Paolo Giani
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Paolo Giani has a total of 55 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Glenn Flierl
Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts
8 shared publications- Noelle Eckley Selin
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, 54-1412, Cambridge, United States [US
8 shared publications - Christopher Womack
Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, United States
7 shared publications Andre N. Souza
Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA
6 shared publications- Sebastian David Eastham
Department of Aeronautics, Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom
6 shared publications Shahine Bouabid
Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 April 2026
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of Climate
- Vol. 39 (7) , 1681-1701
Origin and Limits of Invariant Warming Patterns in Climate Models
Climate models exhibit an approximately invariant surface warming pattern in typical end-of-century projections. This feature has been used extensively in climate impact assessments for fast calculations of local temperature anomalies, with a linear procedure known as pattern scaling . At the same time, emerging research has also shown that time-varying warming patterns are necessary to explain the time evolution of effective climate sensitivity in coupled models, a mechanism that is known as the pattern effect and that seemingly challenges the pattern scaling understanding. Here, we present a simple theory based on local energy balance arguments to reconcile this apparent contradiction. Specifically, we show that the pattern invariance arises from the combination of exponential forcing, linear feedbacks, a constant forcing pattern, and linear changes in heat transport. These conditions are approximately met in typical Coupled Model Intercomparison Project phase 6 (CMIP6) shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs), except in the Arctic where nonlinear feedbacks are important and in regions where different aerosol projections alter the forcing pattern. In idealized experiments where concentrations of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) are abruptly increased, such as those used to study the pattern effect, the warming pattern evolves considerably over time because of spatially inhomogeneous ocean heat uptake, even in the absence of nonlinear feedbacks. Our results illustrate why typical future projections are amenable to pattern scaling and provide a plausible explanation of why more complicated approaches, such as nonlinear emulators, have only shown marginal improvements in accuracy over simple linear calculations. Significance Statement: In typical end-of-century climate projections from comprehensive models, the ratio between local and global surface temperature anomalies is approximately time and scenario invariant. This feature has enabled fast calculations of local temperature changes by scaling the global average with a constant pattern. At the same time, idealized quadrupling of CO 2 (4xCO 2 ) experiments show a different behavior and a considerable time evolution of the warming pattern. We present a simple theory based on local energy balance to reconcile this apparent contradiction. Specifically, we show that the pattern invariance arises under a set of conditions that are approximately satisfied typical end-of-century scenarios. Our findings clarify why scaling the global average to calculate local temperature anomalies is effective for most future projections.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of Climate
- Vol. 39 (7) , 1681-1701
Top Cited PapersOrigin and Limits of Invariant Warming Patterns in Climate Models
Climate models exhibit an approximately invariant surface warming pattern in typical end-of-century projections. This feature has been used extensively in climate impact assessments for fast calculations of local temperature anomalies, with a linear procedure known as pattern scaling . At the same time, emerging research has also shown that time-varying warming patterns are necessary to explain the time evolution of effective climate sensitivity in coupled models, a mechanism that is known as the pattern effect and that seemingly challenges the pattern scaling understanding. Here, we present a simple theory based on local energy balance arguments to reconcile this apparent contradiction. Specifically, we show that the pattern invariance arises from the combination of exponential forcing, linear feedbacks, a constant forcing pattern, and linear changes in heat transport. These conditions are approximately met in typical Coupled Model Intercomparison Project phase 6 (CMIP6) shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs), except in the Arctic where nonlinear feedbacks are important and in regions where different aerosol projections alter the forcing pattern. In idealized experiments where concentrations of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) are abruptly increased, such as those used to study the pattern effect, the warming pattern evolves considerably over time because of spatially inhomogeneous ocean heat uptake, even in the absence of nonlinear feedbacks. Our results illustrate why typical future projections are amenable to pattern scaling and provide a plausible explanation of why more complicated approaches, such as nonlinear emulators, have only shown marginal improvements