NGNatalia N. Goncharova

Natalia N. Goncharova

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Natalia N. Goncharova has a total of 31 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    DENTAL PATHOLOGY IN THE NORTH CAUCASUS POPULATION FROM THE IRON AGE TO THE EARLY MIDDLE AGES (ZAYUKOVO-3 BURIAL GROUND MATERIALS)

    by Alla Perevozchikova, Natalya Goncharova, Natalia Berezina

    The article presents the results of a comprehensive study of dental and maxillofacial pathologies in the population of the North Caucasus who lived from the Early Iron Age to the Early Middle Ages (10th century BC to 9th century AD). The research material was derived from paleoanthropological collections of the Zayukovo-3 burial site (Kabardino-Balkaria Republic). The burials of the studied individuals belong to the Western Koban culture (7th – 5th centuries BC), the Sarmatian period (Podkumok-Khumara cultural group, 1st – 3rd centuries AD), and the Alanian era (5th – 7th centuries AD). In this study, an adapted version of M. Schultz’s methodology was used to analyze the frequencies of caries, apical periodontitis, enamel hypoplasia, dental calculus, antemortem enamel chipping, and the degree of dental wear. Significant differences were found in the dental and maxillofacial conditions among representatives of different archaeological cultures. Individuals associated with the Koban culture exhibited pronounced dental wear and a low prevalence of caries, suggesting a balanced diet dominated by meat and dairy products. During the Sarmatian period, an increase in caries and dental calculus was observed, which may be linked to dietary changes, possibly involving greater consumption of high-carbohydrate foods. The Alanic period was characterized by severe dental wear, an increased frequency of enamel hypoplasia, and traumatic dental injuries, indicating a decline in living conditions and overall population health.

  • Open Access

    Variability of sexual dimorphism in dental metric traits: a comparative study of ethno-territorial groups

    by D.S. Khodyreva, N.N. Goncharova, N.YA. Berezina

    Sexual dimorphism represents a significant component of morphological variability within biological popula-tions. Investigating patterns of sexual differences in tooth size is essential for the development of sex identification methodologies based on odontometric data. This study aims to examine sexual dimorphism in dental metric traits across geographically and chronologically diverse samples and to conduct a comparative analysis of these pat-terns. The study encompasses five cranial series comprising a total of 524 individuals: Mamisondon (7th– 9th cen-turies AD, North Ossetia), Mayatsky (8th–10th centuries AD, Voronezh Region), Dmitrievsky (8th–9th centuries AD, Belgorod Region), Kozino (18th century AD, Moscow Region), and Obdorsk (18th–19th centuries AD, Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug). Dental measurements were conducted in accordance with the methodological guide-lines established by A.A. Zubov [1968] and S. Hillson [2005]. To assess sexual dimorphism indices, different sets of odontometric traits can be categorized into multiple groups. The analysis revealed unequal contributions of different components of the odontometric system to Mahalanobis distances. Furthermore, each new study group exhibited varying levels of sexual differences for individual traits compared to other series. These results suggest that complex mechanisms underlie human dental sexual dimorphism, which substantially limits the applicability of dental metric traits for sex identification methodologies.

  • Open Access

    DIACHRONIC CHANGES IN LONG-BONE DIMENSIONS AND RECONSTRUCTED STATURE FROM THE EARLY IRON AGE TO THE EARLY MEDIEVAL PERIOD: EVIDENCE FROM THE ZAYUKOVO-3 CEMETERY (KABARDINO-BALKARIA)

