessment of the level of poverty of the population is very relevant, since ensuring the sustainable development of regions does not allow ignoring situations of social inequalities in society.
- Open Access
- 30 April 2019
- Published by Korea Distribution Science Association in The Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business
- Vol. 6 (2) , 299-307
Reduction of Economic Disparities in the Regions of Kazakhstan Based on Inclusive Development
- 30 April 2019
- Published by Korea Distribution Science Association in The Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business
- Vol. 6 (2) , 299-307
Open AccessReduction of Economic Disparities in the Regions of Kazakhstan Based on Inclusive Development