in accuracy over simple linear calculations. Significance Statement: In typical end-of-century climate projections from comprehensive models, the ratio between local and global surface temperature anomalies is approximately time and scenario invariant. This feature has enabled fast calculations of local temperature changes by scaling the global average with a constant pattern. At the same time, idealized quadrupling of CO 2 (4xCO 2 ) experiments show a different behavior and a considerable time evolution of the warming pattern. We present a simple theory based on local energy balance to reconcile this apparent contradiction. Specifically, we show that the pattern invariance arises under a set of conditions that are approximately satisfied typical end-of-century scenarios. Our findings clarify why scaling the global average to calculate local temperature anomalies is effective for most future projections.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Advances in generative climate emulation to support impact-assessment
Policy targets evolve faster than the Couple Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP) cycles, complicating adaptation and mitigation planning that must often contend with outdated projections. Climate model emulators address this gap by offering inexpensive surrogates that can rapidly explore alternative futures while staying close to Earth System Model (ESM) behavior. Here we present recent advances in probabilistic climate emulation aimed to provide inputs for impact models. We show that a generative emulator can reproduce key climate variables at a small fraction of the computational cost of ESMs, while retaining skill in reproducing probability distributions, cross-variable dependencies, time of emergence, and tail behavior. The emulator is informative even for scenarios with aggressive emissions reductions to meet Paris targets. We further show how generative emulators can extend beyond traditional ESMs by directly integrating bias-correction strategies, thereby avoiding separate post-processing steps commonly used in impact assessment pipelines. Finally, we present a framework to design emission scenarios optimized for emulator training, that yields emulators with comparable or improved skill while reducing the volume of ESM simulations needed to train the emulator. We suggest that modeling centers allocate dedicated resources to such "emulator-training" experiments, enabling the rapid generation of large, impact-relevant ensembles across Shared Socioeconomic Pathways while freeing computational capacity for other scientific applications of full-scale Earth system models.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAdvances in generative climate emulation to support impact-assessment
Policy targets evolve faster than the Couple Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP) cycles, complicating adaptation and mitigation planning that must often contend with outdated projections. Climate model emulators address this gap by offering inexpensive surrogates that can rapidly explore alternative futures while staying close to Earth System Model (ESM) behavior. Here we present recent advances in probabilistic climate emulation aimed to provide inputs for impact models. We show that a generative emulator can reproduce key climate variables at a small fraction of the computational cost of ESMs, while retaining skill in reproducing probability distributions, cross-variable dependencies, time of emergence, and tail behavior. The emulator is informative even for scenarios with aggressive emissions reductions to meet Paris targets. We further show how generative emulators can extend beyond traditional ESMs by directly integrating bias-correction strategies, thereby avoiding separate post-processing steps commonly used in impact assessment pipelines. Finally, we present a framework to design emission scenarios optimized for emulator training, that yields emulators with comparable or improved skill while reducing the volume of ESM simulations needed to train the emulator. We suggest that modeling centers allocate dedicated resources to such "emulator-training" experiments, enabling the rapid generation of large, impact-relevant ensembles across Shared Socioeconomic Pathways while freeing computational capacity for other scientific applications of full-scale Earth system models.
- Open Access
- 16 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (1) , 107-139
A theoretical framework to understand sources of error in Earth System Model emulation
Full-scale Earth System Models (ESMs) are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromise fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques and use it to understand potential sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation guidance for each technique. Using pedagogical examples including idealized box models and a modified Lorenz 63 model, we illustrate the expected errors from each emulation technique considered. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. Potential benefits and trade-offs from incorporating statistical mechanics in climate emulation through the use of the FDT are discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for ESMs with emulation in mind. We argue that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities. We conclude by discussing optimal use cases for each emulator, along with implications for ESMs based on our pedagogical model results.
