Sarah Holcombe
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Sarah Holcombe has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Arn Keeling
Memorial University of Newfoundland
3 shared publications - Deanna Kemp
Centre for Social Responsibility in Mining, Sustainable Minerals Institute, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, 4072, Australia
3 shared publications - Jocelyn Davies
ACSIRO Ecosystem Sciences, PO Box 2111, Alice Springs, NT 0871, Australia
2 shared publications - Rebecca Hall
Global Development Studies, Queen's University
2 shared publications - Alec Doomadgee
Waanyi Native Title corporation
1 shared publication - Alicia Boyle
Northern Institute, College of Indigenous Futures, Arts & Society, Charles Darwin University , Darwin, Australia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by University of Arizona in Journal of Political Ecology
- Vol. 32 (1)
Self-Determination in mine site transitions and mine closure governance across Indigenous nations
This introductory article provides a synthesis of and a conceptual framing for, the five contributing articles in the Special Section "Self-determination in mine closure and mine site transition across nations". These articles explore the intersections of mineral extraction, environmental legacies, and Indigenous post-mining futures in the context of mine site transitions. The articles provide a series of Indigenous-authored and collaborative contributions offering a deeper exploration of community perspectives, engagements and governance practices at extractive sites in Australia and Canada. Written from diverse ecological, social and political contexts, taken together the articles elevate Indigenous voices and experiences in mine closure governance. This addresses the significant gap in the literature on the social aspects of mine closure, which is particularly glaring in relation to Indigenous peoples' rights and interests. The mines that are the focus of consideration in this Special Section cover various commodities including gold, diamonds, nickel, zinc, lead, silver and copper. Many of them were, and in some cases still are, long-lived mines. Though they all have particular histories and contexts, all the Indigenous commentators reflect on mining as an expression of the continuity of settler colonialism and environmental injustice.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by University of Arizona in Journal of Political Ecology
- Vol. 32 (1)
Open AccessSelf-Determination in mine site transitions and mine closure governance across Indigenous nations
This introductory article provides a synthesis of and a conceptual framing for, the five contributing articles in the Special Section "Self-determination in mine closure and mine site transition across nations". These articles explore the intersections of mineral extraction, environmental legacies, and Indigenous post-mining futures in the context of mine site transitions. The articles provide a series of Indigenous-authored and collaborative contributions offering a deeper exploration of community perspectives, engagements and governance practices at extractive sites in Australia and Canada. Written from diverse ecological, social and political contexts, taken together the articles elevate Indigenous voices and experiences in mine closure governance. This addresses the significant gap in the literature on the social aspects of mine closure, which is particularly glaring in relation to Indigenous peoples' rights and interests. The mines that are the focus of consideration in this Special Section cover various commodities including gold, diamonds, nickel, zinc, lead, silver and copper. Many of them were, and in some cases still are, long-lived mines. Though they all have particular histories and contexts, all the Indigenous commentators reflect on mining as an expression of the continuity of settler colonialism and environmental injustice.
- Open Access
- 14 December 2024
- Published by University of Arizona in Journal of Political Ecology
- Vol. 32 (1)
Reasserting Gija women's role in mine site reclamation: A perspective from the Argyle Diamond Mine
The Argyle diamond mine, in the East Kimberley region of Western Australia, ceased production in late 2020 after 37 years of operations and producing 865 million carats of rough diamonds. Opening in 1983, it was the first major diamond-mining operation in Australia and brought with it a very mixed history of Traditional Owner engagement with the Company (Rio Tinto). Closure now offers an opportunity to reassert cultural authority and reclaim Traditional Owners', and specifically, women's rightful place in decision-making. But the path to get there is complex. From the perspective of Kia Dowell, a community leader and Chair of Gelganyem Limited (an Aboriginal charitable trust), and supported by her mother Ethel McLennon, this article will trace the legacies of structural injustice as this mine was developed, which includes the two negotiated agreements and state government mining regulations, all of which actively marginalize Traditional Owner rights and interests. Likewise, during the initial and subsequent agreement negotiations women's customary interests were sidelined in favor of a western governance system, which privileges the male dominated view and voice. This is despite the fact that the site of the open pit mine was known to be an important women's site for the Gija people and was subsequently destroyed. Telling this story provides not only a chance to reflect on the past, but to also stake a locally self-determined agenda in order to reclaim Aboriginal governance structures and redefine how Traditional Owners are choosing to engage with Rio Tinto (the Company) and the Western Australian State government.
