Jian Bi
Research Subjects
Jian Bi has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Carla Kuesten
Kuesten Sensory Perception Research, LLC Richland Michigan USA
14 shared publications Carla Kuesten
Kuesten Sensory Percept Res LLC, Richland, MI USA
5 shared publicationsMichael O'MAhony
3 shared publicationsHoliday Durham Zanetti
Nutrilite Health Institute Buena Park California USA
2 shared publicationsHye-Seong Lee
2 shared publicationsJennifer Dang
Nutrilite Health Institute Buena Park California USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 25 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 41 (3)
Proportional Odds Model ( POM ) for Analyzing Rate‐All‐That‐Apply ( RATA ) Data: Detecting Sample Effects
Rate‐all‐that‐apply (RATA) data, as an extension of check‐all‐that‐apply (CATA) data, are being used more frequently in sensory and consumer research. How to analyze RATA data is of theoretical and practical importance. This paper proposes and advocates the proportional odds model (POM) or the proportional odds mixed model (POMM) as a standard first‐selected model for the analysis of RATA data. Using a food‐related case study, it is shown that POM or POMM are more appropriate and useful statistical models than the conventional linear model (LM) or linear mixed model (LMM) for RATA data. Log of odds‐ratio in POM or POMM is a more meaningful index to measure sample effects and sensory differences between samples for RATA data than the difference of rating means in LM or LMM. Generalized linear models (GLM) and generalized linear mixed models (GLMM) with binomial distribution are also discussed for when the proportional odds assumption fails.
- 25 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 41 (3)
Proportional Odds Model ( POM ) for Analyzing Rate‐All‐That‐Apply ( RATA ) Data: Detecting Sample Effects
Rate‐all‐that‐apply (RATA) data, as an extension of check‐all‐that‐apply (CATA) data, are being used more frequently in sensory and consumer research. How to analyze RATA data is of theoretical and practical importance. This paper proposes and advocates the proportional odds model (POM) or the proportional odds mixed model (POMM) as a standard first‐selected model for the analysis of RATA data. Using a food‐related case study, it is shown that POM or POMM are more appropriate and useful statistical models than the conventional linear model (LM) or linear mixed model (LMM) for RATA data. Log of odds‐ratio in POM or POMM is a more meaningful index to measure sample effects and sensory differences between samples for RATA data than the difference of rating means in LM or LMM. Generalized linear models (GLM) and generalized linear mixed models (GLMM) with binomial distribution are also discussed for when the proportional odds assumption fails.
- Open Access
Thurstonian Model for the Difference-from-Control Test
The difference-from-control (DFC) test is one of the sensory discrimination methods which is applicable to sensory evaluation in some areas, including process optimization and quality assessment for foods. Thurstonian models are needed for any one of the sensory discrimination methods, including the DFC. This is important because the models provide a useful sensory measure, the Thurstonian discriminal distance, or , which is theoretically independent of the methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper originally derives the Thurstonian model and the estimations of the model parameters for the DFC test based on the folded normal distribution. The statistical testing, difference testing power, and sample sizes needed for the DFC test are also discussed. R codes for the estimations and tests of parameters of the model for the DFC are developed, used, and provided in the paper.Open AccessThurstonian Model for the Difference-from-Control Test
The difference-from-control (DFC) test is one of the sensory discrimination methods which is applicable to sensory evaluation in some areas, including process optimization and quality assessment for foods. Thurstonian models are needed for any one of the sensory discrimination methods, including the DFC. This is important because the models provide a useful sensory measure, the Thurstonian discriminal distance, or , which is theoretically independent of the methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper originally derives the Thurstonian model and the estimations of the model parameters for the DFC test based on the folded normal distribution. The statistical testing, difference testing power, and sample sizes needed for the DFC test are also discussed. R codes for the estimations and tests of parameters of the model for the DFC are developed, used, and provided in the paper. - Open Access
- 31 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Thurstonian Model for the Difference-from-Control Test
The difference-from-control (DFC) test is one of the sensory discrimination methods, which is applicable to sensory evaluation in some areas including process optimization and quality assessment for foods. Thurstonian models are important and needed for any one of the sensory discrimination methods including the DFC, because it provides a useful sensory measure, Thurstonian discriminal distance, δ or d', which is theoretically independent of methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper originally derives the Thurstonian model and the maximum likelihood estimations of the model parameters for the DFC test based on a folded normal distribution. R codes for estimations and tests of δ or d' are developed and used in the paper.
