CSChristoph Salge

Christoph Salge

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Christoph Salge has a total of 77 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Landmarks, Monuments, and Beacons: Understanding Generative Calls to Action

    by Victoire Hervé, Henrik Warpefelt, Christoph Salge

    Algorithmic evaluation of procedurally generated content struggles to find metrics that align with human experience, particularly for composite artefacts. Automatic decomposition as a possible solution requires concepts that meet a range of properties. To this end, drawing on Games Studies and Game AI research, we introduce the nested concepts of \textit{Landmarks}, \textit{Monuments}, and \textit{Beacons}. These concepts are based on the artefact's perceivability, evocativeness, and Call to Action, all from a player-centric perspective. These terms are generic to games and usable across genres. We argue that these entities can be found and evaluated with techniques currently used in both research and industry, opening a path towards a fully automated decomposition of PCG, and evaluation of the salient sub-components. Although the work presented here emphasises mixed-initiative PCG and compositional PCG, we believe it applies beyond those domains. With this approach, we intend to create a connection between humanities and technical game research and allow for better computational PCG evaluation

  • Open Access

    Process Empowerment for Robust Intrinsic Motivation

    by Stas Tiomkin, Christoph Salge, Daniel Polani

    Information processing in dynamical control systems influences the properties of the perception-action loop in natural and artificial agents. The ability to causally affect environment by agent's actions is crucial for learning meaningful behavior and survival. Empowerment is an information-theoretic approach to intrinsically discover this causality between actions and observations without externally provided domain expertise such as a reward function. This form of artificial intrinsic motivation has been successfully demonstrated to lead to the emergence of meaningful behavior in various domains ranging from robotics to transportation. The original formulation of the empowerment principle is based on the information flow from open-loop actions to future observations. This is not robust to randomness and unpredictable perturbations in environments with structures that require careful maneuvering. In this work we define a feedback-aware empowerment variant, called \emph{process empowerment} and derive a solution given by self-consistent equations which can be used for its numerical evaluation. Process empowerment proves to be a robust intrinsic motivation in a paradigmatic proof-of-concept example ('Windy Bridge'), and in scenarios with obstacles and noisy perturbation ('Hallway') and with occasional adversarial action by an oracle agent ('Race'). It demonstrates superior robustness in dealing with noisy environments in delicate situations, and allows transferring solutions for deterministic problems into a noisy, disruptive and occasionally adversarial variant of the problem, through `empowerment cushioning'.


  • An Examination of the Hidden Judging Criteria in the Generative Design in Minecraft Competition

    by Jean-Baptiste Hervé, Christoph Salge, Henrik Warpefelt

    Game content has long been created using procedural generation. However, many of these systems are currently designed in an ad-hoc manner, and there is a lack of knowledge around the design criteria that lead to generators producing the most successful results. In this study, we conduct a qualitative examination of the comments left by judges for the 2018–2020 Generative Design in Minecraft competition. Using abductive thematic analysis, we identify the core design criteria that contribute to a generator that creates “good” content – here defined as interesting or engaging. By performing this study, we have identified that the core design criteria that create and interesting settlement are usability of the settlement environment, the thematic coherence within the settlement, and an anchoring in real-world simulacra.


  • Open Access

    Exploring Minecraft Settlement Generators with Generative Shift Analysis

    by Jean-Baptiste Hervé, Oliver Withington, Marion Hervé, Laurissa Tokarchuk, Christoph Salge

    With growing interest in Procedural Content Generation (PCG) it becomes increasingly important to develop methods and tools for evaluating and comparing alternative systems. There is a particular lack regarding the evaluation of generative pipelines, where a set of generative systems work in series to make iterative changes to an artifact. We introduce a novel method called Generative Shift for evaluating the impact of individual stages in a PCG pipeline by quantifying the impact that a generative process has when it is applied to a pre-existing artifact. We explore this technique by applying it to a very rich dataset of Minecraft game maps produced by a set of alternative settlement generators developed as part of the Generative Design in Minecraft Competition (GDMC), all of which are designed to produce appropriate settlements for a pre-existing map. While this is an early exploration of this technique we find it to be a promising lens to apply to PCG evaluation, and we are optimistic about the potential of Generative Shift to be a domain-agnostic method for evaluating generative pipelines.