- 14 December 2024
- Published by University of Arizona in Journal of Political Ecology
- Vol. 32 (1)
Open AccessReasserting Gija women's role in mine site reclamation: A perspective from the Argyle Diamond Mine
The Argyle diamond mine, in the East Kimberley region of Western Australia, ceased production in late 2020 after 37 years of operations and producing 865 million carats of rough diamonds. Opening in 1983, it was the first major diamond-mining operation in Australia and brought with it a very mixed history of Traditional Owner engagement with the Company (Rio Tinto). Closure now offers an opportunity to reassert cultural authority and reclaim Traditional Owners', and specifically, women's rightful place in decision-making. But the path to get there is complex. From the perspective of Kia Dowell, a community leader and Chair of Gelganyem Limited (an Aboriginal charitable trust), and supported by her mother Ethel McLennon, this article will trace the legacies of structural injustice as this mine was developed, which includes the two negotiated agreements and state government mining regulations, all of which actively marginalize Traditional Owner rights and interests. Likewise, during the initial and subsequent agreement negotiations women's customary interests were sidelined in favor of a western governance system, which privileges the male dominated view and voice. This is despite the fact that the site of the open pit mine was known to be an important women's site for the Gija people and was subsequently destroyed. Telling this story provides not only a chance to reflect on the past, but to also stake a locally self-determined agenda in order to reclaim Aboriginal governance structures and redefine how Traditional Owners are choosing to engage with Rio Tinto (the Company) and the Western Australian State government.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2024
- Published by University of Arizona in Journal of Political Ecology
- Vol. 32 (1)
"What does Closure even mean?" at Century Mine: Multiple companies, mine closure trajectories and disputation
During the peak of its operation, Century mine, in Australia's western Queensland, was the third largest lead, zinc and silver mine in the world. The mine has had a turbulent history. It was resisted by the indigenous Traditional Owners, and then an uneasy truce followed, with an unprecedented agreement struck between the (then) company, the state government and Traditional Owners. Over a period of only 16 years the mine has been owned by 6 different companies, each with different approaches to working with Traditional Owners. This article will focus on the most recent period from the perspective of the current Chair of the Waanyi Native Title Proscribed Body Corporate (PBC), Alec Doomadgee. This recent period includes a declaration of 'closure' by MMG (Minerals and Metals Group) Corporation, with promises made that Traditional Owner businesses would have opportunities for mine-site rehabilitation. This was quickly followed by the purchase of the operation by another company, who renamed it New Century. The business model of this new junior company – which focuses on re-mining tailings and also rehabilitation – seems to directly compete with Waanyi PBC interests, while mine expansion is also planned. There has been an increase in conflict and rivalry during this latest period, with disputes and lateral violence amongst Traditional Owner groups.
- 21 October 2024
- Published by University of Arizona in Journal of Political Ecology
- Vol. 32 (1)
Open Access"What does Closure even mean?" at Century Mine: Multiple companies, mine closure trajectories and disputation
During the peak of its operation, Century mine, in Australia's western Queensland, was the third largest lead, zinc and silver mine in the world. The mine has had a turbulent history. It was resisted by the indigenous Traditional Owners, and then an uneasy truce followed, with an unprecedented agreement struck between the (then) company, the state government and Traditional Owners. Over a period of only 16 years the mine has been owned by 6 different companies, each with different approaches to working with Traditional Owners. This article will focus on the most recent period from the perspective of the current Chair of the Waanyi Native Title Proscribed Body Corporate (PBC), Alec Doomadgee. This recent period includes a declaration of 'closure' by MMG (Minerals and Metals Group) Corporation, with promises made that Traditional Owner businesses would have opportunities for mine-site rehabilitation. This was quickly followed by the purchase of the operation by another company, who renamed it New Century. The business model of this new junior company – which focuses on re-mining tailings and also rehabilitation – seems to directly compete with Waanyi PBC interests, while mine expansion is also planned. There has been an increase in conflict and rivalry during this latest period, with disputes and lateral violence amongst Traditional Owner groups.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 171-197
Comparative perspectives on the social aspects of mine closure and mine site transition in Canada and Australia
In response to the growing recognition of mine closure as a unique phase of the mining cycle, increasing scholarly, industry, and regulatory attention is being focused on the social and economic dimensions of mine site transitions. Recent best practice statements and guideline documents promote “integrated closure planning” as an approach to mine closure that includes both environmental and socioeconomic objectives. In spite of these commitments, in many jurisdictions, the regulatory framework around closure planning neglects or overlooks the necessity for socioeconomic plans or lacks clear objectives for social outcomes. This gap inhibits the ability of industry and communities to adequately account for and mitigate the often devastating socioeconomic effects of mine closure, and integrate community objectives for mine site transitions. In this chapter, we compare approaches to mine closure regulations in three jurisdictions—Queensland and the Northern Territory in Australia, and Nunavik (Northern Québec) in Canada—to assess whether and how regional authorities address the social aspects of mine closure and mine site transitions, including economic and cultural impacts and post-mining land use. In particular, we focus on barriers and opportunities for local and Indigenous community participation and highlight emerging practices of community engagement in mine closure and transition planning. This comparison highlights the factors that shape the approach in these jurisdictions, including governance structures, Indigenous rights, negotiated agreements, and the scale and scope of mineral development activities.