    by Alla A. Perevozchikova, Natalia N. Goncharova, Natalia Ya. Berezina

    This study investigates changes in skeletal long-bone dimensions in North Caucasus populations over a span of approximately 1,500 years (from 8th century BC to 7th century AD), using materials from the Zayukovo-3 polycultural cemetery (Kabardino-Balkaria Republic, Russia) as a case study. The research aims to reconstruct stature and assess morphological variability among individuals from three key cultural-chronological phases of the site: the Western Koban culture of the pre-Scythian period (8th–5th centuries BC), the Podkumok-Khumara cultural group of the Late Sarmatian period (1st–3rd centuries AD), and the Early Alanian period (5th–7th centuries AD). Methods employed include paleoanthropological analysis, reconstruction of fragmented skeletal remains, osteometric measurement, stature estimation, and statistical processing of the resulting data. The analysis revealed statistically significant differences and similarities among the compared groups. Males from the Koban and Alanian stages displayed morphological similarity, while female stature showed no significant difference between the Koban and Sarmatian samples. The Koban population exhibited pronounced sexual dimorphism in skeletal proportions. Sarmatian males had the lowest mean stature (163 cm) and were morphologically distinct from the other groups. Reconstructed stature was 169 cm for Koban males and 168 cm for Alanian males. These results align with recent paleogenetic studies suggesting biological continuity between Koban and Alanian populations. The findings underscore the value of osteometric analysis in paleoanthropological research and highlight the complex biological dynamics of ancient North Caucasus populations. They indicate both long-term continuity across certain archaeological cultures and the potential impact of external components during the Sarmatian period. These patterns warrant further verification through interdisciplinary studies.

  • Open Access

    The DNA portrait of an individual from the Medieval necropolis of “Patriarchal Garden” (Vladimir city) with a rare funeral rite — a stone pillow

    by A.I. Alperovich, A.D. Soshkina, T.V. Andreeva, S.S. Kunizheva, I.YU. Adrianova, A.B. Malarchuk, I.L. Kuznetsova, N.N. Goncharova, D.A. Kabaev, L.L. Chernyaeva, et al.

    The history of Ancient Rus’ is inextricably linked with the history of ancient Vladimir, the capital of North-Eastern Rus’ in the 12th–14th centuries. Historical, anthropological, and archaeological data suggest a complex composition of the population of Ancient Rus’ cities, however, the genetic structure of this population is currently practically unexplored. We performed whole-genome sequencing with high coverage for an individual from a burial with a stone pillow from the necropolis “Patriarch's Garden” in Vladimir, dated to the second half of the 13th–14th centuries. Based on this, the individual was identified as a male. Identified haplogroups of mitochondrial DNA (H1ba) and Y-chromosome (R-L21) of the buried man have not been previously described in burials from the territory of Ancient Rus’. The paternal lineage of the individual is likely traced to the territory of Northwest Europe. In combination with data on autosomal markers, these results testify to the genetic connection of the man buried in Vladimir with the Western European populations.


  • Open Access

    Application of the Decision Tree Method for Differentiating Human Groups

    by O. A. Fedorchuk, N. N. Goncharova

    One of the tasks of modern biological anthropology is to develop a system that could objectively classify humanity on the basis of measurements. Here, the decision tree algorithm was chosen to create a classification of groups. The method helps to evaluate the differentiating power of specific dimensions for separating samples and to assess the composition of clusters at each step of the analysis. Standard cranial measurements were used, and the entropy index was chosen as a heterogeneity measure. Classification units were 39 ethno-territorial groups from 13 major regions of the Old World. At the first step, differentiation is made between broad-faced and narrow-faced groups, demonstrating the classificatory value of this trait. The first cluster includes only Mongoloids, admixed Southern Siberian populations, and Ainu. The second cluster is heterogeneous, but its further subdivision is more in line with the traditional classification. Traits underlying the branching of the tree may be the same in different branches, evidencing their taxonomic importance. Capabilities of the decision tree method proved sufficient to construct a system largely similar to the traditional one. Certain traits separate large groups of populations, while others are efficient at the regional level. The method, therefore, can be recommended as a supplementary tool at the intraspecific level.