- 31 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessThurstonian Model for the Difference-from-Control Test
The difference-from-control (DFC) test is one of the sensory discrimination methods, which is applicable to sensory evaluation in some areas including process optimization and quality assessment for foods. Thurstonian models are important and needed for any one of the sensory discrimination methods including the DFC, because it provides a useful sensory measure, Thurstonian discriminal distance, δ or d', which is theoretically independent of methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper originally derives the Thurstonian model and the maximum likelihood estimations of the model parameters for the DFC test based on a folded normal distribution. R codes for estimations and tests of δ or d' are developed and used in the paper.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 15 (2) , 991
Thurstonian Scaling for Sensory Discrimination Methods
Thurstonian scaling, i.e., Thurstonian discriminal distance or , can be used as a sensory measurement index to measure and monitor food sensory difference/similarity between test and control samples due to potential food contamination. It can be obtained from any one of the sensory discrimination methods. Thurstonian scaling is theoretically independent of the methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper discusses statistical inference including estimations and tests of hypothesis for . Ten basic sensory discrimination methods including six forced-choice methods and four methods with response bias are used in this paper to estimate values and their variances. Statistical tests are conducted based on the estimated values and their variances. The statistical tests include difference testing and equivalence/similarity testing for individual values for test and control samples and for two or multiple values for test samples. The application and significance of Thurstonian scaling for sensory discrimination methods are discussed generally. R codes for estimations and tests for values are provided in the paper.- 20 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 15 (2) , 991
Open AccessThurstonian Scaling for Sensory Discrimination Methods
Thurstonian scaling, i.e., Thurstonian discriminal distance or , can be used as a sensory measurement index to measure and monitor food sensory difference/similarity between test and control samples due to potential food contamination. It can be obtained from any one of the sensory discrimination methods. Thurstonian scaling is theoretically independent of the methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper discusses statistical inference including estimations and tests of hypothesis for . Ten basic sensory discrimination methods including six forced-choice methods and four methods with response bias are used in this paper to estimate values and their variances. Statistical tests are conducted based on the estimated values and their variances. The statistical tests include difference testing and equivalence/similarity testing for individual values for test and control samples and for two or multiple values for test samples. The application and significance of Thurstonian scaling for sensory discrimination methods are discussed generally. R codes for estimations and tests for values are provided in the paper. - Open Access
- 30 September 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Thurstonian Scaling for Sensory Discrimination Methods
Thurstonian scaling, i.e., Thurstonian discriminal distance δ or d' can be used as a sensory measurement index to measure and monitor food sensory difference/similarity between test and control samples due to potential food contamination. It can be obtained from any one of the sensory discrimination methods. Thurstonian scaling is theoretically independent of methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper discusses statistical inference including estimations and tests of hypothesis for d'. Ten basic sensory discrimination methods including 6 forced-choice methods and 4 methods with response bias are used in this paper to estimate d' values and their variances. Statistical tests are conducted based on the estimated d' values and their variances. The statistical tests include difference testing and equivalence/similarity testing for individual d' values for test and control samples and for two or multiple d' values for test samples. Application and significance of Thurstonian scaling for sensory discrimination methods is discussed generally. R codes for estimations and tests for d' values are provided in the paper.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessThurstonian Scaling for Sensory Discrimination Methods
Thurstonian scaling, i.e., Thurstonian discriminal distance δ or d' can be used as a sensory measurement index to measure and monitor food sensory difference/similarity between test and control samples due to potential food contamination. It can be obtained from any one of the sensory discrimination methods. Thurstonian scaling is theoretically independent of methods or scales used for its estimation. This paper discusses statistical inference including estimations and tests of hypothesis for d'. Ten basic sensory discrimination methods including 6 forced-choice methods and 4 methods with response bias are used in this paper to estimate d' values and their variances. Statistical tests are conducted based on the estimated d' values and their variances. The statistical tests include difference testing and equivalence/similarity testing for individual d' values for test and control samples and for two or multiple d' values for test samples. Application and significance of Thurstonian scaling for sensory discrimination methods is discussed generally. R codes for estimations and tests for d' values are provided in the paper.