- 13 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 171-197
Open AccessComparative perspectives on the social aspects of mine closure and mine site transition in Canada and Australia
In response to the growing recognition of mine closure as a unique phase of the mining cycle, increasing scholarly, industry, and regulatory attention is being focused on the social and economic dimensions of mine site transitions. Recent best practice statements and guideline documents promote “integrated closure planning” as an approach to mine closure that includes both environmental and socioeconomic objectives. In spite of these commitments, in many jurisdictions, the regulatory framework around closure planning neglects or overlooks the necessity for socioeconomic plans or lacks clear objectives for social outcomes. This gap inhibits the ability of industry and communities to adequately account for and mitigate the often devastating socioeconomic effects of mine closure, and integrate community objectives for mine site transitions. In this chapter, we compare approaches to mine closure regulations in three jurisdictions—Queensland and the Northern Territory in Australia, and Nunavik (Northern Québec) in Canada—to assess whether and how regional authorities address the social aspects of mine closure and mine site transitions, including economic and cultural impacts and post-mining land use. In particular, we focus on barriers and opportunities for local and Indigenous community participation and highlight emerging practices of community engagement in mine closure and transition planning. This comparison highlights the factors that shape the approach in these jurisdictions, including governance structures, Indigenous rights, negotiated agreements, and the scale and scope of mineral development activities.
- Open Access
- 8 March 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Open Engage
Indigenous Exchange Forum: Transition in mine closure
This report is the outcome of an international collaboration between First Nations groups from Canada, Australia and Aotearoa New Zealand who have major mines on their lands and affiliated researchers. “The Indigenous Exchange Forum: transitions in mine closure” was held on 2–3 November 2021 over Zoom, hosted by the Centre for Social Responsibility in Mining (CSRM) in the Sustainable Minerals Institute (SMI), at The University of Queensland. The Forum aimed to affirm, connect, and elevate the voices of First Nations leaders and interested community members impacted by mining and mine closure. In doing so, we aimed to build an international network across these Indigenous communities, to enable the sharing of experiences, struggles, and sentiments in relation to mine site transition and mine-related impacts on their lands. In interviews (virtual and on-Country), participants shared powerful insights about their experiences with the mines in the context of frontier battles, settler colonialism, and mine closure. This included connection to Country, experiences of past mine closure, and concerns, expectations, and aspirations about forthcoming closure. Respect for Indigenous knowledges has been demonstrated through recognising and retaining participant perspectives as largely verbatim. The voices referenced in the major section of the report are followed by a brief synthesis of the themes that emerged from them. The mines discussed include the Argyle and Century mines (Australia), the Waihi and Macraes mine (Aotearoa) and the Faro, Diavik, Ekati, Gahcho Kui and Raglan mines (Canada).