  • Open Access

    Skilled motor control of an inverted pendulum implies low entropy of states but high entropy of actions

    by Nicola Catenacci Volpi, Martin Greaves, Dari Trendafilov, Christoph Salge, Giovanni Pezzulo, Daniel Polani

    The mastery of skills, such as balancing an inverted pendulum, implies a very accurate control of movements to achieve the task goals. Traditional accounts of skilled action control that focus on either routinization or perceptual control make opposite predictions about the ways we achieve mastery. The notion of routinization emphasizes the decrease of the variance of our actions, whereas the notion of perceptual control emphasizes the decrease of the variance of the states we visit, but not of the actions we execute. Here, we studied how participants managed control tasks of varying levels of difficulty, which consisted of controlling inverted pendulums of different lengths. We used information-theoretic measures to compare the predictions of alternative accounts that focus on routinization and perceptual control, respectively. Our results indicate that the successful performance of the control task strongly correlates with the decrease of state variability and the increase of action variability. As postulated by perceptual control theory, the mastery of skilled pendulum control consists in achieving stable control of goals by flexible means.


  • Open Access

    Impressions of the GDMC AI Settlement Generation Challenge in Minecraft

    by Christoph Salge, Claus Aranha, Adrian Brightmoore, Sean Butler, Rodrigo De Moura Canaan, Michael Cook, Michael Green, Hagen Fischer, Christian Guckelsberger, Jupiter Hadley, et al.

    The GDMC AI settlement generation challenge is a procedural content generation (PCG) competition about producing an algorithm that can create a settlement in the game Minecraft. In contrast to the majority of AI competitions, the GDMC entries are evaluated by human experts on several criteria such as adaptability, functionality, evocative narrative, and visual aesthetics – all of which represent challenges to state-of-the-art PCG systems. This paper contains a collection of written experiences with this competition, by participants, judges, organizers and advisors. We asked people to reflect both on the artifacts themselves, and on the competition in general. The aim of this paper is to offer a shareable and edited collection of experiences and qualitative feedback which have the potential to push forward PCG and computational creativity, but would be lost once the individual assessments are compressed to scalar ratings. We reflect upon organizational issues for AI competitions, and discuss the future of the GDMC competition.


  • Open Access

    A Continuous Information Gain Measure to Find the Most Discriminatory Problems for AI Benchmarking

    by Matthew Stephenson, Damien Anderson, Ahmed Khalifa, John Levine, Jochen Renz, Julian Togelius, Christoph Salge

    This paper introduces an information-theoretic method for selecting a subset of problems which gives the most information about a group of problem-solving algorithms. This method was tested on the games in the General Video Game AI (GVGAI) framework, allowing us to identify a smaller set of games that still gives a large amount of information about the abilities of different game-playing agents. This approach can be used to make agent testing more efficient. We can achieve almost as good discriminatory accuracy when testing on only a handful of games as when testing on more than a hundred games, something which is often computationally infeasible. Furthermore, this method can be extended to study the dimensions of the effective variance in game design between these games, allowing us to identify which games differentiate between agents in the most complementary ways.

  • The AI Settlement Generation Challenge in Minecraft

    by Christoph Salge, Michael Cerny Green, Rodrigo Canaan, Filip Skwarski, Rafael Fritsch, Adrian Brightmoore, Shaofang Ye, Changxing Cao, Julian Togelius


  • Open Access

    Generative Design in Minecraft: Chronicle Challenge

    by Christoph Salge, Christian Guckelsberger, Michael Cerny Green, Rodrigo Canaan, Julian Togelius

    We introduce the Chronicle Challenge as an optional addition to the Settlement Generation Challenge in Minecraft. One of the foci of the overall competition is adaptive procedural content generation (PCG), an arguably under-explored problem in computational creativity. In the base challenge, participants must generate new settlements that respond to and ideally interact with existing content in the world, such as the landscape or climate. The goal is to understand the underlying creative process, and to design better PCG systems. The Chronicle Challenge in particular focuses on the generation of a narrative based on the history of a generated settlement, expressed in natural language. We discuss the unique features of the Chronicle Challenge in comparison to other competitions, clarify the characteristics of a chronicle eligible for submission and describe the evaluation criteria. We furthermore draw on simulation-based approaches in computational storytelling as examples to how this challenge could be approached.