- 23 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 39 (5)
Thurstonian Models for the Duo‐Trio and Its Variants
The duo‐trio is one of the basic sensory discrimination methods. There are various variants of the duo‐trio including the double duo‐trio (DDT), the dual reference duo‐trio (DRDT), the paired duo‐trio with AB and BA pairs (PDTAB), and the paired duo‐trio with same (AA or BB) and different (AB or BA) pairs (PDTSD). Thurstonian models, that is, psychometric functions for the duo‐trio and its four variants, DDT, DRDT, PDTAB, and PDTSD, are reviewed and developed in this paper. The theorized performances, that is, statistical powers of the four variants were explored and compared with the conventional duo‐trio. R codes are developed and provided for analyses of the data of the duo‐trio and its variants.
- 23 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 39 (5)
Thurstonian Models for the Duo‐Trio and Its Variants
The duo‐trio is one of the basic sensory discrimination methods. There are various variants of the duo‐trio including the double duo‐trio (DDT), the dual reference duo‐trio (DRDT), the paired duo‐trio with AB and BA pairs (PDTAB), and the paired duo‐trio with same (AA or BB) and different (AB or BA) pairs (PDTSD). Thurstonian models, that is, psychometric functions for the duo‐trio and its four variants, DDT, DRDT, PDTAB, and PDTSD, are reviewed and developed in this paper. The theorized performances, that is, statistical powers of the four variants were explored and compared with the conventional duo‐trio. R codes are developed and provided for analyses of the data of the duo‐trio and its variants.
- 23 September 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Food Quality and Preference
- Vol. 111
Thurstonian model for the four-interval oddity task
- 23 September 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Food Quality and Preference
- Vol. 111
Thurstonian model for the four-interval oddity task
- 4 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 38 (6)
Thurstonian models for three variants (specified, unspecified, and unspecified with forgiveness) of the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method
The Two‐Out‐of‐Five method is one of the basic sensory discrimination methods. It is a special case of the ‘M+N’ method with M = 3 and N = 2. Three variants of the method are discussed in the paper: specified, unspecified, and unspecified with forgiveness. Analytical and simulation‐derived psychometric functions for all three variants of the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method are derived and produced. The performance of the method in both difference and similarity/equivalence tests are explored. It is shown that both difference and similarity/equivalence testing powers for the specified Two‐Out‐of‐Five are larger than those for the 2‐AFC and 3‐AFC. Both difference and similarity/equivalence testing powers for the unspecified Two‐Out‐of‐Five are larger than those for the Triangle and Duo‐trio. Both difference and similarity/equivalence testing powers for the unspecified with forgiveness Two‐Out‐of‐Five are larger than those for the conventional unspecified Two‐Out‐of‐Five and unspecified Tetrads. Tables and R codes are presented and provided for estimations of the probability of correct response, Pc, Thurstonian discriminal distance or d', and the B value for estimating the variance of d' for the three variants of the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method.Practical Applications: The Two‐Out‐of‐Five method is a powerful sensory discrimination method. However, this method has not been used widely in sensory and consumer research, partly since the method has not been explored adequately in the literature. This paper explores the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method and shows that the method has potential for wide application. The Two‐Out‐of‐Five method involves a larger number of samples (5) and sensory fatigue may be of concern. Hence, the method may not be suitable for taste and smell tests with strong stimuli. The method is particularly suitable for manual and visual inspection testing where sensory fatigue is of a lesser concern.