- 16 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (1) , 107-139
Open AccessA theoretical framework to understand sources of error in Earth System Model emulation
Full-scale Earth System Models (ESMs) are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromise fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques and use it to understand potential sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation guidance for each technique. Using pedagogical examples including idealized box models and a modified Lorenz 63 model, we illustrate the expected errors from each emulation technique considered. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. Potential benefits and trade-offs from incorporating statistical mechanics in climate emulation through the use of the FDT are discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for ESMs with emulation in mind. We argue that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities. We conclude by discussing optimal use cases for each emulator, along with implications for ESMs based on our pedagogical model results.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Reply on RC2
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Open AccessReply on RC2
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Reply on RC1
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Open AccessReply on RC1
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Comment on egusphere-2025-3792
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-3792
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- Open Access
- 23 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Comment on egusphere-2025-3792
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- 23 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-3792
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- Open Access
- 19 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
A framework for assessing and understanding sources of error in Earth System Model emulation
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- 19 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-51
Open AccessA framework for assessing and understanding sources of error in Earth System Model emulation
Full-scale Earth system models are too computationally expensive to keep pace with the growing demand for climate projections across a large range of emissions pathways. Climate emulators, reduced-order models that reproduce the output of full-scale models, are poised to fill this niche. However, the large number of emulation techniques available and lack of a comprehensive theoretical basis to understand their relative strengths and weaknesses compromises fundamental methodological comparisons. Here, we present a theoretical framework that connects disparate emulation techniques, using it to analyze sources of emulator error focusing on memory effects, hidden variables, system noise, and nonlinearities. This framework includes popular emulation techniques such as pattern scaling and response functions, relating them to less commonly used methods, such as Dynamic Mode Decomposition and the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem (FDT). To support our theoretical contributions, we provide practical implementation details for each technique, evaluating performance across a series of experiments designed to highlight different potential sources of error. We find that response function-based emulators outperform other techniques, particularly pattern scaling, across all scenarios tested. We additionally outline potential advantages of incorporating statistical mechanics into climate emulation through the use of the FDT, though this technique requires greater computational resources and non-standard scenarios for training. Results highlight the relative utility of each technique discussed, along with the importance of designing future scenarios for Earth system models with emulation in mind, suggesting that large-ensemble experiments utilizing the FDT could benefit climate modeling and impacts communities.
- Open Access
- 2 August 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres
- Vol. 130 (15)
Evaluating WRF Multiscale Wind Simulations in Complex Terrain: Insights From the Perdigão Field Campaign
Accurate microscale flow simulations are essential for assessing wind characteristics in complex terrain. This study evaluates a large ensemble of multiscale simulations, including large‐eddy simulations (LES), using the Weather Research and Forecasting model (WRF) over Perdigão, Portugal, driven by boundary conditions from multiple global data sets. Simulations are compared with data from the Perdigão field campaign, including radiosonde and flux tower measurements. Results show that LES, using high‐resolution topography and land use data, better replicate flow features and dynamics, providing valuable insights for wind resource quantification and mapping. We identify that model performance varies spatially. The RMSE of wind speed at 10 m at ridge towers is 5.65 m , while at valley towers, it is lower (2.28 m ), and variation across runs is greater for higher wind speeds. Temporally, surface winds show substantial variability throughout the day, posing greater modeling challenges during nighttime and synoptic transitions. This variability is not observed at 100 m, where topographic effects are less dominant and RMSE remains consistent across runs. Simulations driven by hourly boundary conditions perform best. However, drawing general conclusions about optimal turbulence modeling in the gray zone remains challenging due to microscale meteorology in complex terrain. Wind field characteristics are sensitive to turbulence scheme choice, particularly in the boundary layer, while above it, wind behavior is mainly influenced by boundary conditions. These results help identify key factors driving model variability and biases, which may guide future model developments to enhance wind flow simulation accuracy and reliability.