  • ANTHROPOLOGICAL STUDY OF THE POPULATION OF SMOLENSK IN THE 16TH-17TH CENTURIES BASED ON THE MATERIALS FROM THE EXCAVATIONS AT PYATNITSKY DISTRICT

    by A.D. Buriak, N.N. Goncharova

    Introduction. The article analyzes materials dated to the 16th-17th centuries came from Smolensk. This period turned out to be one of the most complex and eventful in the history of the region, that's why every new detail is significant for the study. For a long time, Smolensk functioned as a boundary city and also as an important trade hub between the Muscovite Tsardom and the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth; so, the composition of its population may reflect the influence of the western neighbors. Materials and methods. There were examined the craniological materials discovered during the excavations at the Pyatnitsky district of the city in 2012. The necropolis dates back to the turn of the 16th-17th centuries, it is located on the high bank of the Dnieper near the fortress wall of the Smolensk Kremlin. The materials include 17 male and 19 female skulls. Classical and multidimensional biometric methods were used as statistical approaches. Results. The comparison beetween the studied sample and the other sample of the 12th century city population known from the literature has showed their high similarity, although the later sample tends to be slenderer. Statistically significant differences were recorded only for certain parameters of the skull. The comparison with the aggregated sample of the rural Smolensk region population dated to the 18th-19th centuries also revealed a significant difference for the cranial length and height and some parameters of the facial skeleton. Discriminant analysis showed a quite unique status of the studied sample, which differs from both synchronous urban groups and later samples of the rural population of the central region. There are also no processes of macrosomization observed for it. Conclusion. The absence of significant differences for most characteristics between the studied sample and the urban population of the 12th century can indicate the continuity of the morphological type of the Smolensk urban population. On the other hand, the intermediate position of the studied sample in relation to early and late comparative materials can indicate that the studied sample represents recent settlers from the rural area.


  • Application of the Decision Tree Method for Differentiating Human Groups

    by Lomonosov Moscow State University, O. A. Fedorchuk, N. N. Goncharova, Bochkov Research Center for Medical Genetics

    Одной из задач современной антропологии является разработка системы объективной классификации человечества по измерительным признакам. В настоящей работе для создания классификации выборок использован алгоритм деревьев принятия решений. Метод позволяет оценить дифференцирующую значимость тех или иных размеров при разделении групп, а также состав последних на каждом шаге анализа. Для дифференциации групп использовались размерные характеристики черепа человека. В качестве критерия разнородности выбран показатель энтропии. Использованные краниометрические признаки соответствуют стандартной методике, принятой в российской антропологии. Материалами послужили средние значения размеров черепа по 39 этнотерриториальным группам из 13 макрорегионов Старого Света. На первом шаге происходит разделение на широколицые и узколицые группы. Дихотомия по ширине лица соответствует представлениям о значимости этого признака для классификации. Первый кластер включает только монголоидов, популяции переходной южносибирской расы, а также айнов; второй — разнородные в расовом отношении группы, однако его дальнейшее дробление приводит ко все более полному соответствию антропологической классификации. Признаки, по которым происходят дихотомические деления узлов, во многом повторяются в разных ветвях классификационного дерева, что говорит об их таксономической значимости. Возможности метода деревьев решений оказались достаточными, чтобы построить систему, сходную с классической антропологической классификацией. Выявлены признаки, которые хорошо отделяют большие группы популяций, а также признаки, разделяющие отдельные региональные группы. Это позволяет рекомендовать применение алгоритма как еще одного независимого метода систематики даже на внутривидовом уровне.

  • Open Access

    An example of a favorable outcome of a cervical spine injury occurring on a background of diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis: the result of an anthropological finding in the church of St. Peter in the town of Domashevo (Bosnia and Herzegovina)

    by O. A. Georginova, N. N. Goncharova, E. A. Grishanina, S. A. Zakharova, E. A. Makarov, T. N. Krasnova

    The article provides a description of the anthropological finding – human remains discovered in the church of St. Peter (Domashevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, burial at the turn of the 15th and 16th centuries AD). The available morphological data most likely indicate the presence of diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis. This disease resulted in trauma to the cervical vertebrae, which altered their morphology. However, the injury did not lead to death; the person lived for a long time afterwards, as post-traumatic skeletal changes with the development of torticollis were noted.