- 4 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 38 (6)
Thurstonian models for three variants (specified, unspecified, and unspecified with forgiveness) of the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method
The Two‐Out‐of‐Five method is one of the basic sensory discrimination methods. It is a special case of the ‘M+N’ method with M = 3 and N = 2. Three variants of the method are discussed in the paper: specified, unspecified, and unspecified with forgiveness. Analytical and simulation‐derived psychometric functions for all three variants of the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method are derived and produced. The performance of the method in both difference and similarity/equivalence tests are explored. It is shown that both difference and similarity/equivalence testing powers for the specified Two‐Out‐of‐Five are larger than those for the 2‐AFC and 3‐AFC. Both difference and similarity/equivalence testing powers for the unspecified Two‐Out‐of‐Five are larger than those for the Triangle and Duo‐trio. Both difference and similarity/equivalence testing powers for the unspecified with forgiveness Two‐Out‐of‐Five are larger than those for the conventional unspecified Two‐Out‐of‐Five and unspecified Tetrads. Tables and R codes are presented and provided for estimations of the probability of correct response, Pc, Thurstonian discriminal distance or d', and the B value for estimating the variance of d' for the three variants of the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method.Practical Applications: The Two‐Out‐of‐Five method is a powerful sensory discrimination method. However, this method has not been used widely in sensory and consumer research, partly since the method has not been explored adequately in the literature. This paper explores the Two‐Out‐of‐Five method and shows that the method has potential for wide application. The Two‐Out‐of‐Five method involves a larger number of samples (5) and sensory fatigue may be of concern. Hence, the method may not be suitable for taste and smell tests with strong stimuli. The method is particularly suitable for manual and visual inspection testing where sensory fatigue is of a lesser concern.
- 30 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 38 (6)
Time‐intensity data analysis in terms of R‐index measures transformed from menopause rating scale data collected in a longitudinal menopause tablet perceptual efficacy study
A 12‐week longitudinal study with 247 US menopausal women was undertaken to investigate the perceptual efficacy of a tablet formulated with an extract of Siberian rhubarb to provide relief from menopausal symptoms. The 5‐point menopause rating scale (MRS) (0 = none; 1 = mild; 2 = moderate; 3 = severe; 4 = extremely severe) was used to measure symptom intensity. The MRS scale, an ordinal categorical scale, was transformed into an R‐index, a ratio scale, using the frequencies of the MRS categories. Symptom relief was compared to an initial week baseline measure; defined as R‐index = 0.5. An index, A.RDEX, which is based on area under the R‐index curve (AUC) in the range of 0–84 days was used to measure percentage efficacy of symptom relief. Results show that symptom relief occurs through the first 17 days in terms of R‐index = 0.64 for the total score and improves with continued use, reaching an A.RDEX = 0.42 by 84 days, suggesting about 42% relief considering all 11 MRS attributes.Practical Applications: MRS ratings data can be transformed into an R‐index using MRS category frequencies at an initial week and a subsequent week. Functional data analysis for R‐index values provides an advanced statistical model for analysis of perceptual differences throughout longitudinal studies that can examine MRS attribute effects over time. R codes are developed and provided in the paper to transform MRS data into R‐index measures and to conduct functional data analysis for R‐index measures obtained from different time points (weeks or days).
- 30 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Sensory Studies
- Vol. 38 (6)
Time‐intensity data analysis in terms of R‐index measures transformed from menopause rating scale data collected in a longitudinal menopause tablet perceptual efficacy study
A 12‐week longitudinal study with 247 US menopausal women was undertaken to investigate the perceptual efficacy of a tablet formulated with an extract of Siberian rhubarb to provide relief from menopausal symptoms. The 5‐point menopause rating scale (MRS) (0 = none; 1 = mild; 2 = moderate; 3 = severe; 4 = extremely severe) was used to measure symptom intensity. The MRS scale, an ordinal categorical scale, was transformed into an R‐index, a ratio scale, using the frequencies of the MRS categories. Symptom relief was compared to an initial week baseline measure; defined as R‐index = 0.5. An index, A.RDEX, which is based on area under the R‐index curve (AUC) in the range of 0–84 days was used to measure percentage efficacy of symptom relief. Results show that symptom relief occurs through the first 17 days in terms of R‐index = 0.64 for the total score and improves with continued use, reaching an A.RDEX = 0.42 by 84 days, suggesting about 42% relief considering all 11 MRS attributes.Practical Applications: MRS ratings data can be transformed into an R‐index using MRS category frequencies at an initial week and a subsequent week. Functional data analysis for R‐index values provides an advanced statistical model for analysis of perceptual differences throughout longitudinal studies that can examine MRS attribute effects over time. R codes are developed and provided in the paper to transform MRS data into R‐index measures and to conduct functional data analysis for R‐index measures obtained from different time points (weeks or days).
- 25 April 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Food Quality and Preference
- Vol. 108
The methods of Tetrads, Hexads, and Octads: A type of more powerful sensory discrimination methods
- 25 April 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Food Quality and Preference
- Vol. 108
The methods of Tetrads, Hexads, and Octads: A type of more powerful sensory discrimination methods