- 8 March 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Open Engage
Open AccessIndigenous Exchange Forum: Transition in mine closure
This report is the outcome of an international collaboration between First Nations groups from Canada, Australia and Aotearoa New Zealand who have major mines on their lands and affiliated researchers. “The Indigenous Exchange Forum: transitions in mine closure” was held on 2–3 November 2021 over Zoom, hosted by the Centre for Social Responsibility in Mining (CSRM) in the Sustainable Minerals Institute (SMI), at The University of Queensland. The Forum aimed to affirm, connect, and elevate the voices of First Nations leaders and interested community members impacted by mining and mine closure. In doing so, we aimed to build an international network across these Indigenous communities, to enable the sharing of experiences, struggles, and sentiments in relation to mine site transition and mine-related impacts on their lands. In interviews (virtual and on-Country), participants shared powerful insights about their experiences with the mines in the context of frontier battles, settler colonialism, and mine closure. This included connection to Country, experiences of past mine closure, and concerns, expectations, and aspirations about forthcoming closure. Respect for Indigenous knowledges has been demonstrated through recognising and retaining participant perspectives as largely verbatim. The voices referenced in the major section of the report are followed by a brief synthesis of the themes that emerged from them. The mines discussed include the Argyle and Century mines (Australia), the Waihi and Macraes mine (Aotearoa) and the Faro, Diavik, Ekati, Gahcho Kui and Raglan mines (Canada).
- 1 June 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in AlterNative: An International Journal of Indigenous Peoples
- Vol. 18 (2) , 225-234
Activism through anthropological practice in the Global South: an exploration
- 1 June 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in AlterNative: An International Journal of Indigenous Peoples
- Vol. 18 (2) , 225-234
Activism through anthropological practice in the Global South: an exploration
- Open Access
- 8 March 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 40 (4) , 413-435
Indigenous co-ownership of mining projects: a preliminary framework for the critical examination of equity participation
Negotiated agreements are now a commonplace mechanism for governing the relationship between mining companies and Indigenous peoples. What is not commonplace are agreements in which Indigenous people acquire an equity stake in industrial-scale projects on their land. Recent and powerful calls for greater Indigenous control of mining projects have drawn renewed attention to the question of Indigenous co-ownership and Indigenous equity participation. This paper describes co-ownership arrangements emerging globally and raises critical questions that drive closer examination of the value proposition of Indigenous equity participation for Indigenous groups and other parties.
- 8 March 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
- Vol. 40 (4) , 413-435
Open AccessIndigenous co-ownership of mining projects: a preliminary framework for the critical examination of equity participation
Negotiated agreements are now a commonplace mechanism for governing the relationship between mining companies and Indigenous peoples. What is not commonplace are agreements in which Indigenous people acquire an equity stake in industrial-scale projects on their land. Recent and powerful calls for greater Indigenous control of mining projects have drawn renewed attention to the question of Indigenous co-ownership and Indigenous equity participation. This paper describes co-ownership arrangements emerging globally and raises critical questions that drive closer examination of the value proposition of Indigenous equity participation for Indigenous groups and other parties.
- 13 May 2020
- Published by Wiley in Sustainable Development
- Vol. 28 (5) , 1122-1135
From pay‐out to participation: Indigenous mining employment as local development?
Unprecedented numbers of Indigenous peoples in Canada and Australia are working in the mining industry. This study explores the proposition that Indigenous mining employment is a form of local development for these peoples. We establish links between the literatures on Indigenous work in the mining industry with development theory. For employment to be considered a form of local development we maintain that it must be understood through the framework of self‐determination, as this applies within a colonial context. A range of potentially enabling requirements is identified, including effective regional governance, career progression, gender equity and equality, and free prior and informed consent. We argue that, where such conditions are not in place, Indigenous peoples in settler states, such as Australia and Canada, risk swapping one kind of dependency for another: the welfare state for the mining economy. It is important that future research test the legitimacy of these conditions, while exploring alternative value propositions when mining companies seek to negotiate access to Indigenous peoples land and resources.
- 13 May 2020
- Published by Wiley in Sustainable Development
- Vol. 28 (5) , 1122-1135
From pay‐out to participation: Indigenous mining employment as local development?
Unprecedented numbers of Indigenous peoples in Canada and Australia are working in the mining industry. This study explores the proposition that Indigenous mining employment is a form of local development for these peoples. We establish links between the literatures on Indigenous work in the mining industry with development theory. For employment to be considered a form of local development we maintain that it must be understood through the framework of self‐determination, as this applies within a colonial context. A range of potentially enabling requirements is identified, including effective regional governance, career progression, gender equity and equality, and free prior and informed consent. We argue that, where such conditions are not in place, Indigenous peoples in settler states, such as Australia and Canada, risk swapping one kind of dependency for another: the welfare state for the mining economy. It is important that future research test the legitimacy of these conditions, while exploring alternative value propositions when mining companies seek to negotiate access to Indigenous peoples land and resources.