- 2 August 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres
- Vol. 130 (15)
Open AccessEvaluating WRF Multiscale Wind Simulations in Complex Terrain: Insights From the Perdigão Field Campaign
Accurate microscale flow simulations are essential for assessing wind characteristics in complex terrain. This study evaluates a large ensemble of multiscale simulations, including large‐eddy simulations (LES), using the Weather Research and Forecasting model (WRF) over Perdigão, Portugal, driven by boundary conditions from multiple global data sets. Simulations are compared with data from the Perdigão field campaign, including radiosonde and flux tower measurements. Results show that LES, using high‐resolution topography and land use data, better replicate flow features and dynamics, providing valuable insights for wind resource quantification and mapping. We identify that model performance varies spatially. The RMSE of wind speed at 10 m at ridge towers is 5.65 m , while at valley towers, it is lower (2.28 m ), and variation across runs is greater for higher wind speeds. Temporally, surface winds show substantial variability throughout the day, posing greater modeling challenges during nighttime and synoptic transitions. This variability is not observed at 100 m, where topographic effects are less dominant and RMSE remains consistent across runs. Simulations driven by hourly boundary conditions perform best. However, drawing general conclusions about optimal turbulence modeling in the gray zone remains challenging due to microscale meteorology in complex terrain. Wind field characteristics are sensitive to turbulence scheme choice, particularly in the boundary layer, while above it, wind behavior is mainly influenced by boundary conditions. These results help identify key factors driving model variability and biases, which may guide future model developments to enhance wind flow simulation accuracy and reliability.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Biogenic Emissions Modulate the Tropospheric Hydroxyl Radical (OH) Response to Climate Warming
The hydroxyl radical (OH) sets the oxidative capacity of the atmosphere and determines the lifetime of reactive greenhouse gases such as methane (CH4). The response of OH to climate warming is influenced by uncertain and compensating processes involving weather-sensitive chemistry and emissions. In this study, we extend the idealized aquaplanet configuration of the Community Earth System Model (CESM) Community Atmosphere Model version 6 (CAM6) to include atmospheric chemistry (“AquaChem”). Beyond the aquaplanet’s zonally symmetric sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and lack of seasonality, we further simplify the spatial variability of trace gas and aerosol emissions. We show that the AquaChem configuration generates a robust OH chemical budget, including both production and loss pathways, with relatively short simulations. Thus, the AquaChem model serves as an effective tool for rapidly assessing the sensitivity of OH chemistry, including both production and loss pathways. Rapid convergence allows us to assess the sensitivity of OH chemistry to surface warming. The strongest direct response in OH to increased surface temperatures is an increase in “primary” OH production due to higher water vapor concentrations. We then test the sensitivity of OH sources and sinks to different assumptions regarding the response of emissions to rising temperatures. AquaChem simulations indicate that biogenic emissions are a dominant factor influencing the OH response to climate warming. In tropical regions, climate warming enhances biogenic emissions and increases the OH loss rate, outweighing the increase in OH production resulting from rising water vapor and resulting in a decrease in OH abundance.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessBiogenic Emissions Modulate the Tropospheric Hydroxyl Radical (OH) Response to Climate Warming
The hydroxyl radical (OH) sets the oxidative capacity of the atmosphere and determines the lifetime of reactive greenhouse gases such as methane (CH4). The response of OH to climate warming is influenced by uncertain and compensating processes involving weather-sensitive chemistry and emissions. In this study, we extend the idealized aquaplanet configuration of the Community Earth System Model (CESM) Community Atmosphere Model version 6 (CAM6) to include atmospheric chemistry (“AquaChem”). Beyond the aquaplanet’s zonally symmetric sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and lack of seasonality, we further simplify the spatial variability of trace gas and aerosol emissions. We show that the AquaChem configuration generates a robust OH chemical budget, including both production and loss pathways, with relatively short simulations. Thus, the AquaChem model serves as an effective tool for rapidly assessing the sensitivity of OH chemistry, including both production and loss pathways. Rapid convergence allows us to assess the sensitivity of OH chemistry to surface warming. The strongest direct response in OH to increased surface temperatures is an increase in “primary” OH production due to higher water vapor concentrations. We then test the sensitivity of OH sources and sinks to different assumptions regarding the response of emissions to rising temperatures. AquaChem simulations indicate that biogenic emissions are a dominant factor influencing the OH response to climate warming. In tropical regions, climate warming enhances biogenic emissions and increases the OH loss rate, outweighing the increase in OH production resulting from rising water vapor and resulting in a decrease in OH abundance.