  • Comparability of results from canonical discriminant analysis based on different input data

    by Olga A. Fedorchuk, Natalia N. Goncharova

    Canonical discriminant analysis, based on the mean values of the traits, is widely used by anthropologists. These analyses use standard deviation means, as well as standard correlation coefficients. The question of the comparability of the results of such analysis with the results based on individual values remains open. Moreover, the existing inter-group variability in correlation coefficients can lead to altered analysis results when applying the correlation matrix calculated for the specific under analysis groups. This study compares the results of three variants of the canonical discriminant analysis: based on individual data, based on average values and a generalized (species-specific) correlation matrix, and based on average values and a regional (calculated for a certain region) correlation matrix. Materials and methods. Data from 48 ethno-territorial groups from the Old World were used. The series are dated close to modern times, from the 16th to the 20th century. Twenty-five craniometric linear features have been measured. For canonical analysis on individual data we used the R language package, and for average data analysis the MultiCan software was used. Results. The results of the two analyses performed on individual data and on average data turned out to be quite similar. A comparison of the results of a series of discriminant analyses carried out on samples of the three major races using different correlation matrices reveals some small differences in the mutual arrangement of groups. In general, the distribution of samples in the scatter plots, as well as the standardized coefficients of discriminant functions coincide, regardless of the type of initial data. Conclusion. In general, it may be concluded that the use of both individual values and sample averages in most cases leads to the same results. When individual values are used, the results may be distorted as a result of a strong reduction in the number of samples. Also, sample differentiation in this case is strongly influenced by a higher real intra-group variability.

  • The Effectiveness of Sex Determination of Immature Individuals by Morphological Methods (A Case Study of Medieval Mamisondon Series, North Ossetia)

    by Lomonosov Moscow State University, Daria Khodyreva, Natalia Goncharova, Alexandra Buzhilova, Natalia Berezina

    Introduction. One of the main issues in the analysis of human remains in paleoanthropology and forensic examination is the sex determination. A large number of reliable methods for sex determination in adult individuals exist. However, when examining the remains of children and adolescents, the problem of sex determination is much more complicate. Various methods of such determination have been developed. All of them have different degrees of accuracy, applicable to different osteological series. Methods and materials. The early Medieval Mamisondon series (North Ossetia) was chosen for the study, in which the sex of the buried, including children, determined the location of the corpse. Genetic analysis and peptide analysis of tooth enamel were carried out to confirm the connection of body location with sex. Three methods of morphological sex determination in children’s skeletons have been tested: the use of discriminant functions for the size of the teeth and the use of descriptive characteristics of the mandible and pelvis shape. Mesiodistal and bucco-lingual tooth sizes were measured in 60 adults and 43 children. Morphological features of the mandible were evaluated in 37 individuals and the ilium in 33. The evaluation of the descriptive characteristics of the postcranial skeleton was carried out by the blind method, and then the data obtained were compared with sex determination data confirmed by laboratory methods. Analysis. By the method of step-by-step discriminant analysis, the characters were selected that most successfully dividing individuals by sex in our series. Results. We have built several discriminant equations based on deciduous and permanent molars, which allow us to determine sex with an accuracy of 70–80%. In our work, we especially note the importance of the first permanent molar for sex determination in children, since it appears first among permanent teeth, which are more dimorphic than deciduous teeth. We consider this method to be promising, however, due to the unequal level of sexual dimorphism and the size of teeth in different populations, the discriminant functions created by us are not universal and are applicable only specifically to our series, or to another series with the same level of sexual dimorphism and dimensional characteristics of the teeth. The descriptive characteristics studied in the work showed a low percentage of correct decisions in determining sex. Authors’ contribution: D. Khodyreva – experimental research, data analysis, writing original draft; N. Goncharova – methodology of statistical analysis, formal analysis, review and editing; A. Buzhilova – methodology of the research algorithm, review and editing, critical revision in order to improve the content; N. Berezina – the concept of the research algorithm, methodology, writing, review and editing.